Prologue

Discipline

THE PLANET BELOW HIM WAS HIDDEN TO ALL OF SHARLS'S

senses save for the Neutrino Screen, the Neudar. What
had been a gas giant planet a billion years ago was still a
world two and a half times the size of the Earth: an egg
of rock and nickel-iron hidden in world-sized storms. The
storms spread out into a cloudy ring occupying the en-
tirety of Goldblatt's World's orbit around the neutron
star.

Sharls watched storms spin outward from the gas giant.
Streams of fog and cloud and dust ran slow near the
Smoke Ring's outer rim, faster at the Smoke Ring median,
faster yet as they neared Levoy's Star; and everywhere
there were flattened whorls of hurricane. The gravity gra-
dient was savage this near the ancient neutron star. The
innermost limits of the Smoke Ring circled Levoy's Star
every two hours.

The Smoke Ring was tinged with green—it had its own
billion-year-old ecology—and somewhere in that cloud
were men.

1

2 / Larry Niven

The temptation to go to them was a constant low-level
irritant.

When moving between stars. Discipline burned the
near-infinite hydrogen of interstellar space; but Discipline
had been at rest for a long time now, and onboard fuel
was limited. Refueling could not have progressed far
when the mutiny came. Sharls's supply of deuterium-trit-
ium mix was finite. He had no way of knowing how long
he must wait for the children of Discipline's crew to re-
discover civilization, to build their own spacecraft, to
come to him. He was always short of power. The solar
collectors on his two remaining CARMs didn't give him
much.

Sharls ignored the stars, most of the time. He watched
the Smoke Ring. When the boredom became too much
for him, he edited it from his memory. Boredom was a
recurring surprise.

Five hundred and thirty-two Earth years was one
hundred and ninety-two orbits of Levoy's Star round its
companion star. But the natives of the Smoke Ring mea-
sured years from the passings of the neutron star (Levoy's
Star, "Voy") across the face of the yellow dwarf (T3,
"Sun"); so a Smoke Ring "year" was 1.384 Earth years.
Sharls had been waiting in the L2 point behind Goldblatt's
World for three hundred and eighty-four Smoke Ring
years.

Best to sit it out in a stable orbit, and watch, and wait
for men to develop civilization. Best to edit the memory
of boredom . . .

Discipline's computer/autopilot stored its information
as a human brain did, or a hologram, though Sharls could
feel differences. Memories from his time aboard Disci-
pline were sharp and vivid. Those he had edited were gone
completely. But memories from his time as a man, trans-

THE SMOKE RING / 3

ferred long ago from a human brain now long dead, were
blurred, hard to retrieve.

So: it wasn't like a relay clicking over.

But somewhere in the computer there was a change of
state. Five hundred and thirty-two years, and enough is
enough. Sharls Davis Kendy was done with waiting.




Section One

CITIZENS
TREE

Chapter One

The Pond

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 19 SM:

PONDS

WATER DROPLETS COME IN ALL SIZES HERE. CLOUDS
MAY HOLD EVERYTHING FROM FINE MIST, TO GLOBULES
THE SIZE OF A FIST, TO SPHEROIDS THAT HOUSE ALL
MANNER OF LIFE. THE BIGGEST "POND" WE'VE SEEN
MASSED TEN MILLION METRIC TONS OR SO; BUT THE TIDE
FROM LEVOY'S STAR HAD PULLED IT INTO TWO LOBES
AND THE DIFFERENTIAL WINDS WERE TEARING IT APART.

THE ECOLOGY OF THE PONDS IS ONE RATHER THAN
MANY. LIFE IS QUEER AND WONDERFUL, BUT IN EVERY
POND WE HAVE EXAMINED IT IS THE SAME LIFE. PONDS
ARE TEMPORARY; POND LIFE MUST OCCASIONALLY MI-
GRATE. IN THE SMOKE RING EVEN THE FISH CAN FLY.
—CAROL BURNES, LIFE SUPPORT

LAWRI AND JEPFER SWAM BENEATH MURKY PONDWA-

ter, trailing forty square meters of fabric stretched across
7

8 / Larry Niven

the net more commonly used to sieve harebrains from the
sky. They gripped its corners in strong toes and swam
with their arms.

The sheet Tesisted. The leading edge tried to crumple.
Tethers at the comers of the harebrain net got in their
way. We could have had some help, Jeffer thought. Lawri
wouldn't have it. Lawri's idea. Lawn's project! She'd be
doing this by herself if she possibly could.

Air! He slapped her thigh. She dropped the sheet and
they swam toward the light.

Air is the sweetest taste, though one must risk drown-
ing to appreciate it.

They were at the arc of the pond nearest Citizens Tree.
The center of the trunk was a mere three klomters east.
Seventy klomters of trunk ran out and in from the pond,
ending in paired curved tufts. The in tuft, home, looked
greenish black, with Voy's blue pinpoint shining almost
behind it. A single line ran from the trunk, and divided.

The sheet was a ghostly shadow deep within the pond.
Lines ran from the comers, up through the water and out,
to join the main cable that ran to the trunk.

"Almost in place," Lawri said doubtfully.

"Close enough."

"All right. You go get the CARM ready. I'll draft some
hands to pull it in."

Jeffer nodded. His legs scissored and shot him into the
air. He drifted toward the main cable in a spray of drop-
lets.

It was easier than arguing. Lawri would not leave Jeffer
to organize the final stage. When Lawri the Scientist got
an idea, nobody else got credit. Particularly not Citizens
Tree's other Scientist, her husband.

Partway around the curve of the pond, Minya and
Gavving floated in the interface between air and water,
surrounded by thrashing children.

THE SMOKE RING / 9

Lines ran from each child toward the cable from Cit-
izens Tree. The children were taught the backstroke first.
It kept their faces in the air. Some preferred the frog-kick
that let them look beneath the water. Swimming was a
balance of surface tension versus the thrust of arms and
legs.

If a child kicked himself entirely out of the water, an
adult must go after him. A child who went beneath the
surface could panic and must be pulled out before he
drowned. There were carnivores among the waterbirds.
Minya and Gavving wore harpoons. They had three of
their own among the swimmers.

Gavving used lazy strokes to change his attitude, mov-
ing his field of view in a clockwise circle.

"Look at Rather," Minya said.

The oldest of the children were swimming together.
Daughter of two jungle giants, golden-blond Jill had grown
to merely normal height in the tide of Citizens Tree. She
was thirty ce' meters shorter than her parents ... but the
contrast between Jill and Rather was startling. At four-
teen, Minya's dark-haired firstborn son was less than two
meters in height. Jill had more than half a meter on him.

Yet Minya never spoke of Rather's height. Gavving
looked again and said, "Right. Rather!"

Rather paddled over, reluctantly. Fine green fur,
barely visible, grew a mi'meter long on his left cheek.
Gavving gripped the boy's arm and lifted him partway out
of the water, against surface tension. The green could be
traced down Rather's neck, over his shoulder, and part-
way across his chest.

"Fluff," Gavving said. "Why didn't you tell some-
one?"

Rather grinned guiltily. "I've never swum before."

Minya snapped, "You go straight—"

"No. Finish your swim. You'll pay for it. You've seen
your last of the sun for a while. Have we raised a fool?
It's almost reached your eye!"




10 / Larry Niven

Rather nodded solemnly and paddled away. Minya
watched him go, her mouth pursed in anger. Her husband
wriggled and was silently underwater; kicked, and was
beneath her; grasped an ankle and dove. Minya doubled
back on herself and kicked him across the jaw. Gavving
reached through the defense of her waving arms and legs
and had her head between his hands; pulled her to him
by main strength and kissed her hard. She laughed bub-
bles.

He kicked toward the surface with Minya in tow. They
blew water from their faces before they inhaled, and were
back on duty before any child could get into trouble.

Debby was some distance from where the children
swam. She stayed just under the surface, motionless,
peering, her spear poised. She expelled stale air—which
stayed before her as a bubble—raised her head, snatched
a breath, ducked again.

Debby had lived her first nineteen years in free-fall.
Fourteen years in the tree tide had put muscle on her
without shrinking her height. Her children—and lisa's,
the children they had borne to Anthon—were no taller
than ordinary tree dwellers. But Debby was two and a
half meters tall. Her fingers were long and fragile; her
toes were sturdier if less agile, and the big toes measured
six ce'meters. Her rich brown hair was beginning to show
gray, but she still wore it a meter long. For swimming she
wore it looped in a braid around her throat.

The water was murky. This was a new skill for Debby,
but she was learning.

She struck. The ripple other thrust expanded outward
around the great globule, past playing children and the
Scientists working their cloth sheet.

A silver shape wriggled on Debby's spearpoint. Debby
reached above her head, tugged hard at the tether, and
gasped as her head broke the surface. The waterbird, sud-
denly thrust into air, expanded its small wings and

THE SMOKE RING / 11

thrashed mightily. A blow to the head end quieted it.
Debby pushed it into a net bag to join five others.

Her chest still heaved with the need for air. She rested
quietly on her back, her hands fluttering from time to time
to keep surface tension from pulling her under.

Eastward, a thousand klomters past Citizens Tree, the
cloud patterns thickened into a flattened whirlpool. The
Smoke Ring converged beyond and below the whorl in a
stream of white touched with blue-green, narrowing as it
dropped toward the dazzling point of Voy.

Things tended to collect in that special part of the
Smoke Ring, east of Gold by sixty degrees of arc. The
citizens had reason to know that the storm-whorl around
Gold was dangerous. They assumed that the Clump was
too. They had never taken the tree nearer than this.

They had never visited a jungle.

Human beings certainly lived elsewhere in the Smoke
Ring, but Citizens Tree had never attempted to contact
them.

Citizens Tree was placid, safe. Working within the
pond was as much excitement as Debby ever got these
days. Life in Carther States had been different. The oc-
casional raids from London Tree forced the citizens to be
always prepared for war, until in one magnificent raid they
had ended London Tree's power forever.

Debby's connection with the jungle warriors had ended
too. A mixed group of copsiks and warriors had stolen
London Tree's CARM. The vehicle was old science, pow-
erful and unfamiliar. They and their prisoners had been
lucky to bring the CARM to any kind of safety; but
Carther States was lost somewhere in the sky beyond
Gold.

From westward came a cheerful cry. "Citizens! We
need muscle!" Debby saw Lawri the Scientist floating in
the sky with one hand on the main tether.

Debby snatched at the" net bag (six was a nice day's
catch), kicked herself into the sky, and began reeling her

12 / Larry Niven

line in. She was first to reach the Scientist. Clave and
Minya and Mark the Silver Man were leaving the pond,
reeling in lines. Gavving had stayed to gather the children.

Four tethers led to the corners of the sheet-covered
net, which was now deep underwater. Lawri stationed
them along the main tether as they arrived. "Gather it
in," she directed them. "Make loops. Steady pull."

Debby wrapped her toes and her fingers around the
cable, and did her savage best to contract her body. No
loop formed. She knew she wasn't as strong as a tree
dweller, but the others were having trouble too.

Lawn called, "Good! It's coming straight out."

That was not obvious to Debby. She strained . . . and
gradually the pond bulged. The sheet and its net backing
were rising, carrying tons of water. Debby pulled until
her knees and elbows met, then shifted her grip and con-
tinued pulling.

The pond stretched, and tore. A baby pond pulled

clear, leaving a trail of droplets the size of a man's head.
Water flowed over the edges of the cloth but was not lost,
for surface tension held it. The main pond pulsed as sur-
face tension tried to form the sphere again.

"Keep pulling!" Lawri shouted. "Steady . . . okay.

That should do it."

The citizens relaxed. The bud-pond continued to move
east on its own momentum, toward the tree, with the net
and sheet now in the middle of a pulsing sphere.

Debby coiled line that was now slack. Glancing toward
the trunk, she saw what the curve of the pond had hidden

earlier.

Parallel to the trunk and many klomters beyond it

floated a slender dark line. A young tree, no more than
thirty klomters long, and injured; for the in tuft was miss-
ing, chopped away somehow. The view was confusing,
for the midtrunk was wreathed in cloud . . . dark, dirty

cloud . . . smoke!

Debby tugged abruptly at another line. The motion set

THE SMOKE RING / 13

her drifting toward the Chairman. Clave caught her ankle
as she arrived. "Something?"

Debby pointed with her toes. "That tree. It's on fire!"

"... I believe you're right. Treefodder! It'll be com-
ing apart. Two fires to worry about."

Debby had never seen a tree break in half, but Clave
spoke from dreadful experience. They might have to move
the tree. It would take time to get the CARM ready—

Clave had already thought that far. His voice became
a whipcrack roar. "Citizens, it's getting toward dinner-
time, and we've got all these waterbirds. Let's break up

the swim."

His voice dropped. "You go now, Debby. Tell Jeffer
we may need the CARM. We'll get the women and chil-
dren down into the tuft, if we've got time. Your eyes are
better than mine. Do you see anything leaving the tree?

Like clouds of insects?"

There were black specks, big enough to show detail.
"Not insects. Something bigger . . . three, four . . .

birds?"

"Doesn't matter. Get going."

It had taken Jeffer the Scientist a fifth of a day to cross
three klomters of line.

Free-fall brought back memories. When Quinn Tribe
was lost in the sky after Dalton-Quinn Tree came apart,
his crew would have given eyes and limbs to reach a pond.
Fourteen years later, the grandmother of all ponds floated
three klomters from Citizens Tree; and now their main
problem was to get rid of most of it. Jeffer wondered if
the children appreciated their wealth.

Perhaps they did. Most of Citizens Tree, thirty naked
adults and children, had come to swim in that shimmering

sphere of water.

There was no foliage on the high trunk. It was thick
rough bark, with fissures deep enough to hide a man. Jef-
fer found and donned his tunic and pants, then anchored




14 / Larry Niven

his toes in a crevice and thrust to send himself gliding out
along the bark, toward the CARM.

The lift cable ended two hundred meters short of the
CARM's dock. The citizens may have feared that careless
use of the CARM might spray fire across a rising cage.
More likely, they feared the CARM itself. They would
not lightly come too near that ancient scientific thing.

The CARM was old science. It was roughly brick-
shaped, four meters by ten by thirty-two, and made of
starstuff: metal and glass and plastic, sheathed with
darkly luminous stuff that took the energy from sunlight.
The bulk of it was tanks for hydrogen and oxygen and
water. Nostrils at the aft end—four at each corner, and
a larger one in the middle—would spurt blue fire on com-
mand.

They had neglected the CARM of late, and Jeffer ac-
cepted some of the blame. The CARM made two "fla-
vors" of fuel out of water and the power in the batteries.
The batteries held their full scientific charge—they filled
themselves, somehow, as long as sunlight could reach the
CARM's glassy surface—but the hydrogen and oxygen
tanks were almost empty. It was high time they filled the
water tank.

The CARM's bow was moored in a dock of wooden
beams. Double doors led into a hut with cradles for pas-
sengers, moorings for cargo, and a broad transparent win-
dow. The window looked forth on nothing but bark.
Ventral to the window was a gray sheet of glass and a
row of colored buttons.

Jeffer went forward. A touch of a blue button lit the
gray glass panel. Blue governed what moved the CARM:

the motors, the two flavors of fuel supply, the water tank,
fuel flow. Jeffer read the blue script:

H2: 0,518
Oz: 0,360
HzO: 0,001
POWER: 8,872

THE SMOKE RING / 15

The batteries danced with energy. Why not? The
CARM wasn't using power. Nobody in Citizens Tree had
bothered to fill the water tank in seven years; so power
wasn't needed to split water into hydrogen and oxygen.
The water tank was virtually dry.

And he could get something done while he waited for
Lawn's pond. Jeffer touched the blue button (the panel
went blank) and the yellow (there appeared a line diagram
of the CARM's bow, the hut section). He touched a yel-
low dot in the image, and turned his fingertip. Then he
moved aft.

The residual goop in pond water stayed in the tank after
the pure water was gone. Jeffer's finger motions had (mag-
ically, scientifically) caused a spigot in the aft wall to ooze
brown mud. He cupped the globule in his hands. He
tossed it at the airlock, and most of it got through. Another
globule formed, and he sent it after the first. He wiped
his hands on his tunic. The mud flow had stopped.

Next he pulled several loops of hose from cargo hooks.
He rotated one end onto the spigot, then tossed the coil
through the twin doors. Done! When Lawri's blob of pond
arrived, she would find the CARM ready to be fueled.

Jeffer returned to the controls. He had a surprise for
his wife.

Two sleeps ago, while the rest of the tribe was roasting
waterbirds from the pond, Lawri had held one of the crea-
tures up for his perusal. "Have you ever really looked at
these?"

Jeffer had seen waterbirds before . . . but he'd kept
his mouth shut, and looked.

There were no feathers. The modified trilateral sym-
metry common to Smoke Ring life expressed itself in two
wings and a tailfin, all in smooth membrane on collapsible
ribs. The wings could be held half collapsed for motion
within the denser medium of water. Only one of the three
eyes looked like a normal bird's eye. The others were big
and bulbous, with large pupils and thick lids. The bodies
were slippery-smooth.




16 / Larry Niven

"I've eaten them, but . . . you're right. I've seen
everything from mobies to triunes to flashers to drillbits,
and they don't look like this. Earthlife doesn't either. Do
you think it's so they can move through water?"

"I've tried looking them up in the cassettes," Lawri
had said. "I tried bird. I tried water and pond. There's
nothing."

Jeffer's next sleep had ended with a dream fading in
his mind, leaving a single phrase: "... even the fish can
fly."

He'd had to wait until now to try it.

He tapped yellow (the display vanished), then white
(and got a tiny white rectangle at the dorsal-port comer).
White read the cassettes; white summoned Voice. "Pri-
kazyvat Voice," he said.

The voice of the CARM was a throaty bass, as deep
as Mark the dwarf's voice. "Ready, Jeffer the Scientist."

"Prikazyvat Read Fish. Read it aloud."

The cassette was one that Jeffer had stolen from Lon-
don Tree, but it was no different from Quinn Tribe's lost
records of Smoke Ring life forms. As Voice spoke, print
scrolled down the display screen: words recorded long
ago by one of Discipline's abandoned crew.

FISH

IF THE BIRDS WITHIN THE SMOKE RING RESEMBLE
FISH—LEGLESS, DESIGNED TO MOVE THROUGH AIR
WEH3HTLESSLY, AS A FISH MOVES THROUGH WATER-
THEN THE FISH THAT LIVE WITHIN THE PONDS RESEMBLE
BIRDS.

EVERY FISH WE HAVE EXAMINED BREATHES AIR.
THEY ARE NOT MAMMALS, BUT LUNGFISH. THE SINGLE
CLASS OF EXCEPTIONS, GILLFISH, ARE DISCUSSED ELSE-
WHERE.

SOME CAN EXTRUDE A TUBE TO THE POND'S SURFACE.

THE SMOKE RING / 17

A PEW CAN EXPAND THE SIZE OF THEIR PINS VIA MEM-
BRANES, TO MAKE THEM SERVE AS WINGS. ONE FORM,
CORE FISH, INFLATES ITSELF WITH AIR, DIVES TO THE
CENTER OF A POND, AND EXPELS A BUBBLE. IT CAN STAY
SUBMERGED FOR UP TO A DAY—SEVERAL SMOKE RING
DAYS—REBREATHING ITS AIR BUBBLE, MAKING FORAYS
TO HUNT, AND THEN RETURNING.

THE WHALE-SIZED MOBY USES ITS POND AS A LAIR
FROM WHICH IT BURSTS TO SWEEP THROUGH PASSING
CLOUDS OF INSECTS. MOB VIS A COMPROMISE FORM, AND
THERE ARE OTHERS.

CLEARLY EVEN THE LARGEST PONDS CAN BREAK UP
OR EVAPORATE OR BE TORN APART BY STORM. EVERY
CREATURE THAT LIVES IN A POND MUST BE PREPARED TO
MIGRATE TO ANOTHER: TO BEHAVE LIKE A BIRD. EVEN
GILLFISH—

"Prikazyvat Stop," Jeffer said. This memory that had
surfaced from his adolescent training under Quinn Tribe's
Scientist was going to put him one up on his wife!

Back to work. He tapped white, then green, then each
of the five green rectangles now onscreen. Within the
great window that faced the bark, five smaller windows
appeared, looking starboard, port, dorsal, ventral, and
aft. The ventral view had a blur and a flicker to it. The
rest were clear, like the window itself.

The aft view looked along the line that led west to the
pond. Citizens were returning to the tree. Behind them a
bud of pond was already drifting toward the tree, with the
harebrain net showing as a shadow within. Lawri's crazy
idea was working.

They swarmed back along the cable toward the mid-
point of Citizens Tree. Gavving and Minya and Anthon
hung back, counting heads to be sure that all children were
accounted for. A girl lost her grip and drifted; she was

18 / Larry Niven

chortling and trying to swim through the air when Anthon
scooped her up.

As children arrived, Clave herded the smaller ones,
with some difficulty, into a rectangular frame with a slat-
ted floor: the lift cage. He stopped when twelve children
were inside. Leave room for a couple of adults.

The rest clung to the rough bark or floated like balloons
on their tethers. There were wrestling matches. Eight-
year-old Arth was getting good at using the recoil of his
opponent's line. He was Clave's youngest, and just be-
ginning the tremendous growth of adolescence.

Debby had arrived first. Clave could see her a hundred
meters out along the bark, climbing toward the CARM.

The bud-pond continued to move. Lawri wore a pro-
prietary smile. Still, Citizens Tree had better have more
line next time they tried this. The pond was too close. If
the tree had brushed it there would have been a flood.

The lift now held a score of children. Whoever was in
the treadmill would have a problem braking that weight.
It couldn't be helped. Clave looked about. Mark and An-
thon looked ludicrous together. Mark short and wide, An-
thon long and narrow, their heads pointing in opposite
directions— He called, "Anthon, Mark. Take the chil-
dren down and bring back any adult you can find. Be
prepared to fight a fire."

Anthon stared in astonishment. "Fire?"

"Burning tree. It's around the other side of the trunk
now. Go down and get some help. Rather— Where on
Earth is Rather?"

Mark pointed outward. "I didn't know any reason to
stop them," he said defensively. "They won't fit in the
lift this trip—"

Clave cursed silently as he watched Rather and Jill
clawing their way out along the bark. There was no tide
to hurt them here. If they slipped, someone would go get
them. But he could have used their help.

THE SMOKE RING / 19

Jeffer couldn't guess how long it took him to realize
that the background had changed. Behind the five camera
views superimposed upon it, the window no longer
showed bark a few ce'meters distant. It showed a huge
face, strong, with massive bones: the brutal face of a
dwarf.

Chapter Two

Discipline

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 6 SM:

FIRE

MAKING A COOKP1RE IN FREE-FALL IS AN EXCES-
SIVELY INTERESTING EXPERIENCE IF WHAT YOU REALLY
WANTED WAS DINNER. IT'S TAKEN ME EIGHT STATE
YEARS TO PERFECT MY TECHNIQUE.

THE FIRST LESSON IS THAT A FLAME DOESN'T RISE IN
FREE-FALL. I LEARNED THAT WITH A CANDLE, WHEN I
WAS A CADET DREAMING OF STRANGE WORLDS. IF
THERE'S NO WIND (TURN OFF THE AIR FEED), THE CAN-
DLE FLAME SEEMS TO GO OUT.

BUT IT ISN'T OUT YET. THERE'S WAX VAPOR, AND
THERE'S THE AIR AROUND IT, AND AT THE INTERFACE IS
AN ENVELOPE OF PLASMA WHERE GAS AND OXYGEN IN-
TERACT. IT CAN STAY HOT FOR MINUTES. COMBUSTION
CONTINUES AT TfiE INTERFACE. WAVE THE CANDLE
AND POP\ THE FLAME IS BACK.

THE SMOKE RING / 21

IN THE CASE OF A COOKFIRE, THE WOOD CONTINUES
TO CHAR. WAIT AN HOUR, THEN BLOW ON THE COALS
WITH A BELLOWS. THE FIRE JUMPS TO LIFE AND THERE
WENT YOUR EYEBROWS.

—DENNIS QUINN, CAPTAIN

DISCIPLINE HAD BEEN DETERIORATING.

Cameras outside the hull showed rainbow-hued scars
from matter that had penetrated the electromagnetic ram-
scoop while Discipline was in flight. They also showed
newer micrometeorite pocks. Sharls could ward off any-
thing big enough to see coming, by turning on those mag-
netic shields for a few seconds, but they ate power in great
gulps.

One day he might regret even the little power he used
to maintain the gardens and the cats.

Within the hull, time had discolored metal and plastic.
The air was dust-free; metal was clean, but not recently
polished. Many of the servomechs had worn out. All but
a few of the crew cubicles were kept cold and dark and
airless. Kitchen machinery was in storage, with power
shut down. Some of the bedding had decayed. Water mat-
tresses had been drained and stored.

Sharls kept the control room free of water vapor and
almost cold enough to freeze carbon dioxide. He hoped
that the computer and its extensions would survive longer
in the cold. But the gardens and corridors and even some
of the cubicles were kept habitable. Sharls left the lighting
on a day-night cycle, for the birds and cats and plants.

The gardens were surviving nicely. It was true that
some of the plants had died out completely; but after all,
his ecosystem was missing its most important factor.
Human crew were supposed to be in that cycle, and they
had been gone for half a thousand years.

Scores of cats prowled the ship hunting hundreds of

22 / Larry Niven

rats and a lesser number of turkeys and pigeons. The tur-
keys made a formidable enemy. The cats had learned to
attack them in pairs.

Sharls trained the cats to respond to his voice. He had
released the experimental rats long ago. The birds were
already loose; they must have been released during that
blank spot in his memory, the mutiny; but by themselves
they wouldn't have fed the cats. They were too agile, for
one thing. With all of the animal life in the system now,
the gardens had a better chance of surviving.

By watching the cats and rats and plants and turkeys
and pigeons interact, Sharls hoped to learn how an eco-
logical system would behave in a free-fall environment
. . . like the larger ecosystem that flowed beneath Dis-
cipline in endless rivers of curdled cloud.

Or had he simply become lonely? In his youth Sharls
had never been a cat lover. (A sudden memory: his hand
swelling with white patches rimmed in red, itching hor-
ribly. A kitten had scratched him playfully while he was
stroking it.) And now? They didn't obey orders worth a
damn ... but neither had his crew.

A computer program would hardly have retained al-
lergies; but who would expect a computer program to be-
come lonely?

Discipline skimmed above the curdled whorl of the
fourth Lagrange point. A fraction of Sharls Davis Kendy's
attention watched on various wavelengths. This close, he
could confirm an earlier sighting: minor amounts of car-
bon were being burned at sites around the edges of that
endless storm. This was no forest fire: too small, and it
had gone on for years. It might indicate human industry
at a primitive level.

Now, where was CARM #6?

. . . Funny that the cats hadn't gone with the muti-
neers. The crew had loved cats. Somewhere in the lost
part of his memory, there must be a reason. Perhaps
Sharls had pulled free of the Smoke Ring without warning.

THE SMOKE RING / 23

He might have done that if the mutineers planned some-
thing really foul, like cutting the computer out and trying
to run Discipline manually.

The mutiny was a blank to Sharls.

He had edited those memories. He even remembered
why. The descendants of the mutineers would need Sharls
Davis Kendy someday. It was not good that he hold
grudges against specific ancestors, against old names. But
had he been too thorough?

—There! CARM #6's communications system had
come alive.

It was a thousand kilometers behind him and something
less than six thousand kilometers in toward Voy. Kendy
did several things at once. Before his new orbit could
carry him away, he restarted the drive. He beamed,
"Kendy for the State. Kendy for the State."

The CARM autopilot responded.

"Link to me. Beam records."

He'd made mistakes enough during that unexpected
contact twenty Earth years ago! At least he'd accom-
plished something: he'd broken the program that denied
him access to the Cargo and Repair Module. The drive
systems were beyond his reach. The original mutineers
must have physically cut the fiber-optic cable. But the
CARM would talk to him!

He'd instructed the autopilot to take photographs at
ten-minute intervals. Reentry was in progress when he
sent that message. Static might well have fuzzed him out.
But pictures were streaming in.

Time passed at a furious rate. CARM #6 flamed as it
plowed through thickening air, veering from plants and
ponds and creatures. It dipped into a pond to refuel, then
bedded itself in the Voy-ward tuft of the largest of a clus-
ter (grove?) of integral trees. It stayed there, with not
much of a view at all, for most of a Smoke Ring year.
Flickering shapes carved cavities through the foliage and
wove small branches into wasp's-nest structures. Ab-




24 / Larry Niven

ruptly the CARM backed into the sky, skittered outward
under inexpert handling, and docked at the midpoint of
the tree.

With another part of his mind, Kendy fiddled with Dis-
cipline's fusion motor. He could not match his orbit to
that of the CARM. He must stay well outside the Smoke
Ring to protect Discipline from corrosion. The best he
could do was twice the CARM's orbital period, to dip low
above the CARM's position once every ten hours and
eight minutes. But he'd be in range for half an hour while
his motor was firing.

More of his attention went to watching the CARM's
lone occupant in real time.

Jeffer the "Scientist" was stored in memory. He had
aged twenty Earth years: hair and beard going gray, wrin-
kles across his forehead (broken by a white line of scar
that was a healing pink wound in Kendy's records), and
knuckles turning knobby. Height: 2.3 meters. Mass: 86
kilograms. Long arms and legs, toes like stubby fingers,
fingers like a spider's legs: long, fragile, the hands of a
field surgeon.

The Smoke Ring had altered Discipline's descendants.
The tribes of London Tree and Dalton-Quinn Tree had all
looked like that. The jungle giants who had grown up with-
out tidal gravity were hardly human: freakishly tall, with
long, fragile, agile fingers and toes; and one of the twelve
was a cripple, and others had legs of different length. Only
Mark the Silver Man had looked like a normal State cit-
izen. They had called him "dwarf."

They were savages; but they had learned to use State
technology in the form of the CARM. Still human. Per-
haps they could be made citizens again.

To Kendy, who thought with the speed of a computer,
the "Scientist" moved much too slowly. Now he was at
the controls, auditing a cassette; now checking the camera
views in present time . . .

The incoming CARM records showed clouds and

THE SMOKE RING / 25

ponds and trees and trilaterally symmetric fishlike birds
swirling across the sky. Natives flickered through the
CARM cabin: the same savages, growing older; a growing
handful of children.

At fifteen years minus-time the CARM backed out of
its timber dock for a journey of exploration. It visited a
green puffball several kilometers across, and when it
emerged there was vegetation like a houseful of green
spaghetti bound to its dorsal surface. It hovered in the
open sky while men darted among a flock of birds—real
birds with real wings: turkeys—and returned to its dock
with prisoners.

At thirteen years minus-time it left the trunk to return
with a dubious prize: several tons of black mud.

There were no more such forays. The Cargo and Repair
Module had become a motor for the tree.

It was docked when the main drive fired for several
hours. Kendy watched side views as the integral tree
drifted across the sky. It had been circling too far from
the neutron star. Air grew thin away from the Smoke Ring
median.

The tree was lower now; the air would be as thick as
mountain air on Earth. And now the CARM was not being
used at all; but there was plenty to watch. The Smoke
Ring environment was fascinating. Huge spheres of
water, storms, jungles like tremendous puffs of green cot-
ton candy.

In present time, the aft CARM camera showed nearly
thirty natives maneuvering between the tree and a tre-
mendous globule of water. They were using the free-fall
environment better than any State astronaut. The State
had need of these people!

Discipline's own telescope had found the foreshor-
tened tree, with the pond to mark it. And what was that
on the opposite side of the tree? Infrared light glowed near
its center . . .

Half a thousand years of sensory deprivation were

26 / Larry Niven

being compensated in a few minutes. After more than five
hundred years, Sharls Kendy had left the stable point be-
hind Goldblatt's World. He had burned irreplaceable fuel,
and it was worth it! Sharls tried to absorb it all, integrate
it all... but that could wait. The "Scientist" might leave
at any minute!

He beamed: "Interrupt records." It was twenty Earth
years of nothing happening, and the tiny CARM autopilot
couldn't handle too many tasks at once. "Activate
voice."

"Voice on." The .04 second delay was almost too
short to notice.

"Send—" He displayed a picture of himself as a
human being, with minor improvements. At age forty-two
Kendy had been handsome, healthy, mature, firm of jaw,
authoritative: a recruitment-poster version of a State
checker.

These were not obedient State citizens. They hadn't
trusted him twenty years ago. What words might give him
a handle on Jeffer the "Scientist"?

He sent, "Kendy for the State. Jeffer the Scientist,
your citizens have been idle too long."

Jeffer jumped like a thief caught in the act. Two long
seconds passed before he found his voice. "Checker?"

"Speaking. How stands your tribe?"

Out beyond the terrible whorl of storm that surrounded
Gold, out where water boiled and froze at the same time
and the legendary stars were a visible truth, lived Kendy
the Checker. He had claimed to be something like an elab-
orate cassette: the recording of a man. He had claimed
authority over every human being in the Smoke Ring. He
had offered knowledge and power, while they were still
near enough to hear his ravings.

Perhaps he was only a madman trapped somehow
aboard the spacecraft that had brought men from the
stars. But he had knowledge. He had coached them

THE SMOKE RING / 27

through that terrible fall back into the Smoke Ring, four-
teen years ago.

The face in the CARM's window had not been seen
since. It was the face of a dwarf, a brutal throwback. The
jaw and orbital ridges were more massive even than
Mark's, the musculature more prominent.

"We lived through the reentry," Jeffer told him. "lisa
and Merril are dead now. There are children."

"Jeffer, your tribe has possessed the CARM for four-
teen of your years. In that time you have moved the tree
twice and thenceforth done nothing at all. What have you
learned of the people of the fourth Lagrange point?"

The what? "I don't understand the question."

"Sixty degrees ahead of Goldblatt's World on the arc
of the Smoke Ring and sixty degrees behind are regions
where matter grows dense. They are points of stability in
Goldblatt's World's orbit. Material tends to collect
there." The dwarf's brutal features registered impati-
ence. "East of you by twelve hundred kilometers, a vast,
sluggish, permanent storm."

"The Clump? You're saying there are people in the
Clump?"

"I sense activity there. A civilization is growing twelve
hundred kilometers from where your tree has floated for
fifteen Earth years. Jeffer, where is your curiosity? Has
it been bred out of you?"

"What do you want from me, Checker?"

Kendy said, "I can be in range to advise you every ten
hours and eight minutes, once every two of your days. I
want to know more of the people of the Smoke Ring. In
particular, I want to know about you and about the Clump
civilization. I think you should link with them, perhaps
rule them."

Jeffer's one previous experience indicated that Kendy
was harmless. For good or ill, he could only talk. Jeffer
gathered his courage and said, "Kendy, the tales say that

28 / Larry Niven

you abandoned us here, long ago. Now I expect you're
bored and—"

"I am."

"And you want to talk to someone. You also claim
authority 1 won't grant you. Why should I listen?"

"Are you aware that you are being invaded?"

"What?"

The face ofKendy was suddenly replaced by a dizzying
view. Jeffer looked into a river of storm, streaming faster
as the eye moved inward toward a tiny, brilliant violet
pinpoint. Jeffer had seen this once before: the Smoke Ring
seen from outside.

Before he could remember to breathe, the view
jumped. He was looking at what had been the center of
the picture, vastly enlarged.

"Look." Scarlet arrowheads appeared, pointing—
"Here, your tree."

"Citizens Tree, from the out tuft? Yeah, and that must
be the pond." Both were tiny. Opposite the pond was. . .
another tree? And dark cloud clinging to the trunk?

The view jumped again. Through the blur and flicker
in the illusion of a window, Jeffer watched a tree on fire.
Moving between the two trees were creatures he had
never seen before.

"Treefodder! Everybody's on the other side of the
trunk. Those bird-things will be on the tree before anyone
knows it."

"Look in infrared." The picture changed again, to red
blobs on black. Jeffer couldn't tell what he was looking
at. The scarlet arrowhead pointed again. "You are seeing
heat. This is fire in the intruder tree. Here, these five
points are just the temperature of a man."

Jeffer shook his head. "It doesn't mean anything."

The enlarged picture returned . . . and suddenly those
tiny "creatures" jumped into perspective. "Winged
men!"

"I would have called those enlarged swimming fins

THE SMOKE RING / 29

rather than wings. Never mind. Have you ever heard tales
of winged men?"

"No. There's nothing in the cassettes either. I've got
to do something about this. Prikazyvat Voice off." Jeffer
made for the airlock without waiting to see the face fade.
His citizens wouldn't have a chance against winged war-
riors!

The sun was at three o'clock: dead east, just above
where the Smoke Ring began to take definite shape.
Kendy can only talk, sure, but he talks with pictures, and
he tells things nobody can know. He'll be in range every
other day at this time. Do I want to know that? But Jeffer
had other concerns, and the rest of that thought lay curled
unfinished in the bottom of his mind.

Jill was leaving Rather behind. She glanced back once
and moved on, and there was laughter in the sound of her

panting.

Jill was his elder by half a year. When he wanted com-
pany it was generally Jill he wanted; but they did compete.
There had been a year during which she could beat him
at wrestling, when she suddenly grew tall and he'd lagged
behind. She'd taught him the riblock the hard way: she'd
held his floating ribs shut with her knees so that he
couldn't breathe. He could wrestle her now—he was a
boy and a dwarf—but her longer arms and legs gave her
an unbeatable advantage at racing. He'd never catch her.

So he moved outward at his own pace, giving due care
to his handholds and footholds in the rough bark, follow-
ing the blond girl in the scarlet tunic. Her long-limbed
mother had already reached the CARM ahead of them.

At fourteen-plus. Rather was considered an adult. He
was built wide and muscular, with heavy cheek, jaw, and
orbital bones. His fingers were short and stubby, and his
toes, though strong, were too short to be much use. His
hair was black and curly like his mother's. His beard was
sparse, without much curl to it yet. His eyes were green

30 / Larry Niven

(and green tinged his cheek, with a growth of fluff that
would be many days healing). He stood a meter and three-
quarters tall.

Dwarf. Arms too short, legs too short. He should have
gone around the trunk. Jill could have told the Scientist
about the burning tree; Debby might already know. He
could have been getting a closer look!

The CARM loomed ahead of him. It was as big ...
no, bigger than the Citizens Tree commons.

Debby shouted into the airlock. Someone emerged:

Jeffer. They talked, heads bobbing. Debby moved to the
front of the CARM; Jeffer was about to go back inside—

Rather heard Jill calling. "Scientist! There's a burning
tree coming toward us!" She paused to catch her breath.
"We saw it, me and Rather, we—while we were swim-
ming—"

Jeffer called back. "Debby told me. Did you see any-
thing like winged men"?"

"... No."

"Okay. Help Debby with the moorings, there at the
bow." He noticed Rather struggling in Jill's wake. "Get
Rather to help you."

Debby and Jill were both fighting knots, and Jill was
muttering "Treefodder, treefodder, treefodder," when
Rather caught up. "I bent my finger," she said.

Debby said, "I hate to cut lines. See what you can
do."

The CARM's tethers hadn't been moved in years, and
the knots were tight. Rather's stubby fingers worked them
loose. Dwarf. Clumsy but strong. Presently the CARM
was held by nothing but its own inertia. Jill did not look
pleased. Debby and Rather grinned at each other. It was
something, to do a thing an adult warrior could not!

Jeffer called from the airlock, twelve meters beyond
the bark. "Come aboard!"

Debby jumped and Jill followed. Rather hesitated until
he saw them bump against the airlock door. The jump

THE SMOKE RING / 31

looked dangerous. Tide was gentle, but one could fa\\ into
the sky. Rather had never been inside the CARM, and he
wasn't sure he wanted to be. The starstuff box was like
nothing else in or on the tree.

But he had to follow. He caught the edge of the outer
door as it passed, pivoted on the strength of his arms, and
entered feet first. Can't jump right, can't reach far. What
if I'a missed?

It was weird inside the CARM. There were openings
in the back wall, and hard round loops sticking out of the
dorsal and side walls. Farther toward the front were rows
of cradles almost the size of an adult, ten in all, made of
nothing like wood or cloth.

Rather made his way forward. The others were in the
first row of cradles. "Take a seat and strap yourself in,"
Jeffer ordered. "Here, like this." He fastened two elastic
tethers across Jill's torso. "Lawri showed me how to
work these, years ago."

The cradle had a headrest that fitted nicely behind his
ears. Jill's and Debby's dug into their shoulders. It's true,
Rather thought suddenly. The CARM was built for
dwarves! He liked the thought.

"The winged men weren't very close," the Scientist
said. "We've got time." His fingers drummed against the
flat panel below the window.

There was tide pulling Rather forward, and a whisper-
roar like a steady wind. The bark receded; the tree backed
into the sky. Jill gripped the armrests of her cradle. Her
mouth was wide. Debby said, "Clave didn't say take off,
Scientist. He said get ready."

"No time. They're headed for the trunk. Also the
CARM is mine, Debby. We settled that once."
"Tell it to Clave."
"Clave knows."

The invaders kicked themselves through the air,
slowly, in the last stages of exhaustion. Five, it looked

32 / Larry Niven

like, until Rather realized that the older woman carried a
half-grown girl in her arms.

Jeffer nudged the CARM toward them, in along the
trunk.

Smoke Ring people came long, longer, or dwarf. These
invaders were of the longer persuasion, like jungle giants,
born and raised in free-fall. They were quite human: an
older man and woman and four girls. The wings were ar-
tificial, bound to their shins, made of cloth over splayed
ribs. One girl trailed behind, struggling along with only
one wing.

They were in sorry shape. Closer now, and Rather
could see details. The man's hair was burned, and the
loose sheet that covered him was charred. The wingless
girl was coughing; she didn't even have the strength to
cling to the woman who carried her.

Their legs stopped pumping as, one by one, they saw
the CARM.

Debby said, "I don't see anything like bows or har-
poons. Can we take them aboard?"

"I thought of that, but look at them. The CARM scares
them worse than being lost in the sky. Anyway, the man's
almost there."

The burned man hadn't seen them. Kicking steadily,
far ahead of the others, he reached the bark and clung.
Without a pause he pounded a stake into the bark, moored
a coil of line, and hurled the coil at the older woman. She
freed a hand and caught it, pulled herself toward the tree,
then snapped the line to send a sine wave rolling toward
the trunk. The nearer girl caught the line in her toes as it
bowed toward her.

Clave came around the bulge of the bark. He slowed
when he saw the strangers. Gavving and Minya joined
him. They moved toward the strangers.

There were four on the trunk now: a girl, the man, and
the older woman with her coughing burden. Rather

THE SMOKE RING / 33

watched Clave take the burned man's line, hurl a sine
wave across the one-winged girl's torso, and pull her in.
"Looks okay," the Scientist murmured.
Clave looked up and waved. Jeffer nodded and set the
CARM moving. "It's all right," he said. "They sure don't
look dangerous. I wonder what happened to them? Where
are they/row?"

"I never saw strangers before," Jill said. "I don't
know what to think."

"That burning tree is still coming at us," Rather said.
Jeffer nodded. The CARM surged, turning.

Black smoke wreathed the middle section of the tree.
Flame glowed sluggishly from within, illuminating blurred
curves and oblongs. Debby said, "There's stuff in the fire.
Made stuff, machinery. It'll burn up."

That was knowledge burning in the core of the fire.
Jeffer hated what he had to say. "We can't save it. If we
had Mark and the silver suit. . .no. That might burn even
him."

"You're not taking us into the fire?"

"We can push anywhere. The tide will hold the tree
straight." Jeffer had already taken them below the inward
limit of the firecloud, where a black plume drifted east.
The CARM was passing north of the trunk. Jeffer tapped:

the CARM turned. "It's still dangerous. The tree could
come apart while we're on it."

He moved in on the trunk. The bow grated against
bark; Jeffer's crew surged forward against their elastic
bands. "I think the CARM was built for pushing," he
said. He tapped a blue dash in the center of the panel,
and the whisper of power became a whistling roar. Tide
surged against his back.

This was what it was to be a Scientist. Knowledge,
power, mastery of a universe. This was what Kendy the
Checker had to offer. At what price? Who but a Scientist
would have the strength to resist?

34 / Larry Niven

The sun passed zenith and started down its arc. Jeffer
had changed the display; he watched sets of letters and

numbers. The roar of the main motor strummed his
bones.

Chapter Three

Refugees

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 4 SM:

TIME

WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO KEEP TO EARTH TIME, BUT
THAT WORD "DAY" IS ABOUT AS USEFUL AS BALLS ON
A CHECKER. THE CLOSER YOU GET TO VOY, THE
SHORTER THE DAYS GET, DOWN TO ABOUT TWO HOURS.
CLOSER THAN THAT, THE AIR'S TOO THIN AND THERE'S
NO WATER TO SPEAK OF. AT A TEN-HOUR ORBIT, SAME
THING, THERE'S NOTHING TO BREATHE. WE'VE BEEN
KEEPING TO SHIP-TIME. TWENTY-FOUR HOURS CONSTI-
TUTE A "SLEEP." A "DAY" IS ONE ORBIT AROUND
VOY, WHEREVER YOU HAPPEN TO BE. GOLD'S ORBIT IS
A "STANDARD DAY."

THE STATE TAKES ITS DATES FROM THE YEAR OF ITS
FOUNDING. WE'VE DONE THE SAME, DATING SMOKE
RING YEARS FROM FOUR YEARS AGO. OUR YEARS ARE
35

36 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 37

HALF A ROTATION OF VOY AND ITS COMPANION SUN . . .
HALF BECAUSE IT'S MORE CONVENIENT.

IF DISCIPLINE EVER DOES COME BACK FOR US,
KENDY WILL HAVE TO LEARN A WHOLE NEW LAN-
GUAGE.

—MICHELLE MICHAELS, COMMUNICATIONS

THE HUTS OF CITIZENS TREE WERE ENCLOSURES MADE BY

weaving living spine branches into a kind of wicker-work.
The Scientists' hut was larger than most, and more clut-
tered too.

The Scientists were the tribe's teachers and doctors.
Any hut would have harpoons protruding from the walls
and high ceiling; but here the wicker sprouted starstuff
knives, pots of herbs and pastes, and tools for writing.

The hut was crowded. Lawri stepped carefully among
five sleeping jungle giants.

She'd covered their wounds in undyed cloth. The
strangers moaned and twisted in their sleep. The youngest
girl, with her hair burned down to the scalp on one side
of her head, was holding herself half in the air.

The noise from outside wasn't helping. Lawri bent to
get through the doorway. "Could you hold it down!" she
whisper-snarled. "These citizens don't need . . . oh.
Clave . . . Chairman, I'm trying to give them some quiet.
Can you take the talk to the commons?"

Clave and Anthon were intimidated into silence. Jeffer
asked, "Can any of them answer questions?"

"They're asleep. They haven't said anything sensi-
ble."

Her husband merely nodded. Lawri went back in. Rus-
tling sounds receded. For a moment she felt remorse. Jef-
fer would want to see the strangers as much as anyone.

When the burns healed, the strangers would be hand-
some, but in weird fashion. Only birds wore the gaudy

colors of their scorched clothing. Their skin was dark;

their lips and noses were broad; their hair was like black

pillows.

The youngest girl stirred, thrashed, and opened her
eyes. "Tide," she said wonderingly. The dark eyes fo-
cused. "Who're you?"

"I'm Lawri the Scientist. You're in Citizens Tree.
You're safe now."

The girl twisted to see the others. "Wend?"

"One of you died."

The girl moaned.

"Can you tell me who you are and how you came

here?"

"I'm Carlot," the girl said. Two tears were growing.
"We're Serjent House. Loggers. There was afire ... the
whole tree caught fire. Wend got caught when the water
tank let go." She shook her head; teardrop globules flew

wide.

"All right, Carlot. Have some water, then go to sleep."
Carlot's drinking technique was surprising. She took
the pottery vessel, set two fingers to nearly block the
opening, then jerked the pottery vessel toward her face.
The jet of water struck her lower lip. She tried again and

reached her mouth.

"Would you like something to eat? Foliage?"

"What's that?"

Lawri went out to strip some branchlets of their foli-
age. Carlot looked dubiously at the fluffy green stuff.
"Oh, it's greens."

"You know it?"

"I've been in a tree tuft." She tasted it. "This is sweet.
Older tree?" She continued eating.

Lawri said, "Later I'll get you some stew. You should

sleep now."

Carlot patted the wicker floor. "How can I sleep with
this pushing up against me? All my blood wants to settle
on one side."




38 / Larry Niven

London Tree, Lawn's home, had been bigger, with a
stronger tide. In Citizens Tree you could drop a stone
from eye level and draw a slow breath and let it out before
the stone struck. But this Carlot must be used to no tide
at all.

She turned over, gingerly. Her eyes closed and she was
asleep.

They moved through the green gloom of the corridor,
back toward the commons. Anthon said, "I always won-
dered. Lawri doesn't take orders from you either, does
she?"

Jeffer laughed. "Treefodder, no!"

Clave said, "I really wanted to ask them some ques-
tions before we tackle the firetree."

"We can't wait," Jeffer said. "Let's go see what we
can scavenge. This is the most interesting thing that has
happened to us in fourteen years."

"It's bound to bring changes."

"Like what?"

Clave grinned at Jeffer. "They've already changed
your home life. You can't sleep in the Scientists' hut and
Lawri won't leave."

"I've got the children too. I'm living in the bachelors'
longhut with my three kids and Rather. Look, I want to
go now, before that burned tree drifts too far. Anthon?"

"Ready," said the jungle giant.

Clave nodded, reluctantly. "Just us three? Stet. We'll
round up some kids to run the treadmill. And let's take
those wings along. I want to try them."

The tree still burned. Fire had eaten six or seven klom-
ters in from the midpoint along the lee side, progressing
alongside the waterfall channel, where there was partial
protection from the wind. The flames streamed east like
the mane of a skyhorse. At the midpoint there were only
red patches glowing in black char. In the center of the

;                            THE SMOKE RING / 39

,   burn was a prominent uneven lump. Jeffer eased the
I   CARM toward that.

Clave said, "I don't understand why it hasn't come

,   apart."

Anthon nodded uneasily. Jeffer said, " It' s a short tree.
I   With a tuft missing it's even shorter. Tide would pull
harder on a grown tree, but that thing could still come
apart while we're on it. I don't ever want to go through
that again."

Anthon asked, "Why do trees come apart?"
"They do it when they're dying," Clave said.
Jeffer said, "When a tree drifts too far away from the
Smoke Ring median, it starves. It saves itself by coming
i   apart. The tide takes half of it out, half in. One half falls
;    back to where the water and fertilizer are. The other half
... dies, I guess."

"I still don't see any bugs," Clave said. "It's the bugs
!    that eat a tree apart, isn't it? The tree isn't getting fed,

so the bark lets the bugs get inside—"
|      "I don't know everything, Clave."
:      "Pity."

They were close enough now to make out black lumps
at the center of the charred region. There: a shape like a
huge seed pod split open from inside. There: a thin shell
of char, a bell shape not unlike the fire-spitting nostrils
at the CARM's aft end. A ridge of white ash joined the
•    bell to the split pod. Beyond: several fragile sheets of
charred wood, the remains of an oblong hut with interior

walls.
'      Clave reached for the wings he'd bound to cargo hooks.

"Scientist, can you hold the CARM here? We'll go see
:    what there is to see. If the tree breaks in half, you'll still

have us tethered."

i      Jeffer stifled a protest. He ached to explore that ruined
|    structure, but— "I can handle it. Take lines too."
i      The sun would be dead east in a few tens of breaths.
A stick protruded from the butt end of each fan-shaped




40 / Larry Niven

wing. After some experimentation they settled for lining
the stick along their shins and binding them with the
straps. The wings tended to hang up on things even when
folded. Clave and Anthon wriggled through the airlock
and flapped into the sky.

Jeffer tapped the white button. "Prikazyvat Voice,"
he said.

The CARM said, "Ready, Jeffer the Scientist."
Clave and Anthon fluttered erratically through the air.
Suddenly Anthon moved purposefully toward the blister
of charred machinery, moving easily, as if he had always
been a bird. Clave moved after him, fighting a tendency
to veer left.

They swept away the white ash that lay between the
bell and the tank. The ash enclosed them in cloud. When
the cloud dispersed, they had exposed a length of tube
and a loose webbing of metal strands around it.

"Kendy for the State. Hello, Jeffer."

Jeffer didn't jump. "Hello, Kendy. What do you make
of all this?"

"You'd know more about the injured plant than I. I've
been studying the machinery." Within the bow window
the metal strands and the enclosed pipe began blinking,
an outline of red light. "These, the pipe and the chicken
wire, are metal. The ruptured tank—" another blinking
outline "—appears to have been a large seed pod. The
cone is half of a similar seed pod. The ash around the pipe
appears to be wood ash.

"We're looking at a steam rocket, Jeffer. Your invad-
ers used a wood fire to heat the pipe. They ran water
through the pipe and into the nozzle. Very inefficient, but
in your peculiar environment they could move a tree with
that. Slowly, of course."

"Why would they pick an injured tree?"

"Ask them. Did any survive?"

"One's dead. 'Five more are in bad shape. My wife
won't let me near them. Wait a few days and see."

THE SMOKE RING / 41

Clave and Anthon flew along the split in the great tank.
They reached the cluster of black oblongs at the other

end.

The Checker said, "Their wounds won't become in-
fected. We didn't bring disease bacteria."

"What?"

"I was thinking aloud. I want to talk to your invaders.
Take them on a tour, Jeffer, when they're ready. Show

them the CARM."

"Kendy, I'm not sure I want them to know about

you."

"I will observe only."

Clave and Anthon were flapping back to the CARM.
They carried blackened cargo, and they no longer wore
tethers. "Company coming," Jeffer said.

"Jeffer, you've concealed your contact with me from
the rest of your tribe, haven't you?"

"I haven't mentioned it to them yet."

"I'll keep my silence while others are aboard. Play the
game any way you like."

Clave and Anthon returned black with soot. They un-
tied the now-clumsy wings, then wiggled in, pushing arm-
fuls of blackened salvage ahead of them. Clave crowed,
"I love it! It's really flying!"

"You never did like tide, did you, Clave? How's the

leg?"

"It never gets any better." Clave flexed his right leg.
The misshapen lump on his thighbone bulged beneath the
skin and muscle. The compound fracture he'd suffered in
Carther States had healed, but in the jungle there had been
no tide to tell the bone to stop growing. "It feels like I
strained it. If I have to fly any distance I'll use just one

wing."

They set to mooring their loot along the walls. Two
tremendous hooks, wood stiffened with metal. A meter's
length of metal band with tiny teeth along one edge. A

42 / Larry Niven

hardwood tube had kept its shape if not its strength; the
remnants of charred plastic hose clung to one end.

"Weapons and tools," Clave said. 'There was wire
twisted together like a harebrain net, but it was burned
through in too many places. Nothing else worth taking
except the pipe. We've got to have that pipe. We moored
the lines to it, Jeffer. Let's pull it loose."

"It must be important, given that you've moored the
CARM to a tree that's about to come apart. Why? Just
because it's metal?"

"I've got a vague idea what this setup is for," Clave
said. "We could duplicate everything except the pipe, in
theory anyway. The pipe isn't just metal, it's starstuff,
something out of the old science."

"Why do you say that?"

"We couldn't find a seam," Anthon said. "It gleams
when you rub away the soot. Clave, I'm not sure I like
any of this. Jeffer's right, that tree could come apart and
throw us spinning across the sky, and for what? Wings,
sure, those are wonderful, but the rest of this is just
weird!"

Clave the Chairman said, "Pull that pipe out. Scien-
tist."

Anthon fumed and was silent. Jeffer said, "Strap
down. Let's hope the tethers hold."

Under attitude jets the CARM shuddered and lurched.
Then six meters of metal pipe two hundred ce'meters
across pulled loose in a cloud of ash.

When Anthon and Clave went out to retrieve it, Jeffer
went too. They watched, grinning, while he thrashed and
spun; and suddenly he was flying, kicking stiff-legged
across the sky like any swordbird.

They bound the pipe up against the hull and took the
CARM back to Citizens Tree. The burning tree continued
to drift west and in.

Lawri kept the citizens away from her hut for five days,

THE SMOKE RING / 43

a full waking-sleeping cycle. That became impossible
when she sent Rather for food. Rather came back with
waterbird stew, and Clave, Jeffer, Gavving, Minya,
Debby, Jayan, Jinny, Mark, Jill, and a host of children.
She kept them outside while the strangers ate. Then she
and Jeffer pulled the hut's entrance apart. It could be re-
built later.

The man named himself: Booce Serjent. He shaped his
words strangely. He named the others: his wife Ryllin,
and their daughters Mishael, Karilly, and Carlot.

"We've delayed the funeral until you're strong
enough," Clave said. "Can you make yourself discuss
funeral practices?"

Booce shrugged painfully. "We cremate. The ashes go
into the earthlife tanks. What do you do here?"

"The dead go to feed the tree."

"All right. Chairman Clave, what has happened to
LogbearerT'

"I don't understand."

"Logbearer is our ship. You saw a burning tree? The
fire started around Logbearer, in the middle."

"We went there. We brought back a metal pipe and
some other stuff."

"You saved the main feed pipe! How?"

"We used the CARM. It's an old starstuff relic, still
working. We use it to move the tree."

Booce smiled and sighed and seemed about to drift off
to sleep.

Lawri asked, "What are you? Carlot said loggers."

"Let him alone. I'm awake." The older woman
sounded tired. "I'm Ryllin. Yes, we're loggers. We take
lumber back to the Clump and sell it there."

Chairman Clave asked, "You mean there are men in
there?"

Ryllin's laugh chopped off as if it had hurt her. "More
than a thousand. With children, near two thousand."




44 / Larry Niven THE SMOt

"Thousands. Huh. And you move trees. Don't you
have trees in the Clump?"

"No. The tide's wrong."

"How do you move a tree?"

"You cut off one tuft. Then the wind only blows on
the other tuft. Booce generally takes us west, so of course
we want the log to go east. So we cut the in tuft. The
wind pushes just on the out tuft, so it pushes the tree west,
and that slows it down. The tree drops closer to Voy and
speeds up—"

The children and some adults were looking confused.
We taught them this! Lawri thought angrily. West takes
you in. Pushing a tree against the Smoke Ring's rotation—
west—would drop it closer to Voy. Lower orbits were
faster orbits. The tree would move east toward the Clump.

"—But of course we need the rocket too," Ryllin was
saying. "A rocket is a tank of water, and a nozzle, and
a metal pipe with a fire around it. You run water through
the pipe. The steam sprays away from where you want
to go. Without the pipe there's no Log bearer. You un-
derstand reaction effects?"

The citizens looked at each other. Children understood
the law of reaction before they could speak!

Ryllin said, "Well, when you get to the Clump you
sever the other tuft and work the log to a mooring with
the steam rocket. Then you have to sell it. We've done
it all our lives. But the pipefire got away from us ...
Lawri? I'm tired."

Gavving said, "Sell?"

"Forget it, Ryllin. Everybody out," Lawri ordered.
"Chairman, can you move them?"

The citizens drifted away in clumps of heated discus-
sion.

Four sleeps after reaching Citizens Tree, all of the Ser-
Jents were on their feet. Various citizens volunteered to
lead them about. They moved tentatively, slowed by heal-


ing bums and unaccustomed to tide. Tb
tently, and spoke in vowel-twisting aecen
words ... but for Karilly, who huddled ck
of her family, silent.

Booce and his family came back tired. T
was primitive, and roomy, and oddly bea
izens had managed well with so little.

Lawri the Scientist looked them over ai
well enough to attend a funeral.

Chapter Four

The In Tuft

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 7 SM:

INTEGRAL TREES

. . . THESE INTEGRAL TREES GROW TO TREMENDOUS
SIZE. WHEN SUCH A PLANT REACHES ITS FULL GROWTH,
IT STABILIZES BY TIDAL EFFECT. IT FORMS A LONG,
SLENDER TRUNK TUFTED WITH GREEN AT BOTH ENDS:

TENS OF THOUSANDS OF RADIAL SPOKES CIRCLING LE-
VOY'S STAR, EACH SCORES OF KILOMETERS LONG.

LIKE MANY PLANTS OF THE SMOKE RING, THE IN-
TEGRAL TREE IS A SOIL COLLECTOR. THE ENDPOINTS
ARE SUBJECTTO TIDAL GRAVITY. AND WIND' THE TUFTS
ARE IN A PERPETUAL WIND, BLOWING FROM THE WEST
AT THE INNER TUFT AND FROM THE EAST AT THE OUTER
TUFT. THE TIDE-ORIENTED TRUNK BOWS TO THE WINDS,
CURVING INTO A SINGLE, NEARLY HORIZONTAL BRANCH
AT EACH END, GIVING IT THE APPEARANCE OF AN IN-
46

THE SMOKE RING / 47

TEGRATION SIGN. THE TUFTS SIFT FERTILIZER FROM THE
WIND: SOIL, WATER, EVEN ANIMALS AND PLANTS
SMASHED BY IMPACT.

FREE-FALL CONDITIONS PREVAIL EVERYWHERE EX-
CEPT IN THE INTEGRAL TREES. THE MEDICAL DANGERS
OF LIFE IN FREE-FALL ARE WELL KNOWN. IF DISCIPLINE
HAS INDEED ABANDONED US, IF WE ARE INDEED MA-
ROONED WITHIN THIS WEIRD ENVIRONMENT, WE COULD
DO WORSE THAN TO SETTLE THE TUFTS OF THE INTEGRAL
TREES . . .

—CLAIRE DALTON, SOCIOLOGY/MEDICINE

FOLIAGE FRAMED HALF A WORLD OF SKY.

The treemouth faced west, at the junction between
branch and trunk. Spine branches migrated west along the
branch, carrying whatever their foliage had picked up
from the wind, to be swallowed by the conical pit. Citi-
zens came too, to feed the tree. The treemouth was their
toilet, their garbage disposal, and their cemetery.

Lawri the Scientist had described all of this in advance.
Booce tried to tell himself that it made sense; it was rea-
sonable in context; it only took getting used to.

Wend had been placed at the lip of the pit. She'd had
time to ride the spine branches halfway into the cone of
the treemouth. Booce was glad that he could not see her
better.

Burning was cleaner. Reducing the body to ashes
burned away memories too . . .

How was Karilly taking it?

Karilly was the quiet one. She obeyed orders, but
rarely showed initiative. She almost never spoke to
strangers. A good child, but Booce had never really
understood her.

She hadn't been burned. All of them had watched
Wend die; how could it be worse for Karilly? But she
hadn't spoken a word since the fire.

48 / Larry Niven

Chairman Clave spoke, welcoming Wend into the
tribe. Lawri spoke of a citizen's last duty, to feed the tree.
Ryllin spoke her memories of her lost daughter. Karilly
cried silently; the tears sheathed her eyes in crystal.

Older citizens ate first. Booce saw his daughters hang-
ing back—they had learned that much already—while a
Citizens Tree girl-child filled his bowl with waterbird stew
from a large, crude ceramic pot. He lurched away across
the woven-spine-branch floor of the commons, following
his wife, trying to keep his bowl upright.

"You think of the tide as something to fight," his wife
said softly. "Think of it as a convenience."

"Hah."

"Tide gives you a preferred direction. Something to
push against. Look." With the bowl held in one hand,
Ryllin leapt one-legged into the air and spun in a slow
circle before her feet touched the floor again. She hadn't
spilled a drop.

"Moving isn't unpleasant in a tide, it's just different.
These, ah, citizens make us look clumsy, but we can ad-
just, love. We will adjust."

"Stet. I've climbed trees all my life. . . . Company."
They were surrounded by children. A pudgy half-
grown girl said, "How do you move a tree without a

CARM?"

Booee said, "Let's sit down and I'll tell you."
A dozen children waited patiently while Booce and

Ryllin nested themselves in foliage. Then they all settled

at once.

Booce thought while he ate. He said, "You need a
rocket. My rocket was Logbearer, and it was my father's
rocket before me. To make a rocket you need a rocket."
One asked, "How did anyone build the first rocket?"
Booce smiled at the dwarf boy. "The first rocket was
given by Discipline. It had a mind—the Library—and the
Admiralty still has that, with more knowledge in it than

THE SMOKE RING / 49

you'll find in your little cassettes. Anyway, you've got to
have a rocket so you can get to the pod groves."

A woman of Booce's own size settled within earshot.
Booce pretended not to notice. "The biggest pod you can
find in the pod grove becomes your water tank. You cut
another pod in half and it's your rocket nozzle. You run
the pipe into the stem end. You wrap sikenwire around
the pipe to hold the firebark. You light the firebark. You
pump water through the hot pipe and it turns to steam
and goes racing out the nozzle, and that pushes you the

other way."

The pudgy girl (though all the children looked a bit
pudgy, well fed and compressed by tide) asked, "Where
does pipe come from?"

"I don't know. Discipline, maybe, if there ever was a
Discipline." The children snickered. Booce didn't know
why, so he ignored it. "There's a hundred and twenty
meters of pipe in the Empire, so they tell me, and forty-
eight of that makes up the pipes in eleven logging ships.
Woodsman carried a spare pipe, but they're richer than

we are.

"So. A rocket is one and a half pods, and a pipe, and
some sikenwire, and the hut complex at the other end of
the tank. You need big hooks for towing, saws to carve
up wood, and crossbows, because you've got to find your
own food. A trip takes a year or two. Most of us travel

in families.

"Now you find a sting jungle. The honey hornets live
in the sting jungles, and there's nothing so big they can't
kill it. You need to cover yourself all over to get at the
nest. Honey is sticky red stuff, sweeter than foliage.

"Now you pick a tree. If it's more than forty klomters
long, the wood'll be too coarse and you'll be forever com-
ing home. Thirty's about right. You moor your rocket at
the midpoint, but you don't use it yet. You paint a line
of honey down the trunk to one of the tufts. Then you
gash the bark in a circle above the tuft, and paint honey

50 / Larry Niven

along that. You know the bugs that eat a tree apart if it
starts to die?"

Heads nodded. The Serjents had been told of the death
of Dalton-Quinn Tree. Children must hear that tale early.

Booce said, "The bugs follow the honey down. They
eat the honey above the tuft. Then they're stuck, because
they've eaten all the honey. There's nothing left to eat
but wood. After a few sleeps the tuft drops off."

There were sounds of dismay. "We don't use occupied
trees, you know," Booce said gently. "The tree would
die anyway when it gets near the Clump. Integral trees
want a straightforward tidal pull, straight through Voy."

The pudgy girl asked a little coldly, "How many trees
have you killed?" Booce saw that she was almost an
adult. Her height had fooled him: the tide had stunted her
growth.

"Ten."

The dwarf (an adult too, with beard beginning to
sprout) asked, "Why do you cut off the tuft?"

"To move. You know the rule? West takes you in, in
takes you east. I want the tree to move east, back to the
Clump. So I cut the in tuft. Now I've got a west wind
blowing on the out tuft, and nothing at the in stump to
catch the wind. The tree accelerates west. It drops toward
Voy. Things move faster when their orbits are closer to
Voy, so the tree moves east. After a while I'm in from
the Clump and still moving. That's when I need the
rocket. I have to cut off the other tuft, then fire the rocket
to move the tree into the Clump."

The dwarf boy asked, "What then?"

"Then I sell the log for what I can get, and hope nobody
else brought a log in at the same time. If there are two of
us competing, we might not get enough to pay us for the
work."

Most of the children looked puzzled. The dwarf asked,
"What went wrong this time?"

Booce's throat closed up. His decision! With some re-


r

THE SMOKE RING / 51

lief he heard Ryllin say, "We were in a hurry. We thought
we could get more water for the rocket. So we set the
rocket going before the tuft dropped off. That started a
fire. Wend was trying to get out of the huts when the water
tank—well, it got too hot and—"

Booce jumped in, hastily. "The water tank split open.
Wend got caught. Cariot and I were burned pulling her
out of the steam. We were steering the log for that pond
out there, and your tree moved in front of it, so it was
the closest. So we made for it. And you found six of us
clinging to the trunk like toes in hair, and—and Wend
was dead, and the rest of us were ready to die, I think."

The adults had all been served. The children drifted
toward the cookpot. Booce ate. He'd let his stew get cold.

Likely he would never see the Clump again. It was as
well. He and his family would be paupers there. He had
never owned anything but Logbearer itself, and even that
was gone. But was it really beyond belief that these people
could build another Logbearer']

When all the adults were eating, the children drifted
into line at the cookpot. Rather was just ahead of three
tall and dark young women, and just behind his brother
Harry.

"Take Jill's place," Rather told Harry.

"Why should I?"

"Beats me. Will you do it?"

"All right."

The favor would be repaid. Rather would take Harry's
place at the cookpot or in the treadmill, or show him a
wrestling trick; something. These things didn't need dis-
cussion. Harry stepped out of line and talked to Jill where
she was serving stew. Jill served herself and Harry took

her place.

The blond girl joined Rather. "What's that for?" she
asked; but she seemed pleased.

"I've been listening to the old ones. Now I want to

52 / Larry Niven

talk to the girls. Come along?" If they wouldn't talk to a
dwarf boy, maybe they'd talk to a girl.

They followed the Serjent girls as they made their ex-
aggeratedly careful way across the commons' wicker
floor. The refugees settled slowly into the foliage, keeping
their eyes fixed on their bowls. Stew still slopped over
the edge ofCariot's bowl. "The hole's too big," she said.

"You just need practice. —I'm Jill, he's Rather."

"How do you eat when you're at the midpoint?"

Jill and Rather settled across from them. Rather
stripped four branchlets for chopsticks. Jill said, "I'd take
a smoked turkey along. What do you use? Bowls with
smaller holes?"

"Yes, and we carry these." Carlot produced a pair of
bone sticks, ornately carved. "You're lucky. You've al-
ways got ... spine branches?"

"These are branchlets. The spine branches are the big
ones."

The third girl, Karilly, had not spoken. She was con-
centrating fully on her bowl.

Mishael said, "You seem to be happy."

Rather found the comment disconcerting. "What do
you mean?"

"You, all of you. You've got your tree and it's all you
need. Lumber from the bare end of the branch. The
clothes you wear, the cloth comes from branchlet fibers,
doesn't it?"

"It's foliage with the sugar washed out."

"And the dye is from berries. Water comes running
down the trunk into that basin, and you eat foliage and
catch meat from the sky. And there's the CARM. Without
the CARM you'd have to build a rocket to move the tree.''

"Right." Rather thought, We don't know how to do
that. The CARM is all that keeps us from being savages.
Is that how they see us? "We had to leave the tree to get
our lines. And "the adults keep talking about earthlife
crops. They couldn't bring seeds and eggs with them."

THE SMOKE RING / 53

"You could buy them in the Market if you were rich
enough."

Jill said, "We don't know those words. Rich? Buy?"

Carlot said, "Rich means you can have whatever you
want."

"Like being Chairman?"

"No—"

Mishael took over. "Look, suppose you want earthlife
seeds or pigeons or turkeys. Stet, you go to the Market
and you find what you want. Then you've got to buy it.
You need something to give the owner. Metal, maybe."

"We don't have much metal," Rather said. "What are
the people like? Like you?"

"Sometimes," Carlot said. "What do you mean? Tall?
Dark? We get dark and light, short and . . . well, mostly
we're about as tall as me, and the men are taller."

"No dwarves?"

"Oh, of course there are dwarves. In the Navy."

"What do you think of dwarves?" He hadn't meant to
ask so directly; he hadn't realized how important the
question was to him.

Carlot asked, "What do you think of my legs?"

Rather blushed. "They're fine." They were hidden
anyway; Carlot was wearing the scarlet tunic and pan-
taloons of Citizens Tree.

"One's longer than the other. My teacher's got one leg
longer than mine and one leg like yours, and it never both-
ers him. And the Admiral's got an arm like a turkey wish-
bone. I've seen him. We're all kinds. Rather."

It was Mark's habit to eat near the cauldron, where
others might find him. Rarely did he get company. This
day he was mildly surprised when Clave and Minya set-
tled themselves across from him. They plucked branchlets
and ate. Presently Clave asked, "What do you think of
the Serjents?"

"They're doing all right."




54 / Larry Niven

"That wasn't what I meant," Clave said, while Minya
was saying, "What will they do to Citizens Tree?"

"Oh." Mark thought it over. "Half of you came from
the in tuft of a broken tree. You were from the out tuft,
Minya. Three from Carther States. Lawri and me from
London Tree. London Tree used to raid Carther States
for copsiks. Fourteen years we've been living here, and
nobody's killed anyone yet. We can live with the Serjents
too."

Clave said, "Oh, we can live with them—" while
Minya wondered, "What do they think of us?"

Clave snorted. "They think we're a little backward,
and they'd like to talk us into going to the Clump."

Where was this leading? Mark asked, "Are you think-
ing they want the CARM?"

"No, not that. Not impossible either . . . Have you
talked to Gavving or Debby lately?"

"They don't like my company. Neither do you,
Minya."

Minya ignored that. "They're trying to figure out how
to build a steam rocket, starting with just the metal tube
they brought back!"

"Uh-/;«A." Mark saw the point now. "They can build
us a machine that moves trees around. They can tell us
why we should all go to the Clump. So you're a little
nervous. Chairman? We could lose half the tribe. Lawri
keeps saying there aren't enough of us now."

"And what do you want. Mark?"

Mark would have wished for a wife or three, but he
saw no point in telling Clave or Minya that. "I want noth-
ing from the Clump. We're here. Twelve adults, twenty
children, happy as dumbos in Citizens Tree. We shouldn't
be announcing that all over the sky. Even if the Clump
doesn't keep copsiks, maybe somebody out there does.
Things aren't perfect here, but they're good. I wouldn't
want to wind up as somebody's copsik."

Clave nodded. "That's what I'm afraid of."

THE SMOKE RING / 55

Minya said, "We worked so hard to make this our
home. Gavving knows how close we came to dying. How
can he risk what we've got?"

"We seem to be agreed," Clave said briskly. "Well?
What do we do about it?"

Lawri and Jeffer were missing dinner. Lawri had led
her husband east along the branch, beyond the region of
the huts. In a dark womb of foliage and branchlets, they

were making babies.

Resting, relaxed for the first time in many days, Lawri
plucked foliage and put it in Jeffer's mouth. He talked
around it, indistinctly. "Does this remind you of being
young?"

She lost her smile. "No."

He leered. "Little London Tree boys and girls never
snuck off into the foliage—?"

She shook her head violently. "It isn't like that for a
girl in London Tree. When boys get old enough, they
don't need us. They go to the in tuft. Copsik women be-
long to any male citizen. Jeffer, you know that much!"

"I should. That's how Mark got Minya pregnant, be-
fore we got loose."

She changed position to lie along his length. "If he did.

Any man can father a dwarf."

"Even Rather doesn't believe that."

"Bother him?"

"Yeah . . . But women had children in London Tree,
didn't they? And married?"

"Yes, if we were willing to act like copsiks ourselves.
How else could we compete? I would've been some man's
copsik if I wanted to make babies. So I never made ba-
bies."

Jeffer looked into her eyes as if seeing her for the first

time. "Are you glad I came?"

She nodded. Perhaps he couldn't see her blushing in

the near-darkness.

56 / Larry Niven

"Why didn't you ever tell me?"
That was a stupid question. Knowing how she needed
him, he'd use his advantage to win arguments! "This
wasn't what we came to talk about."
"Did we come to talk?"
"What did you find on the burned tree?"
"We didn't keep any secrets. —That's right, you wer-
en't there when Booce was telling us what we had. Well,
we got a pot full of charred stuff—honey, he said—and
a metal thing for cutting wood, and hooks . . . miscella-
neous stuff. And the metal pipe. Everything else that
burned—I've forgotten what he called it all, but it can all
be replaced, except the—what did Booce call it? The sik-
enwire."

"I want to go to the Clump," Lawri said.
"Me too. Clave would never let both Scientists go."
Jeffer kissed her cheek. "Let's wait till the last minute
and then fight about it."

"What about the sikenwire?"
"We'll think of something. Do you think Clave will let
us take the CARM?"
"... No."

She felt him shrug. "Okay. We go as loggers?" She
nodded (their foreheads brushed) and he said, "I'd guess
Clump citizens will all look like jungle giants. We should
have a few. Anthon and Debby'll come. A couple of the
Serjents for guides. Defenses ... we wouldn't want to
risk the CARM in the Clump, but we could take the silver
suit."

"Wrong. A lot of citizens don't want anything
changed. Clave thinks we're too close to the Clump al-
ready. He wants to take us farther west. Mark agrees with
him."

"Yeah, I've talked to Mark. Treefodder. Without him
we can't use the silver suit . . . Lawri? Clave wants to
move us west?"

"What are you thinking?"

THE SMOKE RING / 57

"We don't know enough yet. Forget it. Look what you
missed when you were a little girl..."

Whatever the disagreements now roiling through Cit-
izens Tree, there was at least this bone of consensus: they
all wanted to fly.

The Serjent girls were willing. From branchwood
sticks and from cloth that was made on the looms below
the branch, they made wings. Karilly worked quietly and
skillfully and without words. Mishael and Carlot ex-
plained as they went, and corrected the mistakes of the
children who emulated them. The work went fast. Citi-
zens would wear their old tunics and pants for half a year
longer, for cloth was not made quickly; but twenty-four
wings were ready within twelve days.

Jeffer took Mishael, Minya, Gawing, and eight of the
older children to the midpoint via the lift. Other children
ran with zeal in the treadmill, knowing that theirs would
be the next flight.

Jeffer had chosen with some care. These were the chil-
dren who had not shied back from crossing to the pond
on the day of the firetree. Yet there had been lines to cling
to then. Today there was only bark, and some of them
clung to that.

Rather flew, and was instantly in love with wings. Jill
looked like she was facing death, but when wings were
bound to her ankles and Rather was already in the sky,
she flew. Mishael served as instructor. Jeffer learned how
to kick, how to turn. When the sky was filled with winged
adults and children, the rest gulped hard and loosed their
hold on the bark and flew.

They were in the sky for one full circle of the sun. The
adults had their hands full herding them back to the lift.
Arth made a game of it, fleeing across the sky until Jeffer
and Gawing closed in on him and pulled his wings off.
The sun was rising up the east before they had the children
rounded up.

58 / Larry Niven

Then Jeffer sent the others down without him. He told
Minya, "I want to do some maintenance. Start the lift
again after you're down."

"Kendy for the State. Hello, Scientist."

"Hello, Kendy."

"How are your refugees?"

"Four of the Serjents recovered. One of the girls, Kar-
illy, looks okay but she doesn't talk."

"Shock. She may recover. When may I see them?"
"Kendy, I wanted to give Mishael a tour of the CARM.

The Chairman vetoed that. He's afraid they'll try to steal
the CARM."

"Nonsense. What do the rest of your tribe think?"

"We're split down the middle. Half of us want to go
see what's in the Clump. They've got a place ... the
Market? . . . where we could get anything we want. The
Serjents told us about it."

"And?"

"The Chairman is scared spitless of the Clump. He
thinks we're too close now. Some of the others feel the
same way. Jayan and Jinny, of course, but Mark and
Minya too. Even the Serjents don't all want to leave.
Mark's asked Ryllin for permission to marry Karilly, and
she gave it."

"Good. How do you feel about this, Jeffer?"
"1 want to see the Clump. Booce told me they've got
something they call the Library, but it sounds like a
CARM autopilot. I want to scan their cassettes. Kendy,
I'm doing what I can. I just took some of them flying.
They like that. Maybe they'll start wondering what else
they're missing."

"I remember Clave. He leads his citizens where they
want to go. Call a council. Force your citizens to make
a decision."

"What good does that do us?"
"If you lose the vote, you'll know where you stand.

THE SMOKE RING / 59

Then make Clave set a date for moving the tree. Decide
what you need and who you need. Is there any chance
you can talk Mark around?"

"None."

"The Serjents told you how to go about setting up a
logging enterprise. Tell me."

The children slept on, exhausted by their flying. Gavv-
ing was making an early breakfast on a slice of smoked
dumbo meat. He said, "The Admiralty has earthlife

plants."

"We've lived without them for fourteen years," Minya
said sleepily.

"We lived without lifts and the CARM for longer than
that. It was because we didn't know."

"The Admiralty has never touched us. We wouldn't
know it exists, except that Booce tells us so. But you want
to know more. Aren't these matters more properly dis-
cussed in council?"

Gavving looked closely at his wife. "You looked like
this fourteen years ago, when you were trying to kill me.
The whole tuft is like that. There hasn't been fighting like
this since the War of London Tree!"

"I haven't forgotten London Tree. We made a home
here. Any change is for the worse."

"Dear, are you sorry they came?"

"No!" Minya said with some force. She was fully
awake now. "There aren't enough of us. We all feel that."

"Lawri the Scientist talks about the gene pool being

too small—"

"We don't need that gibberish. We can feel we're too
few. Now we have three more women, even if Ryllin is
too old to host a guest, and they're different from us—"

"They are indeed!"

"Well, that's good!"

"Suppose they want to go home?"

"They can't," Minya said flatly.

60 / Larry Niven

A child stirred: Qwen. Gavving lowered his voice.
"Suppose we built them another rocket. Suppose some
of us wanted to go with them."

Minya stopped to sort words through her head. Gavv-
ing waited patiently. Presently she said, "They'd have to
be crazy. We'd have to be crazy to let them go. Gav, have
you forgotten London Tree?"

"No. I haven't forgotten Quinn Tuft, either, or Carther
States. They didn't make citizens into copsiks, and neither
did your people."

"... No. But we attacked you the instant we saw
you."

"True."

"Do you remember being lost in the sky, clinging to a
sheet of bark and dying of thirst? We faced dangers we
can't even describe to our children, because they were
too strange! We fought hard for Citizens Tree! And now
both Scientists want to cross a thousand klomters to the
Clump shouting 'Here we are!' Why do you want to risk
what we've got?"

"They've got things to trade. They've got wings—"
"We've got wings."

"We picked jet pods, when we could find them. All
this time. And it's so simple'. Minya, what would you have
given for a pair of wings, when we were stranded in the
sky? Everything in the Smoke Ring can fly except men,
and all it takes is spine branches and cloth! They've got
a rocket that moves a tree, and it isn't stolen starstuff,
it's made mostly from things they find in the Smoke Ring.

What have they got in the Clump? What haven't we seen
yet?"

She put bitterness in her laughter. "A thousand people
and a drastic need for copsiks, maybe."

Gavving sighed. "Stet, you don't want anything
changed. What should we do? They're here."

"Make them welcome," said Minya. "Teach them

THE SMOKE RING / 61

how to live in a tree. Get the girls married. Make them
part of us. Gavving, Mark intends to marry Karilly."
"Karilly's sick in the mind. She isn't getting over it."
"Sure, and Mark's a dwarf. He's needed a wife, and
none of us would touch him. 1 never did feel sorry for the
copsik runner, but... but he's willing to take care other.
And I think you ought to marry one of the other girls."
Bang! Gavving stared. This was a woman afraid of

changes? "I am married."

"Clave has two wives. Anthon did, until lisa died. I'm

getting too old to make babies, dear."
"You don't mean—"
"No!" She hugged him. "But it won't give me a guest

to carry."

"You're serious? Okay, who?"

She hesitated. Then, bravely (he thought): "I would
have thought Mishael. She's the oldest. Gavving, she
showed me how to fly. I like her."

"Have you mentioned any of—"

"No, you fool! A woman doesn't ask a woman to be
her wife!" And when he laughed she smiled, weakly.
Gavving saw how difficult this was for her. Minya must
have thought long and hard about this.

"There's room to extend the hut," she said. "We'd
have another pair of hands, adult hands. The children are
growing up, they're not as much fun any more—"

And if some of us marry Serjent women, we'll have
their loyalty when the Admiralty comes to us! Logbearer
can't be the only ship in the sky. Gavving wondered if his
brain was working in the service of his seeds. Minya had
not referred to Mishael's alien beauty.

And if we do visit the Clump, his brain ran on, we'll
need guides. Booce or Ryllin would have to go. With their
daughters among us, we'd have their loyalty—




Chapter Fwe

The Silver Suit

from the Admiralty cassettes, year 3 SM:

WE WERE CHOSEN FOR THIS. NO CITIZEN LEAVES
EARTH ORBIT UNTIL THE STATE HAS LEARNED HIS TOL-
ERANCE FOR FREE-FALL. ONE IN TEN THOUSAND HAVE
THE GENETIC QUIRKS TO SURVIVE MONTHS OR YEARS OF
FREE-FALL WITHOUT SOFTENING OF THE BONES, WITH-
OUT FAILURE OF THE DIGESTIVE SYSTEM, WITHOUT THE
TERROR OF FALLING.

WE SERVED THE STATE BY FLYING TO THE STARS.
WHEN THE DRIVE WAS OFF WE PLAYED AT FLYING,
WHILE CRAMPED IN A SEEDER RAMSHIP WITH BARELY
ROOM TO FLAP OUR ARMS. HERE IS REAL FLIGHT. OF
COURSE THE SMOKE RING SEEMS AN INCREDIBLE
DREAM COME TRUE—TO US.

—SHARON LEVOY, ASTROGATION

"KENDY FOR THE STATE. HELLO, JEFFER. IT'S BEEN

more than thirty days."

62

THE SMOKE RING / 63

"I was busy. We got our council. It's over."

"How did it go?"

"We lost."

"Who sided against you?"

"Clave. Jayan and Jinny. Minya. Mark."

"Five out of ten. If you count the Serjents, twelve."

"Thirteen. Mishael's old enough, and married too, but
she acts like a junior wife. She won't make Minya or
Gavving angry. Gavving doesn't want to fight with Minya.
The Serjents don't think like citizens yet. Anthon won't
get into the arguments. I'm not really sure where he
stands. The rest of us want to see what's out there, but
we don't all want it enough. Debby loves arguing, but
she's not very good at it. We didn't give Clave any trouble
at all."

"You're disappointed. Don't be. Did you think that
flying would bring them around? People tend to side with
authority, and authority tends to protect its own power.
Clave is the key. Clave has everything he wants in Citi-
zens Tree."

"Kendy, do you see us as savages?"

"Yes. Don't take that too seriously, Scientist. I would
probably see the Admiralty as savages too. I want to ed-
ucate you all."

"Then educate me, Kendy. I can't just take Booce and
Ryllin and go off into the sky. We—"

"You must go, Jeffer. The wealth of the L4 point is
almost irrelevant. It takes many people to hold a civili-
zation together. There are too few of you here to be more
than savages!"

Jeffer didn't react to the insult, barring an increase in
infrared radiation from his cheeks, neck, and ears. "We'd
need things Citizens Tree can't spare. Lawri's on my side,
but we can't both go. The tree needs a Scientist. We'd
have to take the CARM too. We—"

"Take it."

"You're not serious. Dalton-Quinn Tree died because

64 / Larry Niven

we couldn't move it. I won't see it happen to Citizens

Tree."

"Bring the CARM back when you're through with it."
Jeffer paused to think. (Kendy never did that. It was

another reason to distrust Kendy: he seemed to leap at

his answers, without forethought.) "We might lose the

CARM."

"You can build a steam rocket. Jeffer, I'm drifting out
of range."

"We've got one pipe, and we need that to be loggers.
Without the pipe, Citizens Tree couldn't build a steam
rocket. I wouldn't have believed that so much could
change in twenty sleeps. Kendy?" The signal dissolved
in noise.

Kendy returned to his records.

For twenty State years CARM #6 had been taking pic-
tures, not just through the CARM cameras but through
the fisheye lens on the pressure suit too.

Here: the squirrel cage that ran a muscle-powered lift,
and the lines leading up. Far too much footage of that.

Here: fire burned in a great bowl of soft clay. The silver
suit moved around the edges of the fire, poking it, or ad-
justing sheets of bark that had been set as vanes to channel
the wind into the burning wood. The look of the clay began
to change.

Here: less fire than smoke. What looked like enough
spaghetti to feed Sol system's entire State government
had been spread leeward of smoldering wood. The pres-
sure suit moved around and within the mass, turning it
and loosening the strands—vines—with the handle of a
harpoon so that the smoke would cure them. These were
the lines that now served Citizens Tree.

Ingenious. A poor way to treat State property; but they
were making use of local resources too.

The platform-around the cookpot was of boards tied
with line. It had always been flimsy, and that didn't matter

THE SMOKE RING / 65

much in Citizens Tree's low tide; but over the years the
lines had loosened. Jayan and Jinny complained about the
way the platform lurched while they tried to make dinner.
So Rather and Carlot had been sent to repair the platform.

Rather enjoyed the work. It called for muscle rather
than dexterity. He lifted one end of a new branchwood
plant into place. He called, "Hold this," and waited until
Carlot was set. Then he bounded down to the other end
and hoisted that.

Carlot giggled.

Rather began to tie the planks. One loop of line to hold
it, then he could work on a more elaborate mooring. He
asked, "What's funny?"

"Never mind," Carlot said. "Are you going to tie this
for me?"

"I thought I'd just leave you there. You make a good
mooring, and decorative too."

"Oh." She held the planks in place with one arm while
she reached out. Her right leg was twenty ce'meters
longer than the left, and she usually reached with that.
Her long toes grasped a coil of line and pulled it to her
hands. She tied a temporary binding.

In the twenty-two sleeps since their arrival, all of the
Serient family had become dextrous in Citizens Tree tide.

Rather wrapped a dozen loops of line around the plank
ends, then began tightening them. Heave on a loop, pull
the slack around; again. From the opening beyond the
treemouth the wind blew steadily, drying sweat as fast as
it formed.

Carlot called from her corner. "That's as tight as I can
get it."

Rather was finished at his end. He jogged down to Car-
lot's end (ripe copter plants buzzed up around his feet)
and began pulling in slack. She'd left a good deal, of
course. Carlot was agile, but not strong. He asked, "What
got you giggling?"

"Just the way you scurry."

66 / Larry Niven

Rather's hands paused for less than a second, then con-
tinued.

"You did ask," she said defensively. "You have to
go running back and forth because you can't reach as far
as—"

"I know that."

"Did you make this cauldron yourselves? I wouldn't
have thought you could do that here. It's big enough to
boil two people at once."

"Hey, Carlot, you don't really eat people in the Em-
pire, do you?"

She laughed at him. "No! There's a happyfeet tribe
that's supposed to do that. But how did you make it?"

"The grownups found a glob of gray mud west of the
tree. Maybe it was the middle of a pond that came apart.
They brought some back. We took all the rocks in Citizens
Tree and piled them in a bowl-shape, out on the branch
where we couldn't do any damage. I was just a kid, but
they let me help with the rocks. We plastered the mud
over the rocks. We got firebark from another tree and
piled it in the bowl-shape and fired it. It took a dozen days
to cool off, and then it was like that. We did it twice—"

"You're cute," she said solemnly.

Carlot was a year older than Rather. An exotic beauty
was growing in her. Half her hair had been burned off,
and she had cut the rest to match. Now it was like a skull-
cap of black wire. She was two and a half meters tall,
with long fingers and long, agile toes, and arms and legs
that could reach out forever.

Carlot affected Rather in ways he wasn't quite ready
to accept. He said, "Put it in the treemouth. When do I
get to be overwhelmingly handsome?"

"Cute is good. If I weren't your aunt—"

"Treefodder."

"Are you not my nephew?"

Rather studied his work. "I think we're done. —It's
an Empire thing, is it? You don't make babies even with

THE SMOKE RING / 67

relatives of relatives? Fine, but you've got a thousand
people in the Empire! At least that's what your parents
say. We had ten adults and twenty children when you
came. I won't get much choice about who I marry."

"Who, then?"

He shrugged. "Jill's a half year older than me. All the
other girls are younger. I'd have to wait." The subject
made him uncomfortable. He looked up past the treadmill
and along the trunk, to where a handful of citizens were
trying their wings. "I wish I was up there. You've been
flying all your life, haven't you?"

"I should be there, showing you people how to fly.
This damn fluff," Carlot said. Long sleeves were sewn
loosely to her tuftberry-scarlet tunic. She pulled one
away. The green fur along her arm had turned brown; the
patch had shrunk. "How's yours?" She touched his
cheek. The patch felt half numb and raspy; it ran from
his face down his neck and across part of his chest. "It's
drying up. Ten days, it'll be cleared up."

"Too treefeeding slow."

"We just have to stay in the shade for a while. Fluff

needs sunlight."
"Yeah."
From eastward, his first mother's voice called above

the wind-roar. "Rather!"

Rather bounded toward Minya across the floor of
braided, live-spine branches. Carlot gave him a good head
start, then bounded after him. Her asymmetric legs gave
her an odd run, a pleasure to watch: boundBOUND,
boundBOUND, low-flying flight. Soon she'd be faster
than Jill. She reached Minya a good six meters ahead of
Rather, turned and flashed a grin at him. She lost it im-
mediately.

"—Crawled too far toward the treemouth, and now he
can't—" Minya stopped and began again. "Rather! It's
the children. Harry and Qwen and Gorey went crawling

68 / Larry Niven

around in the old west rooms. Gorey went too far, and
Harry and Qwen can't reach him, and he can't get out."

"You can't get to him?"

"I didn't try. Rather, we don't know how long it was
before Harry came to get us."

"Oh." Harry would have tried to rescue Gorey him-
self, then spent more time working up the nerve to tell
his mother. And Gorey was only five! "I'll need some
kind of knife," he said.

"What?"

"I'm no narrower than you are, First Mother. I'm just
shorter. I may have to cut through some spine branches."

The wind didn't reach Mark's long hair and beard.
They held the sweat like two sponges. The slab of hard
branchwood strapped to his back massed as much as he
did. He scrambled up the slope of the treadmill, panting,
trying to stay higher than Karilly and seven children. With
a weight on his back, Mark was the equal of any two
adults.

The treadmill was six meters across and four wide, a
fragile wheel of branchwood sticks. Water running down
the trunk helped to spin it, but runners were still needed.

It was getting easier; the treadmill was spinning faster.
The cages must be almost passing each other. "Out!"
Mark panted. "Runners, out!" Seven laughing children
jumped from both sides of the treadmill, until only Mark
and Karilly were left.

Above was a sudden glare as the sun passed into view.
Karilly's dark skin shone with sweat; she breathed
deeply as she bounded uphill alongside him. He knew she
could understand him. "Karilly. When the up cage is at
the top it ... doesn't weight anything. It takes all of us
... to lift the down cage. Right now ... the cages are
next to each other. I can run by myself. In a little while
. . .the down cage will be falling. I'll have to get out. Use

THE SMOKE RING / 69

the brake. Slow it down." She watched him as if she were
listening. "So you jump out now."

Then he saw that she was afraid.

"Okay." He let the cage carry him around. Inverted,
he scrambled down the other side. "I'm slowing it. Can
you get out now?"

Karilly scrambled out.

Twenty klomters over his head, Lawri and her student
flyers must be wondering what had gone wrong. Mark
started the cage spinning again, letting his body do its
accustomed work while his mind drifted.

Long ago and far away, there had been civilization.

London Tree had had stationary bicycles to run the
elevators to the tree midpoint, and copsiks to run the bi-
cycles. Citizens Tree was primitive. They had London
Tree's CARM, of course: a thing of science dating from
the day men came from the stars. Otherwise they must
build everything.

Mark had shown the refugees how to build a lift. Mark
had wanted to make bicycles, but the Scientists had built
the treadmill instead. They kept the silver suit next to the
treadmill with its helmet open. Citizens at the CARM
could call for the lift through the radio in the suit.

Below him he could see the hollow space of the com-
mons, and two children bounding east. The tall, dark girl
was far ahead of the smaller boy, who moved in slower,
shorter steps, as if tide were heavier for him.

His son. His size proved it. Mark would not have
wished that on him; yet Rather would be the next Silver
Man. Mark wondered if the citizens would appreciate
their fortune. In the short lifetime of Citizens Tree there
had been no need for an invulnerable fighter, and the sil-
ver suit had become a mere communications device.

Had it not been for one stupid, stubborn act, Mark
would still be a citizen of London Tree. But he would
never have seen the stars, and he would never have seen
his son.

70 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 71

The treadmill was spinning by itself. Mark jumped out.
He set the branchwood slab down. He looked up along
the trunk, but he couldn't see the down cage yet. "We'll
let it run for a bit."

If Karilly could talk, would she still smile at him like
this? He took her hand. "Lawri wanted you with them.
You were afraid to go up, weren't you?" He had known
a London Tree citizen who was afraid of falling. It was
instinct gone wrong. If such a woman were born in a place
like Carther States, would she be afraid all the time? Until
the added terror of a fire pushed her over the edge.

"Lawri wanted me up there too. I wonder what it's
like. Flying."

But the silver suit caught his eye. No.

His business in London Tree had been war. Were there
copsik runners in the Clump? Karilly would know. "I
wish you could talk. The Scientists can't marry us till you
can say the words. The key word is yes. Will you try?
Yes."

"Mark!"

He jumped. "Debby?"

She called from below. "Yeah. Shall we relieve you?"

Mark swallowed his irritation. "The empty's coming
down. You want to brake when the sun's at about
eleven."

"We'll do it." Debby and Jeffer climbed up to join
them. "Hello, Karilly."

Jeffer said, "You didn't go flying? You should try it."

"Not me. I'm the Silver Man. I fly with the silver suit.
Come on, Karilly." Maybe somebody would need muscle
at the cookpot platform.

The tunnels ran through the tuft like wormholes in an
apple. Unused tunnels tended to close up; but passersby
ate from the foliage as they passed, so the tunnels in nor-
mal use stayed open. One such tunnel ran past Rather's
home.

At its west end Rather could have circled the hut with
his legs. This was the oldest section. As the spine
branches migrated west along the branch, eventually to
be swallowed by the treemouth, enclosures tended to
shrink. The newest sections were the largest.

This disappearing section had been small when new.
It had housed only Gavving and Minya and the baby
Rather. Other children had come, and Gavving wove new
rooms eastward, faster than the treemouth could swallow
them. By now there were seven children, and a new wife
for Gavving, and a far bigger common room; for the Cit-
izens Tree populace was growing too. The original rooms
had disappeared into the treemouth. These that he was
passing now, wicker cages alongside the tunnel, were still
less than Rather's height. The children tended to claim
these for their own.

Rather found a deformed door. As he crawled inside
he heard Minya saying, "Keep going, Carlot. Go to the
common room and get my old matchet off the wall and
bring it back. Hurry."

Harry, eight years old and Rather's height, was crying
into Mishael's chest. Rather nodded to Mishael. "Second
Mother. Which way did he go? Straight west?"

Mishael, seven years older than Carlot, had Carlot's
dark, exotic beauty in fully developed form, and legs that
caused even Rather to stare: long and slender and per-
fectly matched. She'd cut her trousers into loose shorts,
odd-looking in Citizens Tree. The low roof cost her some
dignity. She had to crouch. She looked uncomfortable and
annoyed. "Straight on in. And he's stopped talking. I
think he's mad at us."

Rather said, "You know this is no big deal, don't you?
It happens all the time."

"I don't know. Rather, I still get the shivers in your
crawling huts! Your parents just don't understand that.
And poor Gorey, he is frightened."

"Sure. Carlot's coming with Mother's matchet. Send




72 / Larry Niven

her after me. I need it to cut my way through." It didn't
feel odd to be speaking thus peremptorily to his second
mother. Mishael wasn't that much older than Rather; she
was new to all this, and it showed.

Rather crawled west.

Memories tried to surface around him. His parents'
bedroom: he'd lived in a basket, in a corner too small for
a baby now. The private dining area, and ghosts of won-
derful smells: were they in his nose, or in his mind? The
common room, and too many strangers: he'd cried and
had to be taken away. The spaces were distorted and tiny,
a green-black womb. The spine branches were still grow-
ing. He tore them away with his fists; tore through an old
partition.

He didn't like this. His past was too small to hold him.
"Gorey!"

From west by north, Gorey yelled piercingly. He
sounded more angry than frightened. How had he gotten
thereat What had been a kitchen wall had crumpled and
grown half a meter thick! He must have found some way
around—

"Rather?"

Carlot, behind him. He reached far back and took what
was pushed into his hand. "Thanks." He pulled it to the
level of his face, turned it with some difficulty and pushed
the blade further.

"Can you get to him?"

"One way or another."

For years the matchet had been no more than a part
of the wall. He'd never really looked at it. The handle
was long and a bit too wide for his short fingers. The blade
was sixty ce'meters of black metal, tinged red by time.
Time and use had serrated the edge. It had once belonged
to a Navy man of London Tree.

In this restricted space he must use it as a saw. He
didn't try to cut the wall. He cut branchlets west of him.

THE SMOKE RING / 73

He turned starboard, still sawing through miscellaneous
branchlets. "Gorey?"

Cautiously, doubtfully: "Rath?"

"Here. Give me your hand. Can you reach me?"

"I can't move!"

Rather saw a thrashing foot. He pulled on it experi-
mentally. Gorey was pinned between a spine branch and
a smooth dark wall: the main branch itself. He must have
tried to crawl between them. Rather wriggled forward.
He sawed the spine branch half through, reached farther
and broke it with his hands. Gorey wriggled out and
wrapped himself around his brother and clung. Presently
he asked, "Are they mad?"

"Sure they're mad. How did you get here? Hide and

seek?"

"Yeah. Harry said he was gonna catch me and feed
me to the triunes, so I kept going. Then I was afraid the
treemouth would get me and I got really scared."

"Harry wouldn't get that close to a triune family. You
know that."

"Yeah, but I was mad."

"You'd starve to death before you reached the tree-
mouth. Here, grab my foot and follow me."

The boy's fingers were long enough to overlap Rather's
ankle. He was already taller than Rather. They crawled
out, with easier going at every meter.

In the common room Rather's mothers greeted him as
a hero, while Gorey was scolded and petted. Rather took
it with what grace he could. He wondered if Carlot was
laughing at him; but in fact she seemed to think he had
done something actively dangerous.

It made him uncomfortable. He was vastly relieved
when Gavving poked his head through the door. "Tread-
mill runners!" he called. "Rather?" And Rather was res-
cued.

Harry and Carlot came with them. As they neared the

74 / Larry Niven

treemouth Gavving said, "Harry, Carlot, why don't you
see if they need help with the laundry pot?"

They split off. Harry grumbling.

Rather followed his father up through the tunnels to-
ward the treadmill. His nerves were prickling. Something
odd was going on. "Father? Do they really need treadmill
runners?"

"No," Gavving said without looking down.

The treadmill was at rest. Debby and Jeffer lay in the
foliage nearby, eating and talking. They sat up when
Gavving appeared. "Got him," Gavving said.

This must have something to do with the Serjent fam-
ily; and the conference before the last sleep, from which
children were barred; and the arguments that divided half
the families in the tree. Do my mothers know about this?
Would they approve? Rather asked instead, "Should we
have brought Carlot?"

"No need. Rather, we have to find out something."
Gavving pointed at a short, faceless fat man made of sil-
very metal. "Try that on."

"The silver suit?"

"Yeah. See if you can get into it."

Rather looked it over. This thing had a fearsome, quasi-
scientific reputation. It was a flying fighting machine,
stronger than crossbow bolts, stronger than the airless-
ness beyond all that was known. Rather had never before
seen it with its head closed.

Jeffer instructed him. "Lift this latch. Take the head
and turn it. Pull up. Turn it the other way."

The head came up on a hinge.

"This latch too. Now pull this down . . . now pull it
apart . . . good."

The suit was open down the front, and emptv.

"Can you get in?"

"Where's Mark?"

"Debby?"

THE SMOKE RING / 75

"No problem. We relieved him and he took Karilly to
the kitchen."

"Father . . . wait. Listen. I'm the only boy in the tree
with two mothers and two fathers." Rather plunged on
despite the sudden hurt in Gavving's face. "We've never
talked about this, but I always knew . . . sooner or later
I'd ... does Mark know what you're doing with the silver
suit?"

"No."

"What's it all about?" Four big adults could make him
do whatever they wanted; and it didn't matter. They
needed his cooperation, and he didn't know enough to
give it.

Jeffer the Scientist said, "It's about seeing what's out-
side Citizens Tree. It's learning about the Smoke Ring,
what we can use, what we need to be afraid of. Or else
it's about staying savages until someone comes out of the
sky to teach us the hard way."

"We're going to the Clump," Gavving said. "We'll be
safer if we can take the Silver Man."

"Uh-huh. Mark doesn't want to go?"

"Right."

They watched as Rather tried to get into the suit. He
had to get his legs in first, then duck under the neck ring.
He closed the sliding catches, the headpiece, the latches.
The suit was loose around his belly, snug everywhere
else. "It fits."

Jeffer closed the helmet on him. He rotated it left until
it dropped two mi'meters, then right.

Rather was locked in a box his own size and shape.
The suit smelled faintly of former occupants, of exertion
and fear. He moved his arms, then his legs, against faint
resistance. He turned and reached and plucked a handful
of foliage . . . good. He could move. He could move like
a normal man.

The air was getting stale ... but Jeffer was already

76 / Larry Niven

turning the helmet, lifting it. The adults were smiling at
each other. Gavving said, "Okay. Get out of it."

Getting out of the silver suit was as difficult as getting
in. Rather said, "Now tell me."

"Some of us are going to visit the Clump. Do you want
to come with us?"

"Who's going? How long will it take?"

"Me," said Jeffer. "Gavving. Booce and Ryllin. An-
thon and Debby. The Clump is all jungle giants. We need
people that size."

"How does the Chairman—"

"He'll try to stop us."

"Father, I don't really like the thought of not ever com-
ing home."

Gavving shook his head. "They'll want the CARM
back. They'll want us back too. Citizens Tree isn't so
crowded that they can afford to lose anyone who
breathes. They'll want to know what we learned. They'll
want what we bring back. Half the citizens are on our side
anyway; they just don't want to buck the Chairman."

"You're taking the carmT"

"We are." Gavving clapped him on the shoulder.
"Think about it. We've got two sleeps to get ready. What-
ever you decide, don't mention this to anyone, particu-
larly your mothers."

"Father, you'd better tell it all." Rather didn't con-
sider whether he had the right to ask. Clave wouldn't like
this; Minya wouldn't like it; and if he agreed to this—it
was only just coming to him—if Rather agreed, then he
was the Silver Man.

Jeffer said, "It isn't just the wealth of the Clump Ad-
miralty. It's—"

"Tell me what you're going to do."

They told him.




Chapter Six

The Appearance of
Mutiny

from Disciplined log, year 1893 State = 370 SM:

MEDICAL READOUTS SHOWED THAT THE INHABIT-
ANTS OF CARM #6 LIED TO ME. THEY REACTED
STRONGLY TO ACCUSATION OF MUTINY. I LOST MY
CHANCE TO QUESTION THEM IN DETAIL. THEY MAY
HAVE MUTINIED AGAINST LEGITIMATE HOLDERS OF THE
CARM. HEREDITY WILL TELL.

IT'S A BAD HABIT. I WILL BREAK THEM OF IT.

—SHARLS DAVIS KENDY, CHECKER

CLAVE PULLED HIMSELF OUT OF THE ELEVATOR FIRST.

Wings were tethered next to the cage, and he pulled one
free and tied it in place along his left shin. "This was a
good idea, Gavving. Wings aren't much use in the tuft."
"Oh, we'll keep some there too. Hunters used to carry
jet pods. Wings are better. But there's no point porting
77

78 / Larry Niven

them up and down every time someone wants to fly. What
are you doing?"

"Fixing this." He chopped with his matchet at his
other wing. When ten ce'meters were gone, he tied the
wing to his right shin. He felt distinctly lopsided.

•letter and Gavving were also winged now. The three
flapped out toward the CARM, spurning the convenient
handholds the bark afforded. Clave's flight wavered, then
steadied. He'd been right. This was easier on the warped
muscles in his thigh.

Jeffer was first through the airlock. "Prikazyvat
Voice."

The CARM's deep voice said, "Ready, Jeffer the Sci-
entist—"

A woman's voice broke in. "Jeffer, it's Lawri. I think
I want to join you."

"Come on up. Bring something to eat. We'll be running
the main motor for maybe two days."

"Will do. Lawri out."

"What was that about?" Clave asked.

"Lawri doesn't trust me with the CARM." Jeffer
laughed. "Now we refuel the beast."

Clave sighed. "Pump?"

"Right. You pump while 1 do a checklist. Otherwise
we'll lose the pondlet when we go under thrust."

Some pumping had been done, but megatons of water
still nestled against the trunk. Clave ran the hose from
the CARM to the pondlet. The pump was a wheel and a
tube and piston, all carved from hard branchwood. Clave
braced his back and arms against the bark and kicked the
wheel around with his feet on the spokes. "Help would
be appreciated," he grunted.

Gavving joined him.

The pump leaked. The pond didn't dwindle fast, but it
dwindled. They broke to drink thirstily, then resumed
pumping. The sun had dropped from zenith to nadir—
which at the midyear was not behind Voy, but north by

THE SMOKE RING / 79

three full degrees—when Jeffer poked his head through
the airlock. "Stop! The tank's full!"

Clave tossed his head to shake some of the sweat out
of his hair.

"Come inside." Jeffer ushered them forward to the
front row of seats. "Strap down."

He tapped, and vertical blue dashes appeared in the
panel below the window. Four clusters of four each at the
corners of a square, and a larger dash in the center. He
tapped the central dash.

The sound within the cabin was like the roaring of wind
at the treemouth. Clave felt a featherweight of tide and
knew the tree was in motion.

Jeffer told them, "We're already placed right, with the
motor aimed west. We thrust eastward. That puts Citizens
Tree in a wider orbit, so we slow down and drift west,
away from the Clump."

Clave wondered if he wanted to watch from outside.
"Is it dangerous out there?"

"Could be. You don't want to fall into the flame. Any-
way, the view's better in here." Jeffer's fingers danced,
and the CARM window sprouted five smaller windows.
"The ventral view got ruined when we fell back into the
Smoke Ring—"

"Jeffer, you don't lecture this much unless you're ner-
vous. What's wrong? We've moved the tree before."

Gavving laughed. It appeared that he had a touch of
nerves too. "Remember how twitchy we were then? Mer-
ril was sure we'd break the tree apart and kill ourselves."

Clave shrugged. He went aft and braced himself in the
airlock.

What remained of the pondlet stretched itself out from
the trunk, then broke into one big drop and a line of little
ones. The mother pond they'd robbed twenty-two sleeps
ago drifted west. The sun passed Voy and began to climb.
A fat triple-finned bird, dead west by a klomter or three,
suddenly went into an epileptic seizure, split into three

80 / Larry Niven

slender birds, and scattered. Clave was late in under-
standing what he'd seen: a triune family suddenly washed
by the invisible heat of the CARM's exhaust.

Clave went in and strapped down again.

He had been anticipating Lawn's arrival for some time,
but the CARM's roar covered her entry. He turned to see
her halfway up the aisle ... and Debby behind her. And
Ryllin. And Booce and Carlot. Clave fumbled to release
the buckle that bound him to the chair.

It took too long. He was between Jeffer and Gavving,
with Lawri behind him. He sighed. "What's it all about?"

Jeffer's fingers danced. The board went blank. He said,
"We can fight or we can talk. Or we can talk and then
fight, but there's only one»of you. Clave. Cripple me and
Lawri flies the CARM."

Call for help? If he could get past Jeffer to use Voice,
the elevator would still take a day to get up ... forget it.
Voice connected to the silver suit, which Rather was now
pulling headfirst through the airlock.

It would have felt good to hit somebody. Clave said,
"I'll be good. Now what's it all about?"

"We're going to visit the Admiralty," Jeffer said.

Rather and Booce were moving things inside: two
smoked turkeys, a huge amount of foliage, water pods.

"All of us?"

"Not you. Clave. Lawn's staying too. Citizens Tree
needs a Chairman and a Scientist."

"How did you decide—"

There was a bit of an edge in Lawri's voice. "We knew
one of us would have to stay. Now I've missed my time
of blood. I'm hosting a guest. I wondered why the copsik
was being so affectionate."

"You should all be staying. You're taking the
CARM?"

"The CARM, the silver suit, and the pipe from Log-
bearer."

They all looked very serious. The background roar

THE SMOKE RING / 81

prompted Clave to ask, "Are you planning to set the tree
moving first? Or was that a lie too?"

"We'll give you a day's thrust," Jeffer said. "No
more. I won't be here to decelerate you, and I want to
be able to find you again."

"With what? Would London Tree have let you keep
the CARM? The Admiralty won't either!"

Patiently Gavving said, "We've talked that over. We
won't take the CARM into the Clump. They'll never know
it exists. Jeffer will hide the CARM somewhere. The rest
of us will go in as loggers, with Booce and Ryllin to show
us how."

Clave's mind was racing. "Now listen to me. Will you
listen?"

"Yes, Chairman."

"First, are you all volunteers? Rather, how did they
suck you into this?"

"They can't go without the silver suit," the boy said.

"Oh, they'd go. Wouldn't you, Jeffer?"

"Yes."

"I'm going anyway," Rather said.

He didn't look like he'd change his mind. Rather didn't
even bother to argue, though the boy was good at that.
Clave knew how he would enlist a fourteen-year-old boy.
Put him in the silver suit, call him the Silver Man, offer
him status and adventure . . . "Carlot?"

"I'm going home," the girl said defiantly.

"Debby?" But aglance told Clave he'd lost that battle.
Debby was fiercely happy. He hadn't seen her like this
since the War of London Tree. "What about Anthon?"

Debby said, "I never told him. Jeffer, I did get him
talking. He likes Citizens Tree just fine and he doesn't
want any changes. Have you noticed how fat he's get-
ting?"

"Too bad," Jeffer said.

Clave said, "Stet. I accept that you're going to do this.
I've heard your speeches, and you've heard mine, and the




82 / Larry Niven

treemouth can have them both. But don't you see that
this will tear Citizens Tree apart? It's mutiny. Hold it! I
mean it's mutiny the way you've planned it. If we don't
fix that. Citizens Tree will never recover. It's got to look
better than it does."

The mutineers looked at each other.

"Here's how it's got to be," said Clave. "First, I'm
going. Gawing isn't. You said it and you're right. The
tree needs a Chairman and it's Gawing."

Gawing said, "That's silly. You're—"

"I'm the treefeeding Chairman, and if 1 go the expe-
dition is official. Besides that, I've got to see to it that
you return the CARM and the silver suit. The citizens
would be crazy to settle for less. I hereby appoint you
my Chairman Pro Tern until I return."

Coolly Gawing asked, "Anything else?"

"Yes. You don't get both Booce and Ryllin. One of
them stays. There has to be some reason for the Serjents
to bring us home."

"We can't do that," Ryllin said. "Booce takes care of
Logbearer. I take care of business. I do all the buying
and selling. Anyone who sees one of us in the Clump will
expect to see us both."

Clave was massaging the lump on his thigh. Sometimes
that helped him think. Think! "The citizens you deal with,
the ... merchants? If they deal with Booce, what will
happen?"

Ryllin said, "My husband is very good with machinery,
not so good at trading. He did much better after he had
the good sense to marry me. But Logbearer understands
him, he—"

"Without you they'll get a better trade?"

"Damn right they will," Booce said bitterly. Then:

"Yes, they will."

"They'll like that? They won't be too curious about
where their luck comes from?"

THE SMOKE RING / 83

It was Ryllin who nodded. "It's all right, love. Think
of a story. They'll want to believe it."

"But we're missing three daughters too!"

"The house. They must have finished building our
house by now. The girls and I are with Logbearer or we're
at the house, wherever you're not. Maybe I'm somewhere
in the Market buying furniture. That was the whole point
of this last trip, we were going to—we were—" She
turned away suddenly.

Emotional displays weren't needed here! Clave said,
"We're not hiding anything but the silver suit and the
CARM. Otherwise we can tell any story we want. What's
next? Gawing, Lawri, Ryllin, you back each other up
when you go back to the tuft. Whoever's asking, the
Chairman had to be talked into this, but I did agree, and
I put the fine details in."

Rather called from aft. "Jeffer, the pipe's moored to
the hull. We've got everything else, but it all has to be
moored."

"Go ahead. I'll check you later. Gawing, are you will-
ing?"

"Treefbdder. Well, it'll probably keep Minyafrom kill-
ing me ... Clave, will this work? Is it enough?"

"Only if we come back. We come back with the CARM
and something else too. It almost doesn't matter what."

"Stet. I'm the Chairman Pro Tern."

Jeffer killed the main motor. "Somebody go out and
get our lines untied."

Rather went. Debby joined Booce aft. They began
mooring what remained of the cargo: two big hooks, spare
clothing, sacks of undyed cloth, harpoons, crossbows.

Lawri said, "Jeffer, let me show you something." She
eased up next to him and tapped at the controls, whis-
pering. Her shoulder blocked Clave's view. Clave's mind
still raced, seeking flaws ... he was looking for holes in
a harebrain net! There was no way to make mutiny smell
sweet.

84 / Larry Niven

"Are we bringing the spitgun? No, of course not." The
weapon Mark had been carrying when he was captured
was now in custody of the Chairman. "Gavving, it's in
the older part of my hut, what used to be the common
room. If you don't have the spitgun, you're not the Chair-
man. Get it before anyone notices."

Rather scrambled back through the airlock. Gavving,
Ryllin, and Lawri left. Jeffer let them get well clear before
he pulled away on the little jets.

The tree receded. Three tiny citizens fluttered toward
the elevator dock, A cage had nearly reached the dock.
One of the occupants was shrieking and waving its fists.

"Somebody must have found Mark," Debby said.
"Relax, Clave, we only tied him up."

"Yeah. But if I'd known a rescue party was coming
. . . skip it. You'd have closed the airlock in their faces.
1 hope you treefeeders can find something worthwhile in
the Clump. It's my reputation on the line now."

Section Two

THE
LOGGERS

Chapter Seven

The Honey Hornets

from the Citizens Tree cassettes:

YEAR 384, DAY 1590. JEFFER, SCIENTIST. WE HAVE

DEPARTED CITIZENS TREE TO EXPLORE THE FOURTH LA-
GRANGE POINT, WITH ATTENTION TO RESOURCES AND
POPULATION. THE MISSION AS OUTLINED IS REVISED AS
FOLLOWS: CHAIRMAN CLAVE NOW LEADS. THIS EX-
PEDITION HAS BECOME AN APPROVED ACTIVITY OF CIT-
IZENS TREE. I NOW TURN THE LOG OVER TO CHAIRMAN
CLAVE.

CLAVE, CHAIRMAN. CREW CONSISTS OF JEFFER AS
SCIENTIST AND CAPTAIN, CITIZENS DEBBY AND
RATHER, BOOCE AND CARLOT SERJENT AS GUIDES,
AND MYSELF. PRIORITY AT ALL TIMES WILL GO TO PRO-
TECTING THE CARM AND OTHER VITAL PROPERTY OF CIT-
IZENS TREE. NO KNOWLEDGE IS WORTH GAINING
UNLESS IT CAN BE REPORTED TO CITIZENS TREE.
I                             87




88 / Larry Niven

CARLOT WAS WATCHING OVER THEIR SHOULDERS.

"You use—"

"Prikazyvat End log," said Jeffer.

"—the same dates we do?"

"Why not?"

"Well, how do you know?" Carlot demanded. "Years,
you just watch for the sun to go behind Voy, but what
about days? We sleep a couple of days out of five, right?
But maybe you lose count—"

"Who cares?" Clave said. "Who knows how many
days there are in a year? It depends on where you are."

Jeffer summoned up numbers on the panel. "The
CARM logs a standard day, about four and a half per
sleep. We used to keep marks on sticks in the Scientist's
hut. How do you keep time?"

Carlot said, "The Admiralty posts the time."

Booce laughed. "They must get it the same way! The
Library looks a lot like this panel, Jeffer. Like somebody
ripped out this part of the CARM."

"Keys like this too?"

"I wasn't close enough to see. They don't let ordinary
crew near it. Let's see ... in the crossyear ceremony
Radyo Mattson did the talking, but there was a Navy
officer standing in front of the Library, and his hands
moved ..."

And Kendy watched them all.

The CARM autopilot heard everything. Every ten
hours and a little, it squirted its records at Discipline.
Kendy sorted the conversations for what he could use.

Two CARM autopilots, separated for five hundred and
thirty-two years and eleven months, were both keeping
Smoke Ring time, with Discipline's arrival set at zero.
Interesting. The mutineers must have adjusted them after
it was certain that they would never return. They had
severed relations with the past, with Kendy, with Earth,
with the State itself.

Yet they used mutiny as an obscenity. Puzzling.

THE SMOKE RING / 89

The CARM flew east, airspeed seventy-one kph, par-
tially fueled, carrying water that would become fuel. Solar
collector efficiency was running at fifty-two percent, the
collectors partially shadowed by the old pipe moored to

the hull.

It was a liquid oxygen pipe ripped from a CARM. Many
CARMs must have been dismantled when they stopped
working. The Admiralty "Library" was certainly the con-
trol panel from a ruined CARM; but was it still functional?

The cabin interior was offensively dirty. Kendy de-
tected traces of old meals eaten aboard; feathers and bird
shit from the turkey roundup ten years back; the black
clay that had returned the same trip; and mud repeatedly
expelled from the water tank. Dirt was not dangerous,
only aesthetically distressing. Kendy foresaw no prob-
lems other than those of microsociology.

He was on course.

Humankind was scattered. No telling how far they had
spread through the Smoke Ring. They had settled cotton-
candy jungles and the tufts of integral trees; he knew of
four tiny civilizations outside the L4 point. But the Ad-
miralty seemed to be the densest gathering, the most nu-
merous, the best organized: the political entity most
suited to become the heart of an expanding empire.

It would not resemble the State at first. Conditions
were fantastically different. Never mind. Give them com-
munications, gather them into one political group. Then

shape it.

He must know more. Hearsay from a family of wan-
dering loggers wasn't good enough. The Admiralty "Li-
brary," that would tell him how to proceed next. . . but
he already knew that he must eventually contact the of-
ficers themselves.

Somehow the CARM must be moved into the Clump.
Jeffer had seemed to have matters well in hand. The
effects of mutiny on Citizens Tree did not concern Kendy
... but Clave had ended a mutiny by joining it! Now he




90 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 91

must persuade Jeffer and Clave both. But Kendy couldn't
talk to Clave. Exposing Jeffer's secret would lose Jeffer's
trust.

It was precisely the kind of problem a Checker enjoyed
most.

For now Kendy watched six savages in a recording
made over the past ten hours. They had much to teach
him.

Booce speaking: "We own—owned our own ship. I
suppose that made us richer than most. I inherited Log-
bearer from my father, and I made my first trips with him.
Ryllin was another logger's daughter, and she was used
to the life. We had four daughters and a few lost ones out
of maybe twenty pregnancies, all while hauling logs. I've
become a good maternity doctor ..." The cassette
ended.

Men had changed in the Smoke Ring.

Pregnancy was easy in low gravity. Women became
pregnant many times during their lifetimes.

Infant mortality ("lost ones") was high, perhaps
around sixty percent; the natives seemed to take it for
granted. Discipline had carried no diseases. Yet the
growth of bones and organs was altered by altered gravity.
Some children could not digest food. Some grew
strangely, until their kidneys or livers or hearts or intes-
tines would no longer work because of their shape.

The environment was user-friendly for those who sur-
vived childhood. Kendy's citizens came in odd shapes.
Kendy caught a reference to Merril Quinn and learned
that she had died six years ago, in early middle age. Merril
had had no legs. She had fought against London Tree, and
not as a cripple.

Distorted children had wandered through the CARM
to be photographed. Ryllin Serjent had an awesomely long
neck, quite lovely and graceful and fragile looking. Car-
lot's legs . . . Kendy wished he could see her walk or run.

They matured more slowly. Carlot claimed fourteen

and a half years; she would be twenty by Earth's reck-
oning. But she looked no more than fifteen.

Men had not evolved for the Smoke Ring. Infant mor-
tality must have been ghastly among the original crew.
Five hundred years of natural selection was taking care
of that. As with the cats a few generations back: the near
future should see an impressive population explosion.

Kendy would guide the civilization that resulted. He
had been right to move now.

The CARM was coming back into range. Kendy's tel-
scope array picked it up falling east and out, slowing.

In present time, Booce and Carlot and Rather were on
watch while the others slept. The CARM moved through
a patch of thin fog. Fog didn't block the CARM's senses.
Kendy noticed the anomaly some time before the crew
did.

He saw birds of unfamiliar type. They had lungs (the
CARM's sonar could see the triple cavity), but they had
retained part of what must once have been an exoskele-
ton: an oval of hard sky-blue shell covered one side. Four-
teen of these birds, each about the mass of a boar pig,
were strung in a line across the sky. They were folded
into themselves, fins and wings and heads folded against
that oval of shell. Sky-blue blobs, cool in infrared, com-
atose or dead.

Booce had noticed now. He shook Jeffer awake. "A
whole flock of dead birds. What killed them?"

"Nothing that can touch us with the airlock closed."
Jeffer's fingers danced. "Outside air's okay, nothing poi-
sonous. Well, treefodder!"

"What?"

"The temperature. It's cold out there."

Kendy had already found the source of the cold.

The present-time transmission showed Jeffer easing
the CARM alongside one of the big birds. The other crew
were in and around the airlock. Debby sent a tethered




92 / Larry Niven

crossbow bolt into the bird. It twitched. She loosed an-
other . . .

. . . while Kendy set a blinking light around the image
of the pond.

Only Jeffer was there to see it. He said softly, "Stet."

They had pulled the bird aboard. Clave said, "Well,
it's dead now."

"I've got something," Jeffer said. "Clave, there's a
pond in that dense cloud. Do you see anything odd about
it?"

"No life around it. That cloud's awfully thick for being
so small. What does it mean?"

"I don't know."

Ice. The pond was a core of foamy ice within a shell
of meltwater. Ice was rare within the Smoke Ring. The
pond was huge now, several hundred thousand tons, but
Kendy guessed that it had been bigger yet. A tremendous
pond must have been flung out of the Smoke Ring by a
gravity-assist from Gold. In the near-vacuum of the gas
torus it would have boiled and frozen at the same time,
and later fallen back, reduced by evaporation, reduced
further by reentry heat. Now it cooled the sky around it
as it melted. Kendy could hear the pings as bubbles of
near-vacuum crumpled within the ice core.

"I don't like it here," Booce said. "It's too strange."

"Your wish is granted. Strap the bird down and take
your seats." Jeffer waited while they did that, then fired
the aft attitude jets. The CARM surged away.

Cariot pointed into the aft view. "Look!"

The shieldbirds tumbled in the CARM's hot wake. One
by one they fluttered, then spread a rainbow of wings and
tails and fluffy feathers. They basked in the heat, catching
as much of it as they could. Now their shells were no
bigger in proportion than a warrior's shield. As Discipline
moved out of range, the birds were lining up and flying
west, putting distance between themselves and the melt-
ing glacier.

THE SMOKE RING / 93

"There's no point picking out a tree till you've got
honey," Booce said. "You can find a tree a hundred
klomters from the Clump and still go half a thousand
klomters to find your sting jungle."

Their catch was moored by cargo hooks, divested of
skin and guts and some of the scarlet meat. Booce was
holding raw bird flesh sliced thin and rolled around a stalk
of lemon fern. He used it to point into the dorsal view.
"And that is a sting jungle. The green dot, straight out."

"Stet." Jeffer tapped attitude jets to life. The CARM
turned. Cariot squeaked and grabbed Rather, startling him
awake. Booce dropped his meal to snatch at a seat back.

Jeffer hid a grin. These sophisticated Admiralty folk
found the CARM as unsettling as Jeffer's own citizens

did.

He aimed the CARM east of Booce's green dot. East
takes you out. . . "Half a day and we'll have honey. What
else do we need?"

"Some way to collect it," Booce answered.

"We'll put Rather in the silver suit. No treefeeding
insect will sting him through that!"

"Right. Better than armor."

"Tell us about the Admiralty," Clave said.

Booce closed his eyes to think. Then: "You're lonely
out here. There's too much space. Everything is dense in
the Clump. Think of a seed pod, and think of the Ad-
miralty as the shell. There are more people in the Market
alone, any time of day or night, than you've ever seen.

"We pull the logs back to the Clump over the course
of a year or two, and we arrange an auction in the Market.
Twice we've been attacked by happyfeet bandits. Once
we got back just as another log was being docked, and
we got half what we expected for the wood. But over the
years we put enough money together to buy my retailer's
license. This was going to be our last trip. We were going
to settle in the Clump, and I'd work the wood myself and

94 / Larry Niven

sell finished planks and burl, while Ryllin set about finding
good husbands for our daughters. That was the point:

they're reaching that age ..."

Clave asked, "Can we really make the Admiralty be-
lieve we're loggers?"

"We'll be loggers," Booce said. "Rebuilding Log-
bearer's no problem. We should have more weapons in
case happyfeet come by, and it all has to look like Ad-
miralty gear . . . and we still won't look like a typical
logging family. But we don't have to, because I've got
my retailer's license."
"What does that mean?"

"It means we don't have to sell the log straight off.
The Navy ships will escort us in and give us a berth. I
can set up shop in the Market and sell wood, and hire
anyone I like; which means that the rest of you can be
workers hired off a happyfeet jungle, or bought as cop-
siks. Some of the happyfeet keep copsiks. The Admiralty
doesn't, so you'd be free if I bought you."
"Free, but not citizens."
"Right."

"Why can't you have hired us off a tree?"
Booce thought about it, and smiled. "You have a gift,
Clave. Tell as much of the truth as possible. Debby,
you're from Carther States, directly. You were stranded
in the sky, you made your way to a tree, and now you
want to live in a jungle again. Okay, Debby?"

Debby's lips were moving as she silently repeated the

details. "Stet."

"We'll have to say Citizens Tree is close to the Clump.
Otherwise we got home too fast, and we'd have to explain

about the CARM."

Clave nodded. "So then we sell the log. How?"
"Set up in the Market and announce an auction. Buy

your earthlife seeds with the money and go home. The

Admiralty'11 take half in taxes—"
Clave exclaimed, "Half?"

THE SMOKE RING / 95

Jeffer said, "Taxes?"

"Taxes," Booce said, "is the money the Admiralty
takes to run itself. Everybody pays, but the rich pay more.
A good log is wealth. For the price of the CARM you
could be very rich indeed."

"The CARM is what makes us what we are. We won't
risk that," Clave said.

"Then don't take it into the Clump. The Navy won't
want something that powerful floating around. They'll pay
well, but they'll buy it whether or not you're selling."

Jeffer tapped the forward jets awake. They were pull-
ing near the sting jungle.

Certain mooring loops fit the silver suit too perfectly,
as if it were their specific purpose. Four sets. For four
suits?

Jeffer pulled it loose. "The silver suit is yours, Rather.
I'm going to teach you everything about it."

Rather had seen the silver suit as a mark of rank. He
hadn't thought of it as an obligation. "Did Mark show
you how to work it?"

"I've watched him. Lift this latch. Take the head and
turn it till it stops. Pull up. Turn it the other way. Lift.
Now this latch. Now pull this down . . . pull it apart . . .
good."

The suit looked like the flayed skin of a dwarf.

Legs first, then arms. Duck under the neck ring. Rather
closed the sliding catches, the latches. "Do I have to close
the head?"

"Cover yourself. You don't want to be stung," Booce
said. "Those little mutineers can sting a moby to death."

Rather closed the headpiece. He said, "The air's get-
ting stale."

They couldn't hear him. He couldn't really suffocate
this fast, could he?

Jeffer lifted the headpiece. "Listen first. Put your hand
here." He guided Rather's fingers to a row of square but-

96 / Larry Niven

tons on the outside of the neck ring. He pushed one (col-
ored lights lit below Rather's chin), and another (air jetted
inward from all around the neck ring). He used Rather's
fingertip to roll a small wheel back and forth (the air jets
grew weaker, then stronger). "Close the helmet."

Rather did as Jeffer had shown him. Air from the neck
ring hissed around his head.

Clave was saying something inaudible. Jeffer guided
Rather's fingertip to another tiny wheel, and suddenly
Clave's voice was a roar. "—use up the air? Does that
thing have to be closed? We're not going back out of the
Smoke Ring again, are we?"

"Let's hope not. Rather, you're leaking. Close that
flap at your chest. The way Booce talks about honey hor-
nets, you don't want anything open."

Rather felt it out, then used finger pressure to close a
snap he'd missed.

Now he was being shown little wheels on his chest.
He moved the left one experimentally. His left foot kicked
upward and he was wheeling in the air, banging his head
and elbow, snatching for a mooring loop while his other
hand rolled the wheel back to zero. He banged both knees
before he could stop his spin.

Clave and Debbie were helpless with laughter. Jeffer
had jumped clear. "Leave those alone while you're in-
side! You fly with those. Now I'm going to walk you out
the airlock. Play around with the jets. If you get in trouble
we'll come after you."

Rather braced himself in the airlock, feeling impris-
oned. The sting jungle was a fat, fluffy ring half a klomter
across, dark green around the outside, slowly rotating.
The inner rim flamed in orange and scarlet. Rather, look-
ing out through the airlock, saw motion there like jittery
fog.

Clave and Booce eased him into the sky.

They couldn't have any idea what the boy was going

THE SMOKE RING / 97

through, Kendy thought. How would they? None could
fly the ancient pressure suit. Rather would have to be an
agoraphile and an acrophile both.

Kendy had explained the pressure suit with diagrams
and pointers; but had he shown Jeffer how to replenish
the suit's oxygen and fuel? Replay that memory ... no.
Do that soon, if it wasn't already too late. What Kendy
was watching was already two hours past.

But the CARM was in range again, and in present time
the boy was aboard, and out of the suit, and still alive.
Kendy kept the tape running:

Debby and Clave hovered a safe distance away. The
boy floundered. He was all over the sky, spinning, faster
. . . slower, tilting himself back and sideways to slow the
spin . . . learning to move arms and legs to change his
attitude. He found the throttle dials and turned both jets
to minimum. He circled the CARM, then arced off toward
the green doughnut that Booce had made his target.

Jeffer spoke through the suit radio. "Not yet. Rather.
Come back. You don't have anything to carry the, the,
Booce?"

"Honey."

"The honey. Booce, what does he need?"

"That's what the sacks are for."

Rather oriented toward the CARM, increased the
thrust, doubled on himself for two seconds, then arched
backward as he fell toward the airlock. Fir sprayed from
his ankles, arcing forward. Nice, Kendy thought. Of
course he wasn't a complete novice. He'd flown with
those giant swim-fin fans.

The boy left his helmet open (but didn't turn off the
air jets!). Debby began strapping twelve coarse sacks to
his back, got yelled at, and strapped them to his chest
instead, where he could reach them. She used several
loops of line. The savages were never without line, Kendy
recalled. Good practice in a free-fall environment.

98 / Larry Niven

In present time Rather was leaving the airlock again,
and the signal was fading. Kendy waited.

The great green torus became landscape as Rather
came near. It was darker than integral tree foliage, and
fluffy, finely divided to catch as much sunlight as possible.
Scarlet and orange peeked over the curve, becoming
clearer. Orange hom shapes, rocket-nostril shapes, quite
pretty. Thousands of them.

The jittering mist cleared too: not steam roiled by wind,
but myriads of particles swirling round the blossoms, dip-
ping in and out. Now the motes abandoned the horn
shapes and streamed toward Rather.

They were all around him, a humming black cloud of
rage.

"Scientist? I'm in the center. I can hardly see. The
honey hornets are—"

"Look for red," said Booce's voice.

Orange and scarlet. Orange horns the size of drinking
gourds, and scarlet of another shape. Rather jetted closer.

The honey hornets came with him. Thousands of
thumb-sized birds: tiny harpoon for a nose, invisible blur
of wing behind. He could hear the angry buzz through his
helmet. "I've got a red thing . . . Booce, it's a kind of a
sloppy polyhedron half a meter through, covered with lots
of little triangle holes. It's growing between these horn
shapes."

"Those are flowers. It didn't grow there, it's attached.
Did you take a knife?"

"No. Wait a breath, there's a matchet on mv leg. It
must be Mark's."

"Cut the honeypod loose and put the sack around it.
Tie the neck shut."

Rather swung the matchet behind the scarlet polyhed-
ron. The silver suit made all movements stiff. Presently
the honeypod was floating loose. Rather pulled a sack

THE SMOKE RING / 99

free, opened the mouth, and swept it around the honey-
pod.

"Got it? Tie the bag shut. Done?"

"Done. There's sticky red stuff all over my gloves."

"Stet. Now keep doing that till you run out of sacks.
Don't lick the honey."

"With my helmet closed?"

"Don't ever lick honey. It's suicide."

Chapter Eight

The Honey Track

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 1426 State:

GOLDBLATT'S WORLD

GOLDBLATT'S WORLD MAY HAVE BEGUN LIFE AS A
NEPTUNE-LIKE BODY IN THE COMET CLOUD AROUND
THE PAIRED STARS. IN GOLDBLATT'S SCENARIO, THE
BODY WAS CAPTURED SOME MILLIONS OF YEARS AFTER
THE SUPERNOVA EVENT. THE COLLAPSING CORE OF THE
SUPERNOVA, SPEWING ITS OUTER ENVELOPE ASYM-
METRICALLY DUE TO A TRAPPED MAGNETIC FIELD, MAY
HAVE PICKED UP A SKEW VELOCITY THAT NEARLY
MATCHED THE VELOCITY OF THE PROTO-NEPTUNE.
ROBBED OF ITS ORBITAL VELOCITY, GOLDBLATT'S
WORLD WOULD FALL ALONG A DRASTICALLY ECCEN-
TRIC ORBIT, PASSING VERY NEAR LEVOY'S STAR. EX-
TREME ROCHE TIDES WOULD WARP THE ORBIT INTO A
CIRCLE WITHIN A FEW SCORES OF PASSES.

100

THE SMOKE RING / 101

IT SEEMS LIKELY THAT GOLDBLATT'S WORLD'S
ORBIT AND THE ASSOCIATED GAS TORUS HAVE BEEN
CONTRACTING FOR ALL OF THEIR BILLION YEARS.
MEANWHILE LEVOY'S STAR HAS BEEN COOLING—
SINCE NEUTRON STARS NO LONGER UNDERGO FUSION-
MAINTAINING A RELATIVELY STABLE BALANCE OF TEM-
PERATURE IN THE SMOKE RING.

NOTE THAT THE ROCHE LIMIT IS NEVER AN ABSO-
LUTE. IT VARIES AS THE DENSITY OF THE ORBITING
BODY. A GASBALL WORLD MAY BE WITHIN ITS ROCHE
LIMIT, AND THIS ONE PROBABLY WAS. BUT THE ROCK-
AND-METAL CORE IS DENSE. GOLDBLATT'S WORLD
WOULD HAVE BEEN WELL OUTSIDE ITS ROCHE LIMIT
AFTER THE GASBALL LOST SOME OF ITS GAS AND THE
ECCENTRIC ORBIT BECAME MORE CIRCULAR.

THE PLANET IS NOW NO MORE THAN TWO AND A HALF
TIMES THE MASS OF EARTH . . .

—SAM GOLDBLATT, PLANETOLOGIST

"YOU SEE THE PROBLEM? TOO MUCH OF IT IS GIBBER-

ish," Jeffer told the children. Rather and Carlot were nod-
ding, but their eyes were glassy. "You can look up some
of the words. You can guess a little. Goldblatt's World is
Gold. There's a file on Earth and Neptune and the rest
of the solar system, but it's hard going. Roche tides,
Roche Limit—that seems to be a balance point between
tide and some other force, maybe the same force that
changes your orbit if you pass too close to Gold. Fusion
is power: it makes the Sun bum, and Discipline ran on
fusion. Oort cloud, magnetic field, supernova—Lawri
and I never figured those out."

He turned to Booce. "The kids need this, but I hate
to make you sit through it again at your age—"

Booce's eyes were glassy too. "No, no, no. This is all
new to me."

102 / Larry Niven

"Didn't you have classes? There's the Library—"

"For officer's kids only," Booce said brusquely. "Go
on with this. What's eccentric?"

"That's a round path that isn't a circle. It goes out and
in. Booce, am I committing a crime if I teach you and
Carlot these things?"

"But I want to learn!"

"Shush, Carlot. It's never come up before," Booce
said. "You're not showing us the Library, after all."

Carlot demanded, "Scientist, what's the point in stop-
ping nowT'

Jeffer laughed. He tapped, and the window was re-
stored. The Clump was nearer now, and a score of parallel
dashes lay across the CARM's path. "You're right. Car-
lot, but the lesson's over anyway. We're getting too
close."

Debby answered with a raspberry.

"Booce?" Jeffer said. "Any special favorites?"

"The smallest, I'd think, but let's have a better look."
Booce disengaged his seat tethers and moved aft. "Jeffer,
would you open those doors?"

"Will do." He did. "Booce, don't you trust the win-
dows?"

"I prefer my eyes. Swing us around, will you?" He
braced himself in the airlock. Others of the crew had fol-
lowed him.

Jeffer began the maneuver. In the forward view, now
moving into the port view, one of the trees had begun
blinking: a green halo going on, off, on, off.

Nobody was near. Jeffer whispered, "Why?"

Now a point far in along the trunk was doing the blink-
ing. Then that stopped—

An arm stabbed past Jeffer's ear, and he had to repress
a shriek. "There," Booce said, pointing at one of the
trees. "Thirty klomters, and it seems healthy."

"What about this one, Booce?" Jeffer tapped the tree
that had blinked at him.

THE SMOKE RING / 103

"Nothing wrong with it. It's bigger, twice the mass.
Take us longer to get it to the Market, but of course
there'd be more wood too, and there's the CARM . . .
Why that one?"

"A hunch. You've got no objection?"

Now Clave was behind him too. "Jeffer, are you play-
ing dominance games?"

"T_"

"I'm the Chairman, you captain the CARM, Booce is
the logger. Booce chooses the tree."

Jeffer repressed a sigh. "Yes, Chairman. Booce?"
Booce pointed to Jeffer's selection. "That one."

Ten klomters above the tuft, the wood of the trunk had
grown to enclose a node of foreign matter. Jeffer saw
Booce catch his daughter's eye as Carlot was about to
speak. She held her silence.

At the tree midpoint Jeffer nosed the CARM against
the trunk. He ran the attitude jets while his crew pounded
spikes into the bark to mark a rectangle the size of the
CARM's bow. The CARM drifted while they chopped out
a dock with matchets.

Even on this younger tree, the bark was a meter thick.
They made life easier for themselves by chopping along
cracks. The five of them lifting together could rip great
mattresses of bark away from the wood beneath, then saw
off sections. Booce and Carlot used the saw, then let oth-
ers take over until they got the hang of it.

Booce and Carlot rejoined Jeffer in the CARM. Booce
said, "They seem to be doing all right."
"But it's scarred," Carlot objected.
"And how much wood will that cost us?"
She shrugged. "Five percent? And weren't we in a
hurry to get home?"

Booce was smiling. "Exactly. Jeffer, why this tree?"
"You'll be painting a line of honey down the trunk,
stet? Have a look at that scar."

104 / Larry Niven

"Can you tell me what I'm supposed to find?"

"No, I can't."

"Jeffer the Scientist, Citizens Tree gave us shelter and
a place among you. We're grateful. I will not quarrel with
any decision you make. You won't need to test it again."

Jeffer could feel his ears and cheeks burning. "If that
scar isn't more interesting than you expect, you can count
on it that I won't make a fool of myself twice. Stet?"

"Stet. I won't raise this subject with the Chairman,
ever."

"You are kind. What's next?"

"The honey line."

In the cabin the roar of the main drive was like a great
beast heard far away; but outside the airlock the roar was
deafening. A translucent blue flame reached out from the
CARM's main rocket nostril. Warmth backwashed
against the bark.

Carlot's eyes were big with fear. Rather pulled at her
arm to set her kicking toward the in tuft, and followed,
with Booce following him.

They stopped where the noise had decreased some-
what. The rough bark itself absorbed sound. Booce
screamed, "That noise is beyond belief! What is that
damn CARM, a ship from the stars?"

"Jeffer says it rode here on the starship. My father
never saw Discipline." What Rather said would be true
whoever his father was. "But he's seen the stars. They're
real."

"I'm afraid of it. I admit it. Look, the noise is scaring
the bugs out of the bark! Let's get to work."

Booce used a branchwood matchet to open a hole in
one of the honeypots. The interior was partitioned; the
cells held red, sticky honey. Booce used the blade to paint
it on the bark.

"You'll find .a few hornets still in there," he told
Rather. "They try to sting through the sack if you give

THE SMOKE RING / 105

them a few days to get restless, and then they die. But
don't count on it. Don't let one get at you. Now you paint
dabs a couple of meters apart. Closer, you waste honey.
Farther apart, the bugs lose their way."

Rather had thought he was a climber, but this was dif-
ferent. He had problems keeping up. He was almost lost
among the sacks he was carrying. Booce and Carlot
climbed head down; they would have left him behind if
Booce had not been stopping to paint the trunk.

They took a breather when the sun was at nadir and
the shadows had become confusing. The sun was passing
closer to Voy as the year waned.

A day later they took a longer rest. "This is the part
I like best," Booce said. "We're usually in too much of
a hurry. This time your CARM is already pushing us
home. We can take our time, do what we like!"

"Like what?"

"I'll show you as we go." Booce began tearing up
sheets of bark greater than a man, mooring them edgewise
against the bare wood. When he had them arrayed he set
them alight.

The smoke tended to stay where it formed. Booce
moored a four-kigram slab of shellbird meat in the cloud.
They broiled smaller steaks on their matchets, closer to
the fire, and ate them still hot.

"The smoked meat will keep till we're down," Booce
said. "But there are other things on the trunk. You've
never climbed?"

"When we were children we did a little climbing, but
just on the lower trunk. We weren't supposed to go more
than a klomter up. If you fell, the foliage would catch you.
Any higher, we rode the elevator."

They slept carefully tethered in cracks in the bark.
Sometimes, for moments, the roar of the CARM could be
heard above the wind. A dark cloud had formed above
them and was gradually drifting down.

The bugs of the tree had found the honey.

106 / Larry Niven

They breakfasted on smoked bird. Then Carlot did the
painting while Booce carried the food.

The sun circled them, once and again. Always they
stopped when the shadows were pointing straight out.
Water was beginning to flow sluggishly in alongside their
path. "Bugs like it damp," Booce said. "The bark's wet
enough for them around the midpoint, but not lower
down. You have to paint down the east side, alongside
the waterfall, or they won't come. Also the trunk blocks
the wind. You don't want the bugs blown away."

There was fan fungus like so many pallid hands reach-
ing from the bark. Carlot showed Rather how to tear the
red fringe off before eating the white interior. It was
bland, almost tasteless, but went well enough with the
strongly flavored smoked meat.

With lunch came entertainment: a gust of roses on the
wind. The stems were four meters long. Dark-red blos-
soms fragile as tissue paper pointed straight toward Voy,
soaking up blue Voy-light. Rather had never seen the like.
He and Carlot watched the roses blowing east until they
were out of sight.

Rather took his turn painting. Booce kept a close
watch, but it seemed simple enough. A dab the size of a
baby's hand; the next dab two meters lower.

A dark cloud flowed after them down the trunk.

The wind grew stronger, though the trunk blocked
most of it. The growing tide made climbing easier for
Rather. The water flowed more strongly. It was cleaner
than pond water, cleaner than the water that reached the
basin in the commons. It tasted wonderful, and painting
was hard, thirsty work.

In two days. Rather's arm was one long cramp.

He was too tired to help with dinner. Booce managed
alone. He found shelled things hiding in the bark and
pulled them loose. Roasted, their white flesh made a fine
meal.

THE SMOKE RING / 107

Again they wedged themselves along a wide crack in
the bark, with Carlot between the men. There were dan-
gers on the trunk.

Rather's aches kept him awake. He presently noticed
Carlot's feet stirring restlessly. "Carlot?"

He would not have spoken twice, but she answered at
once. "Can't sleep?"

' 'No. My father told me about climbing up a tree. When
they got to the top the tree came apart."

"That's one reason we don't just chop off the tuft or
burn it loose. This is easier, but it also gets the bugs away
from the midpoint. When the tree dies, they're not there
to eat it apart."

"How do you get rid of the out tuft?"

"Oh, some of the bugs won't follow the honey. They'll
be breeding while we travel. When we get close to the
Clump we'll paint another trail out."

"Why are you awake?"

"Tide. I have trouble sleeping in tide." But her voice
trailed off raggedly. He stopped talking, and presently
slept.

After breakfast Booce said, "There's something I want
to see on the west side of the trunk. Leave the gear here."

Climbing was easy if you didn't have to paint too. In
less than a day they had half circled the trunk. Above
them by a quarter klomter, the bark bulged like a wave
surging across a pond. They climbed toward that.

"Jeffer wanted us to look at this," Booce told them.
"Something must have hit the trunk while it was younger.
The wood'sgrown around it."

The wood bulged to hide it like some secret treasure.
Rather was almost inside the crater before he could see
anything. Carlot, ahead of him, had stopped. Booce was
at his shoulder. Rather heard him gasp.

Carlot said, "Metal!"

"I must apologize to Jeffer," Booce said. "Metal in-

108 / Larry Niven

deed! The tree may consider it poisonous; see how re-
luctant the wood is to touch it! But the Admiralty won't
think so."

Rather asked, "We want this?"

"We do. Secret auction, I think." Booce was deep into
the crater, running his hands over the reddish-black sur-
face of the metal. "Six or eight thousand kilos. No point
in trying to move it. We'll have to show it to the Navy
anyway, unless . . . hmm."

Carlot looked at her father. "We don't want to attract
attention."

"Exactly. I have to think about this. Well, my merry
crew, I think we've earned a holiday."

They climbed back around the trunk, taking their time.
Booce knew just where to find the shelled burrowers.
After lunch they spent a day tethered in the now strongly
running waterfall, first washing each other and squeezing
honey out of their clothing, then wrestling. They still got
some painting in before sleeptime.

In twenty days they had reached the wild tuft.

Rather had never appreciated foliage before. It had sur-
rounded him all his life. He gorged, savoring the taste and
texture. "You love it too," he observed. "Carlot, Booce,
why don't you live in a tree?"

"Oh, there's foliage in the Clump too," Carlot said.
"All kinds. Rather, I can't wait to show you!"

They slept in foliage. Rather slept like a dead man,
from exhaustion and the familiar sensation of sleeping
under tide, in a womb of soft foliage. He woke early,
feeling wonderful.

Carlot lay not far from her father. Her face was grief-
stricken. She thrashed in slow motion, unconsciously
trying to hold herself against the tide.

Rather took her hand, gently. "Hey. Nightmare?"

Her eyes opened. '"Oh. Rather. I was trying to get to
Wend. She was screaming and trying to fly with just her

THE SMOKE RING / 109

bare feet—" She shook her head violently and sat up.
"Something I have to tell you."

"Okay."

"When we were swimming. Father noticed you were

up."

"Up? Oh, up. You're very pretty," Rather said a little

awkwardly.

"We can't make babies."

"We can't? Hey, the jungle giants and the Lon-
don Tree citizens didn't have any trouble. I'm a dwarf,

but—"

Carlot laughed. "Father says we can't. He wants me
to marry another logger. I think he wants it to be Raff
Belmy, from Woodsman, but definitely another logger. I
thought I'd better say something before . . . well, before
you got to thinking."

"Thinking. Well, it's too late, then."

"It's all right, then?"

"Sure. Go back to sleep." The truth was that Rather
was almost relieved. Carlot with her clothes off made his
head swim and his blood boil: an uncomfortable feeling.

And Booce didn't want his daughter to love a dwarf
savage. Should he resent that? Somehow he didn't.

Breakfast was more foliage. Then Booce gave Rather
the matchet. "Pry the bark off. We want a complete ring
of bare wood half a meter across. We'll paint along behind

you."

Three and a half days later he was halfway around.
The bark was soft, easy to pry loose, but the trunk must
have been a good two klomters in circumference. They
returned to the wild tuft to sleep and eat. Rather was one
vast ache, but it still felt good to be sleeping in tide, in

foliage.

After breakfast Rather was still on the matchet. The
Serjents seemed to share Citizens Tree's faith in a dwarf's
superior strength. He finished the job before they slept
again. They were ahead of schedule. Jeffer would not




110 / Larry Niven
bring the CARM down for them for another six or seven

days.

From the base of the trunk they watched a moby attack

the bugs descending along the honey track. Mobies nor-
mally skimmed clouds of bugs from the sky for their food.
This was a tremendous creature, mostly mouth and fins,
riding the wind toward the trunk and the bug-swarm at a
hundred meters per breath. It realized its mistake just in
time. It thrashed madly, gaping, irresistibly comical, as
the wind hurled it toward the tree. Its flank smashed loose

a shower of bark as it passed.

The bugs descended like a cloud of charcoal dust. They

reached the ring of painted bare wood and spread to north
and south. The cloud condensed, growing darker, swarm-
ing-a few ce'meters out from the bark.

"Carlot. Do you like it on the tree?"

She nodded, watching the bugs.

"Booce? I've watched you. You like it here."

"I love it."

"Then how can you kill trees?"

Booce shrugged. "There are plenty of trees."

Chapter Nine

The Rocket

from Logbearer's log. Captain Booce Serjent speaking:

YEAR 384, DAY 1280. TEN DEGREES WEST OF THE
CLUMP. WE'VE FOUND A GROVE AND CHOSEN A SHORT

ONE, 30 KLOMTERS.

DAY 1300. REFUELED IN A RAINCLOUD. EVERY-
THING'S WET.

DAY 1310. ANCHORED AT MIDPOINT OF TREE.
DAY 1330. RYLLIN AND KARILLY MUST HAVE LAID
THE HONEY TRACK BY NOW. BUGS ARE FOLLOWING
THEM DOWN TO THE TUFT. I'LL TAKE LOGBEARER IN TO
PICK THEM UP. WE'RE ALL EAGER TO RETURN TO THE
ADMIRALTY, BUT THERE'S NO WAY TO HURRY THE

BUGS.

DAY 1335. RYLLIN AND KARILLY ARE ABOARD.

FROM THE IN TUFT THEY SPOTTED A POND 50 KLOMTERS
WEST AND A LITTLE IN. THE WOMEN ARGUE THAT WE
CAN FIRE UP THE ROCKET AND START OUR RETURN WITH-
OUT WAITING FOR THE BUGS. THE POND WILL LET US
111

112 / Larry Niven

REFILL THE WATER TANK. IT WOULD GAIN US TWENTY

TO THIRTY DAYS.

NOW IT'S MY CHOICE. THERE'S A RISK, BUT I'VE

NEVER YET HELD OUT AGAINST THE WOMEN. I'LL GIVE

UP EARLY, SAVE TIME.

DAY 1360. THE BUGS HAVE REACHED THE HONEY

BAND AROUND THE IN TUFT. ORDINARILY I WOULD BE
DOWN THERE SUPERVISING, BUT I CAN'T DO THAT

WHILE WE'RE UNDER ACCELERATION.

WE MAINTAIN STAGGERED WATCHES AGAINST HAP-
PYFEET. IF THEY FIND US WE CAN READY LOGBEARER
FOR INDEPENDENT FLIGHT IN HALF A DAY. THE ROCKET

IS HOT AND RUNNING.

DAY 1370. I'LL STOP FEEDING THE PIPEFIRE SOON.

LET IT BURN OUT BEFORE THE BUGS CUT THE TUFT
LOOSE. I CAN GUIDE US INTO THE POND ON THE LAST OF

OUR STEAM.

IF THE ROCKET RUNS DRY IT'LL TEACH THE GIRLS

CAUTION. WE'LL STILL FILL THE TANK BEFORE WE
REACH THE CLUMP . YOU ALWAYS BUMP A POND OR TWO

WHEN YOU'RE MOVING.

DAY 1380. A MATURE TREE IS DRIFTING TO BLOCK

OUR PATH. DAMMIT. MAYBE IT'LL MOVE PAST.
NO FURTHER ENTRIES.

THE CARM PICKED THEM UP ON THE BRANCH AND RE-

turned to its dock with the cabin half filled with foliage.
Rather suspected that they would not eat foliage again,

nor sleep in decent tide, for a long time.

He heard the argument when Clave wanted to restart
the motor. "There's no point," Jeffer told him. "We'd
be using fuel to fight wind. We're doing fine."

Booce added his voice to Jeffer's. "We'll sail even
further in after the tuft severs. Leave us something to

breathe!"

THE SMOKE RING / 113

Had anyone else seen Clave glance aft? Clave had
taken less than a breath to read the faces of his crew, but
Rather had caught it.

Not so long ago, far away in Citizens Tree, Gavving
had spoken thus to his eldest son: "You're a citizen now.
Watch Clave during a meeting. He leads where we'll go.
He always has. You don't have to go Clave's way just
because Clave says so ..."
The motor stayed off.

The tree moved ponderously west and in. Its westward
motion slowed over several days. The days were shorter,
and Voy had come nearer. The smallest children learned
never to look directly at Voy; but Rather could tell. In
the corner of his eye the violet-white pinpoint was more
intense, closer and smaller, with less sky to blur and dis-
tort it.

It took six days to make a sleep; then seven. Time
whirled around them until they stopped caring. The jour-
ney had become more important than their destination.

The crew lived on the bark, all but Jeffer. They found
the CARM too strange. Even Rather left the CARM after
a few sleeps. He had learned that he liked strangeness;

but he sensed that Jeffer saw him as an intruder. The Sci-
entist captains the CARM.

Debby and Booce disappeared down the trunk to mon-
itor the progress of the bugs. They returned with smoked
dumbo meat and two cured skins, which Booce shaped
into armor that looked remarkably like the silver suit.
"We won't use it this trip, but it's standard gear. The
Navy will expect us to have it."

A grove of integral tree sproutlings passed Voy-ward
of the tree, the first the citizens had ever seen. They were
a few scores of meters long, tufted only at the out end.
"The seeds drop away, out and in," Booce told them.
"After they sprout, they have to sail back to the median.
They'll grow the other tuft when there's enough to feed
them."




114 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 115

The day came when Carlot called her father and
pointed outward. "Isn't that a pod grove?"

Backlit by the sun, the cluster might almost have been
a miniature tree grove hundreds of klomters out. "Small
... yes. Too far, though."

"Why?" Debby asked.

"Well, it'd take too long to ... I'd forgotten the
CARM. Let's ask Jeffer."

Jeffer summoned up his windows-within-windows.
"Sure, we can get there. Clave, want to take a trip?"

"Can we find our way back? The tree looks big
when you're tied to it, but from six hundred klomters
away—"

"Trust me."

Forty plants grew in a loose cluster, all much alike.
From a fibrous cup that faced west, a long, limp leaf
trailed eastward, waving sluggishly in the wind. A thick
vine reached a hundred meters out from the boll, ending
in a kind of collar. Each collar held a brown egg-shape.

"Those are jet pods," Debby realized suddenly. "We
used to ride them in Carther States."

Booce directed Rather to one of the largest plants. Car-
lot and Debby hung back. Rather the Silver Man circled
the pod, cautious in the face of a new thing: a fibrous
brown egg as big as the common room in his father's hut.
There was tide enough to pull the vine taut. Smaller pods
grew in a spiral around the stem end, ranging from fist-
sized to man-sized. Replacements, he surmised, that
would grow after the ripe one dropped away.

Satisfied, Rather wrapped his legs around the stem for
leverage and swung his matchet.

The sound blasted his whole body. The sky spun round
him. Tide was pulling him apart. His fingers and toes felt
like they were inflating as spin pulled blood into them.

Against the tide that was pulling him rigid, Rather
forced his legs vertical to his torso, pulled an arm against

his chest, and fired the ankle jets. The spinning sky
slowed. He aimed his feet against the spin and brought it
to a stop.

Battered and deafened, he pulled his helmet open to
hear what Booce was shouting at him.

"That one was ripe! Try another plant!"

Rather jetted toward the grove. Booce guided him from
a distance. "No, that one's stunted. We want a big one."

"Aren't the big ones likely to be riper?"

"That's why we use armor! Try there—"

The pod exploded, blowing him west and away, while
seeds sponged off the silver suit. The spin was less this
time; the blow had been more direct. Rather opened his
helmet. "I think I had more fun on the tree!"

"It's too wet here. The pods like to spread their seeds
when there's water around. Try that one. Close your hel-
met!"

Rather seriously considered telling the alien merchant
to go feed himself to the tree. But he was already moving
toward a third vine. There isn't any other Silver Man, he
thought. He swung viciously at the base of the pod. And
what am I, if I'm not the Silver Man?

The pod dropped out and away. Carlot and Debby
flapped after it.

The next one didn't explode either. Rather chased the
seed pod down, with Booce chasing him. They braced
their shoulders against the pod and started back. They
were near the CARM when Rather's jets died.

He fiddled with the throttle wheels. Nothing.

"Booce! Don't leave me!"

"What's wrong?"

"The suit won't move!"

Booce laughed. "Are we going to have to put wings
on that thing?"

"Can you push me—"

"Can and will. Here comes Debby. I'll push you and




116 / Larry Niven

the ladies can have the pods." Booce seemed indecently
cheerful, and Rather was a long time understanding why.
Booce had found a flaw in Citizens Tree's intimidating
science.

"You ran out of fuel, that's all," Jeffer told him. "See
that little red light below your chin?"

"It was on when I started out. I don't know what it
means."

"Means you're out of hydrogen. There must be a way
to refuel the suit. I'll search the cassettes. If I can't find
anything we'll have to ask Mark, after this is all over.
Calm, now! We've got pods and we've got honey. Maybe
we won't need the silver suit again."

A forty-klomter-long tree is hard to lose from six
hundred klomters away. Jeffer had no trouble bringing
them home.

Booce attacked the first pod gingerly, hacking at the
stem with the matchet, flinching back at each blow. At
the sixth blow the pod suddenly spewed foggy air under
terrific pressure. Booce threw himself into the sky. He
flapped back, staying well clear.

He opened the other pod in the same cautious fashion.
Then he and Carlot sawed it in half. The inside was lined
with fist-sized puffballs, each with a dangling tendril.
Booce scraped these away.

He sawed the stem off the first pod, leaving a small
hole. He shaved the edges until the hole was just smaller
than the metal pipe, and quit for dinner.

They resumed work after breakfast. It took four of
them to shove the ends of the pipe into the holes in both
pods.

Clave asked, "Now how do you get water in there?"

"Punch a little hole in the other end of the tank. Put
the pipe in a'pond and suck. You need good lungs to be
a logger."

THE SMOKE RING / 117

"We're too far in to find many ponds."

"I know. Usually we fuel Logbearer before we go to
work on the tree. But, dammit, we've got the CARM, and
there'll be a pond somewhere, and Logbearer is whole
again! Except for the lines. And cabins. We'll need wood
to build cabins."

"We'll go for wood after the next sleep," Jeffer said.
"The out branch, I think. The in branch may be about to
fall off."

"No. Another thirty days at least."

Carlot said, "Father—"

"Don't trust that," Booce said instantly. "We'll use
the out branch."

"You're the logger. What changed your mind?"

Booce sighed. "I was guessing. I don't really know
when the in branch will fall off. Jeffer, there's likely to
be a shock when the branch tears loose. Stay aboard the
CARM. Stay strapped in when you sleep. Leave the
motor off."

"Stet. Will the rest of you be okay on the trunk?"

"As long as we keep our wings handy. Always have
your wings in reach . . . always. But you should be in the
CARM in case we need rescue."

The steam rocket still required attention. Booce and
Carlot festooned the water tank with lines and wove a
braid of lines around the bow end. "We'll moor the cabins
here. Other than that ... I still don't know what we're
going to use for sikenwire. There has to be some way to
hold the coals in place."

Clave had a suggestion. "We could arrive crippled. Get
a push from the CARM to drift the log into range, then
signal for help somehow. Tell the Navy we lost our sik-
enwire, got home by luck."

"Mmm . . . maybe. I'd look like a fool, but maybe. I
just don't want to be in too much of a hurry." He stopped
abruptly. Then he said, "Ryllin and the girls, they—we

118 / Larry Niven

were in a hurry to get back to the Admiralty. We started
the rocket running before the tuft dropped off."

"What's—?"

"Did I tell you you're rich?"

"I don't know what it means," Clave said.

"That wart on the trunk is thousands of kilos of metal.
With metal you can buy anything that's for sale in the
Market. It also makes us a target. Someone might try to
steal it."

"Good news and bad news."

"Right. We'll set up shop to sell the wood, and take
our time selling the metal. No hurry."

Food had grown short again. Debby and Clave flew in
along the trunk until they found a covey of flashers. With
the trunk as a backstop they fired their full complement
of arrows and shot half a dozen of the small birds. It took
them six days.

They built a fire on the trunk to cook the birds. Log-
bearer's crew was ready for a feast.

Booce was the exception. He ate little. He was un-
characteristically silent, his eyes on the fire, until Carlot
said, "Dad? Twenty, twenty-five days?"

"About that," Booce said. Then: "I guessed last time.
I should be in the tuft watching the bugs."

"Dad, you couldn't warn us from down there any-
way."

"I could start climbing ten or fifteen days early ..."

"Dad—"

"I'm glad we don't have the rocket running. We were
running the rocket when it happened."

The silence stretched. Debby asked, "What hap-
pened?"

Booce told it.

Booce was fast asleep when the cabin's yielding
wooden wall slammed into his face and chest. His grunt

THE SMOKE RING / 119

of surprise was lost among feminine shrieks. He was
reaching for his wings before his eyes were fully open.

The women were a flurry of action around him, snatch-
ing for their wings, moving out. Ryllin reached the door,
looked about her, then immediately turned toward a vi-
olet-white glare that hadn't been there when they'd gone
to sleep. Carlot and Karilly followed. Wend hadn't found
her wings. She was near tears as she searched.

Booce left her. Nothing terrible could happen to Wend
aboard Logbearer, and this would teach her always to
know where her wings were.

He saw it all at a glance:

Logbearer was moored against a vast wall of bark, the
east side of the trunk. Coals in their retaining net burned
bright orange along the middle length of the pipe. The
nozzle cone pointed east toward the Clump. Some meters
from the cone, live steam condensed into a white stream
klomters long.

The Clump was a distant whori of white-and-gray
storm, with the misty white tube of the Smoke Ring con-
verging beyond and below it. The eye might follow that
white line down the sky . . . and where the tree converged
to a point, there was Voy.

The glare-white pinpoint had been masked by the in
tuft when Booce went to sleep. The in tuft was gone. It
had torn loose days before Booce expected it. Freed from
its weight, the tree had lurched outward. Booce had
guessed as much; now he could see it.

In toward Voy, a fluttering black silhouette was haloed
in blue light.

Mishael had been outside on watch. The lurch had torn
her loose. She was far in along the trunk, flapping out-
and-east to bring her out, just as she'd been taught. But
he'd never taught her to lose one of her wings!

Ryllin and the girls flew toward her: foreshortened
black silhouettes. They made slow progress. In-and-west

120 / Larry Niven

would have taken them straight in, but the west was a
wall of black bark.

Booce followed slowly. Mishael seemed to have it
under control.

With the in tuft gone the center of mass was higher on
the tree. Tide was pulling Booce away from the tree, and
in. A new breeze announced that the tree was under sail,
accelerated by the wind on the out tuft. He kick-flapped
to adjust. Ryllin and the girls had nearly reached Mishael.
Karilly looked up and flapped to turn. She was shouting
at him. The wind tore her voice away. He tried to hear.
She kicked toward him, screaming—

Booce turned toward Logbearer, too late.

The lurch and the breeze and Booce's inattention,
these had caused the disaster. A flurry of coals had been
jarred loose from the sikenwire cage. Irradiated by the
pipefire, the bark had been drying and warming for tens
of days. It had been ready to ignite.

Under normal circumstances an integral tree is in equi-
librium with the wind. A steady gale blows at each tuft,
and no wind blows at its center. Air must move past a
fire to keep it burning. But a tree under sail is moving,
and there is wind. Coals reached the bark and blazed up.

Booce flapped hard toward a Logbearer already
embedded in flame.

He hadn't panicked then. There was a hose, and pres-
sure in the water tank, for the fire would be heating it.
He would use the hose to spray water and steam on the
fire. Booce breathed deeply as he flew, hyperoxygenat-
ing. He'd hold his breath while he worked. The danger
was that he might breathe flame.

Wend crawled gingerly through the cabin door. Her
feet were wingless, her eyes and mouth wide in terror.
She saw Booce, gathered herself, and leapt toward him,
into the sky.

The water tank ruptured.

Booce saw Wend blown outward in a wind of live

THE SMOKE RING / 121

steam laced with boiling water. He flapped to catch her,
hearing his own howl. She was flying past him. He
stretched impossibly and caught her bare ankle, and felt
the scalded skin slide loose beneath his hand.

There were comforting hands on Booce, on his shoul-
ders and arm and ankle, for touching was the way of Cit-
izens Tree. Rather hung back, uncertain, reluctant to take
such liberties. Booce was a mature adult.

Where was Carlot?

Booce was hoarse, for he had been shouting, howling;

but he sounded almost calm now. "Everything's blurred
after that. . . Lawri the Scientist was feeding me foliage
and I couldn't remember anything. It all came back a bit
at a time."

Rather eased away from the cookfire and flew toward
Voy. Behind him Booce was speaking mostly to Debby,
who was rubbing his temples.

"It never happened before . . . not to us. Sometimes
a logging concern just disappears. We wonder why. We
never find out. For Ryllin, for the girls, I should give it
up. But logging's all I know ..."

The memories must have been too much for Carlot. If
she wanted to hide ... a crack in the bark? Bark walls
would muffle the agony in her father's voice. She might
have gone in any direction . . . but the cracks ran out and
in. Try in.

Rather coasted above the bark. He didn't mind being
seen. She'd have kept going until she couldn't hear the
words.

"Go away."

He somersaulted and kicked air to stop himself. "Car-
lot?"

No answer. It had come from his left, from the north.
There: scarlet showed in a crack. He said, "I wouldn't
have found you if you'd kept your mouth shut."

122 / Larry Niven

She was pulled into herself, like the shellbirds around
the ice pond. Her wings were on her back. He fluttered
into the crack beside her but didn't touch her. "It must
have been bad."

"It was bad."

He tried again. "Want a hug?"

"I want Wend back."

"You have to leam to think of her as a lost one."

"She was fifteen!"

("She wasn't even two!" Jill had wailed after a sister
sickened and died. lisa had hugged her daughter fre-
quently. When lisa died at thirty-one, it had been no better
for Jill.

(Age didn't matter. Touching helped.) Rather worked
his fingers into her hair and began a scalp massage. She
didn't move. He said, "I've had brothers and sisters die.
We all have. You forget."

She'd removed her sleeves after the fluff died. The skin
of her arms was smooth and richly dark, and she suddenly
wriggled about and had him in a deathgrip.

Rotating, they drifted in the sky. Rather still wore his
wings; his instincts told him to return to the tree. He held
her.

She wasn't sobbing. Presently she pulled her chin off
his shoulder and kissed him.

He asked, "Better?"

"Yes. I don't want to go back."

"Will you be all right here? Shall I stay?" Half a dozen
finger cacti drifted east, less than a klomter distant. A
windborne finger cactus could be lethal. These were only
drifting, and drifting away at that . . . but you never
stopped looking for danger.

Carlot hadn't answered. He said, "Your father might
get upset if we stay here too long—"

"Father's made mistakes before."

"He tells you who to make babies with, though. Mis-
hael had to ask, and she's older than you."

THE SMOKE RING / 123

"Do you want to go?"

"... No."

"I thought hard before I took my clothes off in front
of you."

He remembered swimming in the waterfall, and
laughed. "I noticed. But Booce was there."

She freed him, and all the muscles in his body jumped.
Loose in the sky! But he had wings. Carlot drifted, ro-
tating away from him . . . donning her wings? No: she
pulled her tunic over her head, then rolled her pants off
and balled them up together.

He looked. Now she was tying her wings to her ankles.
Her clothes too. Nudity was not strange to him, but this
was different. Carlot was long, one and a half times his
own height. Her breasts were perfect cones, an abrupt
break in the long smooth stretch of her torso. Rather re-
sisted the urge to touch her. He spoke hurriedly, before
he could lose that fight. "Now, what would happen if we
really did make a baby? Could you still marry anyone you
want to?"

She said, "It's all right. We just have to watch what
time we do this."

"Yeah?" Rather had never heard anything about how
not to make a baby. "When can you do it?"

"Now."

"I've never done this before." He swam toward her.

"I'll show you. Take these off."

Chapter Ten

Secrets

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 31 SM:

FISHER PLANT is BOLL-SHAPED, 100-300 ME-
TERS IN DIAMETER. IT CAN EXTEND A LONG WATER-IN-
FLATED ROOT INTO A PASSING POND, FOR FERTILIZER AS
WELL AS WATER.

FISHER JUNGLE MAY BE CONSIDERED A LARGE

(400-700 METERS) FISHER PLANT WITH A STING. MAY
ATTACK BIG BIRDS AS WELL AS PONDS. PREY ARE
BROUGHT INTO THE JUNGLE TO ROT.

FINGER CACTUS—THE NEWLY BUDDED FORM

LOOKS A LITTLE LIKE A GREEN POTATO, WITH EYES.
FINGERS SPROUT FROM THE EYES, AND BRANCH AND RE-
BRANCH, UNTIL AN ADULT IN FLOWER MAY BEAR 20-30
FINGERS. EACH FINGER IS TIPPED WITH A SPINE. ANY
CREATURE THAT COMES TOO NEAR MAY BE SPEARED;

AND THEN ROOTS GROW INTO THE VICTIM. LATER IN
LIFE, FINGERS BUD NEW FINGER CACTI. DANGEROUS.
124

THE SMOKE RING / 125

RATHER WOKE BECAUSE HIS EYES BURNED.

They were filled with tears. Blinking did no good. The
tears were under his eyelids, filling them. The pain had
him whimpering. He tried lifting his eyelids with his fin-
gertips to let the water out. That hurt. Mopping his eyes
with his tunic brought agony. He couldn't see!

"Carlot?" He remembered that she wasn't with him.
They had not returned to the cookfire until all were asleep
except Debby, on watch. She had winked at them . . .
they had separated . . .

Sleep, then daggers in the eyes. He would not have
wanted Carlot to see him like this. But he was alone, and
blind!

"Clave? Debby? Anyone?"

Rather could feel bark surrounding him. Yell again?
He'd yelled when the silver suit's jets gave out. The mem-
ory embarrassed him. He'd had gritty eyes before, when
he was tired ... but not like this! "Someone help me! I
can't see!"

"Rather?"

"Debby? My eyes are on fire and I don't know why!"

Her hands were cool and rough on his cheeks. "Open

them."

"I can't..." He got them open, just a slit for just a
moment. The light was agony.

"They're bright red. I'U get Clave. Don't loose your
tether."

"No way!"

The pain grew no worse and no better. It was a long
time before he heard voices.

"Rather?"

"Clave! What's wrong with me?"

Long fingers held his head still; thumbs lifted his eye-
lids. "You're not blind. You're not dying either. It's an
allergy attack. Your father used to get this way when Dal-

126 / Larry Niven

ton-Quinn Tree was dying of the drought. We were too
far in toward Voy. Dry, thin air and not enough sleep."

"What do I do?"

"Gavving mostly suffered. In half a day he'd be over
it. Don't rub your eyes. Let me think."

It seemed to hurt less now that he knew it would go
away. It hadn't killed Gavving. And if they both had the
same allergy, then— He's really my father! I should tell
him! Mother too . . . and Mark? But the pain was more
urgent. "Clave, if this happens when I don't sleep, and
I can't sleep because it hurts too much . . . Clave?"

His line went slack. "I've thought of something. Just
relax. I'll tow you."

"Kendy for the State—"

"Kendy? Treefodder! It's been a long time."

"That's not my fault, Jeffer. Every time our orbits
have matched, there has been someone else in the CARM.
Where are they now? I don't find them outside either."

"They're asleep. I was too. Everyone but me sleeps
on the bark. Kendy, how do I refuel the silver suit?"

Diagrams appeared: CARM and silver suit, side by
side. Parts of the schematics blinked blue as Kendy
talked. Jeffer saw that tanks along the calves of the silver
suit were what made the legs so bulky. "Hydrogen here,
oxygen here. There's hose under these little panels. The
spigots are recessed, here and here, under these covers
on the hull. You open them from the control panel. Bring
up the schematic, then twist above these dots, this way."
An arrowhead circled.

"Good."

"Remember. Oxygen line from here to here. Hydrogen
from here to here. Getting it wrong may cause an explo-
sion."

"What keeps the gases cold?"

"In a pressure suit? No, the gases are just under pres-
sure. That's why the tanks go dry so fast." Kendy's face

THE SMOKE RING / 127

was back in the bow window. "Did you find six metric
tons of metal ore?"

"Yes. Thanks. Booce says it makes us rich."

"Good. I see you've been building a steam rocket. Is
it finished?"

"Booce still has to build cabins. We'll go to the out
branch for the wood. He still doesn't know how to hold
the pipefire—"

"Here's the CARM," a voice said. "Feel the airiock
walls? TreefodderF

Clave was in the airiock with Rather behind him. The
display went blank, a breath too late.

Clave got his mouth closed. "First things first. Sci-
entist, Rather's having an allergy attack. You remember
how Gavving was during the drought? Rather, you need
thick wet air. So, we'll close the airiock and turn up the
pressure and humi . . . um, wetness. Do it, Jeffer."

Jeffer let his fingers dance. Close both doors, humidity
up, pressure up. Pressure in his ears. He worked his jaw.
He untethered himself and moved aft.

Rather's eyelids were puffy; the eyes were scarlet. Jef-
fer said, "It goes away after a while no matter what you
do. This might help. Or not. Work your jaw to pop your
ears." He turned to Clave. "Well?"

"How long has the Checker been back?"

"Since the Serjents reached the trunk."

"Why didn't you tell someone? Me!"

"Let's go outside."

He opened the inner airiock door and gestured Clave
in. From the look of him Clave might explode any minute;

but he came. They were nose to nose while the inner door
closed and the outer opened.

"Keeps the pressure in," Jeffer said. "That's why it's
called airiock." He kicked out into the sky.

Clave followed on mismatched wings. "You're stall-
ing."

"No. Kendy can't reach us except when the sun is

128 / Larry Niven

dead east, but anything that goes on in the CARM, Kendy
hears it later. He can't hear us now."

"He wouldn't have heard us in the Citizens Tree com-
mons!"

"Yeah. Clave, the truth is that I didn't trust anyone
else to talk to Kendy. I don't trust Kendy, and he's very

persuasive."

"Am I too fluff-brained to say no?"

"Clave ... all right, so I was arrogant and wrong-
headed. Now let's go tell the Serjents."

"Uh—"

"Hey, citizumf!" It wasn't really a shout, but Clave's
long fingers closed over Jeffer's face. After a moment the
palm lifted to expose an evil grin.

Clave said, "You still should have told me. Rather
didn't see anything. Did you tell Lawri?"

"No."

"What does Kendy want?"

"He wants the Clump. He wants to know everything
about the Clump."

"This trip was his idea, wasn't it?"

"I told you he's persuasive. Clave, we have to tell
Rather about this before he talks to anyone. He already
knows too much. Nobody else, right?"

"Right. Then I want to talk to Kendy."

"He comes in range every four days lately. Four days
from now, when the sun is dead east."

Jeffer found Rather in the Scientist's seat, hands poised
above the controls. "Freeze," he said. "Now move
away."

Rather obeyed. "I was trying to open the airlock."
"Use the little lights on the doors. Rather, any citizen
knows better than to fiddle with the controls. Once I
nearly killed us all with one ill-considered tap of one fin-
ger. But I don't have to explain that to you. I only have

THE SMOKE RING / 129

to say, Jeffer captains the CARM, keep your tree-feeding
hands off the controls. Stet?"

"Stet. Sorry, Jeffer. I've seen you open the doors, and
I was feeling shut in."

"How are your eyes?"

"Okay."

He held still while Jeffer looked. Rather's eyes were
pink and the lids were puffy, but he didn't blink. "From
now on you sleep in the CARM with me. I should have
someone here anyway in case we get shaken up when the
tuft tears loose."

Rather had already summoned the blue diagram of the
CARM's cabin. Jeffer opened his fingers over the lines
that represented the airlock. The doors opened behind
him. He said, "Help me get the hose linked up. Then take
it outside."

Booce met them at the door. "I'll take that, Rather.
We're filling the rocket. How are you doing?"

"Better."

Debby, Clave, and Carlot waited at the rocket. Booce
and Rather crawled along the bark, dragging the hose after
them. Booce spoke quietly. "Did you know that Carlot
was a crossyear child?"

"No. What's it mean? The crossyear is when Voy
crosses the sun—"

"Children born at the crossyear are unpredictable.
They can go any way at all. Rather, I'm trying to tell you
that you and Carlot are not to marry. She'll marry a log-
ger."

Rather didn't answer. Carlot's expression was un-
readable until the moment Booce's back was turned. Then
she winked. Rather felt his face glowing.

To work. Booce forced the hose into the rocket nozzle.
"Jeffer says he can fill it without anyone sucking on the
end. Clave, give us a hand here. Now push. Jeffer!
Ready r




130 / Larry Niven

The three were braced to hold the hose in place. Clave
said, "There's a signal Jeffer uses that tells the CARM
to push what's in the water tank back out. It gets rid of
mud—"

The hose writhed. Water sprayed out around the join.
Rather could feel the power of the water trying to tear
the hose out of his hands.

They held it, held it... and suddenly the hose bucked
loose and thrashed like a live thing. Rather dodged and
was flailing in the sky. Booce bellowed, "Enough! Jeffer,
it's full!"

They were soaked before the hose went limp. Jeffer
called cheerily from the airlock. "When do we see a
test?"

Booce looked embarrassed. "I still don't know how to
substitute for the sikenwire. We've got time—"

"Yeah. Well, we've used up too much water, one way
and another. I want to refuel the CARM. Clave, Rather,
come along. We won't be long, Booce. The rest of you
can start dinner."

The three of them returned to the CARM. Clave asked,
"What do we do for a pump?"

Jeffer was smiling. "I've thought of something.
There's a pond thirty klomters out and a little east..."

The sun wasn't much past zenith. A pinpoint diamond
blazed next to it, out and a bit west: sunlight focused
through a pond. Jeffer set the CARM moving straight out.

The out tuft ran at them and past them. The pond
wasn't far beyond, and not much bigger than the CARM.
Jeffer set the forward jets firing when they were close.
They came to a stop just in from the water globule.

Jeffer opened the airlock. He told Rather, "Get into
your wings and follow us. Bring the silver suit. We'll re-
fuel the jets."

Jeffer led them outside and around to the CARM's dor-
sal surface. Rather followed, tugging the silver suit by its

THE SMOKE RING / 131

limp wrist. There Jeffer took the suit from him. He
watched as Jeffer produced narrow hoses from under a
hatch . . .

Clave said, "Forget the suit for a while. Let Jeffer do
it. Rather, you missed something during the allergy at-
tack. What do you think happened then?"

"All I know is, you caught Jeffer at something."

Jeffer grunted. He had the hoses hooked to holes in
the suit's legs.

Clave said, "You missed your chance to see Sharls
Davis Kendy. You'll get it again in, what, half a day?"

Jeffer looked at the sun: past two o'clock, a few de-
grees out from west. "A little more than that. The thing
is, this is a secret, Rather."

"Everybody's got secrets. . . . Kendy? The
Checker?"

"Tell him, Jeffer."

Jeffer said, " Kendy's back. He pointed out the Wart
for us. He talked to me the day we rescued the Serjents.
We've talked since. I gather it costs him something,
maybe shortens his life, and he still can't reach us more
than once every two days."

Rather said, "The tales Mark and Gavving tell, Kendy
would have killed you all if he'd known you stole the
CARM."

"I don't think he could have done that," Jeffer said,
"but he might have wanted to. We stole the CARM to
get away from London Tree. We had Lawri tied to her
seat, and Mark the Silver Man too. Kendy might have
called it mutiny. You know some of this."

Rather said, "You were copsiks. They owned you. I
never understood how you could live with Lawri and
Mark after that."

Clave said, "What were we supposed to do, throw
them into the sky? They earned their citizenship. Rather.
When the air was leaking out of the CARM, Lawri found
the way to plug the leak. When Kendy was asking ques-

132 / Larry Niven

tions, Mark covered for us. We could have told Kendy   |
we were escaped copsiks, but I'm not sure how he would   |
have felt about that. Maybe Kendy's people kept cop-   ;

siks."
"Kendy."

"Yeah. He—Scientist, you understand this better than
I do."

Jeffer said, "Give me a minute." He was moving the
hoses. "Need to refuel the legs one at a time . . ."

"Stet. Now, Sharls Davis Kendy claims to be the re-
cording of a man. I don't understand that. Neither does
Lawri. We don't even know how cassettes work, really.
I wondered if he was just some madman who reached the
old starship, like we almost did, and was living aboard.
But it's been fourteen years, and he doesn't sound any
older. He wanted to know all about us. Whether we were
mutineers. Well, treefodder, we did steal the CARM, we
were mutineers, much as I hate the word."

"That's all in the past," Clave said.

"Yeah. Now he wants to see the Clump. Clave, re-
member how he talked fourteen years ago? I think he still
wants everyone in the Smoke Ring to be one big happy
tribe taking orders from Sharls Davis Kendy."

The dark pond blazed at its eastern edge. Rather won-
dered if there would be time for a swim. He was not com-
fortable in this maze of secrets. "Kendy isn't the
Chairman. We don't have to do what he says."

"No."

"Well, we want to see the Clump too. And if he can't
touch us— Why not tell the Serjents?"

"Boy's got a point," Clave said.

"You didn't tell them either."

"Maybe that was just reflex."

"Just talk to Kendy, Chairman, and then I'll point out
something."

Clave merely nodded. To Rather, he said, "One more

THE SMOKE RING / 133

thing. Kendy hears everything anyone says aboard the
CARM."

Rather laughed.

Jeffer asked, "Anything else to discuss? I think I'm
finished here. Now let's refuel the CARM. Go back in
and strap down."

"We still don't have a pump."

The Scientist's answering grin was a little mad. Clave
sighed.

Jets grumbled, then died. Rather watched a wind-rif-
fled wall of water move toward the bow window.

Clave asked, "Shouldn't you close the doors?"

Jeffer grinned and shook his head.

Clave said, "I wish to point out. Captain, that we're
going to hit that pond."

"Yeah."

The pondlet struck. Rather sagged in his straps. Clave
grunted. He asked, "Do you honestly know what you're
doing?"

"I honestly do."

Through the great window the interior of the pondlet
was open to view. A flock of tiny silver torpedoes sped
away through the murk and disappeared through the shiv-
ering silver surface.

"The CARM's hundreds of years old and nothing's
hurt it yet. Now I reduce the interior pressure." Jeffer's
fingers moved; the air system hissed; water entered the
airlock in an expanding silver bubble.

The doors closed. Water remained inside, flowing over
the aft walls, the curve of it becoming more and more
concave. Waves curled and sloshed as Jeffer turned the
CARM away from the pond.

He grinned at them. "Now I set the pressure back to
normal and turn down the humidity. That tells the CARM
to make the air dry by taking water out of it. The water




134 / Larry Niven

goes to the tank. See? We can't run out of fuel now. It's
something Lawri never thought of."

"It's treefeeding wet in here, Scientist!"

"But you don't have to pump. Next on the agenda is
Kendy. Checker, when you hear this, please introduce
yourself."

Clave asked, "What if he's not there?"

"He'll hear it when he runs the record—"

There was a face in the bow window.

Kendy was a dwarf. Rather had expected that, but he
was still taken aback. Deepset eyes examined him, judged
him, within a face like carved rock. A giant's gravelly
voice said, "Kendy for the State. Hello, Chairman Clave.
Hello, Rather the Silver Man. Scientist, your manner of
refueling the CARM is likely to destroy it. If the impact
had torn away the solar cell arrays, how would you break
up water? A CARM doesn't fly on water."

Jeffer looked nettled. Clave said, "Welcome back,
Kendy."

"Thank you, Chairman."

"Why did you hide from me?"

"I felt that Jeffer was better equipped to judge his po-
litical situation than I."

Clave bridled. "And I'm not?"

"If Jeffer had told you, he would surely have had to
tell his wife. Do you trust Lawri's judgment?"

"I give up. Between you, you . . . stet."

"I watched your nonmutiny with some interest. You're
a natural leader, Clave. You should be ruling many more
than your thirteen citizens."

"Thank you, Checker. Where do you propose I find
another thousand citizens, all of whom are inclined to
trust a tree-living outsider?"

The language was cold and stiff. Jeffer and Clave did
not trust Kendy, and Kendy clearly knew it. He said,
"You need not turn a compliment into a policy statement,
Clave. I can't force you to obey my orders. You can't

THE SMOKE RING / 135

stop me from observing through the CARM's instru-
ments. You know that I know things you do not. Can't
we work together?"

"Maybe. Thanks for showing us the Wart."
"You're welcome. Has Booce found a way to confine
the pipefire?"

"Not yet."

"Even with sikenwire, the pipefire is dangerous. You
do have a source of metal. You can make a firebox from
the Wart."

Clave grinned. "What a good idea."

"You probably don't have the facilities to make a
smelter—"

"What?"

"A smelter refines metal. It melts metal ore and bums
away impurities. You shape the metal by pouring the liq-
uid into forms. Gravity is needed, or tide, or spin. The
Admiralty may have such technology, but I gather you
do not."

"We do not. You'd set the tree on fire for sure!"

"But you do have a saw. It was moored in the cargo
section. Use it to cut slices from the Wart."

"Kendy, you'd ruin the teeth."

"No. That saw was taken from Discipline. Most of the
tools aboard Discipline were made to last. Even with triv-
ial items, the major cost was transportation. The chicken
wire must have been made in the Admiralty, but your hose
is reinforced with hullmetal alloy. The pipe is hullmetal.
So is the saw. You won't damage it by sawing slices from
a mass of soft iron. Here—"

Kendy's angular visage was replaced by a line drawing
of the steam rocket, then another line drawing: a rectangle
with tabs at its edges. "Cut three of these. Use the first
as a template—"

"How do we hold the parts together? Tethers would
bum."

"Set the plates in place and pound on the tabs until

136 / Larry Niven

they bend down. They'll fold over each other." Three
rectangular plates formed a triangular prism. The tabs
along the edges blinked green, then bent themselves over
to interlock. Logbearer reappeared, and the three-sided
box now enclosed the pipe and pipefire.

Clave said, "I'll ask Booce. You won't get much air
flow to the coals."

"Mount the rocket two or three kilometers in or out
from the center of mass. The wind will keep the coals
alight. You couldn't make a completely closed box any-
way. It will leak."

"Mmm . . . yeah. You've been thinking hard about
this."

"I can solve simple mechanical problems. What will
you do with the CARM when you reach the Clump?"

Clave was still studying the diagram. "We'll hide it
before we get there. Take the log in with the steam rocket.
Take our time selling it."

"You'll want to keep the CARM safe, but near enough
for rescue if something goes wrong. Now, the Clump is
more crowded than the Smoke Ring in general, but one
may still think of it as mostly empty space. Two thousand
people won't crowd a region the volume of the Earth's
Moon! You'll find plenty of hiding space."

"Kendy, we can't steer the CARM into the Clump and
just look around! We'd be seen!"

"I have a better view of the Clump than you do, even
if it's not a good view. If you approached from north or
south of the Clump—"

"What we'll do is take the log in, then look around
while we're selling the wood. If we find a safe way in,
we'll take it."

"Another thing you might consider," Kendy said.
"The CARM is power. There may come a time when we'll
want to use that power ..." Kendy's voice and picture
faded.

"Well, thafs that." Jeffer left his seat. He stretched

THE SMOKE RING / 137

elaborately. "Let's go out. Take some spears. We'll get
us some waterbirds before we turn back."

They moved out. Clave said, "Well?"

'Wow do you see what I mean? He wants the CARM
inside the Clump. He wants it bad. If he can get some
Admiralty citizens into the CARM, he could look them
over and question them."

"He didn't say anything unreasonable," Clave said.

"Persuasive, isn't he? All right, think about this. There
occurred an accident that allowed Chairman Clave to see
the Checker talking to the Scientist. That happened after
Kendy was sure he couldn't talk me into this."

Clave smiled. "An interesting coincidence. The
CARM has outside cameras, doesn't it?"

"Yeah. And Booce would like to be rich so that he can
give up logging. Do you think Kendy could persuade
Booce to trade the CARM to the Navy for metal?"

The smile slipped. "We'll do it your way. Rather, this
stops with us. All of it. Now shall we get us some wa-
terbirds?"

"I said that to get us outside," Jeffer said.

"Let's do it anyway."

THE SMOKE RING / 139

Chapter Eleven

Happyfeet

from the Admiralty Library, year 131 SM, day 160:

VOICE HAS SET US THE TASK OF INTEGRATING THE
DESERTERS—EXCUSE ME, WANDERERS—INTO THE AD-
MIRALTY. IT WILL CERTAINLY TAKE GENERATIONS.
EXEC WILLOUGHBY ADMITS THAT IT MAY BE IMPOSSI-
BLE, AND I'VE COME TO AGREE.

HALF A DOZEN COTTON-CANDY JUNGLES NOW TRADE
REGULARLY IN THE CLUMP, MEETING AT THE CROSS-
YEAR. THEY OBEY ADMIRALTY LAW, WHERE ADMI-
RALTY NAVY IS PRESENT TO ENFORCE IT. OUTSIDE THE
CLUMP THERE IS PIRACY AND SLAVE-TAKING. WE BE-
LIEVE THAT THE SEEKERS AND THE LUPOPF FAMILY
WERE INVOLVED IN SUCH INCIDENTS, THOUGH THEY
WERE THE FIRST TO TRADE IN THE MARKET.

WE CANNOT BRING LAW TO THIRTY EARTH-VOLUMES
OF INHABITABLE TERRITORY. THE SMOKE RING IS TOO
HUGE, AND WE ARE TOO FEW AND TOO SLOW.

—LIEUTENANT RAND CARSTER

138

BRILLIANT AS IT WAS, THE NEUTRON STAR WAS TOO

small to give much illumination. Yet the sky was never
dark, even at crossyear, when the sun at nadir had to shine
through the full thickness of the Smoke Ring's farther arc.
One must seek darkness in a cloud or a jungle or a tree
tuft, or in the unoccupied depths of the Clump.

Now the sun was dead east, somewhere behind the
slowly roiling blotch that was their destination. It was
gloomy in the shadow of the Clump. Masses near the
white-fringed black mass seemed to blaze in contrast.

"We're better than halfway home," Booce said.
"Debby, I've been looking for more pod plants. The last
thing I ever wanted was to come home with a pod for my
cabin, but we don't have time to build real cabins."

"The rocket's finished otherwise?"

"Yes."

"Good." Debby had been working hard. Her tunic was
off and her pale skin glistened with sweat. "Now, how
do we make it work?"

"Trade secret."

Debby regarded Booce angrily. "We built the tree-
feeding thing. You won't tell us how to make it go?"

"Classified, Debby."

"Will you tell us how to make it stop? In an emergency,
if you and Carlot aren't in reach, how do I stop it from
just burning up?"

"We'll get an extra pod and fill it with water to pour
on the pipefire—"

"Very good! Now, suppose you and Carlot both fall
off the tree and lose your wings and we've got to come
after you. Suppose you left the rocket going. What do I
want to do?"

Booce found her persistence disturbing. "Use the
CARM, I suppose—"

"TheCARMisgone."

"They're only refueling it."

"It could be gone again!"




140 / Larry Niven

"Then use your wings. Don't try to use the rocket.
That's dangerous."

Debby glared and was silent. She was Booce's height
and almost Booce's age, marked by a dangerous and ex-
otic beauty. Pale-brown skin, pale straight hair, fiery blue
eyes; a face all planes and angles, with a nose like an axe
head. She was the type of woman who would remake a
man, who would run his life for him. As Ryllin was. And
Ryllin was far away . . . and ifBooce carried that thought
further, Ryllin would know somehow, and Booce would
regret it greatly. Booce looked at the sky to escape Deb-
by's eyes.

He'd been watching the sky for days now. They were
closing on the Clump. Matter would be thicker here, even
this far in: more ponds, plant life, animals, predators, per-
haps Navy craft or wandering happyfeet.

West of out, almost behind the log's remaining tuft, he
found paired bright and dark dots: the pond and the
CARM. No sign of pod plants. Would they have to cut
wood from the out branch after all? Branchwood was bet-
ter ... but it was hard work, and the cabins would be
crude.

Debby was still fuming. "You know, arguing isn't the
thing I do best. But Clave is going to have this out of
you, because it's stupid not to tell us how to use the
basic logger's tool. Won't the Admiralty expect us to
know—?"

"No. You're hired labor."

"Right. I forgot."

The days went fast this close to Voy: nine days be-
tween waking and waking. North and west, the reddish
fringe of the Clump's shadow was sliding rapidly down a
tremendous wall of cloud. Storm and lightning inside, and
ponds forming. . . The line of sunlight picked out a green
dot, a drifting jungle emerging from the fringes of the
storm.

THE SMOKE RING / 141

Carlot suddenly asked, "Debby, should we know how
to use the CARM?"

"Yes. Yes, we should know how to run the CARM!
Treefeeding fools they are, Lawri and Jeffer both."

Booce was jolted. "Debby? You can't fly the
CARM?"

"Nobody knows but the Scientists. Classified. Lawri
I can understand. But Jeffer, he stole the thing himself,
and now he acts just like her! Fifteen years, almost!"

"Dad? She's right. We should all of us know all of that,
and we have to start somewhere."

Booce sighed. Crossyear child! Playing around with a
dwarf tree dweller ... but the women always won the
arguments. "Debby, as far as any Admiralty citizen is
concerned, you know nothing about how a rocket works.
Understand?"

"Yes, Logger Booce. Now, what is it you loggers have
been concealing from us laborers?"

"Go ahead, Carlot."

Carlot considered before she spoke. "All right. Just
the way you taught me. Debby, you'll have to imagine
the sikenwire in a tube around the pipe. I stuff firebark
inside and light it."

Debby nodded.

"The coals are just along the middle of the pipe, not
too close to the ends. I wait. I want the metal to get hot.
It should glow red. Hotter than that, the nozzle starts to
char. That's bad. So I run water through the pipe. The
metal stays dark red, and steam comes out the nozzle.
You can't see it where it comes out, but it can flay the
flesh from your bones, so stay clear."

Her father smiled, nodding approval. He'd taught her
well.

"Now, how do I move the water into the pipe?"

Debby mulled it. "No tide—"

"How do I keep outsiders from watching me do it?"

Debby brightened. She kicked herself to the fore end

142 / Larry Niven

of the water tank. "I'm here, right? There's a cabin, and
I'm in it. And here's the plug ..."

"Just so!" Cariot joined her. "You pull the plug. You
blow in it. When the water spurts back at you, you slam
the plug in quick."

"I could get a lungful of water that way."

"Sure you could. We've all done our share of choking.
Father taught us this so he wouldn't have to do it him-
self."

"Why does it blow back?"

"I ... Dad?"

Booce said, "The steam pushes both ways. Out the
nozzle, and backward too. That churns the water so more
water comes down the pipe. After the rocket settles down,
it's thrust that pulls the water through. The back-pressure
holds it from going in too fast. You can let the rocket run
till the water's almost gone."

Cariot said, "You've got to let the pipefire die before
the tank's empty. Otherwise you'll char the nozzle and
the tank both. It's a mess if you have to throw water on
a pipefire."

The storm was definitely reaching out to enfold the tree
. . . and the jungle was closer too. Booce pointed. "Car-
lot—"

Cariot looked. "Happyfeet?"

"Maybe. Debby, what have we got for weapons?"

"Harpoons. The rocket, I guess."

"Not enough. All right, ladies. Maybe it's just a loose
jungle, and even if it's happyfeet they may not have no-
ticed anything, but I think we should hide."

"Hide?" Debby was outraged. "Booce, that's not
much of a jungle. Carther States was twenty times that
size."

The jungle was closer now, a fuzzy green ellipsoid with
a shadowy slit in it, as if foliage had been shorn away to
form a window into the interior. Booce said, "A jungle
that size can hold a family of twenty or thirty. Debby, a

THE SMOKE RING / 143

tree is big. We can vanish into cracks in the bark and
never be seen. I ... think we've got time. Help me take
the rocket apart."

"Booce, it was tough enough putting it together!"

"You think I like this?" But Booce and Cariot were
already tugging at pipe and nozzle, and Debby perforce
joined them.

"The pipe is ... priceless. We ... can't let happyfeet
... get it." Booce gasped in the thin air. The nozzle
jerked loose and tumbled along the bark with Booce
wrapped around it. His voice drifted back. "The rest they
can have. We'll hide the pipe in some crack and guard it.
Now we really won't have time to make cabins."

They pulled loose the pipe and water tank. The green
puffball was closer yet, and a line of vapor trailed behind
it. The vapor trail became a curve . . .

Debby said, "It's dropped five men. Winged. Now it's
going away."

Nozzle and tank floated, slowly rotating. Now Booce
was free to look. "They're making for the Wart."

"We can't let them have it!" Debby cried.

"Well, the truth is, we can," Booce said. He was push-
ing the pipe ahead of him, kicking hard. Cariot and Debby
flew to help. "Maybe the CARM can take it back for us.
If not ... we don't need the Wart to reach the Clump.
Those five that were dropped are after us."

. The log was far east, drifting in the fringe of a storm
complex. Rather found it before Jeffer did: shadow backlit
by the sun.

Jeffer chased it down. The CARM arced over the top
of the out tuft, moved in along the east side of the trunk.
The dock came into view: a rectangle of bare wood, rag-
ged around the edges. Rather felt the pull of the forward
jets and heard pondwater slosh toward him. Water had
spread along the CARM's walls and was creeping for-
ward.

144 / Larry Niven

He wasn't actually getting used to this, was he?

"Where's the rocket?" Clave sounded merely puzzled.

Where they had built the rocket, there was nothing.
Wait . . . there, drifting loose, a pale-brown bell shape:

the nozzle. There, some distance away, a brown ellipsoid
trailing lines. Where was Carlot? Where was anyone?

"What happened here?" Clave demanded. "An ex-
plosion?"

Had there been a fire? Rather found only the small
black scar of the cookfire. The arrangements around it
were undisturbed.

Jeffer said, "We can't search the whole tree. Where's
the sun?'' Straight east.' 'We won't get Kendy for another
day."

"Take us in," Rather said.

Jeffer looked at him. "Why?"

"Just a guess." Carlot had gone in, last sleep.

Jeffer swung the CARM toward Voy and fired the jets.
They skimmed above the bark. The fog was around them
now.

Jeffer played with the controls. "There," he said sud-
denly. "Five men." But what showed in the window was
an abstraction, orange blobs on red-and-black.

"We're seeing by heat," Jeffer said. For an instant the
normal view returned: fog sliding along black bark. Then
the red-and-black was back. "Didn't Booce say some-
thing about happyfeet?"

"Find our people," said Clave.

"Mmm . . . there." Three orange blobs in a line. By
normal light they became three human shapes lined along
a crack. "And the rocket pipe, I think. Rather?"

Rather quickly disengaged his seat belt and moved aft.
He pulled the silver suit out of the water and slid his legs
inside. Clave said, "Good. Get the rest of it on and go
join the others. Take some harpoons. They won't have
weapons. Jeffer, how did they get here?"

"Good question. I don't see anything that could have

THE SMOKE RING / 145

brought them. Something could be around the other side
of the bark."

Rather waited while Clave bound six harpoons against
the silver suit's chest. Air on; voice on. "Can you hear
me?"

His voice blurted from the control panel, and Jeffer
jumped. "I hear you fine."

"Let me out."

The bark was half a klomter distant. Rather used his
jets. He thrilled to the pull of thrust along his body: blood
leaving his head, abdomen settling toward his feet. Not
quite a comfortable sensation, but one few others could
share.

Behind him, the CARM accelerated south around the
curve of the trunk and was gone.

Carlot and the others had seen the CARM; they waved.

Two klomters toward the blue blur of Voy, a hundred
meters out from the tree, green-clad men emerged from
the fog. They flew along the bark, peering into cracks as
they passed. At this distance Rather could see only that
they were five jungle giants, and armed.

They saw him. Their legs stopped moving, though their
motion continued. Closer now. One was a woman . . .

Then they were kicking again, turning back toward the
storm that was reaching to engulf the tree.

He could catch them. They couldn't know about the
silver suit. His tanks were full. Rather fired his boot jets;

his course became an arc.

He could catch them. Then what? Kill them? Rather's
parents had both killed. They didn't like talking about it.
When they did, old anger distorted their faces. Yet this
was the Silver Man's duty: from time to time, he killed.

One of the intruders looked back, and then all five were
kicking madly, doubling their speed.

His arms were full of harpoons, hampered, while
Debby and Carlot and Booce had no weapons at all.
Rather swung back toward his crew.

146 / Larry Niven

He thumped into the bark not far from Booce. Carlot
was looking at him oddly. He opened his helmet and said,
"It's me. Five of them almost found you. What hap-
pened?"

"Happyfeet," Booce said. "A small jungle, steam-
powered. Lupoff family, from the look of them. They
want the Wart."

Rather thumbed his personal Voice on. "Silver Man
calling the Scientist. Jeffer, they want the Wart. Go for
that."

Nothing.

"They can't hear me. Booce, I'll guard you on the
surface, but I don't think they'll be back. They looked
like they were running."

Booce grinned. "They thought you were Navy."

"What?"

"Skip it."

Rather settled himself on the bark above their heads.
Helmet closed. The invulnerable warrior (and Carlot had
looked at him as at some alien bird). But the happyfeet
warriors were gone from sight.

The storm enclosed the tree. The fringe of it was a fine
mist, just beginning to obscure vision. / wish I could use
those other kinds of light Kendy sees by. And the ventral
camera's almost blind . . . hydrogen low, oxygen low,
water volume low but increasing. We should have built a
pump by now. Hey— "What's that?"

Clave looked. "Jungle. Small. Just opposite the
Wart."

Now Jeffer spotted green dots around the puckered
bark. Men, and one was pointing toward the CARM.

The voice of Kendy startled him. "I'm scanning in in-
frared. I can't see anything human outside of the Wart
area. Take the CARM closer. Give me a view."

Jeffer accelerated in. He asked, "Did you just come
into range?"

THE SMOKE RING / 147

"Yes. I'm running the record of your approach. You
should have killed the invaders on the east side. They
could attack your people."

As the CARM approached, the jungle jetted away on
a trail of steam: north into the storm, then around the
trunk, steam spraying in a wide curve. It was hidden be-
fore the CARM arrived.

Jeffer brought the CARM to rest a quarter klomter
from the wooden crater. The happyfeet had been digging
around one side of the Wart. Elongated men hovered
around the block of black metal.

"Ten," said Kendy. Rings of red light blinked scien-
tifically on the bark, haloing men Jeffer had already spot-
ted, pointing out others. Three interlocked rings circled
bare wood. "Four in the open, three between the bark
and the Wart, three more in a crack outside the crater."

"We'd better follow the jungle," Clave said. "They
could find the rest of us while we're busy here."

Jeffer turned in his seat, but Kendy spoke first.
"There's time."

"They're too many to fight anyway," Clave said.

"Nonsense. Spray them with rocket exhaust. Jeffer,
have you been shown the throttle for the main drive?"

"Yes." Jeffer didn't know the word throttle, but Lawri
had shown him how to control the push of the rockets.
His fingers danced.

The CARM moved toward the Wart. The happyfeet
waited, blurred by fog, spears ready. "Brace yourself,
Clave." The CARM swung around, still approaching the
puckered bark, but stem foremost.

Men left the Wart, swimming hard. Others appeared
from the bark beyond. Spears flew. The dorsal camera
watched a bulbous-headed spear strike the hull and ex-
plode in a puff of smoky flame. Authoritative thumps
could be heard through the hull.

Jeffer tapped the main drive on..

It felt like suicide. He'd nearly died the last time he




148 / Larry Niven

did that. The CARM surged forward. Jeffer felt his chest
sag, his cheeks pull backward in a dead man's grin. But
his arm was rigid above his face, fingers almost touching
the control panel.

It worked! Moving his fingertip down along the green
bar reduced the main drive's thrust to something he could
handle. Throttle.

A nearly invisible blue washed across ten happyfeet
warriors. The invaders burst into vivid yellow flame.
They were comets, the flame streaming back from them.
Explosions sent bits of men flying—

Clave cried, "Treefodder, Jeffer! Stop!"

Jeffer tapped the drive off. (Hydrogen, oxygen: both
quite low. The Wart receded.) "Clave, they attacked us.
They've got exploding harpoons."

"They couldn't have moved the Wart with us on then-
tails! We only had to take it away from them!"

"All right. Chairman." Jeffer turned to look at Clave.
"Now tell me what they're doing to Booce and Debby
and Carlot."

"It's time to leam that," Kendy said. "Time to move,
Jeffer. I've lost sight of the jungle from Discipline's po-
sition. It circled half around the trunk and was approach-
ing the point where you dropped Rather. We'll have to
get there fast, before I'm out of range. The invaders here
are harmless enough now."

They were. Some were still writhing, some were mo-
tionless, but all were burned black. Jeffer set the CARM
moving. It was too early to feel guilt.

They were in the cloud now: a thick, swirling fog,
growing thicker. Jeffer could see the tree only as a wall
of shadow. Kendy said, "Turn starboard. You need not
steer so wide of the trunk, Jeffer. I have infrared."

The CARM moved around the trunk in a great curve.
Lightning flared suddenly aft.

THE SMOKE RING / 149

"I have the jungle in view, straight out by five point
six kilometers. Straight out, Jeffer."

"I can't see."

"Ventral. Two degrees more. Good. Accelerate. Cut!
Rather has the jungle in view. Silver Man, come in."

Rather's tinny voice spoke from the control board. "I
see a big shadow, but no detail. They can't see us either."

"They've found you somehow," Jeffer said.

"You're near," said Kendy. "Swing one-eighty de-
grees."

"I won't—"

"Citizen, I don't know where the men are! What else
can we do but attack the jungle itself? Swing around."
There was something strange in Kendy's voice.

Jeffer turned the CARM. He half hoped Clave would
countermand the order, but Clave said nothing.

"Main drive." Kendy should have sounded excited.
He only sounded loud.

Jeffer tapped the button. The CARM surged. His face
tried to crawl around to the back of his head. A yellow
light bloomed in the mist behind him, and he heard Rath-
er's gasp. He killed the drive, but the yellow light re-
mained.

The harsh bass said, "Done. I'm losing range—"

Clave said, "You kill too easily, Kendy."

Kendy's voice was becoming blurry. "Citizens, you're
missing the point. This was a mobile jungle. These hap-
pyfeet may have contacts in the Admiralty. They've seen
the CARM and the silver suit."

"Men aren't honey hornets, Kendy!"

There was no answer.

Rain drifted across the CARM's main window in drops
the size of fists, carried by eddies in the wind. The wood
outside was black with water. Inside the cabin it was
soggy enough. Jeffer's segment of pond had spread a film
of water across all the walls and the cradles.

150 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 151

Warm, dry air blew from vents fore and aft, thrusting
the water away from it. The citizens clustered around the
aft jet.

Next time I'll pump the water, Jeffer thought. Got to
build a pump.

Carlot said, "We saw that huge shadow come out of
the fog. It was scary enough. Then five . . . well, they
could have been birds for all I could see, except that they
were flying toward the jungle and thrashing at both ends.
Waving their arms, I guess. It was the bandits who ran
away from Rather. The jungle stopped to pick them up."

"They were Lupoffs," Booce said. "I know their
clothing. I've met them in the Market. A big family, three
jungles, and they'd colonize if they could buy another
firepipe. They're crowded."

Clave said, "So?"

"If the Lupoffs find out what happened here, you'll
have two jungles hunting you."

"They won't find out." There was no triumph in
Clave's voice. Jeffer shuddered.

They were warm enough, dry enough, if they stayed
in the air jet. But the storm splashed rain across the bow
window, and through the rain came the yellow glow of
the burning jungle.

"I wouldn't mind killing a bandit or two," Booce said.
"I've been robbed once or twice. It's the scale of the thing
that bothers me. There must have been forty citizens in
that jungle, not counting children."

Clave jumped toward the fore end of the cabin. After
a moment, Jeffer followed. The fore air jet was as dry as
the aft.

Clave said, "I'd had enough of that."

"Forty people," Jeffer said. "There just isn't any way
to make them stop talking about it."

Clave's voice was'a hoarse whisper. "Persuasive, is
he? Nobody but you can be trusted to talk to Kendy,

right? You burned them while they were trying to rescue
their citizens!"

"They attacked us."

"With spears. So?"

"What was I supposed to do? They were threatening
our citizens!"

Clave sighed. "I'm not blaming you. And if I am, I
shouldn't be. But Kendy—" By the flick of his eyes,
Clave had remembered that Kendy would hear this. He
began pronouncing his words with more care. "Tree-
feeding Kendy killed them like a hive of honey hornets,
because they were in his way. Because they might talk
to the wrong people!"

Silence and discomfort. Debby came to join them.
"Wet," she said. "What did you do to get it so wet?"

Jeffer didn't answer. To Clave he said, "I felt much
worse when I killed Klance the Scientist to steal the
CARM. He wasn't expecting it. These citizens were.
They were making war."

"Right!" Debby said enthusiastically. "When London
Tree raided us, I used to wish we could capture this thing
and set their whole tree burning. The bandits aren't the
same, but by the State, we finally did it!"

"Don't do it again," Clave said. Jeffer nodded.




Section Three

CIVILIZATION

Chapter Twelve

Customs

Year 384, day 1992, by heliograph:

STATION TWO TO GYRFALCON. SWALLOW REPORTS
LARGE INCOMING LOG EAST OF ADMIRALTY. MASTER
UNIDENTIFIED. YOU WILL RENDEZVOUS FOR CUSTOMS
DUTY IF CONVENIENT. LOCATION OF LOG AT DAY 1990
WAS TWO-NINE-OH DEGREES FLAT, FIVE DEGREES
NORTH, TWO-EIGHT-OH KLOMTERS RADIAL. ACKNOWL-
EDGE.

"RICE, DID THIS JUST COME IN?"

"Yes, sir. I was scraping the hull when I saw the light
blinking near the Market. Took the message and came
straight in, but I don't know how long the helio was blink-
ing."

Petty Mart Wheeler thought it through. Gyr falcon car-
ried six crew; Swallow, two. The Navy preferred that ci-
155

156 / Larry Niven

vilians notice the big armed ships. In the act of paying
customs they should remember what they were buying
So.

"Where are we?"

"I'll find out, sir." Spacer Rice turned toward the in-
strument closet.

"No, not you. Bosun Murphy, take our position." This
was not an urgent mission. He'd use it as a training ex-
ercise.

The dwarf nodded cheerfully; her flame-red hair
swirled around her. Her short but powerful legs shot her
across the cabin to the instrument closet. She chose what
she needed and went out.

The long hair would have to go when she reached
higher rank. Pity. But dwarves were rare, and Bosun Sec-
try Murphy must be trained quickly . . .

Through the hatch Wheeler could see a blue light, tiny
and intense: a Navy heliograph, reflected Voy-light blink-
ing near the east limb of the whorl. Red hair and a squarish
feminine face suddenly blocked the view. "Petty, we're
at two-sixty-five flat, six south, two-forty klomters."

"And we've got better than half a tank, right?" Mur-
phy nodded. "Get on the heliograph. We'll rendezvous
with the log. Jimson, Rice, get us ready for a bum."

The thick, disordered sky made Rather dizzy. If he fell
into that he would be more than ordinarily lost. He
climbed with care. Clave and Debby trailed him.

There had been hard work followed by a long climb.
They were all tired. Rather's fingers and toes were start-
ing to cramp. But the rocket was in sight, a hundred me-
ters out ... if that direction was still out.

The log was rising through the Clump's eastern fringes.
Wind slapped at Rather from ambush, here, there, every-
where, as if he were embedded in a flock of terrified tur-
keys. Clouds ran in peculiar directions, not east-west, not
flattened spirals, but shallow in-out curves. A line of small

THE SMOKE RING / 157

green puff jungles flowed in an arc that was not tidelike
at all. Confronted by such strangeness, Rather's bewil-
dered eyes sought the one unchanging reference point.

Voy burned blue-white and steady . . . twenty-five de-
grees east of the stump of the in tuft! Choppy clouds
blurred the sun. Shadows pulsed, blurring and sharpen-
ing. Overlaid on those, Voy's faint, sharp blue shadows
lay in skew directions. Children learned not to see Voy-
shadows. Voy-shadows told nothing, for they never
moved, never changed, never distracted the eye.

The tree had turned; the trunk was pointing wrong.

Booce and Carlot waited at the rocket. Debby called,
"Booce! How can you stand it?"

"The tide? I grew up in it. You'll get used to it. The
happyfeet do."

"The shadows are making me sick to my stomach,"
Debby said.

Rather's own stomach was queasy. "Carlot—"

"We're almost home." There was no mistaking her
joy. She liked it here. "Look, we've got the pipefire
going."

"I'll start the water." A smaller pod had been carved
into Logbearer's new cabin. Booce crawled inside.
"Tether yourselves."

The rocket cone pointed east. Rather poked his nose
into the small hatch. "Booce, are you slowing us again?"

Booce's voice echoed. "What? No, tide's different in
the Clump. We'll push west, straight toward the Dark."
He pulled a wooden plug from the water tank. He inhaled,
put his lips to the hole, and blew,

Rather withdrew his head to watch the completed
rocket in action. Yellow-white coals glowed within the
iron firebox that had given them so much trouble. The
iron glowed dull red. A fourth pod nearby was filled with
water in case the plates didn't hold together.

At the nozzle end of the rocket— "Nothing's happen-
ing."

158 / Larry Niven

His answer was the sound of Booce inflating his lungs.
Then the rocket went Chuff! and sprayed steam.

"It's going, Booce," Rather said, and looked in.

Booce's face dripped with water. He was coughing and
choking while he pounded the plug in with the heel of his
hand. His glare was murderous.

CHUFF, CHUFF, Chuff chuffchuffchuff ... The
rocket settled down. A row of cloud-puffs became a
steady stream jogged by the play of capricious wind.
Rather felt no acceleration. It would be gentle, with so
great a mass to be moved.

Carlot came up behind him; her long fingers found his
hand and enclosed it. "Father? Shouldn't we—"

Booce sounded like his throat was still full of water.
"Yes, go play lookout on the west face, you two. Watch
for Navy and anything we might hit."

The maelstrom revealed itself to them as they circled
the trunk. Flying was a continuing wonder to Rather, but
Carlot did it better. She kept darting ahead, then circled
to urge him on. At a vantage point on the west face they
doffed their wings and rested.

The Clump was a whorl like a tremendous fingerprint.
Inward, matter thickened. There were puzzle trees, dis-
torted cotton-candy jungles, the much smaller puffballs
that Carlot had pointed out for him ("fisher jungles"),
and greenery that was totally unfamiliar. Ponds took odd
shapes in the distorted tide. The sky was thick with birds:

skyhorses, triunes, and a thousand tiny red and yellow
darts converging on a puff jungle. Everything moved in
arcs, tighter near the center of the whorl, and darker. The
center itself was almost black, but motion could still be
seen there.

The triune families were hard to spot, but two had
turned to observe the passing log. They were fat sky-blue
cigar-shapes with wide triple fins: male and female and
child, linked along their bellies. Three slender blue shapes

THE SMOKE RING / 159

flashed violent-orange bellies as they converged on the
red-and-yellow bird-swarm: another triune family, sepa-
rated to hunt.

A thin stream of cloud cut across other patterns of
cloud-flow. Rather spotted it in the moment before Carlot
pointed. "There. Navy."

"How do you know?" Rather saw only a dark point
at the end of the line of cloud.

"It's coming toward us. Customs. They'll make a bum
and intercept us in a day. Oh, treefodder."

Rather laughed. She'd borrowed his curse. "What?"

She showed him.

Far in toward the Clump's dark center, in the thick of
moving matter, was a broad, flat ring-shape with a pebbly
inner surface . . . angular structures in pastel colors . . .
blatantly artificial. Could it really be as big as it looked?

He judged its size by an even larger natural object
nearby: a tree with one tuft missing. The log was smaller
than their own, Rather thought. At its midpoint he could
make out a rocket-shape, cone and tank and angular
cabin.

Carlot said, "I know that rocket. Woodsman. Dad
won't like this. They could just as easily have been out
another damn year." She looked into his eyes. "We won't
have much time together. The Belmy family owns Woods-
man. Dad wants to marry me to Raff Belmy."

"Will you do it?"

"Shut up." She pulled him against her by the slack of
his tunic. "I don't want to think about it. Just don't talk,"
she breathed into his ear, and he obeyed. It crossed his
mind that Booce should be told of these things. But there
would be time ...

Gyr falcon found the log easily: bigger than average,
with both tufts severed. It was making its burn: a wavery
line of cloud behind it was beginning to arc over. The
rocket would be behind the trunk.

160 / Larry Niven

"Instruments," Wheeler instructed. "Rice, get us a
rendezvous track. Murphy, the neudar. That dark blemish
in the wood—"

"I see it, sir."

He waited and watched. His crew moved well, Bosun
Murphy in particular. She hadn't yet used the neudar
under field circumstances. She moved slowly, but without
mistakes. That would reflect well on Wheeler.

"The blemish is dense. Metal," she said. "Kilotons."

"Now the rocket."

"I can't see anything—"

"Behind the midpoint."

"Oh! I can look through the wood!" She tried it.
"Mmm . . . something . . . metal, not much. Our own
iron rocket nozzle would show a mark like that."

"Rice?"

"We need a bum, Petty. Fifty degrees planar, zero
axial, a hundred breaths of bum and we'll go just past."

"Give us the bum, then all hands suit up. Spacer Rice,
you're in the cabin, on instruments. Murphy, on the
pump."

Gyrfalcon carried a glass alcohol tank and a pair of
water tanks. Its valve system had been rifled from the
hulk of an ancient Cargo and Repair Module. On long
voyages, standard practice was to spray water into the
alcohol flame as working mass. Water could be replaced
in domains beyond the Admiralty's reach. Alcohol gen-
erally could not, though some of the happyfeet tribes car-
ried alcohol distilleries for trade with the Admiralty.

Wheeler and Jimson tethered themselves carefully at
the steering platform above the motor. Murphy began to
pedal. Pedals could be extended, but a dwarf on the bi-
cycle always delivered more power. Wheeler put his hand
in the airflow to test it, then started the alcohol flame. He
checked his crew's handholds before he increased the
flow.

Thrust pulled at his skin and his bones. He ran water

THE SMOKE RING / 161

into the flame. Thrust rose again, and heat bathed the

inner surfaces of his straining legs.

Rice called down from the cabin. "Cut it!"
Petty Wheeler reached below his feet for the alcohol

valve. The roar died to a hiss: water on a hot surface.

Next, the water valve. Gyrfalcon fell free.

The log was nearer; the plume of acceleration was

gone. Using the binoculars, Wheeler found a pair of

human shapes on the near side.

"They're not giving us much attention," he said.
Murphy took the binoculars. Presently she said,

"They'll have time." She looked until he took them away.

The Navy ship was bigger and more elaborate than
Logbearer. It arrived in a wave of warm steam and paused
a hundred meters from the center of the midtrunk. Four
men emerged and flew toward them.

Logbearer's crew waited outside the cabin.

"They're fast," Debby said.

Booce chuckled .."Never try to outfly the Navy. Navy
wings are different, and the men are picked for their legs."

They were closer now. Rather suddenly gripped
Booce's arm. "Booce, they're wearing silver suits!"

"A/i/ Rather—"

Rather eased his grip. "Sorry."

"Well, watch that. It's only Navy armor."

"But it looks—"

"Just armor. There are three vac suits in the Admi-
ralty, and we aren't important enough to see one. Inci-
dentally, they'd love to make it four."

Closer yet. The armor didn't cover them. All wore hel-
mets: head-and-shoulder pieces with an opening for the
face. Some wore additional plates. And one was a dwarf.

Their wings! They pointed a little forward, as the foot
did; they folded on the forward kick and snapped open
on the back-kick. The Scientist should see this. Rather
thought.

162 / Larry Niven

They left their wings on even after they touched bark.

The dwarf was a woman. Red hair showed around the
helmet before she lifted it. Pale skin, pointed nose, and
pointed chin; hair like flame streaming from a tree afire.
Her chest plate stood several ce'meters out from her
chest. She was five or six years older than Rather, quite
lovely, and Rather's height.

She caught him looking and smiled at him. He forgot
that he could move. Her eyes were blue, and they danced.

He was blushing, and Carlot had caught it, and Rather
looked away in haste. And watched a long, long man kick-
ing toward them.

The globe helmet was much larger than his head, with
an opening for his face . . . like the silver suit's helmet
with the faceplate missing. Separate curved pieces pro-
tected his thighs, back, upper arms, and hips. Those were
wood painted in silver; but the head-and-shoulder piece
was of hammered metal. Wide nose, dark skin, black
cushion of hair: he might have been part of Booce's fam-
ily.

He recognized Booce (and ignored his crew). "Booce
Serjent? You may remember me: Petty Wheeler. Wel-
come home."

"Good to see you again, Petty. You'll remember Car-
lot—"

She smiled brilliantly. "Good day, Petty Wheeler."

"Oh, yes. You've grown, Carlot."

Booce said, "These others are Clave and Rather Cit-
izen, from Citizens Tree, a few hundred klomters west of
us. Debby Carther we hired before we left."

Meeting strangers was outside Rather's experience.
Booce had told him what to do. He said, "A pleasure to
meet you, sir," and held out his hand.

"Pleased." The Navy man's handshake was strong for
a jungle giant. "I'll speak to you later. Rather. Clave,
Debby, a pleasure. Booce, do you have anything to de-
clare?"

THE SMOKE RING / 163

"Yes. One log, forty klomters or thereabouts. If you
want to measure it yourselves—"

"No, we'll just take half the manifests as you sell it
off."

"And the Wart," Booce said complacently. "Our one
bit of luck, and a happyfeet tribe almost made off with
it."

"That mucking great chunk of metal halfway in?"

"Heh. You've found it already? We haven't measured
that either, but it's thousands of tons. Petty, we'd like the
Wart classified. We won't get so many thieves that way."

"All right, but if happyfeet attacked you—"

"I don't want to file charges. They got away, but we
hurt them, and I don't want them to know who. They
might want to come after us with friends."

"That attitude makes life difficult for the Navy, Booce.
We'd rather chase them down. You're sure?... All right.
We'll want our taxes in metal."

"Fine. I want to keep that makeshift firebox until I can
buy more sikenwire. It's not pretty, but it works. Barring
that, I'll sell the entire lode to the Navy right now, if you
can tear it out and tow it home. Take it off my hands,"
Booce said.

Rather couldn't help himself: he stared. But what if he
takes you up on it?

Petty Wheeler laughed. "I don't have alcohol to tow
it, and I can't authorize that kind of expenditure. But we'll
inspect it now, and I'll send a team to cut our share loose
after you're moored.''

Petty Wheeler's crew began searching Log bearer in-
side and out. Rather's momentary impulse was to stop
them. But Booce showed no surprise . . . and of course
there was nothing aboard Logbearer to be found. Mean-
while the Navy officer turned to Rather and said,
"Rather, wasn't it? You should consider joining the
Navy."

"Why?"

164 / Larry Niven

The man smiled. "The pay is good, particularly for a
tree dweller, if you can get in. We'll shape you up and
teach you things you should know, like how to win a fight.
You'll be holding civilization together. The personal ad-
vantage is, you're the right shape. You noticed Bosun
Sectry Murphy? Short, with red hair—"

"Yes?"

"She'll be wearing a vac suit within six years. Guard-
ian is the highest rank there is, unless you were born an
officer. You could do the same."

"I'll have to think about it."

"Talk to her yourself. Ask Booce, for that matter.
Booce, we'll fly down and inspect your Wart. Would you
like to ride with us?"

"I'd be delighted." Booce looked around at his crew
and added, "We'd all be delighted."

Gyifalcon's hull sported handholds everywhere. The
Navy men spaced Logbearer's people high along one
flank. There were shelves for feet and straps to circle a
waist (or just under the armpits on Rather). "Fighting
vessel," Clave whispered to Debby. "They can cover the
hull with archers."

Three Navy worked aft, around the motor. They ig-
nored the civilians.

Something green was trying to grow on the wooden
hull. Fluff, maybe. The wood had been scraped recently.
Rather noticed that much before the rocket fired.

If Wheeler was trying to impress a barbarian dwarf, he
succeeded. The rocket roared and spat flame. Rather felt
his blood settling into his legs. The log's rough bark surged
past, accelerating. Aft, Wheeler and Murphy used toothed
gears to point the nozzle. In a way it was more impressive
than the CARM. You could see how it all worked.

The roar of the motor would cover his voice (and the
fear in it). Rather asked, "Why don't they let us inside?"

"Classified. Nobody knows what's in a Navy ship,"

THE SMOKE RING / 165

Cariot said. "We haven't seen the whole crew, I'm sure
of that. Rather, I noticed you staring at the, um, red-
haired woman?"

Rather told a half-truth. "She looks short. I mean, it's
surprising, because she's the same size I am. Mark never
looked short."

Cariot seemed to relax. "Well, no. He was bigger than
you when you were growing up."

Wheeler moved the nozzle ten degrees to port. The
ship slewed around, spraying flame. He swiveled the noz-
zle starboard; the rotation slowed and stopped, and Gyr-
falcon decelerated. It eased to a stop less than a hundred
meters from the blister in the trunk.

"The bandits almost had it torn loose," Wheeler ob-
served.

Booce nodded.

The same four Navy personnel accompanied them to
the Wart. Three set to examining the blister that had
grown up around the metal and the matchet-chewed wood
that extended far back behind it. The fourth sought out
Rather. "Petty Wheeler said you might have questions to
ask me," said Bosun Murphy.

Rather was not really thinking of joining the Navy. He
didn't say so. "I don't know enough to ask good ques-
tions."

She smiled enchantingly. "Ask bad ones. I don't
mind."

"What are the vac suits? Why are they important?"

"They're old science, as old as the Library. They're
invulnerable," she said. "The highest fighting rank is
Guardian, and that's the rank that wears the vac suits.
There are supposed to be nine Guardians. We've got
eight. This—" She rapped her helmet, then the plates on
her thighs. "—It looks like this, but all over. You'll get
as high as Petty just because you're the right shape, and
then you find out if you actually fit into a vac suit."

"Do you?"




166 / Larry Niven

"I don't know. I haven't got that far yet." She looked
. down at her protruding chestplate unhappily. "Maybe I
won't fit. I'd still keep my rank as Petty. Understand, you
have to be qualified, you have to be trained. It's just easier
if you're the right size."
"Training. What's it like?"

"They'll put you through exercises. You may think
you're strong—you're a tree dweller? I can see the mus-
cles. But Petty Wheeler could tie you in knots. After
you've been through training you could tie him in knots.
I could, I think, and you're stronger. Your people, do they
use polar coordinates to find themselves?"

"No."

"They'll teach you how to find yourself in the sky.
You'll learn how to count, if you don't know—"

"I can count."

"You'll learn how to work a rocket, not a steam rocket
but a Navy rocket. They teach you how to obey too. You
want to go in braced for that, Rather. A superior officer
tells you to fly, you fly, wings or no."

It sounded unpleasant. "Where do the Navy ships
go?"

"Mmm . . . Where do you come from?"

"Citizens Tree. A little west of the Clump."

"You're not likely to visit your family. We don't see
many tree dwellers. We send ships outside the Clump,
but not often, and never more than a few thousand klom-
ters. Mostly we cruise the Clump itself. We collect taxes,
of course—"

"Yeah."

"We fight the wildlife. Dark sharks and other things.
Citizens find a drillbit nest, or honey hornets, they call
us and we burn it out."

"Triunes too?"

"Oh, no, the triunes got the idea fast. They never at-
tack us. Some of them like us. There's a guy, Exec Mar-

THE SMOKE RING / 167

tin, he hunts swordbirds with triunes. Nobody knows how
bright they really are, but they can be trained."

"Why do you bum honey hornets? Booce says they're
valuable."

Her expression soured. "Honey is contraband. Put just
a tip of a fingernail's worth on your tongue, you dream
wonderful dreams. Then you can't stop. Use a little more
and you die in ecstasy. Some people will pay a lot for
that."

Honey is suicide. Rather hadn't realized that Booce
meant it literally. He thought it over, then said, "But it's
their choice—"

She shook her head. "Not my decision. Then there's
detective work, and riot control, and rescue work. We
don't specialize much. You learn to do all of that, but first
you learn how to fly a ship."

"What happens to cadets who fail? Murphy, what hap-
pens to dwarves who fail?"

"Nothing. I mean, they're out of the Navy, of course.
They hire out or they build a business, maybe they go
diving in the Dark for mushrooms and fan fungus, or they
go logging. Hell, what does a logger do if he fails at some-
thing?" She looked closely at him. "What's the matter?"

"I'm having trouble with this. There're more people
here, so there's more places for people, right? If you can't
hunt or do earthlife farming, you just try something else?"

Murphy nodded brightly. "Next question?"

Would we see each other if I joined up? May I call you
Sectry? "Thank you, Bosun."

"Any time," she said, and Sprang away. She coasted
parallel to the bark, toward Wheeler as he emerged from
behind the Wart.

"It's big," Wheeler called. "Booce Serjent, you've
made your fortune."

"Recouped it, anyway. The first thing I'll do is rebuild
Logbearer."

168 / Larry Niven

"Yes.. . . Well, I've seen enough. Eight thousand tons
or so. Those scars on the metal—"

"We used the saw to get the slabs that make up the
firebox. It worked better than I'd hoped. It's a good sub-
stitute for sikenwire, and the saw's not damaged."

Wheeler nodded, satisfied. "Can we lift you back to

your ship?"

"No, we need to cover this somehow before we reach

the Market."

"I think you're worrying over nothing. How could any-
one steal anything this big7"

"With saws. . . . Well, you may be right."

They watched Gyrfalcon steam toward the Clump in-
terior. Something bright twinkled at the bow. "He's call-
ing home," Booce said. "They use mirrors to bounce
Voy-light where they want it."

"What happens now?" Clave asked.

"Wheeler thinks I sawed off more metal than just those
plates for the firebox. He'll watch to see if I sell it on the
black market. He could have bought the Wart on the spot,
but he thinks I'll give him a better price if he waits. A
few days after we dock I'll get an offer. It'll be too little,
and I'll boost them a bit and then take it so I can stop

guarding the metal—"

"What do we do now, Booce? Jeffer must be going
crazy waiting for us to call in."

"We're still being watched."

Gyrfalcon was tiny now. Its steam trail was dissipating.
Clave asked, "Can they still see? Have they got some-
thing like the CARM windows?"

"A box they hold to their eyes. Clave, we'd like some
way to disguise this mucking great chunk of metal."

So Logbearer's five crew swarmed over the Wart, tak-
ing their time, just looking at it from all angles, as if there
were some way to hide a conspicuous pucker in the honest
wood of a tree. The sun crept from zenith to pass north

THE SMOKE RING / 169

of Voy. And presently Debby said, "Booce, you've seen
more trees than any of us. What kind of a thing causes
this kind of scar?"

"Something hits the tree . . . could be stony, it doesn't
have to be metal. I've seen this kind of gap with nothing
in it at all, just chewed wood healing over. I never did
figure it out."

Debby wondered, "Ice?"

Booce's face went . . . stupid? Mouth agape, eyes
drifting. He said, "Heh. Yes! A chunk of ice could smash
a tree, then melt."

"Still doesn't do anything for us. What else? Disease?
Is there something that builds nests? Or the tree bugs
could chew just in one place—"

"Sure, a honey pod could hit a tree, and the bugs would
chew a huge hole . . . give me a breath, Debby." Stupid
again: thinking. "We can do it. Twenty days to reach the
Market. Okay. We need a fisher jungle that's got termites,
and we need to look like we've been through a disaster,
but we've got that already. I never thought I'd come home
with a pod for Logbearer's cabin!"

"What do you need from us?" Clave asked.

"Stay here, talk to Jefifer. The rest of us will fly up the
trunk. This is nice. If Wheeler wonders why we're still
hovering around the Wart, he'll see us hiding it!"

Rather swallowed his protest, because Clave was say-
ing, "You don't need Rather. I want him."

"Stet." Booce had his wings on. "Come, children."

THE SMOKE RING / 171

Chapter Thirteen

The Termite Nest

CUMULATED MATTER BECOMES THICK ENOUGH TO
BLOCK SUNLIGHT. TIDE-STABILIZED PLANTS DON'T
THRIVE HERE. WE'VE FOUND FAMILIAR LIFE FORMS—
TRIUNES AND COTTON-CANDY JUNGLES—BUT ALSO
SOME SPECIALIZED LIFE FORMS NOT SEEN ELSEWHERE.

DEEP RADAR INDICATES SOLID MASSES WITHIN THE
DARK INNER REGION. NONE ARE LARGE.

WE HAVE WONDERED WHY THE CLUMPS NEVER CON-
DENSED INTO ONE LARGE BODY. PERHAPS LIFE ITSELF
ACTS TO REMOVE MATTER FROM THE INNER REGIONS.
THE FISHER JUNGLES' ROOTS DISRUPT LARGE PONDS.
SAPROPHYTES PEED IN THE DENSE CORE, THEN FIRE
SPORE PACKAGES AWAY INTO THE SMOKE RING. BIRDS
ARE FORCED OUT BY FAMINE OR POPULATION PRES-
SURE . . .

/row the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 5 SM:

THE LAGRANGE POINTS

MATTER TENDS TO COLLECT IN THE FOURTH AND
FIFTH LAGRANGE POINTS (L4 AND L5) OF GOLD-
BLATT'S WORLD. THESE REGIONS APPEAR LESS TUR-
BULENT THAN THE STORMS AROUND GOLDBLATT'S
WORLD ITSELF, BUT WE HAVE POSTPONED EXPLORING
THEM IN DEPTH.

WE INSPECTED ONLY L4. THE MORE OR LESS STABLE
REGION IS 600 KM ACROSS. MAPPING THE EQUIPOTEN-
TIAL TIDE CURVES GETS US NESTED CRESCENTS. WHAT
SHOWS TO THE EYE IS A MISSHAPEN WHORL DWINDLING
EAST AND WEST INTO THE ARC OF THE SMOKE RING
PROPER.

THE WHORL IS GREEN AROUND THE PERIPHERY,
DARKER AND BROWNER NEAR THE CENTER, WHERE AC-
170

IT MADE HIS HEAD HURT.

Jeffer ate as he read. When he reached the end he
doggedly scrolled back to the beginning. His students had
found it bewildering. So did Jeffer, but he had an advan-
tage over his students. He had Kendy.

IfKendy would call!

Today he had hunted the sky. He'd returned to the
dead fisher jungle trailing a sizable shieldbird. A small fire
near the CARM had cooked his catch. He was getting
good at it. Sandwiching the meat between two of the
shieldbirds' bone plates cooked it tender without scorch-
ing it.

He almost choked when the CARM suddenly spoke.
"Jeffer? This is Clave. Jeffer, can you hear me?"

Jeffer swallowed hard and said, "Prikazyvat Send to
pressure suit. And about treefeeding time too! Are you
alive?"

"Jeffer, we couldn't get to the helmet. The Navy
searched Logbearer. Even after they left they were
watching us. Where are you? Are you hidden?"




172 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 173

"Clave, I found something good. Do you remember
Booce's description of a fisher jungle? A green puffball a
klomter across, with a long coiled root. It reaches out
to put the root in a pond, but there's poison on it and it
can attack life forms and kill them and draw them in to
rot—"

"Right. They're not supposed to live outside the
Clump."

"Maybe so. This one's fifty klomters from the Clump
fringes, and it's dead. The axis trunk is hollow. There's
a Navy ship coming this way. It's not likely they'll want
to sniff around a fisher jungle, but I've got the CARM
moored inside the hollow anyway. When it goes away I'll
tether it above the root so the CARM can get some sun-
light. Where are you? I can't see anything."

"I'm in the dark. I'm in that channel we chopped past
the Wart. We haven't moved the silver suit yet."

Jeffer remembered extending the work done by the
happyfeet. His back and shoulders still ached. "We
should have let the happyfeet do more of the carving."

"It was worth it. Booce was right. The Navy knows
if you're carrying metal. This Petty Wheeler citizen knew
about the Wart, but he didn't look for anything behind
it."

"What's the Clump like?"

"Crowded. We'll have the log moored in twenty
days. Booce has a way to hide the Wart. He's afraid of
thieves, and we can't use the silver suit to win a fight,
because—"

"No, of course not."

"—Because they'd recognize it. Jeffer, they've got
three silver suits. It's a mark of high rank. Dwarves are
in good shape if they join the Navy, and Rather's had an
offer."

An offer? "Rather, you there?"

Jeffer heard Clave's distant yell. Presently Rather said,
"Here."

"You had an offer to join the Navy? What was said?
What did you tell them?"

"I didn't take the Petty seriously. The idea is to leam
something about the Admiralty, buy some earthlife seeds,
and get back to Citizens Tree!"

"We want to know about the Navy too."

"I learned a little—"

Clave interrupted. "How serious are we? Booce, what
has the Navy got that we want to see? I'm not so eager
to see the inside of a Navy rocket that I'd feed one of
my—"

"The Library! The cassettes! What's on the Admiralty
cassettes?"

"All right, Jeffer. What makes you think Rather could
get to any of that? Booce might know, but he isn't here
to ask."

Jeffer finished the shieldbird meat while he thought.
"Ask him when you get the chance. Now, I'm getting
terminally bored here. Are you free to move the silver
suit into the rocket?"

"'No. It's too easily recognized," Clave said.

"How about just the helmet?"

"We'll have to ask Booce, but ... I think not. Let's
get Kendy in on this. Are you in contact?"

"He said he was changing orbit. He'll be back in an-
other day. Clave, I wish you could give me some kind of
a view."

"I'll think of something. Jeffer, Rather's waving at
me."

"Scientist out."

"Clave? You'd better see this," Rather said.
"What? I was talking to Jeffer." Clave crawled out of
the cavity behind the Wart. "Oh."

From out of the crowded sky came a shapeless thing
colored a dead yellowish brown. Its outline was fuzzed
with a jittering motion that caused the optic nerves to




174 / Larry Niven

twitch. It was coming straight at them, and Logbearer
was behind it.

"Get out of its way, Rather, it's going to hit! Got your
wings?"

They fled. The thing fell toward the Wart with a faint,
frightening buzzing sound. Myriads of black flecks
swarmed around it, insects much smaller than honey hor-
nets.

It struck the crater around the Wart and deformed like
soft mud.

Logbearer bumped the trunk more softly. Debby
emerged from the hatch in the forward pod. She stared
hard at the intrusionary mass. She called, "It's going to
stick."

Booce answered from inside. "Stet. Spread the
honey."

Debby waved at Booce and Rather, but that was all
the attention she gave them. She began spreading red
sticky honey around the rim of the crater.

The swarm of insects followed her. When she closed
the circle, most of the insects had migrated to the honey.

"Done!"

"Good. Get aboard. Clave, Rather, I've got to moor
this thing. Want a ride?"

Clave bellowed, "Booce, you get out here and answer
some questions!"

Booce's head popped out. He thought it over, then
flapped to join them. He looked indecently self-satisfied.

"It's a termite nest," he said before Clave could ask.
"We'll say we didn't have any choice, it was the only tree
around and we had to get back to the Clump because . . .
I'll think of something."

"Uh-huh. The honey?"

"Encouragement. When the termites run out of honey
they'll eat wood. They'll bond the nest to the Wart."

"What about the silver suit? Were you just going to
leave it?"

THE SMOKE RING / 175

"Where would it be safer?"

"Jeffer's all alone in the sky. He'd go crazy!"

Booce's grimace told it all. Clave said, "He's the Cit-
izens Tree Scientist, and he is not a crazy murderer. He
was in a fight with our lives at stake, Booce, and he used
what he had. It was more powerful than he thought it
was—"

"He used it twice."

"Booce, if you've ever been a happyfeet bandit your-
self, tell me now."

Booce was astonished, then amused. "Oh, really! No,
I'm not protecting my own kind. I'm not defending ban-
dits that prey on loggers. Granted they'd generally rather
attack some tribe of helpless savages. Your suspicions are
right there, Clave, but it doesn't mean I like bandits. I
wouldn't have burned a whole damn tribe either!"

"Uh-huh. You would have sent them away without
hurting them so much. How? Describe the procedure in
detail."

"I can't do that. Jeffer hasn't told any of us how to fly
the CARM! Clave, the Scientist is not to burn any tribe,
ever again. I'm telling you, not him. You are to stop him."

"I'll tell him. Now what?"

"Oh . . . we'll leave everything but the helmet where
it is. Jeffer's scientific eyes are in the helmet, right? Those
little windows in the forehead? We'll moor it in the nest.
He'll have a view. We'll be spending enough time around
the Wart; we'll talk to him then."

The CARM with its cameras was hidden in a dark
place, the pressure suit was in another, the incoming re-
cordings were days old, and in present time Jeffer wasn't
present. Kendy skimmed the recordings. He was learning
more through Disciplined own senses.

Logbearer was easy to follow: forty kilometers of tree
with tufts missing and a metal mass off-center, now round-
ing the starward limb of the L4 whorl. Maintaining contact




176 / Larry Niven

wasn't going to be easy here. Discipline's new orbit had
twice the period ofGoldblatt's World, with periVoy fall-
ing north of the L4 point. Tilting his orbit out of the Smoke
Ring allowed his instruments to penetrate less of the gar-
bage in the Clump; but the log and the CARM and all of
Kendy's citizens would be circling that center on long
kidney-shaped paths.

At least he wouldn't have to burn more fuel. If he could
establish relations with the Admiralty, his present orbit
might suffice for hundreds of years.

Savages in a thriving civilization would find trouble
sooner or later. Patience. Some emergency would force
Jeffer to bring the CARM into the L4 point. Then he must
open the airlock to the Navy . . .

One problem at a time. Wait. Leam.

Jeffer entered the cabin before Kendy passed out of
range. There was fresh pink blood on his tunic and more
on his hands.

"Kendy for the State—"

"Hello, Kendy. How can we—"

"Jeffer, if Rather has an offer from the Navy, I want
him to accept."

"You would. Rather didn't sound too enthusiastic.
Neither am I. How can we get away with not hiding the
silver suit?"

"An excellent question." Kendy was using light am-
plification, but it only showed him iron ore and chewed
wood. Clave and Rather had departed the hiding place.
"If the Navy has pressure suits, they'll recognize yours.
I thought of disassembling it, but they'd know the helmet
too. We would ruin the camera if we tried to dismount it,
and the electrical source is in the helmet."

"So?"

"Patience."

"Feed your patience to the tree, Kendy. I've got a
cryptic entry under 'Lagrange Points'—"

"I've had three hundred and eighty-four years to leam

r

THE SMOKE RING / 177

patience. You are almost out of range. Can you feed your-
self there?"

"Sure. There's hand fungus, and flashers living on the
bugs, and some other things. In a way it's like learning
to hunt all over again ..." The link was lost.

A chance to examine the Admiralty's military arm from
inside! But Rather wasn't enthusiastic. And Kendy would
have to talk Jeffer around before his arguments could even
reach the boy.

Patience . . .







Chapter Fourteen

Docking

THE SMOKE RING / 179

BUT WILL SUFFICE. WE'VE PAINTED THE HONEY HOR-
NET LOGO ACROSS LOGBEARER'S CABIN. NOW WE'LL
SEE WHAT CAN BE DONE ABOUT MY CREW'S WINGS.

DAY 1996. ENTERED ADMIRALTY SPACE. GYR-
FALCON HAS REGISTERED LOG AND METAL FOR CUS-
TOMS. ASSESSMENT TO FOLLOW.

DAY 2000. LOG NEARING MARKET. METAL
CONCEALED FROM ALL BUT NAVY. CONDITIONS OPTI-
MAL.

DAY 2015. DOCKED. SENT THE CREW OFF WITH
CARLOT. WOULD HAVE GONE WITH THEM IF I COULD.
I NEVER DEALT WITH TREE DWELLERS BEFORE. I CAN'T
GUESS HOW THEY'LL REACT.

I MISS RYLLIN. I NEVER IN MY LIFE HAD TO WEAVE
SO MANY THREADS AT ONCE.

from Logbearer',? log. Captain Booce Serjent speaking:

YEAR 384, DAY 1700. THIS TRIP WE NEED NOT
FEAR HAPPYFEET.

I FEAR JEFFER THE SCIENTIST. I FEAR THE SECRETS
WE HIDE FROM THE ADMIRALTY AND THE SECRETS THE
SCIENTIST KEEPS FROM ME. BUT I OWE A MAJOR DEBT
TO CITIZENS TREE.

DAY1710. WE'VE FOUND A SIMPLE WAY TO HIDE
OUR EMPTY CREWMEMBER. MAY I NEVER HAVE THE
CHANCE TO THANK THE HAPPYFEET FOR MAKING IT POS-
SIBLE.

DAY 1780. WE'VE GONE FOR MORE PODS. ONE
HAS BECOME OUR CABIN, ONE STORES EXTRA WATER IN
CASE A FIRE SPREADS. RETURNING WITH A POD FOR LOG-
BEARER'S CABIN GRATES IN MY SOUL, BUT IT WILL
SURELY HIDE THE WEALTH WE CARRY.

DAY 1810. MAKING PAINTS GAVE MORE TROU-
BLE THAN I EXPECTED. THE COLORS ARE STILL POOR,
178

A FAT, BABY-BLUE TORPEDO CRUISED SLOWLY ALONG

the Serjent log, moving closer to where Rather and Carlot
stood watch. Suddenly it split along its length, and four
slender blue-and-orange triunes dived on some tree-dwell-
ing life form.

Rather pointed. "Four?"

"Sometimes triunes have twins."

"I've never heard of that."

"You never saw one of those either." She pointed out
a triangular shadow. "That's a Dark shark. They don't
usually come this far skyward. They're dangerous. All
teeth, no brain."

"Skyward?"

"Dark, skyward, spin, and antispin. We use all the
normal directions too."

"How do you keep it all straight?" Rather reached to
wrap his legs lightly around her waist. She did not re-
spond.

A ball of green fluff stretched a quarter klomter of curly
tail toward a passing sphere of water.




180 / Larry Niven

Booce, Debby, and Clave were around the log's ho-
rizon, ready to use the rocket if anything came near. Car-
lot and Rather kept watch from the east. "We can still
keep our eyes on the sky," Rather pointed out.

Cariot pounded his kneecaps with her fists, briskly.

"Who's watching us7"

"I don't mind triunes watching. Maybe I even like it."

"What about the houses?"

"Houses?"

"You'd say huts. Look—"

Beyond the Market, beyond Carlot's pointing chin, six
cubes were strung along a spire of wood with a rocket
tank and nozzle at one end. "That's Captain-Guardian
Wayne Mickl's household," Cariot said. "He's one of the
richest officers."

"It isn't close."

"That one is."

A structure floated against the Dark, a cube festooned
with platforms, extrusions for tethers, water pods, and
other things for which he had no name.

"That's the Hillards, I think. And that puff jungle is

the Kerians."

The sky was full of puffballs. The one Cariot pointed
out bore a big K with other letters within, too small to
read. Cariot said, "Crew live in those if they're too poor
to buy wood. Usually they clip a logo in the foliage."

Rather laughed. "Okay, I'm convinced." Another puff
jungle was marked with a slender figure-eight. "If you're
rich, you build with wood?"

"Yes."

"Your family has a house."

"We find our own wood! I'll show you if it comes
around. It wasn't finished when we left, but I know the

design."

"We're poor; aren't we? Citizens Tree is poor."
"You live poor. The CARM makes you rich, except

THE SMOKE RING / 181

that you can't use it ... and there's your share of the
Wart, once Father sells it. Rather?"

"Speaking."

"I think I'm going to marry Raff."

Rather turned to look at her. The sudden black emp-
tiness in his belly was entirely new to him, yet he couldn't
feel any surprise. He got his lips working. "Would you
be better off if I went somewhere else?"

She was having trouble meeting his eyes. "I haven't
seen Raff in three years. Rather, I think he'd be happier
if he didn't know we've been ..."

"Making babies. I won't announce it."

"All right. But I wouldn't push you into the Navy just
to get rid of you! Don't ever think that! I don't know if
it's a good idea or not. I don't think for Citizens Tree,
and I don't do your thinking either. Don't give up the idea
just to stay near me."

"I have no intention of joining the Navy." Rather
turned back to the sky. He was still on watch.

Now that he knew what to look for, the sky danced
with structures. Puff jungles were everywhere, more of
them toward the Dark, and some were marked. There
were wooden cubes and clusters of cubes, elaborately col-
ored in bright primaries. He could pick out wind-curdled
lines of steam crossing the Dark.

He said, "People change in three years."

Cariot said, "Sure. Maybe we won't like each other.
We'll see. I'm telling you. Rather, if we get along I'll
marry him. Belmy was the first of the logging concerns,
and it's the most powerful."

The helmet had been in place in the termite nest for
some twenty hours. Kendy ran the record through his
mind, classifying, deducing, making notes. When he
reached present time he went back to the beginning.

His mental model of the Admiralty was shaping up
nicely.




182 / Larry Niven

There were more new plants than new animals. Ani-
mals showed the same modified trilateral symmetry here
as they did in the Smoke Ring proper. There was a clear
absence of tide-stabilized plants: hardly surprising.

The buildings were interesting. Everything less primi-
tive than a carved-out cotton-candy plant was built in rec-
tangular solids. It was as if they still built to resist gravity
. . . but not quite, for addenda sprouted at any angle, and
openings might appear in any of the six walls. They looked
like Escher had designed them.

Some houses had a big square fin sticking out from one
corner. The Clump was turbulent. In infrared Kendy
could see little whirlwinds, "dust devils" with no dust in
them. A house would tumble and keep tumbling without

that fin.

Unless it was attached to some larger structure.
Why was there only one Market? It didn't look difficult
to construct. Houses were scattered through the outer
Clump. Most would have no neighbors at all most of the
time. There was no need for such isolation. It was inef-
ficient and lonely.

The tree's attitude changed continually. The view
through the helmet camera wavered with it. Kendy was
getting only glimpses of the Market, but he could integrate

them.

Many of the structures were moored by concrete to the
Market frame. Too bad. Kendy would have liked to offer
them concrete. If he ever got their attention he'd have to
have something to offer, some bit of knowledge to make
their lives better. He knew the pattern that would make
them a thriving. Smoke Ring-girdling State in a hundred
years; but there had to be something quicker.

Electricity? The Clump never had true night either.
How did they light their houses?

He recognized a glass tank from one of Discipline's
seeding missiles,' emitting a sharp spike in the light spec-
trum: chlorophyll. They'd made it into a hydroponics

THE SMOKE RING / 183

tank. The faceted hemisphere nearby was an old survival
tent sheathed with wood, with transparent facets left
open. Other structures on the ring were made from Smoke
Ring materials: mostly wood, but one was a cotton-candy
jungle tethered to a mast.

A building beyond the Market sported a broad picture
window: the windscreen from a CARM. Otherwise, no
glass anywhere. No sand?

Crew drifted among the buildings like leaves in an au-
tumn wind. Half-grown children flew in groups tended by
one or two adults . . .

I've got to know more. Can I find a way to move the
helmet into the Market?

Booce was in position at the rocket, with hot coals
ready, and Debby and Clave to watch and to steer. The
sky was thick with debris. One might hope that Carlot
and Rather would keep to their watching . . . but at least
they'd have their chance to talk.

A Navy ship had them in clear view. Supervising, to
make sure that the log came to rest a safe distance from
the Market. A larger rocket pulled free of Belmy's log and
steamed toward Logbearer.

Booce and his damaged tree would arrive in a blaze of
publicity.

He was returning like a beggar.

But of course there was the Wart . . . and the silver
suit behind it. He would have liked to lose that. The worst
the Admiralty could charge him with was "concealment
of vital resources," but that was a heavy charge. Was it
worth the risk, to be able to talk to Jeffer the Scientist?

Not that he had a choice.

He was almost home. The Belmy log was ahead of
them, eclipsing the Market. The tuftless end looked
chewed. Belmy had sold some of his wood.

Woodsman was prominent in the sky, arriving nozzle-
foremost. There was no mistaking that elaborate super-

184 / Larry Niven

structure, four cubes surrounding the water pod, each
painted a different color, each bearing the small black B
logo. Handholds everywhere, and a steering platform
around the nozzle, with a carved rail. The nozzle was
mounted a little out from the rest so that replacement
water pods could be inserted easily. Hilar Belmy was

coming to greet him.

"Almost time," he said, and saw Clave and Debby nod
acknowledgment. Booce pushed his coals into the fire-
box. The fire would need time to catch. "Belmy docked
his log behind the Market, of course. We're going to have
to dock behind him. Then it gets unpleasant."

Debby asked, "Why not dock just ahead of the Mar-
ket?"

"Because that's where the Admiralty docks its ships."

"Booce, if you're expecting a fight, you'd better tell
us now. Also, what weapons—"

"Bloodthirsty woman. No weapons, no fight. It's just
. . . I'm coming in behind Hilar Belmy with a fuel pod
for my cabin and a log damaged in two places. Checker
only knows what Hilar will think. He'll change his mind
when he finds out about the Wart, but... That log still
has one tuft."

"So?"
"Why on Earth would Hilar Belmy leave one tuft on

a log?"

Clave asked, "Why didn't we?"

"Wind. You can bring a log to its mooring with one
tuft on, but it's tricky. It usually means you ran out of
honey or bugs . . . hmm?"

"What?"

"Just a passing thought. Hello, Hilar!" His crew
stared. They had never heard so cheerful a sound from
Booce Serjent.

Woodsman'vented steam, decelerating. Two men rode
the platform above the nozzle. They were tall: taller than

THE SMOKE RING / 185

Booce. Their necks were long, like Ryllin's; there was a
great-grandmother in common. Black hair, gray hair,
otherwise nearly identical.

The black-haired man waved joyfully. Booce couldn't
tell Belmy's sons apart, but that must be Raff, and Carlot
would be waving back.

Gray hair was Hilar. He looked good: sturdy, pros-
perous, a few kilos more massive than his son. "Booce!
I thought I'd offer you a tug. How. . . Did you have some
trouble?"

"That we did!" Booce's shout became less effortful as
Belmy's rocket drew closer. "Hilar, thanks for the offer,
but I'll bring her in myself."

"Stet," Hilar Belmy shouted back. Woodsman slowed
and stopped fifty meters from the trunk. "Join us after!
I want to talk business."

"Stet." Booce dropped his voice. "Now let's do this
right. Debby, stand by the water pod. Clave, I'll need you
to help me turn the rocket.'' Logbearer looked ready. The
firebox was dull red; white light glowed through the
cracks. The plates had never fit exactly, but they didn't
seem to be coming apart. Logbearer was tilted nearly par-
allel to the bark.

Booce entered the cabin. He blew into the flow port
(CHUFF CHUFF chuff chuffchuff . . . ) and emerged
panting. "Clave, not quite yet ... now."

They heaved against Logbearer''s fuel pod, tilting the
rocket in its bark nest to keep it pointed straight toward
the Market. Condensing live steam drew a line across the
sky. Woodsman stood well clear. The log turned as it
approached Belmy's log; and the rocket turned in coun-
terposition, and the log's sluggish motion slowed, slowed,
stopped.

Booce dove into the cabin. He knocked the plug loose
from the flow port and jumped away. Warm water glob-
ules followed him out. "I've spilled the water. Debby,
hose down the firebox. We're in place."




186 / Larry Niven

The firebox hissed. Globed in invisible water vapor,
the coals went out immediately. The gap between the two
logs remained constant.

"And that was a nominal docking," Booce said in sat-
isfaction.

Carlot and Rather came around the curve of bark.
Booce called to them. "Well done, my crew! I'm crossing
to Woodsman to see what Hilar wants. Carlot, why don't
you show these people the Market?"

Carlot reached him well ahead of Rather. "Speak to
you in private?"

They flew clear of the others. Booce asked, "Have you
been making decisions?"

She nodded, jerkily. "Raff probably expects to see
me."

"Then you decide whether to take him along. Will
Rather behave himself?"

She hesitated. "It's not a good idea."

"I'll make your excuses to Raff. Blame everything on
me."

Clave and Debby followed Carlot. Rather hung back
a little. Flying too close to Carlot would be uncomfortable
now.

They passed close to Woodsman. It was Rather's first
good look at Raff Belmy. He was dark-haired and tall,
three meters or close to it, with long arms, long sym-
metrical legs, stiff black hair, and a short beard. His neck
was like his father's: long and graceful, but the lines of
muscle showed strongly. If you liked tall. Raff was a good-
looking man. He waved energetically as they flew past,
then ducked into a cabin. There must have been hasty
conversation in there. When Raff Belmy emerged he did
not follow them.

"I'd have liked to talk to Jeffer first," Clave said
softly.

THE SMOKE RING / 187

"Let him wonder," Debby answered. "We'll have
plenty to tell him when we get the chance."

They passed the Belmy log, and the Market was huge
in their sight.

The wheel was ten to twelve klomters in diameter, and
a hundred meters broad. The inner surface was partly
covered with . . . houses? They surely weren't proper
huts. They glowed with color. Most were cubes and ob-
longs, but there were other, stranger shapes: a faceted
hemisphere, a wooden cylinder, a larger cylinder as trans-
parent as the CARM's bow window.

Carlot shouted back at them as they flew. "We leam
all about the Market in school. It started out as a beam
carved along the entire length of a log, three hundred
years ago. The Admiralty ran it through a pond to soak
it. Then they used tethers to bend it in a circle. Before
that, the Market was only shops tethered together."

This tremendous made thing . . . this was wealth.
Rather felt the fear and the awe of any savage approaching
a civilized city.

People were flying to meet them.

"The older shops are funny shapes. Balls and geodes-
ies. That glass cylinder is the Vivarium. Vance Limited
grows earthlife there." Carlot noticed that all three of her
charges were dropping behind. She turned in a half circle
and rejoined them. "Are you all right? Tired?"

Rather answered for the others. "It's a little fright-
ening. Who are those people?"

"Friends. Traders. I'll introduce you. Raym! Crew,
this is Raym Wilby—"

He was an older man, a jungle giant with pale skin and
dark, curly hair and beard. He shouted at the sight of
Carlot, bounced into her a little too hard, and wrapped
her in his arms. As he examined her companions the wide,
goofy smile was lost to a look of comical amazement.
"Carlot? Shorts?"

She rebuked him. "Raym, these are some of the citi-




188 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 189

zens who saved our lives when our tree caught fire. Hey,
John, hey. Nurse!" Others were arriving. Carlot squirmed
loose; clasped hands or toes; chattered introductions.
John and Nurse Lockheed were brother and sister, and
looked it, with angular faces (shaved, in John's case) and
white-blond hair. Long-headed Grag Maglicco was in the
Navy as a Spacer First. Adjeness Swart was small for a
jungle giant. Her hair was black and straight, her nose
curved and sharp. She worked in the Vivarium, Carlot
said.

Half a dozen others reached them and Rather started
to lose track. Raym would be thirty to forty years old;

Grag would be a little younger. The rest were around Car-
lot's age. Jungle giants all, and expert flyers.

Carlot told her tale as they flew toward the Market.
Other strangers joined them and she had to start over.
Now there were a dozen jungle giants among them, and
all were strangers to all but Carlot. She stuck to her fa-
ther's story, and made no mention of Wart or CARM or
silver suit.

The citizens were uncharacteristically quiet. There
was too much to see, and they were surrounded by as
many strangers as there were adults in Citizens Tree.

Debby was finally ready to admit that it had been a
mistake. She wanted to go home.

She hadn't been with Anthon in hundreds of days.
Booce was afraid of his wife, Jeffer seemed to be married
to the CARM, and Clave... the best she could tell, Clave
was vastly enjoying his vacation from his wives. She was
in a sexual desert.

She had other reasons for being on edge. The Market
covered a quarter of the sky. No bigger than a small tree,
it was obtrusively a made thing, made by the ancestors
of this crew.

They didn't look that powerful. They flew a little closer
together than Debby found comfortable. Easy to guess

why: they'd been flying all their lives. Raym Wilby was
chattering to Rather. "The bugeyes, they get whistling
drunk when the fringe blooms. You just reach out and
pop 'em in a bag—" Debby tried to follow it, but she
couldn't. The Lockheeds stayed together, off to one side.
Maybe they were shy?

Adjeness Swart flew alongside Debby. Cheerfully she
called, "How do you like the Market?"

"Impressive."

"Your first visit to civilization?"

"We like to think we've got a civilization too," Debby
said. We must be gawking like fools.

Adjeness laughed and waved around her. They had
passed the rim of the Market and were crossing the central
gap. "If you've got anything like this, the Admiralty
would like to know it." And as Debby was throttling the
urge to tell this smug Clump dweller about the CARM,
Adjeness asked, "How much can you see of the Admi-
ralty from your tree? Why haven't any of you come here
before?"

"Some didn't want us to come at all. We didn't know
what we'd find. Maybe things we wouldn't like. Excuse
me." Debby kicked hard to reach Carlot.

Chattering companions surrounded Carlot. Debby
tried to ease inconspicuously among them, just to listen
... but she hadn't counted on Admiralty manners. The
locals drifted away from Debby and Carlot and left them
to talk.

Carlot looked at her questioningly. Debby said, "I'm
afraid I'll say too much."

"Adjeness?"

"Yeah. It isn't just the questions, it's her treefeeding
superior attitude. Carlot, I feel so small."

"Can't help you there, but ... go fly next to Raym.
He won't let you talk at all." Carlot held her voice low.
"Raym Wilby is an old Dark diver. It's gotten to his
brain."




190 / Larry Niven

"What's he doing with us?"

"He's an old friend of Mother's. I'd hate to have her
see him now! I could get rid of him, but it's more trouble
than it's worth. Either I'd hurt his feelings or it'd take
forever."

"Stet. What's a Dark diver?"

"Ask him. Or just listen."

Debby dropped back. Raym was telling Rather, "It
isn't the dark that bothers you, it's the thick. Your eyes
get used to the light in there. It's kind of gray, and the
colors bleach out. I never heard of a diver getting wrecked
unless he was a damn fool, because things don't move
fast in there. But you can't move fast either. You drift.
Sometimes you get lost, you forget which way is out. You
come out never knowing how many days you were in."

Rather asked, "Why do you—?"

"Credit. On a bad trip you only come out with mud,
but Zakry pays high for mud. A good trip, you can come
out with your hull covered with blackbrain or walnut-
cushion or fringe." Raym grinned, and Debby realized
what it was that bothered her about Adjeness's toothy
smile.

Rather said, "This makes you—"

"No. You never hold onto it."

"—Rich?"

Teeth. Raym was an older man, yet he still had half
his teeth. Adjeness must be Debby's age, but her smile
was all teeth, with only three or four gaps. The rest were
youths: no teeth missing at all.

Angular huts surrounded her. Debby fought vertigo.
Down in all directions; no tide. The Admiralty crew were
forming a line as Carlot led them toward a huge trans-
parent cylinder. They had flown all their lives. Their grace
made Debby feel clumsy.

Debby eased into line behind Rather. The starstuff cyl-
inder had an opening at one end. Debby brushed it with
her wings as she went through. None of the others did.

Chapter Fifteen

Half Hand's

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 80 SM:

WE'VE FOUND A FUNGUS WITH IMPORTANT MEDICI-
NAL PROPERTIES . . .

WOODSMAN'S DOOR HAD BEEN BRACED HOSPITABLY

open. A guest need only grip the rounded edge as he flew
past, set his wings in the racks, and swing himself in.
Booce entered an atmosphere rich with blackbrain tea.

Jonveev Belmy was a small woman, not much more
than Clave's height. Booce had watched her auburn hair
turn gray over the years, but it was still long and thick.
She was busy at a turning cookglobe. She stretched a foot
to meet Booce's hand.

Her grip was strong. "Booce, I'm so sorry about
Wend. Is Ryllin all right?"

"She's fine, Jonveev. We're doing business with Cit-
191




192 / Larry Niven

izens Tree, and that's where she is now." He wondered
what Jonveev was thinking. Her concern was real, of
course; but she had never dealt with Booce himself. In
business matters Ryllin and Jonveev did the talking.

Jonveev swung the big globular teapot round her head
to settle the water, then quickly opened the spigot. Steam
puffed. Hilar wrapped the teapot in cloth and passed it to
Booce. "I never saw a log come home like that. Do you
want to talk about it?"

Booce sipped and swallowed. He liked his tea hot, and
this was just off the boil. He savored old memories
as much as the powerful, bitter taste. He said, "Not a
lot—"

Hilar waved it off. "Oh, then we'll—"

"I have no wish to drive you crazy at this time."

"Tell us a story," Jonveev said.

He told it long. Carelessness and bad luck; the fire;

Wend dead, Karilly mute with shock. "There was a tuft
tribe waiting to rescue us. They helped rebuild Logbearer.
We found a tree." Booce hesitated. "We were only half
a thousand klomters from the Clump, Hilar, and we
might've had to go halfway to Gold to find a better choice.
It was big and it was close and we wanted to go home."

"I never saw termites on a tree before."

"A new breed, maybe. They're dying now. They hav-
en't done that much damage, and it's a lot of wood."

"That it is. We have a problem," Jonveev said.

The tea had come round again. Booce sipped and
passed it on. "I notice you managed to sell some of your
wood."

"Some. Then the whole Market saw you coming and
the orders dried up. I could have sold at a loss, but Jon-
veev thought—"

"I thought we might reach an agreement," she said.
"The merchants can't whiplash us if one of us announces
that his wood isn't '{or sale."

Booce smiled. Such things had been done. "We'd have

THE SMOKE RING / 193

to give them time to believe we mean it. Thirty sleeps or
so. That'll cost one of us."

"We're willing," Jonveev said. "We'll want some-
thing in return, of course."

"Speak further." He sipped. The bitter taste of black-
brain fungus was the taste of civilization and hospitality
and homecoming. He wished with all his heart that Ryllin
were here. If Hilar was tiptoeing round the edges of a
risky venture, Ryllin would have known at once.

Jonveev said, "Booce, we'll agree not to sell our tree
until the next midyear. What I want is a loan at reasonable
interest. Or I'll offer you the same deal."

Booce was silent.

"The loan would be, say, ten-to-fourth chits. Enough
to keep one of us going for nearly a year." She affected
not to notice Booce's sudden mirthless smile.

"I don't have that much on hand. And you, I suspect,
don't need that much—"

"We'd need it if we don't want to short-change some
of our other concerns. But we can float such a loan and
recoup it by selling our wood. On the other hand, what-
ever you're doing with ... what was it. Citizens Tree?
It's bound to bring you money, but not soon, stet? But
you have a house that's never been lived in."

The tea caught in his throat. Booce swallowed care-
fully, managed not to sputter. He said, "Ryllin would
wring my neck."

"Well, then, you can't do it," Jonveev said instantly.

On second thought... he could put the house up for
sale, to buy time. If he set the price high, buyers would
hang back and wait, because the Serjents were supposed
to be broke. If the Navy bought the Wart metal soon
enough . . . he'd have to take a lower price, but he'd be
able to keep the house.

But what did the Belmys have in mind? What would
a loan do for them? It would be eating interest— "Wb°*
interest?"




194 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 195

"We'd pay fifteen percent until the next midyear, or
take the same."

That was high but not out of line. His first niggling
suspicion began to look like the truth. "I'll sleep on it,"
he said.

Wickerwork ran around the inside of the glass bottle
and across the center; wickerwork everywhere, but you
had to look twice to see it beneath the plants and mud.
The mud was at the interstices, held in place by nets.
Plants grew from the mud, bearing red and yellow spheres
and cylinders. Leafy vines strangled the wickerwork, the
mud, and everything else in sight.

It was a jungle with curving corridors through it. Debby
felt a sudden terrible homesickness for Carther States . . .
but the jungle other childhood was drab compared to the

Vivarium.

The old man who watched from within one of the open-
ings was an elderly, undersized jungle giant. In the humid
warmth he wore only a loose pair of short pants. His knees
and elbows were knobby; his skin was yellow-brown, and
there was something funny about his eyes. He watched
the growing crowd in some surprise. He said, "Late,

Adjeness."

"Zakry, these are customers," Adjeness Swart said
firmly. "They've been living without earthlife since
Checker knows when."

"Have they." The yellow man brightened. "Well, we
can't have that. Carlot Serjent, how good to see you!
Adjeness, why don't you show the crew what they've
been missing?"

Carlot and the yellow man disappeared into the green-
ery. Adjeness Swart said, "Clave told me that. No earth-
life crops. Is it true?"

"Almost," Debby said. "We've got turkeys."

Raym Wilby guffawed. Adjeness was suppressing a
laugh. "Turkeys, stet. Try this." She reached into a jun-


gle of vines and plucked forth a red sphere. She sliced it
apart with her knife and offered wedges around.

It was juicy. Its taste was strong. Debby chewed and
swallowed, trying to decide if she liked it.

Rather plucked a slender yellow spike from the muck.
Adjeness intervened. "Not that. Rather. You have to
cook that. Try this. Don't eat the skin." The sphere Adje-
ness sliced up for him was orange outside and in. Rather
bit into a wedge, and his eyes got big.

Being back on Earth would be like this, Debby thought.
Alien. She recognized almost nothing.

There were people darting among the plants. They
glanced incuriously at the intruders, then went back to
what they were doing. Some sprayed water at the mud
globules or the plants themselves. One was pushing a
plant ahead of him; muddy pale appendages waved naked
at one end. An older man floated slowly along an aisle,
turning as he flew, to see in all directions.

Debby tried a slice of the orange sphere. The sweet-
ness, the wonder of it almost paralyzed her. "Treefod-
der!"

"That's an orange. This—"

"I can see that." Debby reached at random. "What's
this, a yellow?"

"Plum. Not quite ripe."

It was bitter, sour. Adjeness gave her a dark-red sphe-
roid from another part of the plant cluster. "This should
be better."

It was.

"You wouldn't want to spend all your funds on fruit,"
Adjeness said. "You'll want legumes too, but they have
to be cooked. Let Carlot take you to Half Hand's Steak
House before you make any final decisions. Unless you're
really rich? Then you can buy everything."

Clave said, "I'm not sure what we can afford. I haven't
heard any prices."




196 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 197

Adjeness nodded. "Here. Eat everything but the cen-
ter, and you can eat that if you want to. Apple."

Rather asked, "Clave, did you eat like this in Quinn
Tuft?"

"No. Hey, corn! We had corn before the drought.
Here. Strip off the leaves. Now the silk too." He smiled,
watching Rather bite into it. "Just the outside, and it's
supposed to be cooked."

"It's okay this way. Leave the white stuff?"

"Stet."

Raym's hand sneaked into a bush as if without Raym's
knowledge. Three red objects each the size of his thumb
went into his mouth all at once. Debby was nearly sure
Adjeness had caught it. She only smiled.

Cariot and the slant-eyed man emerged from a leafy
wall. Carlot's voice was just slightly ragged. "Crew,
Zakry Bowles is our host here. We'll go look at the prices
after we know some of what we want. How are you
doing?"

"Cariot, it's wonderful!" Rather burst out. "Oranges,
plums, I think we want everything in sight. Zakry, can
you eat everything here?"

"Almost. Every plant has something you can eat grow-
ing on it some of the time. These potatoes, you can't eat
what you see. The root's down there in the mud. You
don't eat the inside of an ear of corn—"

"Clave told me."

"Or the pit of a plum."

"Oop."

"What did you do, swallow it? It'll come out all right
in the end. Let me show you what else we've got—"

Bean vines grew mixed with the corn. They seemed to
want to take over everything. "We stopped growing to-
bacco long ago," Adjeness said. "Only the officers had
fire handy, and <hey weren't buying enough. This is let-
tuce." Lettuce was leaves. It wasn't as sweet as foliage.

Strawberries were as startlingly good as oranges. Squash
looked like jet pods. Zakry was enjoying himself.

They went back to the entrance to examine a list of
prices. Clave memorized the numbers he was interested
in. "Why so much for strawberries and bananas?"

"Strawberries keep dying. I don't have bananas.
Can't grow them here at all. They need tide. The Navy
buys them off some tree dwellers east of here, when
they get the chance. Clave, you haven't established credit
yet-"

"Credit?"

Zakry Bowles spoke slowly, enunciating. "You hav-
en't shown that you can pay. But you can pick out what
you want now, then come back later, pay me and collect
it."

"What we want is stuff we can grow in a tree."

They discussed that at length. Rather joined in; there
were things he would not go home without. Debby eased
over to Cariot. "What's got you upset?"

"He won't give me credit. We came in with a pod
for our cabin and the Belmy log already in dock. Well,
Dave Kon owes me money. I'll go see him. Excuse
me."

Zakry was urging something else on them: a greenish-
yellow fruit with an obscene shape. He showed Debby
how to remove the peel. Clave laughed when Debby bit
into it, but it was good. Cariot was talking to the Lock-
heeds, and they were nodding.

She came back. "I have to talk to Dave Kon. You'd
be bored—"

"You're leaving us?"

"Stet. Stay with the Lockheeds. I'll meet you at Half
Hand's Steak House."

Half Hand's was across the Market.
They flew through rain. Droplets flew from the edges
of their wings. Rather breathed through his nose; from




198 / Larry Niven

time to time he snorted out water. Debby and Clave were
doing the same. The locals had donned masks of gauzy
fabric, except for Raym, who breathed in the rain as if he
cared not at all.

Half Hand's was a faceted dome adjoining a smaller,
less symmetrical structure. You could see through some
of the facets on the big dome: they were starstuff fabric.
The rest was gray concrete. One six-sided facet had been
cut away, and a wooden door hinged into the opening.

Grag Maglicco, the Navy man, suddenly asked, "Have
we all got sticks?" He assessed the blank looks correctly.
"Go on in. I'll join you, couple of breaths." He swerved
aside, headed for an angular hut twenty meters along the
wheel.

The inside was concrete too: concrete troweled over
a structure of starstuff, outside and in. The concrete bore
paintings of intriguing complexity and a variety of styles,
but Rather caught only glimpses of these through a wall
of citizens.

Half Hand's was full. Men, women, and children made
a hemispherical shell around the newcomers, their toes
clinging to two-meter poles protruding from the concrete.
There were no foothold poles in the windows, so those
stayed clear.

From an open hexagon on the far side drifted smoke
and cooking odors. Nurse Lockheed led them that way.
She called through the opening. "Half Hand?"

A man came out of the crowd behind her. "Hi, Nurse.
You got money?"

"No. Put it on the Serjents' tab. I have a party of
eight."

There was nothing wrong with Half Hand's hands.
He was a jungle giant, mostly bald, and his arms and
legs were corded with muscle. He said, "Serjents? I
heard—" Pull stop. "Sure, I'll give the Serjents credit.
What do you want?"

"Let's see the kitchen."

THE SMOKE RING / 199

"Nobody sees the kitchen." Half Hand was peering
past Nurse Lockheed. "Shorts?"

"Tree dwellers. They've never seen anything like your
kitchen."

"Nobody sees the kitchen."

"I did," Nurse said.

Debby pushed her way forward. "Half Hand? I'm
Debby Citizen—"

"Pleasure," he said gravely.

"I wonder if you'd be interested in a description of a
kitchen in a tuft."

Half Hand studied her; nodded. "Just you. Nurse, the
special's moby."

"How old?"

"Eight days ago, shipful of Dark divers took a moby.
Special is moby till we run out. Sausage cost you three
times as much. No turkey today."

"We want vegetables, lots, all kinds. Couple of ki-
grams of moby too, not too rare."

"Moby's ready now. Vegetables soon. You, Debby,
you cooked in that tree?"

"Some."

Half Hand beckoned her in.

Rather could feel the eyes. With a conscious effort he
looked. Of the forty or so diners, only a dozen or so were
watching what was happening at the kitchen entrance.
Even those concentrated more on eating; their right hands
kept pale wooden sticks in constant motion. The eye-pres-
sure still made him flinch.

Grag Maglicco rejoined them. He passed out pairs of
sticks of pale wood, no bigger than the branchlets a tree
dweller was used to.

A woman brought them a two-kigram slab of meat,
black on one side, pink on the other. John Lockheed took
it on his knife. He flapped toward the wall, pushing the
meat ahead of him. Diners edged aside to give him room
or to avoid getting grease on their clothing.

200 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 201

Nurse had to urge them. "Come on."

There were too many people.

But Clave followed Nurse, and Rather followed him.

There was room. Nurse talked to some of the locals
around them. John carved chunks from the meat and
passed them, knife to sticks. Moby meat was good. Ten-
derer than swordbird, richer than turkey.

Grag's own sticks—like every Clump citizen's—were
ornately carved. Some were wood, more were bone. Grag
caught Rather looking. He showed Rather his own bone
sticks. "You carve them yourself. Circle would mean I'm
married. Spiral means I'm looking. A bird would say who
I work for. Outline around the bird would mean I own
the company. What I've got is the rocket, 'cause I'm
Navy. You'd want a honey hornet, for Serjent Logging.
Change life style, start new sticks."

John Lockheed pointed out a clump of customers to
Clave. Tall men and women, a dozen or so, and a few
infants; isolated, clustered close as if for protection. Pe-
culiar footgear, thick-heeled sandals with toes protruding.
"They're happyfeet. Half Hand should make them check
those shoes at the door," John said. "They're for fighting,
for kicking."

"Lupoffs?"

"Yes. Why?"

"No reason," Clave said.

Gourds of red liquid passed among the diners. One
came within reach, and John took it. He drank, then
passed it to Clave. "Fringe tea. Don't take too much."

It went from Clave to Rather. Its taste was bitter and
sweet, not unpleasant. John stopped Rather from passing
the gourd to Raym. "Too much in his blood already."
Raym grinned and nodded.

Debby and Half Hand joined them; they made room.
Debby said, "He's got four citizens doing the cooking,
all women. There''s a major fire against the back wall,
held in by sikenwire. The kitchen's got maybe twenty

windows in it, and Half Hand closes some of them to get
the breeze he wants, keep the fire going and the smoke
out. He's.roasting a slab of moby the size of two men.
It's black on one side and raw on the other, and he slices
off the charred side.

"There's also . . ." She waved a hand and a foot as if
trying to describe without words. "I thought it was a ball
of hard stuff like the Vivarium. Inside, a froth of water
and live steam, and cut-up plants."

"It's a bag," Half Hand said. "Keep it turning, the
vegetables cook even. Draining the water is the tricky
part."

"I saw them do that. They open the bag and throw the
whole glob of cookwater at the lee windows and catch
the vegetables in a net."

"Ho! Vegetables are ready then." In fact three jungle-
giant women were already flying around the dome's cur-
vature, passing out what they carried.

"We use an open pot," Debby told Half Hand. "Tide
keeps it in, whatever you're cooking. We cook meat and
vegetables together. If you don't keep stirring it, it all
bubbles out."

"M'shell!" Half Hand waved one long-toed foot in a
half circle, and the nearest of the kitchen women came
toward them. She served red and yellow and green veg-
etables into small-mouthed bowls. Half Hand said, "We
only serve earthlife plants. A man wants foliage, he gets
it at home. Meat's different. We take what we get. Noth-
ing turns up, Sanchiss has a turkey farm Darkward."

The vegetables: some were good and some were not,
and some you couldn't decide right away. Clave was mak-
ing notes as he ate. Food that wasn't eaten went into a
wooden barrel. From time to time one of the woman re-
placed the barrel.

Grag Maglicco was asking Debby, "Has Booce been
wondering where his house is?"

"He hasn't done anything about it yet."




202 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 203

"Well, we saw Serjent House a few days ago. It was
twenty degrees spinward of the Market and maybe fifteen
klomters skyward. Doesn't look like anyone's disturbed
it. Can you remember to tell him?"

"Stet. Tell me something else?"

"Sure."

Debby waved around her. "I'm surrounded by teeth.
How can so many of you keep most of your teeth?"

Grag fished in his tunic and produced a stick like a
third eating stick, carved in the same way, with a tuft of
bristly vegetable matter at the end. "Scrape your teeth
after you eat," he said, and grinned at the tree dwellers'
dubious looks.

Another gourd of fringe tea came past. Rather was
thirsty; but nobody was taking more than a mouthful, and
he didn't either. He passed it to Grag, who drank deeply
and sent it on.

"Why do they call you Half Hand?" Debby asked.

"My great-square grandfather was Half Hand. Stuff
that moved the old CARM sprang a leak, froze his hand.
Grandfather was Half Hand too. Got bit while he was
Dark hunting. Now me. Soon or late, I lose it." The idea
didn't seem to bother him. "Raym, sell me some walnut-
cushion?"

"Not this trip. Next time."

"I need it. Goes good with potatoes. Green beans
too."

"Next time for sure," Raym promised.

Nurse Lockheed laughed and said, "He can't. He
doesn't have a ship."

Carlot was shocked. "Raym? You lost your shipT'

Raym nodded without looking at her.

Half Hand quietly moved off toward the kitchen. Nurse
reached out and lifted Raym's chin. "Tell them the story,
Raym!"

It was the last thing Raym Wilby wanted. Some of the
locals were looking embarrassed. Clave was quick enough

to catch it. "If it's story time, I'll tell you about the
breakup of Dalton-Quinn Tree."

Raym's ship was forgotten as Clave talked.

Rather knew the tale too well. What he noticed was
the rise in the noise level. Half Hand's was turning bois-
terous. Clave's words were just perceptibly slurred, as if
he were sleepy; yet he was animated, frenetic, as he re-
lived what had been the end of the world for him and for
Rather's parents. Rather himself was feeling strange.

Half Hand was back. "Look out the window or go
outside," he said. "See something."

"Water," Rather said clearly.

"What?"

"Water, not fringe tea. Does something to my head."

"Oh. Get you water, stet. M'shell! I'll fix it. Tree
dwellers shouldn't drink too much fringe. Get to a win-
dow, boy. Thank me later."

The nearest window was crowded, but Rather man-
aged to get his head into the grouping. He watched three
kitchen women carry garbage barrels outside and fling
their contents across the sky. Nothing happened for a
time. Rather continued to watch. He felt as if he were
dreaming. Fringe?

He dreamed that triunes abruptly converged from all
directions, splitting into individuals as they came. Rather
shouted: not a warning, just an incoherent yell.

The women heard. They looked at him in the window
and laughed. Slender blue-and-orange torpedos dove
among them. The wind of their passage sent them tum-
bling. In twenty breaths it was over. The triunes moved
away, regathering their families. The garbage had van-
ished. The women kicked to stop their spinning—and not
one had been touched by the predator birds.

All the strangers around Rather were laughing at him.

The only good thing about it (he decided as he returned
to his pole) was that nobody else had gone to a window.
Grag and Debby seemed mostly interested in each other,




204 / Larry Niven

but the rest were held spellbound by Clave's storytelling.
He spoke of the foray into the Carther States jungle—

He was on the verge of describing the London Tree
CARM! "Clave?"

"Me, I didn't notice most of this, what with my broken
leg. Yeah?"

"Drink some water. This fringe is strong."

John Lockheed said, "Yes, you're not used to it," and
passed Clave the water gourd. Clave drank, and drank
again. Rather was given a gourd, and he couldn't under-
stand how he had become so thirsty.

Then Carlot was there and it was all right, and Rather
was free to go to sleep.

Kendy saw them streaming toward the log like a covey
of brightly colored birds: young men and women stretched
like taffy. Wings patterned in primary colors flapped be-
hind, making them seem even longer. Each pattern was
different. Birds must find each other in the sky.

The helmet microphone picked up giggling and
snatches of talk. Some flew with skewed clumsiness,
drunk on alcohol or other recreational chemicals. Kendy
ran the record again, but the noise factor was too great;

the words wouldn't come clear.

They passed out of the helmet's view and were gone.

Chapter Sixteen

High Finance

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 926 State

CHECKER

OFFICER RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ATTITUDES AND
EMOTIONAL WELL-BEING OF THE CITIZENRY, AND FOR
THEIR BENIGN RELATIONSHIP TO THE STATE.

BOOCE STARTED TEA WHEN HE SAW THEM COMING. HE

looked them over as they entered. Nurse Lockheed had

the giggles. Her brother was furious.
Booce smiled at them. "Half Hand's?"
"Right. Fringe tea." Carlot wasn't happy.
"It was strange," Debby said. "We ate ... well, we

tried everything. Clave made a list—"

"I hope we can afford it all," Clave said. "Where'11
205




206 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 207

we grow it? We'll have to plant the out tuft and make the
lift cables twice as long."

The teapot went among the half-dozen dumpers who
had returned with Logbearer's crew. In a dozen breaths
it was empty.

"Jonveev was kind enough to lend me some stuff,"
Booce said. "The teapot, some blackbrain, some cook-
ware. Carlot. . ."He frowned. She should have brought
supplies from the Vivarium and the Market shops.

She handed him a translucent blanket-leaf folded
lengthwise. There was food within: vegetables, a slab of
cold moby meat, and a baked sweet potato. "Half Hand
gave us credit."

"That'll be breakfast. Jonveev fed me."

John Lockheed sensed what was happening. "Many
thanks, Booce, and we'd best be going."

Raym showed his astonishment. "We just got here!"

"Raym, now. Come on, Nurse. Booce, we're sorry
about your trouble, but it didn't ruin a good evening. It's
good to see you-back safe. Carlot—" He stretched his
toes to clasp hers. Then the whole covey of dumpers
moved out into the rain, shooing Raym and Nurse ahead
of them.

"Now why did they do that?" Clave asked.

"They know we have to talk about money. You don't
do that in front of strangers," Booce said. "All right,
Carlot."

"Zakry won't give me credit. We'll have to forage the
trunk for food. I went to Dave Kon. He still owes for a
klomter of wood from our last trip. He wouldn't pay me.
He offered full payment if we'd sell him a klomter off the
new log at two times ten-square. I turned him down."

"Right. That mutineer thinks we can't afford to hire a
judgment! See, Clave, the Admiralty won't convene a
civil court unless both sides can prove that they can pay
court costs. Loser pays. But the Navy knows we have

the Wart! One way or another, we'll get money or credit.
Carlot, I think I know what Hilar has in mind. Burl."

Carlot thought it over. The tree dwellers watched with
no sign of comprehension. She said, "Risky. Nobody
knows how."

"Hilar can afford to take the chance. He brought his
tree in with the tuft still on. He asked for a loan and of-
fered decent terms. Usually the tree dies, but some-
times—"

Debby suddenly said, "I remember. The idea is to let
a tree grow without tide. The wood's supposed to twist
into knots?"

"Right. But trees aren't really built for that. I wonder
if Hilar knows something? If he can get money to live on,
he can grow his burl while we sell our wood. He'd like
to get the money from us, if we had it."

"We should be asking Jeffer about this."

Booce grimaced. Then: "Sorry. Debby, you're tree
dwellers, you should know a lot about them, but you've
never seen a tree growing outside of tide."

"You wouldn't grow burl yourself, stet? Belmy's not
a fool or he wouldn't be richer than you, stet?" Booce
bridled, but Debby went on. "He knows something you
don't, something about burl. Jeffer the Scientist knows a
lot we don't. Let's ask."

"Burl," Jeffer said musingly, watching the faces in the
bow window. Debby was hiding anxiety. Booce had asked
his question with some belligerence. This had been her
idea, not his. Are you any good at all? Prove yourself,
Scientist!

Blue lines of print scrolled across the faces.

INTEGRAL TREES GROW WELL IN A WIDE RANGE OF
TIDES. LOW ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE KILLS THEM
PASTER THAN LOW OR HIGH TIDE. IN DENSE AIR AND
VERY LOW TIDE THEY MIGHT SURVIVE. IN FREE-FALL




208 / Larry Niven

THEY DIE. OTHERWISE WE WOULD FIND TREES GROWING
NATURALLY IN THE CLUMP.

Booce was talking. "Hilar thinks he's got me by the
seeds. He offered me a loan if I withdraw my tree from
sale, but he's not serious. It'd break me. I'd be paying
interest, and no way to get it back. Of course he doesn't
know about the Wart metal."

"Do you really need to know if he can grow burl?"
Jeffer said. "Booce, you're satisfied that he's trying it.
You only need a short-term loan till you can sell your
metal. The Belmys aren't your enemies, are they?"

"No, they're friends. Who would I talk to if I couldn't
talk to other loggers? But Hilar would love to have me
carving the dumbo on my sticks, and all the loggers want
to be richer than, say, the architects. Jonveev won't loan
me money unless she thinks I can pay it back. Or if I've
got some kind of collateral . . . hell."

A TREE SHOULD CONTINUE TO GROW IF THERE IS SUF-
FICIENT TIDE TO PULL WATER AND NUTRIMENT INTO THE
TREEMOUTH AND TO WORK THE INTERNAL VEINS WITHIN
THE TRUNK. SPIN THE LOG, JEFFER.

"Tell them about the Wart," Carlot was saying.

"I didn't want to. I guess . . . I've got to. It'd be better
if I knew exactly what Hilar's planning."

"He'll spin the log," Jeffer said.

"What? What for?"

"Spin tide. Clave. It's a scientific thing. Here, pick up
that pot or whatever and throw it round and round your
head. Ann's length . . . like that, stet. Feel the pull? Like
tide, isn't it? Belmy'll use his steam rocket to start the
log spinning, not enough to tear it apart, just enough to
keep some pull inside the tuft. The tree needs tide to move
its food around—"

THE SMOKE RING / 209

"By the State, I believe you're right."

"But the, uh, growth patterns would still be screwed
up, with Voy going round and round and weird Clump
tides going every which way. I've never seen burl, but
isn't that what you want, Booce? Grain that doesn't grow
in straight lines? He'll spin it just enough to keep water
and fertilizer in the treemouth."

"Yes. Okay."

LOSING CONTACT.

Hilar and Jonveev waited, wearing polite smiles, until
Booce had finished talking. "Burl," Hilar said. "It
sounds interesting but risky."

"Hardly cost-effective," Jonveev said.

Booce said, "There are other values. It would be in-
decently lucrative if it worked. You'd have done some-
thing nobody else could." They did not comment, and he
went on. "Let's assume, just for talking purposes, that
you've been considering a burl tree. Who else would you
let in on the secret?"

The Belmys looked at each other.

"You'd need masses of tree food. Mud, say, from deep
in the Dark. Would you buy it from Zakry? Or haul it
yourselves, with WoodsmanT'

Jonveev sighed. "All right, Booce. What have you got
in mind?"

"Logbearer could haul the mud to feed the tree. The
whole Market knows that my last trip failed. They won't
be surprised when Logbearer becomes a Dark diver. Let
them think I'm looking for fringe and blackbrain while I
haul mud for Zakry."

"Mmm," said Jonveev.

"One thing more. I've got eight kiltons of metal buried
under the termites."

Their faces were quite blank. After a moment Jonveev

210 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 211

said, "That's not portable money. You still can't offer us
a loan, not until you sell it."

"An excellent point. Hilar, Jonveev, what I want is
this. First, you do your damndest to turn that half tree
into burl. Second, I need a loan—"

Hilar was laughing.

"A short-term loan to let me spend money like an old
Dark diver while I wait for the Navy to buy my metal.
I'll pay twenty percent to the crossyear, and I need ten-
to-third chits. I'll pay part of it back in mud at the same
price Zakry pays. The rest at the crossyear, and I'll hand
you another five times ten-to-third. That'll save any
project you had to shortchange. It's not a loan, though.
It buys me half the burl."

"Half!" Jonveev exclaimed.

"So."

Caught! Jonveev Belmy laughed and said, "We hadn't
thought of spinning the tree. But can you really afford to
risk that many chits? You're moderately rich now. Why
not stay that way?"

"I like the odds. I've got some crew who think it might
work, and they're tree dwellers. I think you think it'll
work, and that helps."

"Two-fifths of any burl, and we want five times ten-
to-third chits. We'll get you your loan, but at forty percent
to the crossyear. Mmm . . . I'll hand you our cash on hand
and give you the rest in ten days."

Booce said, "I'll pay thirty percent to ... to ten sleeps
past the crossyear. The Navy might just hold me up for
that long. And classify this. If the Navy knows I took a
loan, they'll know I'm still under pressure. I want them
to move."

Hilar laughed. "Where else could it have come from?"

"I'll visit the house before I start throwing money
around. They'll think I had it in the house."

And all of this was reported in garbled form, through

Clave and then Jeffer, who had never dealt with finance,
to Kendy, who never had either. But Kendy had sketchy
records of the capitalistic societies that had died with the
formation of the State, hundreds of years ago.

It was a hell of a way to run a civilization. These people
needed him.

Jeffer, seated before the CARM camera, asked, "Do
you understand any of this?"

"Yes, but it would be difficult to explain. What matters
is that your citizens will have their earthlife seeds."

"Yeah." Jeffer stretched unself-consciously. "That's
good. We'll have to talk fast when we get back to Citizens
Tree. The seeds'll help, and we'll carry fresh food too,
something they can eat right then. Are you getting what
you wanted?"

What Kendy wanted was still beyond his reach. He
said, "I've learned some things."

"Tell me."

"The Admiralty is self-sufficient. They're a successful
culture, but the crime rate must be high. Otherwise they
would need fewer Navy ships, and the houses would have
more openings." Kendy displayed the picture the pres-
sure-suit camera was sending from the Clump. Small
green outlines flickered as Kendy pointed out ships, then
the few but massive doors on nearby houses. "They've
settled the outer shell of the Clump, but they only venture
gingerly into the dark center. Their infant mortality rate
must be as bad as yours. When they add up their popu-
lation they don't count children, any more than you do."

"I never noticed that. Hmm . . . London Tree didn't
either. Is it because so many children die?"

"Yes. Wait a thousand years and the death rate will
have diminished. There's nothing else to be done."

"I never thought there was. While I've got your at-
tention, Kendy, I found a listing on the Clump. Lagrange
points, it's called. What do these words mean? Equipo-
tential, saprophyte— Something's happening."




212 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 213

A steam rocket emerged from the fog and rain. It came
to a halt fifty meters from the helmet camera. "Navy,"
Jeffer said unnecessarily. "I wonder . . . that's Booce.
And a silver suit!"

"I see them. An equipotential is the curve on which
some force or energy level is everywhere equal. It might
be gravity or tidal force or magnetic force. A -saprophyte
is a family of plants that don't use light. We'll see some
if Clave can take the helmet into the Dark."

Four men flew toward the camera: two in Navy armor,
one standard-issue pressure suit, and Booce Serjent. The
pressure suit was better kept, cleaner and shinier, than
the Citizens Tree suit. There were big Navy-style fins at
the ankles. The design painted on the back was repeated
on one shoulder and on the fins: a broad green ring with
a blue dot at the center.

Kendy tried to make contact with the suit radio. He
found nothing. Either it wasn't on, or the frequency had
wandered over the centuries.

The helmet was thrown back on its hinge despite the
rain. The face inside was a rounded anglo face, without
the soft elfin look of most Smoke Ring citizens: a "dwarf"
face, shaved, sprouting an Earth day's worth of dark
shadow.

The "dwarf" looked around him. '"This was clever,
Booce. Do you have torches?"

"I'm sorry, Captain-Guardian. We can make some
up."

"No need. How do I get through this muck?" The
dwarf had no accent.

Kendy gloated. No accent! He spoke exactly as a State
citizen would have. The officers must learn their speech
from the Admiralty Library!

They were drifting out of view. Kendy switched to the
fisheye lens. He and Jeffer watched the Captain-Guardian
take his wings off and tether them to lines on his chest,
shin-sticks uppermost. The two lower-rank Navy men

pulled up an edge of the termite nest. The "dwarf"
squirmed in. Sudden yellow light flashed through the hole.

Jeffer asked, "Does that light come from the pressure
suit?"

"I'll show you how to work the helmet light. Later."

The "dwarf" popped out of the hole. "There's a re-
spectable store of metal here. We'll have to wait for the
Council to convene before we make an offer per kilton
delivered. Unless you're prepared to accept an immediate
offer of, say, two times ten-to-fifth chits for the whole
chunk?"

"I can get two or three times that on the Market."

"Perhaps. If we come to an agreement I can give you
payment within ten days."

"No, thank you, Captain-Guardian. I'll wait. Maybe
I can earn some money Dark diving. Can I offer you tea?"

"You wouldn't want to have to sell your new house.
Two and a half."

"No. I should point out that you've been seen coming
here. There's a happyfeet jungle in dock, and they might
guess what that means. Also I'll be expected to hire an
exterminator. I can't hide the metal much longer."

The Captain-Guardian snorted and waved to his escort.
They departed.

Booce waited until they were well away. Then he
moved face-on to the camera. "Jeffer?"

"Here."

"That was Captain-Guardian Wayne Mickl. Officer by
birth, but his effective rank is Guardian. Keeping him
happy is a good idea."

"He didn't look happy."

"If he's too happy, we got robbed. Jeffer, how sure
are you that spinning a tree will make burl?"

Jeffer laughed. "I never tried it myself."

"Yeah. Are you all right?"

"It isn't too bad. Something like being young again,




214 / Larry Niven

just old enough to hunt alone. I've got the cassettes when
I get bored. I miss Lawri."

"Well, I'm going to move the silver suit. We can't
leave it here."

"Where, then?"

"My house. I'll set it up so you can see the commons
room. We can talk any time, and when I have guests you'll
see them too."

"That's good," said Jeffer.

VERY GOOD. LOSING CONTACT.

Chapter Seventeen

Serjent House

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 6 SM:

SHARON LEVOY SPEAKS OF THE ARCHETYPAL RE-
BELLIOUS COMPUTER, HAL 9000, FROM GILLESPIE'S

OPERA 2001. CAROL BURNES CLAIMS FRANKENSTEIN
AND FAUST TO BE OLDER AND MORE APPROPRIATE IM-
AGES. ONE-UPMANSHIP IS ALIVE AND WELL IN THE
SMOKE RING. ONE AND ALL, THEY EXPECT ME TO TELL
THEM HOW IT HAPPENED.

FOR THE RECORD: I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S WRONG
WITH KENDY.

—CAPABILITY JASPER GRAY
CYBERNETICIST, DISCIPLINE

DEBBY WAS IN A HURRY THE NEXT MORNING. IT SEEMED

she'd arranged something at Half Hand's: she was to meet
Grag Maglicco for flying lessons. Booce drilled her to
215




216 / Larry Niven

make sure she wouldn't get lost in the sky, then sent her
on her way.

The rest shared out the meal from Half Hand's for their
breakfast, then got to work. They fueled and fired Log-
bearer and set it steaming along the trunk. A half turn
brought the rocket to a halt opposite the Wart.

Clave, Carlot, and Rather swarmed out and attacked
the termite nest with matchets. When Logbearer blocked
the Market, and floating chaff and chips of bark and wood
blocked most of the sky. Clave and Rather ducked into
the nest. Clave retrieved the body of the silver suit. Rather
the helmet. Booce had kept the rocket hot. He jetted
water into it, and away they went.

Secrets. Rather was starting to get the knack of it.

Half the termite nest had been scraped away, not by
a hired team but by amateurs. What would the Market
think? Booce must be hurting for money. His crew has
exposed damage to the log: a gaping, ugly hole behind
the termite nest. They've quit in disgust. Unlikely that
anyone else would pry into that bug-infested darkness.

The house had drifted about the sky since its comple-
tion a year and a half since. Debby had relayed Grag's
message: it was fifteen klomters skyward and some de-
grees to spin from the Market. The house was closer than
it had been when Grag spotted it, but it was still a three-
day trip.

The house was five cubes arrayed around a concrete
core. A small puff jungle grew on the roof. The main door
was a huge slab of wood five meters long by four wide,
half a meter thick. Booce set massive triangular braces
to lock it vertical to the doorway. Mountings covered the
inner surface: tethers for wings and cloaks, and coils of
line, and big knobs to serve as moorings for winches and
pulleys.

They tethered Logbearer to the door. In its shadow
they moved the silver suit and helmet inside.

THE SMOKE RING / 217

Secrets. What has been seen? Logbearer flies to Ser-
jent House. The crew stays for some hours while Booce
inspects his new home and shows it off to visitors. Pres-
ently Booce will be spending money.

Navy: Booce has retrieved funds from some hiding
place. He can outwait the Navy to sell his metal.

Belmy House: Booce came as misdirection.

The Market: Any hiding place in Booce's house must
be empty now.

"Where do we put it?" Rather held the helmet like a
severed head.

"Look around," Booce said. "Something will occur
to you."

The citizens smiled at each other. They began to tour
the house.

Doorways led from one section to another through the
star-shaped concrete core. There were only two ways to
move. Rather had to squeeze past Clave circling the other
way.

The house was roomy: as big as a Citizens Tree hut,
though much harder to build. The public room was lined
with handholds and with hooks for outer garments and
weapons, and a rack for a teapot.

The outer wall of the kitchen had long slots in it for
ventilation, a concrete fireplace with a bellows attached,
and racks for wood and cookware. Rather found Carlot
making tea. He asked, "You already know?"

She nodded brightly.

The sleeproom: tethers and some wiry foliage padding
four of the walls.

What was this next room? Curtains fixed across both
interior doors, handholds and tethers mounted next to
small windows with hatches over them . . .

Ah. This was the treemouth. And the fifth was a stor-
age room, with another oversized door and moorings for
tethers, but nothing stored yet.

Rather returned to the public room.




218 / Larry Niven

Debby was moving slowly around the perimeter. She
seemed more cheerful than she had been lately. "Hi,
Rather. Grag brought me back. I gather we're looking for
some secret hiding place. Any luck?"

"Not yet. Booce, how do you get rid of the treefodder
after you feed the tree?"

Booce stared. "What? —Oh. The wind floats it away
and fisher jungles gather it in. Now you know why every-
one doesn't just tether his house to the Market. Find any-
thing?"

"I didn't see any hiding places. I've never seen a house
before."

"You were all somewhere else, so I searched here,"
Debby said. "Nothing. Booce, are there holes in the con-
crete?"

Booce laughed. "I could have done that. Access
through the walls? Well, any burglar could tear the core
apart and all he'd find is concrete and two chunks of spor-
ing fringe buried along the hub. Meanwhile, what do you
think of my door?"

' 'Thick. Like you're afraid someone might kick his way
through."

"We tend to make them massive. Not just for burglars.
It has to stand up to rough treatment when you're moving
heavy stuff."

Clave shook his head in disgust. "We'd know who our
thief is. We'd kick him into the sky. Booce, your trouble
is, you've got too many people in the Clump."

Booce was taken aback. "I never thought of it that
way. Anyway, let me show you what I did—"

When the door was fully open, one could slide aside
a panel in the edge that faced the hinges. The half-meter
thickness of the wood had been hollowed out. The silver
suit went in easily. The helmet was barely small enough.

"Now we need a hole," Booce said.

"Kendy for the State. Jeffer, would you rather sleep?"

THE SMOKE RING / 219

"Mpf? No. Hello, Kendy." Jeffer stretched. "If I
didn't want you waking me up I'd sleep outside." He
looked at the view in the bow window. "Oho!"

It was dark, but Jeffer could make out Clave's anxious
face. His voice sounded faint, distant. "Jeffer? Talk to
me, Jeffer."

"Prikazyvat Relay to pressure suit. Scientist here."

"What do you see?"

"You. And a ragged border. What did you do?"

"You're looking through a hole in a door. Booce ripped
a hook out. From here it looks like he just put too much
tension on it."

"Good enough. I take it we can talk. Rather, you
there?"

Rather floated into view, smiled, and waved. Others
joined, until five citizens floated in a star with their heads
inward.

Booce said, "I've made a deal with the Belmys. Jeffer,
would you like to learn something about the Dark?"

"You mean the Clump interior? Sure."

"That's good, because I've agreed to bring back some
mud for Belmy's burl tree."

"You're going? All of you? LogbearerT'

"Ah ... no. I think I'd better stay here. I've been
weaving financial threads into one very complicated net.
Carlot, you can handle Logbearer alone, stet? And I
gather Raym Wilby is at liberty. He can guide you." Car-
lot was nodding eagerly. "Oh, and Hilar hadn't thought
of spinning the burl log, but he's going to try it."

"Sounds good. Carlot, will you take the helmet so I
can see these marvels?"

Carlot looked to her father, who said, "Why not?"

"Good. Rather, tell me about the Navy. Take your
time."

Rather talked. Kendy guessed that the boy wasn't hid-
ing anything, but he kept jumping back and forth. Kendy
printed questions across the bow window; Jeffer solicited




220 / Larry Niven

descriptions of Petty Wheeler, Bosun Murphy, Navy
armor, the Navy ship, Murphy's description of Navy life,
Wheeler's offer . . .

"Is this standard, Booce? Anyone can join the Navy?"

"Not just anyone. They wouldn't have Carlot because
of her legs. Otherwise . . . well, any savage could join,
but he might not get beyond Spacer First until they've
watched him for years. The Navy wants loyalty. They
take more men than women, and they won't take you if
you're too old to be trained."

"Loyalty?"

"If you're loyal to your tribe, you're not loyal to the
Navy. Navy above all, even family."

"The question is, if Rather goes in, can he get out?
Booce?"

Booce mulled it. "Up to a point. It would be ... con-
venient if Rather let Petty Wheeler make his pitch.
Rather, the Navy could put certain kinds of pressure on
me until I talk $ou into doing that. They want the Wart,
but they can slow things down for me, and we don't want
the Navy taking a hard look at us."

"No," Clave said.

"But when Wheeler interviews you, he might leam that
you're simply not suited to Navy life. I can help you to
help him reach that conclusion."

Carlot said, "He could get out later than that. Rather,
my cousin Grag says they treat you like a copsik in Basic,
but after that you're supposed to think you're better than
the citizens. They do think they're better than us, and
they don't take just anyone. When you're ready to leave,
just do something wrong. Or get sick and stay sick. Tree
dwellers do get sick in the Clump. They'll bounce you
out."

"You think I should do this?"

She shrugged unhappily. "Whatever you want."

Jeffer said, "'I'd really like to get him into the Library."

Booce shook his head. "No dwarf gets beyond Guard-

THE SMOKE RING / 221

ian unless he was born an officer, and even then . . . well,
Wayne Mickl is officer and dwarf. They need him as a
Guardian, so he'll never use his higher rank. Guardian is
the lowest rank that can reach the Library, but they can't
use it because they aren't taught to read. And you
wouldn't be a Guardian for years, Rather."

Jeffer jumped on it. "But he could reach the Library.
And Rather can read, and I can teach him how to use a
CARM keyboard!"

Rather was feeling trapped. He knew how to talk to
Jeffer the Scientist, but how could you argue with a door?

"I hate to pass up the chance," Clave said. "Rather,
you're reluctant. How do the rest of you feel? Debby?"

"It feels like we're selling him as a copsik. I'm against
it."

Thank you, Debby!

Clave stared at her. Then: "Rather, does it feel like
that? I wouldn't do that. We're just talking now—"

"They want his loyalty, stet, Booce? They've been
doing this for going on four hundred years," Debby said.
"Maybe they can get his loyalty—"

Clave snapped, "Treefodder, Debby. London Tree
was keeping copsiks for about that long. When the chance
came to bust loose, they did it!"

"Not all of them, Clave!"

". . . Uh-huh. Booce?"

Booce said, "We're talking about power. Navy power,
and it cuts two ways. If Rather was Navy, the Serjents
would see a certain friendliness emerge. I'd love to put a
son in the Navy."

"Carlot?"

She spoke to Rather, not Clave. "If you can stand it.
Remember what I said about Basic. They worked Grag's
tail off... hey. You're stronger than Grag. You lived in
a tree. You just might give them a shock."




222 / Larry Niven

"We know you can fit a silver suit," Booce added.
"Even Bosun Murphy doesn't know that."

"I'm scared."

Clave just nodded, but Jeffer snarled like static. "Oh,
Rather! We're here already! Back in Citizens Tree, that
was the time to be scared." Pause. "What are you scared

of?"

"It's all too strange." Rather was suddenly, unbear-
ably homesick. This wooden house, all angles—

"It'll keep being strange. Nobody fooled you on that."
"Scientist, I came here looking for strange. I wouldn't
be here if it was going to be just like Citizens Tree—"

"Then—"

But Rather had the words straight in his mind now. "I
followed you here, but the idea was to face the Admiralty
in the company of my friends and my elders! And my
father. Are we all going to join the Navy now? Is that
what we're talking about?"

Clave said, "Jeffer?"

The door said, "I'm for it, of course, but the boy's got

a point. It's his risk, not ours."

Rather wasn't finished. "You're asking me to swear
to something that isn't true. I am not loyal to the Navy.
If you thought I was, you wouldn't like it."

Nobody wanted to answer.

"You can feed your secrets to the tree. I will not join
the Navy. But I can go talk to Wheeler, if you think it'll

help. I'll do that."

"I go with him," Debby said firmly.

"And Booce, you tell me how to look unsuitable." A
black depression was settling over him. He felt rejected
by all of his companions save Debby; but Carlot wanted
him out of the way. For Raff Belmy.

Chapter Eighteen

Headquarters

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 384, day 2050:

JEFFER THE SCIENTIST SPEAKING. CANDIDATES ARE
CONSIDERED UNSUITABLE FOR THE NAVY IF THEY ARE
SICKLY, OR UNDEFENDABLE, OR EASILY LOST OR DIS-
TRACTED, OR LOYAL TO SOME ENTITY OTHER THAN THE
NAVY. THEY MAY HAVE UNACCEPTABLE MOTIVES FOR
JOINING. IF A FAMILY MEMBER ACCOMPANIES, CANDI-
DATE MAY BE RELUCTANT OR MAY NEED SUPERVISION.

ACCEPTABLE CANDIDATES WOULD PRESUMABLY
HAVE OPPOSITE TRAITS. DATA ARE AS ACQUIRED FROM
BOOCE AND CARLOT SERJENT.

HEADQUARTERS WAS A PILLBOX: A SHORT, WIDE CYL-

inder, blurred to Rather's weeping eyes. The rim was dark
wood. The nearer flat face was concrete covered with a
variety of doors, platforms, winches, coils of line . . . and
223

224 / Larry Niven

a broad strip of glittering stuff very like the hull of the
CARM. Two rockets were moored near the hub. A third,
larger, was being winched in nozzle-foremost.

Debby looked back. Rather was far behind. When she
stopped flapping, a gust of wind caught her wings and
turned her on a random axis. She sighed and flapped back
to rejoin him. "I wish I could help," she said.

Rather made himself laugh. "I did it to myself. Debby,
you fly better than me."

"I watched the crew when we went to Market. Keep
up a steady kick. Don't try too hard. If you kick with all
your might the wings just bend and don't take you any-
where."

"What I need is longer legs."

"Longer wings might do it. Try the Navy wings too.
Now, what door did Carlot say?"

"I can't tell. Pick one."

"No, I—"

"Debby, pick one at random. I don't mind if Wheeler
thinks I got lost."

"Oh. The one in the middle, with the guards. We'll

ask them."

It was big and round and rimmed in scarlet paint. The
four guards wore helmets and torso and leg armor and
carried harpoons. Debby backpedaled to stop within a
meter of the harpoon points. She said, "Looking to join

up."

One smiled and said, "I hope they take you, beauti-
ful." His harpoon pointed. "That one, just next to the

rim."

"Thanks." She rejoined Rather. Half blind, he'd been
afraid to fly close to sharp spears. "It's over there. —
Lovely beard on that one. Like goldenwire plant, and
clean. The .crew keep themselves cleaner than Carther
States people ever did. Maybe I'll see him again."

"Jeffer'd like that."

THE SMOKE RING / 225

"He would, wouldn't he. He probably likes my seeing
Grag too. I wonder what they're guarding?"

The door they sought was a rectangle with curved
sides, marked in print along one edge: RECRUITMENT.

The room within was sizable, but of the same odd
shape. A man made marks on thin white sheets fixed to
a slab of sanded wood. His pants and tunic were blue with
Navy markings. No armor. He ignored them for a bit,
then looked around. "Yes?"

Rather pointed to the wooden rectangle. There were
clips along the edge, and stacks of paper leaves in the
clips. "What would you call that?"

The man frowned. "You never saw a desk before?
What do you want?"

"Petty Mart Wheeler wants to interview me for re-
cruitment. I'm Rather Citizen."

"I'll see if he's available." The man kicked against the
table and disappeared down a corridor. Lack of wings
didn't hamper him: he touched the wall and disappeared
into a doorway in one smooth flow.

Debby smiled at Rather. "Easily distracted?"

"That's why I did it, but look at how the grain of the
wood curls around! I think it must be burl. How did they
get it?"

"There had to be burl somewhere or Booce wouldn't
know it was possible."

When the desk man reappeared, Rather was mopping
at his eyes with his tunic. The man said, "Come with me."

Debby said, "May I come too?"

"I'm afraid not. Would you be his mother?"

"Stepmother. I really think I ought to be with him."

"That's not permitted."

The office was small, a cube with two curved walls.
Petty Wheeler was at a desk, lightly gripping the rim while
he talked to another man . . . and that one was Rather's
height.

226 / Larry Niven

Their talk stopped. Wheeler said, "Rather, good to see
you. This is Captain-Guardian Wayne Mickl."

Mickl nodded but said nothing. He seemed relaxed and
disinterested. Wheeler said, "We want to ask you a few
questions. You probably have questions too—"

"A hundred. Urn, whereabouts is Bosun Murphy?"

"Mpf? Last I saw of her she was on her way to the
Purser's office. After that she'll be on leave. . . . Why?"

"I thought I might see her before I go."
.  (Booce had told him, "Try to talk to Bosun Murphy.
Your interest in the Navy comes straight from your seeds.

If you see her, make a pass."

("What's a pass? Do you mean propose marriage?"
("No . . . yes. That's got just the right touch. All seeds

and no judgment.")

Wheeler asked, "Rather, is there something wrong

with your eyes?"

"They get this way sometimes."

"When?"
"Lack of sleep. Dry air." His eyes were clearing up

now, but they still hurt. To Wheeler they must appear
pink and weeping. He was sniffling too.

Wheeler took writing implement in hand. "Where were

you born?"

"Citizens Tree, year 370. It's a tree sixty klomters

long, six or seven hundred klomters west of the Clump."
"What's your height and mass?"
"One point nine meters. I don't know my mass."
' 'We'll weigh you on the centrifuge. How did you know

the year?"

"The Scientist keeps track. Was I off? This is 384, isn't

it?"

"That's right. Put your arms straight forward, finger-
tips touching. Now your legs, big toes touching."
Wheeler made a note. "Symmetrical. How much do you
know about the Admiralty?"

"Not much. We tasted some of the food you grow and

THE SMOKE RING / 227

had a wild dinner at Half Hand's Steak House." Wheeler
laughed at that. Rather went on, "The Serjents told us a
lot. I've seen houses and the Market. The ride on the
steam rocket was—well, I've never been through any-
thing like it."

"Scary?"

"No, not that." He knew instantly that he should have
said yes.

"Why do you want to join the Navy?"

"I came to find out if that was true. Petty. And you
asked if I had questions."

Petty Wheeler stiffened a little. "Well?"

"I've seen the ships. They're all over the sky. I think
I ought to ask, if I become a Navy man, will I in fact be
riding one of those ships?"

"More than one, I expect. Over the years you'll fly
every style."

"Will I be flying them, or just riding them?"

"You've given this a lot of thought."

"Yes sir. Once I thought I'd be a hunter for Citizens
Tree." No need to mention the silver suit. "When I joined
Booce and went logging, that was a big jump. I didn't
know what I'd find here. The Market, it's frightening to
think such a thing could be built. So many people!"

Wheeler was smiling, nodding. (In the corner of Rath-
er's eye, Wayne Mickl was clinging to a wall tether,
merely observing.) "Daunting, is it?"

Rather nodded.

"The ships, the Market, Headquarters, we built them
all. And more. We built a civilization," Wheeler said
gently. "Now that you've seen it, how can you not be a
part of it? Yes, you'll fly a ship before you're much
older."

"I want to know whether I'll be able to visit Citizens
Tree."

"Mph. The answer's yes, but I don't know how often.
We'll want to contact Citizens Tree at once. Set up some

228 / Larry Niven

form of trade. There'll be visits, and you'll be useful as

an intermediate."

It was the right answer, Rather thought, except for two
things. The tree was in the wrong place; and if the Navy
did find it, the citizens would have to hide the CARM
every time the Navy came visiting.

So Rather only said, "That's good. I'd hate to be cut
off from my family." (Booce had said, "They want your
loyalty. They won't like it if you're loyal to your family,

your tribe, me—")

"How often do you get these allergy attacks?"
"Usually just when the air's too thin. I had them while
we were moving the log; we were too far in. It's like
knives in my eyes. I haven't been getting enough sleep
lately. It happens then too."

"Would you describe yourself as sickly?"
Rather told himself that nobody would come to a re-
cruitment office if he considered himself sickly, and said,
"No. It's just something that happens. A day later I'm
fine. It's almost over now."

"I see. All right, Rather. Go ask Able Jacks to put you
on the centrifuge. We'll get in touch with you through
Booce Serjent."

Debby and the desk man were ignoring each other.
Debby seemed nervous.

"Rather! How'd it go?"

"Fine. Are you Able Jacks?"

"That's right."

"You're to take me to the centrifuge. What's a cen-
trifuge?"

"I'll show you."

The wicker structure resembled the treadmill that ran
the elevator in Citizens Tree. It was wider: twenty meters
across. Rather was instructed to cling to the rim and wait.
Two ratings spun it up, timing it with a hand-held device.
The wheel rolled eccentrically with his mass to throw it

THE SMOKE RING / 229

off. A rating measured the divergence of the hub. ' 'Your
mass is eighty-one kilgrams," he said.

They locked the centrifuge in place and made him run.

Pushing himself round the rim gave him the sensation
of tide. They had him run as fast as he could. It made him
dizzy; the tide became fiercely strong. Then they made
him slow down and run at a measured rate, until his legs
burned and his eyes blurred. He would have stopped then
if he had not noticed Bosun Murphy watching him.

He waved. The motion almost sent him tumbling. She
didn't respond. But she watched, and he ran.

... It came to him that he was rolling around the cen-
trifuge. He'd blacked out.

A rating snatched at his ankle and pulled him out.
"Take a rest. Here." He handed Rather a towel, and
Rather, gasping for air, mopped a sheath of water from
his body.

Murphy said, "That was quite a performance. I could
win bets on you."

"I grew up in a tree."

"I know."

There was no animation in her voice, her face, her body
language. Navy thinks they're superior, Carlot had said;

but that wasn't it. "Bosun, are you all right?"

"I'm a little down," she said. "Call me Sectry, Rather.
I'm not on duty."

"Does down mean something like miserable^,"
"Yeah. Guys, are you finished with him?"
"He's all yours, Bosun. No need to be careful, he ain't
fragile."

Sectry Murphy flashed them a fleeting smile. To Rather
she said, "I can't picture the Petty rejecting you after he
hears about that performance."

Tree/odder. Booce hadn't thought to tell him to hold
back on a stamina test. "What's got you down?"

"Not here, stet? I need someone to talk to, not Navy.




230 / Larry Niven

I just came from the Purser's and I'm ready to tie one on.

Want to join me?"

"I'm with Debby. My stepmother."
"Stet. Let's go get her. How does Half Hand's

sound?"

Rather was coming down the corridor. There was a

woman with him.

Once upon a time Debby had seen Rather and Mark
talking in the Citizens Tree commons. Both dwarves, but
they hadn't looked at all alike: Mark's face nearly square,
Rather's nearly triangular . . . She remembered it now,
because Rather and the dwarf woman looked right to-
gether, though they were clearly from different branches

of humankind.

And both, in different fashions, looked worn out.

Debby asked, "What happened to you?"

Rather said, "Centrifuge. They ran me to death. I
could have lifted an elevator all the way to Discipline.
Debby, you remember Sectry Murphy—"

Clasping toes felt odd: Sectry's reach was so short, her
toes so stubby and strong. "Hello, Sectry. 1 take it you're

off duty."

"Right. On our way to Half Hand's. Join us?"

"Sure."

Sectry led them in. "The place is nearly empty," she

said.

It wasn't. There were a good dozen people scattered
around Half Hand's. But windows were clear, and Sectry
led them to one. "It's nice to have a view," she said over

her shoulder.

Rather flinched. Debby grinned; she'd seen Rather
watching Sectry's kicking legs.

"Grab a pole, someone will come. You hungry?"
When one of the women from the kitchen appeared, Sec-

THE SMOKE RING / 231

try said, "Fringe tea and sausages for three, Belind. You
two should try the sausage."

"Stet," Rather said. "What's got you down?"

The false gaiety ran out of her, and Debby saw pain.
"I've been trying on pressure suits. I don't fit."

Debby said nothing. Rather said nothing.

"They don't let you try the suit till you qualify for
Guardian in all other respects. So they got me into the
small one and I couldn't breathe." Murphy wasn't wear-
ing armor now. Her breasts stretched her tunic tight.
Debby had never had trouble feeding her children, but her
own breasts didn't have that vulnerable look. "I could
have faked it, but the suits aren't all quite the same size.
So I tried the bigger suit. My feet wouldn't reach the toes.
There are controls in the boots. My fingers don't quite
reach either."

"That leaves one," Debby said.

"The large? It's in use. It won't fit. If my damn toes
were longer! I'm out. I can't be a Guardian."

Belind was back.

Sausage was a tube seared around the outside, deli-
cious inside: ground meat with bits of plants added. Fringe
tea Debby knew from last night. She still had a trace of
the morning headache.

The situation felt uncomfortable, and Debby was re-
hearsing excuses to leave. She asked, "Are you going to
stay in the Navy?"

"I think so. I'll never get further than Bosun, though."

"You'll be flying. More exciting than guarding the Li-
brary."

"As a Guardian I could spend some time making a
home! Get married, carry some guests!"

"Don't they mind Navy people making babies?"

"You go to half pay when you're showing, but you've
got a mate working . . . and even if you don't, Navy pay
is good." Sectry drank deep. She hadn't touched her sau-
sage.




232 / Larry Niven

Rather asked, "Sectry? Why would someone like the
Captain-Guardian be interested in a recruit?"

"Wayne? That's easy. If he can get enough dwarves
at Guardian rank, he can move up to Captain. He's got
the rank but not the duties. Him, he'd be better off if he
couldn't fit a pressure suit."

Debby took the rest of her tea in two gulps. "I've got
to be going. Thanks, Sectry. I shouldn't have come in.
I'm supposed to be buying stuff at the Vivarium, now that
we've got money."

"Well, remember you're on fringe," the redhead said.
"Watch the prices."

"I'll be careful."

Outside, Debby let herself smile.

How would Rather handle it? Let Sectry believe that
he'd come to the Navy only to get close to a lovely dwarf
woman?

It might even be true.

A sheet of rainwater clung to the window. A blurred
puff jungle drifted past.

Rather had finished his sausage. Sectry passed him half
others. When Belind came past she ordered more fringe
tea. She asked, "How do you like the Clump?"

"It's mostly strange. Too wet, for one thing. I think I
could get tired of boxes. Huts in a tree aren't like that.
Sectry, why did they build Headquarters round?"

"It was built to spin."

"Spin?"

"The early officers, they thought we'd need tide to stay
healthy. They gave that up early. They couldn't dock a
ship while Headquarters was spinning, and it tended to
wobble. So they stopped the spin and they built the ex-
ercise room, centrifuge included. Those early Navy men
must have been monstrously strong. But it turns out we
don't get sick. We still use the exercise room, though."

The fringe tea was fizzing in his blood. Sectry Murphy

THE SMOKE RING / 233

seemed to glow. His mind was trying to follow a dozen
paths at once. It suddenly seemed very natural that the
early men would move a tree into the Clump, spin it, try
to settle the tufts, get the benefit of tide and the clustered
resources of the Clump. . . and produce the burl that later
generations hadn't been able to duplicate.

At the same time there was a strangeness in what Sec-
try had said . . . and then he had it. "How do you know
all that? Booce told us about the Library. He said only
officers' children are taught there."

"Wayne told me."

"Oh."

"We were together for a while. I never thought he'd
marry me, I'm not an officer, but when he ... What I
was saying, he told me a lot of history. The Library used
to be part of a starstuff rocket. We've never built anything
like it."

"What does it look like? Where—"

She shook her head; her hair spread around her like a
flaming halo. "I never saw it myself. I'd like to. I wonder
if I could talk my way past the guards ..."

Guards. That door.

Voices and vision were turning strange. Sectry glowed;

she was the Smoke Ring's most beautiful living thing.
Rather took a firm grip on his equilibrium. Offering to
make babies with a high-ranking Navy officer now seemed
presumptuous beyond insanity. Carlot had warned him:

she might be badly offended. Yet he'd never seen a
woman like her.

"Then he married a woman three meters tall and thin
as a feathersnake. She's got a face that would scare away
a drillbit, and when she carries a guest she looks like a
line with a knot in it. But she's an officer."

"Money."

"Mmm? No. Rank."

"Money," Rather said distinctly, "is why Carlot is




234 / Larry Niven

going to marry Raff Belmy." He was losing control of his

mouth.

"Oh. The dark girl, Serjent's daughter?" A smile flick-
ered and vanished, but Rather caught it. "That's rank

too."

"You saw us."

"Yeah." The smile was back.

"Do you have rank?"

"I'm a Bosun. Crew."

"Do I have rank?"

"No. What's this all about? If you want rank you join

the Navy. Then you're crew."

"Would you marry me then?" His mouth was running

away with him. Fringe.

She laughed. She was trying to stop, and ultimately

she succeeded. "We just met. How old are you?"

"Fifteen."
"I'm twenty-eight. Where do you want to live?"

"Citizens Tree. Any tree."

"Carlot probably wants to live in the Admiralty."
"To the treemouth with Carlot."
"I do too."

"Make babies with me," his mouth said.
She thought it over, while Rather tried to think himself
invisible. She said, "Right."

A score or so of puff jungles were in view. Some bore
logos. They chose one that didn't, and circled it to be
sure. "Quietly now," Sectry said.

"Nobody here but us flashers."

"If we scare flashers out, some meat eater might come

after them."

He wiggled through the foliage in her wake. Nice to

have a view. The puff jungle was hollow in the middle.
A thousand flashers edged warily away, flashing blue and
yellow wings at them.

THE SMOKE RING / 235

They balled their clothes and threw them at the flash-
ers, causing great excitement.

The birds perched in a shell around the hollow, watch-
ing them. She was just his size. She knew more than Car-
lot: delightful things. There were moments in which
Rather resented that knowledge. Others in which he was
shocked. His body knew things his mind hadn't dreamed.

They rested . . . running hands and toes across the
sweat-slick contours of stranger's flesh, learning each
other. Smooth muscle. Hair red everywhere. Fingers and
toes stubby like his own. Either of Sectry's breasts fit
nicely into his two hands.

"We could go back and forth," she said. "Live some
in the Clump, some in your tree."

"Do you mean that?'' As the fringe died out of his brain
he began to wonder what he had committed himself to.

"Who knows? Don't ever make decisions when you're
on fringe." Suddenly Sectry wriggled out of his arms. She
snatched up her wings and eeled through the foliage and
out. Rather followed, curious and horny.

Only her head poked into the sky. Flashers wheeled
there, and something much larger circled thirty meters
away. Sectry asked, "Want to see something funny?"

A wedge with teeth. "Get back." He pulled at her
ankle. She had donned her wings. "That's a Dark shark.
Carlot showed me."

"We try to keep them out of the Market region." She
thrust herself into the sky, naked; waved her arms and
yelled. The Dark shark froze. A window came open in a
nearby cluster of cubes. The beast charged.

Rather didn't have his wings. He called, "Sectry! Dark
sharks aren't funny!"

The long limber torso whipped back and forth too fast
to see. The narrow triangular wing was a rippling blur.
Sectry turned and kicked hard. She dived into the foliage,
whooping, pulling Rather after her.

They were in the hollow center.




236 / Larry Niven

"Are you nuts?" he bellowed, and she laughed. Then
the Dark shark burst through in a shower of leaves and

splintered wood.

All Rather could see was teeth. His own wings were
out of reach. He set his feet against a branch and watched
the predator. Which way to jump? Flattened head and the
forepart of a thrashing torso, three big crescent eyes, a
thousand pointed teeth . . . the eyes beginning to show
panic. Sectry couldn't stop laughing.

The beast was stuck.

Rather asked, "You do this a lot?"

"Sure. We don't like Dark sharks." She wrapped her
arms and legs around him and laughed into his face.

The predator snapped its teeth at them, raging and im-
potent. Sectry murmured in his ear. "Gives it a kick,
doesn't it?"

Debby was tired. She was flying blind, pushing bags
of about her own mass, with no more than the strength
of her legs. From time to time she stopped to look past
her burden. The Serjent log grew larger.

Logbearer had dropped Debby and Rather near Navy
Headquarters on its way to the Serjent log. Now Debby
found the rocket moored near what had been the out tuft.

Two days' time had wrought wonderful changes.

A skeletal cylinder perched atop the fuel pod. Men
were all over it, placing planks, driving pegs into wood.
Booce floated nearby, watching contentedly. When he
saw Debby coming he donned wings and kicked to join

her.

"No problems?"

"No problems," she said. "Zakry wanted money. I
just went down the list and paid him what I had. Here,
there's some left. I don't think I got cheated. I've only
got half the seeds here. We're supposed to get the rest
within five days. Where do we store all this?"

"Not in Logbearer. There'll be paint fumes."

THE SMOKE RING / 237

They lined the seed bags along a crack in the bark and
ran tethers across them.

More men approached, pushing a cylinder of wooden
beams. Debby watched as they maneuvered the lumber
toward Logbearer. She called, "Ho, Clave! Learning a
new trade?"

Clave joined them. He smelled of hard work. "I'm
learning it, but I don't like it. Too nitpicking. Every board
has to be just the right size, just the same thickness."

"I got the seeds."

"Good. Booce, isn't this a bit of a luxury? Don't we
have other concerns?"

"Like selling my wood? This'll show off its quality!
I'll paint my logo, but I'll leave most of the wood bare.
I'll cruise past the Market and anyone can see I've got a
good tree."

The hired crew were fixing panels on the long cylinder.
Clave, rested, resumed work. Some of the panels were
on swivels: windows. The sun swung behind the Dark;

the day turned gloomy. When the sun reappeared, passing
within a degree of Voy, one whole flank of Logbearer
was finished.

A shadow flapped out of the sun and became Carlot
with her arms full of gear. Debby flew to help her. Carlot
was pushing cooking utensils and a slab of smoke-black-
ened moby meat. She asked, "Where's Rather?"

"I left him in Half Hand's with Sectry Murphy."

"Mmm."

They stored the gear near the bags of seeds. "We'd
better do our cooking here tonight," Carlot told her fa-
ther. "That paint's awful stuff." Booce agreed.

Carlot asked, "How did Rather do? I keep forgetting
we want him to fail."

"Yeah. The way Sectry Murphy was acting, he made
some kind of endurance record on a big wheel. Somebody
should have thought of that."

"Me," Booce muttered.




238 / Larry Niven

"Might not matter. They seem to want him bad."
The cabin formed with remarkable speed. Now men
were pegging crossbars across the bow ... for pushing
against a log? Two men produced gourds; wind brought
a noxious chemical reek. Booce excused himself and went
to supervise while they painted the finished flank ofLog-

bearer.

Cariot asked, "What was he doing with Murphy?"

"You remember your father said—"
"Yes, and I said she might be seriously offended. He

didn't actually make a pass, did he?"

"Not while I was there. She's in a rotten mood. They
put her in a pressure suit and she didn't fit."

"That's bad."
"She wanted to blow her mind out on fringe tea, and

she wanted company. I left them alone. Treefodder, Car-
lot, if he does get Murphy mad at him, what'll she do?

Keep him out of the Navy!"

"... Yeah.'' Cariot began setting her gear up for cook-
ing. She worked with furious energy.

Debby watched. Presently she asked, "Cariot, are you

going to marry Raff Belmy?"

"I don't know. I just spent a couple of days with Raff
aboard Woodsman. He seems—he takes it for granted
we'll be married. He's so sure, he hardly mentioned it."

"So? It's what you told Rather."

"I know. Where is he?"

There were beams left over from the making of Log-
bearer. Clave brought them an armload. Cariot arrayed

them and started a fire.

Booce paid off the hired crew and they departed. His
own crew went to inspect the altered rocket. Booce was
exuberant. Clave was proud. Debby made appropriate
noises. Logbearer had been repaired in just four days.

The paint was well done, she thought. She wasn't qual-
ified to judge' woodwork. The cabin was as big as the pod,
roomy for half a dozen. Booce and Clave began the fin-

THE SMOKE RING / 239

ishing touches: setting knobs and moorings into the hull,
outside and in. Booce wanted particular patterns . . .

The fire was going well: a dim globe of heat, nearly
invisible while both Voy and the sun bathed this side of
the log. Cariot sliced the moby meat into two slabs. She
set sliced vegetables between the slabs, locked them to-
gether with wooden pegs, and tethered it all within the
fringe of the flame.

A distorted blue-fringed black man-shape swam across
Voy.

"Rather! Where have you beenT' Cariot shouted.
He reached the bark. "I'm in deep trouble," he said.
"Where's the Chairman?"

"Working on the rocket. What kind of trouble?"
"Cariot, maybe you can tell me." Rather looked be-
wildered, a little frightened. "I'm afraid I've gotten my-
self in deeper than I wanted."




Section Four

THE DARK
AND
THE LIGHT

Chapter Nineteen

The Dark

from the Citizens Tree cassettes, year 54 SM:

WE'VE HAD SERIOUS ARGUMENTS ABOUT WHY
KENDY CUT CONTACT. MAYBE SOMETHING JUST
BURNED OUT SOME CIRCUITS. MASS DOES CONSTANTLY
RAIN OUT OF ORBIT ONTO VOY—MAKE THAT LEVOY'S
STAR, MY APOLOGIES TO SHARON. A BIG INFALL
WOULD CAUSE BIG MAGNETIC STORMS, MAYBE BIG
ENOUGH TO BURN OUT DISCIPLINE'S COMPUTER, AND
THE THICK SMOKE RING ATMOSPHERE WOULD STILL
SHIELD US. I HATE TO THINK SO. I LIKED KENDY.

THAT SOUNDS CRAZY. A COMPUTER PROGRAM . . .
I CAN'T HELP IT. KENDY HAD LESS IMAGINATION THAN
THE TURKEYS. I TRIED TELLING HIM A JOKE, ONCE AND
NEVERMORE. BUT I ADMIRE DEDICATION, AND KENDY
HAD AS MUCH DEDICATION AS A MAN CAN STAND. I'M
GOING TO LEAVE THIS IN.

—DENNIS QUINN, CAPTAIN
243

244 / Larry Niven

BOOCE HAD BOUGHT A SMALL PUMP. RATHER WAS

working it to fill Logbearer's fuel tank. A Navy ship was
doing much the same on the other side of the pond. Water
had to be shared, this close to the Market. Greetings had
been exchanged, and now the two crews were ignoring

each other.

Cariot said, "Raym's been running messages for Dave
Kon and Mand Curts. They'll know where he is. You'll
have to track him down, though."

"No problem," Booce said. "How did he lose his

rocket?"

"I didn't want to ask. He's far gone on fringe spores,
Dad. We want him, but I don't want him in charge of

anything."

"Fine. Rather, stop, it's full."

Rather began packing up the pump and hose. "That
was quick," he said, remembering how long it took to fill

the CARM.

"A pretty good pump for something that's all hard-
wood. Let's get going. Cariot, you drop me and Clave at
the Market and then go on to the house. Clave, you get
the rest of the seeds. I want to buy us some clothes.
You're all still wearing tree-dweller pajamas."

"You'll bring Raym?"

"I'll send him to the house. If he's too fringey to find
it, I don't want him aboard any ship of mine."

Rather had not found the chance to confide in anyone
but Debby and Cariot. Maybe that was good. Booce
seemed to take it for granted that he would stay where
the Navy could find him. Rather's plans were quite dif-
ferent.

Would Cariot help him? He wasn't sure. The way she

was acting—

The Market swarmed like a hive. When the rocket
came near, a dozen citizens separated from the pattern
and flew to look. Booce delayed his exit for dramatic rea-

THE SMOKE RING / 245

sons. When he emerged he was surrounded. He stayed
to talk, and Cariot joined him. Clave grew bored and
flapped off toward the Vivarium at the far rim. Booce took
an order for a thousand square meters of wooden planks
. . . and the sun crossed half the sky and was behind the
Dark before Logbearer moved on.

Serjent House continued to drift. It was now radially
out from the Market. The Dark eclipsed the sun; Voy
shone from the side. Half violet, half black, the cluster
of cubes made an eerie sight.

"We'll have to tell Clave," Debby said. "First chance
we get."

Cariot said, "I'm still not sure about this."

Rather said, "Booce was right, wasn't he? I want to
look undependable. So—"

"They'll think you had Dad's permission!"

"The Navy doesn't own me. Booce doesn't own me.
Even you don't own me, Cariot, and if you're holding me
as a copsik I want to know it so I can think about es-
caping!"

"No, I don't own you." The ship was turning, dece-
lerating. Cariot was very busy tending the rocket, too
busy to look him in the face. Her voice was almost in-
audible. "But it was a fool stunt, running off to make
babies with that Navy woman."

"You're going to marry Raff Belmy."

"I said probably. Skip it. It was a fool stunt. So tell
me this. Does Clave own you? Your Chairman?"

". . . Maybe."

"So ask him whether you're going."

"I want to talk to Jeffer too. And one other."

"You keep hinting—"

"You'll see for yourself. You too, Debby. I am tree-
feeding tired of keeping secrets."

A random comet had impacted Levoy's Star. It had
reached the surface as a stream of gas moving at thou-




246 / Larry Niven

sands of miles per second. The neutron star had rung like
a bell. There were two hot spots on the rapidly spinning
body, at the impact point and the point opposite, where
the shock waves had converged. The violet ion streams
that normally rose from the magnetic poles of Voy, which
natives called the Blue Ghost and Ghost Child, were
brighter than Kendy had ever seen them. Radiation was
beginning to sleet against Discipline's hull.

But Kendy spared instruments for the CARM.

He ran the record as it came in. Jeffer had been idle:

not much there. The house had been empty most of the
time. Ah, here was something—

The motley collection of metal and plant tissue the sav-
ages called Logbearer bumped the wall nozzle-first.
Rather, Debby, and Carlot emerged. They tethered the
steam rocket to the door, close enough to block the sky.
Rather said, "Jeffer. Come in, Jeffer."

Jeffer had been reviewing records from the cassettes.
He set up the link. "I'm here. Hello, Debby, Carlot,
Rather."

"I'm in trouble," Rather said.

"Tell me."

"Petty Wheeler interviewed me for the Navy."

"How did it go?"

The depth of Smoke Ring atmosphere was blocking
most of the radiation and X-rays, and Kendy's instru-
ments too. He could still watch events on the star itself
via neudar. A plasma cloud hovered over the impact site,
several centimeters high and spreading at terrific speed
along lines of magnetic force—

Rather said, "Scientist, I did everything right except
only two things. I did what Booce told me. I slept in the
silver suit with the humidity turned low, and got there
sniffling and crying. Debby came with me, and I really
did need supervision. I could hardly see where I was
flying. I asked for Sectry Murphy: all seeds and no brain,

THE SMOKE RING / 247

stet? But Booce didn't tell me not to show off my muscles,
so I did."

"You're strong but sickly."

"And I'm a dwarf. If enough dwarves get into the
Navy, a certain Captain-Guardian Mickl gets to act like
an officer. I'm quoting Sectry. Mickl was there to watch
the interview."

"Two mistakes. Did you suggest marriage to Bosun
Murphy?"

Laughter, chopped off. "We got high on fringe tea.
Then we dived into a puff jungle and—" Quick sidewise
glance at Carlot, whose face was like stone. "Jeffer, none
of us ever thought she might take me up on it. Now she
thinks I'm joining the Navy and making plans to marry
her. Maybe she can hold me to it!"

"This is not to your taste?"

"Sectry ... I don't know. I don't want to join the
treefeeding Navy and I don't know how to tell her that!"

"Okay, I'm thinking. . . . Rather, they already know
you're allergic. Let them train you. Carlot said they
don't give you much sleep in training. Stay awake

even when you don't have to. Get sick a lot. They'll
give up."

"I thought of something better."
"Listen—"

"No, you listen. I went running to Carlot and Debby.
Help, I said. I'm in trouble, I said. The Navy wants me.
What do I do? And we talked it over, and what I want to
do now is talk to Kendy."

Jeffer's medical readings showed his shock. Kendy
stopped paying attention to the impact on Levoy's Star.
Paydirt!

"Rather? You told them?"
"I'm letting you tell them. You and Kendy."
"Kendy isn't in range yet. When he gets the
record—"

Carlot said, "Kendy the Checker^"

248 / Larry Niven

"The same," Jeffer said. "Kendy made contact with
us fourteen years ago . . . fifteen now. I made a mistake
with the CARM. Kendy told us how to get home. We
didn't hear from him again till... well, it was just before
you showed up, Carlot. He wanted this expedition."

Debby was seething. "Jeffer, you treefeeding muti-
neer! What game did you think you were playing, hiding

a thing like this?"

Carlot exclaimed, "You can't deal with the Checker!

We know all about—"

The record was finished. He'd reached present time.
Kendy printed I'LL HANDLE IT across the bow window in
front of Jeffer. He sent, "We told Clave. Rather was
there, so we told him too. Hello again, Debby. Carlot,
it's a pleasure to meet you at last. Rather, you did the

right thing."

"And I suppose you'll try to talk me into joining the
treefeeding Navy! But I won't do that, Kendy. I want out

of this."

Rather wasn't aboard the CARM. Kendy couldn't get
medical readings; but he sensed truth here. Never give
an order that won't be obeyed! Try something else . . .
while Discipline moves steadily out of range. Wrap it up
fast, but wrap it tight—

Kendy asked, "Rather, what are you planning?"

"Remember Booce telling me to look undependable?
The Navy expects me to stay in touch. I'm going Dark
diving. Carlot and Debby and Clave are taking Logbearer
to get mud for Belmy's burl tree. I'm going with them."

"Just to look undependable?"

"It's not a crime. Sectry'll hate me, and I don't like
that, but it'll get me off the harpoon."

Kendy finished putting details on his own plans. The
speed of his thoughts was one powerful advantage to
being a computer. It helped win arguments too. He said,
"That's good, but it's not enough. Not if this Wayne
Mickl wants you so badly. We need to get you out of the

THE SMOKE RING / 249

Clump entirely. Mmm . . . Rather, I think I may have
something. Booce was planning to take the helmet with
him so that Jeffer and I can see the Dark. Still true?
Carlot?"

"Stet. Dad wants it out of the house."

"Good. Take the whole suit. Take Rather too. Go into
the Dark. Rather, the suit's fully fueled. When you're out
of sight of the Market ..."

They heard him out, looking at each other. The silence
that followed lasted only five or six seconds, but Kendy
found it excruciating. Then Jeffer asked, "How long have
you been planning this?"

"About thirty seconds . . . twelve to fifteen breaths.
I think faster than you do, Jeffer."

Carlot's voice held doubt, not anger. "It's mutiny—"

"We steal nothing," Kendy said. "We won't harm
the Admiralty at all. The information doesn't disap-
pear, but I can read it, and then it becomes available to
Jeffer the Scientist. Rather, Debby, don't you see?
We came to learn. Clave and Jeffer won't leave until
they know what to tell Citizens Tree about the Admir-
alty. This way we'll learn everything we want in half
a day."

Rather said slowly, "You say you can tell me how to
do this."

"I've taken neudar readings. I can see the gross struc-
ture of Headquarters. It's most of a CARM surrounded
by a concrete shell." The neudar shadow of the CARM
was splayed around its aft end, and the back third
was missing. The explosion must have pulped any pas-
sengers. It had ripped away the outer door of the airlock
too. "The Library must be the control room. I'll
guide you. We'll time it so I'm in contact the whole
time. Even if someone sees something funny, it'll be too
funny. He won't believe it. Afterward you take Log-
bearer home."

Carlot looked at Rather. "I don't owe you this."




250 / Larry Niven

"Losing contact," Kendy said. There might have been
time for three words more, but what would they have
been? He'd simply have to wait.

The redhead found Booce as he was returning from
Market. She looked funny, flying. Her legs chugged faster
than a normal woman's and made shorter strokes. She
wouldn't have caught up if Booce hadn't been pushing
baggage.

She wasn't breathing hard, though. She had a charming
smile. "Booce Serjent, do you remember me?"

"Bosun Sectry Murphy. We met when Gyrfalcon came
to collect customs. How do you do. Bosun?"

"I do okay. Rather's been accepted for training. I'd
like to tell him."

Rather wouldn't like that. "He'll be at the house."

"I'll come. Shall I help with those?"

They kicked slowly along. Behind them the Dark
moved in uneasy turgid patterns, out and east; the sun
crept toward Voy; western rain clouds crawled in long
curves. To fill the silence Booce said, "We've finished
repairing Logbearer. After breakfast we cruised past the
Market—"

"Moving slow. I saw it."

"Clave went for the rest of his seeds, and I picked up
some clothing and toothbrushes. Can't have my crew
looking like savages."

"My superiors may be wondering where you found the
money."

"It's not easy. The Navy's taking its own sweet time
to bid a decent price for our metal. But I've got some
orders for wood, and my crew is going Dark diving."

"Did Rather say anything about . . . yesterday?"

"Not to me. He didn't seem to want to talk. It must
have been a strange experience."

She laug'hed, then grew pensive. Presently she said,
"Isn't that Serjent House?"

THE SMOKE RING / 251

"Yes, but . . ." Logbearer wasn't there.
Booce invited her in. The Navy woman waited while
he made the circuit of the rooms. He found nobody. There
were no seeds: Clave hadn't arrived yet.

"They must have left already," he told her. "I stayed
to bargain for wood. Clave should have come back well
ahead of me." It was puzzling.
"Was Rather going with them?"
"No. He should be back soon, wherever he is."
She accompanied him to the kitchen and watched while
he made tea. They returned to the common room and
passed the pot between them, all in near-silence. Booce
wondered if Jeffer had noticed the Navy woman. What
they really needed right now was a metallic voice bellow-
ing out of the door.

"You'd think he'd leave a message," she said.
Booce nodded. But they'd have left it with Jeffer!
Murphy was frowning. "Is it normal for Rather to do
. . . something like this?"

Booce was quick on the uptake. "He's never done this
before. Well, he's been worried about whether the
Navy'11 take him. Maybe he got terminally antsy. A trip
to the Dark—" And Booce knew he was right. If they
think you're undependable— Rather had gone into the
Dark.

"—could be just what he needs," he finished.
"It's not what we need." Murphy rejected the offered
teapot. "How long do you expect them to be gone?"

They weren't seriously hunting treasures such as fringe
or blackbrain. All they wanted this trip was mud, so—
"Thirty, forty days." But they wouldn't have left without
Clave, so they must have taken the seeds he was carrying
too. Why?

"Tell Rather we're unhappy. Booce, I've got to be
leaving."

Booce hovered at the door to watch Murphy depart.
He whispered, "Jeffer?"




252 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 253

Nothing.

Of course, they took the helmet too. He waited until
Sectry was no more than a speck before he opened the
compartment in the door.

The whole damn illegal pressure suit was gone.

For one magical moment he was nothing but relieved.
But something was going on here, and Booce didn't like
it at all.

Carlot made her burn with the bow pointed straight
into the Dark. East takes you out, out takes you west.
That a rocket might go where it was pointed was contrary
to Rather's experience; but he didn't want to argue with
Carlot.

The Market passed them at impressive speed. A few
citizens turned to watch, and were gone.

Raym Wilby had never kept silence in his life. "This
first part of a trip is fun, but you can still get hurt. Carlot,
the tank's near dry, stet? Turn us. Cut the water flow.
Go in facing sideways."

Carlot looked at him.

"See, if something comes at us, you run the last of the
water in. Doesn't matter what way you're facing, long as
it isn't forward. Something's ready to hit us, you change
course. If it's gonna miss, you don't."

"Oh." She and Clave tilted the nozzle. Log bearer
started its turn as she cut off the water flow. The slow
turn continued as the sky began to darken.

"Birds are the worst. A pond, a glob of mud, a jungle,
they don't follow you if you dodge. Everybody got har-
poons? Stet. Hey, smell that. First whiff of the Dark.
State, it's good to be back!"

Logbearer fell straight in. It was like entering a huge
storm cloud ... a granular-looking storm cloud. The air
smelled of wet and rot and mustiness.

They strung'line, using beams on the nose as mooring
points. Raym watched and frowned and told them to put

the lines closer together. "It's got to hold the mud while
you make the burn." When they finished, Logbearer's
nose was the center of a great web. "I always string my
extra clothes across the middle of the web. That way you
know the mud won't go through and all over the cabin.
You bring any extra clothes, Carlot?"

She spoke through gritted teeth. "You didn't tell me
to. But yes, I brought extra clothes, and I don't much like
getting them covered with mud."

"So wash them after. You do it when you're ready to
leave. Then you use what's dirty. Look there, aft of cen-
ter. Kerchiefs!"

Kerchiefs looked like a score of scraps of pink and
green cloth afloat on the wind. "Those're flowers," Raym
said. "Not fungus. They'll—"

"Could you spread those to hold the mud?"

"Carlot, they're not strong enough. Touch them and
they shred. Hey, you don't mind dirty clothes when
you're Dark diving!"

They took turns sleeping. The sky thickened and dark-
ened over five or six days. Then Voy and the sun were
hidden and it was impossible to know day. Rather's eyes
adjusted. He saw colors emerging from the dark: blue
tinges, green, orange. Behind them the murky sky was a
blaze of light, suddenly bluer as Voy passed, too bright
to look at.

Raym was forward, inspecting the web again. Or
maybe he only liked the view.

Clave said, "It isn't the risk that bothers me. It's the
fact that I'm not taking it. Feels like this should be my
job."

Rather didn't answer, but Carlot did. "Oh, you're tak-
ing a risk. If Rather gets caught, the Navy'11 want us all.
Clave, it's not too late to change our minds!"

"Yeah. I know how persuasive Kendy is. And I think
I should have been consulted." Rather started to speak.




254 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 255

Clave snapped, "Yes, Rather, it couldn't be done. Be-
sides, Kendy's right. It gets us everything we came for.
Rather, if you don't come back in a decent time, we're
leaving. I've got the seeds. We'll just bum straight out
and let Jeffer find us in the sky."

"Stet," said Rather.

"And what about Dad?" Carlot demanded. "Why
should the Navy believe him when he tells them he didn't
know?"

"I won't get caught. One big risk and we go home."

"I don't owe you this," Carlot said, as she had said
before. This time nobody answered. (But Jeffer had said,
"You owe Citizens Tree for your life," and it was true.)

"I think we've gone far enough," Clave said. "No-
body's going to see us from the Market."

Rather nodded. "But there's still Raym."

"He's easily distracted."

The rocket had slowed considerably. They were drift-
ing, not flying. The murky sky was busy with soft, shad-
owy shapes. Once there was a jagged rock the size of
Logbearer, half covered by ... Rather stared. That had
to be a fungus. But it was convoluted like the moby's brain
Half Hand had tried to serve them.

Raym pointed through the net of lines. "You can eat
that."

Clave said, "Treefodder! I mean literally. That's a tuft
off an integral tree!"

It could have been, Rather thought. There was the
curved blade of the branch. But where foliage should have
been, now there was a great misshapen lump of soft gray
curves. "I pushed one of those home once," Raym said.
"Had to. My nets were torn up. It was all the food I had
left, and I barely made a dent in it getting home. Half
Hand served slices of it for the next twenty days, but he
didn't pay much . .'."

Rather tuned him out.

The orange tinge ahead grew gradually stronger.
Orange light shining through shadows. Rather had grown
used to the wet, musty smell, but something else was in
it now. "Raym, what's that?"

"I've been living with Exec ever since the accident.
My son, Exec Wilby. He only went into the Dark but
once— What?"

"That."

"That's the fire. Carlot, we have to turn."

Carlot jerked around. "Fire?"

Now Rather knew that smell. Fire burning in some-
thing wet and rotten.

"It's been burning down here since ... I don't know
when. All my life, anyway. Never gets much bigger, never
gets much smaller. Now, don't hurry. Look around and
find a pond and steer for that. We need more water any-
way."

They looked. There was no mistaking the shape of a
pond, of course, even in darkness. Rather found no sphe-
roids in evidence. Carlot said, "I don't see anything!"

"There."

"But that's . . . oh." Raym was pointing to a fungus
jungle, a maze of thick white threads . . . and the orange
light glinted off something reflective inside. The mass, in
fact, was mostly pond, but it was laced with fungus.

Clave used the bellows. The pipefire that had been es-
tivating in the windless murk now blazed up. Carlot blew
the last of their water into the pipe while Rather and Clave
tilted the rocket.

The fungus jungle drifted across the orange light. Log-
bearer impacted softly against resilient fungus fingers,
and recoiled.

"What kind of pump you got? Good. Boy . . . Rather,
you want to pump?"

"You pump, Raym," Carlot said. "Debby, you go
with him. Keep your harpoon handy."

"Stet, that's good thinking, Carlot. No guessing what's




256 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 257

lurking in there." The imaginary horrors didn't diminish
Raym's enthusiasm as he flapped away with the pump.
The hose slowed him. Debby kissed Rather's cheek be-
fore she picked up a loop of hose and flew after him.

Raym disappeared among interlocked white strands
that broke where he touched them.

Clave said, "Now, Rather."

They entered the cabin together. The bags of seeds
nearly filled one compartment. Rather pulled them out,
reached further, and had the silver suit.

Debby saw only kicking wings among finger-thick
white pillars of fungus. "Nothing dangerous yet," Raym
called cheerfully. "Watch for stinkbirds. Great State!
Girl, get me a bag, a big one!"

Debby dropped the hose and worked her way in.
"What—"

"Fringe!"

"Oh. Here." She'd taken to carrying the big bags
they'd used to collect honey while logging. She passed
one in. She couldn't see what Raym was doing in there,
but the air had turned dusty. She sneezed.

Raym wriggled out in a cloud of dust motes. There was
something shapeless in the bag. "Sixty, seventy chits
worth," he said. "I'll just take this back—"

"I've linked up the hose. What have you got?" Carlot
had come at his shout.

Raym showed her the bag.

"Dammit, Raym, that's sporing fringe! Debby, get
away from it."

"Yeah.'' Debby kicked out into the air. She was feeling
dreamy. . .light-headed. . .happy. But if she'd breathed
spores, Raym must have breathed more.

Keep him away from the ship! Debby pulled on the
hose until she had the pump. "Raym, take this around to
someplace else and start pumping."

"I'll take this back," Carlot said. "Raym, you

shouldn't get near sporing fringe! Sure it's worth
money—" She gave up. Raym was laughing.

Clave had stuck the helmet to a wall with a dab of glue.
It watched him in stoic calm. "Try to do the circle in one
sweep," it said.

"Is that how the original was done?"

"First painting was probably a template, but templates
wear out. The suits must be painted over and over. Every
so often the junior Guardian has to paint it. I'm guessing,
of course, but the original looks a little sloppy in Kendy's
pictures."

Clave pointed the brush like a pencil and moved in a
single graceful sweep. The resulting greenish-white circle
wasn't half bad. "Bring it close," said the helmet. "Too
narrow and also a little small. Go around again and add
some bulk to the outer rim. Rather, when you leave, drape
a cloth over yourself. We don't want to get it dirty while
it's wet. . . Stet, Clave. Now the dot in the middle. Stet,
leave it tiny. Give me another look at the shoulder—"

"Raym found you something, Silver Man."

Clave jumped. "What? Carlot, don't do that."

"Rather, take it. It's sporing fringe. Bring it back if
you can. It's worth money."

Rather took the bag. "What's it for?"

"If you're in trouble, throw it. Everyone around you
will have a wonderful time while you get away. Make sure
you don't breathe it."

"Oh. Thanks."

"Sure."

"I'm ready to go."

There was something more that he ought to say, some-
thing she expected, but he couldn't for the life of him think
what it was.

"You get tired, I'll take over," Debby said.
"No, no, the tank must be nearly full by now." Sweat




258 / Larry Niven

slicked Raym wherever his skin showed. He was grinning
and panting and pumping his legs with the vigor of a much
younger man.

The tank must be full already, Debby thought. They
wouldn't let Raym stop until—

Raym stopped. "What was thatT'

Debby turned to where he was looking. "I don't see
anything."

Tiny twin flames burned in the Dark, receding.

"Huh." Raym resumed pedaling. "Hope that isn't the
fire getting closer. You never know where it's gonna be.
It doesn't just drift like everything else, it spreads in spots
and goes out in spots—"

Carlot called from the rocket. "Raym! Enough. Let's
go find our mudball."

Chapter Twenty

The Library

from Discipline'.? records, year 926 State:

YOUR ORDERS ARE AS FOLLOWS.

1) ... YOU WILL VISIT EACH OF THESE STARS IN
TURN. OTHER TARGETS MAY BE ADDED. WHERE APPRO-
PRIATE YOU WILL SEED THE ATMOSPHERES OF PROTO-
EARTH WORLDS WITH TAILORED ALGAE USING THE CAN-
NISTERS YOU CARRY. THE STATE EXPECTS TO SETTLE
THESE WORLDS, SPREADING HUMANITY AMONG VARI-
ABLE ENVIRONMENTS, AGAINST DANGERS THAT MIGHT
AFFECT ONLY SOL SYSTEM.

2) THE STATE IS AWARE THAT YOU DO NOT REQUIRE
A CREW TO OPERATE.

THE HUMAN SPECIES IS NOT INVULNERABLE. THERE
IS FINITE RISK THAT THE CREW OF ANY INTERSTELLAR
SPACECRAFT MAY FIND, ON ITS RETURN, THAT IT HAS
BECOME THE ENTIRE HUMAN RACE. YOUR CREW AND
THEIR GENES ARE YOUR PRIMARY CARGO. CLASSI-
FIED.

259




260 / Larry Niven

3) YOUR TERTIARY MISSION IS TO EXPLORE. IN PAR-
TICULAR, ANY EARTHLIKE WORLD WITH POSSIBILITIES
FOR COLONIZATION MUST BE INVESTIGATED AND RE-
PORTED IMMEDIATELY.

—LING CARTHER, FOR THE STATE

MATTER WAS TOO THICK IN HERE TO USE BOOT JETS.

Rather used them to get clear of Raym's sight, then
donned his wings. He wanted to fly straight north, along
the axis of Clump and Smoke Ring both. Matter should
thin out rapidly in that direction.

There were no ponds; but sometimes you could catch
a glint of light from one of the fuzzy-edged fungus jungles.
There were white pillow shapes, and flat white lenses
streaked with yellow and crimson, and networks of in-
terwoven pale stalks. He took care to avoid touching any-
thing; he flew around clouds of dust or spores. The paint
on him would still be wet.

Rather began to understand the beauty Raym found in

the Dark.

Straight lines, rare in a tree, were unheard of here, save
(rarely) for long beams of blue-white or yellow-white sun-
light breaking through the murk. Where he saw these, he
corrected his course to cross them. This close to cross-
year, north would be at right angles to Voy and the sun.
After what felt like a couple of days he was seeing many
more. The Dark had grown rarified. Now there was room

for jets.

He fired a burst of five breaths' duration.
Mist flowed past him as he coasted out of the Dark.

The day brightened. Too bright. His eyes were slow to

adjust.

"Jeffer the Scientist calling Rather. Can you hear me

yet?"

Jeffer's voice was scratchy. Rather turned up the vol-

THE SMOKE RING / 261

ume. "Reception isn't good, but I'm hearing you. I'm
nearly out, moving north, coasting. The rest of us are in
good shape. How long till we get Kendy?"

"A quarter day to spare. Rather, did you bring wings?"

"Yes."

"Good. You can't approach Headquarters on jets. I
didn't think of it."

"I did."

"I have you located. Make your burn now. You're well
north of the Smoke Ring. The air's thin, it won't slow you
much, but in less than a half day you'll be back in the
plane."

"I know, north and south bring you back. So. How
long a bum? What direction? I'm well and truly lost."

"I'll time you. Three minutes, about sixty breaths. Can
you see Voy? The Market is ten degrees west of out from
you, and you have to cross four hundred klomters. You
didn't actually get very far into the Dark."

By now he'd fallen into clear air, with the Dark spread
out below. Rather wriggled to point his feet ten degrees
east of Voy. He would move nearly at a tangent to the
flow patterns in the Dark.

He lit the jets. His body tried to sag into his boots.
The Dark skimmed below him, a storm with granulations
in it, and sudden red and golden and purple glows where
the sun shifted just right. Jeffer counted aloud and told
him when to fall free.

Flying. The Dark was thinning out, but coming closer
too. He skimmed through the fringes of a raineloud—

"Kendy for the State," said the familiar deep voice.
"Rather, are you on schedule?"

"No problems. Expedition's in good shape. Raym will
probably swear I was there the whole time."

"Repeat after me. 'There's a respectable store of metal
here.'"

"There's a respectable—"

262 / Larry Niven

"Try to say it like I did. Listen a few times. 'There's
a respectable store of metal here.'"

Rather deepened his voice and tried to spit the sylla-
bles. "There's a respectable store of metal here."

They rehearsed "You wouldn't want to have to sell
your new house," and "I need to consult the Library,"
and "I relieve you." Rather was lethally sick of it when
Kendy quit. "It'll have to do. Try to be in a cloud when
you sight Headquarters. Don't make your approach with-
out me."

"Right."

"I've displayed a neudar map of Headquarters for Jef-
fer. He can guide you if I'm out of range. Back in two
days. Kendy out."

"Jeffer?"

"Here. Rather, you should try to sleep."

"Sleep?"

"Nothing natural can hurt you in the silver suit. Sure,
sleep. You'll be less hungry. You've got no food."

"I'll give it a try."

He slept not a wink. The turning of the Clump spiral
caught him up and he had to make a correcting burn.
Houses and decorated puff jungles passed, none close
enough to see more than a passing pressure suit. Citizens
would wonder what the Navy was doing out here.

Within a layer of haze he found the unmistakable shape
of the Market. Headquarters to spinward . . . "Jeffer? I
have it."

"How close?"

"Forty klomters."

"Get a lot closer. Approach from the Market side if
you can. Rather, it just struck me: there are two ways
into the Library, and they have to guard both."

"So?"

"I don't think it was ever meant to be guarded. The
Library was supposed to be free to all. Just a guess."

"What's the word from Kendy?"

THE SMOKE RING / 263

"Any breath now."

"I'll come in through that cloud bank. You see it? I
think there's a pond in there. I'll come around that."

"Kendy for the State. Rather, are you in place?"
The boy sounded edgy. "Ready. You missed some in-
teresting stuff."

Headquarters was four hundred meters distant. They'd
lose a few minutes crossing that. Kendy sent, "Something
I should know?"

"No, just interesting. I watched two triune families
arrange a marriage."

"If your helmet faced it I didn't miss it. Time to move.
Just wings."

Kendy watched the guards as Rather approached.
Would they expect him to have an escort? They spread
arms and legs as he came near, with a hand and foot to
hold the harpoon. That position had been Attention! for
any military man in free-fall since long before Kendy's
birth. The door behind them was large and massive, and
closed.

"Just go in unless they do something," Kendy said.
"I've watched them every orbit. You won't need a pass-
word because your helmet's closed. Don't hurry. Let
them open the door for you."

Checklist: Communications systems nominal. Drive
warming. Course correction ready. Kendy didn't intend
to bum fuel until everything else had gone right.

The guards waited until they could read Rather's in-
signia. One rapped the door with his spear butt. It slid
open in time to let Rather pass.

"Left. There's a hall, then another door." Kendy no-
ticed pads of cottony-looking vegetation on the far wall.
"Pause. Wings off, then clean your suit. You'll be ex-
pected to. Pat, don't rub. Remember the paint."

Rather patted muddy rainwater off his suit. Kendy




264 / Larry Niven

wished he could see the result. There were paint smears
on the pad. The boy moved down the corridor.

The inner door had one guard. He starfished the way
the others had. "Captain-Guardian? You're early, sir."

"I want to consult the Library."

"But that's . . . yessir." The man didn't move.

Kendy sent, "You're still carrying your wings. Tether
them to your chest plate." The guard must expect that,
and it would give Kendy time to think. "No hurry. Aris-
tocrats don't hurry. Shin sticks toward your chin."

To door: no hinges visible. It would swing in. What
was protocol here? Have to guess. "Open it yourself,
Rather."

"How?"

"Paired handles on door and wall. Grip both. Push the
door inward. No, pause—"

As Rather finished tethering his wings, the guard fin-
ished pushing the door open and moved aside. "In," said
Kendy.

Rather entered. He turned at the sound of the door
closing. There was no handle on the inside, though a sear
showed that one had been removed.

The light source was electric. Would that bother
Rather? No, he was used to electric lights in the CARM.

A man in a pressure suit waited. He held a crossbow.
The bow and quarrel were both hullmetal: lengths of stiff
CARM wiring, with superconducting cores. So this was
how they used their heritage.

The Guardian's voice had to echo through helmet and
faceplate. He sounded tinny (as Rather would; Kendy had
counted on that) and surprised. "Captain-Guardian?"

"'I know I'm early. I relieve you. I need to use the
Library.'"

Rather was slow. "I know I'm early—"

"That's all right, Captain-Guardian."

"I need to use the Library. I relieve you."

"Yes, sir. For what purpose, sir? I'm required to ask."

THE SMOKE RING / 265

While Kendy mulled possible answers, Rather had
started to speak. Kendy listened. Rather said, "We want
to locate an integral tree west of here. I want its probable
orbit."

No way to read the silver man's face. The Guardian
said, "Yes, sir," and rapped on the door. It opened for
him and closed after him.

"Alone at last," Rather said.

The room was much bigger than the machinery it
housed. The CARM control system had been remounted
in a wooden cradle. There were wooden handles on its
four sides. Hadn't Booce Serjent said that it was some-
times displayed to the citizens?

Cradled against an adjacent wall was a small portable
fusion generator. The Library's light source was a panel
running around its rim. The power cable was coiled
against its side. "Rather, do you see a coil of line, thick
as your wrist, black—"

"Got it." Rather moved toward the generator.

"The free end has to go into a hole in the CARM con-
trols. At the near end, near the wall."

"There are a lot of holes."

"I'll guide you."

They played "cold" and "warm" with the end of the
plug. It was taking too long. The power plant might be
dead. The computer might be dead. The programs might
be scrambled. There would be no second chance: Rather
Citizen was probably trapped behind locked doors, with
Wayne Mickl already on his way. Once Kendy had es-
tablished contact with the Admiralty, he might be able to
buy Rather loose. The boy was doing his best, after all,
fumbling, but doing his best—

"Just push it in hard and turn it counterclockwise. Stet.
Face the controls. Tap the white key." A white cursor
appeared. "Say 'Prikazyvat Voice.'"

"Prikazyvat Voice."




266 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 267

"State your authority," said a voice so like Kendy's
that Rather squeaked in surprise.

"Say 'Rather Citizen for Discipline. Open contact.'
Watch your accent." With another part of his attention
he began beaming his signal to the old CARM computer.
Voice was activated; the computer would hear. Kendyfor
the State. Discipline to all CARMs. Kendyfor the State.

The computer must be trying to answer. It wouldn't
be able to find Discipline with its navigational instruments
severed. He sent, Beam to pressure suit 26.

"Something just started humming in my head."

"Everything's fine, Rather." The signal was being re-
layed. He sent, Status?

CARM #2 sent its tale of woe. Massive malfunctions.
Internal sensors out, external sensors out, motors not re-
sponding, life support systems not responding, naviga-
tional systems not responding, power low. Records intact.
Presiding officer: Admiral Robar Henling . . .

Kendy sent, Copy.

All?

Y.

The Admiralty Library accepted the Copy program,
hummed thoughtfully, and began beaming its records.

That would take twenty-six minutes. Kendy activated
the course change he'd worked out hours ago. Discipline
was about to use a good deal of fuel. It would hold him
over the Lagrange point for long enough.

The records arrived in reverse order. Common prac-
tice. Recent records were likely to be more urgent. Kendy
dipped into the flow. The control board had seen little
while housed in the Library room. There were glimpses
of the sky during ceremonies. Records of births, deaths,
marriages. It had been dismounted in year 130 SM. The
CARM hadn't crashed; it had deteriorated over the years,
helped by deteriorating maintenance . . .

He couldn't spare attention with so much else going
on. The drive ran smoothly. Tank less than a fifth full.

Discipline accelerated, drive swinging out to point at the
stars, to hold the ship close above the L4 point against
its own spin. Rather was exploring the room; his pulse
and breath rate were rapid. He was bored and anxious.
Jeffer, crouched above CARM #6's control board, was
in similar shape. The neudar view of Admiralty Head-
quarters showed fog-spots clumping, then moving in two
streams toward the Library.

Something was happening. Little lights brightened and
dimmed on the CARM control panel. His helmet
hummed. It wasn't particularly entertaining. Rather said,
"Kendy?"

"It's working, Rather. Don't bother me."

"Jeffer?"

"Here."

"Kendy's busy and happy."

"You've got more than two hours—about half a day—
before Mickl's on duty. Nobody should bother you."

"I'm hungry enough to eat a swordbird, and may the
best entity win."

"Did everything go all right?"

"I'm scared, Jeffer. I may never get over being scared.
Why on Earth are we doing—"

The door opened.

Rather saw a silver suit pointing a crossbow a few de-
grees wide of his navel. The insignia was familiar. He and
Booce had spent half a day painting it on the silver suit,
from pictures taken by the silver suit's camera.

The door—

Rather's radio spoke in his helmet. "I know who you
are," said the voice he'd been trying to imitate. "What
I want to know is why. Let's—"

Rather leapt straight at Wayne Mickl, and fired a burst
from his jets for extra force. He couldn't let the door
close.

The silver man swung his crossbow aside and braced




268 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 269

to kick, too slowly. He'd expected the jump but not the
jets. Rather slammed into him. Mickl bounced away.
Rather struck the jamb and, spinning, was through the
door and out into a horde of Navy crew.

"I know who you are—" Wayne Mickl's voice, pres-
sure suit #5, radio frequency badly distorted by time, and
Kendy locked on it. He beamed instructions to the Li-
brary: Record the view through pressure suit #5 cameras,
one snap per ten minutes, henceforth.

It was a nice bonus. He welcomed it, because he was
about to lose Rather Citizen. A dozen Navy crew in the
fisheye view, unknown numbers out of camera range—

Jeffer bellowed, "Rather! What's going on?"

"Wayne Mickl came back. Can't talk."

Kendy sent, "Get outside if you can, Rather. Mickl's
jets aren't fueled."

"I've got the whole treefeeding Navy here!" They
were hesitating, but they wouldn't for long. "They'll
swarm all over me like honey hornets— Hey!" Rather's
hands came in view holding a bag; ripped it open and flung
it. The corridor became vague and golden.

Wayne Mickl could pull the cable! Was he still in the
Library? CARM #2 had a hundred years of records to go
... a solid block of data was running now, data that must
have been beamed long ago by Discipline itself. Kendy
knew he wouldn't want to read that in full, not if it was
records of the mutiny. He'd spot-check.

The other pressure suit emerged from the Library and
jumped to join the fight. Good!

Rather's camera view shot down the corridor, through
dust and bodies. Navy crew grabbed at him, clung . . .
and let go. It began to look as if he might make it.

What was running through Discipline's receivers was
a message from the State, from Earth.

Nothing in bis own memory matched. Kendy pulled it
and ran it. It was brief.

Rather jumped down the corridor, arms raised to block
the men who blocked his path. Impacts slowed him. A
burst from the jets compensated. Somebody was riding
him, legs around his hips ... a man impacted heavily
against his helmet, slid across his chest, and was gone.

The silver man jumped him. The man who clung to
Rather took the force of impact. They tumbled. Rather
reached the door, kicked, swung himself around the jamb
and was out in the sky. A burst of jets took him clear.

He paused then.

The silver man emerged and, twenty meters away and
receding, stopped to put on his wings. Navy crew
emerged behind him. Two flailed; they had no wings at
all. The third couldn't get his on. Fringe spores must have
reached their brains.

That left only the silver man.

Rather grinned. He put on his own wings and kicked
away strongly. "Kendy? Jeffer? Are you watching?"

"Jeffer here. I can't get Kendy. He may be out of
range."

"Well, watch. This is going to be good."

Mickl was catching up.

Rather's radio sounded calm and a bit supercilious.
"Rather Citizen, you can't escape. Your wings are the
right color, but they're not Navy wings. You know I don't
want to hurt you. I had the chance to kill you and I didn't.
But the crossbow is all I have, and it will penetrate—
make holes in a Navy pressure suit. There's a hole in one
of our suits because one of our Guardians turned mutineer
once."

"Don't answer," Jeffer said."He's guessing. Don't
give him a chance to test it."

Mickl was meters behind him, but the drugged Navy
crew were nearly out of sight. Rather pulled his wings
loose, pointed his feet at the silver man, and fired his jets.

He was head-down to the Dark. Mickl was kicking




270 / Larry Niven

hard, falling rapidly behind. A scream of shock or frus-
tration burst in Rather's ears; he found the volume control
and turned it down fast.

The Dark was around him. He couldn't see the other
silver man, he couldn't see the Market.

Jeffer spoke in his helmet: a tiny squeak until Rather
turned the volume back up. ". . . due to rendezvous. I've
got a ship moving north out of the Dark. Stand by ...
There's a dark blob bigger than the cabin—"

"That's Logbearer. They've got their mud."

"Turn seventy degrees clockwise from where you
were pointed and, oh, ten degrees north. Make your
bum."

Rather obeyed. Jeffer counted off twenty seconds:

seven breaths. The Dark thinned.

"We've got to get rid of the silver suit," Jeffer said.

"No." I'm the Silver Man!

"I don't mean feed it to the tree! I mean don't have it
when Logbearer gets home."

"How?"

"I don't know, and Kendy isn't answering. I don't
even know what course he's on now."

"What if I don't go back? You can pick me up with
the CARM."

"Sure, and what does Wayne Mickl say to the Ser-
jents? You've got to face him and lie."

Rather could see the Market far behind him. Was he
in view of Navy instruments? But they'd have to find him,
and he'd changed direction.

The deep voice of Wayne Mickl was small and full of
the chattering sound of distance. "Rather Citizen, I will
wait for you at Serjent House."

"I heard that," Jeffer said. "I've spotted you. Can you
see Voy? Sixty-five degrees east, bum for five seconds.
Zero north, there's no point in getting higher. You'll both
be back in the Dark before you meet."

THE SMOKE RING / 271

"Jeffer? Why don't you come get the silver suit?"

". . . Stet. Here I come."

Rather himself had spotted Logbearer now, above the
plane of the Dark, foreshortened and trailing steam.

Jeffer said, "I'm on my way, but it'll take me nearly
a day. If you just ditch the suit it'll fall back into the
Dark."

"It's doing that now. You'll have to find it somehow.
I've got an idea."

Rather flew through the Dark. He was using wings.
There couldn't be much left of his fuel;

He glimpsed a man-shape through the murk.

Carlot. When he opened his helmet she kissed him
breathlessly. "I thought I'd never see you again! Did you
do it?"

"Yeah. All of it, but the Captain-Guardian knows, or
thinks he does."

She talked while she helped him out of the suit. "Raym
got too much of the fringe. He's in the cabin getting
through the hangover. Debby's with him. She'll keep him
quiet. We've got our mud and four tons of walnut-cush-
ion. Two Dark sharks tried to open us up. Debby took
them. Rather, I'd hate to have her mad at me. We've got
the meat, and I'll show you tooth scars on the wood—"

"I hope they were big. I'm hungry." He was out. He
closed up the suit, leaving the helmet open. "Jeffer?"

"Here. I'm above your position."

"I'm doing it." He closed the helmet. He turned the
pressure dial high and the temperature low. The suit grew
rigid. "Now I want to start a fire."

"In the Dark that won't be easy."

"Help me. That. . . fisher jungle, I guess it was." He
indicated a mass of dry brush with white things taking
root in it. "Help me push the legs in."

They pushed the suit into the decaying fisher jungle.
The branches still had some strength. Rather got a good

272 / Larry Niven

grip, then closed a jet key with his toe. Flame blasted
through the rotting fisher jungle; the suit tried to escape.
He let the jet run for several breaths before he turned it
off.

"Jeffer should find that okay," he said. He was guess-
ing and he knew it.

"Then tell me! What happened?"

He told her some of it while they searched out Log-
bearer. The rest would wait. Clave and Debby would have
to wait to hear the tale, since Raym could not be allowed
to. And Rather would have his chance to eat and sleep.
He was exhausted.

Chapter Twenty-One

The Silver Suit

from the Library cassettes, year 200 SM:

CITIZENS MAY NEVER ENTER THE LIBRARY ROOM.
CITIZENS WILL BE GIVEN ACCESS TO THE LIBRARY ONLY
THROUGH OFFICERS, AND THEN ONLY ON CERTAIN
DATES. . . . ON THESE DAYS THE LIBRARY WILL RE-
MAIN AVAILABLE, WITH A PROGRAMMER ON DUTY,
UNTIL ALL CITIZENS HAVE HAD OPPORTUNITY TO ASK
THEIR QUESTIONS; THOUGH SOME QUESTIONS WILL CER-
TAINLY BE UNANSWERABLE . . .

THEY STOPPED TWICE: ONCE AT THE MARKET, TO LET

Raym off with half his pay in hand, and once at a pond,
to refuel.

Belmy's log was very slowly turning end-for-end. A
thread of steam poured from above the tuft. As Cariot

273




274 / Larry Niven

made her final bum to bring Logbearer to rest near the
midpoint, Woodsman cast loose and moved toward them.

Serjent House was just visible to antispinward: west.
Rather tried not to think about the dot visible alongside
it. He welcomed the delay.

Debby said, "I'd like to get this over with—"

Clave shook her by the ankle. "Wrong! We went into
the Dark for mud, and we're back to get rid of it. We
don't know of anything urgent. We're in no hurry at all."

Carlot shouted from where she and Rather worked the
rocket. "Stet! Treefodder, they always make us wait!"

They had it all figured out. But copter plants were
launching their seeds in Rather's belly.

Woodsman eased alongside. Hilar and RaffBelmy flew
toward Logbearer. "You'll like Raff," Carlot whispered.
"Ac? like you like Raff."

"It's all right. I'd make babies with him if it'd make
you happy ... or get me away from the Navy."

Hilar introduced his son. (Treefodder, but they were
big!) Raff smiled much and said little. He was shy for an
adult, Rather thought. He stared at the tree dwellers, but
his eyes seemed to slide aside from Rather's.

The teapot passed. Carlot asked, "How are you doing
with the log?"

Hilar shrugged. "No burl yet." The others laughed.
"Give it time. We have some spin. I don't think we want
to overdo it. We've splashed a pond against the trunk;

that gives us a water flow. How are you planning to de-
liver the mud?"

"I ... hadn't thought past just bringing it here."

"Raff and I talked it over—"

Raff spoke. "Dad always says keep it simple. We'll
just impact it against the tree, lee side, two, three klomters
above the tuft. There's already water running down to the
treemouth. Let it carry the mud too. Easy, steady delivery
system."

THE SMOKE RING / 275

He can talk when it's about something real, Rather
thought. "Have you done a lot of logging?"

Raffs head bobbed. "I spend more than half my life
in the outer sky. Sometimes I wondered what living in a
tree would be like."

They were getting used to that question. Clave said,
"I miss it myself. Well, you grow up shorter and stronger.
Cooking's easier. Hunting's different: the wind throws the
prey at you ..."

Rather tuned it out. The dot next to Serjent House must
be a Navy ship. He felt their long-sight devices on him.
What the Navy saw must look puzzling. Let them wonder:

he had an explanation both interesting and innocent.

His attention snapped back when Hilar said, "Booce
has been making deals. I expect he'll pay back the loan
well before crossyear."

Carlot asked, "Has the Navy bought the metal yet?"

"No. In fact, something's upsetting the Navy. I hav-
en't heard a rumor I can believe, but. . . stay alert, Car-
lot. You know you've got visitors?"

"We can see them. Hilar, Raff, it's time to deliver our
cargo."

It took a day and a fraction and was entirely straight-
forward. Logbearer burned toward the turning tree. Her
crew dismounted the spokes that braced the web that sup-
ported the mud. Mud and lines and wooden spokes
smacked the trunk hard enough to stick. Water flow was
already carving a runnel in the mud as Logbearer accel-
erated away. They'd be back to collect the beams and
lines after they were washed clean.

Gyrfalcon was not moored; it floated free a hundred
meters from Serjent House. Two men working on the hull
did not return Clave's cheerful wave. Rather recognized
one as Petty Wheeler. They watched fixedly while Log-

276 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 277

bearer's crew swarmed out and set about the business of
mooring their ship.

Rather looked around the common room while they
tethered their wings. One fast look and then he'd have to
react:

No teapot. Not a social occasion. Booce Serjent looked
angry and unhappy. Bosun Sectry Murphy started to jump
toward Rather, then pulled herself back. Three long-
limbed Navy men were stationed around the walls, and
a fourth: silver suit, helmet thrown back, bearded dwarf-
face within. Wayne Mickl.

Rather let himself break into a delighted grin. It was
surprisingly easy. He wanted to reassure Sectry; he was
glad to see her. He let his eyes flick from Sectry to Wayne
Mickl to Sectry again. He blurted, "Am I in?"

Sectry flashed from unhappy to angry. Wayne Mickl
broke into delighted laughter. "Very good! But, Rather,
there just aren't enough dwarves to make it work. Take
him."

Two of the Navy crew were on him. They pulled him
loose from his handhold, set him spinning in the air. He
caught glimpses of them rebounding from walls. Then one
had wrapped his arms and legs around Rather's lower ribs
from behind, and the other had a foot in Rather's crotch
and Rather's two ankles in his hands, stretching his legs
straight.

There was a wrestling trick. Jill had shown him, in the
brief period when she was stronger than he was. You
wrapped your arms or legs around your opponent's short
ribs and tightened them. Your opponent couldn't inhale.
Presently he would faint.

Rather had used it on others afterward, and been pun-
ished for it. Most of the children were smaller than he
was. Jilly wasn't, but she didn't have the strength of a
dwarf after they beth got older. Rather had been taught
not to fight. He still got angry sometimes, but he learned

to control it. Sometimes he wrestled with adults. He gen-
erally lost.

The man behind him (call him Navy #1) was letting
him breathe, but shallowly. The other (Navy #2) wasn't
kicking Rather's seeds into his belly; but he could. Rather
held the red rage in check. "Booce?"

Booce answered the implied question. "You tell me.
Where have you beenT'

"The Dark. We've delivered Hilar's mud. We've got
some walnut-cushion and—"

"The Navy went through this house like a whirl-
wind. I told them about the sporing fringe in the con-
crete. I was about to show them a hiding place I made
in the door. I think they'd rather chop my house
apart, and I get the distinct impression that it's all your
fault—"

"Shut it, Booce," Mickl said. "Rather, what did you
think you were coming home to?"

Anger made his thoughts murky, but he'd rehearsed
this part in his mind. "I thought ... I saw Sectry and I
saw you. I thought the Captain-Guardian had come per-
sonally to tell me I was in. The Navy. You know.
But—"

"You must know that an officer wouldn't care that
much about a new inductee."

"Well, you're here and . . . someone told me you're
very eager to put another dwarf in the Guardian slot. What
me you doing here, Captain-Guardian?"

"It's a mistake!" Sectry burst out.

Mickl didn't shout; he projected his voice over hers.
The walls shivered to it. "Let me tell you something about
mistakes. There's—"

"No, allow me." Rather reached for the foot in his
crotch with both hands. He had it before the leg could
snap straight, and he twisted. His rib cage closed. He
stopped breathing and kept twisting. The leg buckled;

Navy #2 was pulled close; he loosed Rather's ankle and




278 / Larry Niven

Rather kicked him twice under the jaw. Now his hands
were free to pull the constricting arms apart and over his
head and down. Torsion pulled the legs free too, and he
could breathe.

Navy #2 kicked at Rather with his good leg. Rather
caught it on his foot. Reaction separated them: Navy #2
was headed toward a wall. There was blood on his mouth.
Rather pulled the other's arms around behind him. They
came, not easily, and Rather kept pulling until he had
pulled Navy #l's shoulder from its socket.

Clave had a rib lock on the third man.

Rather pushed Navy #1 away. The man turned in the
air, moaning, his arm at a crooked angle.

Navy #2 had reached the wall. He jumped. They
traded blows: Rather put his heel in the other's midsec-
tion, but a fist smacked solidly into the side of Rather's
neck. Short arms and legs had cost Rather more than one
match.

Again the blows had thrown them apart. Rather's ears
buzzed; lights flared in his eyes. He was too far from the
walls. He waited ... but Navy #2 was curled in a tight
ball. When a wall touched him he stayed there, winded,
resting.

Wayne Mickl was pointing a crossbow at Rather. "Cut
it. I'll shoot you someplace nonlethal. You too, Jonthan.
Stay there. You, the tree man, let go ofDoheen!"

Clave released Navy #3. Doheen was unconscious.

Panting, elated, Rather said, "Stet. But mistakes are
something . . . somebody pays for, and that's what . . .
the word is for. Or am I going too fast for you?"

"Yes. Pause a minute. J— What is it now?"

The men in the doorway both looked surprised. One
was a Navy crewman. He had Raym Wilby in a rib lock.
"Captain-Guardian, this one flew up like he was coming
to the house. Then he saw the ship and turned around
and flew away. The Petty and me chased him down."

"Who are you?" Mickl demanded.

THE SMOKE RING / 279

Raym only gaped. Cariot said, "It's Raym Wilby. He
guided us into the Dark."

"Wilby, what were you flying from?"

"I ... I just don't like N-Navy."

"Stet. Jonthan, wipe your face, then take Wilby into
the storage room. Ask him about the trip. Be polite."

Doheen blinked; his eyes opened. The man from the
ship took charge of Navy # 1, the man with the dislocated
arm. Rather heard him yell as his shoulder popped into
place. Jonthan (Navy #2) wiped blood from his mouth
with a cloth, then took Raym Wilby by the elbow and
towed him away. Rather noticed for the first time that
Sectry had a crossbow too. It was pointed at Clave.

Mickl ignored it all. "Now, Rather, tell me about a
pressure suit that looks like mine. Don't forget the cross-
bow."

Rather was still panting a little. He took a moment
more than he needed. "Pressure suit? Booce told me.
You've got three. Nine crew to use them, but you're short
of dwarves." Which ought to be a pun, he thought; but
he'd irritated Micklenough without that.

"A fourth pressure suit invaded Headquarters fifteen
days ago. You were in it."

Rather stared. "No, I wasn't. Fifteen days? I was in
the Dark getting mud. Is that what this is about?"

"Rather, it's your bad luck that I'm interested in
dwarves. I know where every dwarf in the Admiralty is
right now. There are twelve. Ten are in the Navy. One
is eighteen years old. He'll be a Petty soon. Sectry already
is. The rest are Guardians. There's a Dark diver's boy,
but his brain was thick with spores before he could grow
a beard. And there's you."

"And another pressure suit."

"Yes. I want it."

Rather wiped sweat from his face. He was thinking as
carefully as if he were innocent. The trick was not to know
anything he shouldn't. This seemed safe: "Captain-

280 / Larry Niven

Guardian, if a pressure suit got into the Admiralty without
you knowing it, maybe there was a dwarf in it."

Mickl didn't answer. Rather said, "S— the Bosun and
I are about the same size, but I think you're bigger. How
big was that fourth suit? Would I even fit?" He was stut-
tering a little; he had to think every word through first.
How clearly had Mickl seen the silver suit? It always
looked bigger than the occupant. "Maybe it's smaller yet.
Maybe it's so small that it'll fit in places you wouldn't
look, a closet in a happyfeet ship—"

"Why that?"

"Happyfeet tried to rob us before we got here. They
don't care much about laws. Isn't there a Lupoff ship in
dock?"

"True enough, but a closet is silly. He'd suffocate."

"Somewhere else, then." There's air in the silver suit.
Am I supposed to know that? What else am I not supposed
to know? "What really happened? What is it you think I
did?"

"You entered Headquarters in an unregistered pres-
sure suit painted like mine. You got into the Library. You
got rid of the Guardian. We haven't been able to find out
what you did there, or whether you got what you wanted,
but Voice was running when you left. When I came in
you scattered sporing fringe throughout Headquarters and
got away." Mickl's throat worked, and Rather saw how
close he was to uncontrolled rage. "I went after you. I
couldn't catch you."

"Um . . . that doesn't make sense. Booce told me
never to try to outfly Navy. The wings are different—"

Mickl slashed the air with his arm. "The suit outflow
me! This isn't just another pressure suit. You'd be in
enough trouble if it was only that. We've got to have this
suit. It's special."

"How?"  <

"Classified, you little fungus!" Wayne Mickl closed

THE SMOKE RING / 281

his eyes. He pulled air in through his nose until his lungs
were full, then let it all out. Calmly he said, "Booce, show
me this hiding place."

Booce showed him. We wouldn't have been told this
either, Rather thought. Secrets!

Mickl closed his helmet. When he peered into the com-
partment, light blazed from the forehead. He studied the
interior at length. "Ingenious."

"Maybe not. It weakened the door." Booce pointed
out the hole. Mickl nodded.

Jonthan was back. A long bruise was forming on his
jaw. His glance at Rather seemed disinterested. He and
the dwarf officer conferred in low voices. They disap-
peared toward the storage room.

That left only Navy #3, Doheen. He and Clave were
holding a staring contest. Clave smiling, the other poker-
faced.

Booce said carefully, "Rather, there's something you
should know. You're trying to tell the Captain-Guardian
that you're probably innocent. It's not enough."

Rather had thought things were going well. "Raym was
with us. He'd have to believe Raym was lying too. Raym
doesn't have the brains."

"No, of course not. Mickl believes you now." A quick
glance at Doheen, who reacted with something like a
shrug. "But just in case he's wrong, he'll stop Logbearer
from ever leaving the Admiralty, because we might be
smuggling that fourth suit. He'll ruin me financially, in
case I might say something to save myself. He'll hound
you. It'll never be over."

"Then . . ." What'll I do? There can't be a way to
convince Mickl I'm innocent. I'm guilty!

Admiralty pressure suits don't have working jets. No
fuel. There's a suit with jets, somewhere, and Mickl wants
it. He'll never settle for less.

Give him the silver suit? He'd know we're guilty then.

If I could— Ah. He had something.




282 / Larry Niven

/ can't ask Booce. Doheen's listening, and Booce
doesn't know what happened anyway. The others—

Fate and air currents had put Rather near Sectry. He
moved closer. She moved the crossbow aside for him.
Her face was hard to read.

"I shouldn't have left," he said.

"Why didn't you wait?"

"They tell me the Navy takes forever to do anything.
I couldn't just hang around twitching, and we needed the
mud."

Their voices had dropped. She said, "I was here. I
turned down a flight, but I can't do that twice running.
You left me for mudT'

It was a miserable thing to have to admit, but it was
better than the truth. He nodded.

"Rather, nobody makes decisions when he's on fringe.
So tell me, am I too strange? Am I too old?"

"My mother's older than my father. I like strange. I'm
in the Clump because I like strange. Sectry, I don't regret
anything I said or did." Which was not quite the truth.
Secrets— "Hilar Belmy is trying to grow a burl tree."

She said, "That never works."

"Well, he's trying something new. Booce bought a
piece of the tree. And he owes us."

"So it's not just mud, it's money. All right. Rather. I
can understand money."

"That's more than I do. It's power, but it doesn't make
you an officer. Are there un-rich officers?"

Her lips twitched. "They marry rich citizens. Their
children are officers. The number of officers goes up. One
day we'll all be officers."

"Why does Wayne Mickl want that suit so much? I'd
think it would be the other way around—"

"It's bad for the Admiralty if happyfeet hold old sci-
ence. I think Wayne's almost given up on taking his Cap-
tain's seat. The pressure suit is as much power as he'll
ever have, and he takes his responsibilities—"

THE SMOKE RING / 283

They were back: Wayne Mickl and Raym Wilby and
Jonthan. Raym was unwontedly quiet. Mickl said, "And
what were you discussing with the Bosun?"

Sectry was flustered; Rather answered first. "I was
suggesting that if you did have a fourth pressure suit,
you'd need twelve dwarves to man them."

Sectry tried to cover her laugh with her hands. Booce
laughed outright. Doheen's mouth was rigidly straight.
Mickl was about to explode.

And Rather had learned little from Sectry, but it might
be enough. Go for Gold. Before Mickl could speak, he
asked, "Does it fly better than your suits?"

Mickl's face didn't change. "Yes. How did you know
that?"

"You said it outflew you. Besides, I heard something
once."

"You'll tell me."

"Privately, if you don't mind, Captain-Guardian."

They took the kitchen. Mickl said, "That fringe-addled
Dark diver makes you a poor witness."

"I don't know anything about your Chairman's
Court."

"You'll see a court soon enough. Talk to me, boy."

"I don't know anything about your mutineer pressure
suit either—"

"Then—"

"I once heard that there's a way to make little holes
on a pressure suit spray fire. Then it can fly without
wings."

"Go on."

"Maybe I can find a man who can do it. He doesn't
have a pressure suit, so he's never tried it."

"Take me to him."

"They don't deal with Navy. They don't even come
into the Admiralty." Rather visualized a mysterious hap-




284 / Larry Niven

pyfeet tribe, isolated and distrustful. "They sent copsiks
once. The Scientists don't come themselves."

"Give me a name."

He picked one he could remember. "Seekers."

"There's no such tribe."

Rather shrugged.

"Well, what are we doing here, Rather?"

"What happens is, you give me your pressure suit—"

Mickl laughed.

"I take it somewhere." Payment? Not money; the
Seekers might not use money. "I take fringe too, maybe
twenty kilos. I take tools. I bring the suit back. They keep
the fringe and the tools. Maybe the jets work and maybe
they don't."

"Let me tell you why I can'tgive you my pressure suit,"
Mickl said gently. "First, it belongs to the Ad-
miralty. Second, it alternates among three Guardians.
My triad would notice. Third, turning a pressure suit
over to savages would certainly be judged as mutiny,
especially since—fourth—you might not bring it back.
Stet?"

"Not stet. Let me think."

"While you're thinking . . . This mysterious tribe, did
they ever have a pressure suit to practice on?"

"They say they did—"

"Could they have got it working again?"

This was taking Rather into empty sky. Treefodder!
Maybe it was lost, or stolen, or—

"Talk to me!"

"I was trying to remember. They threw it away."

"What?"

"It killed three citizens."

"How?"

"The . . . silver was only for one who was worthy.
One day the old dwarf died while he was using it. Three
dwarves wrestled for it—"

"That sounds like too many dwarves. Rather."

THE SMOKE RING / 285

It did. "I saw two myself, and I never got inside the
jungle. I guess Seekers get more dwarves."

". . .Goon."

"The winner put the suit on and died. The one who
lost to him put it on and died. The last one was a woman.
She started to get into it, but while the—" Rather patted
his skull "—this part was still open she said she heard
the voice of Kendy the Checker. Nobody else could hear
it. They got scared and dumped it and moved to another
part of the sky."

"Sounds like the air feed went bad. What then?"

"That's when they found the Admiralty. They say one
of your ships tried to rob them—"

"Nonsense."

"We say treefodder. They say you did." It might have
happened in the past: Navy robbing savages—

Wayne Mickl was looking disgusted. He said, "It's
possible. A ship low on provisions . . . this isn't helping.''

"Wait. You three who trade your suit off. Are you
always on duty at Headquarters?"

"No, of course not. Why?"

Rather took a deep breath. "Your fourth point: of
course we'll bring the suit back. Not all of us will go.
You'll keep friends of mine to answer for it if the suit
doesn't come back.

"Your third point: maybe it's mutiny if you lose your
chance at a pressure suit that can fly without wings, es-
pecially if it belongs to the Admiralty, which was my first
point, and especially if you could get three\ So let's work
on your second point. Can you get the Admiralty's per-
mission?"

"Admiral Robar Henling would rather give up his
seeds. At his age it wouldn't— No. Just no."

He was getting somewhere. He had Mickl's attention.
Think! "Will your, uh, triad try to track down that flying
pressure suit?"

"We will. We are!"

286 / Larry Niven

"You can go anywhere if you think it's the right di-
rection, stet? You're Guardians. One of you is an officer.
Nobody'11 ask. Am I completely off the track?"

". . . Not yet."

"So off you go, tracking rumors of a fourth pressure
suit. Maybe you find it. You close in. But there's a dwarf
in it, and he sees you coming and flies away laughing.
What he doesn't know is that your triad was working with-
out a pressure suit for a while. Then it came back. Now
off goes the bandit dwarf, but he's doomed, because your
suit flies too and he doesn't know it!"

Mickl's grin was not quite a pleasant sight. "Were you
a Teller, where you came from?"

Rather knew exactly what he meant. "Our Teller was
Merril till she died. These days everyone does some tell-
ing. Captain-Guardian, I'm trying to help. I'll bring the
suit back whether it works or not."

"But would your Seekers give it back?" Mickl sighed.
"I don't blame you for attacking my men, and I won't
charge you. We'll leave it at that for the moment. This
isn't finished, Rather."

The civilians watched the Navy people fly toward their
rocket. Sectry was trailing; and when he saw her look
back, Rather snatched his wings from the door and
jumped after her.

She stayed in the air while he strapped his wings on.
A voice spoke from the Navy ship's cabin; she answered.
Then she kicked away to avoid the rocket's exhaust. She
did not fly back toward Serjent House.

The Navy rocket departed.

Rather reached her. He didn't have breath to speak.
She said, "You're involved in something."

He shrugged helplessly.

"I don't know what's going on, but I don't want any
part of it. I've decided I don't want to live in a tree
either."

THE SMOKE RING / 28\

Rather had his breath back. He said, "We're the right
size."

She shook her head violently. Teardrops flew. "Didn't
Wayne tell you how many dwarves there are in the Ad-
miralty? Rather, it was a good offer. Nobody makes real
decisions when she's on fringe. I'm sorry."

"So am I." His tongue was in knots and his thoughts
were scrambled. The Scientist and the Checker, they
caused this, they sent me into Headquarters! Would it be
different if they hadn't? Did I mean it, that offer? How
will Carlotfeel about this? Or Jill?

"I do want to see you again. After this is over, if it's
ever over. You'll be going back to the tree, won't you?
You won't like it here, not with the Captain-Guardian on
your tail!" She didn't wait for his answer. "Well, sooner
or later there'll be a mission to Citizens Tree, and I'll be
on it. I hope this is all cleared up by then."

She flapped spinward, toward Headquarters or the
Market. He called after her. "We have a rocket—"

"No. Thanks. I'll go on foot." She kept kicking.
Rather turned back to Serjent House. He was going to
have to do some fast talking . . . again.




THE SMOKE RING / 289

Chapter Twenty-Two

Loop

WHERE HAD IT ALL GONE WRONG? A MESSAGE MAY BECOME

garbled across fifty-two light-years of distance and inter-
stellar dust. But this was simple, unambiguous, and re-
peated—

from the CARM #2 cassettes, recorded year 76 SM, day
1412:

TO DISCIPLINE, YEAR 1435 STATE. RETRIEVE YOUR
CREW AND CONTINUE YOUR MISSION.

—FANK SHIBANO, FOR THE STATE

—as if he were a wayward computer in need of re-
programming. Arrival date: Feb 26,1487 State. Recorded

by CARM #2 sixty-one Earth days later.
He'd accomplished his mission! Why this?
He had attempted to follow his new orders. Of eight

CARMs he had sent into the Smoke Ring, he located
288

three. The rest must have been destroyed, or worn out,
or their sending systems turned off.

From CARM #2 he had learned of the death of Claire
Dalton. Claire had died at one hundred and thirty-eight,
less than two months before the message arrived. No
other survivors were known to the CARMs. Many death-
dates had been recorded.

Amazing that Claire had lived so long.

There had been a mutiny. Kendy had stored it in
CARM #2's computer before he erased it from his own
memory. Sharis Davis Kendy had mutinied against his
crew. Fool, not to have seen that! Their descendants used
mutineer as an insult!

He'd made an irretrievable mistake. But how? His rea-
soning was straight. His orders were unambiguous . . .
weren't they?

1) ... YOU WILL VISIT EACH OF THESE STARS IN
TURN. OTHER TARGETS MAY BE ADDED . . . THE STATE
EXPECTS TO SETTLE THESE WORLDS, SPREADING HU-
MANITY AMONG VARIABLE ENVIRONMENTS, AGAINST
DANGERS THAT MIGHT AFFECT ONLY SOL SYSTEM.

2) ... THE HUMAN SPECIES IS NOT INVULNERA-
BLE. THERE IS FINITE RISK THAT THE CREW OF ANY IN-
TERSTELLAR SPACECRAFT MAY FIND, ON ITS RETURN,
THAT IT HAS BECOME THE ENTIRE HUMAN RACE. YOUR
CREW AND THEIR GENES ARE YOUR PRIMARY CARGO.

CLASSIFIED.

3) YOUR TERTIARY MISSION IS TO EXPLORE . . .

—LING CARTHER, FOR THE STATE

How could it be clearer?

Kendy knew how the dinosaurs had died. The State
had explored the ringed black giant planet that periodi-
cally hurled flurries of comets into the solar system. The
State could stop comets now. The solar system was




290 / Larry Niven

tamed. Ten planets were better than one; cities and in-
dustrial sites on thirty moons and hundreds of asteroids
were better than none; but the lesson of the dinosaurs
remained. Planets are fragile.

Earthlike worlds had been found in the habitable zones
of nearby stars. Green life had emerged on two. At Dis-
cipline's departure they were in the process of final
terraforming. On twenty-six worlds, poisonous air resem-
bling Earth's primordial reducing atmosphere had been
seeded with tailored algae. In a thousand years some
would be ready for further attention. The seeder ramship
program had been running since seven hundred years be-
fore Kendy's birth.

And Discipline had found a habitable nonplanet!
Humanity was to be spread as widely as possible.
The dangers here were not a planet's dangers. The
Smoke Ring and its enveloping gas torus were dense
enough to protect Earthly life from radiation from the old
neutron star, and from other radiation too. Radiation
sources were normal throughout the universe. A super-
nova explosion near Sol... a passage of Sol and its com-
panion stars through a region of star-creation ... a
catastrophe in the galactic core . . . events known and
unknown could cause havoc through Sol system and all
nearby systems. But none could harm the Smoke Ring!

His own message to Earth, sent in year 1382 State, was
long and detailed. CARM #2 had the record:

Sharls Davis Kendy had abandoned his crew as they
explored the Smoke Ring. Three who remained aboard
had been invited to take what they needed from Discipline
and join the others. He had never given reasons; his sec-
ondary mission was CLASSIFIED. He had shut down
systems aboard Discipline in a pattern that forced them
to the CARMs.

Ah, that explained something: those three had not
loved cats. Pure coincidence.

THE SMOKE RING / 291

Then, the message from Earth. Put it back the way it
was.

How? His crew was dead!

Faced with conflicting orders, he could not function at
all. He would be locked in a loop of reinforcing guilt.
Kendy had sequestered all data relating to the mutiny and
beamed it to CARMs #2, #6, and #7, then erased it all
from memory.

How had he gone wrong? Could the message itself have
been garbled? Through 200 repetitions?

TO DISCIPLINE, YEAR 1435 STATE. RETRIEVE YOUR
CREW AND CONTINUE YOUR MISSION.

—PANK SHIBANO, FOR THE STATE

No explanations, no elaborations. He'd been repro-
grammed like a wayward computer. Why? He'd accom-
plished his mission!

Was the message genuine? Check the dates:

Kendy's own mission report, sent 1382 State.
Message from the State dated fifty-two point two Earth
years later. He was fifty-two point one light-years from
Earth. This Shibano had not lingered over his decision,
but ... it checked.

—Arrived fifty-two point one years after that. Check.
. . . Odd. Why would the State expect any crew to
remain alive? That Claire had survived was partly due to
low gravity, good conservative health habits (her mind
was that of an elderly corpsicle), youth (via the body of
some bright, healthy criminal), and luck. The rest must
have been dead decades earlier (and their descendants
called him murderer and mutineer and damaged machine).

Shibano for the State. Kendy found it difficult to con-
sider Shibano as separate from the state, but ... what
could Shibano have been thinking? Rescue after one
hundred and four years: it was insane.




292 / Larry Niven

Perhaps the State's medical resources had improved?
Times change. Every generation of mankind has sought
longer lives. Thousand-year lifespans might have become
common . . .

Speculative.

But times change. Goals change. Kendy's route here
had been circuitous. The state that had given Kendy his
orders was four hundred and fifty-five years old when he
reached the Smoke Ring. Five hundred and seven when
Shibano spoke. Five hundred and fifty-nine when his mes-
sage arrived.

Kendy did not normally question orders. Conflicting
orders could throw him into a loop. But he had been round
and round this loop, while some voiceless subsystem
sought desperately for a way out.

Somewhere in a pattern of magnetic fields there was
a change of state . . . and Kendy the man would have
laughed. A change of State, yes. Sharls Davis Kendy's
State was a thousand years in the past. Dead. Somehow
he must serve anyway. His own goals had been spelled
out in detail; he would serve those.

Humankind was to settle varied environments. So be
it. What was his present situation?

The receding Smoke Ring covered forty degrees of sky.
His mind had been following a loop for just under two
months! He'd missed the final stages of the explosion of
Levoy's Star, the foray into the Admiralty might have
disintegrated by now ...

To work. Discipline's drive had shut down without his
attention. Good! He still had fuel.

He started the drive warming. His orbit was a comet's,
highly eccentric. Equations ran through his mind ... fire
a short burst at aphelion. Shed some velocity by aero-
braking, by dipping into the gas torus around the Smoke
Ring, twice. Use Goldblatt's World as a gravity sling, save
a few cupfuls of deuterium that way . . .

Glowing in direct sunlight, the Clump was green-and-

THE SMOKE RING / 293

white chaos in Logbearer's steam trail. Clave felt good:

loose and free, cruising through an uncluttered sky.

Rather crawled out of the angular cabin. His head was
metal and glass. "The suit's too big, but I can wear the
helmet."

Clave smiled at the sight. "Getting anything?"

"Getting . . . ? No, Jeffer hasn't called. Maybe he
can't call this suit. I tried Kendy too."

"Too bad." Clave had been watching a distant brown-
ish smudge of vegetation. Now he shouted aft. "Cariot?
Could that be a fisher jungle?"

"Be with you in twelve breaths." Cariot finished what
she was doing to the motor and crawled to them over the
cabin. "Where?"

Clave's toes jabbed east and out.

"I don't see the root . . . right, that's what it is. I'd
better turn off the motor or we'll go past. Rather?"

Rather followed her aft. Clave stayed at the bow while
they worked the motor. Presently the tide behind him
went away.

Closer now, the fisher jungle looked dead enough.
Brown foliage and bare branchlets. Tufts and patches of
vivid green: parasitical growths. The fisher root was half
extended, like a dead man's hand with three scarlet fin-
gernails. He looked for the CARM . . . and found a man
flapping toward him.

Jeffer pulled himself aboard, panting. "Moor to the
root. Treefodder, I'm glad to see you, but what are you
doing here? Is everyone here?" He looked over the edge
of cabin and shouted, "Hello, Cariot! Rather, what . . .
is that a pressure suit helmet?"

"Yes. The rest of it's inside."

They told it in tandem while they moored Logbearer.

"I never did quite know if the Captain-Guardian be-
lieved me," Rather said, "but he left Serjent House with-
out taking any copsiks—"

"The Navy watched us for the next forty, fifty days,"




294 / Larry Niven

Clave said. "We weren't doing anything peculiar. Booce
sold wood and hired people to cut it. We bought more
seeds and some tools and stuff. We're carrying all that.
Mickl kept coming around, interrupting us, trying to get
Rather to tell him more about Seekers—"

"I tried not to talk too much. I built up a picture of
these Seekers in my mind, and maybe I got it across.
Secretive. Not very many of 'em. Too many Scientists,
maybe half a dozen. They've got a cassette and reader
but they don't show it to outsiders. They threw away their
silver suit, but they've got records on how to maintain it.
And they swear to kill anyone who tells their secrets. The
citizen who told me disappeared. He was high on fringe
and I was just a kid, but I had a better memory than most
kids . . . That part's true anyway," Rather said. "I hav-
en't told Mickl all of this."

"Dangerous," Jeffer said. "You'll have Mickl des-
perate to meet them."

"Not if I read him right. Scientist, you know the story
now, and you can back me up. Give him details I didn't."

Clave asked, "Jeffer, did Kendy get the records he
wanted?"

"I haven't heard from him."

"If we're lucky the treefeeder never will call back.
Anyway, we must have looked innocent enough. We
never did anything odd because we didn't know anything.
So. Twenty days ago three dwarves pulled up to Log-
bearer in a Navy rocket. Mickl and another man and a-
woman, all the same size. Weird. They gave us the pres-
sure suit and went away. We're supposed to get the jets
going and pay off the Seekers. Would you like ten years'
supply of fringe?"

"No. You'd better leave it here if you're supposed to."

They carried the suit and helmet into the dead foliage.
Rather and Carlot set to moving their cargo while they
looked about.-

Entropy and parasites had eaten a deep cavity into the

THE SMOKE RING / 295

fisher jungle's dead trunk. The CARM was there, and
Jeffer's camp: rocks for a fireplace, a rack of poles for
smoking meat, a midden a decent distance away. Jeffer
had made a third wing for himself, a prudent move for a
man alone. From the blackened look of it he'd been using
it to fan his fire.

Jeffer had the pressure suit splayed like a bird's flayed
skin. "Rather, did you try it?"

"It's too big for me. —And the air feed doesn't work.
I got the panel open. A little wheel isn't connecting to
anything, and there's a spoke with nothing on it."

Jeffer grinned. "I see."

Rather laughed. "Mickl doesn't want the Seekers
stealing his silver suit! If they try it they'll find out no-
body's worthy!"

"I'll refuel it. No guarantee the jets still work."

"Well, if they do work, I get the impression that Booce
will get a decent offer for the Wart. Mickl never actually

said so."

"Three pressure suits?"

Clave said, "Stet. We may have to do this twice more.
And they're searching Dark and sky for a fourth pressure
suit. They must be looking hard at where Logbearer went.
You may want to move the CARM."

Carlot arrived pushing the last of the cargo: not seeds,
but tools. "You're going to love this, Scientist." She sep-
arated something out.

Jeffer took it with glad cries. "A pump! Wonderful!
The CARM's low on water, and I hate the way I filled it
last time. Can I keep it?"

"Stet. We're supposed to bribe the Seekers with it.
Here, this is a bellows from the Market. You anchor one

end. It's easier."

"Nice. Can you stay for a couple of sleeps? I've got

food and—"
"Lonely?"
It showed in his face. "You know it."




296 / Larry Niven

"We've got food you never tasted. Dark fungus and
earthlife. You'll love it."

Their exotic dinner was nothing unusual for Rather,
not any longer. What made it fun was watching Jeffer
react.

Jeffer talked while he ate. "I had some trouble getting
the silver suit. I found it okay, but it was right in the fire.
I had to get the bow up against it and push it out along
with a kilton of burning goo. I just wonder how many
Admiralty citizens saw me."

"The stories won't match," Clave said. "In sixty days
it won't matter at all. I've been thinking. We'll bum the
fringe here. If a Navy ship comes they'll find that the
Seekers had a hell of a party and then went away."

"Good. I'll have to take the CARM someplace you can
find it—"

"No. You find us. Logbearer will be returning to Cit-
izens Tree in due course, maybe another thirty days.
Keep watch. Pick us up well outside the Clump."

"Another fifty days of this? Treefodder. And I never
even saw the treefeeding Clump."

"We'll leave you most of our food," Clave said.

Carlot carefully wasn't looking at Rather. "I'll be
bringing a guest. Raff Belmy and I'll be married as soon
as we get back to the Admiralty. I want to bring him back
to the tree. What he tells his father is up to him, but he'll
have at least a quarter year to think about it."

"So you decided," Rather said. He felt he had almost
gotten used to the loss.

"I'm like you. I'm tired of secrets."

"There's a plant here that grows good foliage," Jeffer
offered. "Dessert."

Carlot tossed an orange sphere at him.

Jeffer's acting like a happy eight-year-old. Rather

THE SMOKE RING / 297

thought as he tethered himself into a foliage patch for
sleep. Being alone out here must be rough on him. Maybe
all adults stay children someplace in their heads . . .

"Rather?"

"Yuh. Carlot?"

She wriggled under the lines and was alongside him.
Rather opened his mouth and closed it again. Then he
said, "I don't like lying to you."

"What now?"

"I was going to not say, 'What would Raff think?'"

She didn't move away. Presently she said, "You don't
understand us."

"Nope."

"We like to spread the genes around. Nobody talks
about it in public, but you hear. A man and a woman get
engaged. They make babies together. Sixty, seventy days
later, they get married. Maybe the first kid looks like the
rest and maybe he doesn't."

"But why?"

"It's the last chance. See, I'm going to marry Raff,
but there are men I turned down. They're not going to
just vanish. I wasn't with Raff off those sleeps I was away.
Raff's been seeing friends too, I don't know who. Rather,
it's just different. The officers say it's good. They talk
about gene drift."

"Okay."

"What Raff thinks about it is, he'd rather not know.
I never did wonder what Jill would think."

Jill. "We never made promises."

"Sure. But who else is there? There's nobody any-
where near her age in the tuft. Just you."

"I suppose. I wish I could have told her I was leaving.''

She said nothing. Rather couldn't drop it. "I wish I
could tell her it was worth it. You never wanted that raid
on the Library. You were right. If Kendy's really gone,
then why did it happen? The Navy'11 never stop being
suspicious ofus,and we didn't learn anything, and I can't

298 / Larry Niven

even tell Jill about the raid because I can't tell her about
Kendy."

She stirred. "You don't want me?"

"Sure I want you. Every sleep we're here, I want you.
I wanted you for keeps."

"You can't have that. When we marry, that's the end
of that. Understand?"

"Stet."

Kendy had run the records from CARMs #2 and #6
over and over. He'd built up a sublibrary of sorts under

RESOURCES, LOCAL USAGE.

Here: Citizens Tree was firing mud to make a cookpot.
Here: firing the laundry vat. Both had been recorded by
the silver suit as it moved unharmed through the fire. One
clip every ten minutes.

Here: curing the lines from the spaghetti jungle. Mark
the Silver Man unharmed in the smoke.

Here: the elevator in Citizens Tree. Here, recorded
years earlier by Klance the Scientist: the London Tree
elevator, run with stationary bicycles.

Here: CARM #6 changing the integral tree's orbit.
Here: Logbearer moving another tree.

Here: Rather collecting honey. Booce's voice explain-
ing that it was usually done with handmade armor. Here:

a set of hornet armor made to show the Navy customs
collectors, lest they seek for such and find the silver suit
instead.

The natives used materials from Discipline when they
had it. When they didn't, they made do. They were doing
very well without Kendy.

Discipline was making its second aerobraking pass,
ass-backward through the gas torus. The cone of the fu-
sion drive approached fusion temperatures. That was
hardly a danger, but the plasma streaming back along the
hull had to be watched.

Velocity, Smoke Ring median: 11 kps. Velocity at

THE SMOKE RING / 299

Kendy's distance: 3 kps. Discipline's, relative velocity: 20
kps and falling. Discipline reached perihelion and began
to rise, embedded in hot plasma. The animals were fran-
tic. Kendy couldn't spare attention for them. Nothing had
melted on his first pass . . . but the gas ahead of him
thickened as he rose, because Goldblatt's World was
ahead.

Visual: a raging, endless storm the size of Neptune.
Neudar: a core the size of two and a half Earths spun
once every seven hours, carrying the storm around with
it, until the atmospheric envelope trailed off into the
Smoke Ring. Instruments: impacting plasma increased in
temperature and density; velocity decreased. The ship
was surviving. There'd been the risk that he would have
to blow hydrogen ahead of him for cooling.

Goldblatt's World passed below, warping the ship's
path into something nearer a circle. Now the plasma den-
sity dropped fast.

Fifteen minutes of that was enough excitement for any
computer program. In an hour he'd be over the Admiralty
and out of the gas torus. He'd make his last short bum
then. It would hold him near the Admiralty for a good
half hour.

Discipline would be glowing bright enough to see, if
anyone looked in just the right direction. That might or
might not be good. Kendy had taken his time returning.
His long-range plans were in tatters and he didn't know
what to do about it.

Chapter Twenty-Three

Beginnings

from the Citizens Tree cassettes:

YEAR 384, DAY 2250. BOOCE RECORDED OUR

HOLDINGS BEFORE WE LEFT. HE'S APPALLED THAT WE
NEVER ASKED. BAD BUSINES8PERSONS, HE CALLS US.
WE DON'T USUALLY BOTHER TO SPELL OUT WHO OWNS
WHAT IN CITIZENS TREE. IT DRIVES BOOCE CRAZY.

WE SPENT A LOT ON SEEDS AND POOD AND WID-
GETS, BUT WE STILL HAVE CREDIT—IMAGINARY
MONEY—IN SOME VAGUE AMOUNT THAT DEPENDS ON
WHAT BOOCE ACTUALLY GETS FOR THE WOOD AND THE
METAL. WE'LLLEARNTHATWHEN, AND IF, WERETURN
TO THE ADMIRALTY.

—JEFFER THE SCIENTIST

THE LIFT CAGE DROPPED. IT WAS CROWDED WITH EIGHT

people and several bags from the CARM. Lawri and

THE SMOKE RING / 301

Gavving, Scientist and Chairman Pro Tern, seemed dis-
tinctly uncomfortable. It wasn't hard to guess why. Raff
Belmy was uncomfortable too. Carlot clung tight to his
arm, possessively, protectively.

"I had some trouble finding the tree," Jeffer said.

"Your problem," Gawing answered. "After all, you
took the silver suit. How were we supposed to tell you
where we were?"

"Yeah, but you moved the tree, didn't you? That thing
next to the lift, is that what I think it is?"

"Yes. Lawn's doing, mostly."

"Hah. Scientist, I thought you'd be twiddling your toes
waiting for me to come home."

"We found ways to occupy ourselves, Scientist." La-
wn's pregnancy was growing conspicuous. The formality
between her and her husband did not seem unfriendly.

Gavving said, "I hope you brought something to make
us look good."

The rest of them laughed; but Clave said, "Trouble?"

"Treefodder, yes, trouble! I'd have flown to a new tree
if I'd been sure they'd let me have wings. One thing, the
children are on our side. They've been crazy with waiting
to see what you bring back. And Minya stuck with me."

"She did? Good," said Clave.

"She did, in public."

Clave reached into a bag. He sliced an apple in half
and passed it to Gavving and Lawri. They bit, distrust-
fully, and continued eating. "That'll do it," Gavving said.

"Fine. Here. Don't eat the hull." He'd cut an orange
into quarters.

They gnawed the insides out of the oranges. Lawri
chewed and swallowed a bit from the peel, but did not
take another. Gavving said, "Yeah!"

"We've got seeds," Clave said. "This and a lot of
other earthlife. We'll plant them in the out tuft."

Faces like afield of flowers below the falling cage. Two

302 / Larry Niven

meteor-trails of golden blond hair: Jill next to Anthon,
she a meter shorter than her father, both scanning the
faces in the lift cage. Rather knew when -Till's eyes met
his, but her face didn't change.

The cage thumped into its housing. Children piled out
of the treadmill, and Mark with them. Everyone in Citi-
zens Tree was here.

They looked short: a field of dwarves in which Anthon
and the Serjent women stood out as normal. Rather had
become used to giants. Children and some adults crowded
around the cage. Jill and Anthon hung back, not quite
hostile, but suspending judgment. Mark had that look too.

For all these hundreds of days Rather had wondered
what the tribe would think of his mutiny. He'd almost
managed to forget that he had never told Jill, could not
have told her that he was going to leave the tree.

His mothers were crowding close around the lift, and
Karilly and Ryllin with them. The Serjent women hugged
Carlot, then Carlot's new husband. Karilly hung back a
little. She was conspicuously carrying a guest. Raff
beamed like sunlight at seeing someone he knew. They
fell into rapid conversation, moving away, taking Karilly
with them. "Damn, but I missed oranges . . . Booce had
to stay? I'm not surprised, but ..."

Karilly was silent.

Clave folded his wives into his arms and forced apples
on them.

Anthon slapped an orange from Debby's hand. Rather
heard: "You took this Admiralty man aboard the carmT'
before his First Mother picked him up to hug him.

"You treefeeding fool," Minya whispered. "You fool
mutineer, you. Drillbits in your brains, both of you, you
and your father. He never stopped wishing he'd gone too.
Are you all right?"

"I'm in good shape. Mostly." She pulled back to look
into his face. He tried to look earnest. "First Mother, I'm

THE SMOKE RING / 303

allergic to dry, thin air. Not enough sleep does it too. It's
like knives in the eyes. I go blind. It lasts for hours."

She started laughing. She said, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry,"
and hugged him hard, still laughing. There were tears in
her eyes. She put him down and saw him smiling slyly.
She said, "It'll never happen again. We'll keep the tree
where the air's thick. You'd better go talk to Jill."

"Why? What's wrong?"

"Talk to her first. Then I think—"

Jeffer shouted for attention. "I here present Raff
Belmy. Raff and Carlot are married by Admiralty law.
The record is in the cassettes."

Over the heads of his brothers and sisters, Rather saw
thejudging-look fade from Jill's face. She moved forward
at last. Rather said, "Harry, can you give me some pri-
vacy? Take them along?"

Harry said, "Oh. Sure." Somehow he got his siblings
moving away before Jill reached him.

Thejudging-look was back. She said, "Rather. How
are you?"

"Fine. Nobody made me a copsik. I didn't get killed.
Jill, I wanted to tell you."

"Were you afraid I'd run tell my father?"

"If I wasn't, the rest of us would have been. I couldn't,
Jill."

He saw her reject that. She asked, "What was it like?"

"I'll be a lot of days telling you that!" And suddenly
it was a pain in him, that he couldn't tell her about the
raid, ever.

"What's wrong now?"

"Nothing," he lied. "I was remembering how close I
came to joining the Admiralty Navy. I got out of it though.
Jill, dinner has to be something special. Is there time to
cook some of this earthlife?"

"Couple of days yet."

"I'll show you what to do." Take the kids too? He'd
thought he wanted to be alone with Jill, but now he knew

304 / Larry Niven

he didn't. "Harry! Gorey! Bring those bags to the cook-
pot."

The Admiralty slid west below him. Kendy began his
bum, then turned to his instruments.

Neudar and the telescope array caught Admiralty
Headquarters as it emerged from behind the Dark. The
Library didn't respond. It must be turned off. CARM #6
was nowhere in evidence. No pressure suit responded to
his query.

Sharls Davis Kendy had made more than one mistake.
For half a thousand years he had been frantic to begin
guiding his citizens in the Smoke Ring. Now he could
begin, and now he almost knew how. Opportunities would
come.

A part of his attention scanned his growing file on RE-
SOURCES, LOCAL USAGE:

Debby described Half Hand's kitchen for Jeffer's ben-
efit.

Clave carried the helmet on a slow trip through Serjent
House.

The camera viewpoint spun erratically through a cloud
of children. Children had knocked the helmet off its usual
perch at the lift, then played with it like a basketball.
Kendy viewed the commons as a series of stills. Corridor
openings, the water trap, the communal cooking area,
children laughing as they bounded in slow arcs.

A series of angular Clump houses, wildly various.

Mark's hut in various stages of construction. The silver
suit had been housed there for a time.

Abruptly the CARM #2 control board came to life.
Kendy sent his signal. Records came back: stills of var-
ious bored Guardians in their shared pressure suits, cul-
minating in (present time) six jungle-giant men in a half
circle around the control board, wearing anxious faces
and spotless new uniforms. These must be officers; and
now Kendy had their insignia.

THE SMOKE RING / 305
The signal disintegrated with distance.

He rounded forty degrees of Smoke Ring before he
made contact with CARM #6.

The vehicle was in its wooden dock at the midpoint of
Citizens Tree. It was empty of citizens and cargo. That
was Logbearer next to the left cage, and some smaller
structure next to that. Kendy "stared": he enlarged the
image and examined it in detail.

They'd built a steam rocket.

They didn't have a metal pipe or sikenwire, so they'd
used ceramics. Fired mud! The laundry vat was part of
it!

Records: the CARM on its way home. Logbearer was
strapped along the hull. Booce was missing. Rather was
present(!). The jungle-giant stranger matched the still of
Hilar Belmy's son.

Raff Belmy's medical readings, originally ominous,
settled down over passing days. Carlot must have helped
to calm him down. Rather was being abnormally polite to
both, and keeping his distance. The two spent consider-
able time out of sight aboard Logbearer.

Records: moving toward the Citizens Tree midpoint.
The ceramic rocket returned ahead of the CARM. It
puffed toward the in tuft, pushing a huge glob of black
mud, and passed out of range.

Records: "Year 384, day 2400, Jeffer speaking as Sci-
entist. Carm and Logbearer are both docked at Citizens
Tree. This will be my last log entry until Kendy calls.

"Kendy, for your information, Rather got out of Head-
quarters safely. We refueled the jets on an Admiralty pres-
sure suit and returned it. Captain-Guardian Mickl could
have had the other suits refueled too, but he never brought
them. Now he's got a pressure suit with jets. We gave
him some time to play, and then we told him what to do
when they run out of fuel.




306 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 307

"We've had no further trouble. Booce got a good offer
on the metal. The Navy was carving it up when we left.

"Rather suggests that Mickl wants the flying suit for
himself. It's something even the Admiral doesn't have.
He's got a secret now, and we know it, and he'll need us
to keep it flying. That gives us a certain edge with the
Captain-Guardian if we ever want to exploit it.

"We have some wealth and some influence in the Ad-
miralty. We got it without your help. We do not appreciate
your abandoning Rather in the middle of the raid.

"I've spent as much time waiting for your call as I care
to. I'll be back from time to time. If you haven't called
by the crossyear, which is three hundred and ninety-one
days from now, I will turn Voice off."

Nobody was near the CARM. The lift wasn't running.

The CARM drifted out of range. Kendy scanned the
far arc of the Smoke Ring out of habit; he had never seen
signs of industrial activity there.

The Admiralty flowed below him. The Library had
been turned off again.

Their ancestors hadn't listened to him either. They'd
turned off the Voice subsystems; they'd cut the fibers that
allowed Kendy to fly a CARM by remote. He'd been com-
pletely cut off for half a thousand years. As he was now.

Rather was scrubbing his teeth and thinking about
breakfast when the Silver Man came into the bach hut.
He spit and said, "Mark?"

"Who else?" Mark threw back his helmet. The silver
suit was filthy and stank of smoke. "I tried that. I felt
silly."

"Sure, silly. Mark, I saw their teeth. The older Ad-
miralty citizens still have half their teeth! I bet Ryllin and
Mishael have been scrubbing their teeth all along."
Rather remembered that this man wasn't his father . . .
and didn't know it, and had a legitimate grievance. All in
a rush he said, "I stole it. We thought we needed it and

we did. It was right to go. Treefodder, Mark, you're from
a bigger tree! Don't you feel cramped here?"

"Fifteen years I've felt cramped. Relax. You brought
back some wonderful things. You brought back the
CARM and the suit and you didn't ruin the suit."

"You looked mad enough to kill when we came
down."

"That was three good dinners ago. I never thought I'd
taste potatoes again. I know a better way to cook them."

"You forgive me? Mark, I'm really glad."

"What are my choices? Sure I forgive you. We're firing
the new laundry pot."

"Is it that late? I slept like a rock. Needed it too. These
first few sleeps I just lay there wondering why one of the
walls was pushing against me."

"I've spent some sleepless nights here myself," Mark
said. "It's lonely in the bach hut. We built it too big. Big
enough for the next crop of men."

"Maybe that's it."

"Have you talked to Jill?"

"Minya asked me that. We've talked. Why?"

"Yeah. Well." Mark sometimes had trouble finding
words. "Citizens Tree is strange. None of us grew up the
way you did. There are adults and children and a big gap
in between, so you couldn't tell much from just watching
older children grow up. Maybe there are things we should
have said—"

"I know about sex, if that's what you mean. . .Maybe
I need to know more. Two women have told me to feed
the tree. It hurts. What could you have told me about
that?"

Mark whistled. "You started young. Well, someone
could have said, There's only one suitable mate for you
and there's only one for Jill in this whole tuft, and she
thinks she owns you, and maybe she's right.'"

Rather let that percolate through his head. "Jill wants




308 / Larry Niven

to make babies with me? Did she tell you that, or are you
guessing?"

"I'm guessing. All I know is, when Instant Chairman
Gavving told us you'd gone off with all the wealth of Cit-
izens Tree, Jill was madder than I was, and that took some
doing. She wanted you thrown into the sky with no wings.
A hundred sleeps later she was sure you'd all be killed
and she couldn't see for crying."

"I'll go see her. Where is she?"

"Go easy, stet? You know you can find other mates.
Jill doesn't."

"I don't either. Sectry wants no part of me—" He
couldn't say why. Secrets. "And Carlot married someone
else. You can't imagine how bad that was. All the way
home, Carlot and Raff. They spent most of their time in
Logbearer. It wasn't any better when I couldn't see
them."

Mark said, "When nobody wants you in the first place,
that's worse. Trust me."

"Mark, I've gotten very good at lying. I'm trying to
stop."

"Good. Go talk to Jill."

"Where is she?"

"Everybody's watching us fire the laundry vat except
Jill. I've got to go back and see if anything needs doing.
Try the miz hut. Then the commons."

The deep voice hailed him as he entered. "Hello, Jeffer
the Scientist. This is Kendy."

Shouldn't that have been Kendy for the Statel Jeffe*-
said, "Uh-huh. You missed all the excitement."

"Not all. A large Navy ship is moving toward your
position. They'll reach you in eighty standard days."

Jeffer took a moment to absorb the shock. He should
have known. It wasn't over; it never would be. There was
no going back from the Clump expedition. No going back
from knowing about the Admiralty.

THE SMOKE RING / 309

He pulled himself forward to the control board. "That
gives us some time to talk."

The square, hard face in the bow window had always
lacked expression. It said, "A bad thing happened to me,
Jeffer. I learned too much about myself. There was no
way I could communicate until now."

"Lie to me, Kendy. Say there was something wrong
with Voice."

Kendy said, "The glitch was in myself. I think I have
it fixed. Machines go bad, Jeffer. I left you a file under
HISTORY. It's selected records from the settling of the
Smoke Ring. It explains some of what went wrong. Play
it after I'm out of range."

"Can you tell me about it?"

"No."

"Your timing was lousy. We thought you'd left Rather
for treefodder. If you ever—"

"I can't talk about it. It hurts my mind. Damage might
be permanent. Do you seek vengeance against me?"

The trouble was that Kendy looked and sounded as
calm as death. Kendy never showed anger, nor relief,
love, pain. It was hard to believe he was hurting ... yet
he was not a man. Maybe. Maybe.

Jeffer said, "Well, we got home. I assume you got most
of it from the log. The earthlife food stopped most of the
arguments. Now all the reunited couples are busy making
babies. The arguments haven't gone away, though.
They're just simmering. It won't help if there's a Navy
ship coming."

"It's coming. I couldn't resolve details of design.
There's alcohol in the exhaust, and it's coming from the
Clump. Definitely Navy. What have you done with the
seeds?"

"Seeds? We'll plant them in the out tuft. Mark's talk-
ing about building an extension to the lift before anything
gets ripe enough to pick."

"Cut some foliage so the sunlight can reach the plants.

310 / Larry Niven

THE SMOKE RING / 311

I can show you how to use water flow to move the lifts
with less effort. You haven't mentioned the fired mud
rocket."

"That's nice, isn't it? We don't need the Admiralty's
treefeeding pipes."

"You don't need me," Kendy said. He knew the risk
he was taking. It was acceptable. "I've been looking at
records. Most of what can be done with materials from
Discipline can also be done with Smoke Ring resources.
Lifts, housing, clothing, food, domestic animals. Now
rockets. The Admiralty even has a heliograph."

"No, we don't need you," Jeffer said, "but I never
thought you'd know it."

"A bad thing happened to me. I don't trust my judg-
ment any more. My intention has always been to make a
civilization in the Smoke Ring, modeled on the State that
shaped your ancestors. The Smoke Ring will never be
that. How can I make a State in a place where I can't
even make maps?"

"Would we even like your State? Skip it. What do
we do about that ship? I hope Sectry Murphy's aboard.
We'll get some notion of what they want if Rather talks
to her—"

"Hide the CARM in another tree. Tear out the dock
too, or put the ceramic rocket there. Show them that. It's
not advanced, but it doesn't need starstuff resources. It
may impress them. Keep the CARM manned. There are
two ways you might need it—"

"I won't bum them!"

"One way, then. You can't ignore the Admiralty.
You'd really like to join as officers. You may have to show
them the CARM before they'll listen to that. Demand of-
ficer status, but they may settle for giving it to just the
Chairman and Scientist—"

Jeffer laughed. "For a man who doesn't trust his own
judgment, you certainly—"

"I think fast. I plan fast. I make mistakes."

"Anything else?"

"Mark might want to join the Navy. Sound him out.
See if the Navy personnel might want him. I gather they
don't like older recruits, but Mark was trained in London
Tree. Karilly may benefit from going back. Is she still
mute?"

"Yes, but she's also pregnant and happy. I'm not sure
I want to fiddle."

"I'm almost out of range. Back in two days. The code
is HISTORY. Tell nobody of what you are about to leam."

"K—"

"Unless in your judgment it would be beneficial."

Kendy had never talked like this. "Stet."

The face faded. Jeffer didn't move for some time. Fi-
nally he tapped the white button. "Prikazyvat Voice."

"Hello, Jeffer the Scientist."

"Link to the pressure suit."

"Done."

"This is Jeffer calling anyone. Anyone home?"

"Hello? Scientist?" It was Jill's voice.

"I want to talk to my wife."

"I'll get her. She's on the branch."

That would take most of a day. Jeffer started the HIS-
TORY file and listened to it all the way through. Then he
started it again.

Lawri climbed in through the airlock. "I didn't have
anyone but Rather and Jill for a treadmill team. Every-
body else is on the branch. Now, what's all the excite-
ment, Scientist?"

"Prikazyvat Voice. Run HISTORY."

Dead voices spoke. Discipline's crew reported the dis-
covery of a weird cosmological anomaly. Some of what
followed was familiar from the cassettes. Some was en-
tirely cryptic.




312 / Larry Niven

"How long have you had this?" Lawri demanded.

"Kendy only just filed it. I ... I've been in contact
with him since before we left for the Clump."

Lawri was coldly angry.' 'That was mutiny! How could
you not trust meT'

"I'm trusting you now. Listen."

They heard a highly formalized quarrel. Some of the
participants argued for settling the Smoke Ring; some
were for moving on to an unnamed destination. Kendy
spoke in favor of staying, then tried to terminate the ar-
gument. It continued.

There were parts of a broadcast from Discipline to
Earth: it had been decided that they would settle the
Smoke Ring environment.

There was a message from Earth: Retrieve your crew.

"And that's it. Kendy got conflicting orders," Jeffer
said. "It tangles his mind. He can't go for new orders
because Earth is too far away, and he can't make up his
own mind because he's a machine, and he can't talk about
it because it drives him nuts. If that's all true, he must
be close to crazy all the time. The question is, what do
we do now?"

Lawri said, "We can play it through the silver suit.
Play it for the whole tribe. Tell everyone."

"It'll start some fights."

"Feed the—"

He rode her down. "There's a Navy ship coming. The
fights'U have to be over when it gets here. A hundred
days."

"Stet. Play it at dinner."

". . . Stet."

The situation was ideal in its way. They were together,
but they couldn't talk. There were only the two of them
to run the lift. It took all their breath. Jill scrambled over

THE SMOKE RING / 313

the rungs, keeping up with him. Her tuftberry-red tunic
was dark with sweat at chest and armpits. Her hair was
a golden halo, as interesting and as beautiful as Sectry's
scarlet.

After the cages passed each other, they let the treadmill
carry them round and round. Then it was time to throw
their weight on the brake. The lower cage settled. Rather
and Jill dropped into soft foliage and panted.

Rather found his breath . . . and found Jill watching
him solemnly.

He said briskly (he hoped), "Mark says you own me.
This is a thought that never crossed my mind."

"He says that?"

"Yes. He says I own you too. What do you think?"

"I think Mark doesn't have the right to say it."

He was an arm's length away. He couldn't read her
expression. He said, "It's not just Mark. My parents—
all four, or all three and a half, and everyone else too,
including you, Jill. You all seem to know just where I fit
and what I'm supposed to do for the rest of my life."

"Well, you don't take orders worth treefodder." He
was not sure that was a smile. "What's bothering you,
Rather? You came home on purpose. You're on the cook-
pot because you volunteered to cook the earthlife. You're
the Teller because you've got stories and you like telling
them. It gets you offtreemouth duty."

"I like all of that. But I'm told where to sleep and I'm
told who to marry, and everyone looked at me funny till
I changed back into tuftberry red, and the whole damn
tribe sent me to talk to you."

"Okay. Talk."

"Rather doesn't take orders worth treefodder. You
talk. Are you unsatisfied with me?"

"You went into the sky and left me behind."

"I did."

"Is that over now? Are you back for keeps?"

314 / Larry Niven THE SMOKE RING / 315

"No."
"Why not?"

Rather sighed. "I like coming home. I like seeing new
things too. Some of us will have to go back to the Ad-
miralty anyway, Jill. Ryllin wants to join Booce. Then
there's a whole sky out there! Lawri says our gene pool
is too little. Fine. We'll go find some other trees and get
mates there."

"Should I do that?"

Running endlessly up the treadmill, he'd had some time
to think. "Maybe. Or you could marry me, but I'll take
trips, and you'd have to put up with that—"

She flared. "You'd be making babies with every
woman who talks funny!"

That was manifestly unfair. Rather let it pass. "Or you
could come with me."

"Stet."

"That quick? Are you sure?"

"Sure."

This was working out better than he'd hoped. "Did
you work on that new rocket?"

"No. Why?"

He hadn't thought it all the way through after all.
"We've got time. In a couple of years a dozen kids will
be ready to find mates. That's when we'll start visiting
other trees—"

"I see it. I'd have to know the rocket inside out, how
to steer it, how to fix anything that goes wrong, because
I'm the oldest."

"You and the rest of the crew too. Can you fly?"

"Sure. Oh, all right, I don't do much flying. Rather?"

"Here."

"You seem to have a very good idea of where I fit and
what I'm supposed to do."

It was a smile. "Sorry."

"Maybe this is what being married is like. Anyway. . .
I'll go on the next trip. That'll tell us everything we need
to know. Whether I can stand it. Whether citizens can
stand my company aboard a rocket. Whether I'm any
good. Whether I want a mate from somewhere else.
Whether you do."

"Next trip will be the Admiralty."

"Stet," said Jill. She stood up. "Let's go flying."

"There's nobody to run the lift for us."

"Off the branch," said Jill. "Fly to the midpoint. Sur-
prise Lawri."

It would do that! Rather began to understand that Jill
would go where he would, and try to beat him there too.
"We'll have to fly more than thirty klomters out. Can you
handle it?"

"Sure. We'll go off the branch and put wings on af-
terward. Otherwise someone'11 stop us. Come on."

Kendy had assembled the HISTORY file with some care.
It was unaltered records, but it gave the distinct impres-
sion that Discipline's crew had themselves decided to set-
tle the Smoke Ring.

The population of the Smoke Ring was between two
and three thousand (Kendy included children). By his
original orders, Kendy must consider that they might now
be the entire human race. The temptation to meddle was
very strong.

He would not shape them. They were shaping them-
selves, and they were doing it well. For agonizing mo-
ments he had even considered severing communications
entirely.

But he had things to teach them!

The Library was off when he passed the Admiralty. It
wouldn't stay that way, though. Day 2791 was the mid-
point of the crossyear, three hundred and fifty-odd days
away. If Kendy knew his citizens, they would celebrate,




316 / Larry Niven

and the Library would be involved. Perhaps he c<
reach Wayne Mickl. Kendy had a handle of sorts on
Captain-Guardian.

Meanwhile a Navy ship was moving on Citizens T
He'd see what terms he could arrange.

Plenty of time. Kendy waited.