THE ROAD TO 
DUNE 
THE   DUNE   SERIES 
FRANK HERBERT'S  DUNE NOVELS 
Dune                    God Emperor of Dune 
Dune Messiah                 Heretics of Dune  
Children of Dune             Chapterhouse: Dune  
DUNE COLLECTION  BY FRANK HERBERT, BRIAN HERBERT, AND KEVIN J. ANDERSON 
Dune Novels by 
Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson Dune: House Atreides                      Dune: The Battle of Comin 
Dune: House Harkonnen             Spice Planet  (in The Road to Dune) 
Dune: House Corrino                  Hunters of Dune  (forthcoming) 
Dune: The Butlerian Jihad             Sandworms of Dune (forthcoming) 
Dune: The Machine Crusade                Paul of Dune  (forthcoming) 
Dune Short Stories by 
Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson 
A Whisper of Caladan Seas 
Hunting Harkonnens 
Whipping Mek The Faces of a Martyr 
Dune Films 
Dune 
Frank Herbert's Dune  (television miniseries) Frank Herbert's Children of Dune  (television miniseries) 
THE ROAD TO 



                                                                                        

Frank Herbert, Brian Herbert,  
and 
Kevin J. Anderson 
TORŪ 
A TOM DOHERTY ASSOCIATES BOOK NEW YORK 
FOR   BEVERLY  HERBERT 
There is no more moving tribute in all of literature than the three pages Frank Herbert wrote about Beverly Herbert 
in Chapterhouse: Dune,  a novel that he completed at her side in Hawaii, while she was dying. Concerning his loving 



wife and best friend during more than thirty-seven years of marriage, he said, "Is it any wonder that I look back on 
our years together with a happiness transcending anything words can describe? Is it any wonder I do not want or 
need to forget one moment of it? Most others merely touched her life at the periphery. I shared it in the most intimate 
ways and everything she did strengthened me. It would not have been possible for me to do what necessity 
demanded of me during the final ten years of her life, strengthening her in return, had she not given of herself in the 
preceding years, holding back nothing. I consider that to be my great good fortune and most miraculous privilege." 
His earlier dedication in Children of Dune spoke of other dimensions of this remarkable woman: 
FOR BEV: 
Out of the wonderful commitment of our love 
and to share her beauty and her wisdom, 
for she truly inspired this book. 
Frank Herbert modeled Lady Jessica Atreides after Beverly Herbert, as well as many aspects of the Bene Gesserit 
Sisterhood. Beverly was his writing companion and his intellectual equal. She was Frank Herbert's universe, his 
inspiration, and-more than anyone else-his spiritual guide on the Road to Dune. 
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 
WE ARE GRATEFUL to the people who contributed to this book, in particular to Frank Herbert, Beverly 
Herbert, Jan Herbert, Rebecca Moesta, Penny Merritt, Ron Merritt, Bruce Herbert, Bill Ransom, Howie 
Hansen, Tom Doherty, Pat LoBrutto, Sharon Perry, Robert Gottlieb, John Silbersack, Kate Scherler, 
Kimberly Whalen, Harlan Ellison, Anne McCaffrey, Paul Stevens, Eric Raab, Sterling E. Lanier, Lurton 
Blassingame, Lurton Blassingame, Jr., John W. Campbell, Jr., Catherine Sidor, Diane Jones, Louis 
Moesta, Carolyn Caughey, Damon Knight, Kate Wilhelm, and Eleanor Wood. 
FOREWORD 
FRANK HERBERT HAD more fun with life than anyone I've known. He laughed more, joked more, and 
produced more than any writer I've ever met. With modest beginnings just across the Puyallup River from 
my own birthplace, and passionate about outdoor life, he judged people by their creativity, and by whether 
they met hardship with humor or with bile. Humor helped him to endure hardship and to enjoy his rise 
above it, Frank believed the suffering-in-the-garret stereotype was foisted onto writers by publishers so 
that they could get away with small advances. The only true currency that Frank recognized was time to 
create. 
"Here it is, Ransom," he said. "First class buys you more time to write." 
Never ostentatious, he lived as comfortably as he wanted but not as extravagantly as he could, always with 
close ties to the outdoors. Enjoyment A.D. ("After Dune") came from trying new writing adventures and 
from helping others succeed; Frank offered opportunities, not handouts, saying, "I'd rather give a man a 
hand up than step on his fingers." This echoes my favorite Dostoevsky line: "Feed men, then ask of them 
virtue." 
Everything and everyone fell into two rough categories for Frank: It/he/she either contributed to his 
writing time or interfered with it. I've always had pretty much the same attitude. We knew of each other 
through our publication successes, but we noticed each other's successes because we both came from the 
Puyallup Valley, we both had fathers who were in law enforcement in the same district, and we'd had 
shirttail relatives marry. We moved to Port Townsend in the same week in the early seventies and 
discovered this when the local paper ran stories on each of us. I wanted to meet him, finally, but I wanted 
to be respectful of his writing time. Frank wrote a piece under a pseudonym for the Helix, my favorite 
underground newspaper in Seattle, just a few years earlier. I dropped Frank a postcard addressed to the 
pseudonym ("H. Bert Frank"), saying I wrote until noon but would love to meet for coffee sometime. The 
next afternoon at 12:10 he called: "Hello, Ransom. Herbert here. Is that coffee on?" It was, and thus began 
our fifteen-year routine of coffee or lunch nearly every day. 
Frank believed poetry to be the finest distillation of the language, whether written in open or closed form. 
He read voraciously in contemporary poetry through literary and "little" magazines, and he wrote poetry 
as he worked through issues of life and of fiction. As a very young man, he discovered that he could make 
somewhat of a living from his nonfiction prose style, which was far more readable than most of the 
journalism of the time. His prose style, his eye for detail, and his ear for true vernacular coupled with that 
ever-persistent "What if?" question in his ear made for a natural transition to fiction. Success came to 



Frank in prose, but inspiration filled his notebooks and his fiction with poetry. 
My first poetry collection, Finding True North & Critter, was nominated for the National Book Award the 
same year Frank's Soul Catcher was nominated in fiction. Perhaps if Frank and I had both been fiction 
writers off the bat, or both poets, our friendship may have developed 
differently. As it was, we refreshed and reenthused each other with our writing, and encouraged each other 
to risk something in our work, like crossing over into other genres, such as screenplays. The greatest risk 
of all, to friendship and to our writing reputations, came when we co-wrote The Jesus Incident and 
submitted it under both of our names. Frank pointed out that if the book were published we would each 
face specific criticisms for working together. People would say that Frank Herbert ran out of ideas, and 
that Bill Ransom was riding on the coat-tails of the Master. When these statements did, indeed, come up, 
we were better prepared psychologically for having predicted them in advance. Circumstances leading up 
to our collaboration were complex, but our personal agreement was simple: Nothing that either of us 
wanted would stand in the way of the friendship, and we shook hands. Nothing did, not even the 
publisher's preference that we release it just with Frank's name (the advance offer under this potential 
agreement was larger by a decimal point than what we received with both names on the cover). The power 
people also would accept a pseudonym, but they were adamant that a novel acknowledged to be by two 
authors would not fly with the reading public, and equally adamant about talking only with Frank. In 
addition, they believed that my reputation in poetry circles would contribute nothing toward marketing the 
book; therefore, I should get 25% and Frank 75% of whatever we agreed on. Frank literally hung up the 
phone and bought a ticket to New York. The way he told the story upon his return with contract in hand, 
he simply repeated a mantra throughout his visit: "Half the work earns half the credit and half the pay." 
Frank took a 90% cut in pay and split the cover byline in order to work with me, only one example of the 
strength of his character and of his friendship. 
The gamble paid off. We'd heard that The New York Times Book Re-view would cover it, and I was 
nervous. "Relax, Ransom," Frank said. "Even a scathing review in The New York Times sells ten thousand 
hardbacks the next day." John Leonard wrote a wonderful review, and we were launched. Now the 
publisher wanted two more books in the series, The Lazarus Effect and The Ascension Factor, with no 
further discussion about names on the cover. For two rustic, self-taught Puyallup Valley boys who ran 
traplines as kids, we did well because our focus always was on The Story. We had no ego conflicts while 
writing together, largely because Frank didn't have much ego as "Author." I learned from him that authors 
exist merely for the story's sake, not the other way around, and a good story had to do two things: inform 
and entertain. The informing part must be entertaining enough to let readers live the story without feeling 
like they're on the receiving end of a sermon. Writing entertainment without information, without some in-
sight into what it is to be human, is a waste of good trees. 
Frank believed that poetry was the apex of human language; he also believed that science fiction was the 
only genre whose subject matter attempted to define what it is to be human. We use contact with aliens or 
alien environments as impetus or backdrop for human interaction. Science fiction characters solve their 
own problems-neither magic spells nor gods come to their aid-and sometimes they have to build some 
intriguing gadgets to save their skins. Humans go to books to see how other humans solve human 
problems. Frank admired and championed human resolve and ingenuity in his life and in his work. He had 
a practical side about this, too: "Remember, Ransom," he said, "aliens don't buy books. Humans buy 
books." 
Frank raised chickens, and he even did that first-class, with a two-story, solar-heated chicken house with 
automatic feeders that abutted the garden to enrich the compost. Beside the chicken mansion, but 
mercifully out of sight of the chickens, was a processing station complete with wood stove, steamer, and 
automatic plucking machine. Every activity of Frank's daily life was fair game for ingenuity and fun. He 
admired the very intellectual writers, like Pound, but had a particular soft spot for other blue-collar, self-
taught writers who investigated human nature, such as Hemingway and Faulkner. 
William Faulkner's work influenced Frank in many ways, not the least of which was creating a believable 
fictional universe built on a 
complex genealogy. Frank saw science fiction as a great opportunity to reach a very wide audience with 



"the big stuff." He was moved by Faulkner's 1950 Nobel Prize acceptance speech and he took it to heart in 
everything he wrote: "... the young man or woman writing today has forgotten the problems of the human 
heart in conflict with itself which alone can make good writing because only that is worth writing about, 
worth the agony and the sweat. . . the old verities and truths of the heart, the old universal truths lacking 
which any story is ephemeral and doomed-love and honor and pity and pride and compassion and 
sacrifice." Story itself provides the foundation for every human culture, and storytellers must respect this 
responsibility. 
Frank had a guardian angel, someone who protected him and his writing time at all costs for almost four 
decades. Beverly Stuart Herbert honeymooned with him in a fire lookout, packed the kids up in a hearse to 
live in a village in Mexico while he wrote, and encouraged him to quit dead-end jobs to write what he 
loved, come what may. She had uncanny radar for detecting buffoons, hangers-on, con artists, and other 
fools, and Frank was pretty good at this, too. Not many got past Bev to test Frank. But Bev had the 
diplomacy and good graces to protect Frank while also protecting the dignity of those who would intrude 
on him. Later, over coffee and homemade pie, came the jokes. 
Bev was the one who suggested that we collaborate on a novel. She was Frank's first reader and critic, and 
her opinion held serious water. Over our daily coffee sessions we'd been tossing a story back and forth just 
for fun. "You two should just write this story and get it out of your systems," she said. Each of us took on 
the project for very different reasons. I wanted to learn how to sustain a narrative for a novel's length, and 
Frank wanted to practice collaboration because he was interested in screenwriting, a notoriously 
collaborative medium. We both got what we wanted, and with his usual wit Frank referred to our process 
as "... a private act of collaboration between consenting adults." 
Not all of our experiences together were celebratory. My writing work with Frank is bracketed by sadness 
for both of us. We began our 
first collaboration when Bev was diagnosed with cancer and I was going through a divorce; we wrote The 
Lazarus Effect as Bev fought her second round of illness (Frank wrote The White Plague at the same time) 
and it was published shortly before her death. Our collaboration on The Ascension Factor ended with 
Frank's death. 
An unexpected benefit of our exercise in collaboration became Frank's collaboration with his son Brian. 
Frank said that he had hoped that one day one of his children might follow in Dad's writing footsteps, and 
Brian began with some humorous science fiction. Father and son working together on Man of Two Worlds 
marked a breakthrough for Frank after the long ordeal of Bev's final illness. Brian learned the fine art of 
collaboration at Frank's side, and Frank would be proud that the dual legacies of the Dune universe and the 
Herbert writing gene survive him. Brian and Kevin J. Anderson are having the kind of fun with writing 
that Frank and I enjoyed, and they've added a new physical depth and enriched the sociopolitical detail of 
the greater tapestry on which Dune was woven. 
I was at about mid-point in writing the first draft of The Ascension Factor when the morning radio 
announced that Frank had passed away. Typically, he believed he would beat this challenge as he'd beaten 
so many others. Also typically, he was typing a new short story into a laptop when he died, a story that 
he'd told me might lead to another non-genre novel like Soul Catcher. In the crowding and confusion of 
those final lifesaving attempts, that laptop and his last story were lost, like Einstein's final words were lost 
because the nurse at his side didn't speak German. 
I think of Frank every time I touch a keyboard, hoping I'm writing up to his considerable standards. In the 
Old English, "poet" was "shaper" or "maker." Frank Herbert was a Maker on a grand scale, the most loyal 
friend a person could ask for-and a funny, savvy, first-class guy. He continues to be missed. 
-Bill Ransom 
PREFACE 
A beginning is the time for taking the most delicate care that the balances are correct.  
- FROM FRANK HERBERT'S Dune 
IT WAS LIKE finding a buried treasure chest. 
Actually, they were cardboard boxes stuffed full of folders, manuscripts, correspondence, drawings, and 
loose notes. Some of the box corners were sagging, crumpled by the weight of their contents or partially 



crushed from languishing under a stack of heavy objects. 
As Brian described in his Hugo-nominated biography Dreamer of Dune, Frank Herbert's wife, Beverly, 
was very ill in her last years and unable to keep up with the deluge of paper. For a long time before that, 
she had kept her prolific husband highly organized, using an ingenious filing system to keep track of old 
manuscripts, contracts, royalty reports, correspondence, reviews, and publicity. 
In the boxes we found old manuscripts for Frank Herbert's various novels, along with unpublished or 
incomplete novels and short stories, 
and an intriguing folder full of unused story ideas. There were old movie scripts, travel itineraries, and 
legal documents from Frank Herbert's work on various films, including The Hellstrom Chronicle, Thresh' 
old: The Blue Angels Experience, The Tillers, David Lynch's Dune, and even Dino de Laurentiis's film Flash 
Gordon, on which Frank had worked in London as a script consultant. There were contracts and 
screenplays for numerous uncompleted film projects as well, including Soul Catcher, The Santaroga Barrier, 
and The Green Brain. 
Salted among the various boxes full of materials for Dune Messiah and God Emperor of Dune (under its 
working title of Sandworm of Dune), we found other gems: drafts of chapters, ruminations about ecology, 
handwritten snippets of poetry, and lyrical descriptions of the desert and the Fremen. Some of these were 
scrawled on scraps of paper, bedside notepads, or in pocket-sized newspaper reporter notebooks. There 
were pages and pages of epigraphs that had never appeared in Frank's six Dune novels, along with 
historical summaries and fascinating descriptions of characters and settings. Once we started the laborious 
process of sifting through these thousands of pages, we felt like archaeologists who had discovered a 
verified map to the Holy Grail. 
And this was just the material in the attic of Brian Herbert's garage. 
It didn't include the two safe-deposit boxes of materials found more than a decade after Frank's death, as 
we described in the afterword to our first Dune prequel, House Atreides. In addition, Frank had 
bequeathed dozens of boxes of his drafts and working notes to a university archive, which the university 
generously opened to us. After spending time in the silent back rooms of academia, we uncovered further 
bounty. Kevin later returned for more days of photocopying and double-checking, while Brian tended to 
other Dune projects. 
The wealth of newly discovered material was a Dune fan's dream come true. And make no mistake: We 
are Dune fans. We pored over hoards of wondrous and fascinating information, valuable not only for 
its historical significance but also for its pure entertainment value. This included an outline (along with 
scene and character notes) for Spice Planet, a completely different, never-before-seen version of Dune. 
We also found previously unpublished chapters and scenes from Dune and Dune Messiah, along with 
correspondence that shed light on the crucial development of the Dune universe-even a scrap of paper 
torn from a notepad on which Frank Herbert had written in pencil: "Damn the spice. Save the men!" This, 
the defining moment in the character of Duke Leto Atreides, might well have been written when Frank 
Herbert switched on his bedside lamp and jotted it down just before drifting off to sleep. 
The Road to Dune features the true gems from this science-fiction treasure trove, including Spice Planet, 
which we wrote from Frank's outline. We are also including four of our original short stories: "A Whisper 
of Caladan Seas" (set during the events of Dune) and three connecting "chapters" surrounding our novels 
in the Butlerian Jihad saga: "Hunting Harkonnens," "Whipping Mek," and "The Faces of a Martyr." 
Had Frank Herbert lived longer, he would have presented the world with many more stories set in his 
fantastic, unparalleled universe. Now, almost two decades after his untimely death, we are honored to 
share this classic legacy with millions of Frank Herbert's fans worldwide. 
The spice must flow! 
-Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson 
SPICE PLANET 
The Alternate Dune Novel 
By Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson, from Frank Herbert's original outline  



INTRODUCTION 
FINDING SUCH A wealth of notes was just one step down the road, but the fresh material, ideas, clues, and 
explanations suddenly crystallized many things in the chronology of the Dune epic. It rekindled in us a 
kind of honeymoon excitement for the whole universe. 
We photocopied boxes of this material and then sorted, labeled, and organized everything. The biggest 
challenge was to make sense of it all. As part of the preparation work before writing our first Dune 
prequel, we had compiled a detailed concordance and electronically scanned all the text from the original 
six novels so that we could better search the source material. Now, with highlighter pens, we marked im-
portant information in the stacks of notes, illuminating unused blocks of text and descriptions that we 
might want to incorporate into our novels, character backgrounds, and story ideas. 
Scattered among the boxes, we found some sheets of paper marked with letters-Chapter B, Chapter N, et 
cetera-that were at first puzzling. These pages gave brief descriptions of dramatic scenes that dealt with 
sandworms, storms, and unexpected new spice-mining techniques. Some of the action took place in 
recognizable but skewed places, as if viewed through a fractured lens: Dune Planet or Duneworld instead 
of Dune, Catalan instead of Caladan, Carthage instead of Carthag, and the like. In Spice Planet, unlike 
Dune, the characters do not break the rhythm of their strides on the desert sand to prevent a sandworm 
from hearing them and attacking. Apparently, this had not yet occurred to Frank Herbert in the evolution 
of Dune. 
The chapters of Spice Planet were populated by unfamiliar characters- Jesse Linkam, Valdemar 
Hoskanner, Ulla Bauers, William English, Esmar Tuek, and a concubine named Dorothy Mapes. These 
strangers were interacting with well-known characters such as Gurney Halleck, Dr. Yueh (Cullington 
Yueh instead of Wellington Yueh), Wanna Yueh, and a familiar-sounding planetary ecologist named Dr. 
Bryce Haynes. Although a minor character (a spice smuggler) had been named Esmar Tuek in the final 
published version of Dune, he was quite different in the newly discovered notes, a major player and 
clearly the original model for a well-loved figure, the warrior-Mentat Thufir Hawat. Dorothy Mapes filled 
a role similar to that of Lady Jessica. The nobleman Jesse Linkam himself was obviously the basis for 
Duke Leto Atreides, and Valdemar Hoskanner was the embryonic Baron Vladimir Harkonnen. 
When we arranged all the chapters and read through the remarkable outline, we found that Spice Planet 
was a unique and worthy story in its own right, not just a precursor to Dune. Although the harsh desert is 
very similar to the one familiar to millions of fans, the tale itself is thematically different, focusing on 
decadence and drug addiction instead of ecology, finite resources, freedom, and religious fanaticism. In 
part of the short novel, the main character, Jesse Linkam, must survive in the desert with his son, Barri (an 
eight-year-old version of Paul Atreides, without his powers). This scene echoes the escape in Dune of 
Lady Jessica into the desert with her son Paul. Spice Planet, like Dune, is filled with political intrigues and 
a ruling class of self-indulgent noblemen, so there are plenty of parallels. Above all, this earlier concept 
gives us an insight into the complex mind of Frank Herbert. 
Somewhere along the way, the author shelved his detailed outline for Spice Planet. Starting from scratch, 
with input from legendary editor John W. Campbell, Jr., he developed the concept into a much more vast 
and more important novel, yet one that he found nearly impossible to sell. It was rejected by more than 
twenty publishers before being picked up, finally, by Chilton Book Co., best known for publishing auto 
repair manuals. 
Ironically, if Frank had written Spice Planet according to his original plan-a science-fiction adventure 
novel about the same length as most paperback books published at the time-he might have had a much 
easier task finding an editor and a publishing house. 
Using Frank's outline, we have written the novel Spice Planet according to the original design, providing a 
window into the Dune that might have been. 
PART ONE 
1 
Duneworld is like the Empire and life itself: Regardless of what one sees on the surface, a clever investigator can uncover dee per and deeper 
layers of complexity. 
- DR. BRYCE HAYNES, planetary ecologist assigned to study Duneworld 



 When the Imperial ship arrived at Catalan's main spaceport, the 
high rank and notoriety of the passenger told Jesse Linkam that the news must be important. The 
Emperor's representative directed his transmission to the House Linkam "protocol office," demanding to 
be met with full honors, and without delay. 
Jesse politely acknowledged, not revealing who he was or that his household had no need for a formal 
protocol office. He preferred not to make an issue of his rank and enjoyed spending his free time among 
the working class. In fact, he had spent that very afternoon fishing on Catalan's vast and fertile sea, 
making a sweep for glimmerfish before an expected storm hammered the coast. When the message 
arrived, he'd been hauling in the sonic nets full of fish, laughing with the rough 
crewmen who struggled to get over their awe of the nobleman and accept him as one of their own. 
Though he was the foremost aristocrat on Catalan, Jesse Linkam didn't mind getting his hands dirty. Tall 
and middle-aged, he was a quiet man with hidden strengths. The gray eyes measured, weighed, and 
counted everything. His classic features bore a rugged cast, thanks to a once-broken nose that gave his 
face the look of an offbeat metronome. 
He was not soft and preoccupied with silly diversions like most of his noble peers on other worlds, who 
treated leadership like little more than a game of dress-up. Here on the "uncivilized" fringes of the Empire, 
too much real work needed to be done to bother with fashions and courtly intrigues. Jesse loved the fresh, 
salty air and considered sweaty clothes a better badge of honor than the finest whisper-lace from the 
Imperial capital world of Renaissance. How could anyone expect to rule a people well without knowing 
their daily toil, their joys and concerns? 
However, because of his high station, Jesse was required by law to be at the beck and call of the Grand 
Emperor's envoy. Returning to his mansion, the Catalan nobleman changed his clothes and scrubbed the 
fish smell from his hands, while a doting servant spread a perfumed ointment on his chapped knuckles. As 
a last touch, Jesse pinned badges of office onto his own surcoat. He had no time for further grooming: 
Counselor Bauers would have to accept him as he was. 
Out in front, he joined a hastily organized groundcar entourage already waiting to depart for the spaceport. 
"I hope this is important," Jesse muttered to his security chief. 
"Important to you? Or to the Grand Emperor?" Esmar Tuek sat beside him in the lead vehicle as the 
motorcade moved with stately haste toward the landed ship. "How often does Emperor Wuda take notice 
of our little Catalan?" Since they were in private, Jesse allowed the old veteran to use familiar speech with 
him. 
The question was a fair one, and Jesse hoped it would be answered soon enough. Banners fluttering, the 
groundcars approached the gaudy Imperial ship. The vessel's ramp was already extended, but no one had 
emerged, as if waiting for an official reception. 
Jesse stepped out of the lead car. In the breeze, his dark hair whipped about like loose strands of sea kelp. 
He straightened his formal jacket and waited while the honor guard scrambled into position. 
No doubt, the impromptu procession would only foster the impression of Catalan being a rude backwater 
world. On other worlds, noblemen drilled their soldiers in relentless parades and exhibitions. In stark 
contrast, though Jesse's volunteers would fight fiercely to defend their homes, they had little interest in 
twirling batons or marching in lock-step. 
On the Imperial spacecraft's ramp, Counselor Ulla Bauers stepped out. His nose twitched as he sniffed the 
ocean-mist air, and his forehead wrinkled. The Grand Emperor's representative-a prissy and ferretlike 
man with a demeanor of foppish incompetence-wore a voluminous high-collared robe and dandy 
ornamentation that made his head seem too small. 
Jesse knew not to underestimate this man, however. The Counselor's overemphasis on fashion and 
trappings might be a mere disguise; Bauers was rumored to be a swift and highly effective assassin. The 
fact that he had come here did not bode well. 
With a flick of his fingers to one eyebrow, the traditional sign of allegiance to the Emperor, Jesse said, 
"Counselor Bauers, I welcome you to my humble Catalan. Won't you come and join us?" 
The Imperial advisor descended halfway down the ramp with a smooth gait, as if his feet were on wheels. 



Bauers's piercing eyes swept the docks, the fishing boats, the weather-hardened shacks, the warehouses, 
and shops that ringed the harbor. He soaked up droplets of information like a dry sponge. "Hmm-ahh, yes . 
.. humble indeed, Nobleman Linkam." 
The local guardsmen stiffened. Hearing an impolite grumble and a 
sharp, whispered rebuke from General Tuek, Jesse merely smiled. "We will gladly provide you with our 
most comfortable rooms, Counselor, and an invitation to this evening's banquet. My concubine is as 
skilled at managing our household kitchens as she is at organizing my business affairs." 
"I have my own chef aboard this diplomatic craft." Bauers removed an ornately inlaid metal cylinder from 
one of his billowing sleeves and extended the messagestat like a scepter toward Jesse. "As for this eve-
ning, you would be better advised to spend your time packing. I return to Renaissance in the morning, and 
the Grand Emperor wishes you to accompany me. All the details are contained in this dispatch." 
Feeling an icy dread, Jesse accepted the cylinder. Bowing slightly, he forced himself to say, "Thank you, 
Counselor. I will study it carefully." 
"Be here at dawn, Nobleman." Turning with a swirl of his robes, Bauers marched back up the ramp. The 
dignitary had not even set foot on Catalan, as if afraid it might soil his shoes. 
A COLD RAIN stretched into the darkest hours of the night, while clouds masked the canvas of stars. 
Standing on an open balcony above the sea, Jesse watched raindrops sizzling against the electrostatic 
weather screen around him. Each sparkle was like a variable star, form ing transient constellations just 
above his head. 
For most of an hour, he had been brooding. He picked up the messagestat from where it rested on the 
balcony rail. When he pulled on each end of the cylinder, mirrors and lenses popped up, and words 
spooled out in Grand Emperor Wuda's voice: "His Imperial Majesty requests the immediate presence of 
Nobleman Jesse Linkam in the Central Palace to hear our decision in the matter of the spice-production 
dispute over Duneworld in the Arrakis system. As the complainant, and as a duly elected representative of 
the Nobles' Council, you are hereby notified that the defendant, Nobleman Hoskanner, has offered 
a compromise. If you refuse to appear, we shall dismiss your action, and no further arguments will be 
heard." 
Jesse snapped the cylinder shut before the Grand Emperor's voice could reel off his tedious vocal 
signature, which included the customary list of titles and responsibilities. 
Dorothy Mapes, his beloved concubine and business manager, came up behind him and touched his arm. 
After serving eleven years at Jesse's side, she knew how to interpret his moods. "Most nobles would be 
honored to receive a personal summons from the Grand Emperor. Shouldn't you give him the benefit of 
the doubt?" 
Jesse turned to her with a quick frown. "It is couched in the best diplomatic language, but I fear this could 
be the end of us, my darling. Any offer from Valdemar Hoskanner comes with more than strings 
attached-a noose is more likely." 
"Then be cautious. Nevertheless, you know you have to deal with Valdemar. You've been drawn into this 
dispute, and the other nobles are counting on you." 
He gave her a wan, loving smile. She had short, dark hair interspersed with lighter peppery flecks. Set in 
an oval, attractive face, her large rusty brown eyes were the color of the polished myrtle wood found in the 
headlands. For a moment, he stared at the unusual diagem ring she wore on her right hand-his 
nobleman's pledge of love to her. Though a commoner, Dorothy was not at all common. 
"For years, Dor, you've been my inspiration, my guiding light, and my closest advisor. You've turned our 
family's finances around, repairing most of the damage my father and brother did before their deaths. But 
I'm not so sure about Duneworld . . ." He shook his head. 
The petite woman looked up at him. "See if this helps clarify your thinking." She placed a pinch of the 
spice melange on his lips. "From Duneworld. It's what this is all about." 
He savored the cinnamon flavor, felt the pleasurable rush of the drug. It seemed everyone was using it 
these days. Shortly after the discovery of the substance on the inhospitable world, the Emperor's survey 
crews had installed forward bases and mapped the desert, laying the groundwork for exploitation of the 
spice. Since then, melange had become an extremely popular commodity. 



In a commercial coup that left many suspecting bribery or blackmail, House Hoskanner had been granted 
a monopoly on Duneworld operations. Ever since, Hoskanner crews had worked the hostile dunes, 
harvesting and selling spice at huge profits, from which the Grand Emperor took an extravagant 
percentage. Imperial penal planets provided an army of sandminers as veritable slave labor. 
At first the other noble families, preoccupied with court follies, didn't notice the preferential deal the 
Hoskanners received. Jesse was one of the few who had called attention to the imbalance, and finally, 
eyeing the wealth reaped by the wily Hoskanners, the other nobles agitated for a piece of the action. They 
shouted in the Imperial Assembly, issued charges, and finally appointed the no-nonsense Jesse Linkam as 
their spokesman to deliver a formal complaint. 
"The nobles didn't select me because of my abilities, Dor, but because they hold nostalgic memories of my 
foolish father and Hugo, my inept brother." He glared at the messagestat cylinder, sorely tempted to fling 
it off the balcony into the waters that churned far below. 
"Jesse, your father and brother may have been bad businessmen, but they did earn considerable goodwill 
with the other nobles." 
He frowned. "By playing games at the Renaissance court." 
"Take advantage of that, my love, and turn it to our own profit." 
"Little enough profit will come of this." 
After his older brother's pointless death in the bullring, Jesse had become the leader of House Linkam 
before his twentieth birthday. Soon afterward, his concubine discovered the muddled mess of Catalan's 
finances and industries. 
After meeting with the Nobles' Council, Jesse soon learned that few of the modern nobles, having 
inherited their holdings, were good leaders or competent businessmen. Once vastly wealthy and powerful, 
but 
now sliding into decadence, many families groaned inexorably toward bankruptcy, most without even 
realizing it. 
With extravagant festivals and poorly financed construction projects, Jesse's father and brother had 
brought House Linkam to the brink of ruin. But in recent years Dorothy's careful management and auster-
ity measures, along with his own rallying of the people to increase productivity, had begun to turn the tide. 
He gazed out into the rain-swept night, then sighed with resignation. "It always rains here. Our house is 
forever dank, no matter how many shields or heaters we install. This year the kelp harvest is down, and 
the fishermen have not caught enough for export." He paused. "Even so, this is my home and the home of 
my ancestors. I have no interest in other places, not even Duneworld." 
Dorothy eased closer and slipped an arm around Jesse's waist. "I wish you could take Barri along. Every 
noble son should see Renaissance at least once." 
"Not this time. Too dangerous." Jesse adored their eight-year-old boy, proud of the way Barri had matured 
under the careful tutelage of his mother as well as the old household doctor, Cullington Yueh. Barri was 
learning to be a good businessman and a good leader, too-traits that would serve him well in these days 
of fading Imperial grandeur. Everything Jesse did was for the future, for Barri and the advancement of 
House Linkam. Even his love for his concubine had to be second to that. 
"I'll make this trip, Dor," Jesse said, "but I don't have a good feeling about it." 
2 
Beware of compromises. They are more often weapons of attack than tools of peace. 
- GENERAL ESMAR TUEK, strategy concepts 
Ulla Bauers sat alone in the executive cabin of his diplomatic craft, thinking about the foolish nobleman 
he was transporting to Renaissance. Fishing! Jesse Linkam had been out on a boat performing the work of 
common laborers. What a complete waste of time. 
The quarters aboard Bauers's spacecraft were crowded and austere, but he understood the reason. For such 
a long journey between star systems, fuel costs placed strict limitations on discretionary mass. Meals were 
nothing more than tablets of concentrated melange, another sign of the widespread importance of 
Duneworld's product; after more than a week in transit, the passengers and crew would begin eating great 
quantities of real food upon reaching their destination. Bauers was perpetually hungry when he traveled 



through space, and it didn't put him in the best of moods. 
He heard his stomach growl. Taking another melange tablet, he savored the cinnamon flavor and felt the 
drug's soothing effects seep through him. 
Spice made a person feel better and increased the efficiency of human metabolism, streamlining the intake 
of energy from food. From a practical standpoint, this meant that the bulky supplies normally needed for 
long space voyages could be reduced to a case or two, permitting cargo holds to be used for other things. 
Bauers had heard a theory that melange might even increase the human life span, though with only a few 
years of recorded use, no long-term studies had yet proven the claim. 
While the diplomatic transport snipped shortcuts through the fabric of space, Counselor Bauers kept to his 
own cabin, making no attempt to socialize. Ironically, though he had great diplomatic skills, he didn't 
really much care for people. 
TWO LEVELS BELOW Bauers, Jesse sat in a passenger compartment with six hand-picked members of the 
Catalan home guard as his escort; he preferred spending time with his own men anyway. 
He had chosen his best fighters, including General Tuek. A slender man with olive skin, the old veteran 
had stooped shoulders and a manner that demonstrated loyalty while at the same time rebuffing intimacy. 
His thinning gray hair was receding over a leathery tanned scalp. The bright red stains around his lips 
signified his successful battle against sapho addiction, and he wore the marks like a badge of honor. 
The security chief had faithfully served both Jesse's father and brother, saving both of them from repeated 
assassination attempts, though not from their own recklessness. Sworn to serve any head of House Linkam 
without preference, in recent years Tuek had actually become Jesse's friend. In a rare unguarded moment, 
he'd once said that 
it was refreshing to see a man make important decisions based on substance rather than a whim or a roll of 
the dice. 
"We need to be ready for anything, Esmar," Jesse told him as they sat down to a game of strategy-stones 
in the cramped compartment. Meanwhile, the other five guardsmen blocked off the narrow corridor to 
practice rapier dueling and hand-to-hand combat, preparing to defend Nobleman Linkam against any 
attacks. 
"I lie awake at night thinking of things to be concerned about, My Lord," Tuek said, as he began to beat 
Jesse in the first game. "My greatest hope is that Valdemar Hoskanner will slip up so I can find an excuse 
to kill him while defending you. He needs to pay for the death of your father." 
"Valdemar won't slip up, Esmar. We weren't summoned to Renaissance by accident. You can bet your last 
credit that the Hoskanners have a clever plan in mind. I fear it's too subtle for us to see yet, far too subtle." 
FROM THROUGHOUT THE star-spanning Empire, wealth flowed to the planet Renaissance, enabling the 
Grand Emperor to stage any gaudy extravagance he could imagine. And many generations of rulers had 
imagined a great deal of extravagance. 
The Central Palace was a huge spherical construction inlaid with millions of crystalline panels. Armillary 
arcs curved along what would have been latitude and longitude lines on a celestial sphere, while lights 
spangled the outer wall, marking the astronomical locations of Emperor Inton Wuda's star systems. In the 
precise center of the sphere, the Emperor sat at the symbolic zero coordinate, thus presiding (figuratively) 
at the center of the Known Universe. 
As he went to meet the emperor, Jesse wore the formal cloak and pantaloons that Dorothy had selected 
from his rarely used wardrobe of courtly attire. His dark hair was oiled and perfumed with a cloyingly 
sweet scent that turned his stomach; lotions covered the calluses on his hands. 
General Tuek inspected the five Catalan Guards, then made a show of removing even their ceremonial 
weapons before they entered the Imperial presence. Only Tuek and Jesse knew that his men still carried 
hidden weapons: sharp strangling wires concealed as strands of hair, self-stiffening sleeves that could be 
turned into cutting edges. Without doubt, the Hoskanners had taken similar precautions; the question was 
whether Valdemar would be so bold as to provoke a bloody attack right here in the throne room. 
After a melodious fanfare, a bellowing crier announced the arrival of Nobleman Linkam, using the five 
primary languages of the Empire. Head high, Jesse marched toward the throne. 
Suspended in a curved chair atop a high monolith, Grand Emperor Wuda was a plump, bald man with 



gelatinous skin. Though he was relatively young, a hedonistic life had made him age badly, and his body 
had already sagged into a fleshy dumpling. Even so, he controlled more wealth and power than any other 
human in the Known Universe. 
Jesse stepped back as a second fanfare preceded the crier's multilingual introduction of Nobleman 
Hoskanner from Gediprime. Valdemar was strikingly tall, like a walking tree. He wore a black reflective-
weave suit that shimmered like oily shadows around his lanky frame. Dark hair combed back from a 
prominent widow's peak surmounted a thick and heavy brow, on which was tattooed the sinuous shape of 
a horned cobra, the symbol of House Hoskanner. Valdemar's nose jutted from his face, and the lantern jaw 
seemed designed for extra power when he wished to clamp his teeth together. Keeping his gaze focused 
on the foot of the Grand Emperor's throne, Valdemar delivered a perfect, formal bow. Never once did he 
glance at the Linkam party. 
Six Hoskanner bodyguards, the same number as Jesse was allowed, wore imposing studded uniforms. 
Their faces were blunt and blocky, almost subhuman, all of them also bearing the horned-cobra tattoo, but 
on their left cheeks. Tuek sneered at them, then turned back when the Grand Emperor summoned both 
noblemen. Dutifully, the pair marched along opposite paths toward the towering pedestal that held the 
high throne. 
"Nobleman Jesse Linkam, you have filed a complaint on behalf of the Nobles' Council regarding the 
Hoskanner monopoly on spice production. We normally ask aristocratic families to settle their disputes 
without Imperial intervention. You have more straightforward means at your disposal-personal combat 
between champions, mutual arbitration, even kanly. None of these is deemed satisfactory?" 
"No, Sire," both Jesse and Valdemar said in unison, as if they had choreographed their response. 
The Grand Emperor's fleshy face descended into a scowl. He turned toward Jesse, his tiny eyes set deep 
within pale folds of fat. "Nobleman Hoskanner has offered a compromise, and I suggest that you accept 
it." 
"I will entertain any proposal, so long as it is fair and just." Jesse glanced over at Valdemar, who avoided 
looking at him. 
"House Hoskanner has met our spice requirements for eighteen years," the Emperor said. "We see no 
reason to change this profitable enterprise simply because other families indulge in a fit of pique. We must 
be convinced that any change is to our advantage. 
"Nobleman Hoskanner is justifiably proud of his accomplishments. To prove a point, he is willing to 
surrender his monopoly on Dune-world for a period of two years. House Linkam-and Linkam alone- 
will assume control of spice harvesting. If, at the end of the probationary period, Linkam has produced 
more than Hoskanner did in the previous two-year period, we will award spice operations to his 
household, in perpetuity. You may then distribute contractual shares to the Nobles' Council as you deem 
fit." 
"A contest, Majesty?" 
The Grand Emperor did not like to be interrupted. "Nobleman Hoskanner has shown great generosity in 
making this offer, and he demonstrates an implicit confidence in his own abilities. If you can do 
better, then the monopoly is yours. Do you accept these terms as a reasonable resolution to your dispute?" 
Jesse saw from the barely contained smile lurking on Valdemar's face that this was exactly what his rival 
wanted, but he could see no way out. "Am I to be allowed access to the Hoskanner production figures so 
we can determine at what levels we must produce?" 
Hoskanner stepped forward. "Sire, my crews did not have a challenge or a target. We did our best and 
provided the required quota to the Imperial coffers. Providing Nobleman Linkam with an exact target 
would give him an unfair advantage." 
"Agreed," the Grand Emperor said with a darting glance toward Valdemar. Jesse was convinced they had 
arranged this beforehand. 
The Linkam patriarch did not give up easily, however. "But Hoskanner has had years to set up his 
infrastructure, train his crews, buy his equipment. My people would be starting from scratch. Before I go 
to Duneworld and begin the two years, I must be allowed an acceptable ramp-up time. Will House 
Hoskanner leave some of their specialized equipment for us to use?" 



Valdemar scowled coolly, and his response sounded rehearsed. "House Linkam will already have the 
advantage of our experience, the data from eighteen years of working the sands. Our sandminers had to 
learn by trial and error and endure many setbacks. My engineers designed the spice-harvesting equipment 
and techniques, and it didn't always work well. In many ways, my opponent is already starting out with a 
more favorable position than we Hoskanners ever had." When his brow furrowed, the horned-cobra tattoo 
looked as if it were coiling, ready to strike. 
With a bored gesture, Emperor Wuda said, "The disadvantages seem to balance the advantages." 
"Sire, we must have some equipment to begin with!" Jesse insisted, then smiled. "Otherwise the spice 
operations will cease entirely until we have everything in place. It could take months. I doubt the Empire 
would want that." He waited. 
"No, that would be unconscionable." The Grand Emperor sniffed. "Very well, House Hoskanner is hereby 
instructed to leave twelve spice harvesters and three carryalls on Duneworld. They will be considered a 
loan, to be repaid at the end of the challenge, regardless of the outcome." 
Valdemar's features grew stormy, but he said nothing. Jesse pressed his advantage. "And may I also 
request an Imperial edict that neither Nobleman Hoskanner nor anyone connected to him may interfere 
with my operations? After all, House Linkam did nothing to hinder his in the past eighteen years." 
The Grand Emperor's impatience bordered on outright annoyance. "We will not be drawn into the 
minutiae of your petty dispute, nor will we mediate a squabble that has already taken too much of our 
precious time. Additional rules and restrictions would only complicate the matter. At the conclusion of 
two years, House Linkam will compare its tally to that of House Hoskanner. As your sovereign, I must 
remain neutral, so long as the flow of spice is uninterrupted." 
Jesse knew he would do no better. He bowed formally. "I accept the challenge, Sire." No rules. 
The Grand Emperor folded his hands across his swollen belly and smiled. Jesse thought he could hear the 
steely jaws of a trap clamping shut around him. 
3 
I have always considered the descriptive powers of poetry and song to be invincible. But how can one begin to capture the essence of Duneworld 
in mere words? A man must journey there and experience it for himself. 
- GURNEY HALLECK, 
jongleur of House Linkam 
As an advance guard for the new Linkam operations, Esmar Tuek  and a hundred Catalan men arrived on 
Duneworld. 
The Hoskanners had packed up in a flurry and departed like tenants evicted in the night. They took most 
of their expensive spice-harvesting machinery and transport ships, leaving behind only twelve units, as 
ordered: but they were the most broken-down, poorly maintained equipment. 
Esmar Tuek shook his head at the bad news. The Emperor had sent word that his concession was 
generous, so he must have set aside his own substantial stockpile of spice, more than enough to tide him 
over while leaving House Linkam to struggle against formidable odds to get their operations up and 
running. More than likely, the Hoskanners had 
bribed the Emperor with some of their own melange hoard, to influence his decision. 
While a few ambitious independent sandminers continued spice-harvesting operations in the interim, 
Tuek's men set up a base of operations in the main city. Carthage was perched in a forbidding tangle of 
crags that rose high from the gulf of open sand, offering shelter from furious storms and other threats. 
Tuek would have preferred a more organized layout, but the rugged terrain allowed no discernible grid for 
constructing buildings, roads, and landing zones. Structures had to be erected in any open and level spot, 
no matter how small. 
Most of the hired workers were forced to remain, unable to afford the exorbitant passage offworld. 
Support staff, cooks, water merchants, repairmen, sellers of sundries and desert garb remained in 
Carthage, ostensibly eking out a minimal living. Tuek suspected that many of them might be saboteurs, 
intentionally left behind to work against House Linkam. 
The old veteran's first order of business was to secure a chief of spice operations, someone with 
experience as a sandminer but with no love for the Hoskanners. He wanted to choose a man well down in 
the ranks, believing that anyone high in the former hierarchy might feel loyalty to the previous masters, 



whereas a miner suddenly jumped in rank and responsibility-not to mention pay-would be inclined to 
offer his full allegiance to House Linkam. 
Tuek and the Linkam family jongleur, Gurney Halleck, met with each of the men who applied for the job, 
as well as others who had learned not to call attention to themselves under the Hoskanners. A redheaded 
boulder of a man, Gurney had a sharp eye and a deadly blade, though his jovial demeanor kept his 
enemies continually off guard. 
After interviewing more than forty candidates, Tuek decided on an ambitious spice-crew manager named 
William English. Even after the Hoskanners departed, English had taken charge of three spice crews and 
arranged for them to keep harvesting melange-and acquiring 
bonuses-during the change of government. In his favor, the manager came from a noble bloodline, his 
grandfather having been a Linkam ally before an economic downturn ruined House English. The left side 
of the man's face was rough and waxy, as if scoured by an industrial polisher. English had been caught out 
in a furious sandstorm, unable to find adequate shelter in the rocks. Most of his exposed left cheek had 
been worn away. The medical facilities in Carthage had been sufficient to save his life, but not to make 
him handsome again. He had no love for the Hoskanners. 
Tuek was more interested in the unusual chevron tattoo over the potential foreman's right eyebrow, 
however. "What is that symbol? I've seen them in Carthage, often among the seasoned sandminers." 
"Something to do with the Zensunni prison religion?" Gurney offered. "Were you brought here as a 
convict laborer?" 
English's expression shifted into one of pride as he tapped the tattoo. "Most of us came here as prisoners, 
but this mark signifies that I am a freedman. I was convicted of a crime and sentenced to twenty years of 
hard labor in the penal caves on Eridanus V. Then the Grand Emperor and the Hoskanners offered 
amnesty to any prisoner who worked on Duneworld for a time equivalent to twenty-five percent of the 
original sentence. I had to work only five years of my original twenty." 
Gurney grunted. "The Hoskanners needed a lot of manpower for their spice operations." Always eager to 
find new stories and material for the songs he loved to write, he asked, "What was your crime? Something 
to do with the unfortunate fall of your House?" 
English's mood darkened. "My sentence has been commuted, the records expunged. Therefore, I 
committed no crime." He smiled wryly. "Isn't every person guilty of something anyway?" 
Ever conscious of security, Esmar Tuek did not like the fact that most of his sandminers were convicts. 
How trustworthy could they be? However, he also knew that many of the best military fighters with whom 
he had served were those with shady pasts or guilty consciences. 
In a conciliatory tone, he asked, "How long do you have left on Duneworld? I don't want a spice foreman 
who'll leave us in a few months' time." 
"As I said, I am now a freedman. I have been here twelve years, seven past the end of my sentence." 
Gurney exclaimed, "Then why haven't you left, man? I can't imagine anyone staying in this wretched 
place by choice." 
"It is not by choice. When our time is finished, we are not allowed to leave unless we pay our own passage 
offplanet. Few except the most crafty and devious are able to acquire that kind of money. Thus, even 
freedmen stay here and work as virtual slaves. I've been saving for years and have only half of the credits I 
need." He grimaced. "Regrettably, I didn't notice the odious clause when I signed the contract." 
"Sounds like a neat little scam," Tuek said. 
English shrugged. "Scam or not, I wouldn't have survived the penal caves on Eridanus V, with the 
dripping acid and the tunnel collapses that maim and kill so many. And even if I did finish my sentence 
there, I would still have been a convicted felon when I emerged." He tapped the mark above his brow 
again. "Here, I am forever a freedman, not a criminal." 
Suitably impressed, Tuek decided to give the man a chance, while keeping him under close scrutiny. "Mr. 
English, would you pilot an ornijet and take us on an inspection flight?" 
"Nothing easier, General. I'll check the locations of the crews that went out today. Only a few of them 
could get their equipment going." 
THE THREE MEN left the black mountain battlements and flew over the endless plains of buttery dunes. 



Gurney stared at the wasteland through the ornijet's tinted window. "'A desolation and a wilderness, a land 
wherein no man dwelleth, neither any son of man passth thereby,'" the jongleur offered from his vast 
repertoire of pertinent 
quotes. He turned back to look at the blocky structures of Carthage nestled among the dark rocks. "As 
Isaiah said long ago on another world, 'He built towers in the desert.'" 
Tuek peered disapprovingly at the dirty city the Hoskanners had built. "I wouldn't exactly call them 
towers." 
As English guided the ornijet deeper into the desert, he opened the wings to full extension. They flapped 
slowly as the craft rattled and bounced in air turbulence. He wrestled with the controls. "Hold on, 
gentlemen. Could get worse, could get better." 
"Ah, now that's covering your options!" Gurney said with a chuckle. 
"Storm coming?" Tuek asked. 
"Just thermals. Nothing to worry about." English touched the roughened, waxy skin on the left side of his 
face. "I can sense bad weather. My knowledge of Duneworld's storms is unfortunately intimate." 
After he had stabilized the ornijet, English glanced at the old veteran. "I told you about my tattoo, General 
Tuek. Would you return the favor and explain those red stains on your lips? I have never seen anything 
like them." 
Tuek touched the bright cranberry smears that forever marked his mouth. "I was once addicted to the 
sapho drug. It makes you euphoric, makes you lose your edge .. . and it ruins your life." 
"Sapho makes those stains?" 
"Sapho juice is colorless. These red stains mark that I have taken the cure-and survived." 
"It was a true addiction?" English looked uncomfortable. "And you have beaten it?" 
"Any addiction can be overcome if a person has strong enough will." At his sides, Tuek unconsciously 
clenched and unclenched his hands. He remembered the nightmarish agony, the days of longing for death. 
He was a veteran of many battles, but breaking his dependence on the drug had been one of his most 
difficult victories ever. 
Once they had reached the appropriate area, English guided the ornijet toward a column of dust and sand 
that looked like exhaust from a chimney. "Spice operations." 
"I can't wait to see the equipment they left for us," Tuek said, his tone sour. "Twelve harvesters and three 
carryalls to deliver them to the spice sands?" 
"The numbers are right, but the machines are in lousy condition." 
The old warrior scowled. "The Emperor insisted that the Hoskanners leave them for us, but I assume they 
will not be sufficient for us to exceed the previous production." 
"We'll fall far short." 
"Ho, that's a cheery thought," Gurney said. " 'He who looks to the Lord with optimism secures the prize, 
while the pessimist also secures what he envisions: defeat.'" 
The spice foreman shook his head. "It's not pessimism; it's the reality of mathematics, and this hellhole. 
Unless we find a way to dramatically increase spice production with the equipment we have, House 
Linkam won't stand a chance. In two years, the Hoskanners will return in force-and I'll be put to death." 
English looked strangely at his two passengers. "Nobleman Hoskanner does not look kindly on a man 
whose loyalties can be bought." 
"Sweet affection!" It was Tuek's favorite saying. "Then why did you agree to the position, man?" 
"Because you offered me an increase in pay. If I starve myself and earn maximum bonuses, there's a slim 
chance I can afford to buy passage off Duneworld before the Hoskanners return." 
English tapped a control, and long, telescoping whiskers extended from the nose of the ornijet to pick up 
sensor readings from the surface below. "Where there's one vein of spice, there are likely to be others. 
These probes take readings to help us determine a good place to come back another time." 
"What about all those little ships?" Gurney asked. 
"Scouts spot good sand by surface markers, dune irregularities, and indications of worm activity." 
"Worm activity?" Tuek asked. 
Airborne lifters swooped down to the flurry of activity while smaller ships flew nearby in wide arcs. 



English gazed down at the operations. "Ah, looks like we're wrapping up for today. The crews can only hit 
each vein for an hour or so before we have to evacuate. See, that spice harvester is ready to be hauled to 
safety." 
Below, while men sprinted to their main vehicles, a heavy carryall linked to a boxy hulk of machinery in a 
valley of dunes, then heaved it into the air. 
"Hauled to safety? From what?" Tuek asked. 
"Didn't the Hoskanners tell you anything about spice operations?" 
"Nothing." 
Below, only moments after the carryall lifted the spice harvester from the sand, an enormous writhing 
shape bucked through the dunes. A serpentine beast with a cavernous mouth launched itself toward the 
rising spice harvester, but the straining carryall climbed higher and higher, out of reach. With a crash of 
sand, the great worm thundered back to the dunes and thrashed around. 
"Gods, what a monster!" Gurney said. "'And I saw the beast rise from the sea, with ten horns and seven 
heads.'" 
"Harvesting vibrations summon a sandworm to defend its treasure- just like a mythical dragon," English 
explained. "Under the Hoskanners, I crewed on seven spice harvesters that were lost." 
"Did everyone get away down there?" Tuek peered through the ornijet's window, searching the ransacked 
dunes for casualties. 
English listened to the staccato reports. "Everyone checked in except for one scout flyer caught in a 
downdraft in the wake of a sand geyser." 
"Sand geysers? Giant worms?" Gurney cried. "Does Duneworld breed strangeness?" 
"In a dozen years, even I have yet to see all of its mysteries." 
BEFORE RETURNING TO the mountains around Carthage, English landed at a small encampment where 
twenty workers in sealed bodysuits spread out, planting long flexible poles in the soft sand. The line of 
poles stuck out like quills from the back of a spiny beast. . 
The three men climbed out of the ornijet, breathing hot air through face filters. Around them on high 
dunes, Tuek saw a whirl of wind devils. Even active crews were spread across the sheltered valley, a great 
emptiness that was like a hungry mouth gulping every sound. Standing in the immense silence, he thought 
he could almost hear the desert breathing. 
Gurney plodded through the soft sands to reach one of the flexible poles the crew had recently planted. He 
wobbled it like an antenna. "And what's this?" 
"They are poling the sand to help determine the weather." 
"Don't we have satellites in orbit? I was sure the Hoskanners left them." 
"Those provide only a large-scale picture, and the terrain is a mosaic of microclimates. With fluctuating 
temperatures and tides of sand, the local weather is dangerously unpredictable. Each of these poles has a 
signal beeper. As they bend and twist in the wind, the transmissions help us chart storms. Blowing grains 
etch lines into the waxy surfaces of the poles. Some natives claim they can read the patterns." He 
shrugged. "I've never been able to see it myself, but their reports are as accurate as anything else we 
have." 
One of the questing men on the far side of the basin plunged his pole into the sand and suddenly let out a 
loud yelp. He threw up his arms, wailing; his feet went out from under him as if a great mouth was trying 
to suck him down. 
The alarmed spice foreman stood where he was, feet planted safely on the more stable dune, but Tuek and 
Gurney sprinted toward the man. By the time they neared the spot, the hapless worker had already 
vanished beneath the powdery surface. Not even his fingers or a stirring of movement showed where he 
had been. 
Gurney grabbed Tuek's shoulder and pulled him back. "Best stay far away, General! Maybe it's another 
worm." 
Tuek whirled to face William English, who walked grimly up to them, picking his footsteps carefully. 
"Sweet affection! Couldn't you do anything to help him?" 
The desert man shook his head. "He was lost the moment he stepped on the wrong spot. Sand whirlpools 



appear in unpredictable places, sinkholes that spiral downward." 
Hesitant to move, Tuek remained where he was for a minute, his jaw muscles working like a tiny imitation 
of a worm. "Gods! What kind of demon world is this?" 
4 
Even in the most barren wasteland, a flower always grows. Recognize this, and learn to adapt to your surroundings.  
- DR. BRYCE HAYNES, planetary ecologist assigned to study Duneworld 
With her family balanced on the cusp of survival, Dorothy Mapes 
vowed that every moment on Duneworld and every action 
would count. "This is a serious planet that demands undivided attention," 
she observed, gazing out the oval porthole as the Linkam transport ship 
cruised over the sea of dunes toward a line of stark, black mountains. 
Seated with Jesse on the starboard side of the transport, she saw his attention focused on a looming dust 
cloud that approached like an inexorable Catalan tide. Moments ago, he had said he was having second 
thoughts about this side excursion he had ordered the pilot to take after the cross-space journey, flying 
over the desert for a hundred kilometers instead of landing directly at Carthage. But he had wanted to see 
what the planet was like, showing his concubine and son where they were going to live for at least two 
years. 
Now she hoped it wasn't a dangerous mistake. 
"I think we can beat that storm," the pilot said. "I sure hope so, because we don't have enough fuel to go 
back into orbit." 
Jesse did not say anything, and neither did Dorothy. He squeezed her hand in a private way that imparted 
reassurance, telling her that he wouldn't let anything happen to her, or to young Barri, who sat at another 
window, transfixed by the alien vistas outside. After more than a decade together, the nobleman and his 
concubine had ways of communicating through only a look or a touch. He ran a fingertip across her 
diagem promise ring. 
Though Jesse was the patriarch of the Noble House, Dorothy Mapes took care of important business 
details and family matters. She had once compared herself to the wife of an Old Earth samurai, with her 
access to and control over a great deal. She understood full well that the spousal analogy was only her 
wishful thinking. Because of the Empire's strict and convoluted society, Jesse could never marry a com-
moner, no matter how deeply he cared for her and how essential she was to him. 
Dorothy was the mother of his son, the male heir to House Linkam. Although she taught the boy important 
skills, she also pampered him-too much, according to Jesse. The nobleman wanted Barri to face enough 
adversity to make him strong. Under pressure, Dorothy would yield to Jesse's commands in this regard, or 
appear to do so; then, invariably, she would return to indulging the boy. 
"Oh, I hope we get there soon." From across the aisle the kindly old family doctor fidgeted in his seat, 
while staring straight ahead and refusing to look out the window at the dizzying landscape sweeping past. 
Cullington Yueh had bristly gray hair and a salt-and-pepper mustache. "Oh, these bumps and vibrations 
are making me nauseated." 
"Carthage dead ahead." The pilot's small voice squeaked over the speaker from the bridge. "Prepare for 
more turbulence as we approach the mountains." 
"Wonderful." Yueh turned even paler. 
Through the oval viewing window, Dorothy watched the city come into view, buildings and cleared areas 
interspersed among the dark crags. Such an ominous-looking place, expanded and fortified by the 
Hoskanners during their eighteen-year tenure. Narrow roads ran through gorges and valleys; blocky ledges 
held dwelling complexes and smaller habitation domes connected by paths and steep steps. Many of the 
largest buildings were linked by trams and tunnels to the rest of the fortress city. Though Carthage had no 
major spaceport, several airfields had been blasted into the rocks and then armorpaved, resulting in two 
main landing zones on opposite sides of the city-one larger than the other. 
The pilot circled a flat area near the headquarters mansion. The russet-and-black structures of Carthage 
peeked around bulwarks of rock. Winds began to buffet the craft in advance of the storm, like a squadron 
sent in to soften up the enemy before a larger onslaught. The craft lurched and swayed, eliciting another 



round of miserable groans from Dr. Yueh. 
With a resounding, rocking thump, the craft set down in a level region sealed by armorpave, surrounded 
by sharp cliffs. All around them, local ships and shuttles landed swiftly, eager to outrun the storm . . . they 
were like desert hawks rushing back to their nests in the high rocks. Particles of sand pelted the windows. 
"We're home," Jesse said. "Duneworld looks like a nice, friendly place." 
DOROTHY HARDLY RECOGNIZED the two men who came forward as she and her party entered the central 
lobby of the receiving building. Dust swirled around their boots, bodysuits, and desert cloaks as they 
marched across the floor. But her sharp eyes identified the pair from the way they walked and interacted. 
Dorothy had learned the art 
of observing small details about people and reading their body languages: It was the only way to achieve 
success in a society that valued noble blood more than intelligence and wit. 
With a flourish, Gurney Halleck swung open his cape, spraying the air with loose dirt. The jongleur's 
coarse face beamed impishly as soon as he saw Jesse. "About time you got here, laddie!" Beneath matted 
pale red hair, his forehead and stubby nose were grimy, but a patch around his mouth remained completely 
clean, where it had been protected by the mask. 
Esmar Tuek kept his own cape closed, and his dark eyes peered over the top edge of the facial seal. "Sorry 
we didn't have time to clean up for you, My Lord, but we've been out in the desert. Those Hoskanner 
bastards left us with nothing but junk for spice-harvesting equipment! We need to get some decent 
machinery in here quickly. At a pretty price, I'm afraid. The Hoskanners have probably rigged the 
market." 
"Our finances are stretched to the limit," Dorothy warned. "Anticipating problems, we've already ordered 
more equipment, what little we can afford." 
"Looks like we need to order even more," Jesse said. "No matter how deep we have to dig into our coffers, 
we need the right tools for the job, or we can't do it at all." He smiled at her. "You'll find a way." 
"Somehow, I always do." Countless times, Dorothy had set priorities for House Linkam, tightened the 
budget, even uncovered new sources of income. Now her mind spun as she considered the enormity of the 
problem. 
Attendants surged forward to assist with unloading their luggage and belongings. Dr. Yueh, still wobbly, 
finally emerged. He took deep breaths of the dry air and made a face, as if smelling something unpleasant 
all around him. 
The two dusty escorts led the newcomers toward the nearby mansion, along a steep path. Wind from the 
rising storm found its way through the sheltering crags and tugged at their hair and clothes. Jesse 
and Dorothy both ducked against the stinging breeze. Their son had run ahead, but she called him back. 
Reluctantly, the brown-haired boy waited for them to catch up. 
"It's probably best for you to get a face full of grime the first day," Gurney said. "That's the way it is here 
on Duneworld, and we haven't figured out a way to clean the place up yet. The accursed sand and dust 
gets into everything. I've got the worst rash on my-" Glancing at Dorothy, he left his sentence 
uncompleted. 
She took Barri by the hand as they continued walking. At a disapproving glance from Jesse, she released 
the boy to walk on his own, a few steps ahead. 
"The main spice fields are fifteen hundred klicks from here," Tuek quickly filled the silence, "but 
Carthage is the nearest stable and defensible site for a large city and landing zones." 
Gurney nudged Jesse and pointed ahead. "Feast your eyes on your new home, laddie." 
Through a haze of blowing sand, Dorothy barely made out the old headquarters mansion in front of them, 
a rock-walled fortress that reflected the brutish architectural tastes of the Hoskanners. She thought again 
of their former home on the Catalan shores, the rustic yet welcoming wood furnishings, the rugs and 
fireplaces, the cheerful lights. In contrast, this place offered all the creature comforts of great hunks of 
stone and fused alloy beams. 
What have we gotten into? 
Immense statues of old Hoskanner family patriarchs lined the entry walk. "Those will have to come 
down," she said immediately. 



"Old Valdemar won't like that at all if he comes back here," Gurney said, grinning more than scowling. 
Jesse paused for a long time before he said, "If Valdemar comes back in two years, I will be beyond 
caring." 
DOROTHY WOKE EARLY the next morning after a night of fitful sleep in a flinty-smelling 
bedchamber. Sitting up in bed to look at the harsh yellow sunlight bleeding through the shielded window, 
she noticed that Jesse was no longer beside her, though the sheets on his side of the bed were rumpled. 
Detecting that she was awake, a tiny device like a fat bee buzzed in front of her face, and she blew a 
breath to activate the messager. Jesse's compressed voice said, "I'm on an inspection tour with Esmar and 
Gurney. You took so long to get to sleep, Dor, I didn't want to wake you." 
She smiled at his consideration, but could not allow herself to rest, not on their first full day on 
Duneworld. Thousands of details demanded her attention for the household to run smoothly. 
Barri was already up and bursting with energy. He had dark brown hair that remained unruly despite 
Dorothy's efforts to tame it. His nose was round and covered with a thin scatter of freckles easily disguised 
by the ever-present dust on Duneworld. His bright laughter came easily, especially when he amused 
himself by discovering interesting facets to even ordinary things. 
The smart eight-year-old followed her throughout the morning, asking constant questions, poking into 
unlabeled boxes, exploring hallways and closed rooms. Dorothy issued instructions to the domestic staff 
she had brought from Catalan, as well as a handful of Hoskanner holdovers that General Tuek had 
screened with his usual care. Jesse might trust the old veteran's precautions, but Dorothy had quietly 
decided to make her own judgments about the staff. The consequences of an error in this regard were too 
high, the stakes too enormous. 
She took a stone stairway down to the main kitchen. When she entered, the chef was discussing that 
evening's meal with two staff members. Piero Zonn had operated a gourmet restaurant on Catalan prior to 
joining the Linkam entourage; Jesse had brought him along to serve meals in the headquarters mansion, 
but the small, energetic man 
seemed at a loss as to how he would do his job properly. Dorothy wanted to reassure him, but she didn't 
know herself how many things they would have to sacrifice here. 
The chef and his assistants fell silent when they saw her; she was a commoner like them, but they lived in 
different circles. Nearby, a Carthage native maid paused while wiping dust from a decorative stone alcove, 
then resumed her work with renewed vigor. Dorothy felt very much out of place. 
Later, as the two of them walked alone through a hall to the upper levels, Barri tugged at his mother's cool 
blouse. "What does Odokis mean?" 
"Odokis?" 
"The star we saw when we came into the system." 
"That's Arrakis, dear. In ancient astronomy it meant 'the dancer' or 'the trotting camel.' It's the sun up in 
our sky now, on this planet." 
"I'd rather be back on Catalan. I miss my friends." 
"You'll make new friends here." In truth, though, Dorothy had noticed few children in Carthage, and the 
ones she had seen appeared to be street urchins. With a population of convict laborers and freedmen who 
could not afford passage home, Duneworld was not much of a place to raise a family. 
With Jesse already throwing himself into the spice business, Dorothy spent the morning unpacking while 
Barri continued to explore. An exceedingly curious young man, he invariably pestered his mother when 
she was busiest or most agitated. But she found reservoirs of patience within herself, knowing that his 
curiosity was a sign of intelligence. 
In the large master suite, she organized a few Linkam mementos, the bare minimum Jesse had permitted 
her to bring along, due to the weight restrictions on space cargo. The rest of their possessions had been left 
behind on Catalan. So much of her life remained back there, and not just things. Barri looked forlorn each 
time he realized that some toy or keepsake was far away, and possibly lost forever. 
"It's good to start anew," she said aloud with a brave smile. While she studied inventory lists, the boy 
occupied himself by playing with something he had found on the floor in a corner of the large suite. 
One of the articles she unpacked was a holophoto of Jesse's father. Placing it on the mantle of the bedroom 



fireplace, she activated it to show the heavyset Jabo Linkam in his gaudy faux-military uniform, the attire 
he had preferred to wear, though he had never served in any army. A sycophant at the Imperial court, the 
old fool had loved to dress in fancy costumes and throw extravagant balls that he could not afford. In the 
process, he'd nearly bankrupted House Linkam. 
During one such banquet, a crazed chef had attempted to assassinate the father of Valdemar Hoskanner by 
slipping a powerful toxin into his dessert, a famous Catalanian layer cake. But the delicacy had been one 
of Jabo's favorite treats, and he had devoured the dish, not knowing it was poisoned, and it quickly killed 
him. Only a year later, emboldened by the death of his enemy, sure that House Linkam had been behind 
the poisoning attempt, young Valdemar had publicly challenged Jesse's brother, Hugo, to fight in a 
Hoskanner-sponsored bullfight. Hugo let himself be shamed into participating. . . and the bull killed him. 
Sheer stupidity. Thus the youngest Linkam had been left in charge of the Noble House. 
As Dorothy studied Jabo's holophoto, she hoped her beloved Jesse never fell victim to the prideful ways of 
his star-crossed family. 
Dr. Yueh stepped through the open doorway. "Oh, I'm feeling much better today, now that I've done some 
unpacking and started to get organized." He held up a long, wickedly sharp ceremonial knife in the form 
of a gilded and gem-encrusted scalpel. "I even found this old thing, from when I received my first medical 
credentials." He flashed a self-deprecating smile. "It probably wasn't worth the cost of shipping, even to 
this vain old man." 
"I think we can indulge you in this instance, Cullington." 
The old doctor rubbed his hands together briskly. "I'm about to have 
a late lunch. Care to join me? The nobleman hasn't returned yet, but I thought you might enjoy a break." 
"Yes, of course. Barri, come with us to the dining hall." She was surprised at how quiet he had become 
while sitting cross-legged by a sealed window with his back to her. "What are you doing there?" 
Still playing, he looked over his shoulder with a cherubic grin. His blue-green eyes sparkled with 
fascination. "I have a new friend after all, Mother. Look; it's like one of the tide pool crabs at home." He 
held up his hand to show a jagged-legged creature on his palm. The jet-black arachnid crawled up his bare 
arm, prowling. He giggled. "That tickles!" 
Dr. Yueh's jaw dropped. "Oh, don't make any sudden moves!" The old doctor pushed Dorothy back and 
moved toward the boy. "It's an indigenous sand scorpion. The sting is deadly!" 
With every muscle in her body, Dorothy wanted to leap to her son's aid, but didn't dare startle the creature. 
Making a sudden move, Yueh slapped the scorpion from Barri's arm. The creature struck a settee near 
Dorothy, fell to the floor, and rolled into a black, defensive ball. She stepped on it hard, grinding with her 
heel. Though it was smashed and dead, she stomped on the sand scorpion again and again. 
"That's all right," Yueh said soothingly as he pulled the boy away, but Barri struggled to get free, his eyes 
full of tears. 
Drawing her son to her bosom, Dorothy said, "This is a dangerous place. You must not play with the 
creatures you find here. Even Dr. Yueh could not have saved you from a scorpion sting." 
Barri glared at her for killing his new pet. "Cullington could have figured out an ant'dote." 
The old doctor patted the boy on the head. "Let's not test my abilities, all right?" 
5 
The living always stand on the shoulders of the dead. It is the nature of human advancement. 
- A SAYING OF OLD EARTH 
Jesse called a staff meeting on the top floor of the headquarters  mansion. The plaz-windowed conference 
chamber was insulated against Duneworld's unrelenting sun. Through the plaz, he had a view in all 
directions: the desert, the crags, the spaceport landing zones, and the scattered buildings of Carthage. 
Although the alloy-paneled room had been swept clean and scrubbed that day by household staff, a layer 
of gritty dust already covered the furniture and floor. Jesse smeared a finger across the table surface, 
looked at the mark. Such conditions would be his constant companion for some time. 
Esmar Tuek and Gurney Halleck entered the room with the new spice foreman, William English. A 
houseman in a short brown cloak 
brought a steaming pot of spice coffee with four cups and then departed, closing the door behind him. 



Before beginning, Jesse moved around the table and poured the rich, aromatic coffee for his companions, 
demonstrating that he was different from other noblemen. "I was greatly disturbed by what I saw during 
yesterday's inspection tour. The Hoskanners have prepared a nasty trap for us here." 
"You've got that right, laddie," Gurney grumbled. "This might as well be a prison planet for House 
Linkam: We can't leave until we complete our sentence." 
"Even then, going home doesn't seem to be an option," English said, his tone as bitter as spice-coffee 
dregs. "Not for most of us." 
Jesse studied the scarred crew manager, whom Tuek had approved. In the days when House Linkam had 
fared better, English's grandfather had been on close terms with Jesse's. English seemed competent and 
dependable enough, but Jesse knew there were no certainties in life. Risks had to be taken. He had to rely 
on people. 
But people are prone to fallibility, he thought, and betrayal. They change with every breath they take. 
Nevertheless, he made up his mind. He looked around the table. "Even though most of the sandminers 
here are-or were-convict laborers, I do not consider them slaves. I've worked with the people on 
Catalan, watched them take pride in the most menial tasks if they had some reason to do so. I intend to 
give the people on Duneworld a reason to work hard. Our only chance of winning this challenge is if the 
populace is on our side. We can't do it without them." 
"Very few workers are on Duneworld by choice, My Lord," English said. "The Hoskanners ground them 
under their heel, worked them to death, stole their hope as soon as they transferred here from prison 
planets." 
"Then I will give them hope. For their benefit and for ours, I will show them that I am different from 
Valdemar Hoskanner." Jesse flashed a hard smile. "General Tuek, Mr. English, I want you to put out the 
word. Inform the sandminer crews that if House Linkam wins this challenge, I give my oath as a 
nobleman that every freedman shall have his passage offplanet. I'll pay for it myself if I have to." 
"My Lord!" Tuek said. "House Linkam doesn't have the finances for that, nor can we afford to lose all of 
our most experienced crewmen!" 
"Esmar, if we win the challenge, then we will have sufficient spice income to pay for it. We can begin 
training the senior convict laborers to take over for the freedmen, and perhaps we can entice some of the 
freedmen to stay." 
English's eyes sparkled. "My comrades will be extremely glad to hear this news, My Lord." 
Jesse drew a deep breath, knowing he had stepped off a precipice, and he only hoped he could survive the 
landing. Though Linkam family finances had improved under his stewardship, his family's credit standing 
remained low, thanks to the damages his father and brother had done. To fund this bold and risky venture, 
he had borrowed large sums from the Imperial bank and reluctantly accepted aid from a few politically 
allied Houses. 
In scrambling for money, Jesse had been chagrined to discover that many of the noble families who had 
prodded him into contesting the Hoskanner monopoly now refused to support him when it counted most. 
He'd felt like an unprepared victim thrown into an arena while others cheered or jeered from the safety of 
their seats, casting wagers as to his fate. Jesse should have expected little else from most of them. 
Despite all obstacles, though, he was determined to win the spice challenge. He had to get the workers on 
his side. Once he broke the Hoskanner monopoly, he would share the profits as he saw fit, rewarding his 
few supporters lavishly and leaving others in the financial deep freeze. 
This planet is a treasure chest,  he thought, and I must find the key to open it. 
"I chose the course of dignity and honor, though it may have been a 
foolish one." Jesse slumped into his high-backed chair. "If only I knew more about how much the 
Hoskanners were producing here." 
Tuek brought out a document, slapped it on the table, and slid it over to Jesse. "I do have a little something 
for you, My Lord." 
Jesse recognized columns of spice-production figures. "Hoskanner numbers for the past two years? Where 
did you get this?" 
"From an impeccable source." The old veteran looked at English. 



The new spice foreman said, "I wasn't that significant when the Hoskanners were here, but documents did 
get passed around, to compare month-by-month results and motivate the spice foremen into competing 
with one another. They made copies for internal purposes and . . . lost track of some of them." 
Tuek added, "William had to call in a lot of favors for this information, but it makes for interesting 
reading." 
"Excellent," Jesse said. "Now we'll know where we stand." 
"Or how far behind we are," Gurney suggested, with a smirk. "Look at the numbers, laddie." 
Jesse whistled. "If these figures are right, the Hoskanners produced an incredible amount of melange! Has 
this much spice been distributed throughout the Empire? I had no idea its use was so widespread." 
Tuek cautioned, "Could be a trick. Inflated amounts." 
But Jesse shook his head. "If this was a trick, Valdemar would have under-reported to escape Imperial 
tariffs and lull us into a false sense of security." 
Studying the document, Gurney said, "Sorry to state the obvious, laddie, but the Hoskanners had a whole 
fleet of spice-processing machinery. The twelve decrepit spice harvesters and three old carryalls they left 
us are not nearly adequate." 
"The equipment spends more time in repair shops than in service," English said. "The Hoskanner scum 
took the most qualified crews with them, too, paid them a bonus for not helping us, including passage off-
world." Though the scarred spice foreman glowered at the injustice, 
Jesse suspected that English himself would have taken the offer, had the Hoskanners made it to him. 
"Only eighty-one experienced freedmen stayed behind," Tuek said. "And our workers from Catalan need a 
lot of training. We've got a long way to go." 
Jesse stood and began pacing. "I expected some of this. Immediately after accepting the challenge, I had 
Dorothy order six new spice harvesters and two more carryalls from the Ixian machine works, even paid 
for rush delivery." Jesse grimaced. "Last night, after the inspection tour, I sent for six more spice 
harvesters and another carryall." 
"Can you afford it, My Lord?" Tuek asked. 
"More than I can afford not to." 
"That's twelve new harvesters and twelve old ones," Gurney said. "Still less equipment than the 
Hoskanners had." 
"Then we'll just have to work harder and smarter than they did," Jesse said. "According to Dorothy, we've 
sold most of our valuable family heirlooms and mortgaged everything else. She says we're not stretching 
the budget-we're breaking it." He sighed. "But what choice do we have if we want to win? For the 
survival of House Linkam, we must win!" 
English self-consciously rubbed the waxy scar tissue on his cheek. "The Hoskanners had a lot of trouble 
with the weather. Sand ate into the biggest spice harvesters and damaged the factory modules. The dust 
here is more corrosive and statically charged than anyone expected. Even with thirty harvesters, at least a 
quarter of them were down for repairs at any one time." He paused. "But there is a way to improve on that. 
I think." The room fell silent. Looking at Jesse, the spice foreman cleared his throat. "The Grand Emperor 
said this game has no rules, right?" 
Jesse nodded. "It'd be nice to have that work to our advantage for a change." 
"The Emperor's first inspection crews set up advance bases out in the 
desert, sealed structures that have been sitting there for years, filled with machinery and supplies. Some of 
my freedmen know where they are. Everything's in perfect working order, because they used live-rubber 
shielding over the structures." 
"Never heard of it," Tuek said. 
"A very expensive material. It's incredibly malleable, and could be fitted over the engine housings and 
other sensitive areas to keep sand out of the harvesters. There might not be enough live-rubber shielding 
for all the machines, but it'll definitely help. I've thought about it for years, but never got around to 
suggesting it to the Hoskanners. I was nobody to them, and they probably wouldn't have listened anyway." 
He smiled. "Besides, I rather enjoyed watching them struggle." 
"Doesn't that property belong to the Emperor?" Tuek pointed out. "Technically?" 



"No rules-the Emperor said it himself." Gurney was grinning.   "Duneworld has a way of making its own 
rules," English said. 
Jesse made up his mind. "We raid the advance bases." 
Deep in thought, he took a sip of spice coffee. As he gazed through the plaz toward the sands, he could 
feel the soothing effects of melange. "Collect all the data compiled by advance survey teams and as much 
intelligence as you can find about the spice operations of the Hoskanners. We'll need access to that 
information before we can rise above their mistakes and reach another level. Otherwise we won't know 
what we're doing." 
Dorothy burst into the conference room, her face flushed. "We've just received an emergency 
transmission, My Lord! A carryall broke down and stranded one of the spice harvesters. They're calling 
for an emergency rescue before a worm comes." 
"We have two other carryalls, don't we?" Jesse asked. "Send one quickly." 
Now English looked distressed. "Sir, one carryall is in the repair depot, and the other is in a spice field 
near the equator. Much too far away. They'll never get there in time." 
"What about all those men?" Jesse demanded. "Isn't there a full spice crew on that harvester?" 
Dorothy's face darkened. "They shut down operations and dampened their noise and vibrations. But even 
if they lie low, they're sure a sandworm will come soon." 
Jesse fairly lunged out of the room. "William, get me our fastest transport shuttles, anything that can carry 
crewmen. We'll save as many as we can. Gurney, Esmar-come with me! There's no time to lose." 
6 
Nobility is not the same thing as bravery. 
- NOBLEMAN JESSE LINKAM, private notes 
For more than three decades General Esmar Tuek had served House Linkam, first as a member of the 
guard force, then working his way up to security chief. In earlier years he had tried to keep Jabo Linkam 
from accidentally killing himself, and the same with Linkam's eldest son, Hugo, but those noblemen had 
gone to great lengths to avoid using what little brains they had. 
Now, at long last, Tuek had a chance to serve someone with a solid head on his shoulders. Jesse was a 
thoughtful man willing to perform honest work for what he wanted, much loved by his people back on 
Catalan. But was the young nobleman just as big a fool as his predecessors for letting himself be goaded 
into Valdemar Hoskanner's challenge? Perhaps it would still end badly. 
Racing to rescue the stranded spice harvester, Gurney Halleck handled the controls of the transport ship 
with a kinesthetic accelerator connected to his fingertips. English stood behind him in the cockpit, 
struggling to hold his balance while guiding their course. 
The roaring ship flew so low over the dunes that the noise of its passage rattled the sands. Looking back 
through the aft porthole, Tuek saw a monstrous worm surface just behind them, questing with its blind 
head. 
The spice foreman had suggested a low and erratic flight pattern to confuse the creatures, and hopefully to 
prevent them from going after the disabled equipment. "They're unpredictable beasts," English said. "I 
wouldn't count on anything. There's never been a truly safe or effective means of harvesting melange." 
Twenty years before, Donell Mornay, an inventor with the third Imperial expedition to this desolate 
planet, had developed the initial techniques for excavating spice, under contract from the young Grand 
Emperor Wuda. Mornay's early harvesters had been much smaller machines, and when most of them were 
devoured by worms, he conceived the flying carryalls to lift the mobile factories to safety and deposit 
them at other rich spice veins, a leapfrog process that always kept the harvesters one step ahead of the 
worms. When everything worked properly. 
The Hoskanners improved the guerrilla mining technique with larger harvesters and more powerful 
carryalls. With any luck-and Tuek wasn't sure if House Linkam had any left-Jesse might further refine 
the techniques. 
Finally, the fast transport reached the weathered spice harvester sitting in the orange-and-brown sand. The 
quiet machine looked like a frightened rabbit huddling motionless, hoping not to be noticed. 
"A rich, rich vein," English said, his voice dismal. "A shame to just abandon it." 



"We'll salvage what we can from the cargo holds-if there's time," 
Jesse said, watching tensely. "The crews made a good haul before they got into trouble. I've already called 
for help from the Carthage shipping yards. More carriers are on the way." 
As the rescue transport arrived, a flurry of small ornijets rushed in from the west. Hovering overhead, five 
of them dipped vacuum tubes into the harvester's cargo hold, sucking up melange like hummingbirds 
sipping nectar. 
Tuek dropped a rescue chute onto the sand beside the massive vehicle and switched on the mechanism's 
motor. "Put it in reverse," Jesse ordered. "I'm going down myself." 
"My Lord, you don't need to do that. With all this increased activity, a worm will come soon. Bet on it!" 
"I didn't ask your opinion, General." Hearing the rebuke in the nobleman's voice, Tuek did as he was told. 
"Wormsign! Less than twenty minutes out!" English shouted, listening to a report from the ornijet scouts. 
"They have to hurry! Get salvage crews right now-off-load the spice! Save the melange!" 
"Damn the spice!" Jesse called. "Save the men!" 
He rode the stepped conveyor down to the sand. More than fifty sandminers had already boiled out of the 
harvester, seasoned freedmen and convicts still working off their sentences, along with new arrivals from 
Catalan. Jesse urged the men into the rescue chute. From above, Tuek barely heard their voices over the 
machinery sounds as he reset the conveyor. 
Tuek saw a mound of sand coming toward the shut-down harvester. The old veteran set the conveyor to 
ascend as rapidly as possible. More and more men made it to safety. 
Gurney said, "That machine's already scrap metal for the worms." 
Desperate crewmen streamed out of the stranded harvester and ran across the sand toward the rescue 
chute. Dust-encrusted workers began to spill into the transport ship, spreading through the passenger com-
partment. English and Tuek guided them to the back, shouting for the men to cram together. "Faster! 
Worm's coming! Faster, damn you!" 
Moments later, Jesse tumbled into the passenger compartment himself, staggering with an injured 
sandminer over his shoulder; the man's sleeve was torn and bloody, his arm bent at an unnatural angle. 
Tuek grabbed him, taking the weight from Jesse. "Here, My Lord. Let me help." 
"Take him, Esmar! There's still more down there! More men!" 
Wrestling the nobleman clear, Tuek looked back down the chute, where six frantic sandminers scrambled 
onto the rescue conveyor. Relieved of the injured man, Jesse turned, ready to climb back down and lend 
more assistance on the ground. 
Then a giant mouth ringed with glittering crystal teeth broke through the sand and shot up toward the 
bottom of the chute. Tuek smelled a nauseatingly strong belch of cinnamon, and felt the heat of the 
monster's exhalations. Four men screamed as they tumbled into the maw. 
The straining transport lurched into the air, and then the worm seized the end of the conveyor. English 
shouted from the cockpit, and Gurney lifted the ship higher, until the chute finally tore free. Suddenly 
loose, the aircraft recoiled up into the hot desert sky. Two remaining workers dangled from the torn end, 
trying desperately to hold on. 
The blind worm sensed the clinging sandminers, and with a more vigorous lunge the beast bit off the rest 
of the chute, taking them with it. 
Inside the passenger compartment, the terrified crewmen screamed. The transport craft spun and wavered 
unsteadily in the air, struggling to pull away. 
"Higher!" English shouted. 
Gurney responded, optimizing the kinetic controls. Staring down through the whistling gap, Tuek watched 
the worm turn its wrath on the abandoned spice harvester. 
The rescued crew chief hunched on the deck, shaking dust out of his hair and bemoaning the disaster. 
"Must be twenty sandminers lost! Eight of them freedmen we rehired. All good men." 
Jesse sat numb and exhausted, staring through the aft porthole. "I don't want to send more crews out until 
we can protect them. Let the Hoskanners burn in hell. I won't commit murder!" He shook his head. "I hope 
some of the new equipment arrives soon. We don't seem to have benefited much from paying extra for the 
rush delivery." 



Tuek wanted to chide the nobleman for risking himself, hut he would not do that in front of the men. 
Interestingly, because of Jesse's actions, the rescued crews looked at him with a strange, newfound re-
spect. 
Tuek also viewed the nobleman through fresh eyes. Perhaps Jesse was the sort of leader who could inspire 
men to overcome their fears, despite bad equipment and dangerous working conditions. The sand-miner 
crews needed that as much as they needed new machines. 
Perhaps, despite the tremendous odds they faced, House Linkam would survive after all. 
7 
Some people keep their secrets. Others build them from scratch. 
- DOROTHY MAPES, reflections 
Before allowing the Linkam family to set foot inside the Hoskanner mansion, General Tuek's men had 
scanned it for weapons, traps, electronic eavesdropping devices, and any number of hidden pitfalls. The 
veteran did find numerous traps, hidden explosives, tiny assassination devices disguised as "security 
systems," and poisoned food supplies. He even found two meek-looking household servants who, when 
strip-searched, displayed small horned-cobra tattoos on their backs signifying their ties to House 
Hoskanner. The security chief evicted them immediately and sent them to live with the convict laborers in 
Carthage. 
Despite his indignation, Tuek seemed to think these hazards were not serious attempts by the Hoskanner 
nobleman-more a game to 
show his contempt for the Linkams. The security chief continued his search, trying to find something 
more subtle and insidious. 
Though Tuek had combed the rooms and corridors to the best of his ability, Dorothy still sensed the old 
veteran had missed something. 
With sharp eyes and attentive skills that, she believed, surpassed Tuek's, the petite woman studied the 
various chambers, the architectural layout, even the choices of furnishings, to better understand Jesse's 
nemesis. Valdemar Hoskanner had designed this building to flaunt his wealth, to demonstrate his power 
on Duneworld. He had left signs of his aggressive personality, and perhaps his weaknesses, everywhere. 
Hoskanner supervisors and functionaries had shared communal residences with few amenities; their lives 
centered on work. No doubt they counted the days until they could be rotated home to Gediprime. Those 
buildings were now inhabited by the loyal staff members from Catalan. 
Deeper in the town, the hardened freedmen had dwellings of their own, most of them squalid but private, 
while the newest convict laborers were assigned to prefab barracks. Duneworld's environment provided all 
the security necessary to keep the prisoners from escaping; neither convicts nor freedmen could go 
anywhere. 
Every scrap of moisture was recycled and hoarded. But Valdemar himself, in open defiance of the desert, 
had built this huge headquarters mansion with cavernous rooms that needed to be sealed and cooled. To 
Dorothy, with her hard business mindset, the grandiosity seemed unnecessary and profligate. She would 
have to shut some of the wings and floors down in order to conserve. 
As she looked around, Dorothy tried to get into the mindset of their nemesis. This imposing mansion 
suggested to her the sheer scale of spice exports, the incredible profits. Once she began to realize how 
high the stakes truly were, Dorothy knew that Valdemar Hoskanner 
would do anything to win. This had never been a fair contest, and the Hoskanners had never intended to 
offer an actual compromise. They wanted only to eliminate the annoyance of House Linkam through de-
ception, and dispense with the objections of the Nobles' Council. 
Dorothy intended to find some of the traps Valdemar had left behind herself, using her own sharp wits 
instead of Tuek's technology. 
In the south wing, she noted with interest that a fourth-floor corridor seemed to go nowhere. A piece of the 
architecture did not fit. Having compared an aerial image of the headquarters mansion with on-site plans 
that Tuek's inspection team had drawn up, she realized now that the stone building's physical outline did 
not precisely match its interior layout. A small part of this wing was wrong. 
To her sharp eye, the hall floor showed faint signs of regular passage. Why would that be so, if the 



corridor didn't lead anywhere? With nimble fingers, she touched the irregular contours of the wall, 
searching for anything unusual. Not surprised to discover that one of the stones felt hollow and seemed to 
be made of a material that did not match the other blocks, she figured out its movement and unlocked the 
clever mechanism. 
With a gentle hiss, the hidden door unsealed and slid aside. Startlingly moist and mulchy air wafted 
toward her, so full of the smells of plants, leaves, roots, and compost that it struck her like a slap in the 
face. Alert for booby traps, Dorothy stepped inside. 
Cleverly concealed mist nozzles sprayed moisture in the air, while automatic irrigation piping fed flower 
beds, hedges, potted fruit shrubs. Dorothy had no doubt that these were flora brought from Gediprime. She 
saw an explosion of colorful flowers-purple, yellow, orange- amid verdant ferns. One set of huge 
scarlet blooms turned toward her as she moved, as if sensing a human presence. A raft of capped mush-
rooms spread out, speckled with golden-brown spots and silvery flecks. 
The smell of moisture in the air and the sight of misty droplets sent a wistful pang through her. Though 
she had only been on Duneworld 
for a few weeks, it seemed like years since she'd experienced an afternoon rain shower on Catalan. With 
delight, she realized she could bring Barri here whenever he grew lonely for his former home. It would be 
their special, private place. 
But Dorothy understood that would make her as wasteful and excessive as Nobleman Hoskanner. Her 
practical mind ran through swift calculations, and she was appalled to estimate the expense this conser-
vatory required. 
When she thought of the people living in squalor in Carthage, she grew angry that Valdemar Hoskanner 
would have indulged himself so. These plants did not belong here. It was an insult to the freedmen who 
had worked themselves almost to death to complete their sentences, and who were now unable to afford 
passage offplanet. 
Already mired in debt, with unexpected expenses and regularly occurring disasters, House Linkam had to 
pare their operating costs to the absolute minimum. They must adapt to this desert land, not expect 
Duneworld to change to suit their own needs. 
She would have to speak to Jesse in private about this. Better not to let anyone know the precious garden 
even existed. The conservatory would have to be shut down immediately, to stop the hemorrhage of water. 
INSIDE THE MAIN spaceport terminal, parsecs from his home on Catalan, Jesse leaned against the parapet 
of the landing-control tower and thought about loneliness. The night's first moon rose above the mountain-
jagged horizon. He watched it through the blast shutters, looking into the haze of dust that had drifted in 
from the desert wilderness to the south. The moon shone brightly, and the rolling dunes beyond the cliffs 
gleamed like parched icing. 
Already Gurney and his crews had gone out to the old Imperial stations to strip away valuable live-rubber 
shielding. William English had teams installing the shielding in the old harvesters, restoring them to 
greater efficiency. Jesse still needed a lot more equipment, but at least the machines he had should 
function better after this. 
And word had spread about his offer to pay for passage offplanet to any freedmen, provided House 
Linkam won the challenge. Many of the sandminers were giddy at the prospect, even the convict laborers 
who saw this as a sign of hope. Some skeptical men-secret Hoskanner sympathizers?-grumbled that it 
was a trick, that the devious nobleman would tell any lie to win his bet, but the majority believed him. 
They wanted to believe. . . . 
Though he had hoped for solitude, he heard soft footsteps, a gentle movement like wind through a stand of 
trees . . . but there were no trees on Duneworld. He turned to find Dorothy looking at him with an 
expression of concern on her oval face. He had told no one he would be out at the main spaceport, but she 
always seemed to know where to find him. 
"It's late, Jesse. Why don't you come to bed?" Her voice carried a quiet invitation, as it always did, but she 
would let him decide whether or not they would make love. Often, troubled by the uncertain pressures of 
this dangerous new venture, he would spend an hour simply holding her before drifting off to sleep. 
"My work is not yet finished for the day." He stared through the slats of the blast door. The bright moon 



seemed to beckon him. 
She moved silently, touched his arm. "The day's work will never be done, Jesse. Nor tomorrow's. Don't 
think of it as an individual task to complete. Each day here is a continuing struggle, a marathon race that 
we must win." 
"But if we succeed, Dor, it won't stop even then." 
The possibility of winning seemed like a twisted hallucination brought on by the consumption of too much 
melange. The Hoskanners had been eighteen years establishing their facilities and operations, with no time 
limit or contest to drive them. Jesse's choices were death, bankruptcy ... or victory. He was in over his 
head, much like that hapless sandminer Tuek and Gurney had seen sucked into a sand whirlpool. 
Dorothy slipped her arm around his waist. She had always been more than just his lover; she was a 
sounding board, a trusted advisor whose words and objectivity he could always rely upon. "Would you 
rather stay here and talk?" 
Jesse could not put words to his thoughts; articulating them would only make his troubles more raw. 
Instead he changed the subject. "There's so much we need to know about this world. I'm going to mount 
an expedition to the forward research base in the deep desert, where the Imperial planetary ecologist has 
been working for years. Maybe I can learn something I need to know." 
"How far away is it?" 
His face remained shadowed in the observation tower. "Almost sixteen hundred kilometers south, close to 
the equator. It's a research station and test oasis. That's where most of the deep-desert crews work." 
"So far away. It'll be dangerous." 
Jesse sighed. "Since accepting the Emperor's challenge, everything I do carries an element of danger. All I 
can do is forge toward our goal." 
"Spoken like a true nobleman," Dorothy said with a wistful smile. 
"And . . . I'm taking Barri with me. I want him to see the operations. He needs to learn our family 
business, and it's never too early to start. We'll be gone for at least a week." 
Now she stiffened and drew away. "Not the first time you go out there, Jesse! He's only eight." 
"One day he'll rule House Linkam. I'm not going to pamper him. You do that too much already." 
"Most noble sons his age aren't half as advanced as Barri is." 
"You know how I feel about most of those noble sons." He snorted. "Because of the position we're in, 
Barri has to be ready at all times, for any situation. My father was poisoned, my brother died in a foolish 
bullfight, and I've roused the ire of the Hoskanners. What are the odds I'll make it to my next birthday?" 
"All the more reason you shouldn't risk Barri! I've seen the mortality statistics of the workers. Those men 
would be safer in a penal colony. How can you take our boy into the middle of that?" 
Jesse took a deep breath. When Dorothy set her mind on something, it was like trying to pry open the jaws 
of a gazehound from its quarry. "I do it because I am the head of House Linkam, and he is my son. He 
goes where I say he goes." The iron tone of his voice cut off further protests, though he could tell she still 
had a lot more to say. 
"As you command, My Lord." She would stew about it, running the discussion over and over in her head. 
Unwilling to accept his decision, and refusing to concede, she would be like ice to him-probably for 
days. "Stay here in the tower as long as you like. I will not wait up for you." 
After Dorothy left, Jesse felt the great loneliness again. He feared that the next few days before the 
expedition departed would be even less pleasant than the storms of the deepest desert. 
COOLLY BUT DUTIFULLY supportive, Dorothy went to the secondary spaceport to bid her son farewell. 
Though she did her best to conceal her feelings, she could tell that the other members in the party sensed 
the wall between herself and Jesse. 
While the men boarded the transport ship for the forward research base, Jesse stood on the ramp with a 
hand on Barri's shoulder. The grinning boy was clearly excited to be going on a grand desert adventure 
with his father. His blue-green eyes were alight above the face mask, and a tight hood held down his 
unruly brown hair. 
Dorothy gave Jesse a chaste kiss, then embraced their son, holding him a moment too long. "Be safe," she 
said. Stepping back from the ramp, she lowered the gaze of her myrtle-brown eyes. Though General 



Tuek had already completed his inspection, she had quietly double-checked their preparations and 
provisions, satisfying herself that the team had reduced risks to the extent possible. 
"We'll be as safe as Duneworld allows us to be," Jesse said with a faint conciliatory note in his voice. 
Then he and Barri entered the craft and sealed the hatch. 
Dorothy did not stay to watch the vessel lift off and disappear toward the sand-smeared desert horizon. 
8 
The spice is a lens through which one can see the entire universe. 
- A SAYING OF THE FREEDMEN 
Followed by two water-supply ships, Jesse's transport approached  the forward research base near 
Duneworld's equator. 
"Is that it?" Barri asked for the fourth time, as he looked past the pilot, through a front window. He'd 
mistaken practically every outcropping of rock for their destination, but when the base finally came into 
view, its appearance was unmistakable. 
"That's it," Jesse said, putting a hand on the boy's shoulder. 
The cheddar-colored wedge structure thrust up from the sand, surrounded by a low fortress wall of natural 
rock. Mottled tan domes circled the main building, everything aerodynamically curved so that storms 
could skim over the tops without causing damage. V-shaped rows of plantings fronted the settlement area 
like the ripples from a ship's prow forging through a sandy ocean. 
Because the research outpost pursued Imperial-sponsored projects, most of the water burden was covered 
by a stipend from the Grand Emperor's private budget; even so, Jesse knew what an exorbitant cost this 
oasis drained from the planetary treasury. 
William English worked his way back along the line of seats to sit beside Jesse. Outside, the bronze-
orange sun settled toward the horizon. "We're lucky we weren't an hour later, or we'd have a bumpy ride. 
The rapid temperature change at sunset plays havoc with the weather." 
"Will we see a storm?" Barri asked. 
"Not tonight, boy," English said with a smile, tapping his scarred cheek. "I'd be able to feel one coming. I 
learned my lesson the hard way-so I can teach you not to take foolish chances." 
"I won't," Barri said, his eyes wide. 
In the lead, the water-supply ships landed at two of the outlying tan domes. Moisture silos? Kicking up 
blown sand, the transport shuttle came down on a hardened landing area. Barri bounded up from his seat, 
anxious to see the research base, but a stern General Tuek told his passengers to wait. He and his men 
emerged, staying alert for traps. Jesse and his son did not come out until the security chief had given his 
okay. 
A brown-haired man with a sunburned face stepped up to greet them. He extended a dry, rough hand. 
"You must be Nobleman Linkam? I am Dr. Haynes, the planetary ecologist." His curtained blue eyes 
twinkled, as if he was amused to meet the new master of Duneworld. Did he expect the Linkams to be any 
different from the Hoskanners? 
Though technically this man was an Imperial employee and not required to follow the instructions of any 
nobleman, Jesse hoped to secure him as a willing ally. "I understand that you're an expert on this planet, 
Dr. Haynes-more than any other person alive. We are eager to learn what you know." 
"If I understand more than any man about Duneworld, then it is a poorly known planet indeed." He turned 
to Barri. "Is this your son?" 
"He is the next Linkam nobleman in waiting." 
"Some would say this world is not a fit place for children." The planetary ecologist frowned. "But those 
same people would claim that grown men don't belong here, either." He stepped aside to let the rest of the 
men exit the transport shuttle, and offered a familiar greeting to William English. The two men had 
obviously dealt with each other before. 
Haynes led the visitors toward the main base building. "We will go out again after dark," he suggested. 
"On this planet, night is the most instructive time." The doors sealed behind them to keep precious wisps 
of humidity from leaking into the arid air. . . . 
Hours later, guided by a small handlight, Jesse and Barri followed Dr. Haynes out into the rows of 



plantings. The softly cutting soprano smell of sage climbed a desert night lush with stars, and there came a 
stillness so unaltered that the moonlight itself could almost be heard flowing across sentinel saguaro and 
spiked paintbrush. Though Jesse still felt overwhelmed by his impossible task, he felt a special peace here, 
a barely defined reason why one might want to come to this world. 
"All these plants have been imported, genetically modified to survive. As near as we can tell, no 
chlorophyll-based vegetation is native to the planet." Haynes walked among the rabbitbrush, trailing his 
fingers. A few night moths flitted in search of flowers. "With so little native moisture, even our most 
drought-resistant flora perishes without help." 
"But why do this, then?" Jesse asked. "The only reason anyone would come here is for spice. Duneworld 
will never be a colony for anything else." 
"I prefer to paint on a large canvas." Haynes stared wistfully into the night. "I believe it's possible to 
establish a permanent ecological cycle with humans in it as well as these hardy plants." 
"No chlorophyll plants means nothing green," Barri said, proving he'd been paying attention. Jesse was 
proud of his son, impressed with 
the education Dorothy had provided him. He was even correctly pronouncing difficult words. 
"Very perceptive, young Master," the planetary ecologist said. 
"Is there other native vegetation then?" Jesse furrowed his brow. "Ah, there must be-otherwise there 
wouldn't be any air." 
"Duneworld might look barren, but there's a rudimentary ecosystem within the sand itself: a form of 
plankton-we believe that's what the sandworms feed on-along with fleshy organisms we call sandtrout, 
which are like fish that burrow through the sands. Surveys have found native lichens surviving near the 
poles, as well as a type of moss and some wiry scrub. An additional source of atmospheric oxygen could 
be outgassing from volcanic vents. I believe there may be a large subterranean network beneath the sand." 
"Underground? Can you use probes to map it out?" 
Haynes shook his head. "Whenever we try to make a map, all we get is a jumble. The sand itself has 
magnetic ferrous granules, and the constant storms generate too much static electricity. Even the worms 
produce their own fields." 
"Is it possible to mine under the dunes? How about drilling or using blowers?" 
"Trust me, Nobleman, we have tried all these ideas. Subsurface shiftings always break the drills and pipes, 
and the shafts collapse. A standard stasis generator won't work, since static from the blowing sand burns 
out the equipment. And whenever we ground the generators, the pulse attracts and infuriates the worms. In 
twenty years, we've lost more than a hundred people in efforts to develop spice-harvesting technology. 
Grabbing and running is the only technique that has worked at all, and that's not terribly efficient." 
Jesse gave him a confident smile. "Then perhaps, Dr. Haynes, I'll count on you to find something different 
that we can do." 
The planetary ecologist led them along the rows of plantings. From the side of a dune, a vent gurgled and 
hissed, painted with a splash of yellow and orange. 
"It stinks," Barri said. 
"You know what that smell is," Jesse prodded the boy. 
"Sulfur." 
Haynes put his hand into the wisps of gas whistling from the fumarole. When he withdrew, his fingers 
were covered with yellowish powder. "Completely dry. No water content." He looked over at Jesse. "Out 
in the open, you'll see occasional eruptions, huge pillars of dust blasted into the sky like geysers. That 
strongly suggests an active world underneath the shifting dunes, trapped bubbles of superheated gas 
percolating explosively to the surface." 
"Is that where spice comes from? Deep underground?" Barri asked. 
Haynes shrugged. "Maybe. The melange from a fresh blow is particularly potent and easy to harvest. 
Unfortunately, the worms are also attracted by these eruptions, so our crews don't have much time." 
"Infuriating guard dogs," Jesse said. "I wish we could get rid of them." 
"None of our attempts have been successful. I wouldn't be surprised if it required an atomic blast to kill a 
great sandworm." 



"We have atomics!" Barri piped up. "And all our ships run on reactor piles. General Tuek told me they can 
be converted if we get into a military engagement." 
"We are not in a military engagement, Barri," Jesse pointed out. 
"That is closer to the truth than you might think," Haynes said. "We make hit-and-run spice raids on a 
worm's territory, lightning attacks and rapid retreats." 
He led his visitors past a stand of saguaros that stood in the shadows like the silhouettes of ghoulish men. 
When they reached the edge of the oasis, Haynes stopped them. "Stand there and face the desert. Open 
your mind and your senses-and just listen." 
As the three stood in silence, Jesse heard a long, slow exhalation, as from a living creature. 
"Sandtides," Haynes said, "the dunes wafting slowly in one direction and another, tugged by the two 
moons. This peristaltic action makes 
the free-rolling sand move a thousand to fifteen hundred feet a year." Kneeling, he dug his fingers into the 
grains and closed his eyes. "The desert moves and breathes beneath you." 
Barri hunkered down on the still-warm sand. "I miss the rain." 
"Rain . . ." the planetary ecologist mused. 
Jesse gave his son's shoulder a reassuring squeeze. He could not promise that either of them would ever 
see rain again. 
9 
No other planet in the Empire warrants closer examination than this  supposedly barren world. When peeled back, each layer revea ls another just 
beneath it, teeming with energy. 
- DR. BRYCE HAYNES, planetary ecologist assigned to study Duneworld 
 After the morning thermals had stabilized enough for ornijets to fly over the desert, Jesse, Barri, and Dr. 
Haynes went out to observe spice operations. Foreman English was already out on the sands, deploying a 
huge harvester in a new vein of melange that had been uncovered by shifting dunes during the night. 
Dr. Haynes flew the small ornijet with ease. When another pilot transmitted a warning about a thermal 
sink, a patch of cold sand that created a pillar of dangerous turbulence, the ecologist adjusted course to 
avoid the anomaly. "Cold sands indicate ice caves deep beneath the surface," he said to Jesse. "The 
temperature gradient creates a hazard." 
"Underground ice caves? How many more surprises does Duneworld hold?" 
"More than anyone could tally, I'm afraid." 
A plume of smoke and dust marked the ground operations. Jesse and Barri watched the giant mobile 
harvester lumber onto the dunes, gouging up great quantities of sand mixed with rust-colored spice. Scouts 
soared in widespread patrols to watch for any encroaching worms. 
From the ground, English demanded a satellite weather report. "I don't like the looks of that line of dust on 
the eastern horizon.", 
Though the sky looked perfectly blue to Jesse, with only a bit of haze, he did not question the man's 
intuition. Maybe his scar was tingling. 
"Weather satellites are clear. Nothing brewing." 
"Check again." 
A pause, then: "Still nothing on the sats, Mr. English." 
"I'll get back to you." 
When the diligent patrols did spot an approaching worm, the well-practiced workers rushed back to their 
vehicles and evacuated with an efficient system of managed chaos. The powerful carryall lifted the 
support equipment, spice harvester, and ground machinery just as the oncoming subterranean ripples 
reached the work site. Barri moved from window to window in the ornijet, hoping for a glimpse of the 
desert monster, but the worm never surfaced. Jesse saw it churn beneath the ground and then tunnel away. 
Safe for the moment, the breathless crews reported how much spice they had excavated. It was a good 
haul. Jesse processed the numbers in his head: If only the crews could keep up that rate every second of 
every day for the next two years-without any mishaps-House Linkam might have a chance of beating 
the Hoskanners. 



A moment later, William English's voice broke across the comm system. "We have a severe problem with 
the weather satellites!" 
In the excitement of evacuating the harvester, Jesse had forgotten about the foreman's concern. "Nobleman 
Linkam here. What is it, English?" 
"I just tapped our scout flyers, then took a run to the east myself. Twelve different sightings confirm it, 
sir-there's a Coriolis storm 
brewing in the vicinity, an anvil-shaped cloud covering the whole sky. I can't predict a detailed path by 
eyeballing it, but I'd say it's coming straight toward the base." 
Jesse looked to the planetary ecologist for an explanation. Haynes picked up the transmitter. "If it's that 
big, William, how could the satellites not have seen it?" 
"That's just it-they couldn't have missed it. But there's no mistake, and that storm is coming." A dark 
undertone of anger like a bloodstain seeped into his voice. "If we'd relied entirely on those satellites for a 
warning, we would've continued our operations until it was too late." 
The answer flashed into Jesse's mind as clear as weapons fire on a silent night: Hoskanner sabotage. 
"Recall our crews and scouts to the forward base where we'll ride out the storm. Then somebody is going 
to get me answers. We need those satellites." 
INSIDE THE SHIELDED buildings, Jesse held a war council with Tuek, Haynes, and English. They sat at 
a long worktable, talking above the noise of furious winds outside. 
Barri peered through an armored windowslit, trying to see past the murk. Like the men, he wore a sealable 
bodysuit with his face mask flapping loose. "Are we safe? Can the winds cut their way in here?" 
"This shelter is protected enough, young Master," Dr. Haynes said. "Outside, though, that storm-driven 
sand can flay a man to his bones, and then etch the bones." 
Getting down to business, Tuek spread documents on the table. "As near as I can determine, all the 
weather satellites were programmed to replace any readings of major weather disturbances with 
deceptively clear reports. Another goodbye gift from the Hoskanners." 
Dr. Haynes looked at English with respect. "If you hadn't sensed the 
storm, William, we would've been wiped out." The scarred spice foreman sat stiffly, as if trying to 
suppress his continuing uneasiness. 
"It's still a disaster," Tuek said. "When we tried to delete the corrupted programming, we activated another 
trap, which shorted out the satellites. We're completely blind in the skies now." The veteran looked gray 
with disappointment. "I was searching for an outright assassination attempt, but this is much more 
insidious. Sweet affection, if only I'd foreseen it!" 
Jesse simmered as he listened. "What'll it take to repair the satellites?" 
English said, "The damage is too extensive. We need to replace them." 
Jesse put his elbows on the table. "Options?" 
English groaned. "Stop spice mining until we get new satellites." 
"Unacceptable. That might take months." 
Tuek suggested, "We could triple our scout flights to monitor the weather, do our best to predict dangers. 
But increased flights mean increased hazards as well. We'd lose flyers and pilots for sure." 
Jesse looked around the table, hoping for more alternatives. "Else?" 
English spread his hands flat. "How lucky do you feel, Nobleman? We could just continue spice mining 
and take our chances." 
The planetary ecologist pursed his lips. "I may be able to modify a research satellite or two, enough to 
give us some weather data." 
Everyone fell silent and looked at Jesse. "All right. Dr. Haynes, find out how much weather coverage we 
can put together. Minimize risks to our ships and crews-but we need to keep producing spice, no matter 
the setbacks." The sandstorm outside skimmed the dome roughly, like the abrasive caresses of Valdemar 
Hoskanner himself. Jesse looked at his security chief, lowered his voice. "Esmar, I don't know how we're 
going to pay for new satellites." 
"Consult with your concubine, My Lord. But in my opinion, we do what we need to do. We have no 
choice." 



"I'll tell Dorothy to increase our debt, as necessary, sell any holdings we have left on Catalan. But I want 
the network installed as soon as possible. Find out who can do it the fastest." 
Jesse's instincts told him the Hoskanners were likely planning further grand gestures. The unexpected 
storm and the satellite sabotage emphasized the danger of even everyday activities on Duneworld. Right 
now, he felt an overwhelming need to be back with Dorothy, to talk with her, hold her. . . . 
"As soon as this storm passes, I'm going back to Carthage. English, I'd like you to come with me so we 
can review our spice operations, combine resources, and make the most of what we have." 
"It is not wise to rush a Coriolis storm, Nobleman," Dr. Haynes said. "They are unpredictable and 
dangerous." 
Consumed with anger at Valdemar Hoskanner, Jesse felt his muscles tense like steel cables. "I can be 
unpredictable and dangerous, too." 
BECAUSE ONLY THREE of them were returning to Carthage, they took one of the research base's ornijets 
instead of the larger transport shuttle. The dust-laden air was still fraught with capricious breezes, but the 
bulk of the storm had swung south. 
English flew them north toward Carthage, more than fifteen hundred kilometers away. Below, the 
diamond-shaped oasis was already beginning to recover from the blowing sand, and within minutes all 
distinctive features were replaced by the monotony of nothingness. Ahead, a jagged line of black 
mountains jutted up like an atoll in the ocean of sand. From the cliff-walled pan he could see hundreds of 
blind canyons, cut not by water but by seismic action, ancient lava flows, and fierce desert winds. Over 
the next hour, even the intermittent backbones of rock developed a sameness to them. 
The nobleman's thoughts drifted, and he mulled over possible solutions. Barri leaned his head on his 
father's shoulder and dozed. 
As they cruised toward one barrier of mountains, English jerked the ornijet controls. "More storm readings 
ahead, sir." He glanced over his shoulder. "By the deity, it's a backstabber! The storm circled around!" 
"Are we safe in the ornijet?"                                                , 
"We should be able to fly over it." 
Jesse saw a low-rolling tsunami of sand and powder crawling up and over the peaks like a slow-moving 
wave of milk. English kept working the controls, but his movements took on a more intense quality. 
"Why aren't we going higher?" Jesse asked. 
The wall of sand and dust grew larger, spreading to fill their field of view. The ornijet's wings flapped 
furiously, trying to gain altitude. 
"The wings can only take us so high. I'm trying to kick in the jets to leapfrog us over the storm." English 
punched the controls again. "But the blasted craft isn't shifting modes-and without jets we can't make it!" 
"Can we outrun the storm?" 
"Not a chance. I may be able to bypass the switchover and tap into the jets directly. It might cause burnout 
in a hundred kilometers, but we might get away from the storm, where someone can rescue us." His face 
showed a relieved smile. "Ah, there's the bypass." 
A small muffled explosion reverberated in their engines, a shot bomb detonating in the ornijet's rear 
components. "More sabotage!" 
"Signal for help!" 
The spice foreman fought with the controls to keep the aircraft from corkscrewing into the sand. "The 
bomb took out the comm, too. Must have been rigged that way." 
"Just get us down, English." Wide awake now, Barri looked around in fear. Jesse grasped his son's arm, 
sealed the boy's bodysuit and his own, then put on their face masks. 
The ornijet lost altitude, spiraling toward the dunes. Scanning ahead for shelter, English chose a small 
island of rocks, little more than 
THE   ROAD   TO   DUNE 
a scramble of boulders poking up out of the dunes. Out of control, the craft thumped to the sand and spun 
around. 
Before English could even shut off the engines, a towering wave of blown sand broke over them, utterly 
engulfing the ornijet and its occupants. 



10 
Adaptation is an art form, and it is the si ngle-most important aspect of being human. 
- EXCERPT FROM   THE SANDMINER'S MANUAL 
After the storm had washed past, leaving behind an endless ocean of pristine dunes, a slight movement 
stirred a pocket of sand. An indentation formed, then sank, and a small hand reached out while sand 
continued to stream into the buried ornijet's trapdoor opening. 
Coughing, young Barri scrambled into the air as his father pushed him up and out of the uncovered hatch. 
Inside the dim cockpit, Jesse choked on a mouthful of dust. He quickly sealed his face mask in place. "We 
were lucky to survive the storm." 
William English, his tattooed forehead bloody from a gash, stepped back until the sandfall dwindled to 
nothing. "A very small measure of luck, Nobleman." He looked up from the open control panel. "Our 
emergency locator beacon has been intentionally ruined. No one will be able to find us." 
Jesse crouched inside the cramped cockpit, his voice muffled by the mask. "The Hoskanners are thorough. 
They know the value of redundancy." He looked intensely at the spice foreman, lowering his voice. "But 
I'm not willing to give up yet. The three of us are still alive. We'll just have to get out of this by 
ourselves." 
Outside the crashed ornijet, Barri lifted his mask and shouted down to them, "I don't see anything up 
here-just a huge sandbox of dunes and dunes and dunes!" He brushed dust from his freckled nose. "At 
least the storm's gone." 
"We'll be up there in a minute. Be careful where you wander! The sand can be dangerous." 
English dug out a small first-aid kit and applied clotting salve and a gauze patch to his forehead. "Bear in 
mind, Nobleman, that surviving on Duneworld is a challenge even with the best equipment and 
technology. It's not a stroll through one of your rain forests on Catalan." 
Jesse nodded. "We do have control over one thing, English: We can react to our situation with hope, or 
with despair. I prefer the former." 
He climbed out of the buried ornijet to stand on a nearly pristine dune slope, with the exception of Barri's 
small footprints that trailed up to a high point on a newly sculpted hill, from which he had surveyed the 
landscape. Jesse felt very proud of his son. Other children, even many adults, might have panicked, but 
Barri seemed to have complete faith that they would get out of this trap. 
"I hope you're geared up for a tough time, Barri. I need your strength." 
"We'll be rescued, Father. General Tuek will know where to find us. He'll send out men." 
The completely buried ornijet would be invisible to aerial searchers. Jesse considered spending a day or 
two digging it out, as a marker for rescuers to see. But that would take a lot of valuable energy, and the 
loose, settling sand and restless winds would probably erase each day's efforts. 
English tossed a pack up onto the sand and climbed out of the buried ship to stand with the other two. The 
spice foreman squinted in the sunlight, then connected his face mask. "I know approximately where we 
are, at least a hundred kilometers from one of the old Imperial survey outposts." 
"One of the stations Gurney just raided for live-rubber shielding?" "Yes, and Dr. Haynes still uses them 
from time to time. Even if Halleck stripped the nearest station, there's still a solar generator I can use to 
send a signal. But it's going to be a long journey, even if the weather holds." 
Jesse pressed his lips together. "You think that's our best chance?" "The only one I can think of-other 
than waiting here and doing nothing." English shrugged. "I believe it's the best option." "Then that's the 
one we'll choose. How soon can we set off?" "Not until we're prepared." The spice foreman removed two 
handheld devices from his pack. "There's a paracompass in the survival kit, and I pried another from the 
ornijet's controls. We'll each take one. I've locked in the coordinates for the nearest survey outpost." "So 
all we have to do is walk," Barri said. "A long ways." English gave the boy a weary smile. "It'll be a trek 
like none of us has ever made before, young Master." 
"I'm not afraid." Barri lifted his chin. "If that's what we've got to do, then I'm ready." 
Jesse felt another swell of pride for the boy. "Barri's right. We'll do what we have to-even if it's 
impossible." 
ENGLISH INSISTED ON performing a second and third check of the crashed ornijet to make sure they 



scavenged every item of any possible use. Jesse left a scrawled note inside the buried cockpit with the 
coordinates they were trying to reach, just in case a search party found the wreck. 
They had sufficient food to keep their metabolisms running- energy rations and packets of concentrated 
spice-but both Jesse and English knew that their water supplies wouldn't last for the number of days 
required to reach the outpost, even moving at their best pace in sealed bodysuits. 
Before emerging from the cockpit for the last time, Barri peeled off several pieces of a reflective metal 
sheet. "Look, signal mirrors if somebody flies over us. They've got to see us, out here in the open desert." 
"Excellent thinking, boy," English said. 
It was late afternoon when the three began their long walk. Each step was plodding and difficult, and they 
sank in up to their ankles. Loose sand held them back, caressing their legs and encouraging them to stay, 
to stop walking, to sit down and welcome hot, desiccating death... . 
"Will we see worms out here?" Barri seemed interested, but not fearful. 
"Oh, they're out here, young Master. The mining vibrations of our spice harvesters attract them, but we're 
too small to get their attention, like pebbles tossed across the dunes." 
"Even so," Jesse said, "keep your eyes peeled for rippling sand." 
It was a balancing act to maintain a fast enough pace to cover distance before their supplies ran out 
without exhausting themselves to the point of collapse. Although they were weary by the time night fell, 
they rested only briefly before continuing their long journey in the cool darkness, when they would 
perspire less. 
IN CARTHAGE, THE headquarters mansion was in turmoil. Static discharge from the dust had played 
havoc with comm systems across the planet, but General Tuek had transmitted a message as soon as the 
storm cleared. He'd been forced to shout his dire news twice before Dorothy could understand him. 
"The search parties have found no sign of them?" She tried to be as strong and stony as one of the blocky 
statues the Hoskanners had left behind. "Has their whole flight path been checked?" 
Static noises. A garbled response. She repeated herself, and Tuek answered, "Every flightworthy vehicle is 
combing the desert, but the Coriolis winds wiped out all signs." 
Anger and accusations edged her voice. "How could you let them fly into a storm, General? You are 
responsible for the nobleman's safety!" Even when he does foolish things . . .like his father and his brother. 
Despair threatened to overwhelm her, like an inundation of sand burying her for eternity. My son, my son! 
Tuek looked miserable himself, but frowned at her condemnation. "Madam, one doesn't prevent 
Nobleman Linkam from doing anything once he has a mind to do it. Sweet affection, if I had known, I'd 
have used a stunner myself and tied him up in one of the spice silos until he came to his senses." 
"How about the observation satellites? Don't we have any with high enough resolution to scan for the 
ornijet's locator beacon?" 
"Dr. Haynes has been working nonstop, but he's managed to get only four of the satellites working at all, 
and they're not worth much! We should already have picked up the beacon-unless it's not functioning." 
"Can you scan for the hull metal? Debris?" 
"Not with all the distorted fields." Tuek drew a deep breath, sounding impatient; apparently, he had 
already considered every suggestion she'd made. He acted as if she was stepping on his toes. Back on 
Catalan, he and Dorothy had both been powerful, often at odds but with clearly segregated duties. On 
Duneworld, though, business and defense overlapped heavily. "But we'll find him. I'm flying out on a 
scout patrol myself."                                                                                           
"Do you need extra men?" 
"No, there aren't enough vehicles. I've shut down spice operations 
THE   ROAD   TO   DUNE 
to devote all crews to the search. Please don't tell me how to do my job." 
Dorothy bit her lip. Jesse would hate any slowdown in production, and so would the sandminers, who 
desperately wanted to earn their freedom. If only he had listened to her about the dangers of going to the 
forward base-and taking Barri with him. 
The static was growing worse. "Just. . . send me regular reports!" After signing off, she went to find 
Gurney Halleck. The jongleur would round up his own teams, commandeer any functional flyer, and send 



men to scour the desert. If stern old Tuek couldn't rescue her family, maybe Gurney could. 
11 
I have seen many worlds in the Known Universe: some beautiful, some bland, some so alien they defy description or understanding. Duneworld is 
the most enigmatic of the enigmatic. 
- GURNEY HALLECK, notes for an uncompleted ballad 
Trudging across the cool, dark sands, the three figures followed the spine of a tall, snaking dune. Their 
moonlit footprints looked like the track of a centipede winding into the shadows. Barri took the lead, 
showing an energy and determination that went beyond the usual enthusiasm of an eight-year-old. Jesse 
drew strength from his son's tireless optimism. 
Without warning, the boy stumbled into a pocket of loose powder, and his legs slid out from under him. 
He flailed for balance, but could find nothing solid to hold. Barri cried out, slipping down the steep slope 
of the dune. Dislodged sand washed like loose snow down into the basin. A few buried stones, some as 
large as a man's head, spat out of the dune's side, bouncing, tumbling. 
Jesse ran toward him. "Barri!" 
The young man had the presence of mind to jam his legs deep into the sand and thrust his arms into the 
flowing grains, and eventually stopped himself by digging in. Covered with sand, his face mask knocked 
loose, Barri looked up, coughing and choking, but managed to reassure his father. He actually grinned. 
"I'm all right!" 
Sliding sand and stones continued to flow past him to the base of the dune, where the bouncing stones hit 
a hard white patch that broke apart and resonated. Compacted grains struck each other and triggered an 
acoustic shockwave like the heartbeat of a violently awakened giant. The thumping pulse boomed into the 
night. 
Barri tried to scramble up the dune slope, feeling a mixture of fear and fascination. The pounding built 
upon itself, a thrumming vibration that rose to a crescendo. 
"Drumsand!" English exclaimed. "Grains of a certain size and shape, acoustically packed . . . unstable 
equilibrium." The spice foreman was pale. "It's loud enough to draw a worm! Climb, lad; climb!" 
Jesse scrambled to meet his son halfway, grabbed Barri by the arm, and pulled him up. "We have to get 
away from here." 
Already gasping and exhausted, Barri could hardly stay on his feet. When they reached the dune crest, 
English gestured frantically. He bounded along, his feet stirring the sand. When the liquid dune slope 
began to drop them to a gully, the freedman cut sideways and skidded down the sands. "We have to get far 
from that drumsand!" 
They slid into the gully, then slowed as they cut an ascending zigzag up to the peak of another dune ridge 
away from where Barri had first stumbled. From far behind, they heard a familiar hissing, stirring sound . . 
. the passage of something huge and serpentine. 
"Stop!" English said in a harsh whisper. "Don't move. Don't make a sound." 
The three froze and stared across the moon-silvered sands. They saw turmoil in the drumsand valley as a 
blunt head emerged like a sea serpent from the sandy depths. Sand grains showered from its massive body 
like diamond specks. When the worm plunged again, the reservoir of drumsand vibrated and thumped 
with a last few dying echoes until the creature destroyed the delicately balanced acoustic compaction. 
English sank into a weary squat atop the dune ridge. Jesse and Barri sat beside him, holding their breath. 
The slower hissing sound of disturbed sand reminded Jesse of the whisper of waves on the far-away 
Catalan seas. 
Finally, they got up and set off into the night again. 
TWO DAYS LATER in the heat of afternoon, the bedraggled trio stopped in the shadow of a rock 
outcropping. Concentrated spice had kept them alive and moving, but their carefully rationed water was 
now almost gone. Jesse and English both knew they would consume the last drops within another day. 
And according to the paracompasses, they were barely more than halfway to the automated outpost. 
Leaning against the rocks, they kept their uncomfortable face masks in place to minimize moisture loss. 
While the spice foreman dozed, conserving energy, Jesse watched Barri, who was holding up like a 
champion. The boy never slackened his pace, did not moan or complain. Despite Dorothy's indulgent 
manner, Barri did not show signs of excessive coddling; he just needed to be given a chance to prove him-



self. 
If his descendants were like this young man, Jesse held out hope for the future of House Linkam. With 
common sense and a strong foundation of moral integrity, Barri would grow up to be far superior to most 
of the Empire's spoiled and corrupt noble heirs. But only if the boy survived the next few days. . . . 
Snooping among the rocks, Barri discovered a patch of gray-green lichen. He called his father over. 
"Something's alive here." 
As Jesse approached, tiny furtive shapes began moving in the crevices. "They're . . . rodents!" 
Barri reached in and found a nest, but could not catch the bouncing little forms. From a higher cranny, a 
little kangaroo rat poked out its narrow head, squeaking accusations and scolding the human intruders. 
"How did they get out here? Do you think some of Dr. Haynes's specimens got loose?" 
Jesse could think of no other explanation. "Maybe Dr. Haynes intentionally set them free. He said he 
wanted to establish an ecosystem on Duneworld." 
Shoulder to shoulder, he and Barri watched the tiny kangaroo rats scurry about their business. Jesse took 
heart. "If they can survive here, Barri, so can we." 
12 
Life is full of frayed ends. It is a terrible thing when you show anger to a loved one, never knowing that it might be the last time you are together. 
- DOROTHY MAPES, A Concubine's Life 
Jesse and Barri had been gone for too long. Much too long. Few things could have survived out in that 
desert for so many days. 
With aching loneliness in her heart, Dorothy wondered if she would ever see her loved ones again. 
Though she was a sharp business manager and the financial watchdog of the Linkam holdings, she was 
also a mother, and a wife in everything but the title. Her stomach had wrenched itself into a tight knot. 
As each unsuccessful patrol returned, she lost a fine thread of hope, a little bit of the precious connections 
she'd had with Jesse and Barri. The friction of her last night with the nobleman had left her full of regrets, 
guilt, and uncertainty. Should she have demanded that he bow to her wishes? Then Jesse and Barri might 
not be lost out in the infinite 
desert. Or should she have been more supportive, even if she disagreed with him? 
If he ever came home, she knew Jesse would pretend that nothing had happened between them; but he 
wouldn't forget, and neither would she. The disagreement would hang like a curtain between them. 
Intellectually, she understood why Jesse had wanted their son to understand hardship, to know how 
ordinary people lived and worked, to be tempered by real experience and difficult decisions instead of 
softened by pillows and pampering. But how could a mother not try to make her son as safe as possible? 
Barri had not yet reached his ninth birthday . . . and now he was lost out in the arid wasteland, probably 
dead. 
When the boy had departed on the transport shuttle with his father, he had looked so dignified, so proud 
and manlike. She had never seen him look like that before. 
God, how she hated this place! 
Dorothy paced down the halls, trying to keep busy, looking for something to occupy her thoughts. If Jesse 
was gone, should she formally withdraw from the challenge on his behalf? He had designated her his legal 
proxy in business matters. Without Jesse, and Barri, there was no House Linkam, and the Nobles' Council 
would no doubt dissolve it, distribute the Linkam holdings, and absorb the administration into another 
family. She would go back to Catalan as a commoner again, alone except for her memories. 
Ahead, she saw Cullington Yueh slowly climbing the main stairway, holding the stone railing. The gray-
haired old gentleman reached the top short of breath. "Oh, Dorothy! I've been looking for you." 
"Any word?" Her voice cracked with concern, though she tried to cover it with a dry cough. "Gurney 
should have been back hours ago." 
"Not yet, but General Tuek says communications are fully restored, back online after the storm. He's quite 
interested in getting the spice operations going again. Some of the ships have been improved with 
live-rubber shielding, and they can fly farther and with less risk of malfunction. Oh, and Dr. Haynes has 
restored a few more satellites. Still, you know how problems can arise." 
"Especially here. I hate those Hoskanners for leaving us with junk." 



"No sign of the new spice harvesters or carryalls that you ordered from Ix, either." Yueh rubbed his gray 
mustache. "Aren't they overdue?" 
"Yes, the first order is a week late." It struck her as odd that the kindly old family physician was interested 
in spice-harvesting equipment, but she appreciated his concern while Jesse was gone. Gone. Such a final 
sound to the word. Her heart sank, but she forced her thoughts into line. Jesse was counting on her to 
make sure House Linkam did not fall apart. "Something about production delays." 
Gurney had attempted to follow up with an Ixian representative, but hadn't gotten a straight answer, and 
for the past several days all resources had been devoted to the search for the missing ornijet. She frowned. 
"You think the Hoskanners might have something to do with that?" 
"Accidents happen," Yueh said. "And some accidents happen on purpose." 
Sensing her misery, the old man massaged her shoulders and neck with his surgeon's fingers, working 
pressure points, but she could feel his hands shaking. "This used to make my wife Wanna relax." 
"Your wife? I didn't know you were married, Cullington!" 
"Oh, it was a long time ago. She died . . . something I couldn't cure. That's why I try my best to heal 
everyone else." He gave a bleak smile. 
Yueh was a self-described "splint and pill man," earning his early medical experience on Grumman's 
World, a distant planet replete with odd swamp maladies and native fruits that oozed contact poisons. He 
had joined House Linkam years ago as their dedicated physician, claiming he wanted a peaceful, out-of-
the way place like Catalan. Here on Duneworld, though, he seemed out of his depth. 
Dorothy eased his hands away. "Thank you, Cullington. I feel much better." 
His hazel eyes were filled with concern. "No, you're still worried. But I appreciate your saying so 
anyway." Then he ambled off on one of his many errands. Rarely did she see the doctor take a break. 
Dorothy headed for the south wing. Encountering one of the maids, she requested a pot of strong spice tea 
and a large cup on a tray. Then, carrying the tray herself, Dorothy took a spiral staircase up to the fourth 
level. The melange would soothe her . . . and so would the conservatory. 
She pressed the hollow stone on the dead-end wall. When the hidden door slid open with a hiss, she 
stepped inside and was assailed by the heavy odor of dead and decaying plants. Not a soothing place after 
all. 
The secret conservatory had suffered for weeks, since she had shut off the irrigation system and diverted 
the water to vital uses. The speckled fungi had already collapsed into mush, while the once-verdant ferns 
had turned a sickly, yellowish brown. Formerly bright and colorful flowers were dried up now, with 
discolored petals scattered on the caked soil. Only a few plants still clung to life, though they had no hope 
of surviving. 
Scuttling insects darted in and out among the dead plants, feeding off the remains. The decay had turned 
into a feast for the tiny scavengers, and they'd been reproducing madly. But that niche of life, like the rest 
of the enclosed ecosystem, would also end soon. 
These plants were victims of an untenable situation, trapped in a place where they did not belong. Like 
House Linkam, she thought, barely surviving on this barren world, hoping our lives will be returned to us.  
Feeling gloom wash through her, Dorothy placed the tray on a plaz table and brushed dirt and dead insects 
off a chair before sitting down. She poured the rich, aromatic tea into her cup, and steam escaped into the 
air. Lost moisture. As she lifted the cup to her lips, a rush of cinnamon tickled her nostrils. 
Only she and Jesse knew this place existed, and only the two of them knew that the plants would soon all 
be dead. She could be completely alone here, undisturbed with her thoughts, though she doubted she 
would find any solutions. Dorothy finished the spice tea, and as melange seeped into her body, her mind's 
eye projected vivid images of watery, dreamlike Catalan. If only she and her family could be back there 
again. . . . 
But mere wishes could not transport them home, could not erase the unfortunate events that had brought 
them here. Where were Jesse and Barri now? What if William English himself had remained secretly loyal 
to the Hoskanners? Had he dumped their lifeless bodies in the desert to shrivel like the plants around her? 
Tears streamed down her cheeks. On this world, they called it "giving water to the dead." 



13 
In the desert, hope is as scarce as water. Both are a mirage.  - SANDMINER'S LAMENT 
Even after the water ran out, they kept moving. They had to. English took the lead, frequently checking 
his paracompass, while Jesse and Barri plodded after him. There could be no turning back now. It was a 
hot afternoon, with the unrelenting sun in the western sky. 
They approached a low-hanging, discolored haze, and Jesse realized they had stumbled upon a patch of 
fumaroles. Though they had little hope of finding water there, they traveled toward the hissing steam-
vents. If nothing else, the chemical steam would obscure some of the painful sunlight. 
When the wind picked up, English looked around in concern. He touched the waxy scar on his cheek and 
met Jesse's gaze. "Weather's changing. I feel it." 
"How soon until the storm gets here?" Jesse asked. Barri searched the horizon for the wall of dust heading 
their way. 
"No telling," English answered. "They're capricious things. Could come right at us, no matter where we 
hide-or the weather front might turn aside and go somewhere else entirely." 
Taking shelter in partial shade among the sulfur-painted rocks near the roar of a fumarole, they sat down 
to rest. Jesse opened the pack and withdrew his paracompass. "I need to know how far we have left to go." 
To his dismay, when he studied the coordinates, their destination seemed farther away than ever. The 
directional needle pointed at an extreme angle from where they'd been heading. "William, check your 
compass." 
The spice foreman held his device next to Jesse's. After comparing, both men were astonished to see that 
the readings were entirely different. When English pushed the reset button, his needle spun until it landed 
at a new spot. Jesse did the same, and now the direction on his instrument pointed back the way they had 
come. The men looked at each other. 
"More sabotage?" Jesse asked. 
"No, I think it's magnetite in the dunes," English said, his voice thick with discouragement. "Static energy 
from the storm front or maybe from a sandworm. It scrambled the compasses." 
Jesse reset his device again, and now the needle spun in wild circles. 
English slumped in hopeless surrender. "We weren't going in the right direction! We have no way of 
knowing where the outpost is, and now we can't even find our way back to the ornijet. Our footprints 
would have been erased days ago." 
Jesse was not willing to show fear in front of his son. They had been wandering in the desert, possibly 
going in circles. In the open expanse he could not begin to guess where anything might be-the Imperial 
outpost, the city of Carthage, the buried ornijet, or the forward base. They were utterly lost, and they had 
run out of water. 
Reaching an edge of desperation, English staggered to the discolored sands near a fumarole. He stood 
there poised for a long moment, staring down as if in a daze. Jesse wondered if the man intended to plunge 
headfirst into the exhaling vapors. 
"How can anything survive out here?" English finally said. "Every living thing needs water. Maybe we 
should have drunk the blood of those kangaroo mice." 
"I tried to catch them," Barri said, his voice dry and raspy. 
English bent closer to the crusty sands near the fumarole, as fiercely intent as a hunter. His voice dropped 
to a whisper. "But immense creatures live in the sands. There has to be water." The bedraggled spice 
foreman slowly extended his hands, toward shapes that writhed and squirmed in the warm sands around 
the steam vent. 
He lunged, digging his hands through the powdery crust. Like a dog, he furiously scooped sand aside, 
burrowing, clawing, until he finally seized something. He struggled, cried out in triumph, and lurched 
backward, uprooting a shapeless blob that looked like a gigantic cell as long as his forearm. English tossed 
the thing onto the hard-packed sand, then dropped to his knees and flipped it over, trying to hold it down 
as it continued to flop. 
Barri hurried forward, full of boyish curiosity, despite their ordeal. "What's that?" 
"Sandtrout. Dr. Haynes told me they're often found near fumaroles." English looked up at them with 



reddish eyes. "All I care about is that it's alive, and there's some sort of liquid inside-blood, sap, proto-
plasm. Who knows?" He pressed his fingers into the pliable skin of the squirming thing, then drew a 
utility knife from his pack. 
"Can we survive on it?" Jesse asked. 
The spice foreman pulled his face mask aside and shrugged. "I've never heard of anyone eating a 
sandtrout. As far as I know, nobody's had to." 
"What if it's poison?" Barri asked. 
"Seems to me, young Master, that we're as good as dead anyway if we don't get some water soon." He 
tried to swallow, but could find no 
moisture in his dry throat. "I'm going to take a chance. One of us has to." 
Jesse lowered his voice. "Thank you for not giving up, William." 
With his fingers, English jabbed the sandtrout's leathery membrane, then broke through with the tip of the 
knife. Thick liquid oozed out like viscous saliva, and a potent aroma wafted up, a tang of harsh alkaline 
mixed with cinnamon so strong that it stung their eyes. "It smells like spice beer." English dipped his 
finger and touched it to his tongue. "Tastes like spice, too . . . extremely potent stuff. But different." 
Surrendering caution, desperately thirsty, he lowered his mouth to the still-squirming sandtrout. With his 
eyes closed, he took a long slurp of the slimy fluid. 
Jesse had wanted English to take just a small taste, to wait and see if there might be adverse effects . . . but 
considering their complete lack of supplies, his warning would have meant nothing. 
Barri moved forward, looking thirstily at the sandtrout and the slick fluid oozing from it. 
Suddenly English sat ramrod straight and dropped the protoplasmic creature to the packed ground. "It 
burns! But it sparkles like a thousand tiny explosions in my mouth." He touched his sternum. "In my 
chest, moving its way down!" He drew a long, gasping breath and stretched his arms out to both sides, 
straining as if he meant to pull his own fingers out of their sockets. 
"I can feel it all the way to my fingertips! Like land mines exploding energy to every one of my cells." He 
lunged to his feet and shuddered, then stared into a sky that was already growing restless from the on-
coming storm. "This is the spice, the heart of Duneworld! I can feel the sandworms." 
Jesse reached out to grab the man's arms. "William, take deep breaths. Control yourself. You're having an 
adverse-" 
Eyes wild, the spice foreman turned in a slow circle. "I can sense everything beneath us, and all around. 
The spice, the worms, sand 
plankton, and.. . more. Wonders we have never seen or imagined. Ah!" 
English struck Jesse, knocking him away, and dropped back to his knees. Like a madman, English 
grabbed the sandtrout carcass, plunged his face into the viscous moistness, slurped up more of the fluid, 
and began to laugh. When his eyes settled on Barri, he rushed over to the boy, yelling. "I'm alive! I can see 
the future and the past. But which is which?" 
Jesse pushed him away, standing between the wild man and his son. "Stay away. William-" 
"I can sail through the dunes, dive under them, tunnel deeper. Must protect the spice, the spores ..." 
He grabbed Jesse by the chest and leaned toward him, frantic. Blood leaked from his gums, staining his 
teeth. "Too much spice . . . but never enough spice. Must protect the spice! The sandworms. I am a 
sandworm!" 
Hemorrhages blossomed in the whites of the scarred man's eyes. Within seconds, English began weeping 
blood. Still raving, he touched his eyes, looked at his scarlet-stained fingertips. "The spice! The spice! It 
has us all trapped. We'll never break free." 
"Father, what's happening to him?" Barri cried. "We've got to help!" 
"There's no way to do that," Jesse said. "He's had too much spice, an overdose." 
English bolted into the steamy field of fumaroles. "Find the spice! Become one with the spice, one with 
the sandworms!" Screaming, he ran headlong-until the ground dropped from beneath him. The swirling 
mouth of a sand whirlpool. 
"William!" Jesse rushed forward, but stopped himself, realizing the danger of the treacherous ground. 
"William!" 



As the sand spun and sucked him down, English cried out with laughter and howled in delight. He seemed 
to want to be drawn underground-and the sand whirlpool obliged him. 
Barri started toward the foreman, but Jesse held him back. English's upraised, slime-slick hands vanished, 
leaving only the faint stirrings of the top powdery layer. 
"He's gone forever," Barri said. 
Jesse sank down next to his son. "Now it's just the two of us." 
After a long moment, Barri straightened his shoulders and clasped his father's hand. His voice was very 
small. "Just the two of us." 
14 
He is one with the sand. 
-DUNEWORLD FUNERAL LITANY 
Though she refused to accept defeat, Dorothy had performed her own calculations and projected the 
supplies that might have been aboard the ornijet, extrapolating how long anyone could have survived. 
Search party after search party returned without success. In a desert as large as a planet, a human being 
was no more significant than a grain of sand. Like a voracious predator, the endless wasteland had swal-
lowed Jesse, Barri, and English. 
In the convict-worker barracks in Carthage and the freedmen section of town, Gurney Halleck had tried to 
encourage the men, to maintain their morale. She admired his efforts, the way he sang inspiring songs, but 
lately the verses he had repeated for her sounded increasingly tragic. 
Freedmen sandminers, pulled from their work to continue the hopeless search, were beginning to grumble 
about lost bonuses. Dorothy couldn't blame them; for such men, bonuses were their only hope of earning 
passage off of Duneworld. The convict laborers did not want to be taken from the spice harvesters, either, 
fearing they would be sent back to even worse penal worlds such as Salusa or Eridanus V. And nobody 
looked forward to having the Hoskanners return.. . . 
"Their ornijet could have crashed in the storm," General Tuek said, as he met with her in her office on the 
third level of the headquarters mansion. He stood with his hands on the back of a chair. "But it could just 
as easily have been sabotage. Anyone who knew the nobleman was out at the forward base could have laid 
a trap for him when he returned." 
"Many people knew of the expedition, General." She stood near the window, with her arms folded across 
her chest. Something about this man always grated on her. 
"You knew about it, madam. Any observer on the landing field could feel the friction between you and the 
nobleman as he left. What exactly was the nature of your disagreement?" 
Red anger flashed through her eyes, burning through her grief and hopelessness. "Any personal 
discussions between Jesse and myself are exactly that-personal! How dare you even imply that I might 
have had something to do with their disappearance." 
"It is my duty as security chief to suspect everyone, especially those who might benefit. You are the legal 
proxy for House Linkam. In my opinion, the nobleman has given a commoner altogether too much control 
over his finances and business." 
Dorothy was so disoriented by the accusation that it took her a moment to grasp onto a thread of logic. 
"Leaving aside the fact that Barri is my own son-" She drew a breath, forced ice into her words. "If 
House Linkam is dissolved, then I would lose everything. I would be a fool to place Jesse's life at risk." 
"You are no fool, madam. In fact, you would be smart enough to divert a great amount of Linkam wealth 
into secret accounts of your own." The veteran's red-stained lips were set in a grim line, showing no 
compassion. 
She placed her hands on her hips so that she wouldn't try to throttle him. "That is quite enough, General-
especially from a man who has implied he believes we should give up the search." 
"I made no such suggestion." He stiffened defensively, stood at attention, with his arms at his sides. "I 
have served House Linkam for far longer than you have known Jesse, madam. I have already seen two no-
blemen die. If we abandon the search, then House Linkam dies and the Hoskanners have already won." 
His red-stained lips twitched. "However, if we cease all spice production, then that is also true. I merely 
implied that we should consider sending some of the teams back to work. Each day, we lose more ground 



against the Hoskanners." 
Dorothy stared at him coolly, then asked herself the fundamental question: What would Jesse want her to 
do? Even in this terrible situation, he would expect her to hold on to hope longer than anyone else, but he 
also trusted her to manage the noble household, to be his proxy in business matters, and to keep his future 
safe for Barri. She knew exactly what Jesse's answer would be. 
Speaking in a voice that allowed no disagreement, Dorothy said, "Continue the search, General, but assign 
a temporary spice foreman to oversee harvesting operations in the absence of William English. Get our 
crews out on the sands again, as soon as possible." 
AS THE STORM neared, Jesse settled his son against the shelter of the dune wall where the hard sands 
were crusted with chemical residue from underground volcanic vents. 
Wearily, Jesse trudged to the top of the highest dune and saw a 
smothering curtain of dust billowing ominously toward them. The whistling wind picked up, flinging 
needle-sharp sand grains against his cheeks. His clogged face mask no longer worked well, and neither did 
Barri's. Both of them also had rips in their bodysuits, reducing the effectiveness of the conservation 
mechanisms. And they had no water left, not even a drop. 
Jesse slid back down the slope and unpacked a reflective blanket. After testing the wind, he found the best 
place to sit in the lee of the dunes where they might ride out the oncoming storm. They huddled together 
with the blanket wrapped around them, listening to the sifting sand and dust. Jesse remembered all too 
well how English's face had been scarred by the abrasive winds, how other men had been scoured to 
skeletons. Their chances of surviving the night were vanishingly small. 
Like a living thing, the wind swirled around the fumarole field, lashing the sulfurous vapors in all 
directions. A thickening layer of sand covered their blanket, muffling the fearsome sounds; intermittently, 
Jesse tried to shake it off so they wouldn't suffocate. 
In the middle of the long night, the winds began to die down, and the storm noises grew distant. By 
morning, amazed to be alive, Jesse and Barri worked together to lift the sand-weighted blanket. After 
shaking off the sand and wiping powder from their eyes, they looked around. Only the edge of the storm 
had touched the fumarole field before it had swerved, leaving them unscathed. 
Jesse hugged his son. "A miracle, my boy!" His throat was so dry he could barely speak, and his words 
emerged as a rough croak. "We survived one more day." 
Barri's lips were parched and cracked, and his voice was no better than his father's. "Maybe we should just 
pick a direction and follow it." 
Thirst burned like an ember in Jesse's mouth. "We'll keep going today and tomorrow ... as long as it takes. 
Our chances aren't good, but if we give up, there's no hope at all." 
The fumaroles coughed like a choking man clearing his throat. Gases continued to percolate out of the 
sand whirlpool that had swallowed the delirious William English. 
After giving the boy strict instructions not to wander off, Jesse slogged through loose sand at the bottom 
of the depression, then climbed the other side of the towering rise. In the early light of day, perhaps he 
would see a landmark ... or a fleet of rescue ships coming across the ocean of dunes. 
When he reached the high ridge on top, Jesse shuffled ahead, his feet sinking in. Unexpectedly, his boot 
snagged on something buried beneath the surface. He tripped and fell forward. 
Jesse rolled over, brushing himself off, wiping his face. He dug with his hands and extricated a bent white 
polymer rod. Loosened, the thin flexible staff sprang erect again: one of the many weather poles that 
sandminers had installed in the open desert to keep track of localized storms. 
Casting his gaze right and left, Jesse moved off several paces until he found a second bent weather pole, 
which he freed. He wagged the whiplike rods, saw that they were unscathed even by being forced to the 
ground and buried under the sand. He drew a deep breath of flinty air, accepting the symbolism as an 
omen: A survivor stays alive only by bending with the blows. Be flexible. Bend against the unstoppable force and 
then spring back when it has passed. 
Barri came running up. "Are you all right? What did you find?" 
He turned to his son. "These are data-collection devices for the weather satellites. Help me clear them 
out." 



Scooping sand, Jesse dug to the root of the pole. When he found its instrument package, he smiled for the 
first time in days. "And each one has a transmitter uplinked to the weather satellites! Dr. Haynes was 
tinkering with the satellite network. If he's got it functional again, and if we can modify these pulses ..." 
Barri understood. The two of them found six poles in a line. They 
removed each one from where it was embedded and took the devices back into the depression where they 
were protected from the winds. Jesse used a small multitool from his pack to dismantle the housings and 
access the tiny, hardened circuitry. 
"If we get all six of these in phase, we can send a strong and regular pulse-not a complex code or a voice 
message, but if anyone is watching from the base, they should see the blip. . . ." 
Most people might have given them up for dead already, but he doubted Dorothy would ever surrender 
hope. 
By midday they had all the weather poles silently thrumming, sending out a modulated electronic signal, a 
repeating pattern that could not be missed. Gathering the blanket again to shelter them from the day's heat 
and to present a visible, reflective target, he held Barri. "Now it's only a matter of time. I hope." 
15 
At the bleakest, blackest hour of night, the dawn appears, washing away the darkness.  
- A SAYING OF THE DEEP DESERT 
Dorothy occupied herself with work. It was well past the dinner 
hour, but she had told the servants not to prepare anything for 
her to eat. The mansion seemed vast and empty, populated by echoes. 
The Catalan workers were already asking persistent questions, many of 
them believing that the nobleman and his son would never be found. 
Jesse had made her the legal proxy for House Linkam, but had never married her. Without him, she had no 
continuing status, and her decisions would no longer be binding. Once, in private, Jesse had told her, "You 
are far more than a concubine to me, more even than a traditional wife. A noblewoman could never 
replace you in my heart. You are the mother of my son, who is the heir to House Linkam. You are the 
inspiration for my soul." No vapid daughter of a decadent blue-blood family could take that away from 
her. 
But that was no solace at all if Jesse and Barri were lost. Her soul ached for them, and despair welled up 
within her. It had been much too long. 
In her distress, she did not at first hear the shouts from the main entry hall. "Dorothy Mapes! Where are 
you?" It was Gurney Halleck's voice, bellowing for her. "I have fantastic news!" 
Her heart racing, Dorothy took two stairs at a time and bounded down to the closest landing. She came 
upon the startled jongleur so unexpectedly that he half drew the sonic dagger from on his hip. Recognizing 
the petite woman, he let the blade slide back into its sheath. "The satellites detected a signal out in the 
desert! It repeats without message content, but it's a clear pulse that shouldn't be there." 
"It has to be Jesse!" 
"It's certainly somebody," Gurney said. "But there were three people on the downed ornijet. No telling if 
everyone is still alive." 
"Then what are we waiting for? Take me there-" 
"There's nothing you can do right now. General Tuek has already dispatched a rescue craft. We should 
know more within the hour." 
An irrepressible geyser of hope sprang up inside her, and Dorothy hugged the jongleur so furiously that he 
grew red in the face. 
A SQUADRON OF dusty rescue ships returned at sunset to the spaceport landing zone nearest to the 
headquarters mansion. A violent calamity of color spilled across the sky, then streamed away into dark-
ness. 
Dorothy could hardly contain herself as she waited with Gurney and Dr. Yueh. Excited, she watched one 
vessel after another as they set down, flapping their articulated wings and stabilizing their landing gear. 
Finally, the last vessel touched down in a noisy rush of jets, creating a gritty cloud. When the air cleared, 
an entry hatch opened, and a 



rough-faced, red-eyed man appeared in the doorway. At first she didn't recognize him until she noted the 
familiar, though unsteady, way he moved. Details, beloved details! The gray eyes were familiar, but he 
looked so tired, so much older. Finally, the boy appeared behind him. 
She ran forward. "I thought I'd never see you again!" Dorothy hugged them and kissed their dusty faces 
repeatedly.                 , 
With a chafed hand, Jesse wiped her cheeks, smearing her tear tracks into mud. "My darling, we're making 
a mess of you." 
Old Dr. Yueh gave the two haggard survivors a quick once-over, checking their eyes, taking their pulses. 
"Good, good. Oh, I'll give you both full examinations later, after you clean up." He grinned. "It'll waste a 
lot of water just getting those layers of dirt off you." 
"I don't care," Jesse said. "For once in this hellhole, I'm going to wallow in a bath." 
"Me, too," Barri said. "I want to stay home forever." 
Dorothy listened with sadness as they told her what had happened to William English. Such a tragedy. 
Still, as she looked at her family she shuddered with relief. Jesse had exposed their son to unimaginable 
danger against her clear wishes, but he had also saved himself and Barri from almost certain death. 
Dorothy was still angry with him, but if his own ordeal hadn't given him a healthy respect for the risks on 
Duneworld, nothing she could say would make a difference. The only way they could all survive this 
challenge was to stick together. 
Arm in arm, they walked toward the headquarters mansion profiled against the abrupt desert sunset. 
PART TWO 
SECOND YEAR ON DUNEWORLD
                                                                  
16 
The only way to be truly safe is to view everyone as a potential enemy. 
- GENERAL ESMAR TUEK, Security Briefings 
Throughout their first year, Linkam operations suffered frequent equipment damage, the "accidental" 
destruction of supplies and tools, delayed deliveries of new harvesters and carryalls, and overt sabotage. 
Jesse had no doubt that Carthage was crawling with Hoskanner spies, despite the best efforts of his 
security chief to ferret them out. 
To guard against potential attacks, another contingent of highly trained fighters from the Catalan home 
guard had arrived. General Tuek had redoubled his troops around the mansion, posting sentries and 
infiltrating new workers into the ranks of freedmen and convicts. 
Despite their dedicated, backbreaking efforts, Linkam spice production remained pitifully low, barely a 
third of previous Hoskanner tallies, as they knew from the secret information William English had 
provided. To make matters worse, the sandminers were increasingly hostile and insubordinate, because 
reduced production meant fewer credits and dwindling hopes that they would ever leave Duneworld, de-
spite Jesse's promises. 
Awaiting the end of the challenge period on Gediprime, Valdemar must be laughing to himself. ... 
When a nearby storm brought enough dust to obscure visibility and prevent flights to the spice fields, 
Jesse quietly gathered his closest advisors in a small shielded conference room with no windows and only 
one narrow door. After Tuek had scanned for listening devices and covert spy imagers, he declared the 
room clean. 
It was time for them to talk. 
Jesse sat down and folded his hands on top of the table. His grim, gray eyes scanned the faces of Dorothy 
and Tuek sitting at opposite sides of the table, as well as Gurney Halleck, who had taken over as spice 
foreman after the tragic death of William English. Before Jesse could begin, Dr. Haynes hurried into the 
room, having just flown up from the forward research base, one step ahead of the storm. "I apologize for 
my lateness." 
Since Jesse's ordeal in the desert, and his demonstrated resolve to survive, the planetary ecologist had 
become a surprising ally. Haynes made it clear that he respected Nobleman Linkam much more than he 
had the Hoskanners, though technically the Emperor's scientist was supposed to remain neutral. 



Jesse, though, could not afford to allow mixed loyalties. He had to lay everything on the line. "If we are 
destined to lose, we will lose. But I will never give up and make it easy for them." 
"The Hoskanners keep cutting our feet out from under us," Tuek said. "Sweet affection, what underhanded 
tricks! They know exactly how to hamstring our operations. However, with the new soldiers from Catalan, 
I can post extra guards on every operation. Round-the-clock surveillance of our most important 
equipment. I intend to eliminate sabotage completely." 
"Even protecting our equipment won't be enough," Jesse said. "We simply don't have the production 
capacity to meet the goal." 
Though she was normally quiet in these meetings, Dorothy pointed out, "For eighteen years the 
Hoskanners had unlimited resources and manpower. They could afford to replace expensive spice 
harvesters as fast as the worms and storms destroyed them." She shook her head sadly. "Even if half of our 
equipment orders hadn't been delayed or caught up in inexplicable bureaucracy, House Linkam still 
doesn't have the capital to keep up with that." 
"We barely have half as many spice harvesters as we need," Jesse said. "One of the new-model units is 
due to be delivered from an alternative source on Richese, but it had to go through indirect channels." 
"That harvester is a month late," Dorothy said, "but I'm assured we'll get it, just like those delayed Ixian 
deliveries. You can bet the Hoskanners had a hand in it. They just want to stall us, claiming we have 
'credit problems.'" 
"Curse the Emperor and his refusal to impose rules!" Gurney said. "If he wants the spice so badly, why 
doesn't he intervene?" 
Jesse grimaced. "The nobles want it as well, but most of our 'friends' haven't come through as they 
promised." 
Only three families, poor enough that they were willing to take a chance on a long shot, had offered to 
help with funding, but they could spare little; Jesse deeply appreciated their gestures, though the financing 
hadn't helped much. Four other nobles had taken advantage of the desperate Linkam situation, offering 
loans at crippling interest rates; Jesse feared he would have to accept their terms, unless he found some 
other way through the crisis. 
And he still had another year left. 
Dr. Haynes scratched his beard. "The scavenged live-rubber shielding has helped." 
Jesse agreed. "Almost a year ago, we applied it to our harvesters- and that alone kept our machinery 
working much longer than expected. Thus, we were able to put more crews out in the desert, and 
bring back more melange. A step in the right direction, but not enough. Not nearly enough. We'll lose, 
unless something changes. For a year we've been following the techniques the Hoskanners used, but it's 
getting us nowhere. We need to think bigger." 
Dorothy rested her chin in her hands, her brow furrowed in concentration. "We've already tried so many 
things, Jesse."                   
"But we haven't tried the right thing. There's got to be something else, an unexpected approach." 
Over the months, following advice by the planetary ecologist or the suggestions of Gurney Halleck and 
Esmar Tuek, the Linkam operations had tried everything from explosives and energy bursts to poisons in 
the sands. Nothing worked. They had grounded static-shield generators to protect a boundary, but the 
fields drove the worms into a frenzy. They used pheromones, chemical signatures, various potent scents to 
deter the worms from the work perimeter, but the creatures did not respond; as near as Dr. Haynes could 
tell, the monsters were asexual. 
Jesse steepled his fingertips. "The Hoskanner method of spice harvesting is not necessarily the most 
efficient technique. At a spice field, at least seventy percent of the time is involved in deploying harvesters 
and in evacuating the site. With blitzkrieg mining, we strike and then flee at the first sign of a worm. If we 
could only extend our time on the ground before a worm comes, every moment we keep digging would 
greatly increase our haul." 
"Aye, we're like inept thieves robbing a treasure vault," Gurney said. "Give me five hours on a rich vein, 
and I'll provide a month's worth of melange! My sandminers would work themselves to death if they had 
an opportunity like that." 



"We have found no way to kill the worms," Jesse said. "We've tried everything." 
Tuek stared straight at the nobleman. "Not quite. We didn't try our atomics." 
Dorothy bridled. "There could be serious political repercussions. Some of the powerful Houses are 
pushing for prohibitions against atomics." 
Tuek contradicted her, "But there are no prohibitions yet-and we do have our own arsenal. As a worm 
approaches, we could launch a small-yield atomic warhead." 
"I'd like to try that out," Gurney said. "Get revenge for some of the miners we've lost." 
Dr. Haynes lurched to his feet and turned to Jesse, who had never seen such vehemence from the planetary 
ecologist. "Nobleman Linkam, you must not consider such a thing! Even if you killed the worm, you 
would contaminate the spice fields and gain nothing. Melange is extremely susceptible to radiation. 
Coriolis storms would disperse the fallout all over the planet." 
"But there must be a way, Dr. Haynes," Jesse said, wrestling with his frustration. "If we can't kill the 
worms, and we can't drive them away with shields or deterrent chemicals, what can we do?" He stared at 
the planetary ecologist. "Would it be possible to ... stun them? At least long enough for our crews to make 
a big haul?" 
Haynes caught his breath, and his lips formed a thin smile. "We need to use a different paradigm. And that 
certainly opens up new avenues of thought." The ruddy-faced man composed himself, as if preparing for a 
lecture. "With their obvious size and power, the worms are very territorial. We think magnetite grains 
react with an electrostatic field generated by the worm's body as it moves through the sands, either 
through friction or from some organ deep inside the creature's body. The larger the worm, the stronger the 
repelling field it generates-and the greater the territory it claims." 
"We have generators of our own," Jesse said. "Could we tune them to a similar frequency? Stake out our 
own territory and broadcast a boundary so the worm thinks we're a greater rival, making it afraid to 
approach?" 
"We'd have to cover a huge area," Gurney said immediately. "Even with live-rubber shielding, ground-
based fields and storm static still short out our equipment. We could never hold a large enough perimeter." 
Haynes continued his preoccupied, mysterious smile. "If the environment precludes us from countering 
those fields externally, perhaps we could attack from inside the worm and short out its internal dynamo." 
Feverishly, the planetary ecologist began sketching on his portable datascreen. "Imagine a shielded drum-
sized generator with insulated antennae sticking out, and discharge tips to deliver a short, intense shock." 
"Like a depth charge?" Tuek said. "Get the worm to swallow it, then trigger the field?" 
"Precisely! Each worm segment has an independent neurological system chained into the overall whole. 
Thus, we would have to short out each segment. As the worm swallows the charge, the antennae would 
deliver repeated bursts all the way down." 
"Aye, that would kill the leviathan!" Gurney said. 
Grinning, Jesse said, "Even if it only puts the worm out of commission for a while, instead of killing it, 
our harvester crews would have a much longer period to excavate spice." 
He looked at Dorothy, seeing the excitement in her eyes, but also a reluctance. She cautioned, "Dr. 
Haynes, we know you technically work for the Grand Emperor. House Linkam has few funds to divert to 
your project." 
Jesse leaned closer to the scientist. "How much will it cost, Dr. Haynes?" 
The planetary ecologist chuckled. "Don't worry, Nobleman. I will have all the equipment and technical 
assistance I require. Developing a potential new tool for spice harvesting clearly falls within the purview 
of my assignment, even though the Grand Emperor has no real interest in my experiments. However, even 
if I give this concept priority, remember that it is a long march from an idea to a functional prototype." 
"Then we'd best get started." Jesse looked from his advisors to the sealed door of the conference room, 
and stood up. 
Tuek continued to frown. "I would suggest that we keep this line of 
investigation confidential. We have enough trouble with Hoskanner spies and saboteurs, and if they learn 
of a new concept, they will be sure to cause trouble." 
"Even to the Imperial planetary ecologist?" Gurney sounded surprised. 



Haynes nodded. "The Emperor and the Hoskanners will do whatever they want. I am not so bold to think 
that my supposed importance will give them a moment's pause. I hate to say this, but I do not always trust 
the Emperor's motivations." 
Dorothy said, "I'm inclined to agree with General Tuek. We don't dare let the Hoskanners discover what 
we're doing. We've got to let them believe we're hopeless and continuing to flounder." She gave a sly 
smile. "If they're convinced they've already won, they won't try so hard to defeat us." 
17 
Time may wear a benign mask, but it is always the faceless enemy, the destroyer of hopes and dreams. 
-THE PROPHET OF CARTHAGE 
After more than a year, Jesse had finally begun to develop a "typical day" on hostile Duneworld. Early in 
the morning, he donned his sealed bodysuit and desert cloak, and went down to the main dining hall where 
Dorothy and Barri were already waiting for him. 
Servants scurried into action, bringing breakfasts covered with clearplaz to prevent the escape not only of 
heat, but of precious moisture. Developed and marketed by a local entrepreneur, the sophisticated 
plazware was designed to minimize even the faintest wisps of water loss. When the diner moved his eating 
utensil toward the plate, the cover slid back just long enough for a bite, then snapped shut. Dorothy had 
adopted these devices to show that the Linkams understood the value of moisture, that they were not a 
profligate noble family like the Hoskanners. 
Through the plaz lid over the plate, Jesse saw a steaming blue omelet of imported Catalanian eggs 
prepared with desert peppers, boar bacon, and llantro roots. It was one of his favorite meals. Jesse took a 
sip of spice coffee, hardly noticing the cinnamon taste of melange. Now that they consumed spice daily, 
he paid scant attention to it. Strange. On Catalan he had rarely indulged in the substance, and now he 
couldn't imagine a meal without it. Melange had become as much a part of life on Duneworld as the air 
and sand. 
Outside, he heard a large engine. Ornijets and transports were always coming and going at Carthage's 
separate landing zones, but this engine sounded much louder. A massive roar filled the skies of the 
mountain city. 
Barri ran to one of the windows. "That's the Emperor's symbol!" 
With an uneasy groan, Jesse went to see a hulking and intimidating interstellar craft descending over the 
company town, one of the largest vessels capable of landing on a planetary surface. An Imperial inspec-
tion ship, fully armed and threatening. 
No, he realized-this would not be a typical day after all. 
WITH LINKAM FINANCES excruciatingly tight, Dorothy authorized no lavish decorations and shut down 
portions of the mansion. If the Grand Emperor's man had expected to be received in a sumptuous hall, he 
was sorely disappointed. 
Counselor Ulla Bauers twitched his rabbitlike nose and looked around the headquarters building with an 
irritated expression, thus implying that he had more important things to do and wanted to be on his way. A 
precise man with front-parlor habits from another age, he wore a carmine-and-gold high-collared robe that 
would have been the envy of any nobleman. On Duneworld, he looked entirely out of place. 
"Hmmm. By Imperial permission, House Linkam has presided over spice operations for a year now," 
Bauers said in an erudite tone, "but 
your melange exports have been, ahh, seriously below expectations." He narrowed his eyes dangerously. 
"I am afraid, Nobleman Linkam, that you are an embarrassment to the Emperor." 
Suppressing his anger, Jesse explained, "The Hoskanners left us with inferior equipment. Much of the new 
machinery I ordered-and paid for-was either defective upon delivery, or delayed by bureaucratic 
schemes. We have filed a dispute against the Ixian suppliers in Imperial commercial court, but a decision 
will not be reached until after the challenge is ended." He forced a thin smile, trying not to glare at the 
overdressed man. "Still, I do have another year to go and no time to lose. I appreciate the Grand Emperor's 
interest, but we have work to do." 
"Hmm-ahh, perhaps you missed certain nuances in the original challenge agreement, Nobleman? Such 
details are among my specialties." Bauers cleared his throat-not a cough, but a confined disturbance of 



the larynx. "If the Grand Emperor so directs, he can rescind the challenge at any moment and give 
Duneworld back to House Hoskanner." 
Jesse stiffened. "The Grand Emperor explicitly said there would be no rules." 
"Ahh, but the agreement also stated, and I quote, 'This contract shall be subject to Imperial law.'" He 
offered Jesse a disdainful smirk. "That can mean anything the Emperor decides." 
Simmering, Jesse said, "Why would he toy with us in such a way? The Nobles' Council will be outraged if 
you strip away the challenge without giving me a fair chance." 
"It is simple, Nobleman Linkam. The people demand melange, and you haven't shipped enough. We never 
anticipated that you would fail so miserably. It is inconceivable!" He frowned. "Hmmm, or are you hiding 
portions of your output? Hoarding melange for black-market suppliers? Your trickle of exports to 
Renaissance cannot possibly be your entire production. Where are your secret spice warehouses?" 
Jesse chuckled. "We keep barely enough for household use." 
The ferretlike man arched his eyebrows. "Word has reached me that your freedmen and convict workers 
are extremely unhappy. Low production and exports mean paltry bonuses for them. Under Hoskanner 
administration, many of them would have saved enough to go home already. I am informed that Carthage 
is a tinderbox, and a riot could flare up at any moment. Is this true?" 
"Exaggerations spread by a few remaining Hoskanner loyalists," Jesse said dismissively. "A handful of 
loudmouths have been arrested, most of them convicts with years left on their work sentences. We have 
the situation completely under control." 
"Umm-ahh, when the Hoskanners were here, they faced difficulties, too, but spice flowed like a river. 
They developed a market all across the Empire, and now the shortage is being felt, as offworld spice 
stockpiles are depleted. Prices are at record levels." 
"Then the nobles will have to tighten their belts and do without the luxury, or pay more for it. The 
Emperor gets his cut, so he should be happy." Jesse's gray eyes looked like sharp ice chips. "Counselor 
Bauers, I was never asked to provide any sort of progress reports. In the meantime, my rate of production 
is my own concern. The only number that matters is the total I deliver at the end of the challenge. If I am 
to fail, then you can declare my defeat at the end of two years-not a moment before." 
"Hmm-ahh. Remember the fine print, Linkam." 
"There is more to an agreement than fine print, sir, and more to justice than words. We have clear 
evidence of Hoskanner meddling throughout the past year. If the Emperor is so anxious for his spice, then 
he should not have allowed my enemies to hamstring me." 
Hearing the approach of boots, Jesse saw Esmar Tuek appear in the doorway. "Excuse me, My Lord. May 
I speak with you privately?" 
"Counselor Bauers was just about to go and order his inspection ship to withdraw to a convenient 
distance," Jesse said. "He doesn't want to block our spice export vessels." 
Bauers said with a sniff, "On the contrary, I, and my ship, will depart 
only at a time of my choosing. For now, the vessel remains precisely where it is." 
Coolly, Tuek nodded. "Very well then, Counselor, my information concerns you as well. My men have 
scanned the identities of your crewmen who are milling about at the main spaceport landing fields. Are 
you aware that your ship carries known Hoskanner agents who were evicted from Duneworld a year ago?"     
Bauers seemed genuinely surprised. "What?" 
"Your specialty may be fine print, but General Tuek's is security," Jesse said with a cautious smile. "He is 
never mistaken about such matters." 
"Ahh, I certainly had no idea any of my crew had ever been to this planet before." 
"The Hoskanners undoubtedly fooled you, too," Jesse said, "though you do not look like a man who is 
easily hoodwinked." 
Standing stiffly in his dusty uniform, Tuek added, "Due to the obvious security threat, Counselor, we must 
insist that your crew remain within the confines of the landing zone for the duration of your stay here. I 
will assign a cordon of our security troops to assist you in this matter. No member of your crew is to set 
foot in Carthage or mingle with either the convict workers or freedmen." 
Jesse smiled thinly. "You, of course, are welcome to come and go as you please, Counselor Bauers." 



"I know nothing of Hoskanner agents." The persnickety man sniffed. "The Grand Emperor has sent me 
here to inform you that the spice must flow. If you do not show dramatic progress soon . . . hmm, he is not 
a patient man." 
18 
History has shown that if a noble goes soft, it will be his undoing. To avoid this calamity, he must always maintain an emotional distance from the 
people around him. 
- GRAND EMPEROR CHAM EYVOK III (THE WARLORD EMPEROR) 
 With Linkam spice production drastically reduced, the hopes of the sandminers had plummeted along with 
their income. Despite harsh working conditions under the stern Hoskanners, at least back then some of the 
men had eventually earned enough credits to buy their way off of Duneworld. Now the freedmen were 
angry with the downturn in the economy, and the convicts saw no chance for going home when they 
finished their sentences, despite Jesse's promises. 
Having little discretionary income, the sandminers could not spend money in the shops and saloons of 
Carthage, and so the businessmen, water merchants, and wrung-out pleasure women fell on hard times. 
Even the Catalan staff missed their ocean world. They stared at the empty desert skies and longed for 
rainfall instead of dust. 
House Linkam generated enough capital to keep operating, if just 
barely, from their meager spice exports, augmented by hard-fought contributions from a handful of noble 
families. In his precarious financial situation, Jesse had been forced to impose austerity measures in the 
mansion and in Carthage, thus making life even more difficult for the workers. 
He lost much sleep, feeling their misery and discontent, and he wished he had the means to improve their 
lives. Back on Catalan he had been in touch with his people, and they had loved him. He'd been a good 
leader, caring for their needs, listening to their problems. But here . . . 
Meeting with Dorothy, he discussed many alternatives to ease the burden on the people, but without any 
financial cushion whatsoever, he had his hands tied. Though it made administration more difficult, he 
instituted tax relief, forcing his own Catalan staff to work with their salaries postponed. On Dorothy's 
suggestion, he distributed some of the old stored luxury clothes and trinkets the Hoskanners had left be-
hind, but these superficial items helped little and only served to point out how drab and hard their lives 
were on Duneworld. The hard-bitten sandminers and townspeople whispered among themselves about 
Linkam management, asserting that the nobleman's ineptitude was stealing their future. 
Out in the desert, every piece of functional harvesting equipment was in use, protected by live-rubber 
shielding. Extra teams worked without rest in the repair bays to put the spice harvesters and carryalls back 
into service with all due speed. 
Some sandminers had received unrequested furloughs, laid off because there simply wasn't enough 
functional equipment to put them to work. Left to themselves, bored, restless, and angry, the men 
continued to grumble, blaming all their troubles on House Linkam. The convicts especially, espousing the 
increasingly radical teachings of the prison-offshoot Zensunni religion, demanded that Jesse return 
melange operations to the Hoskanners, "who knew what they were doing." 
When thirty-four penal laborers refused to work on their assigned 
harvester teams, Jesse angrily voided their contracts and sent them back to Eridanus V. Meanwhile, the 
Imperial inspection ship continued to loom over Carthage. He knew Ulla Bauers was watching everything. 
. . . 
UNDER A HOT and hazy noon sky, Jesse strode through an open marketplace in the center of town. In an 
effort to disguise himself, he wore the dirty desert cloak of a sandminer, and few people gave him a 
second glance. As the nobleman of Duneworld, he had been wanting to get out and see some of the 
common people in their day-to-day activities, instead of viewing them from groundvans or low-flying air-
craft. Two plainclothed guards accompanied him in similar attire, though he knew Tuek was behind them 
somewhere with a larger force, ever conscious of security. 
In the crowded bazaar, shopkeepers and vendors shouted for customers to notice their wares. Incense 
sellers and purveyors of exotic scents wafted small samples of sweet or pungent smoke, which caught the 



attention of passersby with the enticingly different smells, unlike the more common odor of melange 
throughout the rest of Carthage. 
Behind a thin wire barrier, two old women sat next to dozens of small gray rock pheasants, which they had 
raised in pens. The women had the birds' heads tucked under their wings and tied in place, forcing them to 
sleep. The desert birds, native to other arid planets, had originally been brought here by the Hoskanners, 
one of their better decisions. The pheasants drank very little precious water, and their tender flesh was 
highly prized (and expensive) on Duneworld. Few spice-miners could afford the delicacy, though they 
much preferred the fare to bland company rations. When a customer agreed on the price, one of the old 
women would snap the necks of the chosen birds and hand over the fresh meat in spice-fiber sacks. 
As Jesse was about to leave, he saw one of his guards talking into a 
lapel microphone. The man, who had a sharp chin and small, dark eyes, took Jesse aside, and said to him, 
"My Lord, a spontaneous rally is taking place on the other side of town, led by a freedman. He is calling 
for House Linkam to leave the planet." 
Outside the market, Jesse met with General Tuek. "I'm going over there," the nobleman announced. "I've 
been frustrated with the need to speak on my own behalf, and this is my chance." 
"I advise against it, My Lord." 
"Somehow, that doesn't surprise me." Jesse's eyes twinkled. In a firm voice, he said he wanted to face the 
demonstrators, talk with them, and let them know that he heard their grievances and would do whatever he 
could. 
"The crowd is in an ugly mood," Tuek said. 
"Then it's even more important for me to speak with them." Jesse lifted his chin stubbornly. 
"I expected as much," the old security chief said. "I've already sent for forty of our best guards to go with 
you." 
ACCOMPANIED BY THE guards, Jesse headed for a fleet of ground-vans parked in full view of the towering 
Imperial inspection ship. The unwelcome vessel remained where it had landed a week before, dominating 
the main spaceport, so that many smaller vessels had to use secondary fields. He wondered if secret 
Hoskanner agents had somehow incited the minor uprising from behind their barricades. Were they 
waiting to enjoy his reaction? 
From behind the cordon, Ulla Bauers and the other men noticed Jesse, but he ignored them. He took the 
van's controls himself, letting Tuek's guards find seats or scramble aboard a second vehicle. He roared off 
in a cloud of Duneworld's ever-present dust and steered along the steep roads to where milling, angry 
people had gathered. When he disembarked and strode forward, his phalanx of security men formed a 
protective wedge to clear a way through the throng. Men in desert bodysuits and women in long robes 
moved aside, whispering in surprise when they recognized the noble visitor, who now wore the formal 
cloak of his rank. 
With his mind spinning and questing for alternatives, trying to determine what he might say to them, Jesse 
approached the steps of a large prefab meeting house. A weathered old man stood there shouting, "-
better under the Hoskanners!" Jesse recognized him immediately: Pari Hoyuq, the competent captain of a 
spice harvester that had recently been damaged and remained out of service. Too much time on his hands, 
Jesse thought. Gurney could have handled this in private, if he'd had a chance.  
Seeing him, Hoyuq's face lit up with intense indignation. "You, Nobleman! Are you going to send more of 
us back to prison planets?" 
Jesse kept walking, forcing himself to remain calm and reasonable. "Are you intending to break your 
contract, Pari? Like those other men who refused to work in the spice fields?" He climbed the steps to be 
at the same level as the old sandminer. Alert to danger, Tuek's Catalan security men hurried to protect 
him, using the vantage to scan the crowd for threats. 
Hoyuq said, "I would never refuse work-if work were available! Too many of us have no chance to earn 
any bonuses. No chance at all. I am a freedman. I served my sentence, got my release." He tapped the 
chevron tattoo on his forehead. "We all want to leave this place, but you Linkams have made that 
impossible!" 
Jesse kept his eyes on the old sandminer, as if this were a private conversation between the two of them. "I 



already promised you, and all freedmen, that I would pay your passage home-if we win the contest." 
Instead of cheers, the reminder evoked only groans and grumbles. The man scowled and leaned closer 
with his leathery face. "Ha! Nobleman, there's a greater chance of rain falling from the sky! You gave us 
hope with your empty promise, and we worked hard. We believed you, and for what? You cannot win the 
challenge, so your promise is empty." 
Jesse felt as if a hot knife had plunged into his chest, and he knew how hopeless the situation must seem to 
these people. In the head-quarters mansion, even he and Dorothy could see the numbers and know that it 
would require a miracle for them to surge ahead of their rivals. Still, he squared his shoulders. "I have not 
given up, Pari. And neither should you." He turned to face the crowd at last. "Not any of you." 
From below, several people shouted. "Life was better under the Hoskanners!" 
"No spice, no work, no bonuses-no reason to be here!"  
"These days, even Eridanus V isn't as bad as the mess you've turned Duneworld into." 
"We want the Hoskanners back." 
Stiffening, Jesse took a breath to quell his outburst. Then he said, "Ah yes, the Hoskanners. Perhaps you 
should look more closely at your troubles and turn your anger toward the proper target." He narrowed his 
eyes. "Wasn't it the Hoskanners who ruined our weather satellites, putting sandminers in danger? Wasn't it 
Hoskanner spies who sabotaged equipment so that you can't go out to work the spice veins? Wasn't it the 
Hoskanners who bribed offplanet manufacturers to prevent or delay the delivery of vital machinery? 
Wasn't it the Hoskanners who diverted water shipments so that prices climbed higher and higher?" He 
jabbed a finger at them. "Their only goal is to make House Linkam look weak. I'm asking you for fairness, 
for common decency. Give me a chance to make your lives better." 
Old Hoyuq clung stubbornly to his anger. "Then make our lives better, Nobleman. You cast blame easily, 
but if you want us to believe in a conspiracy against you, prove that you are better than the Hoskanners. 
Show us with your actions." 
Jesse's mind raced, searching for something immediate. He and Dorothy had discussed many possibilities, 
all of which they had deemed too extravagant or too risky. Right now, though, he did not have the luxury 
of studying House Linkam's resources, its ledgers. He had to do something before a riot broke out. 
Jesse folded his arms across his chest. "Very well. In difficult times, we all ration, we all pull together, and 
we all share discomfort. Beginning tomorrow morning, I will distribute the water reserves from my own 
family holdings. Anyone who comes to my home will receive an extra share, until our supplies run out. 
Henceforth, my daily ration will be the same as yours." At the murmurs of disbelief, his gray-eyed gaze 
darted from face to face. "I know your money is tight. Therefore, I am also fixing water prices at the level 
they were when House Linkam came to Duneworld. I will issue a decree to the water merchants." 
As he heard the amazed cheers, he knew he had temporarily dodged the worst unrest. The solution could 
not last, and it might damage the economy of Carthage, but he could not afford to worry about such 
matters. He had to keep his operations going, one day at a time. 
THE WATER SELLERS and importers expressed their outrage at Jesse's price controls by declaring a strike. 
Shipments had been delayed, their own supplies limited, and they had felt perfectly justified in raising 
prices as high as the city could bear. The greedy businessmen shut down all operations, locked their doors, 
and refused to sell water at the low prices House Linkam had set. Several plump and disgruntled water 
sellers demanded justice outside the mansion, but they got little sympathy from the populace, who knew 
the merchants had been gouging them. 
As promised, House Linkam began distributing water freely to the people of Carthage, all of whom were 
affected by the bad times. While some were too proud to accept the charity, old freedmen, out-of-business 
shopkeepers, and widows of sandminers began showing up for assistance; each person who asked received 
a small ration of water. Drop by drop, the Linkam reserves began to dwindle, but the mood in Carthage 
improved. Valdemar Hoskanner would never have done such a thing. 
Jesse worked inside the mansion's banquet hall, showing his face and letting the people see that he was 
responsible for this easing of their misery. Esmar Tuek stood at his side, probing eyes alert, surreptitiously 
scanning every visitor. 
When one bearded man reached the head of the line, the veteran held up the scanner, retrieving images 



from security files and charts of identity points. At a signal from Tuek, two Catalan guards took the man 
into custody, despite his protestations. "What have I done? You can't seize an innocent man!" 
General Tuek held up the scanner screen. "We have detailed files of all Hoskanner sympathizers and 
suspected saboteurs." He smiled. "Now, the rest of you are welcome to step forward." 
A handful of men and women drifted out of line and tried to slip away from the mansion. Tuek sent men 
after them to make more arrests. 
Jesse let his anger show, speaking loud enough for everyone in line to hear him. "Hoskanner agents have 
already done enough damage to my House, and to all of you. Now they dare to come take the water I 
intend to give to my loyal workers?" 
While the people grumbled, Tuek leaned closer to Jesse. Satisfied, he said with a grim smile, "You can 
expect to hear from Bauers about this, My Lord. Arresting Hoskanners? He will be incensed." 
"No, Esmar. As much as he might want to free those agents, he can't admit to any connection with anyone 
who may be working for the Hoskanners. However, it does give me a bit of leverage. I'm going to contact 
him first." Jesse rose to leave. "Our Imperial friend is going to help us break the water sellers' strike, 
though he doesn't know it yet." 
THE NEXT DAY, in a formal announcement from the steps, Jesse offered an ultimatum to the unruly 
merchants. "I have no patience for your price gouging when people are suffering. You can survive with 
decreased profits for a time-as the rest of us have had to. Either accept my terms or depart from 
Duneworld. If you leave, however, you forfeit all assets and go with nothing." 
Predictably, the indignant water sellers stormed over to the huge inspection ship and pleaded with 
Counselor Bauers to intervene. Smiling with amused helplessness, the man declined. "Hmmm, Grand 
Emperor Wuda made it clear that Nobleman Linkam can do as he pleases, with no rules or restrictions, in 
order to produce the maximum amount of spice. Ahhh, my hands are tied because of the edict." His nose 
twitched. 
Before Jesse had issued his hard-line statement, he'd reached a secret deal with Bauers. Though he 
despised the terms, he saw no alternative but to offer the exposed Hoskanner saboteurs as a bribe, 
delivering them to the Imperial ship in exchange for the inspector's cooperation. Without admitting any 
connection to the Hoskanners, Bauers had agreed. Very quickly. 
Later, when the water sellers and producers called upon him and pleaded for leniency, Jesse 
magnanimously granted amnesty. "Now, let's all work together." 
It was another short-term victory, but he savored it nevertheless. Finally, he felt a little momentum on his 
side. 
19 
Everybody complains. 
- GURNEY HALLECK 
On a seemingly quiet evening, Gurney Halleck slipped into the old communal buildings that served as 
residences for the people Jesse had brought from Catalan. These were the best dwellings in Carthage. 
Though he was the spice foreman in charge of freedmen, convict laborers, and Catalan workers alike, 
Gurney had always liked to socialize with his crews. He came into the Catalan residences hoping to relax 
for a change. He wanted to listen to quiet talk of the sea and the rain among men he had considered friends 
back home-men who now served under him as sandminers. 
Immediately upon entering the main hall, however, the jongleur sensed a mood more sour than the odor of 
crowded, unwashed bodies. As the Catalan men organized their gear and supplies for the following 
day's harsh work out on the sands, they complained of thirst, isolation, grit in everything, sandburn, 
sunburn, windburn. Gurney had come to expect such grumbling from the convicts or disenchanted 
freedmen, but not Jesse's loyal men. 
"Now, now, what's set you all off tonight?" 
Unhappy-looking women in drab desert garb distributed packaged food and drinks. Some of the packs 
were open, revealing chunks of gray meat with sticks of too-bright vegetables. The men ate with grimy 
hands, inadvertently adding a seasoning of raw melange to the bland food. 
"There's nowhere to live on this hellhole, Gurney!" one of the men said. "Not under or above ground, not 



in rock caves. And look at this stuff!" He prodded the unappetizing preserved food. "What I wouldn't give 
for some hot fish and lemon stew!" 
The workers turned to Gurney, using him as a target for their complaints. "We're so overworked we don't 
get time to eat in peace, and even on long and dangerous shifts, we still don't harvest enough melange." 
Another man hurled a spice shaker against the wall. "Even if we win the accursed challenge, what will our 
prize be? Will we ever see our homes again?" 
"When will Nobleman Linkam reinstitute our wages? It's bad enough being miserable, but to do it for no 
pay?" 
Gurney chuckled. "You know the nobleman's good for it! You have food, water, and a bunk to sleep in. 
Would you rather I had General Tuek come and tell you stories about how he had to survive during the 
Lucinan campaign?" 
With forced good cheer, like a man hoping to calm a storm by waving his hands against the wind, Gurney 
sat on top of a metal crate and played his baliset, picking out familiar tunes without singing the words. 
"Come now, listen." He might have been their spice foreman, but he was also still a jongleur. He began to 
sing in his most soothing voice. 
"In swirling sand, With men on the ground, Cinnamon rilled the air, As the worm drew near. 
" 'Damn the spice!' he shouted,                                             
And plunged into danger, The bravest of nobles, The bravest of men." 
But the sandminers didn't want to listen. Instead, they began to throw food and insults at Gurney, forcing 
him to back toward the door. Even so, it seemed to him like a good-natured release of steam; he had made 
himself the butt of their dissatisfaction, allowing them to take out their ire on him. He held up his hands. 
"All right, lads! I'll talk to the nobleman! I'll see what I can-" 
Just then, the freedman captain of a spice harvester rushed into the main hall, slamming the heavy 
moisture-seal door behind him. "Where is the spice foreman? It's happened again!" He unsealed his face 
mask and knocked dust off his cloak. 
The mood shattered. Gurney set his baliset aside and strode forward. "I'm here-what is it?" 
"Two more spice harvesters gone, Gurney! Along with half of my mates and the entire crew of the other 
harvester!" Dirt and dust seemed to ooze from every pore of the man's body, with every agitated 
exhalation. "I barely made it off that rattletrap carryall alive. The other survivors are in the Carthage 
infirmary right now. General Tuek told me to find you!" The rest of his words came out in disarray as he 
described the disaster. 
"That leaves us with only seven harvesters!" a man groaned. 
Gurney listened, feeling as if he'd been shot in the stomach. He tried to calculate how many men had just 
been sucked down a worm's 
gullet. Freedmen, convicts, Catalan refugees. So much loss. He didn't see how House Linkam could 
survive any more. 
He muttered, "Even the sandworms are in league with our enemies." 
KNOWN SPIES AND saboteurs should be used as harsh examples, not bargaining chips. Esmar Tuek was 
not happy with the arrangement his nobleman had made. By releasing the captives to Bauers, Tuek and his 
interrogators lost the opportunity to obtain important information. 
Since their arrival on Duneworld, he'd suspected that someone was feeding the Hoskanners details about 
what went on inside the Linkam household. His careful questioning of the newly arrested Hoskanner 
sympathizers and saboteurs had uncovered disturbingly accurate information about finances, habits, and 
new security measures. He was fully aware of one person who had access to all that information inside the 
headquarters mansion. 
His suspicions turned to Dorothy Mapes, a woman who didn't seem to know her place. She had always 
been at odds with Tuek, challenging his decisions, using her wiles with Jesse to seize advantages for 
herself. Though not noble born, she was at the heart of House Linkam's business dealings, tracking 
productivity, controlling finances, dealing with suppliers who did not fulfill their contracts, influencing 
Jesse in clever ways. 
Tuek had seen ambitious, conniving women manipulate and corrupt Jesse's gullible father and brother. 



The current patriarch was smarter, tougher, and more practical than his noble predecessors. But still he 
was a man-and therefore vulnerable. Dorothy knew every detail of the Linkam business, from records of 
the spice crews to Jesse's work routes and itinerary. 
The security chief decided to watch her carefully. She was, potentially, a very dangerous woman. . . . 
20 
For everything measurable, there is always something greater ... and something smaller.  
- IKPAT THE GREAT 
Dr. Haynes transmitted a long-awaited message from the forward research base. He had a prototype of his 
"shock canister" ready for testing against an actual sandworm. 
Because of the severe spice-production shortfalls, Jesse decided to gamble everything on the new concept. 
He would have his other harvesters ready to move if Haynes's device worked as projected. They would 
wait safely and quietly away from the worm zone while another harvester did its work. In the event that 
the shock canister failed to stun the sandworm, his standby harvester crews would lose a day of 
productivity on other fields; if the test worked, though, they might be able to exceed a month's total haul in 
only a few hours. It was worth the gamble, especially now. 
"This is more than a test; it's a huge opportunity," he said to Gurney. 
"I don't want to waste it. Are your men prepared for a massive melange harvest?" 
"I'm always ready for a massive melange harvest," the spice foreman said, with a gleam in his eyes. He 
had already mapped out a particularly rich vein for the following day's mining operations. "This field has 
more than we could take even if the sandworms were on a week-long vacation. I've never dreamed of 
having the chance-until now." 
"Then issue orders to the carryalls. I want them ready to deliver all seven of our remaining spice 
harvesters for a full-force push." 
"If that depth-charge stunner works, laddie." 
"Yes, Gurney. If it works." 
AT THE FORWARD research base, Dr. Haynes proudly displayed a barrel-sized canister that held a 
powerful static generator. Covered with diamond-hard plating to withstand a worm's gullet, dozens of 
flexible whiskers sprouted from the device in every direction. Each antenna was insulated with live-rubber 
shielding and capped with a powerful discharge bulb. 
"Judging from readings I took of worm-generated energy fields, this device should pack enough of a jolt." 
" 'And the dragon saw that he had been thrown down to the earth.'" Gurney scratched his chin. "Aye, the 
worm will swallow quite a bitter pill." 
Jesse nodded. "Let's get ready. We'll deploy the first spice harvester just like we would on a normal day, 
so the crews won't suspect. The minute a worm shows itself, we drop the shock canister-and pray." 
Dr. Haynes took a solo ornijet to deploy the prototype himself, While Gurney readied the harvester crews 
on the ground, Jesse joined Tuek in a scout flyer to observe the test. The nobleman felt tense and eager; so 
much hung on the success of this new technique. He sensed 
that Counselor Bauers was ready to take drastic action back in Carthage-perhaps even pull the plug on 
the whole Linkam operation. 
They flew up into a shatteringly bright day. The first harvester had already been dispatched to churn 
through the spice vein, while spotters watched for the arrival of the inevitable worm. "We need sharper 
eyes than ever before, lads," Gurney transmitted from the desert floor. 
This time the spice operations would also serve as bait. 
The six other fully crewed harvesters were mystified at the change of plans and complained because they 
were kept waiting instead of working the fields. No one but Haynes's small team knew about the shock 
canister. 
Tuek guided their flyer above the dust plume generated by the lone harvester. He looked at Jesse with a 
knowing smile on his red-stained lips as he heard the spice foreman bellowing over the comm system to 
marshal the men. "Gurney's just a jongleur, but he treats the spice crews like soldiers under his command." 
"An apt comparison. We're at war against a dangerous planet as well as the Hoskanners." 
"And devil-worms." 



The huge mobile harvester went about its work, following a routine that had gone on for more than a year. 
Usually, the operations reminded Jesse of a swarm of gnats darting in to bite skin, draw a drop of blood, 
then fly away before a hand could swat them. Now, though, the waiting seemed interminable. 
Gripping the flyer's controls, Tuek was clearly uneasy-but not about the test. Something else weighed 
heavily on the old veteran's mind. Finally, he summoned his courage and said, "My Lord . . . Jesse, there 
is a matter I must discuss with you." 
"I've been wondering what was eating you, Esmar. Out with it." 
After only a brief hesitation, the security chief spoke. "I fear your own concubine might be a Hoskanner 
spy." Before Jesse could even express his shock, Tuek quickly continued, "Someone has been leaking 
vital details to our enemies . . . when equipment is ordered, the maintenance schedules of our harvesters 
and carryalls, even guard duty rosters. I learned that much from interrogating the Hoskanner sympathizers. 
Ask yourself, how many times has Counselor Bauers obtained information he shouldn't have? How often 
do Hoskanner saboteurs know exactly where to find vulnerable machinery?" 
"That doesn't mean we have a traitor, Esmar. Many people have that information. You're a paranoid old 
fool." 
"And you're a lovestruck one. If Dr. Haynes proves his new technique today, it's more crucial than ever 
that we keep this a secret." 
"I have already decided that the crews will be kept isolated to prevent them from passing the word. 
Nobody in Carthage will know." 
"She'll know." 
Frowning, Jesse said, "Dorothy was at the original meeting where Dr. Haynes proposed his idea. I have 
trusted her for twelve years-nearly as long as I've trusted you, Esmar." 
The security chief concentrated on his flying, but his shoulders sagged. "Both your father and especially 
young Hugo lost fortunes, bought expensive trinkets for femme fatales, and allowed themselves to be 
duped into dangerous romantic intrigues." 
"Dorothy's not like that. She is the mother of my son. You'd better have hard evidence if you plan to say 
any more to me." 
Tuek scowled. "No evidence, My Lord, just strong suspicions, which I developed through a process of 
elimination. It is what I do as your security chief." 
Jesse silenced him coldly. "I've heard enough, General Tuek. I refuse to discuss the matter further." 
Wrapping his pride around him like thick armor, the veteran spoke not a word as they sat together and 
waited. It was almost a relief to him when the sandworm came. 
"Wormsign!" The spotter's message repeated over all the channels. Workers in the first spice harvester 
switched to emergency procedures, just as they would on any other day. Gurney would take no chances. 
Most of the men didn't know that something was fundamentally different about the current operations. 
Tuek indicated the ominous rippling line as the immense creature burrowed straight toward the spice 
operations, altering the desert landscape with its passage. Jesse spotted a darting movement as a small 
ornijet streaked down to intercept the worm's path. "That's Dr. Haynes." 
The planetary ecologist landed and planted himself halfway between the monster and the spice harvester. 
Jesse directed Tuek to swoop close to the landing site, in case Haynes needed a rescue. "I've lost enough 
men and equipment. I'm not about to lose our planetary ecologist, too." 
The bottom bay doors of Haynes's ornijet deposited the shock canister onto the dune. The Imperial 
scientist emerged, going about his activities with brisk but efficient movements while the oncoming worm 
picked up speed. Perhaps the creature sensed the small craft and intended to gulp an appetizer before 
charging to the gigantic harvester. . . . 
While Jesse watched, circling above with Tuek, the ecologist bent over the prototype, going through a 
swift checklist, extending the wiry antennae. 
"Why isn't he leaving?" Jesse's pulse quickened. 
"Dr. Haynes does not leave details to chance." 
Finally the ecologist thrust a short pole into the sand next to the diamond-hard canister. Touching his 
collar, Haynes transmitted, "For insurance, I'm activating one of our static-shield generators. It always 



drives the creatures into a frenzy." 
"Get out of there!" 
Haynes switched on the generator. From above, Jesse watched the oncoming worm turn, spraying sand as 
if the small beacon had enraged it. The monster surged toward the bait, dramatically increasing its speed. 
Dashing to his ornijet and scrambling inside, Haynes slammed the access door. The hurtling worm left a 
wake of tan powder behind it like a stampeding bull, reminding Jesse of the maddened beast that had 
killed his brother, Hugo. "Doctor, you'd better hurry!" 
"Oh, yes, Nobleman. I can hear the worm. I feel the vibrations." 
The ornijet lifted off with blast jets. The wings flapped furiously as it gained altitude, first a few meters, 
then twenty, then fifty. 
The static-shield generator continued its call, and the huge worm lunged, its mouth open wide enough to 
engulf the whole dune. The armored prototype tumbled into the gullet, looking altogether insignificant in 
the swirl of sand going down. 
"The worm's taken it!" Jesse exclaimed. "It's swallowing the charge!" 
In the sand-and-air turbulence, Haynes's ornijet dipped and swirled, but the planetary ecologist regained 
control and soared away. 
The shock canister's automatic trigger activated. As the antennae contacted the beast's softer inner flesh, 
the device unleashed its powerful sting. 
The worm swallowed convulsively, and sparks burst out in spectacular, rippling surges. The creature 
reared and writhed, opening its folded mouth to cough out dust and sand. Sparking loops of discharge 
lightning crackled from its yawning throat as if the beast had vomited a tiny thunderstorm. 
Sparks began to fade from the worm's mouth as the depth charge continued all the way down, blasting one 
independent ring segment after another. The sinuous body spasmed, rolling on the open dunes. At last, the 
beast crashed to the ground and lay twitching. 
Jesse responded swiftly. "Gurney, have the carryalls bring in the other six spice harvesters! The worm is 
down. I repeat, the worm is down!" 
While the sandminers from the remaining harvesters rattled off confused questions, the spice foreman 
dredged up and transmitted another one of his quotes, which he'd been saving for just such a successful 
test. " 'May their bellies be filled with treasure, O Lord. May their children have more than enough!'" 
The planetary ecologist circled around and dropped his ornijet onto the churned, fresh sand next to the 
hulk of the motionless beast. 
"Haynes, what are you doing?" Jesse shouted into the comm. 
"This is an unparalleled opportunity, Nobleman. I remind you that my commission still comes from the 
Emperor, and my assignment is to understand Duneworld. I have never had a chance to see a worm so 
close. I can learn more in an hour than I have conjectured in the past two years." 
"If he stays at the beast's side, he can give us early warning when the worm starts to awaken," Tuek 
pointed out. 
"Exercise extreme caution," Jesse said to Haynes, though he suspected the intensely curious man would do 
as he pleased anyway. 
Safe from the guardian worm, the remaining harvesters were dropped along the rich vein. While a few 
spotters cruised overhead, alert for storms and other hazards, the sandminers ran out like giddy children on 
a candy hunt. They could see the giant desert demon lying incapacitated, and they ran out into the rust-
powdered sands, digging, scooping, reveling in their unexpected success. Sandminers threw in redoubled 
efforts, though they could not fight off their joy. Some of them threw handfuls of melange at each other, 
as if they were at play. The men laughed and threw themselves into the work; after more than two hours of 
frantic labor, none of them wanted to pause for even a few minutes of rest. Load after load of rich melange 
filled the cargo containers. Carryalls could not move the bounty away as fast as the men collected it. 
All the while, Gurney shouted encouragement, urging them to greater speed, even singing songs. The 
sandminers were delirious with sudden hope, fully aware of the extravagant bonuses they would at last 
receive. 
"If William English had survived," Jesse said in a low voice, "this 



one day's haul might have been enough to earn him passage back home." 
While the operations continued, Jesse told Tuek to fly him to the fallen sandworm as well. The old veteran 
frowned, and the stains around his lips made him look as if he had just devoured a large quantity of bloody 
meat. "You intend to be as foolish as our planetary ecologist?" 
Coldly, still stung by the veteran's suspicions of Dorothy, he replied, "It's not often I get to look at a 
helpless enemy face-to-face. This worm represents as much of a challenge to us as the Hoskanners. Let me 
feel my moment of victory." 
Dutifully, Tuek landed near the lifeless monster. It looked at least a kilometer long. Jesse disembarked and 
hurried over to the amazed scientist, who stood close to the towering mass. "Is it dead?" The air was filled 
with the cinnamon redolence of spice. 
Haynes had taken scrapings of the hard outer covering of the ring segments. He shook his head. "It'll take 
far more than that to kill one of these creatures, Nobleman Linkam. This worm won't be any trouble for 
hours, I suspect. Your crews should have plenty of time to do their work." 
"After a year and a half of adversity, we've finally turned the corner." Jesse stared at the enormous 
sandworm. The sharp smell of cinnamon yelled in his nostrils-raw spice, acrid like the ooze from the 
sandtrout that had sent English into a drug-induced frenzy. 
The leviathan stirred, causing Jesse and Tuek to jump back. 
"It's done that several times now," Haynes said. "I think it's having worm dreams." 
Before it stopped and settled down again, the creature exhaled a great wind that carried enough vaporous 
melange to make Jesse dizzy, a sensation that passed as the air cleared. "Even with today's huge haul, I 
have decided that we'll send only a modest increase to Bauers-just enough to show progress, keep him 
from shutting us down, but not 
enough to spark his interest. I want the Emperor and Valdemar Hoskanner to believe we're still 
struggling." 
Tuek gazed up at the massive hulk with a grim expression, as if contemplating how he might wrestle such 
an opponent. With narrowed eyes and a furrowed brow, the old general turned to Jesse. "You understand 
that these crews will need to be kept quarantined, My Lord? Now that this trick has worked, if they are 
allowed back in Carthage, the news will leak, and you can be sure the Hoskanners will try to sabotage 
what we're doing." 
Jesse permitted himself a feisty smile. "We'll erect additional barracks and spice storage facilities in 
remote places. We'll keep the men busy enough-and earning enough bonuses-to quell their complaints. 
With only half a year remaining, we need every moment to build up our reserves." 
21 
The purpose of night is to prune the limbs of yesterday. 
- GURNEY HALLECK, unfinished poetry 
As weeks passed with the sandminers sequestered in hastily erected barracks, far from Carthage's few 
amenities, House Linkam amassed a significant hoard of melange. Out in the western mountains Gurney 
established natural warehouses inside rock caves and in camouflaged silos, then posted his most trusted 
men to guard the treasure. 
After each successful worm-stun operation, the isolated workers tallied the spice yield, which translated 
into bonuses. In less than a month, they had earned as much as they would have banked in half a year 
under the Hoskanners. Many freedmen sat in amazed disbelief as they realized they finally had a chance to 
earn passage off this planet. 
Some unhappy workers, however, cursed the spice foreman and complained about their quarantine. After 
several of these disgruntled 
sandminers tried to escape from a temporary camp and were revealed to be Hoskanner spies, Gurney 
threw them into a makeshift brig, seized their spice shares, and distributed them among the remaining 
men. 
Meanwhile in Carthage, Jesse used various excuses along with modest increases in the spice he delivered 
to keep Counselor Bauers at bay. Although Tuek's cordon of soldiers still contained the inspection ship's 
crew (despite their protests), the Grand Emperor's man could come and go as he pleased. Even so, Bauers 



learned little and grew increasingly displeased. 
No one knew where all the missing spice-harvesting crews had gone. Rumors of underhanded treatment of 
the men began to spread, and Jesse declined to provide any acceptable explanations. 
As he stood in his ship looking out on the city, Counselor Bauers couldn't help smiling to himself, a feral 
slash that cut across his face. To survive, Jesse Linkam had begun to think like the Hoskanners. . . . 
Jesse lay in bed beside Dorothy. Sworn to secrecy about the shock-canister method, she kept an unofficial 
accounting of how much melange had been gathered. To boost morale, she suggested that Jesse begin 
quietly providing the exiled spice crews with additional comforts and entertainment, even female 
companionship, if they wanted it. Jesse also decided to donate his personal chef from the mansion, though 
Piero Zonn would have even more problems out in a dusty base camp than in the questionable civilization 
of Carthage. Still, he would be commanded to do what he could for the sandminers; without them, the 
Hoskanners could never be defeated. 
Meanwhile, back in the city, the water reserves of House Linkam had been exhausted. While the people 
appreciated the generosity, as soon as they began to be turned away their grumbling started once again. 
Jesse thought of their hardships, feeling guilt because finally his teams were hauling in huge melange 
harvests, yet he had to pretend to be poor. 
With the tighter markets and the higher demand for melange across 
the Empire, Jesse had Tuek snoop out a few black-market connections. The old veteran was easily able to 
bring in extra water shipments, using a portion of the never-reported spice hoard to pay for the precious 
liquid. Thus, Jesse soon reinstituted the water benefits for all supplicants. Times were still hard for the 
townspeople, but no one in Carthage would go thirsty while he was their nobleman.. . . 
After making love that night, Jesse and Dorothy spoke of old times on Catalan, and wished they could be 
back home. He toyed with the triangular stone of the diagem promise ring on her finger, remembering 
when he had given it to her out on a lonely reef where they had tied up their boat. The day had been full of 
intimate moments, romance, and shared dreams. But now Jesse never completely let down his guard in 
Dorothy's company, troubled by the suspicions Tuek had voiced about her. He held his concubine's firm, 
warm body against his own, listening to her breathe. Although she lay very still and silent, he knew she 
was only pretending to sleep so as not to disturb him. How much else was she pretending? 
He didn't want to think about it. 
AS A TANGERINE dawn profiled the rooftops of Carthage, Ulla Bauers marched to the front arches of the 
headquarters mansion. Dressed in full Imperial regalia, he strode officiously past the stark, empty 
pedestals from which all the Hoskanner statues had been so rudely removed. 
Jesse greeted him in the entrance hall, but Bauers did not return the smile or the salutation. He scowled 
ferociously. "Today, I shall watch your sandminers at work. They have not been seen in Carthage for 
weeks, and most of your crew barracks stand empty. Each time I inquire, you come up with another 
unbelievable excuse. Hmmm, now, tell me the truth!" 
"The workers are out in the desert harvesting spice, Counselor. Just 
as Grand Emperor Wuda wishes." His voice and wide-eyed expression were full of bewildered innocence. 
"Ah, but I will see them! Today!" 
Trying to look a bit downcast, Jesse responded, "I'm afraid that's impossible. We have suffered great 
losses of crews and equipment, and every moment counts. All of my men are out either searching for spice 
veins or trying to harvest them as best they can. You are aware that our exports of spice have increased by 
more than twelve percent since last month. Why would you question me now?" 
Hands on hips, Bauers shot back, spraying spittle with his words, "All well and good, but where are your 
men working? Exactly where?" 
A casual shrug. "Out in the dunes somewhere. I can't keep track of their locations. Gurney Halleck is my 
spice foreman, and I let him choose the most viable veins of melange." 
"Stop being evasive with me! I am the Imperial inspector-give me something to inspect! I have received 
reports of unrest among the Imperial planets, of spice riots and nobles demanding their share of melange, 
of starship crews petitioning the Emperor for priority distribution." 
Jesse raised his eyebrows. "That sounds like quite an exaggeration, Counselor. Our exports are down from 



the Hoskanner peak, but there is certainly enough melange to fill the most desperate need. Perhaps that 
implies a bit too much dependence on a luxury drug?" 
"Melange is a necessary commodity, not a luxury." 
"It still sounds like Hoskanner propaganda. I charge that Valdemar is spreading rumors and causing 
alarm." 
"Hmmm, I assure you these riots are not exaggerations. Thousands have already died. Now tell me where 
your spice harvesters are!" 
Enjoying his guest's discomfiture, Jesse spread his hands. "You could go out looking for them, I suppose, 
if you consider that to be your Imperial duty. But Duneworld is a big planet, and bad things happen out in 
the deep desert. Believe me; my son and I almost died out there. The weather can turn on you in an 
instant." He snapped his fingers. "If you 
go out into the desert against my advice, I cannot guarantee your safety." 
Bauers grew still and cold, reading the implied threat in Jesse's words. "No rules, you mean? You dare to 
threaten me with the Emperor's words ?" 
"As you so rightly pointed out, you are an acknowledged expert in contractual matters, in issues of fine 
print. I am but an inexperienced nobleman faced with a tremendous challenge." He paused for effect. "A 
challenge, I might add, that I take very seriously." 
He ushered the sputtering man out. Jesse knew, however, that Bauers would not give up. He only hoped 
he could stockpile enough melange before the Imperial inspector discovered his secret. 
22 
A good foreman works hard to guide his crew and get the job done. A good crew follows orders and performs to the best of its abilities. Here, we 
have failed in both respects. 
- GURNEY HALLECK, incident report 
Following the evening meal in the temporary base camp, exhausted sandminers drank their ration of spice 
beer and shared stories. Inside the sealed mess hall, the cinnamon odor of spice permeated everything. 
Though they were far from Carthage and had not seen their homes or families for weeks, most of the 
sandminers were content enough with their conditions. The new chef found ways to make the prepackaged 
food much more palatable (though the man huffed about impossible hardships), and each sandminer 
received double their previous allotment of water. Even the pleasure females were glad to have a small 
captive audience of customers with credits in their accounts and very little to spend them on. Though the 
women were dried and leathery, 
unattractive by most objective measures, the majority of sandminers did not complain. 
But some did. The undercurrent never quite disappeared. 
One evening while Gurney played the baliset in the communal tent, the men relaxed, dozed, or gambled 
their shares back and forth in games of chance. The music entertained the crewmen, and the Linkam 
jongleur enjoyed having a group of listeners every night. 
"Toss that baliset over here. It needs to be tuned up," sneered one of the freedmen, Nile Rew. "I'll stomp 
on it a little with my foot." 
Several men laughed. Others told Rew to be quiet. 
Gurney forced himself to receive the comment as a joke, though the man's caustic tone suggested 
otherwise. "I can tune you up the same way." 
Rew poured more of the potent spice beer for himself from a spigot attached to the table. As soon as 
Gurney resumed his music, the edgy freedman swept an arm across the table, sending beer glasses flying. 
Men cursed him for wasting the precious water in the drinks. 
"This place is nothing but a prison! I'm a freedman, by all that's holy! With my bonuses, I've already got 
enough credits to book passage offplanet, but I'm stuck here! For months! Curse the Linkams and their 
secrets. They have no right to treat us like prisoners." He glared at his fellow sandminers, and shouted to 
them. "They have no right to keep us here, men. Anyone who wants to go back to Carthage, follow me!" 
He lunged for the moisture-seal door which led out to the camp's armorpave landing pad where the 
ornijets and carryalls were kept. Some of the spicemen chuckled, while a half dozen followed Rew out 
into the hot night. Despite the large bonuses they were accruing from the remarkable spice harvests, the 
credits did them no good if they couldn't leave the desert planet-or at least spend them in town. 



Gurney stalked after Rew, and a blast of hot wind hit him in the face as he charged through the doorway. 
The spice foreman plowed toward the disgruntled man, knocking aside several of his drunken followers to 
get to him. Gurney's movements were as inexorable as an avalanche, and he caught Rew just as he was 
mounting an ornijet's running board. With a thick forearm, he knocked the surly man to the sand. 
Sandminers came out, cheering for Gurney and yelling disparaging comments at Rew, though a handful of 
men grumbled and moved closer, siding with the surly man. Two of the bedraggled pleasure women 
watched with pinched expressions, unimpressed with the rowdy behavior. 
Rew rose shakily to his feet, then reached into a pocket with surprising speed and brought out a sonic 
knife. The blade glittered in the camplight. 
Gurney backed up a step. "Oh, you want to play, do you?" He drew his own dagger and activated the hilt 
so that the vibrating edge increased its sharpness beyond that of a diamond razor. "With me?" 
The spice foreman swung, cutting a buzzing arc through the air. Rew overreacted as he tried to block, but 
Gurney reversed his own weapon and smacked the freedman's wrist with the butt of the hilt, breaking a 
thin bone. Rew cried out, and his knife clattered onto the ornijet's running board. 
"Enough of this nonsense." Gurney slipped his dagger back into its sheath. 
From behind, something struck a hard blow to the back of Gurney's head. He fell, hitting the sand-crusted 
armorpave surface. He heard a voice, somebody yelling, then rushing footsteps-before he saw a boot 
draw back just an instant before it struck him in the forehead. . . . 
GURNEY WOKE TO a ferocious headache. With his skull pounding and ringing, he had a difficult time 
focusing on the concerned face of Dr. Cullington Yueh. 
"Oh, you gave us quite a scare, friend," said the old battlefield surgeon. 
"What are you doing?" Yueh was supposed to be in Carthage, not at the base camp; the doctor knew 
nothing about the secret deep-desert operations. "You shouldn't be out here." 
"Then don't make it necessary for me to come again. When we got the message from your camp saying 
that you've been unconscious for hours, Nobleman Linkam dispatched me here. Your men were very 
worried about you!" 
"Except for the ones who did this to me." He groaned. 
"A few bad apples. Most of your crew are good men, I think. It was like calming a bunch of frantic 
mothers when I arrived." The surgeon dabbed a pungent-smelling patch on Gurney's aching forehead. 
"Good thing they called-you might have remained in a coma if I hadn't administered the right drugs." 
He gave another, louder groan. "Some doctor! Didn't you bring any pain relievers with you, man?" 
The doctor clucked his tongue. "Oh, you already have a full dose. I'm sure your headache will only get 
worse when Nobleman Linkam gives you a tongue-lashing for not keeping your men under better con-
trol." 
Still dazed, Gurney mumbled, "What happened?" 
"Some of your men escaped and went to town in an ornijet, flying wild. Luckily, because of your crew's 
warning, General Tuek's security force was able to intercept them as they landed-almost crashed, actu-
ally. A pack of drunks." 
"Have they talked to anybody?" Alarmed, Gurney tried to sit up, but the old battlefield surgeon pushed 
him back down. 
"Oh, don't you worry. Tuek has them in isolated custody. Your secret is safe." 
23 
When the world around you is dry as dust, the mere memory of beauty must suffice. 
- DOROTHY MAPES, A Concubine's Life 
                                                                                       
Rife with rumors, angry about the spice crews that had been missing for months, the Carthage population 
blamed everything on the Linkams. Seeing only meager spice shipments brought back from the desert and 
knowing nothing about Jesse's hidden hoard out in the mountain caves and in camouflaged silos, they felt 
no hope, only restless rage. 
Though Nile Rew and his fellow escapees had been arrested as soon as they landed their craft, a wild story 
of forced work camps in the deep desert had leaked out. Other rumors began circulating about the ex-



travagances of the Linkam household. Jesse continued his free water stipend, and the people noticed that 
the nobleman's reserves seemed inexhaustible; their thoughts turned to suspicion instead of gratitude. No 
doubt incited by Hoskanner loyalists, malcontents gathered in 
front of the headquarters mansion, enraged by some unfounded new rumor. The group seemed to have no 
leader, which made them even more dangerous as they demanded entry. They carried makeshift weapons, 
and General Tuek coordinated a defensive operation, which necessitated removing the cordon of soldiers 
that stood watch around the Imperial ship. 
Jesse fumed. How many Hoskanner agents were even now slipping out to infiltrate Carthage all over 
again? Trapped aboard the inspection vessel for so long, the spies would certainly seize their chance. And 
the ungrateful townspeople were undoubtedly aiding their efforts, whether willingly or accidentally. 
The nobleman looked at the distant faces and felt an anger that matched theirs. Did they not know what 
was at stake here? "I have already distributed all of our water reserves, Esmar, and paid out of our own 
spice profits to bring more shipments in. I doubled their rations, gave them all they need. They aren't 
thirsty-just unhappy." He made a sound of disgust. "Nothing will satisfy them." 
Grim, Tuek said, "Sometimes accusations trump goodwill, My Lord. A thirsty man given a drink today 
will demand another tomorrow. Their memories are very selective, but can any of them say their lives are 
worse than they were under the Hoskanners?" 
"If I gave them an ocean, they would still complain. The only ones truly thirsty are those who have 
gambled or lost their own rations. I have been more than generous in trying to buy their goodwill. I 
wanted to be their nobleman, like I was to the people of Catalan. But they spit on my generosity." 
From the front of the crowd, a woman shopkeeper shouted, "We demand to see your extravagant 
conservatory! We know you have it in there." 
"Flowers and shrubs!" another woman shouted. "You arrogant bastards!" 
The crowd roared; a shrill voice rose above them. "How dare you spill water on plants while our throats 
are parched!" 
Perplexed, the security chief turned to Jesse and said, "A conservatory? Where did that ridiculous rumor 
start? Hoskanner seditionists, spreading unrest, prodding sore spots." With a gesture, Tuek summoned his 
armed troops to come forward, their weapons raised. 
Deeply concerned, Jesse paled. "The conservatory was Valdemar's; he left it behind. I thought nobody 
knew about it except for Dorothy and myself." 
Tuek's eyes narrowed, adding data to his ever-growing mental catalog. "So, she was one of the few who 
knew . . . and now someone has leaked it to this mob?" 
"Enough, Esmar," Jesse snapped. 
Provoked by someone at the rear of the crowd, the people pushed higher on the steps. "We can break our 
way inside!" 
"Stand down, or my men will open fire!" Tuek bellowed. 
"You can't shoot us all!" The shouts grew louder, more emotional and incomprehensible. 
"I don't want any of these people killed," Jesse cautioned. "Not over something as stupid as this." 
"That may be unavoidable, My Lord. I am dutybound to keep you alive." As the people stumbled forward, 
Tuek ordered three men to drag Jesse to safety, despite his protestations. "Find a secure room for the 
nobleman." He met Jesse's eyes. "We won't let anyone inside the mansion harm you or your son." Jesse 
noted that the old veteran pointedly left out Dorothy's name. 
At Tuek's command, the loud report of a projectile gun fired into the air should have cowed the people, 
but instead served as a trigger for the riot. With a cry, more and more dusty men and women rushed up the 
stairs toward the door. 
The Catalan Guards stood shoulder to shoulder. "Prepare for a full barrage!" Tuek yelled so loudly that his 
voice cracked in the dry air. 
"Stop!" A woman's voice came from below the steps, to the side of the main entrance. A previously 
locked servants' door now stood open, 
and Dorothy Mapes emerged. "Stop!" For a relatively small woman, she shouted her command with a 
power that seemed superhuman. 



Tuek glared at Dorothy and gestured to four of his men. "Sweet affection, get her out of there!" 
Unprotected, she lifted her head with regal dignity and faced the mob, as if she could guard the servants' 
entrance simply with her confidence." You people have been misinformed! We have given the city of 
Carthage all our water reserves for distribution to the people. You know this." 
"What about the conservatory?" 
"We know you're hiding it!" 
Tuek's security guards elbowed their way down the stairs, but could not move through the crowd swiftly 
enough. Jesse tore himself free of his escort and ran back toward the main entrance, trying unsuccessfully 
to reach his concubine. The men and women were clustered too tightly, jockeying for position and 
pushing him back. 
"Then anyone who wishes to see, come with me," Dorothy yelled over the tumult. She held a hand up. 
"Twenty of you at a time. I will show you the difference between House Linkam and House Hoskanner." 
Before a livid Tuek could stop her, she allowed a group of the protesters inside the mansion. 
WHEN JESSE AND the guards finally caught up with Dorothy and the twenty angry townspeople on the 
fourth floor, she had led them to the end of a corridor in the south wing. "This was a Hoskanner conser-
vatory!" she said. Holding the full attention of the witnesses, she activated the secret panel, and the 
moisture-seal door hissed open. 
"Look inside and imagine the decadence, the waste of water, the lushness that Valdemar Hoskanner hid 
for his own private amusement. 
Imagine how many of your fellow citizens went thirsty because of his self-indulgence." 
Within the sheltered greenhouse chamber, only dead plants filled shelves and counters. Dry leaves and 
dead insects lay scattered about. The air was redolent with the smell of dry decay. 
"Nobleman Linkam knows how hard life is here on Duneworld," she continued, "and such waste offends 
him. When My Lord learned of Valdemar's personal paradise, he shut off all water to this room." Her 
voice was as firm as a rock formation from the deep desert. "Outraged at the excess, we allowed every 
plant in the conservatory to die-and the water was passed on to the people of Carthage, making life better 
for you." 
The twenty spectators gazed around, some nervous, some ashamed, some looking completely out of place, 
as if they didn't know why they had been drawn into the mob in the first place. 
One large man still searched for a way to release his pent-up emotions. Dorothy did not flinch, even when 
confronted by his bulk. "Why won't you let the spice crews come home? What about all the melange 
you're hiding in the deep desert?" 
"Outright lies and destructive rumors." Dorothy waved an arm expansively, sure now that they would 
believe her. "Just like this." 
Tuek's men stood uncertainly in the hall, weapons ready, but the fury had died from this first group of 
observers. The guards led them outside, while Dorothy remained in the room to await others. 
Jesse came to her side. "That was foolish, and dangerous." 
"But effective. Would you rather our house guards slaughtered them all?" She gave him a small, hard 
smile. "Esmar will hate guiding more people in here, won't he? But I keep my word, as you do yourself." 
He frowned, but kept his thoughts private. Even Tuek hadn't known about the conservatory-so how had 
the rumor started in the first place? Of course, he realized: the Hoskanners knew. But they didn't- or 
shouldn't-know about the deep-desert operations. Niles Rew and his unruly escapees had been held in 
isolated custody, yet still someone 
had leaked the information. Two damaging secrets had gotten out, at the same time. 
Tuek couldn't possibly be right about her. But Jesse found it difficult to dispute the facts. Throughout their 
tenure here, saboteurs had known about the movement of equipment, the stations of security troops, the 
orders of new harvesters and carryalls, which were inexplicably delayed. ... 
"What is it, Jesse?" She looked at him, her brow furrowed. Did he see a hint of guilt etched on her face? 
Could she possibly be hiding something? From him? Now, suddenly, he couldn't be sure. 
Dorothy continued to look at him, waiting for an answer. Finally, he turned away. "Nothing."                                                
24 



In the Known Universe some of the most inhospitable worlds hold the most value. 
- REPORT OF THE IMPERIAL RESOURCE BOARD 
After the crowd had dissipated-for now-Jesse and Tuek strode through the corridors of the mansion. 
The brooding security chief seemed even more introspective than usual. 
Sunlight passed through leaded plaz windows with an intensity that suggested the level of afternoon heat 
outside. Members of the household staff were picking up debris and dust in the halls and rooms from such 
a large influx of people. 
With a glance at Tuek, Jesse said, "We've proved something to them at least. Valdemar Hoskanner would 
never have allowed them such access." 
"He would have killed everyone in the mob." The veteran did not sound judgmental. "As I was prepared to 
do." 
"It could have been much worse if not for Dor's quick thinking." 
Scowling, the other man rubbed his red-stained lips. "Her foolish bravado, you mean. She put us all in 
danger." After a long moment, he added, "In my experience, Jesse, rumors begin far from the light of 
day-but they all start somewhere, an ember of truth that is fanned into flames by an instigator." 
He knew the old veteran meant Dorothy. Jesse didn't understand why Tuek had never liked or trusted her. 
Was it because she had so much influence over the nobleman, while she was only a commoner? "When 
we came here, Esmar, we fired much of the old domestic staff that worked for the Hoskanners. Some of 
them could have known about the conservatory. They must have talked." 
"But why now, My Lord? At the same time as the rumor about the spice stockpiles in the deep desert? I do 
not like coincidences." He motioned for Jesse to follow him into a nearby chamber. After they closed the 
door, the security chief removed a messagestat cylinder from an inside jacket pocket. The ornate cylinder 
bore an unmistakable Imperial crest. 
"I found this on my desk an hour ago," Tuek said. "Counselor Bauers has also heard the rumors of our 
secret hoard, and he believes them." 
"He certainly gets up early." 
Tapping the cylinder, Tuek said, "Based on the amount of bluster, I'm confident he doesn't have proof yet. 
But someone informed him, even before today's mob started spreading rumors. In fact, I have it on good 
authority that he has already dispatched search teams into the desert." 
Jesse felt a chill. "Has Gurney's latest camp been moved?" 
He nodded. "I sent an immediate order, and Bauers will only find a few tracks in the sand. We should be 
able to stay one step ahead of him." 
"Then why aren't you smiling, old friend?"                                    
"There's more." The veteran's face darkened. "The Emperor himself is coming here on his private yacht, 
along with an Imperial military force, to formally confiscate all melange . . . supposedly to preserve 
peace. The Emperor plans to strip you of your title . . . and monopoly . . . here." 
Jesse had the cylinder open now, scanning the details. Looking up, he said, "In a contest with no rules, 
keeping our production levels secret should not have been a problem, but I'm afraid they never had any 
intention of letting me win the challenge. The Emperor and Valdemar had a deal in place before any of 
this began." He hurled the cylinder against a stone wall. The cylinder bounced and then rolled on the floor, 
making a clatter that seemed to mock him. 
"We only have three days to get ready," Tuek said. "Then we will have to face Grand Emperor Wuda. I 
hope you're not willing to concede defeat, My Lord." 
"Absolutely not, Esmar. But we need to buy ourselves some time." 
THAT NIGHT JESSE lay beside Dorothy in bed. Though she slept peacefully, he remained awake and alert, 
full of thoughts and doubts that he didn't want to share with her, or with anyone. Not yet. First he needed 
to sort them out himself. 
With his proclamation, Bauers had effectively hamstrung the Linkam hopes. If Jesse revealed the spice 
he'd been holding in reserve while exporting only minimal amounts, then the Grand Emperor would 
simply take it. No rules. Apparently no justice or fair play, either. 
He and Tuek had decided to keep the Emperor's imminent arrival a secret for now, including from 



Dorothy. 
In three days I must face the Emperor. Will I lose my title without so much as a chance to answer his questions? 
Jesse suspected, though, that in this devious trap no answer would ever be acceptable. 
He had plenty of questions of his own. Why was the Imperial leader so desperate for spice? Exports were 
much less than the Hoskanner quotas, but enough melange had still gone directly to Renaissance to 
more than meet the Emperor's personal needs. Were other noble families agitating for shares of the 
Duneworld prize? Melange was in wide demand, judging from the Hoskanner production and export 
records he had seen. But still, wasn't it just a drug-a luxury? 
If the Emperor disqualified Jesse from this contest, House Linkam would be ruined. They had mortgaged 
everything, even borrowing deeply from exploitive noble families who charged crippling interest. Could 
Jesse leave that in place as a legacy for his son? Barri would be penniless, as weak and insignificant as 
William English's family had been. The thought of Barri being thrown onto a penal planet like Eridanus V 
made his stomach roil. 
Intellectually, when he assessed the angry powers arrayed against him, Jesse knew he could not win. For a 
moment he considered just taking his spice hoard and fleeing to another planet. Given the high price of 
melange, even on the black market, he could buy a planet somewhere on the fringe of the Empire. Take 
Dorothy and Barri, load a ship, and go renegade. 
The Grand Emperor cannot strip House Linkam if he cannot find House Linkam. Despite his flouting of rules, 
even Emperor Wuda could not completely spurn the Nobles' Council. Legalities must be observed. 
But unlike his father and brother, Jesse Linkam was not a man to run and hide. Besides, Ulla Bauers 
would undoubtedly use some tricky legal loophole to hunt down Jesse and his family. 
Rage infused Jesse, and fresh determination. He thought of another way. 
Leaning across the bed, he kissed Dorothy on the cheek. "I love you, my darling. Always remember that." 
She murmured the same in return, then drifted back to sleep again with a gentle smile on her face. 
Three days. 
Jesse swung out of bed, dressed quietly, and slipped into the shadowy corridor. He wrote and sealed a 
terse, irrefutable letter that specifically revoked all of his concubine's authority, stating that Dorothy could 
no 
longer be his proxy. And he intentionally named no successor. Let Bauers wrestle with that little legal wrinkle. 
Because he would leave no explanation, she would be angry, even crushed, but Jesse was confident she 
could eventually figure out his reasons. He considered waking Tuek and telling the security chief his 
plans, then decided instead to take this bold action on his own. If they didn't know what he was doing, 
even an Imperial interrogator could not drag the information from them. 
Before long, Jesse was at the controls of an ornijet, speeding over the dark sands toward the forward 
research base. 
25 
We are, each of us, capable of anything. 
- VALDEMAR HOSKANNER 
Confused, upset, and most of all afraid for her nobleman's safety, Dorothy waited for three days, but no 
word came from him. Jesse had disappeared in the middle of the night, leaving only a shocking letter that 
stripped her of all authority. Why? What had she done? Had someone accused her? 
No one seemed to know where the Linkam patriarch had gone, and because he had removed her as his 
proxy, no person could be contacted who was officially in charge of House Linkam. It was an impossible 
situation. All business seemed to be frozen. 
Hardest to deal with were Barri's questions about his father. The boy could sense his mother's concern, but 
he wasn't completely frightened yet. Jesse had often gone out to the spice fields, though never without 
telling her first. 
If he knew anything about the mystery, Esmar Tuek refused to share information with her. The security 
chief seemed even more guarded than usual, as if he dreaded what was about to happen. He kept watching 
the open skies. After reading the severance letter, Tuek had looked at Dorothy with even deeper suspicion. 
It troubled her to see the strange enmity in his eyes, the subtle hostility in his demeanor. But he was hiding 



a deep secret of his own behind that hard, inscrutable face; she could read the telltale signs in his body 
language. 
Yet Jesse claimed he trusted the man implicitly. Tuek had now served three heads of House Linkam, and 
it was not a mere concubine's place to question the relationship between a nobleman and his loyal, if 
overly zealous, security chief. 
Why would Jesse simply leave Carthage? Why hadn't he trusted her enough to explain his strange 
departure? It was as if he wanted to make himself disappear and hide from everyone, even from her. . . . 
And now an unannounced ship was arriving. 
Alerted by an office assistant, Dorothy ran out on a sealed-plaz balcony of the mansion. From her high 
vantage she gazed toward the northern desert, where a heat-addled shape approached, glinting in the 
midday sun. She hoped it was the ornijet Jesse had taken, or perhaps a larger transport ship from the 
forward base. Thermal ripples in the air blurred all details. 
The approaching craft circled, choosing the best of the various landing fields in the stepped and rocky city. 
The Imperial inspection ship still dominated the main field, where it had rested for months without 
moving. 
Hearing something behind her, she turned to see Tuek step out on the balcony. Had he been reading her 
thoughts ... or spying on her in his irritating manner? She kept her tone cordial but cool. "That ship isn't 
Jesse coming back, is it, General?" 
The old veteran stood stiff and straight, watching the unusual craft land in one of the zones normally 
reserved for Linkam ships. She had never seen a vessel of such gaudy design. "No, that is not Nobleman 
Linkam." He pointed toward the smaller of the two spaceports. "It is Emperor Wuda's personal yacht." 
She reeled. The Emperor had come in person! Even under the baking heat of Arrakis, Dorothy felt a 
peculiar, disturbing coldness. An Imperial arrival could only mean a political coup that would damage 
House Linkam. "Does Jesse know about this?" 
The general smiled slightly with his stained lips. "It is not for me to say what the nobleman knows or does 
not know." He turned to look at the Imperial yacht as it landed. "Now the fun begins." 
A POMPOUS AND overdressed emissary issued a formal command for Nobleman Jesse Linkam to meet 
with Grand Emperor Wuda aboard the inspection ship. The tall emissary displayed all the emotion of a 
robot; he stood in the mansion's great vaulted hall, delivered his words to Dorothy, and then turned like 
clockwork, preparing to exit. 
"I'm afraid that's not possible," Dorothy said, bringing him to a halt. "The nobleman is not currently 
available." Her voice, though soft, had the effect of a wrench jammed into the man's gears. 
Flustered, the emissary searched for a new script from which to recite. "No one is unavailable for the 
Grand Emperor!" 
The man's large stature made Dorothy feel even smaller, but she had seen his type before and had no 
patience for imagined self-importance." Nobleman Linkam is in the deep desert supervising spice 
operations. I do not know his exact whereabouts, and I have no way of communicating with him." 
"Nobleman Linkam was forewarned of the Grand Emperor's arrival. He should have arranged to be 
present. Who is his proxy to receive an edict? The formalities must be observed." 
"No one. I was formally removed from that position, and the nobleman has not yet appointed a 
replacement." 
The man looked as if he might explode. A sudden bright pleasure 
warmed Dorothy's heart as she put the pieces together and reviewed the evidence. This was exactly why 
Jesse had made himself unavailable! He had intentionally terminated her as his representative, leaving a 
vacuum, which effectively tied the Emperor's hands. If no one could find the nobleman, then no one could 
deliver legal demands. And no one could make any binding decisions for him. 
Dorothy maintained her confident smile. "Spice harvesting is a difficult business, and unforeseen disasters 
occur with unfortunate regularity." Not a lie ... in fact, she hadn't told him much of anything. "Though I 
am not allowed to make binding decisions for Nobleman Linkam, I would be happy to greet the Emperor. 
Tell him I will be there at the appointed time." 
The emissary did not look pleased, but could only agree. 



AFTER PASSING THROUGH the ornamental rock garden where the broken Hoskanner statues had been 
discarded, Dorothy crossed the armorpave landing field toward the huge inspection ship. Hot yellow 
sunlight pounded down with the force of weapons fire, but she breathed as calmly as she could, trying to 
force peace upon herself. 
General Tuek insisted on accompanying her, but still held his secrets as tightly as Duneworld gripped the 
mysteries of melange. How could she react properly to the Emperor if she did not have the information 
she needed? Why hadn't Jesse explained himself to her before creating the authority vacuum? 
Together, they stepped onto a royal purple carpet that had been laid for the Grand Emperor's procession 
from the ornate yacht at the other spaceport to the enormous inspection vessel. Blown dust and sand had 
already dulled some of the fabric's brilliant color. 
Imperial guards stood at attention on each side of the inspection ship's entrance, where an open lift 
awaited the visitors. She and Tuek 
entered an enclosure that verified their identities and scanned for weapons. After being cleared, they 
stepped through to the lift where Ulla Bauers waited, gazing down the bridge of his nose at them. 
"Hmmm, since when do a concubine and an old soldier speak on behalf of a House? We specified 
Nobleman Linkam in person." 
Dorothy bristled, but tried not to show her irritation. She glanced sidelong at the stoic veteran; his red-
stained lips formed a firm iron line. 
"Nevertheless," Tuek said, "we will try to be of assistance." 
"Hmm-ahh, we shall see. This way." 
The lift took them up twenty-seven levels, deep inside the massive inspection vessel. Dorothy wondered 
why the Emperor's man needed such an immense ship to keep watch on spice operations. Perhaps much of 
the size might be puffery to promote an imposing sense of awe for the Emperor. Tuek was convinced that 
the vessel contained an entire standing army tucked away in soundproof compartments, though he had no 
proof. 
Maybe the Counselor had hoped to seize a huge cargo of spice by military force, leaving the Linkams 
empty-handed. Packing such a hoard into the ship and delivering it to the Grand Emperor, after skimming 
a satisfactory percentage for himself, Bauers would reap many rewards. 
Dorothy and Tuek followed the overdressed, ferretlike man through a maze of corridors, observation 
galleries, and rooms without apparent purpose, then into the opulent grand salon. The gilded walls and 
ceilings were covered with frescoes, some of the finest and most extravagant workmanship she had ever 
seen. On the far side of the chamber, one of the Emperor's numerous portable thrones had been erected; 
Inton Wuda undoubtedly had one aboard his personal space yacht as well. 
The fat, pale ruler sat high atop the elaborate chair; to Dorothy, he looked like an overstuffed, overdressed 
doll. Bauers moved forward 
with a mincing gait that seemed like an intricate court dance. He bowed, then stepped to one side. With a 
casual gesture, Bauers motioned for the two to approach. 
In unrehearsed unison, Dorothy and Tuek bowed, averting their eyes from the most powerful man in the 
Known Universe, the third Wuda to rule in succession following the Millennial Wars. Nearly lost in bowls 
of fat, his eyes moved from face to face. When he spoke, his voice seemed too small to come from such an 
important man. "What is this insignificant delegation? I summoned Nobleman Linkam himself." 
"He is not in Carthage, Sire," Dorothy said, keeping her eyes averted. "And he has left no official proxy to 
act in his stead." 
"This is the nobleman's concubine, a mere commoner," Bauers said with a sniff, then added as if it were a 
joke, "Hmm, and she also serves as the business manager for House Linkam. The former sapho addict is 
Esmar Tuek, their security chief. Note his red lips, from the sapho cure." 
"An odd pair." Wuda scowled and squirmed, as if preparing to rise from his throne in indignation, then 
deciding it wasn't worth the effort. "What sort of insult is this? When is your nobleman expected back?" 
Tuek answered. "We're not certain, Sire. He is working the spice fields with his men, striving to do the 
best possible job on your behalf." 
"If he's working so hard, then where is the melange to show for it?" the Grand Emperor demanded. "His 



output has been shameful, an embarrassment! All across my Empire, people are clamoring for his head." 
Dorothy was sure the Emperor must be exaggerating. "Nobleman Linkam has recently increased 
production, Sire. Since he has several months remaining in his challenge, he hopes to deliver greater 
quantities to you soon." 
"So he's hopeful, is he? Well, so am I! And whatever I hope for holds precedence!" 
Dorothy wasn't sure what distinction the Emperor was trying to make, but he had grown quite red in the 
face. "We will do whatever you command, Sire." 
"Of course you will! And don't speak unless you have something intelligent to say." He snorted, looking 
disdainfully at the diagem promise ring Jesse had given her. "A concubine business manager! And a worn-
out sapho addict!" 
Bauers swept in from the side. "Shall I escort them out of here, Sire?" 
"Not until you learn exactly where Nobleman Linkam is, so that we may go out and see what he is doing. 
We flew halfway across the Known Universe to come here. We must take care of this matter promptly and 
get spice production back to normal. I should never have listened to Nobleman Hoskanner. This whole 
challenge is nonsense." 
"We don't know exactly where our master is," Tuek repeated. Though he spoke the truth, as Dorothy did, 
it was obvious to both of them that Jesse didn't want to be found. 
Dorothy added, "Because of continual danger from worms, spice operations shift from day to day." 
The Grand Emperor showed his displeasure by putting his face through a variety of unpleasant 
expressions. "Incompetence, utter incompetence! You don't even know where your nobleman is, and he 
left no one in charge. No wonder the spice exports have collapsed." 
Bauers emitted a wicked chuckle. "Hmm, the disadvantages of having a commoner for a business 
manager." 
Because the Emperor laughed at the joke, Dorothy and Tuek were forced to chuckle along with him. 
As Bauers herded them out of the grand salon, Dorothy noticed a mark on the lower part of his neck, 
mostly hidden by his voluminous black collar. It looked like a gray tattoo, but she could see only the 
rounded top of it. 
Noting her interest, Bauers quickly got behind her and pushed them toward the doorway. 
Is he hiding something? she wondered. 
26 
Sometimes, it is wise not to investigate every mystery you encounter. - SANDMINER'S ADMONITION 
 Two men stood outside the brown barracks dome watching the 
murk settle in the late afternoon sky. Very soon, Jesse wanted to declare victory by fiat; the only score that 
would impress Emperor Wuda was an overwhelming amount of melange and the secret of an immensely 
effective new production technique. He would have to return with so much spice in hand that Valdemar's 
promises and bribes would look paltry by comparison. 
Jesse Linkam would turn the old order of commerce and politics on its ear. 
Though Dr. Haynes was technically in Imperial employ, he had agreed to keep all aspects of the shock-
canister technology confidential. If Emperor Wuda tried to seize the spice and deny House Linkam its 
profits and glory, General Tuek already had orders to destroy the designs and all of the supporting work. 
Now that the idea was out there, however, somebody could re-create it-but that would take a consider-
able amount of time and effort to accomplish, and the Empire was desperate for spice now. Jesse still 
maintained the upper hand. 
Despite several days of labor that seemed harder than the worst battle he'd ever fought, Gurney Halleck 
wore an incongruously boyish grin on his lumpy face. The bruise in the center of his forehead was a 
fading blotch of yellow and purple. "The Emperor's spies may have learned about our stockpiles, laddie, 
but they have no inkling how much spice we've gathered or how we did it. The numbers, and our method, 
would astonish even Bauers himself." The jongleur's grin widened further. 
"Exactly how much do we have, Gurney? The last tally I saw, we were approaching eighty percent of our 
goal." 



"Should be well over ninety percent now. Now that we've gotten rid of that bastard Rew and others who 
were poisoning morale, our sand-miners have been working like madmen. To quote an old saying, 'All 
work and no play . . . makes for bigger bonuses!' I'm awfully proud of the men." The spice foreman 
narrowed his eyes. "They all deserve a huge reward." 
"After we win, I'll be generous until it hurts, Gurney. As soon as the Emperor locates me, he intends to 
force me to leave Duneworld. Don't think he hasn't already reached a backroom deal with Valdemar 
Hoskanner. The clock is ticking, and a lot of things could still go wrong." He gazed toward the horizon. 
The new weather satellites had spotted a storm brewing out there. 
"This morning's scouts found a rich vein nearby," Gurney reported. "Maybe the biggest yet. It surfaced 
sometime during the night. If we use one more shock canister and put all seven spice harvesters on it, we 
might actually top our production goal. In a matter of hours." 
"Only if the weather holds. We've been in communication silence, but the Grand Emperor must have 
arrived in Carthage by now. He's probably bellowing for me, but we've moved around so much that even 
Esmar can't figure out where we are." 
"Yes indeed. All those storms, static discharges, and faulty Hoskanner equipment." His smile became sly. 
"No way to track us down. Very difficult to keep effective lines of communication open . . . especially 
when we don't want to." 
"Esmar still thinks there's a standing Imperial army hidden inside that inspection ship. If he's right, I hope 
they don't stage a military takeover of Carthage." He clenched his teeth. "No rules! That foul Wuda fails to 
follow his own conditions when it looks as if the contest might not turn out the way he wants." 
"He may be Emperor, My Lord, but he is no nobleman. He has no honor." 
Jesse shook his head sadly. "You're right." 
"The men are tired, and it's late in the day, but we can still deploy a last shock charge and continue spice 
operations into the night until the storm forces us to halt." Gurney's rough skin looked ruddy in the oddly 
colored light. "Or we can pack up and wait for tomorrow." 
"Each tomorrow holds too much uncertainty. Send out the crews and hope the weather doesn't turn on us. 
This time, I'll deploy the canister myself. Let's win this game, Gurney." 
27 
Genuine trust is even rarer than the spice melange.  
- GENERAL ESMAR TUEK, Security Briefings 
Restless and unable to sleep because of the Emperor's threats, Dorothy spent part of the night alone in the 
dry, empty conservatory. It was a silent and private place, though no longer secret. With all the plants 
dead and brittle, no one had a reason to go in there anymore. 
Sitting alone in the darkness, smelling the powdery decay around her, she closed her eyes and imagined 
the room as it had been when she first saw it, so verdant and moist, an oasis in the barren desert. . . an 
outrageous display of Hoskanner wealth and power. 
But had she and Jesse been correct in killing this little piece of Eden? The plants did not belong here on 
Duneworld, but neither did she. No human did. The fungi, flowers, and fruit shrubs were a reminder of 
other places, of more pleasant environments. Was it really a 
reckless waste of water, as she and Jesse had insisted, or should they have seen it as a sign of hope? The 
thought of the greenery, moisture, and teeming life was so blissful that she laid her head on the table and 
drifted off to sleep.. . . 
An abrupt shadow superimposed itself on Dorothy's dream. She sat up in alarm, though she didn't know 
why she felt such urgency. Looking around, she saw nothing out of place, but something was not right. 
Emerging from the sealed conservatory, she sensed immediately that the mansion was too silent. 
The concubine hurried down the wide central staircase to the second level, where she found two of Tuek's 
guards lying in the hall, arms and legs akimbo like insects sprayed with poison. She froze, listening for 
any movement, then glided forward to check them for pulses. Both men were alive, but unconscious. Gas? 
Something incredibly fast-acting, she decided. Sniffing the air, she caught a faint, unusual odor 
reminiscent of pine and burnt sugar. 
As she ran down the corridor, she found more bodies. The night staff had fallen in their tracks. The 



mansion's sealed ventilation system must have been compromised; a powerful soporific would have done 
its work in short order. The isolated conservatory, kept secret by Valdemar Hoskanner, used an 
independent system. 
Heart pounding, she raced to Barri's bedchamber. The door to the boy's room was open, and she nearly 
tripped over Tuek's motionless form sprawled on the floor, his hand gripping a stun gun. Apparently the 
security chief had suspected something amiss, but not in time to do anything about it. 
"Barri!" Stumbling inside, she saw that her son's bedding was in disarray, and expected to find him 
unconscious like all the others. But he was not there. 
My son is gone! 
Dashing to the window, Dorothy saw three dark forms running through the front rock garden where the 
Hoskanner statues had been discarded. She judged them to be large men, and they carried a bundle 
about the size of a young boy. Frantically, she overrode the seals, cracked the casing around the window, 
and broke it open to the dry night air. "Stop!" 
The men looked up at her, but sped onward. They were much too far away for her to catch them. A 
mother's anguished cry rose on a warm night breeze. Her throat was constricted by a rattling necklace of 
horror. The ungainly rhythm of her own heartbeats pounded in her ears. 
As the dark figures kept running, Dorothy broke her paralysis and hurried back to Tuek's unconscious 
form, where she wrenched the stunner out of his slack grip. As soon as she reached the open window, she 
depressed the firing stud without knowing how far the weapon could shoot. Though she sprayed the area, 
the stunner's beam dissipated into the empty night, and the kidnappers disappeared with the boy. She 
tossed the useless weapon on the bed. 
At once furious and terrified, Dorothy went back and tried to rouse the incapacitated veteran, shaking him 
as hard as she could. "Wake up, damn you! General Tuek, do your job!" He didn't move. She slapped his 
face, but he was too deep in unconsciousness. White-hot anger infused her. This man should have 
protected her son! 
"Damn you, damn you, damn you!" She hit him harder across the face, and the triangular diagem of 
Jesse's pledge ring cut the skin on his rough cheek. Blood trickled down the side of his weathered face, but 
she didn't care. 
Someone with intimate knowledge of the household must have abducted Barri. Everything had been 
coordinated too perfectly, executed with precision. Inside her head, Dorothy heard the needle-stick noises 
that came with fear, skin-rasping fingernails followed by a bloom of sound in the murky shadows around 
her, cutting the stillness of the mansion. 
Spinning, she saw Dr. Cullington Yueh sauntering toward her. He had escaped, too! He wore a gas filter 
over his kindly face and held the gilded ceremonial scalpel in his hand, its razor edge glinting in the low 
light. 
Dorothy's eyes widened with realization. She didn't need to say anything, but looked around for something 
with which to defend herself. A small statue was out of her reach. 
"I don't know how you escaped the gas, Dorothy." He pulled his mask aside and let it hang on his neck. 
"Oh, my job would have been easier if you'd gone to sleep like the others. Then I... I could have . . ." 
Her skin grew hot, and she struggled to keep from flying at him with her fists. "Why, Cullington? What do 
you have to gain?" Her words tasted like acid. "Is Barri dead? What are they going to do to him? Tell 
me-now!" 
The old surgeon bowed his head in shame and extended his prized ceremonial scalpel to her, handle first. 
His face was covered with perspiration. "Take my life, I beg you, for I must pay the price of betrayal." 
She snatched the weapon, but hesitated before using it. "What sort of trick is this?" 
"I had no choice but to allow them in, and now I cannot go on. Kill me. That will put an end to it all. Oh, 
I'm sure my Wanna is dead anyway." 
"What happened to Barri? How can I get him back? Why would you do this to us?" 
He reeked with dishonor, appeared barely able to stand. "The Hoskanners. They have imprisoned my wife 
Wanna on Gediprime. They torture her, yet keep her alive. Each time I refuse to perform Valdemar's 
bidding, they send me new images of her agony." 



"You said she was dead!" 
"Better if she were." Yueh shook his head. "They forced me to act as their spy and saboteur. But my life-
even hers-is not worth all this." He gestured at the comatose forms around them, then crumpled to his 
knees, his face a mask of misery. Suddenly, he grabbed the scalpel and slashed at his forearm, succeeding 
only in cutting a long, shallow gash before Dorothy grabbed his weapon hand. 
"Cullington! Stop this nonsense!" She fought with him for the 
scalpel, and finally wrenched it from his sweaty palm, as both of them tumbled to the floor. 
Lying defeated beneath her, the old man looked at the bloody surgical blade in her hands, then at her face. 
"Use the knife, please! If I die, then I am no longer their puppet. Wanna would kill me herself if she knew 
what I was driven to do." 
Dorothy seethed. Tuek had suspected her, but all along Yueh was the real traitor, the clandestine source of 
information for the enemies of House Linkam. She realized that when the surgeon had tended Gurney 
Halleck's injury, he had learned the secret of the new spice-harvesting operations. 
Information he must have leaked to Jesse's mortal enemies. . . . 
"You will not die by my hand, Cullington. Not today. I need to save my son-and you're going to help me 
do it." She threw the scalpel down the corridor, and it skittered away. The old doctor began to stammer 
excuses, but she took him by the collar and pulled his sweating face close to hers. Blood from the cut on 
his arm dripped onto the floor, where thirsty stones absorbed the red wetness. "You're going to do 
everything I tell you to do. Everything, even if it kills you." 
Broken, Yueh sobbed, and tears streamed down his sagging face. "Oh, with all my heart, I pledge myself 
to you. From this day forward, my life begins anew." 
28 
There are many kinds of storms. Take care not to underestimate any of them. 
- NOBLEMAN JESSE LINKAM 
The seven spice harvesters were deployed simultaneously, every able-bodied man ready to operate the 
factory machinery. After months in exile, they could smell the sharp possibility of success, and it smelled 
like melange. 
After opening the comm line, Jesse spoke to the men. They were already charged with anticipation, and he 
funneled their hopes, strengthening their collective will. "After today, if we bring in even half as much 
melange as I hope, you can return to Carthage. Go to your homes, your families, and your well-earned 
rest." He smiled, hearing an echo of cheers over the speaker. "And, at last, many of you freedmen can 
leave Duneworld. There's a ticket offplanet for any man who wants it-or a high-paying job for anyone 
who chooses to stay with me." 
He watched the crews in their joyous frenzy as carryalls picked up harvesters and lifted into the sky. He'd 
never seen the men so eager to hit the sands. "But first, let's fill up those harvesters. This is Duneworld-
and the spice is there for the taking!" 
With military precision, the carryalls dropped the first industrial vehicles onto the rusty sands. In a matter 
of moments, the harvesters ratcheted into position and began to dig into the caked desert. Dust plumes 
churned into the darkening sky. Overhead, circling flyers monitored an oncoming weather front, and 
satellites mapped its course, unable to project how the storm might shift in its path. 
The well-seasoned crews did not allow the weather to slow them. By now, the men had rehearsed the 
routine enough to be comfortable with working on a high wire over a chasm. Every day entailed hardships 
and dangers, while small fortunes of melange passed into their personal accounts. Most of the freedmen 
had already earned enough to buy tickets offworld, and the convict teams saw their passage monies placed 
in trust, so they could truly leave Duneworld as soon as their sentences ended. 
With all the machinery landed in the midst of the reddish vein, the sandminers began loading container 
after container of fresh, redolent spice, which was processed and compacted, then airlifted away to be 
added to the dispersed stockpiles. 
When the inevitable sandworm finally appeared, it charged in from the northern fringe of the storm, 
plowing straight at them. Like a fur-whale breaching the Catalan seas, the creature surged above the 
dunes, a ringed, sinuous body haloed with crackling static electricity. 



Since coming to this planet, Jesse had become a competent ornijet flyer, one who was aware of the 
vagaries of desert weather, cold sinks, thermal updrafts, hot crosswinds, and abrasive sands. Now, as he 
received the worm spotter's call, he cruised in and adjusted his trajectory to intercept the beast. 
"On course," he transmitted to Dr. Haynes on a private frequency. "I'll deploy the canister within safety 
parameters." Jesse's voice sounded 
surprisingly calm to his own ears, belying the fear that he felt. His best men and equipment were out there 
on the spice sands, flirting with disaster. 
In the months since they'd begun using Haynes's depth-charge system, only one of the numerous shock 
canisters had misfired; even then, the highly trained crews had averted catastrophe by evacuating the men 
and equipment in time. And this was to be the last shock-charge deployed before House Linkam claimed 
unexpected victory in the great contest. If he defeated the Hoskanners, Jesse could begin to have a normal 
life again. Success today would guarantee a strong foundation for House Linkam and for his son. 
According to plan, Jesse set the small ornijet down on an open expanse of dunes, then disengaged the 
shock canister and let it settle onto the soft sand. Leaving the engines humming and the wings vibrating, 
he sprang out and set the device. 
Directly overhead, the sky had darkened to an ominous gray-brown soup, the leading edge of an 
approaching Coriolis storm. Wasplike crackles of static began to jump and pop around his boots, while 
pebbles bounced along the top of the dune, activated by the discharge that came as a precursor to the 
Coriolis winds. 
Jesse's hands tingled as he planted the static-shield generator next to the canister. Bait. When he activated 
its thrumming field, alarming blue-white flickers rippled through the air. He hurried. With his senses opti-
mized to a frightening level, he saw and heard the worm coming toward him like a maglev train, lured by 
the tempting song of the generator. 
Visible sparks leaped from the wings of his landed craft, dancing in the air. Incredible! After a quick 
double check of the canister, Jesse scrambled back into the ornijet and lifted into the sky, sending out a 
burst of exhaust. 
He was safely away by the time the sandworm's whirlpool maw gulped the shock canister. A knockout 
surge shot down the worm's gullet, and the creature rose up, writhing and thrashing at the air. An 
amazing burst of lightning flashed out of its mouth. A web of tiny shocks curled up and down its outer 
rings. Balls of white light collected in plasma surges, then flew upward to pop like soap bubbles. St. 
Elmo's Fire. 
Sparks flew in all directions; globes of phosphorescent light erupted like fireworks. The eyeless monster 
lurched forward, leaped high, and then crashed down onto the uneven dunes, sending reverberations in all 
directions. 
"Well, laddie, that was impressive!" Gurney's transmitted voice was exuberant. 
"Never seen anything like it," Jesse said over the comm line. Feeling a little shaky, he circled over the 
downed worm to make sure it was subdued. "We should have a minimum of six hours. Get your crews 
back to work." 
By now, the sandminers knew with a fair degree of accuracy how long each shock canister rendered a 
worm immobile. Even while stunned, the beasts often twitched and stirred, causing jittery observers to 
overreact. Accustomed to that, Gurney's excavation crews refused to sound every possible false alarm. 
Each minute of an early evacuation cut into profits. 
The Coriolis storm's thick, brownish nucleus was still a good distance away, but winds were increasing 
around the spice patch, and would likely force a shutdown before the sandworm recovered enough to be a 
threat. 
Safe from the creature, the sandminers returned to their tasks with redoubled energy, scooping load after 
load of the spice. Excitement and energy flowed through the men. They knew this could be their last haul 
before a long and well-deserved respite. 
Full of adrenaline-enhanced joy, Jesse landed next to the spice harvesters. He stepped into the mounting 
breeze to lend a hand, not afraid to get his own hands dirty, just as he'd done on Catalan. If this final ex-
cavation pushed them past the Hoskanners, he wanted to be part of it. 



The brunt of the angry weather front approached slowly. Gurney monitored the dangerous system, and the 
sandminers worked with frantic abandon, their hair and clothing whipping in the warm wind. The new 
weather satellites transmitted detailed updates every fifteen minutes. Unfortunately, the sandminers' 
attention was focused more on the Coriolis storm than on the motionless sandworm. 
As heat-discharges stitched the sky with white-hot barbs, the monster recovered itself with astonishing 
speed. Rippling its sinuous body, the creature reared up and began to move toward the excavation sites, 
drawn by the pulsing clamor of seven noisy harvesters. 
Alarm shouts went up. Worm spotters, caught off guard, sounded an immediate withdrawal. Gurney 
bellowed for the carryalls to sweep down and grab the huge harvesters and their cargoes. Darting ornijets 
dropped to the sand to snatch crewmembers who were too far from their vehicles. 
Workers rushed in all directions while static sparks flew from the sand. Jesse swung into action. Had the 
unexpected storm discharge weakened the shock canister somehow? Perhaps the spectacular light show 
had bled away the bursts that would normally have knocked out each of the worm's ring segments. That 
was a question for Dr. Haynes to investigate at some later time. Right now, Jesse and his men needed to 
fight for their survival. 
"Run!" he shouted into the microphone on his collar. "Get aboard anything that flies. Leave the equipment 
behind-just get out of here!" Trying to get to higher ground where the extraction crews could see him, he 
plunged up a soft slope through sand that clung to his ankles. 
The maddened worm thrashed through the dunes, then slammed into the first spice harvester before most 
of the crew could escape. Only partially attached to the huge machine, the carryall could not wrench the 
mobile factory free of the sand. As the worm devoured the big harvester, the airborne carryall could not 
disengage. The carryall crew screamed over the comm as they were dragged underground along with the 
doomed sandminers. 
Wreckage from the harvester and the carryall strewed the sand, but the frenzied creature was not finished. 
It turned to the other machinery. 
Two more carryalls clutched a pair of spice harvesters and successfully lifted them into the sky, flying 
away with their engines roaring. Over the noise, Jesse heard the keening of the approaching storm. 
Looking back, he saw the worm abruptly change direction and plunge toward the four remaining 
harvesters. 
Only two carryalls were left. One dropped down, and the locks engaged, grabbing the heavy harvester. 
Stranded sandminers continued to race in from the dune fields and scramble aboard, but the pilot did not 
wait. The carryall lifted off, pulling the harvester out of the sand and leaving a dozen men on the ground. 
The doomed workers turned, mouths open in dismay as the rampaging worm came at them. It gulped the 
whole field in a single mouthful. 
Jesse kept running. He reached the top of a dune and slid down the other side, hoping to put distance 
between himself and the worm. He smelled sulfur in the air and heard shouts, along with the winds and the 
crashing turmoil of the worm. 
He shouted into the collar microphone again, "Save the men! Any ship that can make a second run, swing 
back!" He wasn't sure if anyone heard him amid the babble of overlapping commands and screams. 
Then, as Jesse scrambled forward, the ground unexpectedly dropped out from beneath his feet. He gasped, 
flailed with his hands, and saw the powder swirl, sucking him down. 
A sand whirlpool! 
The vortex had his legs now and yanked him into the sand up to his waist, his chest, his shoulders. He 
cried out one last time, then closed his eyes as the impossibly dry maelstrom swallowed him. He couldn't 
fight, couldn't escape. It all happened too fast. He felt as if he had dropped over a cliff and fallen into 
darkness. 
No one on the surface had even seen him vanish. 
29 
I didn't consider his rank when I confronted him. I thought only of my own duties to House and family. 
- DOROTHY MAPES, 
A Concubine's Life 



After the gas wore off and Esmar Tuek crawled his way back to consciousness, he found that the 
nightmare had only just begun. 
He lay on the floor outside the bedroom of young Master Barri. Memories eluded him, lost in a cacophony 
of questions. He recalled leaving the mansion's security chamber, sensing shadows around him and 
whisper-quiet movements . . . something so wrong that it made the gray hairs on the back of his neck 
prickle. He had gone to check on the nobleman's son, heeding his instinctive sense of danger. 
Now, as he lay recovering, Tuek remembered his legs going heavy, each breath feeling like a gasp through 
clogged bellows, his vision and balance spinning. Shouts had sounded around him, oddly muffled through 
an unseen gauze filling his head. In a blur, the walls and floor had tilted around him as he saw guards 
sprawled comatose on the 
floor. Each footstep had felt like lifting a boulder up a steep hill. Staggering toward Barri's bedchamber, 
Tuek had seen a blur of movement- 
And now he awoke on the cool tiles, his cheek pressed against the stone. With strong arms the old veteran 
levered himself up and sat catching his breath, fighting nausea and a pounding headache. His face hurt, 
and when he touched his bruised cheek he found a hard crust there and a dab of thick blood from a small 
cut under his left eye. Someone had struck him. 
Anger lit a fuse in his bloodstream. He wrenched himself to his feet and gathered his balance enough to 
lean against a stone-block wall. Tuek tried to cry out for assistance, but his voice faded like a dry rasp of 
blown sand against a windowpane. Outside, the light had changed, and it took him a moment to place the 
time-the edges of dawn! How many hours had he been out cold? 
He staggered into the boy's bedchamber, where he saw a plaz window with the seals broken, shockingly 
open to the dry outside air. The self-cooling sheets on the bed were rumpled, but empty. Master Barri was 
gone. 
When he found a mirror above the boy's vanity, Tuek stared at the small cut on his own face, a distinctive 
indentation. He considered taking an impression, using investigative tools to reconstruct the weapon that 
had struck him. Then he recognized the unusual shape of the wound. Dorothy Mapes wore a triangular 
diagem on her ring. 
He drew a breath again and called out, but managed nothing more than a coarse whisper. "Guards! I need 
assistance!" 
Making his way out of the bedchamber, he heard stirrings in the mansion. Groans, curses, and the 
plaintive calls of alarm wafted through the corridors as stunned household staff and Catalan men at arms 
struggled to awaken.                                                                 
"Guards!" he called again, and was pleased to hear the satisfyingly loud voice he produced this time. 
Almost recovered now, Tuek strode down the corridor, his mind spinning through the immediate steps he 
would have to take. He would bring all of House Linkam's resources to bear. The nobleman's son was 
missing, and Dorothy Mapes had something to do with it! 
He stopped in his tracks. Looking down, he saw a gilded ceremonial scalpel lying on the floor. Blood on 
the blade. He bent, but stopped himself from touching it, recognizing immediately that it had belonged to 
the old household surgeon Cullington Yueh. Why was his blade here? Whose blood was it? Tuek marked 
the weapon for preservation and analysis. His teams could learn much from the evidence. . . . 
Later, after the Catalan Guards had made a complete sweep of the mansion and assessed the damages, one 
thing became obvious: someone with intimate knowledge of the floor plan had rigged the dispersal of a 
potent knockout gas through the building's ventilation system. 
In addition to the boy, both Dorothy Mapes and Dr. Yueh were missing. Had they been allies? The stunner 
found inside the boy's bedchamber had been fired enough that the charge pack was nearly depleted. Quick 
scans verified that Dorothy's fingerprints were on the sharp scalpel, and the blood matched Yueh's. Tuek 
touched the distinctive wound on his cheek, obviously made by the diagem ring Jesse's concubine always 
wore. 
"If you search more thoroughly," he grimly told his men, "you should find the body of Dr. Yueh." He sank 
into a hard chair at his security console, but knew it would be days before he allowed himself a full night's 
sleep. "We have been betrayed." 



DR. YUEH ESCORTED a bound Dorothy Mapes past security into the Imperial yacht's plush parlor. Her 
sharp eyes noticed subtle differences in the ornate cut of this throne from what she had seen on the larger 
ship. Apparently, Grand Emperor Wuda had many such thrones; perhaps a different artisan had done the 
work here. 
For good measure, she struggled against the bonds that she had instructed Yueh to tie around her arms; the 
knots were clever, but she could easily work her way free if she wished. It had seemed the only way to get 
on board the Emperor's ship in time to reach Barri. 
"You were not ordered to bring the concubine!" The plump Grand Emperor emerged from behind the 
throne, as if he had been hiding there. He wore a simple black robe with a high gold collar, which made 
his skin look even pastier than usual. Two guards emerged from behind columns, one on each side of the 
visitors. "I want only the son of Nobleman Linkam as hostage." 
Dr. Yueh seemed on the verge of collapse. He stammered, "D-don't underestimate her value, S-Sire. The 
nobleman holds her in extremely high regard. She is the mother of his only son. I believe Nobleman 
Linkam has a powerful emotional connection with her." 
"You mean he loves this woman? A commoner? No wonder he is weak." He tittered, and the guards 
followed suit. "Well, you promised me the boy, and you delivered him. Now, as we agreed, I will use my 
influence to see what I can do for your poor wife in the Hoskanner clutches." 
A flush of gratitude pinkened the old surgeon's milk-pale cheeks. "Thank you, Sire." 
"However, I have no use for a mere concubine-especially one who is not of noble birth. She gains me 
nothing." The Emperor looked at Dorothy with the pouting expression of an insect collector discarding a 
specimen. "She isn't even that pretty." 
Yueh swallowed hard, and uttered the words he had been told to repeat. "Oh, don't underestimate her 
value, Sire. She may be useful as an additional bargaining chip. The nobleman is very fond of her. It is 
one of his weaknesses." 
She lifted her chin, ignoring the turncoat doctor. "Taking political hostages is expressly forbidden by your 
own Imperial law, Sire." 
The Emperor frowned at her. "As you said, it is my own law. I can make new decrees if the old ones no 
longer serve me. It won't be difficult to spread the story that the Hoskanners kidnapped your son. Who 
would disbelieve it?" 
Dorothy did not reply. She wanted to think that General Tuek would be able to ferret out the truth, but he 
had little evidence . . . and plenty of preconceptions against her. 
She waited as Emperor Wuda stepped onto the pedestal of his throne and settled his bulk into the seat. He 
took a long time to make himself comfortable atop a thick gold-and-black pillow. 
"I want to see my son," she demanded, using a level of vocal command that made the Grand Emperor 
flinch and glower. 
"So? I want many things as well, and my wishes trump yours. We've learned of the large spice stockpile 
Nobleman Linkam has been hiding from me. In fact, I am amazed-his complaints and excuses had us 
convinced of his incompetence. And now! If the estimates I'm receiving are accurate, we could ship 
enough melange to end the spice riots on Renaissance, Jival, Alle, and every other planet." His plump lips 
formed a humorless smile. "As soon as we find out where he's hiding it." 
Dorothy frowned. Spice riots? What was going on out there in the Empire that had been kept hidden from 
Duneworld? "And you intend to hold my son hostage until Jesse cooperates ?" 
"And you, too, apparently. Rather simple, wouldn't you say?" 
Though she doubted her appeal would help, Dorothy said, "Grand Emperor, you and your comrades call 
yourselves noblemen. What is noble about kidnapping a nine-year-old boy?" 
"A lowborn concubine wouldn't understand the rules of civilized society," he said with a condescending, 
mocking smile. 
The pieces were falling together all around her, but not in expected ways. Why did so many people crave 
the spice? She redirected her line of inquiry. "Why would you discard centuries of tradition, break estab-
lished law, and do everything in your power to bring down House Linkam when we are on the verge of 
winning a challenge that you yourself offered?" 



"For melange, of course. The spice is everything." 
This still didn't make sense to her. "Why are you so desperate? An Emperor can have at his disposal any 
drug he chooses." 
The flabby leader gripped the armrests of his throne, and leaned forward. "Grand Emperor Inton Wuda is 
never desperate for anything." 
Dorothy caught herself, realizing that she had uncovered a weakness he had never meant to reveal. He was 
obsessed with the spice! What sort of hold did it have on him? She tried to retreat quickly. "Sire, please 
forgive my choice of words. I am agitated about the danger to Barri Linkam, my son, a young nobleman in 
his own right. He deserves every protection that your good offices can afford him." 
The Emperor made an annoyed, dismissive gesture. He shifted uneasily on the pillow. "Naturally, he will 
be protected. He's no good to me dead." 
She held her silence, knowing that Jesse was a stubborn man, not given to compromises, even when faced 
with unfavorable odds. He would not be blackmailed, under any circumstances. She feared what he would 
do when he learned of the kidnapping. 
"Throw the mother into the same room with the brat," said a deep, firm voice that was disturbingly 
familiar to Dorothy. "If that keeps him quiet, it'll be worth letting her live for now." 
At a sound on her left, Dorothy looked in that direction, past Dr. Yueh. 
Striding through a doorway, Valdemar Hoskanner smiled smugly at her. Without a word, he took a seat in 
a chair beside the throne, as if he belonged there. 
30 
There is always a way to escape from any trap, if one only has the eyes to see it. 
- GENERAL ESMAR TUEK, Security Briefings 
Spinning and sliding, Jesse plunged into an empty, suffocating hell. The vortex sucked him downward, 
seemingly to the very core of Duneworld. His elbows and shoulders banged against oddly smooth rock, as 
if he were sliding down a stone throat. 
Dust clogged his mouth, nose, and eyes. He tried to cough but could hardly breathe. Flailing helplessly, 
unable to stop the swift, bumpy descent, he was dragged deeper and deeper down an endless waterfall of 
sand. He had watched William English being sucked to his death. No one had ever emerged alive from a 
sand whirlpool. 
Nevertheless, Jesse struggled for his life. 
Though his eyes were squeezed shut and burning from the grit, he saw tiny flashes of light behind his 
eyelids, followed by blackness deeper than the Stygian realm of sleep. He needed air, but couldn't 
breathe. Sand rushed past him, roaring and scouring, threatening to suffocate him. 
Abruptly, a bubble of exhaled gas and fumes burst around him, pushing away the murderous dust, 
allowing him one choking breath of sulfurous gases that contained just enough oxygen for him to survive 
a few seconds longer.                                                                 
In his fading thoughts, Jesse remembered Barri's determined, optimistic face. The boy always focused on 
solving problems, striving to make his father proud. As Jesse tumbled, he thought of Dorothy, his beloved 
concubine. Such a strong-willed woman! His heart ached for her, and he knew she could not possibly have 
betrayed House Linkam. Esmar Tuek, despite his skills, had to be mistaken about her. 
Too often, he had kept his own feelings locked up, not telling her the depth of his love. As the head of 
House Linkam, he had always tried to be self-sufficient and firm, avoiding the foolish behavior of his 
father and brother. Regrets cascaded around him, flowing like the sands as he plunged deeper into 
Duneworld. He wished he could have one last moment with Dorothy, and with Barri. 
No excavation would ever find him. He would vanish like so many others. Everyone would assume the 
sandworm had devoured him. Now, at the culmination of his spice challenge, just when he was about to 
achieve victory, this capricious planet had stolen it all from him. 
In a measure of defiance, Jesse blew one last breath from his lungs with an angry, exhausted shout. Sand 
and dust coughed out of his mouth- 
Unexpectedly, he tumbled through an open void and landed on a soft mound of sand that had rained down 
from above. The impact was enough to knock the little remaining wind out of him. Stunned and 



disoriented, he sucked in huge lungfuls of humid air that reeked of bitter cinnamon, like a spice harvester's 
exhaust stack. But it tasted incredibly sweet in his lungs, breathable air! With his every gasp, the melange 
essence seemed to reinvigorate his nerves and his muscles. 
Jesse rolled over and got to his hands and knees, coughing grit, shaking his dust-encrusted head. He 
shuddered for a long moment, gulping breaths to replenish the oxygen in his bloodstream. Bits of sand 
continued to fall like gentle rain on top of him, then stopped. 
Questions clamored in his head. Where was he? How far had he fallen? 
This deep underground, he had expected to see nothing but inky darkness, yet a faint blue 
phosphorescence clung to the walls around him, and he could make out a series of tunnels stretching in all 
directions, a honeycomb labyrinth beneath the dunes. His eyes adjusted surprisingly well. 
Jesse struggled to his feet, though his entire body felt bruised, and his arms and legs were scraped raw in 
places. The spice vapors seemed to enhance his senses and sharpen his vision. Frantically, more energized 
than he had imagined he could be, he ran through one passageway after another until he grew short of 
breath. Realizing he could lose track of the original place he had fallen, Jesse tried to retrace his steps, 
using a sharp stone to scrape a mark on the walls at each intersection. He seemed to be in a crisscrossing 
network, like blue blood vessels beneath the sand. 
Dr. Haynes had postulated that the dune seas of this world had tides and movements, exhalations and 
fumaroles that hinted at mysteries far beneath the surface. Jesse wondered if he would ever be able to tell 
the planetary ecologist, or anyone else, what he was seeing here. . . . 
With one shaky footstep, then another, he continued to explore the subterranean paths. He needed to find a 
way out, he realized, not his way back to the mound of sand. He had no inkling of which direction he 
might go or how he might ever get back to the surface. Jesse had fallen so far, he doubted he could climb 
up the stone throat again. He needed to find a different route-or remain down here forever. 
A passageway opened into a large grotto, where the bluish light grew brighter. He could discern shapes 
around him now-bizarre, alien forms, living things that he had never guessed might exist in the arid 
vastness, a bizarre wonderland of life and energy. 
He heard eerie rustling noises: the movement of spongy forms that rose from the tunnel floor on huge blue 
stalks with wide, soft leaves. They reminded him of bulbous fungi, plants with rings around their trunks 
and stalks that swayed and opened up smacking mouths. Their forms hinted strangely of sandworms that 
were rooted to the ground. 
An incomprehensible nursery of exotic fungusoid plants surged and waved around the grotto, piling layer 
upon fleshy layer. As segmented stems bent over, round orifices coughed out a powdery mist of blue 
spores that smelled of spice but oddly seemed the wrong color, not reddish or rust-colored at all. 
With sparkling eyes, Jesse strolled through the odd subterranean warren. The fungusoid plants drifted like 
kelp in an ocean current. In a frenzy of fecundity, the stems grew visibly before his eyes, rising taller and 
taller. Leaves like rounded hands flopped out of the ringed stalks, then fell off and took root themselves, 
spawning secondary waves of growth. 
Jesse continued walking, exploring the freakish milieu. He wondered if his senses had been overloaded by 
all the melange wafting through the air. He had heard of the bad effects of extreme spice overdose. Was 
this all a hallucination? 
Then he came upon a skeleton. A desiccated, mummified cadaver sprawled on the ground with a tattered 
sandminer's uniform. Jesse stared, afraid for a moment that he had found William English, but the clothes 
were wrong. Other men had been lost in the desert, dragged down into sand whirlpools. This victim had 
not been able to find his way out.... 
Jesse continued walking and then running, faster and faster. Now, however, he did not get short of breath. 
Inside his body, Jesse discovered a tremendous, mounting energy-and he covered a great distance 
through the tunnels, chambers, and grottoes without pausing to rest. 
Inside a towering chamber of rock, volcanic light added a yellow-and-orange glow to the pale 
phosphorescence. Shafts of exhaled brimstone vapors curled upward toward the surface. He realized that 
he must be standing at the root of one of the fumaroles. 
The rubbery spice plants grew even thicker there, clustered around the nourishing gas vents. They rose 



like overfertilized magical bean-stalks, clogging the passage and seeking a way to the dunes above. . . . 
Time faded for Jesse as he moved relentlessly onward, covering many kilometers, with the melange-
impregnated air buoying him along. Though he had no way of telling time, he guessed that many hours or 
even days had already passed. How long could he last down here? He never felt a need to rest, but he did 
fear that his body would eventually burn out from its hyperprocessed, restless energy. Long-distance space 
travelers consumed only spice during their journeys across the Known Universe. The substance 
supposedly gave them all the nourishment they required. 
Had word of his death reached Dorothy in Carthage? Did his demise mean that his family automatically 
forfeited the Hoskanner challenge? Or could Barri, as his heir, reap the benefits? He had intentionally left 
no proxy behind, no one who could make binding decisions for the household. Would the Emperor just 
seize it all and ruin House Linkam, much as William English's family had been ruined, generations ago? 
There are no rules.  
Jesse paused in his underground journey, then pushed forward again, regaining his determination and 
resolve. He was not dead yet. He would not give up. There must be a way out. 
Far ahead, he heard a rushing noise as powder tumbled from a new surface opening. A sand whirlpool 
high above had dropped open to let a flood of sand drain down like time grains through an hourglass. 
Fumes from another volcanic vent swirled upward like smoke exiting a chimney, and the blue spice plants 
reached toward the ceiling, groping for a way out. 
Jesse stared as a possibility occurred to him. It was a decent chance, he decided-and he knew of no better 
way out. 
As the fleshy growths clustered together, stretching upward like the hands of clamoring beggars, he dove 
into them. The rising mass of vegetation jostled and lifted. He climbed higher on the spongy flesh, holding 
on and hoping that the vent in the rocks was wide enough to permit his body to pass. 
Around him, he felt the verdant upsurge gain strength as more and more plants shoved toward the surface 
of the desert planet. One of the nearest fleshy mouths opened like a blossom and exhaled a cloud of 
choking cinnamon into his face and eyes, but Jesse did not let go. He felt himself being carried upward, 
gaining speed. The rock walls rushed and scraped past him, cutting his skin as he was pushed higher. 
Then, like a drowning man reaching the surface of an ocean, the profusion of growths exploded into open 
sky, vomiting great gouts of cinnamony, rust-colored powder. 
Jesse found himself flying through the air like a rag doll. Moments later, he crashed against the slope of a 
hard-packed dune. Coughing and shuddering, he scrambled to his feet. Staggering into bright sunlight, he 
saw the swarm of spice plants still boiling up out of the blow, turning from blue to brown in the air and 
spraying melange, dumping a rich, reddish carpet in all directions. 
As he watched, the fungi withered, dried, and fell into a mat across the sandy ground. Within seconds of 
exposure to the desiccated air, the spice plants crumbled and flaked, becoming a layer of rich melange. 
Sunlight-real sunlight-burned his eyes. Shading his vision with one hand, Jesse felt himself adapting to 
the outside air. It was daybreak, with lemon yellow and tan hues creeping through the sky. 
Lost in the midst of the vast desert, Jesse turned in all directions, trying to spot a landmark. Everything 
around him looked scoured and clean. The Coriolis storm must have passed. He could not even hazard a 
guess as to how long he had been gone. 
Then, like a miracle, he saw a line of mountains on the eastern horizon and tiny, diamondlike lights in that 
direction, geometric shapes. He could see them only because his temporarily enhanced vision seemed to 
have telescopic properties. Jesse identified the oasis and 
the diamond-shaped plantings, the pillbox water silos, as well as the wedge-shaped main building of Dr. 
Haynes's research base. Green-planted dunes added a tiny fringe of color before they faded into the 
endless brown of the desert. 
Jesse began to walk across the sand. The desert made distances deceptive, but he had no doubt he would 
accomplish the trek, no matter how long it took. Even in the brutal heat of midday, he doubted he would 
need to slow down. 
Behind him, his footprints began in the middle of a field of fresh spice and extended in a line, following 
him straight to the sanctuary of the forward base. The spice had given him new life. 



31 
There are intriguing puzzles all around  us. Why waste time solving the wrong ones? 
- DR. BRYCE HAYNES, 
Ecological Notebooks 
Aided by the metabolism-enhancing properties of the intense melange to which he'd been exposed, Jesse 
was already recovered by the time he reached Dr. Haynes's base. Despite a long, grueling trek, he felt 
strong, and most of his superficial injuries had disappeared. Giddy, he joked with Gurney that he had 
inhaled an Emperor's ransom of spice with every breath he took in the subterranean realm. 
Blustering, laughing, and clapping him on the back with the force of a crashing cargo skiff, the jongleur 
said, "If it kept you alive, laddie, it was worth more than that!" 
Stunned sandminers milled around the research base, still in turmoil from the disaster. Thirty-seven men, 
two spice harvesters, and one carryall had been lost. Three days ago. He had been underground, 
considered dead, for three days. His safe return was desperately needed good news. 
Even though the storm had dissipated, electrostatic charges in the air still interfered with transmissions. 
The forward base tried to send a signal informing Carthage of Jesse's return, but they heard only white 
noise in response. 
Jesse brooded. "I know how distraught Dorothy and Esmar must be. Gurney, dispatch a fast flyer to carry 
a message-I don't care if the weather is still unsettled." 
The spice foreman raised his uneven eyebrows. "A messenger would give us away. The Emperor won't let 
you hide. Are you ready to give up the game?" 
"It doesn't matter anymore, Gurney. Especially if we have as much spice as you say. I want to end this." 
Jesse spent several hours cleaning himself and eating a meal of real food-washed down with water, since 
he didn't want any of the spice beverages. Afterward, he spent time with his injured and shaken sand-
miners, commiserating with them over their losses and congratulating them all for winning a challenge 
that had seemed impossible from the very beginning. Even with the disaster, Gurney told him the 
harvesters had gathered enough spice to tip the scales in the final tally. "Success is close at hand, men." 
"And I will be true to my word," Jesse told them all. "Once the Emperor acknowledges my claim here on 
Duneworld, any freedman who wishes to depart will be given passage offplanet, at my expense. House 
Linkam will also make it worthwhile for those who choose to stay." 
Gurney found cause for celebration in the mess hall. "'And he seized all the gold and silver and all the 
vessels that were found in the house of God. He seized also the treasuries of the king's house.' That we 
have done, My Lord! According to the final sum, we have beat the bloody Hoskanners, by the grace of the 
gods and demons. I've already begun to compose a song about it." 
"Your songs are always lies or exaggerations, Gurney," Jesse pointed out. 
"Ho, but in this case there's no need. The events themselves are fantastic enough." 
The surviving sandminers understood the terrific news, though many of them still seemed stunned and 
broken to have faced such a disaster at their moment of greatest accomplishment. Every one of them had 
lost friends on the destroyed harvesters and carryall. Jesse looked at them all, feeling their heartache as 
part of his own. He was the nobleman, responsible for their safety and their future. Even with the thrill of 
victory, he promised himself that he would never forget the tremendous cost. . . . 
Gurney led Jesse outside into the brittle daylight and over to one of the rock-camouflaged storage silos. 
Dr. Haynes's plantings extended out in broad chevrons of greenery, windbreak lines where scrub fought 
against the encroaching sands. Gurney said, "It may not be so easy to collect your prize, My Lord, if 
General Tuek is right about an Imperial army hidden in that inspection ship." 
"The Grand Emperor did not come to Duneworld to pat me on the back. We'd better have enough melange 
to impress him." 
Inside the dim cavern of one of their storehouses, the spice foreman stood with his hands on his hips, his 
square chin tilted up and his face alight with pride. Looking around, Jesse saw crate after crate of com-
pressed raw spice. The containers covered the floor and were stacked to the ceiling. 
"This is just a tiny fraction of it. We've tallied up all the caches in caves and hidden in the desert. We beat 
the Hoskanners by a good margin, and our time is not yet up." 



Jesse could not believe the wealth he saw. "Don't forget to count the melange we've already released for 
distribution over the past two years." 
Gurney laughed. "A drop in the bucket compared to the treasure we 
amassed afterward! I tell you, the Empire is starving for this stuff. We'll get a good price for every speck 
of it. Of course, the Grand Emperor and his cronies will get their share, but there's plenty left for us." 
Jesse hung his head. "No profit is worth the misery we've been through, the people we've lost." 
"You were forced into this situation, laddie-and you turned a trap into victory." 
"We're not out of the trap yet. Guard our stockpiles with your life, Gurney. As soon as we can arrange for 
transport and proper security, I'll contact the Emperor's inspection ship and demand that he declare me the 
winner of this damnable challenge." 
"And then Duneworld will be yours." 
Jesse's shoulders felt heavy. "Alas, the rains and seas of Catalan would suit me better, Gurney." 
WHEN JESSE FINALLY met with the planetary ecologist in his laboratory office, Haynes's eyes were glazed 
with wonder and fascination. "I must know everything you experienced, Nobleman." He sat at a 
conference-room table, his hands clasped in front of him, elbows resting on the hard surface. He leaned 
forward, ready to drink in every word. "You've seen things I only dreamed of. No man has ever returned 
from a sand whirlpool. No man has ever seen what creates the spice!" 
And so, to the best of his ability, Jesse described all that he had witnessed and endured. He paced the 
room, then relented and poured himself a cup of spice coffee from a sealed urn. The burn of melange in 
his mouth gave him a delicious thrill. 
Haynes took notes and asked probing questions, but mostly he sat and listened. When Jesse finished, the 
planetary ecologist stared at the chamber wall, his gaze distant, as if his imagination was roaming across 
the dunes to rich spice fields and worm sands, to gasping fumaroles and hidden tunnels beneath the desert, 
running like blue veins through a 
living planet. "Nobleman Linkam, you have helped me complete the working theory I've been developing 
for so many years." 
Inside the room under bright artificial lights, test beds of hardy plants grew, each of them given carefully 
monitored rations of water. Some of the species looked weak and withering, while others thrived. Jesse 
inspected some of the strange adaptations to an arid environment. 
"And what is your theory?" Jesse asked. 
Haynes shook his head, as if suddenly intimidated. "I can't be sure of all the details yet. There are many 
small threads I still wish to tie together." 
"I'm not asking you for a rigorous scientific explanation, Dr. Haynes. At the moment, I'd just like a 
layman's understanding of this planet that's absorbed so much of my sweat and blood for the past two 
years." 
Haynes surrendered. "I have long suspected a network of tunnels and vents beneath the sand. Until now, I 
never imagined that they might be part of an elaborate ecosystem, a labyrinth filled with fungusoid 'spice 
plants,' as you call them. It adds a new foundation to the ecology of Duneworld, which has always seemed 
sparse and mysterious, with too few components to support a biological web." 
"Like only seeing the tip of an iceberg. There is much more to it beneath the surface." 
"Exactly." 
"But what's the connection between these spice plants, the sandworms, and everything else?" On a flat 
specimen shelf, small trays contained samples of melange of varying colors and densities; Jesse knew that 
spice was graded according to quality, though even the lowest form still provided a heady rush. Right 
now, the smell of the open samples made his nostrils tingle. He leaned closer to sniff. 
Haynes looked down at the notes on his datapad. "My theory-and mind you, it is only a theory-is that 
the spice, the fungusoid plants, the sandtrout, and even the worms are all connected." 
Jesse touched a fingertip to the darkest spice sample, tasted it on the 
tip of his tongue. "You mean mutually dependent on one another? Parasites? Symbiotes?" 
Haynes shook his head. "This may be difficult to accept, Nobleman, but I am beginning to conclude they 
are all aspects of the same life-form-phases in a complex growth and development cycle." 



"How can that be? Sandtrout, worms, and plants are nothing alike." 
"Is a caterpillar like a butterfly? Is a larva like a beetle? A nymph like a dragonfly? The sandworms and 
spice plants could be-for lack of a more accurate comparison-male and female forms of a bipartite or-
ganism. Fungusoid organisms grow, and at a certain climactic point they reach to the surface, where they 
spew billions of microspores. In the atmosphere, the plants immediately die, as you witnessed. The spice 
we consume is composed of these microspores mixed with powdery plant residues, distributed by the 
winds. In turn, the spores germinate and grow, forming tiny creatures that devour the sand plankton and 
then grow into what we see as sandtrout." 
Haynes held up a ringer, as if making a place mark in his flow of thoughts. "It's fascinating, if my 
conjecture is correct. The sandtrout themselves may be the larval forms of the monstrous worms, while 
some of the little creatures may burrow deep and take root as spice plants. Perhaps each 'male' sandtrout 
grows into a giant creature, or somehow links together with others of its kind to form a colony organism, 
since each sandworm ring appears to be autonomous." 
"This is all difficult to grasp," Jesse said. "A life cycle so alien, so incomprehensible." 
"We are on an alien, baffling planet, Nobleman." 
Jesse stopped in front of a row of cages holding kangaroo rats, tiny rodents that went busily about their 
lives even in confinement. He wondered if they would rather be free out in the desert, like the ones he and 
Barri had encountered, or if they even had such an awareness. 
"Worms seem to guard the spice sands," Jesse said. "Are they preventing other worms from attacking their 
young? Or preventing our sandminers from stealing the spores?" 
Haynes shrugged. "As good an explanation as any. I never suspected that sand whirlpools and fumaroles 
might be crucial links in the chain of spice distribution. After reaching some catalyst point, a perfect bal-
ance of temperature and chemicals, the fungal organisms reproduce in explosive proportions. They draw 
large amounts of sand-silica-as nourishment or structural material. This, combined with minerals and 
chemicals in the volcanic gases, triggers even more growth and reproduction. They find an outlet to the 
air, where they dump their spores and then die." 
With a wan smile, the planetary ecologist rested his elbows on the table. "Or the real explanation could be 
something entirely different, almost beyond human comprehension. I just don't know." 
As he poured himself another cup of the strong spice coffee, Jesse thought of all the giant worms they had 
incapacitated with shock canisters, all the melange they had excavated from rich veins. He took a long 
drink. "Harvesting so much spice, is there a chance we're destroying a fragile life cycle that has existed 
here on Duneworld for millennia? Humans have only been on this planet for a few years." 
"There's always that chance. I simply don't have enough information yet." 
With the vivid images of the amazing underground catacombs before his mind's eye, Jesse set his jaw. "If 
I'm awarded permanent control of this planet, it may be necessary to curtail our production. We'll have to 
be good stewards of the land and allow some of the melange fields to lie fallow so that the populations of 
worms and spice plants can replenish themselves." 
The scientist's face became sad. "That will never happen, Nobleman Linkam-not as long as the Grand 
Emperors and noble families remain in power. Nobles, starship crews, and wealthy merchants have be-
come increasingly dependent upon the spice, and will demand more and more production. It will only get 
worse, not better." 
"Spice may be popular, but I think you're exaggerating its importance." 
Haynes shook his head. "Why do you think the Imperial inspection ship came here to intimidate you after 
only a year? You may have heard rumors of spice riots on Renaissance and other wealthy planets-they 
are all true." 
"I thought that was just Hoskanner propaganda, to stir up resentment against House Linkam." Restless, 
Jesse found screens that displayed real-time images from the weather satellites. The surface of Duneworld 
was bland and unremarkable, with few features to help him find the location of the forward research base. 
Most of the large storms were centered high in the northern hemisphere. 
"If anything, Nobleman, those reports minimized the uproar. With Duneworld's exports drastically 
reduced, the entire Empire is craving this substance. They desire spice more than anything else." 



Jesse scowled. "Come now, Dr. Haynes-as valuable as it may be, melange is just a luxury commodity. It 
would be good for some of the pampered nobles to forget their hedonistic pleasures for a while. Once 
spice becomes too scarce or too expensive, the people will turn to other vices. The Empire offers plenty of 
them." 
Haynes's voice had a grim edge. "Most noble families are addicted to melange-fatally addicted, I fear-
and they are just now beginning to realize the fact. That is the dark side of the spice." 
"Then they'll have to endure. It'll toughen them up." Jesse's voice grew iron-hard. "Someone will develop 
treatment plans. Esmar Tuek endured his cure from the sapho drug, which is said to be the worst addiction 
ever known." 
The planetary ecologist shook his head. "Believe me, Nobleman, sapho is child's play compared to 
melange withdrawal. You do not consume spice extravagantly yourself, but after your recent exposure un-
derground, I fear you may be inextricably bound to it as well. The Emperor is desperately dependent on 
melange, as are many high-ranking families, and the pilots and crews of starships. If the spice flow stops, 
the whole Empire will fall into a dark age such as the human race 
has never known. An entire generation will die from the drastic effects of withdrawal." 
Jesse absorbed the startling comments. He tasted the pleasant burning of spice in his mouth and lungs 
from the saturation underground, from the cups of spice coffee he'd just finished, from the pure sample 
he'd tasted. Deep inside himself, he already felt an undeniable twinge of longing, not yet a craving but an 
insistent whisper that suggested how sweet melange would taste right now. Yes, he could envision it be-
coming an all-consuming personal need. 
He thought of the noble families and the Emperor himself panicking because their supplies were cut off. 
When Jesse had heard his name being reviled due to his apparent failure, such vitriol had not made sense 
to him, even allowing for Hoskanner rabble-rousing. He had thought that powerful forces were arrayed 
against him, influential people and alliances working to ensure his failure. Now his fingers tightened into a 
fist at his side. The Duneworld challenge had been more than a trap. It had widespread consequences that 
were more severe than he'd ever imagined. 
A commotion arose outside the laboratory, and someone pounded on the door. "My Lord," Gurney said, 
"the messenger's ornijet has just returned! He has news from General Tuek. You'd better hear it." 
Sensing something terribly wrong, Jesse hurried to face the man who bore a communique from the old 
security chief. When the messenger handed over the cylinder, Jesse grasped both ends and pulled it apart 
to display the screen and holographic recording. 
The blurry simulacrum of Esmar Tuek looked distraught, his face pummeled with grief and uncertainty. 
"My Lord, we have been attacked! The headquarters mansion was betrayed from within. All of my men 
were gassed unconscious-including me. Dr. Yueh is missing, and we fear he has been killed. And . . . 
your son has been kidnapped." 
Jesse wanted to shout at the image, but he knew questions would 
have no effect upon the recorded hologram. His throat clenched. "There is more, My Lord. It appears that 
the traitor was none other than your concubine, Dorothy Mapes, who is also missing." 
Grabbing the messenger, Jesse said, "You're flying me back to Carthage right now." He looked back at 
Gurney and barked, "You stay here and defend our melange stockpiles. This sounds like a ploy to steal the 
treasure from us-and I swear, on the sacred honor of my family, that if the Emperor has harmed my son, 
he will not live long enough to feel his withdrawal from spice." 
32 
In every relationship, one party holds leverage over the other.  It is simply a matter of degree. 
- GRAND EMPEROR INTON WUDA, 
Proclamations and Ruminations  
Flying erratically, the ornijet swept in over the mountains of 
Carthage, passing above the main spaceport where the huge Imperial inspection ship stood like a fortress. 
At the secondary spaceport across town, Jesse spotted the Emperor's opulent private yacht waiting. 
He directed the nervous pilot to go directly to a small landing zone on the roof of the headquarters 
mansion. When the ship's wings and engines had settled, Jesse flipped open the angled door and found a 



solemn-looking Esmar Tuek standing there flanked by a small honor guard. 
The old general appeared to have aged decades since Jesse had last seen him. The scab of an odd 
triangular cut marked one cheek. The reddish stains around his lips seemed different. . . more splotchy. 
Jesse feared that in his shame and despair Tuek had allowed temptation to overwhelm him. Had he 
resumed his addiction to the sapho drug? 
Tuek bowed his head, his eyes watery and forlorn. He held a small flat case with scuffed corners, as if it 
had been carried from place to place for many decades. He extended the case, opened the lid. Inside, Jesse 
saw several medals, Catalan rank insignia, as well as ribbons of longtime service to House Linkam. "I 
have failed you, My Lord. I do not deserve these tokens of honor. I have shamed you and myself." 
"What is this nonsense, Esmar?" 
"I hereby resign my post as your security chief. It is my Sincerest hope that my successor will not let you 
down in this crisis, as I have." 
Bristling, Jesse made no move to accept the box of medals. His gray eyes flashed as he stepped closer, 
then shocked Tuek by delivering a quick, sharp slap across the older man's face. "Don't be a fool, Esmar- 
and don't treat me like one! Do you think anyone could have done better than you? I cannot lose your 
skills and advice, especially now." 
"I have no honor, My Lord." 
"No one ever gained honor by running away. To regain it, you must help me rescue my son." He glowered 
at the security chief until Tuek finally lifted his gaze. Looking at the nobleman, the old man flashed a look 
of anger mixed with hope. 
Jesse lowered his voice. "I need you, Esmar. Don't make me ask again. Now, tell me exactly what 
happened, show me your evidence against Dorothy, and I will judge her guilt for myself." 
Tuek's cheek showed a scarlet mark from Jesse's blow. He stood wavering, and finally took a step 
backward. "As you command, My Lord." 
AFTER READING TUEK's report, Jesse sat alone in a small private office adjacent to his suite, his fingertips 
touching the papers as he brooded. He could neither believe nor deny the obvious conclusion: There had 
been a spy in his household. The Emperor and the Hoskanners knew too many secrets, even about the 
stockpiles of spice. Jesse 
had trouble believing that his concubine, his business manager, and the mother of his son could have 
betrayed him. His heart told him it wasn't possible. 
But the evidence seemed to offer no alternative. 
Tuek suspected the kidnapping and betrayal was a Hoskanner plot at its root, because Valdemar feared the 
Linkam stockpile had grown so large he would lose the contest. It was an act of desperation. Could the 
Emperor be involved as well? It seemed unlikely . . . but then, a lot of things seemed unlikely. 
One of the household servants appeared at the open door of the office chamber, fidgeting and clearing his 
throat. Jesse looked up with heavy, weary eyes. "I asked not to be disturbed. I must think." 
"There is a messenger, My Lord. He is carrying a ransom demand." 
Jesse sat up. "Send him in-and call General Tuek immediately." 
Tuek arrived within moments, fully clad in his most impressive military uniform. Wearing ominous 
sidearms and all his badges and medals, he stood beside Jesse as the kidnapper's representative was ush-
ered in. 
Jesse was surprised, and then sickened, to see that it was Ulla Bauers. So this was the Grand Emperor's 
scheme after all! He could have fought the Hoskanners-House against House-but the Emperor had 
brought an impossible amount of power to bear against him. 
Keeping his face hard and unreadable, with his jaw set, Jesse forced out the words. "Why does the 
Emperor's man participate in this criminal, barbarous act?" 
"Emperor Wuda sends his sincere apologies. His embarrassment is acute for being forced to resort to such, 
hmmm, medieval tactics. But you have left us no choice in the matter. Hmm-ahh, we thought concern for 
your son would bring you scurrying out of the desert where you had hidden." 
"To what purpose?" Jesse demanded. "I have done nothing wrong." 
Bauers sniffed. "Your own actions, Nobleman Linkam, are a disgrace. You brought galactic commerce to 



its knees, but not because of 
incompetence, as we thought. Instead, we know that you are hiding an illegal hoard of melange. As is 
clear in Imperial law, all stockpiles belong to the Emperor for distribution as he sees fit." 
"Is that the same Imperial law that prohibits taking noble hostages?" Tuek growled, but Jesse motioned for 
him to be quiet. 
With an effort, Jesse composed himself. "My instructions in the challenge were clear and simple: that by 
the end of two years I was to surpass Hoskanner production amounts. Never was it said that I had to 
deliver the melange as soon as I harvested it. Though your inspection ship has harassed us for months, I 
am required only to show you my total at the end. We kept our production hidden for good reason. If the 
Hoskanners knew how close we were to achieving our goal, they would have increased their sabotage 
attempts. You pride yourself on being a legal expert, Counselor Bauers. What, exactly, have I done 
wrong?" 
"You strangled the flow of spice. Our Empire depends on it. You are a loose cannon, creating turmoil for 
your own profit. You can no longer be trusted." 
"Neither can the Grand Emperor, it seems." Tuek moved to Jesse's side. 
Bauers sniffed. "These are the terms: You will immediately deliver all of your spice stockpiles and 
surrender your operations on Duneworld to Valdemar Hoskanner, who served us efficiently for many 
years. We cannot risk further instability such as you have aroused." 
Jesse met the representative's eyes. "And if I refuse?" 
"Hmmm, one cannot say exactly how the Grand Emperor will express his displeasure. However, it seems 
only your son is readily available to endure his wrath." 
"And my concubine?" 
"Hmmm, does she hold some value to you? Interesting. If you comply, the Grand Emperor may be, ahh, 
generous. We could consider her part of the bargain. They are both on his private yacht, and both are 
uninjured. At present." 
Jesse's voice was frozen metal. "You will find, Counselor Bauers, that I do not respond well to coercion." 
"Hmmm, just as the Grand Emperor does not respond well to a loss of spice." 
Jesse turned to Tuek. "General, while I consider my response, please escort the Grand Emperor's 
representative to our temporary guest quarters." 
With a faint smile, the old veteran nodded. "The small and uncomfortable ones, My Lord?" 
"Those will do fine." He looked at Bauers. 
Pretending not to be alarmed, the gaudily dressed man said, "Hmm, perhaps I wasn't clear enough, 
Nobleman. This is not a matter for negotiation. The Grand Emperor wants the spice. No other response 
will do. Holding me hostage will accomplish nothing." 
"Hostage? You are merely a guest... a guest who has just threatened to murder my son and-with no legal 
basis-ordered me to forfeit all of my family wealth. I need a little time to contemplate the treachery of 
Emperors." 
He gestured, and Esmar Tuek brusquely escorted the man away. 
THOUGH HE HAD many concerned advisors to assist him, Jesse knew that the terrible decision was his 
alone to make. 
He summoned his security chief to the office chamber, along with the men in charge of monitoring 
spaceport operations and spice distribution. "The only response to such a terrible ultimatum," Jesse began, 
"is to find an even greater threat to hold over our enemy. That is what I intend to do." 
Tuek's brow furrowed. "That could escalate the situation out of control." 
Jesse slammed his fist on the table and rose to his feet. "They threatened to kill my son!" He swept his 
gaze around the group of uneasy men. When he saw that he had them cowed, he sat down again and re-
peated in a quieter but more menacing voice, "They threatened to kill my son." 
"So what will you do, My Lord?" Tuek said. "We are prepared to follow your commands."                                                    
Taking a deep breath, Jesse looked toward a window that overlooked the city. Emperor Wuda's yacht, 
visible on the other side of dwelling complexes and habitation domes, was well guarded. Tuek had 
proposed a commando operation to swarm the craft with the best Catalan soldiers and snatch the hostage 



boy. But Jesse could only foresee disaster in such an attempt. So he played another card instead, the 
ultimate gambit. 
"Send a message to Gurney Halleck. Tell him to rig explosives laced with toxic contaminants to all of our 
spice stockpiles. Be prepared to destroy all one hundred thousand Imperial tons of concentrated melange." 
There were gasps and murmurs around the table. Each man knew that such an amount of spice would not 
only buy offworld passage for the entire population of Duneworld, but would allow them to live like 
nobles for the rest of their lives. 
Tuek nodded slowly. "That will definitely get the Grand Emperor's attention, My Lord. Which security 
code should I use for the message?" 
"No code, Esmar I want the Emperor to hear it. Tell Gurney to rig the spice harvesters and carryalls, too. 
Let's make it as hard on the Emperor as possible. If people are already rioting for spice, the nobles could 
overthrow Wuda for this." 
"You're pushing back awfully hard," Tuek said quietly. 
"It doesn't match the executioner's axe they hold over my head." Jesse narrowed his eyes. He had done 
what no other person had ever accomplished: He had gone beneath the surface of Duneworld, seen the 
interconnected spice plants and the network of struggling life in the desert, and returned alive after three 
days. Now Jesse would deliver 
an ultimatum to trump all ultimatums. "Next, Esmar, remove all the reactor drives from our fleet of ships. 
Build as many crude nuclear warheads as you can, and disperse them to the richest spice veins in the 
desert. How many drives do you think we can scavenge in the next few hours?" 
The general withheld his questions and calculated. "More than a dozen, perhaps as many as twenty." 
Jesse's face was a grim mask of determination. "Good. We need our family atomics." 
"KEEP THE CONCUBINE, Emperor," he said in a voice colder than the icecaps on Catalan. As he recorded 
his message, Jesse spoke with a righteous anger and a raw power that made his threat utterly convincing. 
"But know this-if you do not release my son unharmed, if you force my hand, I will destroy every speck 
of melange on this planet, now and forever." 
He slapped the messagestat cylinder into the hand of an alarmed and chastened-looking Ulla Bauers. 
"Make no mistake, without my son, without my title, and with the overwhelming debt I have incurred, I 
have absolutely nothing to lose." 
Jesse sent the Counselor scurrying to the Imperial yacht, then sat in the headquarters mansion and waited 
for the Emperor's response. 
33 
Duneworld is not a dead planet after all, but full of hidden and  marvelous life. Humans, however, can change that in short orde r. 
- DR. BRYCE HAYNES, Ecological Notebooks 
From the sun-filtered window in a high tower of the mansion, Jesse looked across the rooftops and crags of 
Carthage toward the secondary spaceport. His message had been delivered to the Grand Emperor six hours 
ago, but so far the Imperial yacht remained silent and ominous. Gurney Halleck had sent confirmation that 
all stockpile silos, hidden cave caches, spice harvesters, and carryalls had been rigged with conventional 
explosives and toxic contaminants. Jesse did not doubt the spice foreman would destroy it all if given the 
command. In a maddeningly cheery voice, Gurney added over the open channel that his inventory  
calculations  had  actually underestimated  the  stores  of melange-when fully compiled, all the hidden 
storehouses actually held an extra four thousand Imperial tons. It was an added twist of the dagger into the 
Emperor's side. 
Esmar Tuek had used their nuclear engines to create seventeen dirty atomic warheads, which had been 
dispersed to the richest spice sands, where they could be remotely detonated on a moment's notice. 
Emperor Wuda and his advisors knew that Jesse was not bluffing. . . . 
Dr. Haynes became frantic when he learned about the desperate tactics. The planetary ecologist sent an 
urgent message from the forward base. "This is not a game, Nobleman Linkam! The Grand Emperor is 
deadly serious, and I don't think he'll back down." 
"Neither will I." 
"Nuclear fallout will destroy the spice cycle, break the biological chain, and make the sandworms and 



spice plants extinct. You could wipe it all out forever!" 
"I hold my son in the highest possible regard," Jesse said icily, forcing the scientist to believe his intent. 
"If the Emperor harms him, he will pay the price, even if it costs the ecosystem of this planet and the 
industry on which the Empire is addicted." Abruptly, he terminated the communication and went back to 
waiting. 
With a heavy heart, Jesse understood that if Haynes was correct, if most of the nobility really were fatally 
addicted to melange-including Jesse himself-then his action would be a death sentence upon most of 
the leaders in the Empire. The subsequent political turmoil would be unimaginable. 
No, Jesse was not bluffing. 
He thought of his compliant father and his ridiculous brother. Maybe it was for the best, Jesse thought, if 
the Known Universe was finally cleansed of the decadent and parasitic noble families. Recent events had 
proved beyond any possible doubt that "nobles" and "honor" were not necessarily related. 
He had meant to win the challenge fairly. He had intended to divulge the shock-canister technique for 
harvesting larger amounts of spice, present the Emperor with his share of the huge stockpiles, and claim 
his victory. But House Linkam had never been meant to win. 
From the very beginning, the Grand Emperor, House Hoskanner, even much of the Nobles' Council had 
set him up to fail. 
My enemies underestimated me. 
Looking out on the dusty city and the desert beyond, Jesse longed for greenery as wide as the rice-paddy 
region of his beloved Catalan. He wanted to hear the trickle of rain and smell the iodine sea, hear the 
waves crash against jagged rocks, the laughter and songs of fishermen coming in with nets swollen from 
their catch. He had grown tired of the rattlesnake whisperings of blowing sand on barren Duneworld, and 
the odors of dust, sweat, and melange. 
He ached with grief. Still clinging to an irrational hope that it might have been a trick, that someone had 
framed Dorothy, he wished she could be at his side. Despite all he had heard, he didn't know if he could 
live without her. 
As the sky shifted into a pastel sunset, soft orange colors glinted off the Emperor's yacht. The first 
shadows of dusk began to creep outward from the tall mountains. Still nothing but silence. 
His heart heavy, Jesse imagined Barri held in a prison cell. And Dorothy, too? Or had she sold her 
allegiance to the Emperor, to the Hoskanners, or to both? Desperately, Jesse wanted everything back the 
way it had been a scant two years ago: he, his son, and Dorothy, running the family operations on Catalan, 
content with realistic ambitions instead of the folly of Duneworld. He had never wanted to come here in 
the first place. . . . 
Without warning, the Emperor's yacht exploded. 
The sky lit up in a massive fireball, and Jesse jumped back from the window. A moment after the flash, a 
resounding boom slammed the thick windows of the observation tower. The shockwave vibrated the plaz 
as if someone had struck a dulcimer with a heavy mallet. Objects rattled in the room and fell off tables and 
shelves, crashing to the floor. 
At the landing field, a powerful detonation had blasted out the sides of the gaudily armored hull. The 
white-hot flames of ignited fuel burned like cutting torches, tearing through walls and bulkheads, 
shattering windowports, spraying debris high into the air. A secondary eruption drove blue-and-orange 
flames into the inferno, blasting a pillar of fire skyward. 
Moments later, Tuek ran into the room, his face florid, his eyes wide. "My Lord, did you see-" 
Jesse reeled, breathing hard, unable to find words. He gestured listlessly toward the window. Outside, 
debris rained from the sky. 
The nobleman brought a mounted telescope around and with shaking hands trained it on the landing field. 
Heavy frameworks bent and tilted, then crashed over into the flames. Several dead Imperial guards lay 
strewn like broken toys across the armorpave field. Interminable minutes passed before Carthage 
emergency crews arrived and went to work with chemical extinguishers. The entire yacht was incinerated. 
Jesse's knees turned to powder and could no longer support him. He slumped into a chair, almost missing 
the seat, but caught himself. He sat back, so numb he was unable to weep, and unable to absorb the im-



mense scale of the tragedy. 
Dorothy and Barri, both aboard the yacht, had been annihilated in the horrendous conflagration-along 
with the Emperor. 
DURING THE SPICE challenge, Jesse Linkam had fought impossible odds and finally figured out a way to 
earn his victory. Now he wanted to squeeze until he crushed his enemies. His broken heart was held to-
gether only by stitches of revenge. 
Despite his grief and shock, Jesse was his own man, more wily than his father or brother had been, more 
able to survive in the face of adversity. He still had the leverage to escape the numerous traps arrayed 
against him, but he needed to remain rational and strong, not allowing his emotional side to take over. 
From Dr. Haynes, he now understood that control of Duneworld's 
melange provided more leverage than any other House held. He who controls the spice controls the Known 
Universe, Jesse thought. 
With innocent Barri dead, he now stood as the only survivor of House Linkam. He despised the 
incomprehensible treachery that had rendered him as cold and calculating as any of his so-called "noble" 
enemies. ...                                                                              * 
Less than half an hour after the explosion, a contrite and distraught Ulla Bauers rushed to the headquarters 
mansion, as if hoping to prevent Jesse from overreacting to the disaster. 
In the austere parlor on the main floor, Jesse regarded the ferretlike man with disdain, wishing Bauers had 
been killed in the explosion as well. His dark blue coat and billowing shirt had ashes on them, which he 
tried to brush off as he stood there. 
"What do you want?" Jesse's words were like knives. He wanted to kill this wretched Imperial spokesman 
who had shoved all possible acceptable outcomes over a sheer cliff. 
Bauers started to smile, then seemed to think better of it and formed a thin, straight line with his mouth. "I 
come bearing good news, Nobleman Linkam! The Grand Emperor himself is safe after the horrific 
explosion of the Imperial yacht. At the last moment, he was informed of a deadly Hoskanner assassination 
plot upon his person and managed to shuttle over to the inspection ship, just in time. He escaped only 
moments before the bombs detonated." 
"A Hoskanner assassination plot?" Jesse's rough voice oozed skepticism. 
"Yes, Nobleman." 
"And what about my son and my concubine?" 
"Ahh, I am very sorry. Despite rescue efforts, there were no survivors aboard the yacht. How could there 
have been?" 
"Yes," Jesse said, his heart sinking once more. He clenched and unclenched his fists, wanting to strangle 
the man with his bare hands. "How could there have been? Very convenient, don't you think?" 
"The Grand Emperor expresses his deep regret that these discussions 
got out of hand. It was Valdemar Hoskanner who suggested the idea of kidnapping your son. I assure you, 
the Emperor never intended to harm the boy in any way. You are, after all, his noble cousin." 
"Noble? He is not noble! My son is dead because of him." 
"Hmmm, a casualty of the foul Hoskanner plot, I'm afraid. Nothing to do with the Grand Emperor. It 
seems Valdemar planned to kill the Emperor, disgrace the Linkam family, and seize the Imperial throne 
for himself, along with all spice production. The Emperor was deceived. He is quite pained at the misery 
you must be going through." Bauers bent in a formal bow. "With sincere apologies, he begs your 
forgiveness. He wants to make amends, somehow. Provided you release your hoard-after keeping an 
appropriate profit for House Linkam-you will be allowed to maintain control of spice operations here on 
Duneworld." 
"My son is dead, and the Emperor wishes to bargain with me?" Jesse drew himself up, feeling the burn of 
anger. 
"Your son is dead because of Valdemar Hoskanner." 
Jesse wanted to spit. "Really? And what is to become of Valdemar Hoskanner, if he is such a despicable 
criminal?" 
"Ahh, the Grand Emperor has already signed a decree that his House is to be stripped of all power and 



possessions." The prissy man risked a broad smile. "So you see, Nobleman, justice will be done. From 
now on, you will have control of all the Duneworld spice operations. The Grand Emperor is willing to 
offer a great many other concessions, provided of course that you withdraw your threat of destroying the 
melange hoard and, hmmm, remove all atomics from the spice fields." 
Jesse narrowed his eyes. He didn't believe a word of it, strongly suspecting that the Emperor and Bauers 
had concocted a scheme to frame the Hoskanners-thus they could claim complete innocence while still 
getting their spice. The Counselor waited in fidgety silence; once, he swallowed so hard it was audible. 
But House Linkam would not surrender. Aflame with hatred, Jesse meant to make them pay until it hurt 
all the way to their bones. The 
raw Imperial politics they had directed against him would not pass unnoticed, or unpunished. He would 
make his enemies suffer for their actions. "What will happen to the holdings of House Hoskanner?" 
Bauers looked uncomfortable, as if he had hoped Jesse would not think of that detail. "Hmmm, perhaps 
they should be divided equally between House Linkam and the Grand Emperor." 
"Not acceptable," Jesse snapped. "It seems that Valdemar Hoskanner killed my only son and heir. The 
Grand Emperor himself admits this. For my suffering, I claim the right of vengeance. If Valdemar is truly 
to blame, then all of his holdings are forfeit. To me." 
Bauers fidgeted. "Hmm, ah. I shall discuss that with Emperor Wuda." 
Jesse leaned forward. "It is not a matter for discussion, Counselor. That is my ultimatum. If you want me 
to remove the atomic threat from the spice fields and disengage the booby traps from our large 
stockpiles-" He glanced over at Tuek. "How much spice was it again?" 
"One hundred four thousand Imperial tons of melange, My Lord," the old veteran responded. "Packaged, 
processed, and ready for delivery. Unless you decide to destroy it." 
Unblinking, Jesse stared at the Imperial representative. He felt sick inside, knowing that the ache of his 
personal loss would never go away, regardless of any concessions he received now. He didn't want the 
spice holdings, control of Duneworld, or the Hoskanner family fortunes. But he did want the Emperor to 
feel the sting and pay for his part in the tragedy, even if he claimed to have been duped himself. "Do we 
have a deal?" 
The representative bowed slightly. "Agreed, Nobleman Linkam. Accept our congratulations for winning 
the challenge. You have indeed surpassed the Hoskanner output, and made your place in history on this 
day." 
Jesse bit back a retort. He would gladly give up his place in history if he could just have his son back. 
After Bauers departed, Jesse sat feeling stunned, wanting only to be alone. Old Tuek stood beside him, 
seemingly filled with words and wanting to comfort his lord. But he remained silent. 
Jesse did not feel at all victorious. 
34 
There is nothing more satisfying than a vanquished foe. 
- VALDEMAR HOSKANNER 
Shortly before the Emperor's yacht exploded, Dr. Cullington Yueh had been on board in a "secured" cabin 
where no outsiders could see him. Certainly, the Linkams would want to kill him as a traitor. 
As a result of Yueh's betrayals, Emperor Wuda and the Hoskanners had gotten what they wanted, but the 
old surgeon no longer believed his wife would be returned to him. Even if Wanna did miraculously 
survive, he could never admit to his wife what he had done to get her released. The shame of it would be 
too great. 
Responding to a summons from the Grand Emperor, the agitated doctor had been permitted to leave his 
cabin. Two guards had escorted him into the audience chamber, telling him to wait until Wuda chose to 
see him. Alone except for his conscience, Yueh fidgeted beside an 
elegantly adorned porthole, an oval set in a delicately worked gold frame. 
Gazing blankly out at the city, the old doctor thought about how the aggressive bastards had met their 
match in Nobleman Linkam. Instead of bowing to the Emperor's ultimatum after the kidnapping, Jesse had 
countered with a devastating threat of his own. 
Stalemate. The Emperor seemed not to understand the harsh decisions a person might be driven to make 



when he had nothing left to lose. Yueh knew that all too well himself. He wished he could have been so 
strong. Now he worried about Barri and Dorothy, and hated himself for his role in what had happened to 
them. He was supposed to be a healer. How could he ever justify putting their lives at risk? 
Now, why was the Emperor taking so long, and why had he summoned Yueh here? The yacht's elegant 
chamber was silent. . . much too silent. 
The doctor had misjudged many things. When he'd arranged for the kidnappers to gain entry to the 
mansion, he had tried to tell himself that the boy would not be harmed, that Jesse would simply yield, and 
that everything would work out for the best. But after his own years of service to House Linkam, Yueh 
should have known the nobleman better than that. 
Impatient, he looked down at the armorpave landing field and was surprised to see the corpulent Grand 
Emperor hurrying away from the yacht, accompanied by the tall and imposing Valdemar Hoskanner, the 
fidgety and overdressed Bauers, and a small entourage. 
A sudden, inexplicable panic swept over Yueh. They had ordered him here and told him to wait, making 
certain he would stay where he was. 
His mind went numb as he sensed terrible forces aligned against him, dark secrets spinning within even 
darker secrets. Looking toward the chamber entry, he saw that the guards weren't there any longer, either. 
Something was going to happen. He had to leave, quickly! Then he 
remembered his pledge of honor to Dorothy. She and Barri Linkam were being kept in a sealed holding 
chamber aboard the yacht. 
Yueh hurried out into the disturbingly empty main corridor and followed the circular floor plan at a full 
run. Seeing no one, he went up a level and raced toward the holding compartments. He unsealed the 
exterior lock and entered a large, unadorned room that dominated the center of the deck. 
"Barri!" he called. "Where is your mother?" 
At a machine inside, the boy was playing an electronic game, totally preoccupied by it. His unruly brown 
hair was even more mussed than usual. He looked at the doctor with disinterest, then pointed toward an 
inside doorway, before turning back to his game. It seemed to be the only thing to keep the alert boy's 
mind occupied in the austere enclosure. 
With a mounting sense of foreboding, Yueh found Dorothy Mapes in a small room. Although her face was 
red, her mouth drawn, and her chest heaving as if she was shouting, he could not hear a sound. Her hands 
were pressed against an unseen barrier that separated them, and her eyes held the same panic that he 
himself felt. 
Dorothy pointed urgently at something to the doctor's right, a control panel on the wall. Yueh began 
pressing the buttons, entering release codes. Suddenly the silence melted away, and he heard Dorothy 
scream her son's name. "Barri!" 
With the containment field released, she fell forward onto the floor, then scrambled to her feet and ran 
toward the large central room. "Let's go! Barri, come with me-now!" 
The boy's expression fell. "Mother! I'm close to winning!" He kept playing feverishly. 
Yueh grabbed Barri and jerked him away from the machine. "We need to get off the ship! After they 
ordered me to stay aboard, I saw the Emperor and Valdemar Hoskanner fleeing the yacht. Oh, something 
terrible is going to happen!" 
"They're trying to assassinate my son!" Dorothy said, as they hurried into the corridor. "He's the heir to 
House Linkam, and they want him out of the way. When I overheard them, Bauers sealed me in the cell." 
Reaching one of the small emergency hatches, they unsealed it and dropped more than a meter to the 
landing field. Barri stumbled to his knees, but the old doctor helped him up, and the three of them kept 
going. They ran at breakneck speed across the hot armorpave surface, terrified they would be seen, and 
shot. 
Yueh raced around to the side of a small terminal. Under an overhang behind the building, he husked, 
"Get down! Maybe they won't see us." He pressed Dorothy and her son into the shelter and huddled beside 
them. 
"I don't see any guards at all," Dorothy said. 
A huge explosion cracked the air, and pieces of the Emperor's yacht rained from the sky. Yueh heard 



fragments pelting the overhang above them, and the thunk-thunk of debris striking the ground. 
Barri and Dorothy wanted to flee, but the doctor held them back. "We must stay here and hide, exercising 
more caution than ever. Our only advantage right now is to let them think they've succeeded." 
JESSE STOOD IN the sunlit high tower, his heart and thoughts hardened by grief. The cataclysm had been 
too sudden, and the immensity of his personal loss had not yet sunk in. During the aftermath he'd tried to 
keep going, to stay on the course he had set even before knowing the addictive nature of melange. 
Now, more than ever, he was willing to do what must be done. He would participate in an Imperial system 
he hated, playing politics in order to make his enemies squirm, and in the process he would become more 
and more like them. Back when his secret spice hoard had started mounting every day, along with the 
conviction that he might actually 
win the challenge, Jesse had begun to experience a feeling of raw power. It had been heady territory. 
And as the reality of losing Barri and Dorothy became inescapable, he concluded that neither his melange 
stockpile, nor victory in the challenge, nor that feeling of power mattered. Instead, he felt like a beaten 
man whose only future lay in an empty victory. 
The Grand Emperor had offered him a deal, pretending that a hefty reward and continuing control of the 
spice industry somehow made up for the deaths of Barri and Dorothy. The Emperor thought he'd won, 
considered himself safe and secure again now that he'd blamed and ruined Valdemar Hoskanner. And 
Jesse had implied that would be good enough. 
Now he felt ill about it. 
Opening the moisture-sealed door, he stepped out into the hot, desiccated air on the high balcony. From 
there, he could use a longdistance transceiver to reach Gurney Halleck, who still waited at the spice 
stockpile silos, and General Tuek, whose men remained ready at the spice fields with their remote 
detonation devices on atomic warheads. Neither of them would question any decision Jesse might make. 
He depressed the activation button on the communicator. "Gurney, Esmar-I need you to be strong. I need 
you to do what must be done." 
The two men quickly acknowledged, waiting for explicit orders from the nobleman. With a single 
command, Jesse could obliterate a year's worth of spice production and contaminate the richest melange 
fields for centuries, perhaps even destroy the spice cycle of the planet. The nobles, the addicts, the 
hedonists would all die from horrible withdrawal, and the Emperor could shrivel along with them all. If 
Dr. Haynes was right, the Empire itself could crumble-and Jesse didn't give a damn. 
For him, everything had vanished in the single blast aboard the Emperor's yacht. 
In front of him on the high balcony, the drop to the tangled streets of Carthage seemed hypnotic. With one 
easy step, he could plunge 
over the edge. Noble House Linkam had been doomed from the moment Valdemar had offered the 
challenge. How had he ever imagined he could stand against such forces? 
"Gurney, the booby traps on the stockpiles. I want you to-" 
Something caught his eye far below: Three bedraggled forms hurried furtively toward the front entrance of 
the mansion, as if seeking safety inside. It looked like an old man and two smaller figures. 
Jesse's hands gripped the railing, and he lost sight of them as they slipped into the mansion through a 
discreet servants' entrance. 
"My Lord?" Gurney's voice sounded very worried. "What should I do? Do you really want me to-" 
"Gurney, stand by!" He looked down again, squinting, feeling his heart pound in his chest and cursing 
himself for so easily leaping at even a ridiculous thread of hope. He ran back inside and shouted for the 
house guards. 
IN THE RECEPTION hall, a shamefaced Dr. Yueh stood before Jesse Linkam. His eyes downcast, the 
household surgeon revealed his role in the kidnapping plot and proclaimed Dorothy's innocence. Though 
the old doctor offered no excuses, the concubine spoke on his behalf, explaining how the Hoskanners had 
imprisoned and tortured Yueh's wife in order to force his betrayal, and how Yueh had saved them. 
Now, Jesse knew that the defeated and disgraced Hoskanners would strike out in vengeful fury before they 
turned their holdings over to House Linkam. Since the Hoskanners believed the household traitor to be 
dead in the explosion, Wanna Yueh was no longer of any use to them. With a sinking sensation, Jesse felt 



sure that Valdemar Hoskanner had already killed the poor woman, and not swiftly or painlessly. 
The distraught surgeon said, "I have completed my pledge to your concubine, though that does not make 
up for my disgraceful deeds. Oh, even Wanna would never have agreed with what I did." 
Jesse said in a steady voice, "I have always considered you a decent man, Cullington. You betrayed me 
and my family . . . but if not through you, my enemies would have found some other way to destroy me. 
Despite the unconscionable things you did, still my family is alive because of you. I will never forget that 
you abandoned your loyalty to House Linkam. But I grant you your life." 
Yueh kept his gaze down. Tears streamed down the old man's face. "I thank you, My Lord, but no one will 
grant my Wanna her life. So in the end I gained nothing by betraying you." 
Placing a hand on Yueh's shoulder, Jesse said, "Redemption will come for both of us. I promise you that." 
35 
Wealth and power are the great dividers of men. Those who attain them are not always the victors. 
- NOBLEMAN JESSE LINKAM 
Jesse waited, but he did not forgive. 
 Grand Emperor Inton Wuda was a survivor of the highest order, in possession of skills that seemed 
ingrained into his Imperial lineage. In the aftermath of the thwarted plot, he shifted any shadow of blame 
away from himself. Jesse did not believe the man for an instant, but he held his tongue. He observed 
warily, while keeping his family and himself safe. 
All culpability for the "spice crisis" conveniently fell on the shoulders of Valdemar Hoskanner and his 
closest allies. All Hoskanner wealth was stripped away and transferred to House Linkam, as Ulla Bauers 
had promised, on behalf of the Emperor. The disgraced Hoskanners were left even worse off than William 
English's grandfather had been. 
And the Emperor's "indignant revenge" didn't end there. A pair of unpopular heads of smaller Noble 
Houses were blamed for starting spice riots on various planets, and their holdings were forfeited to him. 
Interestingly, their confiscated wealth slightly exceeded what the Linkams received from the dissolution 
of House Hoskanner. 
As a show of good faith, Counselor Bauers offered to take General Tuek on a tour of all levels of the 
inspection ship. In arranging the visit, the security chief had played the role of a curious aficionado, telling 
Bauers that House Linkam might use its newfound wealth to build a fleet of such vessels to transport 
melange cargoes across space. After seeing the interior of the huge ship, the old veteran was relieved to 
report to Jesse that none of the suspected massed troops were hidden there after all. The vessel's sheer size 
was apparently only for the purpose of intimidation. 
Jesse maintained his distance from the Grand Emperor, as one would from a contagious plague victim. At 
first, he had thought the pale and overweight leader was an easily manipulated fool, but now he realized 
how easily Wuda discarded anyone who no longer served his purposes. No doubt, Valdemar Hoskanner 
had thought the Emperor was wrapped around his finger, and now he'd been ruined. Wuda was the 
ultimate fair-weather friend. No matter what rewards or promises the Emperor offered, Jesse would never 
trust him. Never. 
For weeks, while representatives wrapped up details of the new agreement, the Emperor remained aboard 
the inspection ship, which became something of a temporary Imperial capital. He summoned noblemen 
from far and wide, but Jesse felt little forgiveness toward them, either. Still angry with many of the nobles 
for forcing him to be their champion and then abandoning him when he needed their help and finances, he 
pointedly did not invite any of them into the headquarters mansion. Instead, they stayed in improvised 
guest quarters on the inspection ship and around Carthage, all of them looking hungry for more and more 
spice. 
The noblemen who had provided loans at usurious rates were paid in full, and then turned away from 
Duneworld; Jesse had silently vowed not to do business with them again. On the other hand, the three 
poor families who had gambled on House Linkam, by lending all the money they could afford, were well 
rewarded. Jesse intended to let them participate in some of the spice operations and profits. 
In a new agreement hammered out by the Emperor's lawyers, House Linkam would be paid extremely 
well for managing the melange operations. But when Dorothy led him through the intricacies of the 



complicated profit-sharing formula, Jesse was not surprised to see that the Grand Emperor's coffers would 
receive at least twice as much as House Linkam. Even so, the tally for each of them was enormous. 
The newfound melange wealth would be more than sufficient to repair all the financial damage that 
generations of mismanagement had inflicted on House Linkam, while making the family business im-
pregnable. However, Jesse intended to measure success by his own sense of justice, not by mere economic 
standards. 
WHEN THE GRAND Emperor asked to come to dinner at the mansion, Jesse could not turn the man down, 
nor could he object to his bringing Counselor Bauers along. So one evening, by arrangement, Wuda and 
his companion swept into the great house with a contingent of personal guards. Leaving the guards out in 
the corridor, the pair were led by a uniformed servant into the banquet hall. 
Already seated for the meal, Jesse gave Dorothy a tight-lipped smile across the long table. They had 
assumed their customary places of honor, despite the imminent arrival of the important visitors. The Em-
peror and his man were shown to secondary seats, which displeased each of them, from the downturned 
expressions on their faces. Still, 
they said nothing, and smiled when Jesse rose to his feet and greeted them. At the same time, Dorothy 
stood and bowed stiffly. 
"Good evening, gentlemen," Jesse said, and promptly sat back down, as did his concubine. Both of them 
felt very uncomfortable being in the same room with the shiftless Imperial leader and his equally un-
trustworthy inspector. 
A procession of serving women carried in steaming plates of rock pheasant, along with side dishes. This 
fowl had become a favorite of Jesse's-at least, as far as desert fare went. They were small birds, so it took 
three of them to fill each plate. But they were quite succulent, and much enhanced by one of the chef's 
Catalan recipes. 
As the diners ate, hardly a word was spoken. Despite wanting to be civil to these influential men, Jesse 
was not really in any mood for chitchat, not after all he had been put through. Besides, it seemed to him 
that Wuda had invited himself, so he should be the one to select the topic of conversation. The four of 
them exchanged uncomfortable glances around the table, while servants looked on, obviously ill at ease 
themselves. 
When they finished the main course and the plates were taken away, the Grand Emperor said, "There is 
one final matter of pressing importance. My prosecutors have completed a criminal investigation, and I 
have decided on appropriate punishments." Reaching for a silver goblet of spice wine, he gazed 
dispassionately around the table, and took a sip. 
Jesse's pulse accelerated as the withering Imperial gaze settled upon him. He wondered if the corpulent 
leader had found a legal way to break their bargain after all. "Oh?" 
The Emperor raised his free hand, and his personal guard contingent left their stations out in the corridor 
and entered the hall. Six armed men with projectile weapons slung over their shoulders took up positions 
around the banquet table, two of them behind Jesse, two behind Dorothy, and two behind Bauers. Their 
royal blue uniforms were highlighted with crimson piping, like a thin flow of blood. 
Esmar Tuek burst into the banquet hall, heading a larger force of Catalan house soldiers. Though the 
Emperor's guards were surrounded by at least three times their number, they did not flinch. Jesse sat rigid 
and cold, sure that he had been betrayed again. 
Calmly, Wuda took another sip of wine and said, "In our universe, nothing is ever as it seems, is it?" He 
addressed Tuek from his chair. "My guard captain has explained the situation to you, General Tuek?" 
"Your captain has given me his word of honor that there will be no tricks. Yet by my sworn duty, Sire, I 
must hear the promise from your own lips." 
"You have my Imperial pledge," Wuda said, frowning impatiently. "No deceptions. No harm will come to 
Nobleman Linkam or his concubine." 
Tuek whispered in Jesse's ear. "We are forced to entertain a highly unwelcome guest, My Lord." 
Again, the Grand Emperor raised his hand, and Valdemar Hoskanner strode in, unshackled and wearing 
extravagant clothes that dripped with golden chains and jewels. He acted as if he still owned the rugged 
mansion he had built. Hoskanner was followed by six Imperial guards and, behind them, even more of 



Jesse's own house contingent. At the Emperor's command, another chair was brought to the table, and the 
vile Hoskanner patriarch was seated next to Bauers. 
Jesse glared daggers at his mortal enemy, but the arrogant man did not deign to notice him. 
"Now that it's time for dessert," the Emperor announced, "I thought we'd invite my esteemed colleague to 
join us." 
When Jesse looked closer, however, though he tried to appear haughty and in control, Valdemar looked 
like a cornered animal. His dark eyes darted this way and that, not settling on anyone or anything. 
Servers brought in elegant plates of Catalanian layer cake that looked like an intricate cross section of 
colorful geological strata. It had been a favorite of Jesse's own foppish father, the very dessert that 
had poisoned him when prepared by the wrong hands. 
"Oh, how marvelous!" Wuda exclaimed. "Isn't it magnificent, Valdemar?" 
"Yes, Sire. In a ... rustic fashion." 
As the diners consumed sumptuous portions of cake, the Emperor, Bauers, and Valdemar began to 
exchange casual conversation, while Jesse sat coolly formal. The visitors drank fine red wines, ate sweets, 
and told old stories. Jesse was disturbed to note relaxation in the voice and demeanor of the beleaguered 
Valdemar, even after he had supposedly been stripped of all of his possessions. 
When the desserts were finished, more wine was poured. Then the Emperor nodded toward the captain of 
his guard. Four uniformed men took positions behind Ulla Bauers and Valdemar Hoskanner. 
The soldiers brought out glittering wire garrotes from their uniforms. 
Bauers looked over his shoulder, suddenly alarmed. "Hmm, ahhh, Sire-what is this?" 
"So they've found you out, after all." Valdemar's voice was brittle and resigned, as if he had been squeezed 
of all emotion during his confinement. 
Jesse stared in surprise and shock at the Imperial theatrics. 
Casually, the Grand Emperor's forefinger pointed from Hoskanner to Bauers like a metronome, back and 
forth, as if playing a childish game of chance, trying to decide which man to choose. The finger came to 
rest, pointing directly at Valdemar Hoskanner. 
"So," Valdemar said to the plump Emperor. "This is our final exchange?" 
"Regrettably so," Wuda said. "You have engaged in behavior unbecoming of a nobleman, and in the 
process you almost destroyed the spice, Duneworld, and House Linkam. For your unpardonable acts, your 
Noble House shall forever live in infamy. We are adding your family name to the Imperial Dictionary as 
an interesting new noun. 'Hoskanner: A disgraced nobleman.'" 
Already defeated, Valdemar did not respond. 
"Thus I grant you an odd sort of immortality," Wuda said. "At least you have left your indelible mark on 
history, unlike so many people who are soon forgotten, as if they never lived at all." 
With a feral smile, Valdemar tilted his head so that one of the soldiers could more easily slip the sharp 
wire around his neck. It took only seconds. He slumped, then fell onto the floor, taking the chair over with 
him. 
Across the table, Bauers had turned gray, fidgeting more than ever. The Emperor said in a strangely 
reassuring voice, "The same fate is not in store for you, Counselor." 
Bauers looked relieved until the second guard reached down and yanked back his voluminous black collar 
to reveal a tiny gray tattoo in the shape of a horned cobra, the symbol of House Hoskanner. 
Jesse shouted, rising to his feet. From behind him, he heard Tuek and his men engage their weapons. 
Dorothy looked at the Counselor's neck. "I saw part of that mark earlier, but I didn't know what it was!" 
The Emperor gestured casually, and the guard whipped the garrote around Bauers's throat. The ferretlike 
man gasped and thrashed. "You said . . . you said I wouldn't. . ." 
"I said the same fate is not in store for you. Oh, you'll still be executed, but we won't bother to reserve a 
place in history for you, Ulla. You'll simply be forgotten." Bauers gurgled and clawed so much that he 
probably heard little of what the Emperor continued to say. 
Looking down the table, Jesse saw that Dorothy did not squirm in her chair as she watched, though her 
face bore a squeamish expression. She met his gaze, and he saw no pleasure in it, only sadness. 
"The whole affair was a debacle from the start," Wuda said to the struggling man, "and you nearly caused 



my Empire to fall. Your idea of the spice challenge, the threats you advised me to make, your participation 
in the kidnapping plan." 
Bauers kicked and squirmed, tugging on the sharp cord until his fingers were as bloody as his neck. 
"I am very sorry, Ulla, but how can I ever accept your counsel again?" 
Though Bauers took longer to die, soon the guards dumped his body beside Valdemar's on the floor. 
"Well, that was the special dessert I planned," the Grand Emperor said. "Anyone for aperitifs?" 
Showing no emotion, though his insides roiled, Jesse summoned a server to bring the after-dinner drinks, 
while the Emperor's guards dragged the two bodies away. 
"Such a shame," the fleshy leader mused. "All this time, I thought he was working for me. I only learned 
about the tattoo yesterday, and immediately placed him under surveillance. You see, I am as much of a 
victim in this conspiracy as you are." 
"Faulty advice is always dangerous," Jesse said. 
"You and I will have to work more closely together in the future, Nobleman," Wuda said. "I assure you, 
there will be no more problems between us." 
"That is my sincere wish." Jesse wanted to say a great deal more, but his prudent side made him keep his 
silence. He and Dorothy had decided to spend the greater part of the year at his Catalan holdings, leaving 
Gurney Halleck on Duneworld as spice foreman. They had already begun to make quiet plans to build up 
the riches and power of House Linkam, and form solid alliances with a few members of the Nobles' 
Council, to assemble defenses against the scheming Grand Emperor. 
In a way, Jesse found it ironic that he was using techniques he had learned from observing Wuda himself. 
The pasty man had an innocuous appearance but was in reality extremely sharp, observant, and ma-
nipulative, with a seemingly inexhaustible repertoire of schemes. His treacheries had folded and tangled 
together, leaving a difficult trail to 
follow-one that Jesse would take some time to unravel, if he ever could. This much seemed clear: The 
way Wuda worked it, he always placed himself in position to rake in the spoils. 
If Jesse had lost the challenge, Valdemar would have paid the Emperor huge bribes, and everything would 
have gone back to the way it had been. When Jesse won instead, the Emperor successfully destroyed the 
powerful House Hoskanner, which might have posed a threat to his throne. In addition, the challenge 
forced House Linkam to develop an innovation in spice-harvesting methods that the Hoskanners would 
never have bothered to attempt. Now melange exports from Duneworld would dramatically increase. 
Wheels within wheels, Jesse thought. I have much to learn, to protect my House. 
There were few people in this universe the nobleman could truly trust. He could count them on the fingers 
of both hands. Or one. Gurney, Esmar, Dorothy. Dorothy. A tremendous, undeniable impulse came over 
him. 
When the sweet wines were arrayed before them, the customary choice of three stemmed glasses for each 
of the diners, Jesse raised a glass and said, "I have an announcement of my own, Sire. A toast to my 
news!" 
"And what is that?" the Grand Emperor inquired in the most erudite of tones, as if he had just deigned to 
speak directly to an underling. 
Knowing that Dorothy had not betrayed him and had only been trying to save their son, Jesse decided to 
throw caution and time-honored traditions to the winds. He had made the Emperor wealthier than his 
wildest dreams, and that should put him in a sympathetic mood. 
Taking a deep breath for courage, Jesse looked down the table at her. "Dorothy Mapes, you are my 
concubine, the mother of my son, and my loyal companion, but I'm afraid that is no longer sufficient for 
me." He spoke as if no one existed in the entire universe except the two of them. 
She stared at him, her expression a mixture of sadness and love, as if 
she knew what he was about to say. She had always said she expected him to choose a woman from a 
powerful family, joining their Houses in a noble marriage. Now that he had control of Duneworld and all 
of the melange operations, Jesse would receive many such offers. 
Then he stunned her. "Will you become my wife?" 
"But. . . that's not possible, Jesse. You know it." 



"House Linkam cannot exist without you, my love," Jesse insisted, "and I cannot live without you. The 
nobles may be addicted to spice and power, but I am addicted to you." 
Unexpected tears sparkled in Dorothy's eyes, and Jesse hurried down the table to her. She looked up at 
him, then became harder and more sensible. "No, Jesse. I am a mere concubine, without any noble blood. 
You and I can never marry. I will not be the ruin of your great House!" 
He turned a sharp, implacable look toward the plump Wuda. "I'm certain our Grand Emperor will give us 
a special dispensation. As he's told us before, he is the embodiment of Imperial law. The Emperor can 
change it whenever he sees fit to do so." 
Inton Wuda gave a bored wave of assent as he sampled the second liqueur. Obviously, he had expected 
news of more significance. "I think you're a fool, Linkam, but it's the least troublesome request you have 
made in some time." 
Jesse sipped from a small glass of melange distillate, warming his mouth and throat. Setting the drink 
down, he held her and looked into her myrtle-brown eyes. "Marrying you may not be the best political 
path for House Linkam, but forget all that, Dor! After what we've just achieved, we can certainly 
overcome a few mutterings at court." 
She looked at him for a long moment. "If My Lord insists ..." 
He kissed her, and her mouth tasted like spice. 
"From this day forward, you shall be known as Lady Dorothy Linkam," he said. "True nobility is not a 
birthright-it must be earned" 
"THEY STOPPED THE MOVING SANDS" 
In 1957, Frank Herbert chartered a small plane and flew to Florence, Oregon, to write a magazine article 
about a research project being conducted by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The USDA had 
discovered a successful method of stabilizing sand dunes, planting poverty grasses on the crests of dunes 
to keep them from encroaching on roads and buildings. Experts were traveling to Florence from all over 
the world to see the project, since many areas were experiencing problems similar to those occurring in 
the Sahara Desert, where advancing sands were causing severe damage. Frank Herbert was very excited 
about the article, which he titled "They Stopped the Moving Sands." He sent a detailed outline to his 
agent, Lurton Blassingame, along with photographs. 
The agent expressed only lukewarm interest and refused to send it 
out to publishers until it was reworked. Ultimately, Frank Herbert lost enthusiasm for the magazine article, 
and it was never published. It formed the beginning, however, of more than five years of intense research 
and writing that would culminate in Dune. 
Here, for the first time, we are pleased to publish Frank Herbert's notes for the magazine article.                                            
from the desk of FRANK HERBERT 
July 11, 1957 
Dear Lurton, 
Enclosed are some pix to explain an article I'd like to have queried around. Briefly, it involves the control 
of sand dunes which have been known to swallow whole cities, lakes, rivers, highways. The dunes in these 
pix for a time threatened part of an Oregon coastal town. Several agencies attacked the problem some ten 
years ago in a combined operation there. They've come up with the first answer to shifting sands that's 
known in all history. It's so successful that Israel, Chile, the Philippines and several other nations have 
sent experts to Oregon to learn how it's done. 
Sand dunes pushed by steady winds build up in waves analogous to ocean waves except that they may 
move twenty feet a year instead of twenty feet a second. These waves can be every bit as devastating as a 
tidal wave in property damage . . . and they've even caused deaths. They drown out forests, kill game 
cover, destroy lakes, fill harbors. 
Millions of acres of Chilean coast have been made unfit for humans by these shifting sands. Israel fights a 
constant battle     with     surrounding deserts. Several Oregon harbors have been plagued by this problem. 
And there are hundreds of other trouble spots all over the world. 
The scientists working on the Oregon coast found that the sand could be controlled completely only by the 



use of one type of grass that will grow in such places and tie down the sand with an intricate interlacing of 
roots. This grass is extremely difficult to grow in nurseries, and a whole system of handling it had to be 
worked out. They tried more than 11,000 different types of grass before hitting on this one . . . and they 
were working against time because of the sand invasion along this stretch of coast. 
It makes an exciting story with a very nice conservation twist and some excellent human angles. Let's see 
if somebody wants it. 
I'm still plugging along on the new novel. You'll see it soon. 
Best regards, Frank 
THE PROPOSAL: 
The small Oregon coastal town of Florence is the scene of an unsung victory in the fight that men have 
been waging since before the dawn of recorded history. The fight is with moving sand-with dunes. 
Sand dunes pushed by steady winds build up waves like ocean waves-except that they may move as little 
as twenty feet a year instead of twenty feet a second. But these slow motion waves can be every bit as 
devastating to property as a seismic wave-and the damage can be more lasting. 
Wind-driven dunes have swallowed whole cities and towns from ancient times down to modern times. 
Ask any archaeologist about sand covered Tel Amerna, the city of the Horizon of Aten built by Akhenaton 
and his wife, Nefertiti, on the Nile banks. Here are only a few of the communities that have fought a 
losing battle with sand: Murzuk in the Sahara, Washari and a string of other settlements of the Kumtagh 
desert in Sinkiang, hundreds of towns along the Hadhramaut coast of Arabia, Inca settlements and more 
recent ones on the Peruvian and Chilean coast from Trujillo south past Callao and Caldera. 
Dunes have swallowed rivers-on the Guinea coast of Africa and in 
French West Africa near Njeil-and there are other recorded instances. 
Dunes have threatened harbors-on Samar in the Philippines, along Africa's Guinea Gulf, along the Inca 
coast of Peru and Chile- and the port of Siuslaw, Oregon, where the solution was found. 
Millions of acres of Chilean and Peruvian coast have been made un-fit for humans by shifting sands. Israel 
fights a constant battle with surrounding deserts. Harbors all over the world are plagued by this problem. 
In 1948, several federal and state agencies centered a study of dunes at Florence, Oregon, a town 
threatened by moving sand. Efforts were focused on the Port of Siuslaw and the Siuslaw River, both in the 
path of advancing dunes. 
It took ten years, but this group, under the direction of Thomas Flippin (work unit conservationist for the 
Siuslaw Soil Conservation District), has come up with the first enduring answer to shifting sands in all 
history. It's so successful that Israel, Chile, Egypt, the Philippines and other nations have sent experts to 
Oregon to learn how to fight their sands. 
Briefly, the scientists working the Oregon coast found that sand could be controlled only by use of one 
type of grass (European beach grass) and a system of follow-up plantings with other growth. The grass 
sets up a beachhead by holding down the sand in an intricate lacing of roots. This permits certain other 
plants to gain a foothold. The beach grass is extremely difficult to grow in nurseries, and part of the 
solution to the dune problem involved working out a system for propagating and handling the grass. 
More than 11,000 different types of grass were tried by this group in Oregon before they hit on a way of 
handling beach grass-and they were working against time because the sand invasion along this stretch 
was swallowing houses, railroad tracks, Highway 101, the port of Siuslaw and a nearby lake . . . and it was 
drowning out game cover along forty miles of coast. 
How the group in Oregon solved the many problems that go into taming the sands and how their solution 
works make an exciting story with an excellent conservation twist and human interest through the people 
who won the battle. 
July 29, 1957 
Dear Frank, 
Control of sand dunes may be a story; it is fairly limited in appeal but certainly worth trying if you'll make 
your outline a little more detailed. You should put it on a page without any date, just an outline, and give 
the answers to the questions I've written along the margins. We should also know how widespread the use 
of this grass is now and how rapidly it is being multiplied. 



Cordially, Lurton 
(Note: Lurton Blassingame sent two letters with the same date on them.) 
July 29, 1957 
Dear Frank, 
There may be a piece in your battle of the sand dunes but your outline still doesn't indicate it. You give 
much more space here to telling about the cities the sand has destroyed than you do in telling us how the 
battle has been won. There's no statement about the size or the number of dunes moving on Florence and 
Port Siuslaw. We don't know the size of either of these towns. You don't tell us how many miles of road 
and railroad were destroyed. I presume that the victory has been won and, if so, how far apart are Florence 
and Siuslaw? This outline is so vague. What has happened to the railroad? If the battle has been won, has 
the 
crew gone back to some other kind of work or are they rushing on to fight the moving sand dunes 
somewhere else in the country? 
The outline and the story should deal with the battle to save these towns. If you put in any history, it will 
be just to let us see how hopeless the battle seemed, since it had never been won before. And the story 
probably should be tied around the man in charge so that there can be human interest in it. American edi-
tors don't give a damn about Murzuk and Kumtagh; they don't even know what these names mean. If 
you're going to get an okay for a piece, you're going to have to devote the major space in your outline to 
interesting a U.S. editor NOW. 
Cordially, Lurton 
THE LETTERS OF 
DUNE 
 On an odyssey to understand his enigmatic father, Brian researched the biography Dreamer of Dune and 
then wrote new Dune novels with Kevin. During this process, we pored over Frank Herbert's notes, 
correspondence, and drafts. The files were in several locations, spread across more than a thousand miles. 
Unraveling the mysteries of this legendary author, and of his masterpiece, Dune, was formidable and 
fascinating. 
Frank Herbert's correspondence files yielded interesting gems that show an author's passion and his 
continuing drive to find a publisher for a massive novel that he knew was good but which did not fit into 
the marketing niches of the time. 
FOR YEARS after his initial article idea of "They Stopped the Moving Sands," Frank Herbert toyed with 
the story about a desert world full of hazards and riches. He plotted a short adventure novel, Spice Planet, 
but set the outline aside when his concept grew into something much more ambitious. 
When Herbert finally presented an early draft of Dune to Lurton Blassingame in the spring of 1963, the 
agent wrote back: 
April 5, 1963 
Dear Frank, 
Congratulations! You have a novel that is big in many ways, not only in sheer size, but in ideas and story 
value. It is not a Once and Future King of the future because I think it stumbles too often, but it did make 
me think of that delightful book. 
For some readers it may prove to be too slow and I wouldn't be surprised if some editor asked you to cut. 
But the main thing right now is to know when you will have in the remainder-or the outline of the 
remainder. There isn't much science here, but you have a very good adventure story laid in the future and I 
suppose that is all that matters. That, and the fact that you have done a good job with your characters. 
I think this will be called a better book than Dragon in the Sea and that has won many songs of praise. I 
bow three times-and hold out my hands for the rest of the story. 
Cordially, Lurton 
Later in the month, Frank Herbert replied, sending additional chapters. He wrote: 
The science in these books is essentially broad-focus-the shaping of politics, the transformation of an 



entire planet, religion (the transformation of an entire people), and does not dwell long on specific single 
tools-although I'll be surprised if you don't discover that the "stillsuit" concept is a new one, and it plays 
a key part in the stories. And for that matter, human individuals are treated as ecological tools, so what 
this adds up to is that we're looking at science in a different way here. 
I did 70 pages final draft last week (part enclosed) and don't see why I can't duplicate that this week and 
mail it off to you about next Tuesday. The rest of it can come to you at about the same rate. (Think of it as 
a weekly serial.) 
Blassingame liked the new chapters but said: "I am quite pleased with your story and your way of telling 
it. Length is the only problem that worries me. I will look forward to more chapters. I find the work very 
interesting-but how in the world are we going to sell the serial rights when it runs so long?" 
The mechanics of Frank Herbert working with his agent were quite different in those days from what they 
might be today. Blassingame was a hands-on agent, even assisting in the preparation of the manuscript 
pages before sending them to Analog editor John W. Campbell, Jr.: 
May 24, 1963 
Dear Frank, 
I had a call from John Campbell this morning. He is interested in 
Dune and I am seeing him Monday to hear what he has to say. 
The original copy went to him last week after I had corrected all pages, deleting, adding and substituting 
certain pages. In places where one to half a dozen words had been substituted, the 
old lines were X'd out and new words either typed above old lines or printed in by pen. 
Here are seven pages to retype. Certainly those pages where additions have been added in the left margin 
must be retyped. We had time only to start page 210, enclosed with returned pages, for you to follow with 
the others if you wish. I'm sorry we have no time to do all the others but I'm sure you will understand. I'd 
like to get this carbon copy to Doubleday next week. The margin inserts on original copy were typed, the 
sheet cut and the new lines scotch taped onto the page and the page folded up at the bottom to the length 
of uncut sheets. These pages look OK. 
I'm looking forward to receiving the rest of the book! 
Cordially, Lurton 
Five days later, Blassingame wrote again, somewhat concerned about the sheer amount of information 
Frank Herbert was introducing at the start of the novel: 
One way that might help us solve the problem is to do a little more with your history with which you 
precede each chapter of the book. Opening this novel, you might quote from some encyclopedia,   "When  
the  Duke  Leto  inherited  Arrakis  in  the 
year____, the planet had no oceans, no streams. In the northern 
section, there were the cities (in a few sentences you can tell about the water problem on the planet for the 
cities and the 
desert). The Duke's reign lasted only____, then the Harkonnens 
fell upon him and (here you can add about the wiping out of the troops, the killing of the Duke, the escape 
of Paul and Jessica)." You'll do better than this, but I do think we need to have a little more background on 
the planet and the situation into which you plunge us. And your clever use of quotes at the beginning of 
each chapter gives you a chance to provide us with this information. 
Campbell purchased the story in a matter of days, for serialization in the magazine, paying $2,550 (three 
cents a word) for it (a net of $2,295 to the author after agent's commission). Early in June 1963, the 
legendary editor wrote the first of many letters he would exchange with Frank Herbert in ensuing years. 
Concerning the leading character, Paul Atreides, Campbell wrote: "Congratulations! You are now the 
father of a 15-year-old superman!" He then went on for four pages to give suggestions on how to fit the 
powers of the superhero into the novel, culminating in this comment: "If 'Dune' is to be the first of three, 
and you're planning on using Paul in the future ones . . . oh, man! You've set yourself one hell of a 
problem! You might make the next one somewhat more plottable if you didn't give Paul quite so much of 
the super-duper." 
Frank Herbert did not agree, and adhered to his basic view of Paul's powers, in which he had future vision, 



but with some limitations. Frank wrote a detailed and philosophical five-page response discussing the 
nature of metaphysics, time, and prescience. After Blassingame read a copy of this response, he wrote to 
Frank: "I think you did a brilliant job of defending your position. So far [Campbell] has known of only 
two ways of handling supermen and I hope he will accept your arguments and say that in future he knows 
of three ways." 
Campbell did accept the defense. Five days later, he responded in a three-page letter, continuing the 
esoteric discussion but adding: "I'm not suggesting you drop Paul's time-scan ability because I dislike it- 
but because I suspect it might make adequate plotting damn difficult. Your suggestions as to the 
limitations of the ability are sound." 
The interchange between editor and author proved thought provoking in more than just the specific story 
at hand. A few weeks later, Frank Herbert wrote back to Campbell: 
Your letters on Time set off a prolonged conversation here the other night between Jack Vance, Poul 
Anderson, and myself. We missed you. 
Vance: Past and future as "entities" are merely illusion; the only reality is the now-instant. (This tosses out 
all Time-travel stories.) 
Anderson: Time is related purely to standards of measurement. (Very hard-headed on empirical science.) 
Herbert: Time and life are related in a way that does not hold for Time and inanimate objects. 
That oversimplifies, but pretty well summates points of view. There was more-much more. A good Time 
was had by all. 
As I said, we missed you. 
To fit Analog's requirements, Frank Herbert prepared four synopses, which would appear with each of the 
planned four serializations of Dune World, around 85,000 words. Frank wrote: "The synopses, oddly 
enough, break the book into almost equal parts-four of them. This doubtless comes from lavish use of 
cliffhangers." Subsequently, he had to modify this to three synopses, as Campbell changed his mind and 
decided to run the story in three parts. 
All the while, Blassingame had been in contact with major publishers such as Doubleday & Co., trying to 
find one of them to publish the novel in book form. By the summer of 1963, word began to filter back to 
Frank Herbert that this would be no easy task, primarily because of the length of the book. Most science-
fiction novels at the time were only around 50,000-75,000 words, and Dune (when the author included 
more material after the serialization) approached 200,000. 
Because of such artificial attitudes, Frank Herbert did not always think highly of New York publishers. 
One letter attests to this: "As to 
Doubleday-if they take it, excellent. If not, there are other publishing houses. I can feel in my bones that 
the Dune trilogy [the three parts of the original novel now published as Dune] is going to be a money 
maker for whoever publishes it. I always remind myself that editors come and editors go, but writers 
outlast most of them. (Campbell is a delightful exception, but then he's a writer, too.)" 
A week later, Doubleday said they might offer a contract on Dune World, but only if it could be cut to 
75,000 or 80,000 words. Frank Herbert made changes to the manuscript, but in August, Timothy Seldes of 
Doubleday withdrew his offer of a contract, saying he had too much trouble with the beginning of the 
novel: "In fact, I recommend to you the adding up of unfamiliar technology in the first ten pages. It is con-
ceivably a reflection on the story as a whole that, at least to my mind, Mr. Herbert has so much trouble 
getting into it." 
Blassingame had sent the manuscript out to several publishers, and in late October of 1963 it was declined 
politely by Charles Scribner's Sons. Shortly afterward, Frank Herbert completed Book II of Dune 
("Muad'Dib"), and sent it off to his agent, with this comment: "I was unhappy to learn that Scribner's 
rejected Dune. The editor's comment that he may have been mistaken (in doing so)-let us hope that's 
prophetic." 
On November 1, 1963, Frank Herbert completed Book III of Dune ("The Prophet") and sent it off to his 
agent with this note: "Here's Book III of the trilogy, the one I think most successful of the series. Let's 
hope some editors share this judgment." 
Blassingame liked the third part but wrote back: "One big obstacle is the division of material. Most 



trilogies have big time gaps between books or shift viewpoints. Your story is continuous. You really don't 
have three novels; there is only one big novel. It may have to appear as a single volume." In December, 
Doubleday asked for a second look at Dune, so the agent sent it to them again, cautioning the author: 
"Your chief trouble is length. Your novel is about twice as long as most other persons' novels . . ." 
Just  before  Christmas  of   1963,  John  W.   Campbell  wrote   to 
Blassingame that he liked the new Dune material for serialization in Analog, saying: ". . . this is a gee-
gorgeous hunk of stuff." He went on to make suggestions about cutting back the prescient powers of Paul 
Atreides but did not make this a condition of publication. He said that "the major trouble you [have] with 
the Dune World series [is] getting Paul's psi faculty into focus as a useful, profitable faculty, rather than 
something that just confused him and everything else." 
The new material-another 120,000 to 125,000 words-would require an additional five magazine 
installments to publish, but Campbell said it was exactly the sort of "swashbuckler" that he wanted for 
Analog. 
When Frank Herbert saw the cover art for the first "Dune" issue of Analog, he was tremendously 
impressed and wrote: "Frequently, I have to ask myself if the artist was actually illustrating the story his 
work accompanied. No so with John Schoenherr. His December cover caught with tremendous power and 
beauty the 'Dune mood' I struggled so hard to create. It's one of the few such works of which I'd like to 
have the original." 
With equal enthusiasm, John W. Campbell wrote that the cover art was ". . . Schoenherr's sixth attempt, I 
believe. Getting the feeling of desolation, danger, dryness and action was not easy; the guy earned his pay 
on that one!" 
Frank Herbert and John Campbell talked extensively by phone about the manuscript, and the author won 
the arguments over the prescient powers of Paul Atreides. Frank had a strong affinity for ESP and had 
been researching the subject for years, as he explained to his agent: 
ESP is one of my interests to the extent that I have done considerable reading on it in what I would call the 
quasi-scientific end of the field. This includes Rene Sudre's Para-psychology and a considerable amount 
of J. B. Rhine-including The Reach of the Mind and New World of the Mind. I've also dabbled in 
Puharich, the "sacred mushroom" writer. 
I'm what you might refer to as an agnostic where ESP is 
concerned-a "Doubting Thomas." Some of the writers on this end of the field, such as Fodor and Tassi, 
are too kookie for my tastes, and I have strong doubts as to the mathematical basis for the statistics of 
Rhine's tests. 
Okay, I'm from Missouri. This does not, however, limit my enjoyment of a good ESP story or stay in my 
imagination in exploring the "what ifs" of possible mental powers. 
In the interaction with Campbell, however, Frank Herbert did take one important suggestion. In the first 
version of the manuscript, Paul's sister Alia was killed, but the editor talked him into reversing this de-
cision and keeping her alive for future stories. This proved to be wise counsel, as she became one of the 
most interesting characters in the Dune universe. 
(As an aside, Frank also decided to "revive" Duncan Idaho in later novels because the fans liked him so 
much. The Dune universe would be much poorer without Alia Atreides and the serial gholas of Duncan 
Idaho.) 
In the various drafts of the book, Frank wrote additional chapters, which he eventually trimmed from the 
manuscript in an attempt to keep the length under control. These lost chapters are published later in The 
Road to Dune. 
In late January 1964, Timothy Seldes of Doubleday again declined the novel, writing: "Nobody can seem 
to get through the first 100 pages (of Book I) without being confused and irritated." A few weeks later, 
Julian P. Muller of Harcourt, Brace & World also rejected the manuscript, citing "slow spots," "wearying 
conversations," "bursts of melodrama," and the sheer size of the material. He also said: "It is just possible 
that we may be making the mistake of the decade in declining Dune by Frank Herbert." 
In the midst of such rejections, Frank wrote to his agent, insisting: "This is going to be a salable property." 
More people were beginning to appreciate the story as well. A short while later, the 22nd World Science 



Fiction Convention (Pacificon II) notified him that Dune World (based upon the Analog serialization) had 
been nominated for the prestigious Hugo Award. 
In response, Frank Herbert wrote back to the convention: 
I really feel very deeply honored that "Dune World" has been nominated for the Hugo. It really is quite a 
surprise. As a rule, I don't believe writers think about such things. We're too busy writing "the story." 
Win, lose or draw, I'm looking forward to seeing you in September. Right now it's back to the typewriter. 
I'm piled twenty feet deep in work . . . and I love it. 
That summer, Blassingame reported continuing problems with placing the novel with a book publisher: "I 
hope the enormous length of Dune isn't going to prevent a sale, but we are still being bothered by it." 
Saying the novel was "old fashioned in presentation" and in need of cutting, New American Library 
rejected the manuscript a short while afterward. 
At Pacificon II in Oakland, California, Dune World was up against Here Gather the Stars  by Clifford D. 
Simak (book title Way Station), Cat's Cradle by Kurt Vonnegut, Glory Road by Robert A. Heinlein, and 
Witch World by Andre Norton for the Hugo Award. DuneWorld did not win (Way Station did), but John 
Campbell's Analog received a Hugo for best professional magazine. Frank Herbert went to the convention 
and appeared on Campbell's behalf to pick up the award, which he then shipped to New York. In 
appreciation for Frank's contribution, the editor wrote: "I want to thank you for helping us get the Hugo 
this year-in both ways! I told the Committee that either you or Poul Anderson would be the obvious 
proxies for Analog, both being West Coasters, and both being major reasons why the Hugo was coming 
this way." 
Campbell sent payment for the postage, but Frank Herbert wrote 
back: "It was my honor to pick up your hard-earned Hugo and forward it. The postage was such a small 
thing, you shouldn't have bothered. However, it did arrive just as #2 Son (Bruce) asked for an advance on 
his allowance. You may take some satisfaction from the fact that you were there to provide that advance." 
Fan letters began to stream in from Analog readers, but so did rejection letters from major publishers. E. 
P. Dutton added their name to a list of turndowns that would eventually reach more than twenty, writing: 
". . . something of this size would require a perfectly incredible investment and a list price far in excess of 
that any science fiction book has ever had before." Citing similar reasons for his rejection, Allen Klots Jr. 
of Dodd, Mead & Co. added: "It is the sort of writing that might attract a cult and go on forever, but we 
have not had much luck with science fiction and there is too much of a chance, in our opinion, that this 
would be lost of its own weight." 
Early in 1965, Frank Herbert received good news from a surprising source. Chilton Books, best known for 
publishing auto repair manuals, made an offer of $7,500 (plus future royalties) to publish the three Dune 
segments-"Dune World," "Muad'Dib," and "The Prophet"-in a single hardcover. Chilton's farsighted 
editor Sterling Lanier had tracked the agent down after seeing the story in Analog. (Lanier was a science-
fiction author himself, and wrote the novels Hiero's Journey  and Menace Under Mars wood.) 
Lanier wrote that he admired the work and he wanted to publish it in one book, and that he wanted the 
author to add even more material! He intended to name it all Dune, and said he would make contact with 
Campbell's artist, John Schoenherr, for the cover art. The Chilton offer was quickly accepted. A short 
while later, Lanier reported: "I have bought Schoenherr's cover of Jessica and Paul, crouching in the 
canyon, and I think it will make a magnificent and arresting sight." 
As Dune was being prepared for publication, Frank Herbert wrote to a friend, describing his own writing 
style: 
For Dune, I also used what I call a "camera-position" method-playing back and forth (and in varied orders 
depending on the required pace) between long-shot, medium, close-up and so on. Much of the prose in 
Dune started out as Haiku and then was given minimal additional word padding to make it conform to 
normal English sentence structure. I often use a Jungian mandala in squaring off characters of a yarn 
against each other, assigning a dominant psychological role to each. The implications of color, position, 
word root and prosodic suggestion-all are taken into account when a scene has to have maximum impact. 
And what scene doesn't if a book is tightly written? 
Later, responding to a letter from a fan, Frank Herbert wrote: 



My idea of a good story is to put people in a pressure environment. This happens in reality, but life's 
dramas tend to lack the organization we require of the novel. I hit on the idea of a desert planet while 
researching a magazine article about efforts to control sand dunes. This led me to other research avenues 
too numerous to detail completely here, but involving some time in a desert (Sonora) and a re-examination 
of Islam. 
Arrakis is hostile because hostility is an aspect of the environment which produces drama. Typhoons, 
fires, floods-what these do to people contains the essential elements of good story. 
Long novel: it was an experiment in pacing. I'm not sure how successful the experiment, but certainly I 
realize it violates novel conventions. I did not, however, even consider the violation. I was too concerned 
with the internal rhythms of my story. Essentially, these rhythms are coital. .. slow, gentle beginning, in-
creasing pace, etc. Also, I chose to end it in a non-Hollywood way, sending the reader skidding out of the 
story with bits of it still clinging to him. I did not want it neatly tied off, something 
you'd forget ten minutes after putting it down. Casualness is one of our modern hangups. I don't write 
casually, and I should be sorry to hear that anyone read me casually. Lest this sound pretentious, let me 
say that I have no feelings of moral judgment about this way of writing. Good-bad-indifferent? It's just the 
one I chose. 
It's also long because it contains what I call "vertical layers"-many levels at which a reader may enter it 
(another experiment on my part). You can choose the layer you want and follow that throughout the story. 
Re-reading, you might choose an entirely different layer, discover "something new" in the story. 
My opinion of the novel? First, we'd have to do that semantic thing, define what the hell a novel is; then 
we'd get involved with analysis of that verb "to be" in our answer, and at the end, we'd be nowhere. 
This isn't a thing that submits to analysis. There's no truth to be found this way. The novel, as generally 
understood, simply involves good story, which means "entertainment that instructs." Entertainment. Dune 
has elements of caricature-desert reduction and absurdum; Victorian poses. Is it a novel? It falls within 
the usual classification. It is representative? I hope not, but feel unqualified to judge. 
The novel? Lord, man-give me Occam's razor. You're asking me to be a critic, a role I despise. There's 
only one useful kind of critic, the one whose tastes are so similar to your own that when he says, "I liked 
it" you can be sure you'll like it, too. He pre-reads the yearly offerings and keeps you from wasting time 
on things which he turns down. Unfortunately most criticism is by poseurs. They use their comments 
about someone else's work as a platform on which to strike poses. What they're really saying is: "Look at 
me! Look at me!" Most such critics can't write worth a damn in 
the field they're judging or are afraid to cast their own efforts adrift in the sea of poseurs. I guess the only 
worthwhile critic is Time. If it endures . . . And what we classify as "the novel" appears to be enduring. 
What I'm hoping is that it also is undergoing improvement, keeping up with the times. 
Another letter from the author contained even more insights: "The way I write a book, I knew better than 
to send off outline and sample chapters. I compose a book (musical sense)-filling, balancing, em-
phasizing, re-writing . . . Obviously, the finished product will bear little resemblance to any damned 
sample!" 
AS CHILTON BOOKS prepared for the release of its hardcover volume of Dune, Sterling Lanier asked 
Frank Herbert to help in promoting the book. Using his many friends and newspaper connections, Frank 
wrote: 
August 23, 1965 
Dear Sterling, 
Enclosed is the list for the 25 books you said your promotion department would mail to help sales on 
Dune. I've been doing a bit of scurrying on this and have an old friend who runs a Tacoma advertising & 
promotion firm (and who is very good) all set to mount a PR campaign for me through the Pacific 
Northwest. I have plenty of old friends, school chums and the like in key positions (radio and TV 
commentators, editors, columnists and such) throughout the region. This shouldn't be too difficult. 
For San Francisco and Los Angeles-I can be of some promotional help. I'm working on City Lights 
[bookstore] for a window display and whatever other help they can give in the North Beach "Little 
Bohemia." When I go back south next month, I'll deliver a few copies to editor friends on the leading 



papers. 
Oh, one more thing-if your promotion department can spare two more copies-I'd like them to go to 
Robert C. Craig, 3140 E. Garfield, Phoenix, Ariz., 85008. He's the only relative I have who can be of any 
help in this. He travels throughout the Southwest (Arizona, Texas, New Mexico and Oklahoma) for the 
USDA and has hundreds of important friends down there. 
The book looks beautiful and was out sooner than I expected. 
Warmest regards, Frank 
Chilton also produced a two-minute radio spot, which ran on over five hundred radio stations. 
September 30, 1965 
Dear Mr. Herbert, 
Attached is the two-minute script on Dune which was broadcast over more than 500 commercial and 
educational stations, plus 170 Veterans Administration Hospital stations during the week of September 27. 
Many stations will use it more than once. 
The Inside Books Radio programs are sponsored by libraries and book stores throughout the country. We 
believe these broadcasts will broaden the audience for your book among people who are not ordinarily 
reached by the traditional book media, as well as those who are. 
Sincerely yours, Mrs. Mary Jo Groenevelt 
WEEK OF SEPTEMBER 27 
INSIDE BOOKS SCRIPT #4, DO NOT BROADCAST BEFORE THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 30 
Title: Dune    Author: Frank Herbert                                        , 
Publisher: Chilton Books, 227 S. 6th Street, Philadelphia. Price: $5.95    Publication Date: 10/1/65 
Time now for our daily look inside the exciting world of books . . . based on reports we receive from 
Publishers Weekly, the Book Industry Journal, (sponsor time) One of the most fantastic novels that we've 
seen in a long time is Dune by Frank Herbert. When we say that Dune is a fantastic novel, we mean just 
that: a work of pure fantasy ... an exciting science-fiction story that takes place far in the future on a dis-
tant planet. Actually, we should have said several distant planets . . . because the story of Dune concerns a 
Duke named Leto who moves from one planet to another. The planet that he leaves is a rich and fertile one 
. . . and the planet that he moves to is a terrible desert, with almost no water at all. Duke Leto is the head 
of a very ancient noble house, and when he moves from the good planet to the desert planet, the future of 
his entire household is put into jeopardy. But he doesn't really have a choice because he has to follow the 
orders of the Emperor. The Emperor has sent Duke Leto far away because he is jealous of Leto's great 
wealth and popularity . . . and because he is under the influence of Leto's greatest enemy, an evil baron 
named Vladimir (VLAD uh meer) who is the head of a rival noble family. Actually, Duke Leto's new 
planet is not entirely a wasteland. It's also the only planet where one can find the most valuable drug that 
exists ... a drug that contains the secret of everlasting life. But if we tell you very much more about the 
background of Dune, we'll be giving away essential parts of the story. So let's change the subject a little 
bit and say that the real hero of Dune is not Duke Leto but his son, Paul, who is only 
fifteen years old when the story begins. Paul is not an ordinary child. He is much more sensitive than 
most. . . and has a particular mental power which sets him apart from all other people ... a power that he 
has inherited from his mother, and that allows him to recognize the real truth  when he finds it. We said at 
the beginning that Dune was an exciting novel, and it is ... but it's also something more. It's the creation of 
a whole society of the future, worked out to the very last detail. You might call it a kind of super science 
fiction.. . where the author has even gone so far as to provide a short dictionary of special words that refer 
to powers and states of being that don't exist-or don't yet exist-on our world . . . but that form the very 
basis of the world of Dune, (sponsor time) We've been talking about Dune by Frank Herbert. We'll have 
another Inside Books report for you tomorrow, at this time. 
Chilton also sent out an extensive press release, entitled "DUNE Will Never Let the Reader Go": 
Frank Herbert's latest novel, Dune, is a giant work of literature and a gripping excursion into fantasy. 
Because the all-powerful Emperor fears Duke Leto's growing wealth and popularity, the Duke must 
exchange his lands. Duke Leto Atreides must move from a planet, which he owns, to another planet which 
he has been given in exchange. And the Emperor, Shaddam IV, is the Emperor of the Universe. Duke 



Leto's son, Paul, is so little normal in any way that he is the possible key to all human power and 
knowledge. The Duke's lady, Paul's mother, is the creature of the Bene Gesserit, the strangest religious 
matriarchy ever conceived, whose aims are also universal rule. 
The answer to all questions lies in a world called Dune, the planet Arrakis, which produces as its sole 
export Melange, drug 
of immortality. Arrakis is a world of sand, rock, and heat, where roam armed savages who kill for drops of 
water. 
A book as universal as time, brilliant in scope, and dazzling in narrative, Dune is an example of what can 
be done when an inspired writer turns his eyes forward into history rather than back. 
Frank Herbert, whose work has been compared to both Aldous Huxley and Edgar Rice Burroughs, is a 
newspaperman whose published works include The Dragon in the Sea and scores of short 
stories. 
 Science-fiction luminaries also weighed in. Poul Anderson wrote: "By any standards whatsoever, Dune is 
an important book, and within the science fiction field a major work-a suspenseful story, four-
dimensional characters, and a setting worthy of Hal Clement. But there is much more. There is pity, terror, 
irony, Machiavellian politics, and the best study I have seen of one of the most important and least 
understood phenomena in history: the messiah. Frank Herbert is not only concerned with the impact of 
such a prophet on human events. He looks deeper, he asks what it feels like to have a destiny. In so doing, 
he tells us much about the nature of man." 
And Damon Knight wrote: "The highest achievement of a science fiction novelist is the creation of an 
imaginary world so real, so vivid, that the reader can touch, see, taste, hear and smell it. Arrakis is such a 
world, and Dune is clearly destined to become a science fiction classic." 
Then the reviews started coming in. One of the newspapers for which Frank Herbert worked (the Santa 
Rosa [CA] Press Democrat)  ran an article titled "Ex-Staffer's Weird Novel": "Frank Herbert, once a 
Press-Democrat reporter, has been compared to Edgar Rice Burroughs as a spinner of unusual tales. This 
book is, of course, no exception, and will hold the reader spellbound from beginning to end." Kirkus said: 
"This future space fantasy might start an underground craze. It feeds on the shades of Edgar Rice 
Burroughs (the Martian series), Aeschylus, Christ and J. R. R. Tolkien." Science Fiction Review claimed 
that Dune "is, I think, the longest science fiction novel ever published as a single book. ... I won't attempt 
to sketch the plot; suffice it to say that there should be something in the book for everyone: adventure, 
psychology, power politics, religion, etc." 
Perhaps not surprisingly, the reviewer for Analog liked the novel: "Dune is certainly one of the landmarks 
of modern science fiction. It is an amazing feat of creation." However, the reviewer for The Magazine of 
Fantasy and Science Fiction  was not so kind: "I don't think any amount of effort or ability could have 
made this odd hodgepodge of concepts stick together. I cannot possibly trace the many strands interwoven 
in the novel. . . . This is a long book, and in its major premises quite unworthy of the work put into it." 
The El Paso Times wrote: "The creation of an imaginary country, complete with flora, fauna, myths, 
legends, history, geography, ecology and so forth, demands an agile and informed mind. Herbert 
obviously possesses the requisite knowledge to devise and develop such a concept, but unfortunately his 
fantasy is more fascinating to him than to the average reader. . . . What with struggling with an 18-page 
glossary of terms, and concentrating on perfervid prose which makes that of H. Rider Haggard seem 
austere, it is no easy matter to ingest this 412-page tome." 
Early in 1966, the British publisher Gollancz made arrangements to publish Dune in hardcover throughout 
the United Kingdom, while New English Library would do the UK paperback version. In the United 
States, Chilton sold paperback rights to Ace Books. 
Then, on February 17,1966, Frank Herbert received the news that Dune had won the Nebula Award for 
the best science-fiction novel of 1965, awarded by Science Fiction Writers of America. Damon Knight, 
president of the organization, wrote to him in advance of the banquet in Los Angeles: 
February 17, 1966 
Dear Frank, 



It is my pleasant duty to tell you that Dune has won the best-novel award in the SFWA balloting (as, in 
my opinion, it richly deserved to do). Please don't shout this from the housetops yet; it is supposed to be 
under wraps until the March 11 banquet. 
I hope you will be able to attend the L.A. banquet and pick up your trophy; if you haven't sent in your 
reservation yet, it should go to Harlan Ellison. If for any reason you can't make it, please tell Harlan who 
you would like to accept the award for you. 
With personal congratulations & best wishes, 
best, Damon 
(He added a handwritten postscript: It would be even nicer if you could come to the New York banquet on 
the same date, but that's a long way . . . ) 
On the heels of that message, Harlan Ellison wrote to Frank Herbert: 
February 26, 1966 
Dear Frank, 
I've got to know soonest if you'll make the banquet. We have to give them a final count at the restaurant, 
at least a week ahead of time, and also the proportion of prime rib dinners to rack of lamb dinners. So 
letting me know on the 9th is impossible. 
Also, since I have won the short story award-and you can keep that news to yourself, fuzzyface-it 
would be a bit presumptuous of me to accept the novel award for you. It already looks like I bribed the 
membership. So you'll just have to be there to take it yourself. (In the final event that you cop out on all of 
us determined to pay homage to your unquenchable ego, I'll arrange to have some notable accept for you, 
and then ship the effing thing to you; but that is a last resort.) 
Either way, you'd better fill in the enclosed, and send me a check for your ticket(s) just in case you can 
make it. If you can't we'll refund the money. Reluctantly, but we'll refund it. 
Don't miss it, Herbert. It may be the one chance I get to officially insult you from a podium. Also the 
program looks to be extraordinarily exciting and maybe even profitable. 
Be good. See you at the banquet. Don't disappoint me. 
Harlan 
Only a few days later, sad news arrived, as Sterling Lanier announced that he and Chilton Books were 
parting ways. (Though he did not say so, part of this might have had to do with his strong advocation of 
the immense novel Dune, with all of the publication costs involved, and the fact that sales of the book still 
had not picked up.) The supportive editor wrote: 
You have done a fantastic job, and I am deeply proud to have been even remotely associated with you. I 
honestly feel that my only real contribution was to see that the book was a great one and to go out and 
hunt for it. I had to track it down through the good offices of John Campbell. Arthur Clarke gave you a 
fantastic writeup, in a letter to me, which we are using in The Library Journal  along with Faith Baldwin's 
... Hope we meet someday, somewhere. 
On March 11, 1966, Donald Stanley from the San Francisco Examiner  reported: 
Tonight the [SFWA] meets in Los Angeles. The conventioneers will watch a couple of pilot films by 
director Gene Roddenberry from next season's CBS series, "Star Trek." The main business, however, will 
be the presentation of the first SFWA awards in science fiction. 
Winner of the prize for best novel is Frank Herbert, a former picture editor at The Examiner who left last 
year to devote full time to writing. 
The bearded Herbert used to come prowling into our book department asking for "anything you have on 
dry climate ecology." 
Most visitors want Burdick or O'Hara; Herbert lusted after the desert. T E. Lawrence, the Koran, Mojave 
botanicals, all were grist for his arid mill. 
Late last year Chilton published the reason for all this sand-etched activity. "Dune" is the name of the 
novel that took Herbert some half dozen years of researching and writing and which the SFWA jury has 
chosen for its first award. 
In April, Frank Herbert wrote from his study in Fairfax, California, to Damon Knight, who lived in 
Milford, Pennsylvania: "The Nebula sits on my windowsill now against a background of oaks and bays 



which are just getting their spring foliage. Please tell Kate [Damon's wife, Kate Wilhelm] (and Mrs. Jim 
Blish) that there should be an award for the award. Thank God! Someone has at last broken away from the 
glistening phallic symbols with arms reaching toward heaven. This is a work of art." 
("The glistening phallic symbols" was a reference to the Hugo Award-which Frank would also receive 
later that year for Dune.) 
EARLY IN 1967, sales of Dune began to pick up, and Chilton went back to press for an additional printing. 
Frank Herbert wrote to his 
agent: "Book stores in this area can't keep Dune in stock-selling out and reordering at a delightful pace. 
Hope this is a national thing." Indications were good, because by January of 1968 Ace Books went back to 
press for an additional 25,000 copies of the paperback, too. 
By early 1968, Frank Herbert was hard at work on a sequel to Dune but was having some difficulty with 
the title, first choosing Fool Saint and then (The) Messiah, before settling on Dune Messiah. He also con-
sidered and discarded the cryptic title C Oracle, representing a coracle floating on a sea of time. 
John W. Campbell received a copy of the sequel that summer, and he didn't like it at all. In a scathing 
letter, he wrote: "Paul commits acts of absolute folly-which you seek to explain on the basis of His 
Vision Requires It... Paul winds up as a God That Failed-he winds up, in Fremen terms, which he 
accepts as a useless-to-the-tribe cripple abandoned in the desert... In outline, it sounds like an Epic 
Tragedy, but when you start thinking back on it, it works out to 'Paul was a damn fool, and surely no 
demi-god; he loused up himself, his loved ones, and the whole galaxy!'" 
Frank Herbert began his major revisions to the manuscript. Some of the alternate or deleted chapters and 
scenes are included later in The Road to Dune. 
A month later, Frank completed rewrites and sent them to his agent, who reported back: "I think you did a 
good job on the revision of the Dune sequel. It reads better now than it did before, though it still is not the 
masterpiece that Dune is. I think Campbell will like it now. He has a copy." 
But Campbell still didn't like it at all. In a reversal of the experience with Dune, at a time when book 
publishers were vying for the right to publish Dune Messiah in hardcover and paperback, the magazine 
editor took the opposite stance, and refused to serialize it in Analog. He wrote:                                                                        
Herbert's revision of "The Messiah" still didn't satisfy me . . . In this one, it's Paul, our central character, 
who is a helpless 
pawn manipulated against his will, by a cruel, destructive fate. . . . 
The reactions of science-fictioneers, however, over the last few decades have persistently and quite 
explicitly been that they want heroes-not anti-heroes. They want stories of strong men who exert 
themselves, inspire others, and make a monkey's uncle out of malign fates! 
His list of complaints included the following: 
.. . Item: If Paul can't "see" where other oracles have muddied the waters of Time-then neither can they 
"see" where he is working. Because what he does, responding to his vision of the future, alters that future 
to indeterminacy-the future is unstabilized; it is not determinate. 
.. . Item: a Hero leader who cuts and runs from the Climactic Battle is not a Messiah-even though, or 
particularly if, his side actually wins. Neither is he a martyr, nor a Victim of Fate. 
Campbell didn't understand and perhaps Frank Herbert didn't explain adequately at the time that his 
intention was to write an anti-hero book, in order to warn about the dangers of following a charismatic 
hero. As Brian explained in Dreamer of Dune: 
Dune, the first novel in what would ultimately become a series, contained hints of the direction (Frank 
Herbert) intended to take with his superhero, Paul Muad'Dib, clues that many readers overlooked. It was a 
dark direction. When planetologist Liet-Kynes lay dying in the desert, he remembered these words of his 
father, spoken years before and relegated to the back reaches of memory: "No more terrible disaster could 
befall your people than for them to fall into the hands of a Hero." And at the end of an appendix it was 
written that the planet had been "afflicted by a 
Hero." . . . The author felt that heroes made mistakes ... mistakes that were amplified by the numbers of 
people who followed those heroes slavishly . . . 
Among the dangerous leaders of human history, my father sometimes mentioned General George S. 



Patton, because of his charismatic qualities-but more often his example was President John F. Kennedy. 
Around Kennedy a myth of kingship formed, and of Camelot. His followers did not question him, and 
would have gone with him virtually anywhere. This danger seems obvious to us now in the case of such 
men as Adolf Hitler, who led his nation to ruination. It is less obvious, however, with men who are not 
deranged or evil in and of themselves. Such a man was Paul Muad'Dib, whose danger lay in the myth 
structure around him. (pp.191-192) 
Despite Campbell's rejection, Dune Messiah was picked up by Galaxy magazine, and would run in five 
installments, in the July-November 1969 issues. It was also picked up in hardcover by G. P. Putnam's 
Sons, and in paperback by Berkley Books. With sales and accolades on the upswing, an ebullient Frank 
Herbert wrote to his agent: "Dune is hot right now. A sequel is sure to capitalize on that fact. It's required 
reading in several college lit and psych classes and is referred to on campuses as a 'great underground 
book.' Are all the publishers in New York asleep at the switch?" 
He was not yet earning enough money from his writing to entirely quit working as a newspaperman, but 
things were heading in the right direction. In a couple of years, Dune and Dune Messiah would become 
phenomenal bestsellers and Frank Herbert would be lecturing on college campuses all over the United 
States. Dune would be picked up by the environmental movement for its desert ecology theme, and well 
known movie producers would begin knocking on his door. 
UNPUBLISHED SCENES AND CHAPTERS 
INTRODUCTION 
While poring over early drafts of the Dune and Dune Messiah manuscripts,  we  discovered alternate  
endings,  additional scenes, and chapters that had been eliminated from the final published works. 
Prior to its 1965 hardcover publication, Dune was serialized in Analog, but each segment was limited by 
the magazine's length restrictions. The editor, John W. Campbell, Jr., worked closely with Frank Herbert 
to trim scenes and chapters, making them fit into the number of pages that Campbell wanted. 
The following chapters were cut in this fashion and then never restored when the novel was published in 
book form. In one passage here, Frank Herbert mentions that spice has been used for only about a 
century, but in later versions, he expands the time frame to span many thousands of years. Many details 
are inconsistent with the published versions, and these scenes should be considered drafts, not "canon." 
These are interesting and enlightening additions to the stories and are available here for the first time. The 
context should be clear to anyone familiar with the early novels.                                            
Some of the chapters from Dune Messiah are a radical departure from what was published as the final 
version, and some of the alternate endings are spectacular and shocking. 
Deleted Scenes and Chapters from Dune 
PAUL & REVEREND MOTHER MOHIAM 
 (Several short scenes from the opening of Dune) 
On the inner wall beneath the window was a loose stone that 
 could be pulled out to reveal a hiding place for the treasures of 
his boyhood-fishhooks, a roll of meta-twine, a rock shaped like a lizard, a colored picture of a space 
frigate left behind by a visitor from the mysterious Spacing Guild. Paul removed the stone and looked at 
the hidden end of it where he had carved with his cutterray: "Remember Paul Atreides, age 15, Anno 72 of 
Shaddam IV." 
Slowly, Paul replaced the stone above his treasures and knew he would never remove it again. He returned 
to his bed, slipped under the covers. His emotion was sad excitement, and this puzzled him. He had been 
taught by his mother to study a puzzling emotion in the Bene Gesserit fashion. Paul looked within himself 
and saw that the finality 
of his goodbyes carried the sadness. The excitement came from the adventure and strangeness that lay 
ahead. 



PAUL SLIPPED OUT of bed in his shorts, began dressing. "Is she your mother?" he asked. 
"That's a fool's question, Paul," Jessica said. She turned. "Reverend Mother is merely a title. I never knew 
my mother. Few Bene Gesserits of the schools ever do; you know that." 
Paul put on his jacket, buttoned it. "Shall I wear a shield?" 
Jessica stared at him. "A shield? Here in your home? What ever put that idea into . . ." 
"Why're you afraid?" he demanded. 
A wry smile tugged one corner of her mouth. "I trained you too well. I..." She took a deep breath. "I don't 
like this move to Arrakis. You know this decision was made over my every objection. But. . ." She 
shrugged. "We haven't time to dally here." She took his hand the way she had done when he was smaller, 
led him out into the hall toward her morning room. 
Paul sensed the oddness of her taking his hand, felt the perspiration in her palm and thought: She doesn't lie 
very well, either. Not for a Bene Gesserit she doesn't. It isn't Arrakis that has her afraid.  
PAUL TURNED BACK to the Reverend Mother; thinking of the exposed idea within this test: Human or 
animal? 
"If you live as long as I have lived you will still remember your fear and your pain and your hate," the old 
woman said. "Never deny it. That would be like denying part of yourself." 
"Would you have killed me?" he asked. 
"Suppose you answer that for yourself, young human." 
He studied the wrinkled face, the level eyes. "You would have done it," he said. 
"Believe it," she said. "Just as I would've killed your mother in her day. A human can kill what she ... he 
loves. Given necessity enough. And there's something always to remember, lad: A human recognizes 
orders of necessity that animals cannot even imagine." 
"I don't see this necessity," he said. 
"You will," she said. "You're human, and you will." She looked across at Jessica and their eyes locked. 
"And when you've brought your hate to a level you can manage, when you've absorbed it and understood 
it, here's another thing for you to consider: Think of what it was truly that your mother has just done for 
you. Think of her waiting outside that door there, knowing full well what went on in here. Think of her 
with every instinct screaming at her to leap in here and protect you, yet she stood and waited. Think on 
that, young human. Think on it. There's a human, indeed, your mother." 
SOUNDS FROM THE assembly yard below the south windows interrupted. The old woman fell silent 
while Paul ran to the window and looked down. 
An assemblage of troop carriers was drawing up in review ranks below and Paul saw his father in full 
uniform striding out for inspection. Around the perimeter of the field, Paul made out the distorted air that 
spoke of shields activated there. The troops in the carrier wore the insignia of Hawat's special corps, the 
infiltrators. 
"What is it?" the old woman asked. 
Paul returned to her. "My father the Duke is sending some of his men to Arrakis. They're here to stand 
review." 
"Men to Arrakis," the old woman muttered. "When will we learn?" 
She took a deep breath. "But I was talking about the Great Revolt when men threw out the machines that 
enslaved them. You know about the Great Revolt, eh?" 
" 'Thou shak not make a machine in the likeness of a man's mind,'" Paul answered. 
"Right out of the Orange Catholic Bible," she said. "Want to know the trouble with that? It leaves too 
much unspoken. It's a sop to the counterfeit men among us, the ones who look human but aren't. They 
look and talk like humans, but given the wrong pressures they expose themselves as animals. And the 
unfortunate thing is they think of themselves as human. Oh, yes! They think. But thinking isn't enough to 
qualify you as human." 
"You have to think within your thinking," Paul said. "There's no end to it." 
She laughed aloud, a quick burst of sound full of warmth, and Paul heard his mother's laughter joining it. 
"Bless you," the old woman said. "You've a wonderful turn for language, lad, you fill it with meaning." 
"TELL ME TRULY now, Paul, and remember I'm a Truthsayer and can see truth. Tell me: Do you often 



dream a thing and have the dream happen exactly as you dreamed it?" 
"Yes." 
"Often?" 
"Yes." 
"Tell me about another time." 
He looked up to the corner of the room. "I dreamed once that I stood in the rain outside and the castle door 
was locked and the dogs were barking in their cages and Gurney was beside me and Duncan Idaho and 
Duncan stumbled against me and bruised my arm. It didn't hurt much, but Duncan was so very sorry. And 
that's how it happened when I was ten." 
"When did you dream this?" 
"Oh, a long time ago. Before I had a room by myself. It was when I was little and slept in a room with a 
nurse beside me." 
"Tell me another time." There was excitement in the old woman's voice. 
SHE CLEARED HER throat. "Those of our numbers who have not attained the status of Reverend Mother 
know only so much of the search as we tell them. Now, I will tell you a bit more. A Reverend Mother can 
sense what is within her own bodily cells-every cell. We can peer into the cellular core of selfdom, but 
there we find . . ." She took a trembling breath. "This thing of which I spoke earlier. This emptiness which 
we cannot face. Fearful it is. The direction that is dark . . . the place where we cannot enter. Long ago, one 
of us fathomed that a male force is needed to peer into this place. Since then, each of us at attaining the 
Reverence has seen that this is true." 
"What's so important about it?" Paul asked, and his voice was sullen. 
"Let us imagine," she said, "that you have a troop carrier with only half its motor. If you find the other 
half, you'll have the complete unit needed to move your carrier." 
"You still have to put them together and make them work," Paul sneered. "May I go now?" 
"Don't you want to hear what I can tell you about the Kwisatz Haderach?" Jessica smiled at the Reverend 
Mother. 
Paul said: "The men who've tried to ... enter this place, are they the ones you say died?" 
"There's a final hurdle they seem unable to leap," the old woman said. 
His voice was not a child's voice, but old and grim despite its treble pitch: "What hurdle?" 
"We can only give you a hint." 
"Hint then." 
"And be damned to me?" She smiled wryly. "Very well: That which submits rules." 
"That's a hint?" 
She nodded. "But submitting, you rule." 
"Ruling and submitting are opposites," he said.                        
"Is the place between them empty?" she asked. 
"Ohhhh." He stared at her. "That's what my mother calls the tension-with-meaning. I'll think about that." 
"You do that." 
"Why don't you like me?" Paul asked. "Is it because I'm not a girl?" 
The Reverend Mother snapped a questioning look at Jessica. 
"I've not told him," Jessica said. 
"That's it, then," Paul said. "Can a woman help it if her child's a boy?" 
"Women have always controlled what sex their offspring will be," the old woman said. "By acceptance or 
rejection of sperm. Even when they didn't know the mechanism of it, they controlled it. There's a kind of 
racial necessity in this, and men must submit to it." 
He nodded. "By submitting, we rule." 
"That's part of it." 
Jessica spoke from behind him: "Yet, humans must never submit to animals." 
He glanced at his mother, back to the old woman. 
"CONCENTRATE ON  YOUR training, lad, all of it," said the old 
woman. "That's your one chance to become a ruler." 



"What about my father?" Paul demanded. "Are we just. .." 
"Your mother warned him," the old woman said. "Specifically 
against instructions, I might add, but that isn't the first Bene Gesserit 
rule she ever broke." 
Jessica looked away. 
The Reverend Mother plunged on without a glance at her. "You naturally love and respect your father. If 
there's action you can take to guard him, you'll want to take that action. But have you ever thought about 
your duty to the ones who came before your father?" 
"Before . . ." The boy shook his head.                                    
"You're the latest in the Atreides line," she said. "You carry the family seed. And when you come right 
down to it, that's a tenuous thing. There are no other viable members of your line. A once-numerous clan 
comes to this: If both you and your father die, the name Atreides ends there. Your cousin, the Padishah 
Emperor, who is Corrino bar Shaddam, will gather the last of the Atreides holdings back into the Regate, a 
possibility which has not escaped him. Fini Atreides." 
"You must guard yourself for your father's sake," Jessica said. "For the sake of all the other Atreides 
who've come to this ... to you." 
"YOUR MOTHER WILL tell you of these things. They're not in any history books, not the way she'll explain 
them. But what she tells you, depend on it, lad. Your mother is a container of wisdom." 
Paul stared at the hand that had known pain, then at the Reverend Mother. The sound of her voice held a 
difference from any other voice he had ever heard. The words were as though outlined in brilliance. There 
was an edge to them that cut through him. He felt that any question he asked her, she would have the 
answer. And the answer could lift him out of his flesh-world. But awe held him silent. 
"Come, come, ask the question," she said. 
He blurted it out: "Where did you come from?" 
She absorbed the words and smiled. "I've heard it phrased differently," she said. "One youngster asked me: 
'How old are you?' I thought that contained a measure of feminine adroitness." 
She stared at him. He stared back. 
"I came from one of the Bene Gesserit schools. There are many such schools to the power of many. Do 
you know yet about mathematical powers?" 
He nodded. 
"Good. Routine knowledge is always useful for communication. We teach another order of knowledge. 
We teach what you might call 'thingness.' Does that make any sense to you?" 
He shook his head no. 
"If you graduate, it'll mean something to you," she said. 
Paul said, "But this isn't answering my question." 
"Where did I come from? I am a Bene Gesserit. Thence, where did Bene Gesserit come from? Well, lad, I 
have only time to give you the outline. We'll leave it to your mother to fill in the details. Eh?" 
He nodded agreement. 
"A long time ago," she said, "men had machines that did more things for them than machines do today. 
Different things. They even had machines that could, after a fashion, think. They had automatic machines 
to make useful objects. All of this was supposed to have set man free, but, of course, permitted machines 
to enslave him. One man with the right kind of automatic machine could make many destructive objects. 
Do you see that?" 
He found his voice and ventured sound: "Yes." 
She noted the change in him, the increased alertness. "Good, lad. What we didn't have was a machine to 
make all men good or even to make all men into men. There are many counterfeit men among us, lad. 
They look human. They can talk like a human. But given the wrong pressure, they expose themselves as 
animals. The unfortunate thing is, they think of themselves as human. Oh, yes, they think. But thinking 
isn't enough to make you human." 
"You have to think about your thinking," he said. "You have to . . ." he hesitated, ". . . understand how you 
think." 



She had followed his words, mouthing them silently with him. Now, she wiped her eyes, said: "Ah, that 
Jessica." 
"What happened to all the machines?" Paul asked. 
"It takes a male to ask that kind of question," she said. "Well, they destroyed them, lad. There was war. 
Revolution. Anarchy. And when it was over, men were forbidden to make such machines again." 
"You aren't telling me where you came from," he said. 
She laughed out loud, a quick burst of sound full of warmth. "Bless you, my darling, but I am. You see, 
there was still the need for some of the things those so-called thinking machines had done. So somebody 
remembered that certain humans could think in those ways." 
"What ways?" 
"They could take in all kinds of information and never be at a loss to repeat it. They had what is called 
eidetic memory. But more than that. They could answer complicated questions. Mathematical questions. 
Military questions. Social questions. Probability questions. They could swallow all sorts of information 
and spew out answers when the answers were needed." 
"They were human," he said. 
"Well, yes they were, most of them." 
"What do you mean most of them?" 
"It isn't important, lad. Your mother can explain about idiot savants and such if you ask her. But I'm 
explaining where I came from. This was the way of it. Schools were started to train this special kind of hu-
man. One such school was called the Bene Gesserit School. In it was a human who saw the need to 
separate the humans from the animals. As a stock. A breeding stock. But there was a reservoir of chance 
human births among the animals because of ... mixing." She thought she saw his attention waning, and 
snapped: "Do you understand all this?" 
"I know how we pick the best bulls," he said. "It's through the cows. If the cows are brave the bulls will be 
brave." 
"Yes, of course," she said. "It's a general rule. Men are the doers, and human males seek out the Bene 
Gesserit. Well, lad, the Bene Gesserit School was successful. We produced mostly women . .. breeders. 
Brave ones. Beautiful ones. But in the new Empire there were only certain 
ways we could act. Some of the things we did had to remain secret. You know what I'm telling you are 
secret things, don't you?" 
He nodded absently. The secrecy of her manner had been obvious. There were other things troubling him. 
He voiced one of them: "But I'm a boy." 
Maybe he is the one, the old woman thought. So mature for his years. So very perceptive. 
She said: "Men have their uses. And we've always been searching for a special kind of man." 
"What kind?" 
"Our time is too short," she said. "Your mother will have to explain it. I can say this to you briefly: The 
man we need will know himself that he is the man. When he learns this of himself, that will be the 
moment of his graduation." 
"You're just putting me off," he said. He felt resentful. The adult world had no more hateful aspect than 
this form of frustration. 
"Yes, I am," she admitted. "But you'll have to take me on faith right now. It's not only impossible for me 
to answer your question right now, it could be hurtful for you. It's as though the knowledge had to grow 
within you until the day you feel it flowering. It can't be forced. We think we know the climate it needs, 
but. . ." She shook her head. 
The apparent uncertainty in the old woman's manner shook Paul. One moment she had been the Goddess-
source of all knowledge. Now ... he could see her exposing an area of unknown. And that area concerned 
himself. He didn't formulate this feeling as words. He only felt it. It was like being lost. 
"Time to call in your mother," she said. "You've a busy day ahead of you." 
PAUL & THUFIR HAWAT 
Paul continued to stare at the old man. "Thufir, I just thought of       something." 
"Heh?" 



"I really know so little about you." 
"What's that?" Hawat stared sharply at Paul, wondering: Am I being insulted by this cub? Does he doubt my 
loyalty? 
"I mean I don't know real things about you," Paul said. "Like, oh, have you ever been married, or . . ." 
"I've had women," the old man growled. 
"And children?" 
"Like as not." 
"But no family." 
"My Duke's family is my family." 
"It's not the same," Paul said. "You've been so busy with our . . ." "What I want or need my Duke gives 
me," Hawat said. "If talk like yours came from a commoner it'd be a headsman offense. You're born to 
rule, lad, and to accept the services of those whose loyalty you've earned. Being born to it isn't enough, 
though. You've a deal to learn, too. That's why we're here now and we'd best get down to business." He 
tapped the papers on the table. "Yueh and your mother and everyone with a scrap of knowledge about 
Arrakis has been pumping it into you. Now, what do you know about the place?" 
PAUL & GURNEY HALLECK 
Gurney was, in fact, the closest thing to a playmate that Paul 
 knew. 
Gurney dropped the weapons onto the exercise table, lined them up, gave them a last examination to be 
certain they were ready: stunners on safety, buttons secure on the rapier tips, bodkins and kindjals in their 
blunting sheaths, fresh power charges in the shield belts. 
Behind him, Gurney heard the boy moving restlessly, and it occurred to Gurney that Paul was slow to 
warmth with most people, that few saw anything but a strange irregularity of friendliness beneath the 
manners. Like the old Duke, Gurney thought. Always conscious of class. And it's a pity because there's so much fun 
in the boy, too much to be pushed under all the time. He turned, swinging a baliset off his shoulder, began 
checking its tune. There I go again, he thought. Filling my mind with fly-buzz when I should be getting down to work. 
"YOU HATE THE Harkonnens almost as much as my father, Paul said. 
"Almost as much," Gurney agreed, and Paul heard the irony. "The Count Rabban at Lankiveil is a 
Harkonnen cousin. You've heard the tale of Ernso, the goldsmith, captured on Pedmiot and sold to slavery 
of the Count Rabban . . . with his family held in the same bondage?" 
"I've heard you sing the ballad many a time," Paul said. 
Gurney spoke to the wall beyond the boy. "Then you'll recall that Ernso was ordered to embellish the 
handle and blade of the Count's best sword. And Ernso obeyed, but he hid in the design a curse calling on 
heaven to destroy an evil House." 
"Yes." Paul nodded, puzzled. The bloody ballad was not one of his favorites. 
"And the design remained hidden there," Gurney said, "until a Court lackey chanced to see it and 
recognized the script from his childhood. Oh, it was a great joke at Court until word got back to Beast 
Rabban." 
"And for that Ernso was hung by his toes over a chirak nest until dead and his family scattered to the slave 
pits," Paul said. "I remember the story, but..." 
"I'd tell you a thing now that's known to very few in this House," Gurney said. "I'm properly called 
Gurney Halleck Ernson, the son of Ernso." 
Paul stared at the rippling of the scar on Gurney's jaw. 
"It was Hawat's men brought me off Giedi Prime that time they nearly got the Baron," Gurney said. "I was 
just a child, but I showed aptitude for the sword, there being motive behind my learning. Duncan 
Idaho found a way for me to train at his school on Ginaz. I had some large bids for my services when I 
graduated, lad, but you understand now why I came back to the Atreides and why I'll never leave short of 
being carried out in the basket." 
PAUL & DR. YUEH 
That sounds like Hawat," Yueh said, and he smoothed his drooping mustache. "Hawat's gone, I hear. 
Taken most of the propaganda corps, all the presses. Interesting. I wonder what filmbooks he has in mind 



for first publication there. The Harkonnens, you know, didn't use much printed matter on Arrakis. They 
relied on the persuasion of the sword." 
"My father does things differently," Paul said. "Indeed," Yueh said. And he straightened the Suk School's 
silver ring that bound his hair at the shoulder. 
"My mother says you have some Bene Gesserit training," Paul said. "Does the Suk School have Bene 
Gesserit teachers?" 
"No." Yueh dropped his hand to his lap. "My . . . Wanna . . . she was 
Bene Gesserit. A wife teaches a husband much even when he is not deep-trained . . . and when she's Bene 
Gesserit. . ." He shook his head. 
"Is she ... dead?" Paul asked. 
Yueh swallowed in a dry throat. He has pity for me. I do not want his pity! 
"Yes," he said. And he thought: I pray it is true. Let her be dead, and in that death, free of Harkonnens. Yet, I cannot 
be sure until I face the Baron in our own tahaddi alburhan. The challenge of the proof.  My eyes shall see it. 
"I'm sorry," Paul said. And he thought: Perhaps that's why he makes me uneasy. He's a man with a terrible 
grief. I must be kinder to him. Mayhap my father could get him a woman. 
"I must leave in a few minutes," Yueh said. "But we really haven't studied much, have we? It's all this 
upset. We'll get back to regular lessons and a full schedule ... on Arrakis." 
"Things are pretty mixed up," Paul said. "And there's all this huddling within our four walls because our 
forces are depleted by the ones we've sent on ahead. My father says we're not very vulnerable here, 
though, because many of the Great Houses pray for the Harkonnens to violate the Convention. That'd 
make the Harkonnens fair game to anyone who wanted to hit them in force." 
"It is best to stay indoors, though," Yueh said. "I hear they blasted a hunter-seeker out of the orchard last 
night." 
PAUL & DUKE LETO ATREIDES: 
THE SPACING GUILD & THE GREAT CONVENTION 
But first let us consider Salusa Secundus. Forgive me if I seem to deal in the obvious. I wish to be certain 
you see the matter as I see it." 
And Paul took a deep breath, thinking: At last he's going to tell me how we can win. 
"The popular idea," the Duke said, "is that our civilization is a scientific one, based on a Constitutional 
Monarchy in which even the lowliest may gain high position. After all, new planets are being discovered 
all the time, eh?" 
"Hawat says new Terranic planets are as rare as hen's teeth and that dispensation of them is a Royal 
monopoly," Paul said. "Except for the ones we don't know about that the Spacing Guild keeps for itself." 
"I'm glad to hear you quoting Hawat so much," the Duke said. "It bespeaks a native caution in you. But I 
doubt that the Guild holds any planets. I don't think they like living on the dirt. . . out in the open. I've 
ridden Guild ships to Court and elsewhere several times. You don't see much of the crews except on 
viewscreens, but what you do see gives you the clear impression that they despise planet-bound humans." 
"Then why do they deal with us at all? Why not just. . ." 
"Because they understand ecology," the Duke said. "They know they have a nice safe niche in the scheme 
of things. It's cheaper to depend on us for raw materials and those products they don't care to manufacture 
... or cannot-such as melange. Their philosophy is Don't Rock the Boat. They'll transport us and our 
products for a profit. Anywhere, anytime-just as long as it doesn't endanger them. The same service 
offered to all at the same price." 
"I know that, but it's still puzzling," Paul said. "I remember that Guildsman who came here when we 
contracted for the extra rice shipments. He gave me a picture of a landing frigate and . . ." 
"He wasn't a Guildsman," the Duke said. "He was just an agent for the Guild, born and raised on a planet 
as we were. A true Guildsman has never been seen on dirt to my knowledge." 
"It seems strange that the Guild doesn't just move in and take over the worlds," Paul said. "If they control 
all the . . ." 
"They chose their path," the Duke said. "Give them that. They know what any Mentat knows-there's a 
great deal of responsibility in ruling, even when you do it poorly. The Guild has shown many times it 



doesn't want that responsibility. They like what they are, where they are." 
"Hasn't anyone ever tried to compete with them?" Paul asked. 
"Many times," the Duke said. "Competing ships never come back, never arrive anywhere." 
"The Guild destroys them!" 
"Probably. Then again, perhaps not. And the Guild does provide general transportation services at a 
reasonable price. It's only when you get into the special services that the cost goes up." 
"They just destroy anyone who tries to compete with them," Paul said. 
The Duke frowned. "What would you do if a rival House set up next door to you and started competing 
for your world-openly, no holds barred?" 
"But the Convention ..."                                                    
"Hang the Convention! What would you do?" 
"I'd throw every thing I had against them." 
"You'd destroy them." The Duke tapped a finger on the table for emphasis. "Now, let us not forget 
something, a fact you've been told often enough: Ours is a feudal society, each world vulnerable from 
space. That's the real reason for the Great Convention. A planet is vulnerable from space, and the Guild 
will transport anything anywhere anytime for a price. If they carry a cargo of short-range frigates, as 
they'll carry ours to Arrakis, and those frigates bomb out a world, the information on who did it is also 
available ... for a price. This is the Great Convention, the Landsraad, our only true agreement-to unite 
and destroy anyone who attempts such a thing." 
"Well, what about renegades?" Paul asked. "If . . ." 
"Hasn't anyone explained these things to you before?" the Duke demanded. He sighed. "When a renegade 
buys Guild silence, there are two requirements. He may not be fleeing after major violation of the 
Convention, and he may never again contact a central world-in any way. Otherwise, all bets are off. 
That's part of the agreement between Guild and Landsraad. Things aren't all one-sided. We share certain 
rules with the Guild." 
"I've heard all this before," Paul said, "and read about it and asked about it. But it still seems . . . wrong. 
There's . . ." 
"A man's promise is no better than his motives for keeping it," the Duke said. "The agreements don't 
bother you; it's the motives." 
"That's it!" Paul said. 
"What holds the Universe together?" the Duke said. "Why aren't we all renegades? One word, son: trade. 
Each world, each group of worlds, 
has something unique. Even Caladan's pundi rice is unique to Caladan. And there are people who want it, 
who cannot get it anywhere else. It's a superb food for babies and old people, you know . . . soothing, eas-
ily digested." 
"Trade?" Paul asked. "That doesn't seem enough." 
"It isn't for the wild adventurers and the rebels," the Duke said. "But for most people it is. We don't rock 
our boat, either. And that's why we're accepting Arrakis. There's a planet that's not only unique, but 
pricelessly so, and in a way that the Harkonnens and the Imperium do not suspect." 
There it is again, Paul thought, that hint at something in our favor. 
"What is it they don't suspect?" Paul asked. "You and Hawat keep hinting at. . ." 
"Paul. . ." The Duke hesitated, staring hard at his son. "This is a most vital thing. I... but, no, it's time you 
assumed more responsibilities." 
BARON HARKONNEN & PITER DE VRIES 
You say I've not seen death," Piter said. "You are so wrong. Once, 
I saw a woman die. She fell from the third balcony of our home into the courtyard where I was playing. I 
was only five, but I can still recall that I thought she looked like an odd green sack as she fell. She was 
wearing green, you see." 
The Baron, noting the odd change in Piter's manner, said: "Many women do, Piter. Women die every 
day." 
"This one was my mother," Piter said. "Oh, it meant little to me at the time. She was merely one of the 



many concubines around the palace. It was only on reflection years later that I drew significance from the 
event." 
"Ahhhh," said the Baron, "and what was that significance?" 
"The person falling is already dead," Piter said. "The falling and the 
death are thoroughly anticlimactic. The event of true importance is the instant of toppling-then you can 
push or rescue the person about to fall. You control destiny." 
The Baron scowled, wondering: Does this fool threaten me? Is he saying he could oppose me in the matter of the 
Duke? 
"Then what of Duke Leto?" the Baron asked. "Could there be a change in his destiny?" 
"Baron, that you should ask!" Piter said. "The Duke . . . ah, the Duke-he is already falling. An event of 
total unimportance, the Duke." 
New Chapter: FROM CALADAN TO ARRAKIS 
(Paragraph-by-paragraph word counts in margin suggest this chapter was cut due  to length, per Campbell's reque st for serialization in Analog, 
and never restored.)  
How such a mass of misinformation as Wingate's book, "Mentat, Guild and Shield" could command so wide an acceptance is difficult to 
understand. The shield is pictured as a simple device (once you've learned its secret), easily. maintained and enabling the rig hteous to defend 
themselves from all attack. The Guild comes through as a disembodied group of angels waiting in space for the day they can intr oduce universal 
Utopia. And the Mentat! Wingate's Mentat is a golem, without any redeeming warmth. According to Wingate, when you put information into the 
Mentat, a sort of machine-encased-in-flesh spews out answers untainted by human emotions. 
- FROM THE HUMANITY OF MUAD'DIB BY THE PRINCESS IRULAN 
The Atreides frigate lay clamped in a long rack in the womb of the Guild ship. Racked around it lay other 
frigates, some bearing House crests that required memory trance for Paul to recall-so distant and small 
they were. And then wedged and packed around and between the frigates stretched a jumble of cargo 
lighters, pickup satellites, jumpdump boxes, yachts and freight gliders . . . and many shapes for which Paul 
had no association. 
He had watched through the lounge viewscreens as his frigate was warped into the monstrous globe of the 
Guild ship. The first glimpses of that gigantic hold's contents had stunned Paul with the realization that 
movement of Atreides people and freight could be only a small part of this ship's task. 
Caladan was only a minor waystop! 
Now, the Guild ship had linked its communications system to the frigate's, and the screen above Paul's 
floater chair remained dark except for an occasional witch flickering as a voice came from the attendant 
speakers with instructions. 
"Atreides party, do not attempt to leave your ships . . . Communication with members of your party in 
other vessels is available through our shipsystem and under rules of Guild secrecy ... In the event of a 
contract-covered emergency aboard your vessel, activate the red op circuit with which you have been 
provided . . . You will experience strange sensations on and within your flesh as we resume way. Those of 
you who have never before spaced in a Guild ship please do not be alarmed. These sensations are a natural 
and harmless part of the first shipdrive moments . . . The Atreides party will be happy to know that they 
have been picked up by a Guild highline ship. You will be at your destination within a subjective day and 
a half . . ." 
And Paul thought woefully of his father's hope to get a complete rest in deepsleep during the crossing. 
The voice from the screenspeakers interested Paul. He detected the controlled modulation of soothers and 
convincers in its tones. They were broadband but beautifully executed. There was no sign of the face or 
flesh of a Guildsman behind that voice, though. Except for the witch flicker, probably sympathetic sonals, 
the screen remained dark. And Paul thought of the old stories about space adaptation,  that the men of the 
Guild had developed long and supple limbs with prehensile toes, that they were totally depilitated, that 
they had grown extra limbs, that they . . . 
Paul laughed at himself. Perhaps I'll get some accurate data someday,  he thought. 
One of Gurney's men, Tomo, entered the lounge through the door beneath the screen. He was a stocky 
man with barrel chest, heavy arms, a round face held carefully emotionless. He nodded to Paul. "Mr. 
Halleck's respects, M'Lord. He asked me to tell you that you may repair 
to the control cone as soon as all danger's past and we're well under way. Duke's orders, M'Lord." 
"Thank you, Tomo," Paul said. "Would you convey my regrets to Mr. Halleck? My mother has asked that 



I remain here until she returns." 
The man bowed. "At once, M'Lord." He backed out the way he had come, sealed the door. 
Paul glanced up at the telltale glitterings in the room's corners where spy eyes scanned the area for those in 
the control cone, and he smiled. Gurney had sent the man as a gesture of human reassurance. Paul eased 
his position in the chair, turning stiffly against the artificial gravity. 
Only a day and a half to Arrakis, he thought. 
He lay back and the chair accommodated itself to the change. There was a lesson to review, a deep lesson 
from his mother with all its peculiar Mentat overtones. The decision to continue with his training had not 
been difficult. It had been almost as though some force within himself had made the decision for him. Paul 
sank into the lesson-review-awareness, sensing the way the lesson linked itself to related data within his 
mind. 
Three quick breaths triggered it. He fell into the floating state . . . focusing the consciousness . . . aortal 
dilation . . . avoiding the unfocused mechanism of consciousness... to be conscious by choice . . . blood 
enriched and swift flooding the overload regions. .. one does not obtain food, safety or freedom by 
instinct, yet some humanoid creatures long to be animals . . . Harkonnen is a beast of prey .. . animal 
consciousness does not extend beyond the given moment nor into the idea that its victims may become 
extinct. . . the animal destroys and does not produce . . . the animal pleasures remain close to the sensation 
level and avoid the perceptual. . . true human requires a frame of reference, a background grid through 
which to see his universe bodily integrity comes through nerve/blood flow according to the deep 
awareness of cell needs . . . man's necessity is for a universe of experience that makes logical sense, yet 
logic seduces awareness ... all 
things/cells/beings are impermanent. . . one strives for the flow-permanence within . . . 
Over and over within Paul's awareness the lesson rolled, and at its hub lay the single conceptualization: 
The human being can assess his circumstances and judge his limitations within those circumstances, all through a 
mental programming, never risking his flesh until an optimum course has been computed. The human being may do 
this within the compression of elapsed time so short that it may be called instantaneous. 
BLUE-WITHIN-BLUE EYES 
We've started a research project on this condition of blue eyes," Hawat said. "It's a condition not totally 
unfamiliar off Arrakis, of course. You'll recall the scannos on that creature of the Harkonnens, Piter 
Vries." 
"The Mentat," Leto said. 
"Would that he bore some other title," Hawat said. He shrugged. "The contention with some is that this 
condition of blue eyes is a derivative of radiation from the Arrakeen sun. The chief argument is 
comparison with the fact that the sun of Tressi is reputed to give a yellow cast to eyes of fifth-generation 
humans born there." 
"Piter Vries is Arrakeen?" Leto asked. 
"Not according to the best information available, sire." Hawat turned away, paced across the room and 
back, his old shoulders bent, 
the leathery skin of his face seamed with the intensity of his concentration. "One of the entrepreneurs we 
smoked out had an amateur biological laboratory, several cages containing kangaroo rats in a sealed 
ecological system. Records attached said the rats had been born in this sealed system on non-Arrakeen 
stock, never removed from the system, and fed only spice. They were maintained in an area sealed away 
from all local radiation, yet they all had the blue eyes. They were fed exclusively on the spice, mind you." 
"Others have said it might be the spice causing this condition," Leto said. 
"But others haven't kept records of a succession of such experiments wherein the spice was eventually 
withdrawn from the creatures and they died rather than revert to normal diet." He stopped his pacing, 
stared up at the Duke. "Died with every evidence of narcotic withdrawal symptoms." 
The Duke wet his lips with his tongue. "It doesn't seem possible. I've never heard of such a thing. Many 
people use melange regularly. It's part of our diet, Thufir. Surely, we'd have heard reports of withdrawal 
symptoms before now. I, myself, have gone without spice for . . ." He shook his head. "Well, I've . . . 
Dammit, Thufir! I know I can use the stuff or leave it alone." 



"Can you, sire?" Hawat asked softly. 
"But I ..." 
"Has anyone who can afford regular use of melange ever put withdrawal to the test?" Hawat asked. "I'm 
not talking about the casual, middle-class users. I'm talking about the uppers who can easily afford it and 
know its proven geriatric qualities, the ones who take it daily in large quantities as a delightful medicine." 
"That would be monstrous," Leto said. 
"It wouldn't be the first time a slow poison has been marketed under the guise of a public benefit," Hawat 
said. "I invite you, sire, to remember the history of the use of saturial, of semuta, of verite, of tobacco, of. . 
." 
JESSICA & DR. YUEH: THE SPICE 
It's more than that," she said. "Tuek had advance agents in here. 
Those guards outside now are his men. I can smell violence about this place." 
"Are you sure about the advance agents?" 
"Do not forget, Wellington, that I frequently act as the Duke's secretary. I know many things about his 
business." She compressed her lips, spoke thinly. "I sometimes wonder how much the Bene Gesserit 
training figured in his choice of me." 
"What do you mean?" 
"A secretary tied to one by love is so much safer, don't you think?" 
"Is that a worthy thought, Jessica?" 
She shook her head. "Perhaps not." She continued to stare at the sere landscape. "But still I know there's 
danger here, and not from the 
populace. After all, they'll soon rejoice that they're freed from the Harkonnen yoke . . . most of them. But 
the Harkonnens will have left some who . . ." 
"Oh, come, come, now!" 
She glanced at him, looked away. "I know that all the Duke's hatred of the Harkonnens isn't empty. The 
old feud is very much alive. The Harkonnens won't be content with holding the power at Court. This new 
duchy wasn't just a plum they threw us to buy an end to the feud." She nodded. "I've had time to think 
about it. They won't rest until the Duke and his line are destroyed." 
"This is a very rich plum, Jessica." 
"And there's poison in it. The plum offered in such a way that we had to take it. The Baron cannot forget 
that Leto is a cousin of the Emperor while the Harkonnen titles came out of a pocketbook. He will not 
forget that my Duke's great-great-grandfather had a Harkonnen banished for cowardice at Corrin." 
"You're becoming morbid, Jessica. You've had too much time to think during this journey. You should be 
busy with things that hold your interest." 
"You're very kind to try to spare me, old friend," she said. "But I cannot keep my mind from wondering at 
the things I see." She smiled wanly. "Tell me about the spice trade. Is it really as rich as they say?" 
"Melange is the costliest spice ever known. It's bringing six hundred and twenty thousand credits the 
decagram on the open market right now." 
She turned away, crossed to one of the empty bookcases, rubbed its glistening surface. "Does it really 
make people live longer?" 
He nodded. "It has some geriatric qualities, yes, because it aids digestion. It sets up a protein digestive 
balance that helps you get more energy out of what you eat." 
"It tasted like cinnamon to me the first time I ate it," she said. 
"Sometimes it's cut with cassia or cinnamon," he said, "but it does 
have some cinnamic aldehyde of its own, and eugenol. That's why many say it smells like cinnamon." 
"But it never tastes the same twice," she protested. "I've never had a satisfactory explanation for that." 
"You know there are only four fundamental tastes?" he asked. 
"Certainly. Acid, bitter, salt and sweet."                                
He inclined his head toward her. "It is the characteristic of melange that it can blend odd pairs of taste and 
make them acceptable to the tongue. Some hold that it's a learned flavor." 
"The body, learning that a thing is good for it, then interprets the flavor always as pleasurable," she said. 



"That is what you mean?" 
"Yes. And for that reason it's also slightly euphoric." 
"How does it grow? Is it a plant?" 
"Well, the Harkonnens kept the biology of melange under wraps, but a few facts have leaked out. 
Apparently, it is fungasoid, and it must grow violently under the proper conditions." 
"Which are?" 
"We do not know. Attempts to grow it artificially have failed for unknown reasons. And because of the 
sandworms [he saw her shudder] it has been impossible to study the spice thoroughly in situ." 
"So it's a fungus." 
"Not exactly. It has some of the properties of fungus, we believe. But it's much more complicated than 
that. The phenol chain with its odd bifurcation, for example. How can that come from a fungus? And 
there's a cymene counterpart. Melange is a fascinating chemical-botanical problem. We can say little 
more." 
"See how I have to pry for technical information?" she said. "Aside from my secretarial duties, the Duke 
does not expect me to be intelligent." 
"Is he aware that you are?" 
PAUL & JESSICA (In hiding after the hunter-seeker attack) 
 What does it mean that you are Bene Gesserit, Mother?" 
He has inherited my perceptivity, she thought, and said: "That is the name of the school where I was trained." 
"I know that, Mother. But it means something different, too. When my father, the Duke, is bothered by 
something you have done he says 'Bene Gesserit' like a swear word." 
She couldn't suppress the smile that twisted her lips. "And what is it about me that bothers your father, the 
Duke?" 
"When you thwart him. I have heard him call you 'a Bene Gesserit witch.'" 
Silent laughter shook her. 
Paul's face remained sturdily somber. "Will you teach me the secret things you know, Mother?" 
Jessica breathed a silent prayer to Sister Nartha and the oath of succession. I was careless and have a son 
instead of a daughter,  she thought. No! I was not careless. I knew how much my Duke wanted a son. But still it is a 
son . . . of a Bene Gesserit witch. 
"I will teach you some of the things I know," she said. 
He stared at her, dissatisfied with the answer, then: "Now I know how my father, the Duke, feels about 
you sometimes," he said. 
She kept her wry feeling of humor from showing on her face, but still he sensed it. 
"We are not amused," he said. 
And suddenly she saw a veil parted into the future. If he lives he will be a great ruler,  she thought. He has the 
perceptivity, the quickness, the deep intelligence, but above all else, he has the dignity. 
She spoke formally: "I am sorry if I have offended my son," she said. "I beg the prerogative of my 
privacy." 
"You had that without begging it," he said. A tiny smile twitched the corners of his mouth. "I beg the 
prerogative of your indulgence." 
She rumpled his hair, her eyes smarting with unshed tears. "Did you come here to protect me, darling?" 
"Of course. My father, the Duke, has told me to protect you when he is away. I would do it anyway, but 
all must obey the Duke." 
"You are very right," she said. Then: "How will we know when it is safe to leave here?" 
"I told Dr. Yueh that I would find you and close a door upon us until he signaled with our knock." Paul 
turned, rapped on the wall-three raps, a pause, two, then three more. 
"That was sensible of you." She turned away, clasping her hands tightly until she felt pain in her knuckles. 
Death traps . . . deadly peril for her Duke and her son and she herself sought as payment to a traitor. 
Which traitor? Who was the trusted lieutenant? 
"If we are safe in this room, you should relax, Mother," said Paul. 



She nodded, turned a smile of false brightness on him. "What have you and Dr. Yueh been up to?" 
"We've been looking at a filmbook about our planet. Did you know that down in the desert they have giant 
sandworms?" 
"Yes, I read about them." 
"They've killed a lot of dunemen-that's what they call the spice hunters. And they've swallowed whole 
spice factories." 
"I imagine they're pretty horrible." 
"And they have winds here that blow six and seven hundred kilometers an hour!" 
"As hard as that?" 
"And it blows sand that cuts right through metal and everything. And sometimes it gets so hot it melts 
plastics, because of the friction." 
She gnawed at her lower lip, thinking: What a hideous place! 
Paul said: "The filmbook said this is the driest known terra . . . terraform planet." 
"That's why we have to be so careful with water," she said. 
"Oh, Dr. Yueh says this house has lots of water. There's a big tank under it." 
"But still we must be careful with water. It's so precious here. People even pay their taxes in water." 
Paul piped up, "Dr. Yueh says there is a saying on Arrakis. 'Polish comes from the cities, wisdom from the 
desert.'" 
And she thought: Leto, where are you? You're in danger. But you know that, of course. And she felt a moment of 
panic about the room around her. What if Lady Fenring's reassurance about this room were wrong? But, 
no. Bene Gesserits didn't make that kind of mistake. 
"I wish I could go after the spice with my father, the Duke," said Paul. 
"He will send his men after the spice," she said. "He won't go himself." 
"Not even once?" 
"Perhaps. But the spice desert's much too dangerous a place for a boy." 
"I'm almost twelve." 
"I know, darling, but men need years of special training before they go out on the sand." 
"I could learn." 
"Maybe when you grow up." 
"I'll study. Will you tell Dr. Yueh to get me all the books there are about our planet? I want books even 
about the time before they found the spice." 
"We'll get all we can find," she said. 
"Until Dr. Yueh showed me the filmbook I thought we'd always had the spice," he said. 
She smiled in spite of her fears. "Only for about a hundred years." And then she thought: But that is 
always when you're almost-twelve. And she remembered that there was a time in her youth when 
enthusiasm was less a word than a world and less a world than a universe. 
Paul said: "Before they found the spice, Arrakis was just a place where they studied about plants and 
things that grow where it's really dry." 
"His Imperial Majesty's Desert Botanical Testing Station," she said. And she wondered: Where is Dr. Yueh? 
Haven't the guards destroyed that seeker yet? And what other dangers must we face when we leave this room? 
Paul pulled at his chin. 
How like Leto he is when he's serious, she thought. And she suddenly realized that Paul was talking just to 
distract her, to take her mind from her worries. 
"His Majesty had many creatures brought here," said Paul. "And plants. They have a mutated form of wild 
buckwheat that people eat here." 
"Eriogonum deserticole," she said. "That's the botanical name for the wild buckwheat." 
He studied her face. "You know all about Arrakis, don't you?" he said. 
She looked on him fondly, warming her love of him at his effort to distract her. "I know some things about 
our new home. They brought 
the plants and animals here to condition this place for humans. Most of the new ones came from Earth. 
The dry climate plants are called erophytes. I have a filmbook about useful xerophytes. I'll see that Dr. 



Yueh has it for you tomorrow." 
Still, he studied her face. "Don't worry, mother. The guards will take care of the dangers outside. Pretty 
soon they will come for us. I'll protect you until then." 
She put an arm around his shoulder, turned to the tall reach of filter glass that faced the southwest. Out 
there, the sun of Arrakis had moved well on toward sunset. 
Paul put his hand over hers on his shoulder. 
ESCAPE FROM THE HARKONNENS: 
WITH DUNCAN AND LIET-KYNES 
AT THE DESERT BASE 
(Paul and Jessica's first sanctua ry, after the fall of Arrakeen) 
Jessica stepped over the doorsill into a windowless laboratory. 
Paul followed his mother, glanced back at the ornicopter his mother had commandeered to bring them. 
How peremptory she had been to the Duke's guard! He knew she'd used the Voice, and already he was 
beginning to think in Bene Gesserit terms. 
Jessica studied the long room in which they found themselves. It was a civil place full of angles and 
squares. The room contained about a dozen people in green smocks. Most of them were working at a long 
bench along one wall-watching dials, fiddling with instruments. There was the smell of ozone, and semi-
muted sounds that suggested furious activity: machine coughs, the horse-whinnies of spinning belts and 
multidrives. She saw cages with small animals in them stacked against an end wall. 
"Dr. Kynes?" she said. 
A figure at the bench turned. He was a thin man (like most of the dehydrated pods we've seen on this planet, 
she thought). 
"I am Dr. Kynes," he said. He spoke with a clipped-off precision, and looked that kind of man. Jessica 
immediately catalogued him as one whose words could be expected to come out razor apt, rasping off any 
fuzzy edges of meaning. 
Good, she thought. That kind are generally honest. 
"I am Lady Jessica and . . ." She indicated Paul, ". . . this is my son, Paul, the ducal heir." 
Momentary tenseness showed in a tightening of Dr. Kynes' jawline. The others turned from the bench, 
caution in their movements. Machine sounds hummed away to silence. Into this void there came a thin 
animal squeak from the cages. It was cut off abruptly as though in embarrassment. 
"We are honored, Noble Born," said Kynes. 
Noble Born! They all make that mistake, Jessica thought. Ah, well, let it pass. 
"You seem very busy here," she said. 
"What is this place, Mother?" Paul asked. He stared around him at the people who still watched dials, 
adjusted instruments. It reminded him somewhat of Dr. Yueh's laboratory, but there was more equipment 
to this place. 
"Visits of royalty are uncommon here," Kynes said. "We were . . . unprepared. Please forgive the . . ." 
"I thought this place had been abandoned," she said. "Isn't this one of the old desert biological stations? I 
saw it on the Duke's chart. I thought this was the place he was supposed to visit tomorrow." 
Kynes flicked a glance back to the bench, wet his lips with his tongue, returned his attention to her. 
"No one told us you were coming," he said. "The . . ." He shrugged. 
Jessica glanced once more around the room, recognizing the activity now for what it was: they'd been 
cleaning up some sort of last minute 
tests or work of that sort! They'd been preparing to pull all this out of here in a preparation for Leto's visit! 
Paul tugged at her arm. "May I go look at the animals down there in the cages?" 
She looked at Kynes. 
"Oh, they're quite safe," Kynes said. "Just don't stick your fingers in the cages. Some of the kangaroo rats 
will bite." 
"You will stay beside me, Paul," she said. She recognized the planetologist's uneasiness. She stared at him, 
allowing his nervousness to grow. "I like to see things the way they really are," Jessica said. "That's one 
reason I sometimes arrive unannounced." 



Kynes' face darkened. He glanced out the open door at the ornicopter, the two men standing beside it. 
And Jessica realized another thing: Kynes had been expecting someone to arrive. Otherwise he'd have 
made more of a stir about the 'copter. His own transport probably, or more of his workers. She allowed a 
cold smile to pass over her face, looked out the door. 
"Idaho!" she called. "Come here, please." 
She saw Idaho speak to the native pilot, then advance across the sand, through the door. He looked very 
impressive with his chest shield and currassier weapons. His attitude toward Jessica betrayed extreme 
deference. He was extending himself in good behavior, fighting the shame of his drunkenness. 
"Idaho," she said, "there's something unusual going on here. Keep a careful watch on these people. The 
Duke will want to know about this." 
Idaho swept a hard glance around the room. He was the trained killer letting the people here know he 
could smash them and they couldn't so much as scratch him. "Yes, My Lady," he said. 
Kynes swallowed. "My Lady, you don't understand. This is..."          
"Yes," she said. "What is this?" 
Paul looked up at Duncan Idaho, tried to imitate Idaho's hard glance around the room. His own body 
shield was in full force. He 
could feel the faint tingling around his forehead where the field was strongest. 
"My Duke is very generous to those of his subjects who are truthful and honorable with him," she said. 
"He is otherwise, I assure you, with people who lie to him or attempt to cheat him." 
Kynes chewed his lower lip, tried to explain some of his dignity. "My Lady, in all due respect, but this 
station is still part of the Emperor's reg . . ." 
"And the Emperor has been told, I'm sure, that this station was abandoned," she snapped. "Don't play 
games with me!" 
She sniffed and detected cinnamon! It was so faint behind the ozone odor that only her trained senses 
caught it. The spice! They were doing something here that concerned the spice! And the ozone was meant 
to kill the smell. Now, with her senses at full alert, she gestalted the place. She knew she'd be able to sort 
out the impressions later, get an accurate line on their experiments. 
"Really, My Lady," Kynes said. "We're all simple subjects of . . ." 
"You have been experimenting with the spice," she accused. 
Kynes and his workers froze, staring at her. Their fear was so thick it was like a palpable substance in the 
room. 
Jessica relaxed, smiled. "The Harkonnens forbade it, certainly," she said. "But don't any of you simpletons 
realize my Duke is not a Harkonnen, that he might have other ideas about such research?" 
She saw the first dawning hope in Kynes' eyes, glanced at Idaho. "You can relax, Idaho. We've just run 
into a symptom of the Harkonnen disease. They haven't had the Atreides antidote yet." 
Paul looked at his mother, back to Kynes. How had she known about the spice? It must be her special 
training, he realized. But how? The knowledge that she could do such a thing as this and that he might 
learn how to do it firmed his resolution. I will learn, he told himself. 
Kynes said, "But..." 
"Don't try to make excuses," she said. "We're familiar with what 
happens in a Harkonnen fief." She glanced at the workbench, pulling one fact from the gestalt impression, 
and she thought: Let them think we're omnipotent. She said: "You've been tracing the bifurcation of the 
phenol chain. Good. Tell your people to go on with their work. The Duke will want a full report on your 
progress." 
Kynes sagged. Every line of his face betrayed submission. If she even knew the direction of their research 
. . . 
"Tell your people," Jessica repeated. "My Duke rewards this sort of activity . . . especially if it's 
successful. And one thing more: You can discard your ideas about abandoning this place. It appears to be 
an excellent site for such work. It's near the spice sands. It's a place where you won't get casual visitors. . 
." She smiled. "We're not casual visitors." 
Chuckles came slowly around the room, they told her much. The way a person laughs shows you where his 



tensions are, went a Bene Gesserit axiom. One of the men in the room had only seemed to chuckle. She 
marked him for later investigation, said: "Is there somewhere we may talk without disturbing your 
workers or being disturbed ourselves, Doctor?" 
Kynes hesitated, inclined his head. "My office, Noble Born." He gestured toward a door at the end 
opposite the animal cages. 
"Paul, you stay with Idaho," Jessica said. "I won't be long. You may look at those animals if you wish, but 
mind the Doctor's warning. Some of those creatures bite." 
No need telling them to wear shields at all times, she thought. She gave Idaho the casual hand signal that 
told him to disregard her order to relax, for him to remain on alert. Idaho blinked acknowledgement. And 
she noted as she accompanied Kynes toward the door to his office that one of the workers crossed the 
room, closed the outside door. The worker was the one with the non-chuckle. 
Kynes' office was square, about eight meters to a side. Curry-colored walls were broken by a single line of 
reel-files and a portable scanner screen. There were no windows. Almost in the center of the room sat a 
squat desk with a milk-glass top shot full of yellow bubbles. Four 
suspensor-field chairs ringed the desk. There were papers on the desk held down by a small block of sand-
etched marble. 
Where did they expect to hide all this stuff? she wondered. It was a wedge-shaped building driven into a cliff. 
Then she realized that this room must have another exit, possibly an entire wall that swung aside. She'd 
noted when they were coming down in the 'copter that the structure squatted against a cliff. A cave in the 
cliff! she thought. How efficient. 
Kynes indicated a chair. She sat down. 
"There are no windows," she said. 
"Up here this close to the shield wall we get some of the high winds," he said. "They run 700 kilometers 
an hour and even higher. Some of them spill over into this little pocket. We call it the rain of sand. It 
doesn't take long under that kind of sandblasting for a window to become opaque. We depend on scanner 
eyes which can be shielded." 
"I see." She adjusted her chair to lower resistance. "I brought my son up here, Doctor, because someday 
he'll rule Arrakis. He must learn about it. We were told this place had been judged safe for the Duke's 
visit. I therefore considered it safe for my son and me." 
"You are perfectly safe here, My Lady," Kynes said. 
She spoke with a dry bitterness: "No one is perfectly safe anywhere." 
Kynes lowered his eyes. 
"I understand you've been on Arrakis quite a number of years," she said. 
"Forty-one years, My Lady." 
"As long as that?" 
He met her eyes, looked past her. "I was educated at Center, and came here as my first assignment, My 
Lady. It was a family tradition. My father was here before me. He was Chief of Laboratories when Arrakis 
was still His Imperial Majesty's Desert Botanical Testing Station." 
She liked the way he said "My father." 
"Did your father discover the spice?" 
"He did not discover the spice, but the discovery was made by men working under him," Kynes said. He 
looked down at the desk. "This was his desk." 
There was such a sense of pride and devotion in his voice, that Jessica felt the pulse of it with her special 
awareness. 
"Please sit down, Dr. Kynes," she said. 
Kynes' throat worked. He looked around the room, obviously embarrassed. "But, My Lady . . ." 
"It's quite all right," she said. "I'm only the Duke's bound concubine, the mother of his heir, but it'd still be 
all right were I Noble Born. You're a loyal man, Dr. Kynes, and honorable. My Duke respects such as you, 
and we relax the usual ceremony among those we trust." She pointed to the chair across from her. "Please 
sit down." 
Kynes took the chair, adjusting it to its highest resistance so that it supported him stiffly on its edge. 



"You're still operating under an Imperial grant?" she asked. 
"His Majesty very kindly supports our work." 
"Which is?" She smiled. "For the record, that is." 
He returned her smile, and she saw the beginning of relaxation in his attitude. "It's mostly dry land biology 
and botany, My Lady. And we do some geological work-core drilling and testing, things like that. You 
never really exhaust the possibilities of an entire planet." 
"Does His Majesty know the other work you do?" 
"I don't know quite how to say this, My Lady." 
"Try," she said. 
"We don't actually conceal anything from the Imperium," he said. "The records are all kept. We make 
regular reports as required. And we have quite proper authorization for all our projects. We . . ." 
She began to laugh. "Kynes . . . Kynes," she said. "You are marvelous. The system is marvelous. And the 
Imperial Court is so far away." * 
Kynes spoke stiffly: "We are loyal subjects of the Imperium, My Lady. Please don't try to twist what I..." 
"Twist? You disappoint me, Kynes." 
"What we discover is for the good of the Imperial Regate," Kynes said. "It's not as though . . ." 
"I want you to keep one thing foremost in your mind, Dr. Kynes." She permitted a sharpness to creep into 
her voice. "You are now a subject of the Atreides Duchy. My Duke gives the orders here. He, too, is a 
loyal subject of the Imperium. And he knows how records may be kept, and the required reports made, 
and the proper authorizations obtained for his projects." 
Now, she thought, let's see if there's any steel in him. 
A sour expression turned down the corners of Kynes' mouth. "And the Court is so far away. A minor 
planetologist could be dead and buried, all properly authorized, by the time the Court discovered it." 
"You've been too long under the Harkonnens," she said. "Didn't you learn anything except fear and 
suspicion?" 
"Oh, the pattern's clear enough," he said. "My Lady." 
"What pattern?" 
"The army of tame killers, the subtle pressures and the not so subtle ones." Kynes gripped the arms of his 
chair until his fingers were white. "I had hoped that this time . . ." He shook his head. "This planet could 
be a paradise! But all you and the Harkonnens ever think about is grubbing money out of the spice!" 
She spoke dryly: "And how is our planet to become a paradise without money?" 
Kynes blinked at her. 
"As with most visionaries," she said, "you see very little outside your vision." 
Kynes chewed his lower lip. "My Lady, I know I've spoken bluntly, but. . ." 
"Let's understand each other," she said. "My Duke is not in the habit of destroying valuable men. Your ... 
ah ... sharp words merely show your value. They prove there's steel in you that the Harkonnens didn't take 
the temper out of. My Duke has need of steel." 
Kynes drew a deep breath, hunted the corners of the room with his eyes. 
"How can you be sure I speak the truth?" she asked. A wry smile touched her mouth. "You can't be, of 
course, until it's too late, until after you're committed to an irrevocable decision. But the Harkonnen way 
offered you no hope at all, did it?"                                      
He shook his head, staring at her. 
"I, too, can speak bluntly," she said. "My Duke has his back to the wall. This fief is his last hope. If he can 
build Arrakis to a strong and secure Duchy, there will be a future for the Atreides line. He comes from 
Caladan, a planet that was a natural paradise. Too soft, perhaps. Men lost their edge quite easily there." 
"My Lady, there was talk of Harkonnen agents left behind." The words were wrenched from him as 
though he were trying to say more and could not. 
"Of course there were agents left behind!" And now we find out about him, she thought. "Do you know 
any of those agents?" 
Kynes glanced at the door, wet his lips with his tongue. "No, My Lady. Of course not. I have very little 
contact with the world outside my work." 



He's lying, she thought. And the thought pained her more than it should have. She sighed. Another time, 
perhaps. And Tuek would have to be told of this man's knowledge, of course. Again, she sighed. 
"What does your Duke really want of me?" Kynes asked. 
Well, why not change the subject? she thought. "Can the spice grow artificially?" she asked. 
Kynes pursed his lips. "Melange is not an ordinary ... that is, it's possible . . . unless . . . you see, I suspect 
there's a symbiotic relationship between the worms and whatever produces the spice." 
"Oh?" She found herself surprised by the idea. But why not? she asked herself. We know of stranger 
relationships. "What evidence of such symbiosis do you have?" 
"It's very tenuous, My Lady, I agree. But each worm defends its own sector of spice sands. Each seems to 
have a territory that. . . well. .. you see, we have only one preserved specimen . . . it's in another . . . 
location. The capture of that specimen was quite a project, you may . . ." 
"You have a live worm?"                                                      
"Oh, no! It's quite dead. Preserved. We stunned it with a chemical explosion, dug down and killed each 
ring with repeated applications of high-voltage electricity. Each ring had to be killed separately." 
She noted the increased alertness in Kynes, the animation as he warmed to his subject. "Is it a large one?" 
she asked. 
"Quite small, really. It's only about eighty meters long and some fifteen meters in diameter. They grow 
much larger in the deep desert- ten times that size. We caught this one in the high latitudes where the 
sand cover on the basic rock is rather thin. They're rare in that region, of course, and, I might add, so is the 
spice rare there. You never find the worms this far north." He gestured around him. "Too much rock and 
there are the mountains between us and the desert. And there's no evidence of spice in these latitudes." 
"Just because there's no spice where there are no worms," she said, "that doesn't. . ." 
"But there's other evidence," he said. "My examination of our specimen suggests a complicated 
relationship. It is very difficult to find true knowledge about the deep desert. Factory crawlers, aircraft, 
anything that's forced down in the deep desert and unable to get away stands little chance of survival. 
Your only hope is rescue . . . and that as fast as possible unless you can hold out on one of the rather rare 
outcroppings of substratum. There are a predictable number of personnel disappearances every year." 
"Ah, the uses of statistics," she murmured. 
"What, My Lady?" 
"The ubiquitous sand," she said. "And you spoke of making it a paradise." 
Frank Herbert, Brian Herbert, and Kevin J. Anderson  
"Well, My Lady, with sufficient water and . . ." 
The door behind Kynes slammed open onto reeling violence, shouting, the clash of steel, and wax-image 
faces grimacing. Jessica found herself on her feet, staring at Idaho's blood-pitted eyes, claw hands around 
him, arcs of blurred steel chopping. She saw Paul crawling past Idaho . . . the orange fire-mouth of a 
stunner. Paul had his small knife, the poison one, in his hand, flicking it, flicking it... at the people who 
clawed at Idaho and himself. 
In a different version of the scene: 
Our first move," Paul said, "should be to recover our Family Atomics. They're . . ." 
"What of your father's . . . body, his water?" Kynes asked. 
Paul sensed hidden meaning in the question, said: "My father died with honor." 
"You know this without knowing the manner of his death?" 
"I know it." 
"I think perhaps you do, yet the Harkonnens . . . still have his water." 
"The Harkonnens will overlook his water," Paul said. "They don't follow the Arrakeen Way. My father's 
water will escape into the air and soil of Arrakis, become a part of Arrakis, just as I will become a part of 
Arrakis." 
"Fremen will hesitate to follow a man who has not recovered his father's water." 
"I see," Paul said. 
"You asked for my counsel, sire." 
"Could you suggest a way of recovering my father's ... water?" 



"A force is being formed now to recover our own bodies from Arrakeen. They could be told to recover 
your father, also. If they're successful, a token battle with the leader of this band, you being victorious, 
would restore the pattern of things." 
"But that's not the best way," Paul said. 
"No. The best way is for you to do it yourself." 
"Our Family Atomics are in Arrakeen," Paul said. "They're shielded and hidden deep underneath our 
residency there, planted directly in line with the house's power plant and masked by that plant." 
He does not hesitate to tell this man anything, Jessica thought. He knows he has the loyalty. Indeed, what an 
Emperor my son would make. She pushed the thought aside, warning herself: I must not become infected by 
his scheme! 
"On Arrakis," Kynes said, "the water is more important." 
"In the Imperium, a Family's atomics are also important," Paul said. "Without them, you lack an unspoken 
bargaining point." 
"The suicide threat," Kynes said, and his voice was bitter. "I will shatter your planet"  
"Without the atomics," Paul said, "one is not quite a Great House. But then . . ." He gestured to the 
crysknife hilt partly concealed beneath the robe at Kynes' waist. ". . . is a Fremen a Fremen without his 
knife?" 
A smile touched Kynes' lips, white teeth glistening within his beard. 
New Chapter: THE FLIGHT FROM KYNES'S DESERT BASE 
In the cave's blackness, Jessica felt that her life had become sand 
curling in an hourglass, running faster and faster . . . There were no more luminous arrows to guide 
them-only a slit in rock that she felt with her hands. The slit gave out into night with the sound of a sand-
storm keening overhead, and the fall of sand on her outstretched hand. Her eyes tried to force light from 
memory, but found only the empty present. 
"What is it?" Paul asked. "Where are we?" 
"It's the end of the tunnel," she said. She tried to speak calmly, helping preserve his courage. "You saw 
that last arrow?" 
"There was a sign on it," he said. "What did it mean?" 
"Square within a square," she said. "That means 'end of path.' It's a Bene Gesserit symbol." And she 
wondered at the mystery of it. How 
had Kynes or whoever had made this place known to put a Bene Gesserit symbol there? The end that is a 
beginning. 
"What do you feel when you put your foot out?" Paul asked. 
"There's a drop-off of some kind," she said. "I can't feel the bottom of it. We'll have to wait for dawn 
unless we can find some light." 
"I feel sand blowing," he said. "And there's dust in my nose."  
"If only we had shields. You know, I blamed Idaho for not offering you his shield," she said. 
"Lump-lump-lump-lump!" 
It was a fluttering sound, directionless in the dark. Somewhere out there. Jessica held herself motionless 
except for a hand that reached out and gripped Paul's shoulder. Fingernails of terror scraped along her 
nerves. 
"What's that?" Paul whispered. 
"Chireeep!" It came from the inky dark. 
"Maybe something blowing in the wind," she said. "Be quiet and listen." 
The waiting moment was packed with a sense of movements. Every sound had its own dimension. They 
were so tiny, the little movements. Realization flooded through her, squeezing fear into controllable size. 
The ungainly thumping of her heartbeats evened, shaping out the moments of time. She forced inner 
calmness. 
"It's little animals, or perhaps birds," she said. "They were all around us and we frightened them." 
And she realized that this cave must have been a storm sanctuary for creatures from the desert. 
"What was that other sound?" Paul asked. 



"I don't know," she said. "Whatever it was... it was out there . . . quite a ways." 
She felt Paul move under her hand. Her son's first hope was to melt into the protective coloration among 
the people here, to sink back into the people. But first they had to find them. 
"I feel some kind of handle on the wall over here," he whispered. 
"Careful," she said. She moved her hand along his arm, groped fingers over his and onto cold metal: a bar 
in a vertical slot. The bar had been pushed to the top of its slot. 
"It felt like a hydraulic latch," Paul said. "The kind they have on shipboard for airtight doors." 
Airtight, she thought. Sandtight.                                            
Gently, she pulled down the bar. 
A crack of luminosity opened before them-a vertical rectangle. 
"It is a door," Paul whispered. 
"Shhhh," she cautioned. 
She pushed the door and it swung wide onto more blackness broken by two puddles of radiance beyond 
the opening. She recognized the glowing spots for what they were-footswitches. 
"Inside," she ordered. "Stay close. Keep hold of me." 
They slipped through the doorway, and she pulled it closed behind. The sound of the sandstorm dropped 
to a distant mewing. The air around them felt old-touched with dust. . . and faintly cinnamon. 
Jessica probed into the black with her senses, felt no living thing except themselves. 
"What're those two glowing pieces?" Paul whispered. 
She spoke aloud, shaping confidence into her tone. "Footswitches. This must be where the 'copter's 
hidden, the one Dr. Kynes said was at the end of the tunnel." She extended an arm, moved it to set up air 
currents, sensed a gross object. "Be careful you don't bump into it." 
"I'm thirsty," Paul said. 
"Maybe there'll be water in the 'copter," she said. She took his shoulder, crept forward to the puddles of 
radiance on the floor: two glowing circles enclosing black designs. One held a rayflash-it was a light 
switch. The other was bisected by a straight line-a door control. She touched the rayflash with her toe. 
Light drove back the darkness. 
Jessica darted her glance around the revealed room, testing it. The ornicopter was there in front of them, 
sealed beneath a transparent 
cover. Around it, an irregular space had been carved from the native rock and closed away from the 
outside by a flat expanse of metal. The place was just big enough to maneuver around the squat shape of 
the ornicopter. 
"It's a big one," Paul said. "I wonder . . ." 
She motioned him to silence, listening: The faint shrilling of the storm was punctuated now by interval 
chirps, a tiny whistling. Some of the sound came from above and behind them. She turned, looked up at 
broken rock. 
"What's that?" Paul whispered. 
"I don't. . ." 
A flurry of birdwings shocked her to silence. A feathered shape shot across the room over their heads, 
darted into a cranny on the opposite wall. The chirping whistles arose to a new height, slowly died away. 
"A bird," she sighed. "It has a nest in there." 
"It looked like a little owl," Paul said. "But how could it get in here?" 
"There's dust," she said. She pointed to the cover on the ornicopter and to the floor. "There must be a 
small hole in the rocks somewhere." She moved forward to the shield over the ornicopter. "Help me un-
cover this thing." 
Dust filled the air as they rolled back the cover. Paul sneezed. And Jessica recalled the precautionary 
lectures on this planet. Nose filters, she thought. We'll have to find nose filters somewhere. She slipped into the 
'copter, tested one set of its twin controls. 
Paul, right behind her, looked up from an examination of the panel and the interior walls. "It has no battle 
shield," he said. 
"It's not a battle craft," she said. She looked left and right at the spread of wings, the delicate metal 



interleaving that could open to lift them in a soaring glide or compress for jet-driven speed. 
"What're those things on the rear seat?" Paul asked. 
She turned, followed the direction of his pointing finger. Two low mounds of black fabric. She had taken 
them for cushions, saw now that they were shaped to fit a human back, that they had adjustable 
straps-packs. She reached back, flipped one over. It was surprisingly heavy and gave off a gurgling 
sound. Orange lettering came into view. She read it aloud: "Emergency use only. Contents: stilltent, one; 
literjons, four; energy caps. . ." 
"Literjons," Paul said. "That's what it said on a water machine at the landing field. 'Fill literjons here.' 
Could that mean water?" 
"Yes." She continued reading, feeling the rigors of this planet press in on her with every word: "Energy 
caps, sixty; recaths, two; burnooses, two; distrans, one; medkit, one; digger, one; sandsnork, one; stillsuits, 
two; repkit, one; baradye pistol, one; sinkchart, one; filtplugs, eight; paracompass, one; instructs, one." 
"What's a recath?" Paul asked. 
"I don't know," she said. She dropped her attention to the handwritten addition, below the printing, and in 
the same orange: "Fremkit, one; thumpers, four." 
Paul said. "Thumper?" 
"I suppose there'll be an instruction manual," she said. Out of the pack's ziptop came a micro-manual with 
a magnifier and glowtab for turning the miniscule pages. 
"Stilltent," Paul read. "Saaaay ... it reclaims the water that evaporates from your body." He bent over the 
book, reading: "Breath reclamation-breathe through the dry-pass tube at all times. Remember, if your 
stay in the desert may be extended, that all moisture must be conserved. Make sure you wear the recath 
and its collection bottle at all times. See instructions for correct use of catheter equip . . ." He glanced 
down the page. "Mother! Do we drink . . ." 
"Hush," she said. "If it's purified, water is water. What do you think we drank on the spaceship coming 
here?" 
"But. . ." 
"Go on reading," she ordered. When my water is gone, she thought, Paul will still have some left. "Our 
lives depend on how well we learn this. You'll see here, it says people have worn catheters for months at a 
time without ill effect, but we can expect some irritation from them at first." 
"I don't like it," he said. His voice sounded sullen. 
"What don't you like?" she asked. "Living?" 
He looked up at her, then back to the book. Presently, he bent over it, reading and examining the things 
from the pack. 
Stillsuits. They were like a tent, only to be worn at all times. 
Nose filters. She showed him how to install them.                 
Within an hour they had finished the manual and followed its instructions, escaping out to the open sands. 
They wore the light plastic stillsuits beneath sand-colored robes. A stilltent covered them with its snorkel 
protruding upward along a rock face. 
Only a rough package marked "fremkit" remained to be examined from Jessica's pack. She opened it. Out 
puffed a pastel blue kerchief that fluttered gauzily as she lifted it. Beneath the kerchief lay what appeared 
to be a knife in a sheath and a small package marked thumpers. On the thumper package was scrawled: 
"See instructions for calling sandworms inside." 
"Calling a sandworm," Paul said. "Who'd want to?" 
"I don't know," she said. She pulled the knife from its sheath. The blade was about twenty centimeters 
long, four-edged, and made of some milkwhite cloudy substance. She held it up, looked down the point. It 
had a cross-section in the shape of a shallow X and the tip was pierced by a hair-sized hole. 
Poison? she wondered. 
The handle felt warm and resilient beneath her fingers. She hesitated on the point of squeezing the handle, 
decided against it. She put the knife back in its sheath for later examination when they were out of the 
tent. 
There remained now the flat little case labeled distrans, which was a distress transmitter, and the baradye 



pistol. She slipped the transmitter back into the pack, hefted the pistol. The instructions said it could be 
fired into the sand and would spread a patch of orange dye about twenty meters in diameter. 
"What's this?" Paul asked. He lifted a tiny booklet out of the fremkit. 
Jessica took it, opened it to the first page. 
Handwritten! 
The script was small but legible without the magnifier. The glowtab picked out the words. She read, and 
as she read, excitement grew in her. Not so much for the instructions contained there, but for what they 
implied.                                                                           
It opened with two prayers: 
"God give us water in torrents that we may bring forth vegetation and grain and gardens luxuriant." 
And: 
"May the fire of God set a cooling light over thy heart." 
It was called, she read, "The Kitab al-ibar, the azhar book, giving the ayat and burhan of life. Believe on 
these things and al-lat will not burn you." 
She turned the page. 
"What is it?" Paul asked. 
She spoke as she read: "It's a book telling how to live in the desert on the things of the desert. How to use 
the things you find in the desert." She turned another page, read a sentence, and looked up at him. "Paul, a 
thing like this couldn't be unless there were an entire culture behind it." 
"What do you mean?" 
"There are people who live in the desert, or at least on the edges of it, people who call themselves 
'Fremen,' probably meaning Free-men." She looked at him. "If we could find them. If . . ." She turned back 
to the book, continued reading. 
Paul turned, opened his own pack, burrowed in it for his own fremkit. 
She spoke absently as she read: "Be careful of the knife in there. I think it has a poison tip." 
Presently, both of them were reading: two little glowtab spots in the glowglobe dusk of the tent. 
Paul looked up through the transparent end of the tent. He pointed 
to a cluster of stars. "That's the constellation of the Mouse. Its tail points north." 
"There's much to learn," she said. She adjusted the flltertube over her mouth, glanced at him. "Do you still 
have the gun Dr. Yueh gave you?" 
He patted the sash beneath his robes.                                   
"I presume Gurney has instructed you on such weapons." 
"Yes. Why?" 
"If we meet.. . when we meet these Fremen, they may not accept strangers easily." 
"And they might not expect a child to be armed," he said. He touched the shield stud beneath his robes. 
"Nor shielded." 
"In case the need arises," she said. 
And Paul thought: She is right. Grown men might not suspect I'm no longer a child. 
She straightened, listening. "Hear that?" 
"I don't hear anything," he said. 
"The absence of a thing is as important as its presence," she said. "Never forget that." 
"The storm," he said. "I can't hear the wind." He looked back at the packs, flicked his tongue across his 
lips, thinking of the water. But if the storm ... if it was still dark out there. They needed darkness. 
Jessica watched his face in the instant it took these thoughts to flick through his mind. She felt sadness and 
approval at the look of adult decision on his features. 
"It'll still be dark outside," he said. "Best we take advantage of it." 
She spoke with a crisp edge to give him confidence. "Right. Strap yourself in while I see to the door." 
"I can do that," he said. 
MUAD'DIB 
Movement caught Paul's attention. He stared down through smoke bushes and weeds into a wedged slab 
sand surface of moonlight inhabited by an up-hop, jump, pop-hop of motion. 



"Kangaroo mice!" he hissed. 
Pop-hop-hop! 
Into shadows and out. 
Paul untied the line around him, slipped out of his pack. He reached down to the ground for a handful of 
pebbles. 
Jessica watched him, wondering. 
Paul moved forward. He stayed in shadows, creeping-graceful cat movements. 
Slam! 
The handful of pebbles hurtled into the sand clearing. Two tiny 
creatures lay writhing. He was on them in one lithe pounce-cracked their necks. 
Slowly, Paul looked back up at his mother. His burnoose was a grey sliding of motion. 
The hunter, she thought. The animal. Now, he must return to humanity. He must do it by himself.                                           
"We won't starve," Paul said. 
"Indeed we won't," she agreed. 
"They have blood," he said. "It's. . ." He shook his head. "Well, if we have to ... if we can't find water." 
She nodded. 
He looked down at the mice, one in each hand. "They were so beautiful," he said. 
Jessica smiled. Her cracked lips hurt with the movement. 
"They'll save our lives," he said, "if we can't find other food. I'll never forget them." 
She nodded. He was coming back. 
"We'd best make a fire to cook them," he said.               
"Above all, the human is practical," she said. 
"What?" 
"Nothing, dear. I'll help gather twigs for the fire. We can make it here against the cliff where it won't be 
seen very far." 
Deleted Scenes and Chapters from Dune Messiah 
ORIGINAL OPENING SUMMARY FOR DUNE MESSIAH 
The Bene Gesserits operated for centuries behind the mask of a 
semi-mystical school while actually carrying on a selective breeding program among humans. When the 
program appeared to reach its goal they held their inevitable "trial of fact." The records of that trial in the 
case of the Prophet Muad'Dib betray the school's ignorance of what it had done. 
It may be argued that they could examine only such facts as were available to them and had no direct 
access to the person of Muad'Dib. But the Bene Gesserits had surmounted great obstacles and their igno-
rance here goes deeper. 
The program had as its target the breeding of a person they labeled the Kwisatz Haderach, meaning "the 
one who can be many places at once." In simpler terms, what they sought was a human with powers of 
mind that would permit him to understand and use higher-order dimensions. 
The school's proctors had the Mentat example from which to start. The typical Mentat, after his training, 
can solve many problems simultaneously. He investigates long chains of logic and circumstances and, to 
an observer, seems to arrive at his conclusions in a split second. As many Mentats have testified, however, 
the internal sensations of the computing process frequently are such that he may feel he has taken 
millennia to solve the given problems. One of the first steps in training Mentats is teaching them 
awareness of this Time trick. 
Muad'Dib, according to many of the Bene Gesserit tests, was the one they sought. He was born Paul 
Atreides, son of the Duke Leto, a man whose bloodline had been watched carefully for more than a 
thousand years. His mother, the Bene Gesserit concubine, Lady Jessica, was a natural daughter of the 
Baron Vladimir Harkonnen and carried gene-markers of supreme importance to the program. 
Lady Jessica had been ordered to produce an Atreides daughter. The plan was to inbreed such a daughter 
with Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen, a nephew of the Baron. The high probability here was that they would have 
a Kwisatz Haderach or near-Kwisatz Haderach in the next generation. But Paul Atreides appeared a 



generation early when the Lady Jessica deliberately defied her orders and bore a son. 
These two facts alone should have alerted the Bene Gesserits to the possibility that a wild variable had 
entered their plans. But there were other indications which they virtually ignored. 
1) Paul Atreides as a youth showed ability to predict the future. His prescient visions were accurate, 
penetrating, and defied four-dimensional explanation. 
2) The  Reverend  Mother  Gaius  Helen  Mohiam,  the  Bene Gesserit Proctor who tested Paul's humanity, 
testified that he surmounted more agony in the test than any other human of record. She failed to make 
special note of this. 
3) When the Atreides Family moved to the planet Arrakis, the Fremen population of that planet hailed 
Paul as a prophet, "the voice from the outer world." The Bene Gesserits were well aware that the rigors of 
such a planet as Arrakis, with its lack of open water, its vast deserts, its emphasis on basic needs for 
survival, produce a high proportion of sensitives. The Fremen reaction was another clue the Bene 
Gesserits ignored. 
4) When the Harkonnens, aided by the Sardaukar soldier-fanatics of the Padishah Emperor, reoccupied 
Arrakis, killing Paul's father and most of his troops, Paul and his mother disappeared. But almost 
immediately there were reports of a new religious leader among the Fremen, a man called Muad'Dib who 
was again hailed as a prophet. The reports stated clearly that he was guarded by a new Reverend Mother 
of the Sayyadina rite, "who was the woman who bore him." Fremen records available to the Bene 
Gesserits stated clearly that their legends of the prophet contained these words: "He shall be born of a 
Bene Gesserit witch." 
(It may be argued that the Bene Gesserits had sent their Missionaria Protectiva onto Arrakis centuries 
earlier to implant something like this legend as a safeguard should any members of the school be trapped 
there and need sanctuary, and that this legend of the Lisan al-Gaib was properly to be ignored. But this is 
true only if you grant that they were correct in ignoring the other clues about Paul-Muad'Dib.) 
5) When the Arrakis affair boiled up, the Spacing Guild made overtures to the Bene Gesserits. The Guild 
hinted that its Navigators, who used the spice drug of Arrakis to produce the limited prescience necessary 
to guide spaceships through the void, were "bothered about the future." This could only mean they saw a 
nexus, a meeting place of countless delicate decisions, beyond which the path was hidden. This was a 
clear indication that some agency was interfering with higher-order dimensions! 
(The Bene Gesserits were well aware that the Guild could not interfere directly with the vital spice source 
because Guild Navigators already were dealing somewhat with higher-order dimensions such that the 
slightest misstep could be catastrophic. It was a known fact that Guild Navigators could see no way to take 
control of the spice without producing just such a nexus. The obvious conclusion was that someone of 
higher-order powers was taking control of the spice source.) 
In the face of these facts, one is led to the inescapable conclusion that the Bene Gesserits' behavior in this 
affair was a product of a higher plan of which they were completely unaware. 
This is the Summa prepared by her own agents at the request of Lady Jessica immediately following the 
Arrakis affair. The candor of this report amplifies its value far beyond the ordinary. 
New Chapter: ALIA & THE DUNCAN IDAHO GHOLA 
These things I tell you: the sequential nature of real history c annot be repeated precisely by pr escience. We grasp incidents cut out of the chain. 
That is why I deny my own powers. Eternity moves. It inflicts itself upon me. Let my subjects doubt my majesty and my oracular visions. Let them 
never doubt eternity. 
- DUNESDAY PROVERBS 
It occurred to Alia, studying the ghola in her audience chamber, that he was a religious unknown. The way 
he serenely surmounted the turmoil around him filled her with disquiet. 
There were mother-memories of Duncan Idaho within her grasp and she consulted them for a clue to this 
creature whose flesh had been a friend's. With a growing sense of suspicion she realized how she'd leaned 
on pre-judgments. 
Alia-Jessica had always thought of Duncan as a man who could be recognized for what he was-not by 
lineage or planet of origin but of and by himself: stalwart, isolated, self-supporting. It was the way with 
many who'd been friends of House Atreides. 
Now, she rejected all preconceptions. This was not Duncan Idaho. This was the ghola. 



She turned slightly on the altar steps, looking across the ghola at the Guild navigator and his attendants. 
The ambassador, swimming in his container of orange gas, gave every appearance of being satisfied with 
a situation which should not satisfy him. 
"Did you hear me correctly, Ambassador Edric?" she demanded. "My suspicions are not to be taken 
lightly. Perhaps I should order you held prisoner while we seek out and destroy your frigates." 
"Let me remind the sister of the Emperor that I am an ambassador," the guildsman said. He turned, 
reclining in his tank, a buoyant figure with hooded eyes which stared up at her. "You cannot threaten my 
person and escape the consequences. Every civilized man in the Empire will oppose you if this is your 
choice." 
"Mentat," Alia said, "what is this prattle?" 
As she spoke, she knew what the ambassador meant. There was a limit to the force even the most 
powerful could apply without destroying themselves. 
"Do you truly need me to tell you?" Duncan asked. 
She shook her head. The evidence lay all around and she wondered why she hadn't seen it before this. A 
Bene Gesserit axiom arose in her mind like a fish surfacing in turbulent waters: "Concentrate on one sense 
at the expense of the others. This is a danger. Avoid it." Oracular vision was a sense, she realized. It had 
blinded her to what could be seen with the naked eye. The primitive forms lay all around her-in money, 
in culture, in social usages. And the populace was sinking beneath government, being conscripted. 
No populace would permit that. 
Every misuse of power would be held against the government, stored up until it exploded in one violent 
overturning. 
Alia, staring down at the Guild ambassador, realized she was looking at a martyr. He had been prepared-
anointed. He was the sacrifice the Guild offered on the altar of its bid for power. 
"So that's the way it is," Alia said. "Then by the power invested in 
me by the Emperor, I invoke a formal trial. Let the Landsraad judges be summoned. Choose your 
defender, guildsman." 
The ambassador flopped over in sudden agitation, turned his face away from her. The witch! he thought. 
She had always been more dangerous than her brother. 
"There is a Fremen saying," Alia said. " 'It should not be necessary to pay to gain justice.' To this, let me 
add that it should not be necessary to pray, as well. Whom do you choose for defender?" 
Duncan saw the guildsman give a subtle hand signal to an attendant, leaped to place himself between the 
group on the audience chamber floor and Alia. It was an instinctive motion which surprised even him. 
As he moved, Duncan saw something hurtle from the ambassador's attendants toward Alia. With a 
blurring reflex, Duncan swept his hand across the thing's path, felt the horned calluses on the heel of his 
hand strike sharp metal. Something buzzed, clattering to the floor. It flopped there like a wounded fish, 
and he realized they'd dared hurl a hunter-seeker at the Emperor's sister! The realization accompanied his 
own reflexive leap as he stamped on the thing, smashing it before it could find warm flesh and burrow into 
a vital organ. 
The chamber erupted in violence around him. 
The Fremen guard had plunged as one man onto the Guild entourage. 
Knots of struggling battle swayed around the room, churning, rolling-the glitter of knives, grunts, shouts. 
Duncan's gaze took in the scene as he whirled, swept Alia into his arms and plunged with her toward the 
protective seclusion of the passage behind the dais. 
But Alia rolled out of his grasp, her knife in hand, and for an instant he thought she was going to sink the 
blade into him, but she gasped, "Hold!" 
"You must get to a safe place!" he insisted, moving to put himself between her and the violence. 
An odd smile twisted her mouth and she said: "I command you to step aside, Duncan. It's safe enough 
here." She gestured and he sensed the sudden silence of the chamber, turned. 
Bloody robes, mounded figures lay scattered across the floor. Only Fremen guards remained standing, 
their chests heaving from the exertion. Remarkably, the guildsman's tank stood unmarked amidst the 
carnage, the ambassador reclining in his orange gas, arms folded across his chest, eyes intent upon Alia. 



"You can do no more than kill me," he said, and there was a strange feeling of emotion in the artificial 
voice. 
"Is that so?" Alia asked. She gestured imperiously to a guard captain, said: "Bring me a lasgun." 
"No!" Duncan blurted. 
"Do as I command," Alia ordered. 
The guard captain hesitated. "The Guild swine may have a shield in that tank," he said. 
"M'Lady," Duncan said. "Touch a lasgun beam to a shield and the entire city will go up in the explosion." 
"And the Guild will be charged with using atomic weapons against House Atreides," she said. "Who can 
tell a lasgun-shield explosion from the blast of a fusion bomb?" 
"I care not how I die," the ambassador said. "Knife, lasgun beam- however you choose. Offend the law 
in any way you wish. You have slain my attendants and aides. I know what's in store for me." 
"Do you now?" Alia asked. The guard captain placed the black rod of a lasgun in her hand. 
She took it without looking, descended the steps to the chamber floor, avoided a body, stopped beside the 
ambassador's tank. 
"Do you have a shield?" she asked, voice conversational. 
"I have a shield," the guildsman admitted, voice tight, "but it's turned off. I'll not put the Guild in your 
hands that easily." 
Duncan, following Alia, put a hand on her arm. "Can you believe him, M'Lady?" 
"What do you think, Duncan?" She glanced at him, eyes oddly veiled. 
Duncan took a deep breath, put his Mentat awareness to her question. Not likely this man would use a 
shield. This was a dedicated guildsman. He'd die before betraying his own kind. 
"It isn't likely, M'Lady," Duncan said. "But must you kill him?" 
"You object?" Alia asked. She glanced around at the remains of the violence in the chamber. "Some of my 
guards died at this creature's bidding." 
"I do not participate in public homicide," Duncan said. 
"What manner of man are you?" Alia demanded. "You offered your own body to protect me, yet you will 
not agree to the destruction of my enemies." 
"Savagery has been taken out of me," Duncan said. 
She touched his cheek. "But you have flesh." 
"Do not kill this one, M'Lady," Duncan said. "I know it is the wrong thing to do." 
"I command here," she said. "Do you admit that?" 
"Yes!" 
"Then stand aside." 
Reluctantly, every muscle objecting, he obeyed. 
Alia turned, adjusted the lasgun for short range, aimed at the guildsman's tank, pressed the trigger. 
A hole perhaps two centimeters in diameter appeared in the transparent stuff of the tank. Wisps of orange 
gas emerged, trailed upward in the vagrant air currents of the chamber. 
There was a sudden pungency of melange in the room. 
Alia returned the lasgun to the guard captain, kept her attention on the Guild ambassador. Edric the 
Steersman swam unharmed in his tank, eyes intent on Alia.                                                                  
She waited without speaking. 
As though they were controlled from outside himself, the ambassador's eyes went to the hole in his tank 
and the orange gas escaping there. 
"Do you smell the spice, Duncan?" Alia asked. 
"His air must be saturated with it," Duncan said. He studied the orange gas diffusing into the audience 
chamber. 
"You witch!" the ambassador blurted. "Kill me and have done with it!" 
"Kill you?" she asked. "Without a trial? Do you take me for a barbarian?" 
The ambassador's chest was heaving. "You don't know what you're doing," he protested. 
"Don't I?" she asked. 
"I should've turned on my shield!" Edric snapped. 



"You really should have," Alia said. "Whom do you choose for your defender?" 
"Seal my tank this instant!" Edric said. 
"Seal it yourself," Alia said. 
Abruptly, the guildsman placed a webbed hand against the hole in his tank, fumbled in the pouch at his 
waist. 
Alia slid the crysknife from its sheath at her neck. Her Fremen guards stiffened. The crysknife carried 
sacred implications and there were outworlders present. Alia appeared unaware of the disquiet among her 
guards. She reached out the knife point. Light glimmered from the milky blade. Slowly, deliberately, she 
thrust the knife into the ambassador's palm where it lay exposed against the lasgun hole. 
With a piercing yell, the guildsman jerked his hand away from the hole, held up a bloody palm. 
Alia withdrew the reddened blade tip, held it up for Duncan to see. 
"Human blood, I'll bet you," she said. And she extended the blade toward one of her guards, said: 
"Bannerjee, wipe this blade clean and take the wiping to a techman. I want this blood analyzed. I would 
know what humanity it shares with me . . . and how it differs." 
Edric the Steersman had produced a cloth from his pouch. He wrapped his injured hand, stuffed another 
piece of material into the hole in his tank. 
"What do I share with you?" he demanded, glaring at Alia. "I share the common bondage of all life. But 
the dark memories of your savagery-I no longer share those!" 
"I think you have another bondage which is not common," Alia said. "What think you, Hayt?" she 
demanded, glancing at Duncan. 
Instead of answering, the ghola said: "Why do you call me that?" 
"Hayt?" she asked. "Is that not how you're called?" 
"Yes." The answer was filled with reluctance. 
"Can you answer my question?" she asked. 
Duncan nodded. "The air this guildsman breathes is saturated with melange. That says much about him." 
"Those capsules we see him pop into his mouth so frequently," Alia said, "do they not add to the picture?" 
"More of the spice, I'd say," Duncan agreed. 
"The dosage with which this guildsman maintains himself staggers the imagination," Alia said. "How do 
you compute this?" 
Duncan took a deep breath, his manner growing remote in Mentat withdrawal. Presently, he said: "The 
steersmen of the Guild use the spice to heighten their prescient powers. Without it they cannot divine the 
safest paths for their heighliners to course through space. In their duties, they must use more and more and 
more melange . . ." 
"The dosage requirements must increase at a rate which is compounded by a pressure of their need," Alia 
said. "It is a thing which both my brother and I have sensed." 
"You are fools!" Edric raged. 
Alia turned, studied the guildsman swimming in his tank. The orange gas had thinned and he appeared 
pale hanging there in his suspensors. 
"Have you chosen your defender?" she asked. 
"I choose the Reverend Mother you hold prisoner," Edric snapped. "Gaius Helen Mohiam!" 
"Very well," Alia said. She turned to the guard captain. "The ambassador is to be held in custody under 
constant visual guard until his trial," she said. "I wish daily reports on his activities. Meanwhile, you 
will drain the gas from his tank and have it subjected to analysis. Replace the gas with the pure air of 
Arrakis." 
"You cannot!" the guildsman protested. "You mustn't." 
"Why not?" Alia asked. "Will it kill you?" 
"You know it won't," he hissed, bringing his face close to the transparent wall of his tank.                                                      
"It will blind his oracular vision," Duncan said. 
"You have no human feelings!" Edric said. Extreme agitation shook his body. 
"Human feeling?" Alia asked. "What is this birdflap about human feeling? When you've failed, you fall 
back on this intense inner thing which is outraged by violence. Hah! Let me tell you something, gambler, 



human feeling's a feeble argument which labels the loser. You failed to measure the consequences, 
gambler." 
"What did you call me?" Edric asked, shock apparent in his voice even through the transponders. 
"Gambler!" Alia said. "I pay you a compliment." 
"You can't be serious," Edric protested. 
"Gamblers and ecologists are the only ones who truly measure consequences," Alia said. "We of the 
oracles are always gamblers. We're a step beyond politicians and businessmen, I give you that." 
The guildsman shook his head, a fish-motion that sent tremors down his body. "I beg of you not to take 
the spice from my air," he pleaded. 
"With what would you buy that boon?" Alia asked. 
"Buy?" 
"My brother's government is always willing to bargain," Alia said. 
"Buy?" Edric repeated, his voice louder. 
"When you come down to it," Alia said in a reasonable tone, "all government is business. 'Fortune passes 
everywhere,' as my father often said." She glanced sideways at Duncan, found his metallic eyes hidden by 
closed lids. It gave him an odd, more human look, a figure in repose. Ghola substance was masked. 
As though he felt her glance, Duncan opened his eyelids. The metal orbs glistened as they turned toward 
her. 
"Governments always conveniently overlook their own inequities," he said. "This I was taught. Do you 
not see how you play your enemy's game?" 
Anger sent color into Alia's cheeks.                                       
"There are some questions you may not ask!" she snapped. 
"When force closes the mouth of inquiry," Duncan said, "that is the death of civilization." 
Alia glared at him, brought her quickened breathing under control. Platitudes! 
Edric was staring at the ghola. The guildsman twisted his body around, attention focused on the pair 
beside his tank. 
"Hayt," Edric said, "will you help in my defense?" 
Alia whirled. "You presume too much, Ambassador!" 
"Do I?" Edric asked, studying Duncan. 
"Indeed you do," Duncan said. "I was a gift to House Atreides, freely given, freely accepted. You no 
longer have demands upon my services." 
"My brother must be notified at once," Alia said, speaking softly. "His judgment is, after all, the one 
which must prevail." 
"You take the law too lightly," the guildsman snarled. "Its language is plain enough that even the lowliest 
citizen can understand it." 
"The language of the law," Alia said, "means only what my brother says it means." 
With an air of finality, she turned away, motioned her guards to close behind, strode to the dais. There, she 
turned. "Hayt," she said, "you will accompany me." 
Duncan shrugged, fell into step with the guards. 
He could hear other guards behind him taking the guildsman's tank into tow, moving it down the chamber. 
Still more guards, he realized, would be hurrying to collect the bodies and reclaim their water. 
Alia's men were, after all, Fremen. 
New Chapter: THE HUMAN DISTRANS 
(The character Otmo was changed  to Korba in the published version of Dune Messiah.) 
e found the guard swarming in the parade yard, a scene of frantic confusion with rumors passing from 
mouth to mouth in a clamorous, intimidating babble. 
Both moons were up and full, but they were on the windowless side of the passage by which Paul returned 
to the Keep. The hall had been left in darkness broken only by a single shaft of light from the door to the 
Interrogation Salon. Lack of illumination in the approach was a Security rule. Darkness made one a 
difficult target. 
Word had preceded him on the fight at Otheym's house, and now there were loud cries from the guard area 



as it was learned the Emperor had returned. Guardsmen wavered into view from the Salon with the light 
behind them. 
Two of Stilgar's men carried Bijaz between them ahead of Paul. The 
dwarf's short legs couldn't be allowed to slow down the Imperial party. Bijaz, recovered from his fright, 
was darting glances all around, eyes alert and inquiring. 
"Get the Council of Naibs here at once," Paul commanded as he entered the Salon. "And turn down those 
lights except for that corner over there." He gestured. "We'll question Bijaz there." 
"You do not question a human distrans," Bijaz said, a dignity in his manner which made some of the 
guardsmen laugh. 
"Listen to him, now," one of them said. "Would you listen to him?" 
"Put him down," Paul said. "Stilgar? Where is Stilgar?" 
"Gone for the Naibs, Sire," said a man behind him. 
Paul recognized Bannerjee's voice, glanced back, said: "Have you a distrans recorder ready?" 
"All ready, Sire." Bannerjee gestured to an aide who carried a thin recorder tube, its shigawire reel 
glistening in the end. 
Paul looked back at the dwarf, who stood now between two impassive guardsmen, glowglobes bright 
above them. Beads of perspiration stood out on Bijaz's forehead. The dwarf seemed now a creature of odd 
integrity, as though the purpose fashioned into him by the Tleilaxu was projected out through the skin. 
There was power beneath this mask of cowardice and frivolity, Paul realized. 
"Do you truly work as a distrans?" Paul asked. 
"Many things work as a distrans, Sire," Bijaz said. "Anything with a voice and a nervous system can be a 
distrans. You should know this. You know everything." 
"None of that," said the guardsman on Bannerjee's left side, nudging him. 
Paul thought of the code word Otheym had imparted by inference- the name of the one killed: Jamis. He 
felt reluctance to utter the word, to test it on the dwarf. There seemed a demeaning of humanity to use a 
man as a distrans, even such a man as this. 
"Set the recorder for immediate translation," Paul said. 
The guardsman beside Bannerjee adjusted his instrument. 
"Jamis," Paul said. 
Bijaz stiffened. A thin keening sound issued from his lips. His eyes were glazed. The keening wavered 
and twisted. 
Paul stared at the recorder as a piping voice began to issue from it. The voice was very slow with long 
pauses as though spoken out of great weariness. "Tibana was an apologist for Socratic-Christianity," the 
thin voice said. "He was probably a native of IV Anbus who lived between the 8th and 9th Centuries, likely 
in the reign of the Second Corrino. Of Tibana's writings, only a portion survives from which this fragment 
is taken-'The hearts of all men dwell in the same wilderness.' It is a thing to consider when you 
contemplate treachery." 
Paul glanced around at the uncomprehending faces of his aides and companions. He had not told them the 
information Bijaz held and they didn't know what to expect. Names-would the names of any present be 
uttered now by this dwarf? 
"The Fremen of the deep desert have revived the blood sacrifice to Shai-Hulud," the recorder piped in time 
to Bijaz's keening. "They say the Emperor and his sister are one person, one being back to back, half male, 
half female." 
Paul saw eyes turn toward him. He felt suddenly that he existed in a dream controlled by some other mind, 
and that he might momentarily forget this to become lost in the convolutions of that mind. 
"Emperor and sister must die together to make the myth real," the recorder piped. "The words of Otmo the 
Panygerist are preached in the secret ceremonies. 'Muad'Dib is the Coriolis storm,' they say. 'He is the 
wind that carries death in its belly. Alia is the lightning which strikes from sand in the dark sky.' And they 
shout: 'Blow out the lamp! Day is here!' It is the signal they learn for the attack." 
Paul thought of the ancient ritual, mystical, tangled with folk memories, old words, old customs, forgotten 
meanings-a bloody play of ideas across Time. Ideas . . . ideas . .. they carried a terrifying power. 



They could blot out civilizations or become a blazing light in the mind to illuminate lives across the span 
of centuries. He looked at the face of the dwarf, seeing youthful eyes in an old face. Eyes of total blue! 
The dwarf was a melange addict, then. What could that mean? He studied the eyes, total blue at the center 
of a network of knobby white lines which ran to the hollows below the temples. Such a large head. All 
seemed to focus on the pursed mouth from which that monotonous high whine continued to issue. 
The names, Paul thought. Get to the names. 
"Among the Naibs," the recorder piped, "the traitors are Bikouros and Cahueit. There is Djedida, secretary 
to Otmo." 
All around him, Paul felt the guardsmen stiffening as they grasped the import of what was occurring here. 
Bannerjee took a half step forward to stand glaring down at the dwarf. 
Bannerjee, too? Paul wondered. He was obsessed by a feeling of threat. Bikouros, Cahueit, Djedida! 
"There is Abumojandis, the aide to Bannerjee," Bijaz said. "And El-dis . . ." 
Motion erupted beside Paul, a thing he had expected, but not in the form it took. Bannerjee, whirling, 
placed himself between Paul and the aide with the distrans recorder. The aide had lifted the recorder like a 
weapon aimed at Paul. A burst of flame darted from the instrument, catching Bannerjee full in the waist. 
The piping voice of the distrans was stilled but the keening of Bijaz continued as Paul hurled a sliver knife 
from the sheath in his left sleeve. The knife seemed to sprout from the aide's throat. Bannerjee staggered 
back into Paul's arms, muttered: "M'Lord, I failed you." 
The aide was on the floor, arms outstretched and held by guards, dead eyes staring at the ceiling. Paul 
recognized the man then: Abumojandis, a Fremen of Balak Sietch from the deep desert. Otheym's list was 
true, then-traitors. 
Medics pulled Bannerjee from Paul's arms. 
Paul grew aware that Bijaz was going on with that monotonous keening. The distrans recorder remained 
silent. 
"Someone get another recorder!" Paul snapped. "And see if you can shut that creature up!" 
Even as he spoke, he knew the dwarf could not be silenced until the message had run its course. It would 
be a one-way thing: start it and let it run. They'd have to begin again. 
"Get him into the other room," Paul said. 
The new flurry of motion his orders had set off was interrupted by the arrival of the Naibs, the Fremen 
council of Sietch leaders. Stilgar led the procession. He was in his formal robes now, a grim figure be-
neath a shock of black hair. His craggy face, massive nose and rock-hewn cheekbones held an expression 
of wary alertness. 
"M'Lord," he said. "What is..." 
Paul silenced him with a wave of the hand, searched the procession. Bikouros and Cahueit were not 
among the others. 
"Where are Bikouros and Cahueit?" Paul demanded. 
"They have gone to the desert to deliver an observer for the Qizarate," Stilgar said. "They left while we 
were ... in the city." 
"The observer," Paul asked. "Who?" As he spoke, he knew who it would have to be. 
"Why," Stilgar said, "Otmo has dispatched his own assistant, Djedida." 
"So they have chosen to run for it," Paul said. He noted that the medics had brought a stretcher for 
Bannerjee, caught the eye of one of them. 
"He will live, M'Lord," the medic said. "It was a cutterray the traitor used and your knife caught the scum 
in time." 
"That man used his body to shield me," Paul said. "See that he lacks for nothing." 
"Yes, M'Lord." They went out with the stretcher. 
"There are traitors among the Naibs," Paul said. "Bikouros and 
Cahueit among them. And Djedida. I do not expect you will catch them, but send after them, all the same." 
Stilgar turned to obey. 
"And seek out Eldis," Paul added. 
"The keeper of your prison, Sire?" Stilgar asked, turning back. 



"Do you know of another Eldis?" Paul asked.                          
"But that one is with the party going to the desert," Stilgar said. "He spoke of a visit to . . ." 
"Get after them!" Paul barked. 
"At once!" Stilgar hurried from the room. 
Paul looked at the assembled Naibs in their rich robes. They were something far different from what they 
had been in the Sietch days. They stared back at him, not speaking. 
In each case, Paul felt the figure of the real Fremen Naib had been blotted out under an image of an 
uninhibited hedonist, a man who had sampled pleasures most men could never imagine. He saw their 
glances straying toward the doorway where Bijaz had been taken. The keening voice of the dwarf went on 
and on. Some of the Naibs looked at the windows which opened into one of the Keep's walled gardens. 
The glances were uneasy. They disliked buildings, these men. No exotic pleasures could change that. They 
felt unnatural in the confinement of space built above the ground. Give them a proper cave, one cut from 
the rock of Arrakis by Fremen hands, and they relaxed. 
Paul scanned the faces of Hobars, Rajiflri, Tasmin, Sajid, Umbu, Legg ... all of them, names so important 
in Fremen life that they were firmly attached to places on Dune: Umbu's Sietch, Rajifiri's Sink . . . 
He focused on Rajifiri, remembering the rough and bearded commander of the Second Wave in the Battle 
of Arrakeen, found that Rajifiri had become an immaculate fop dressed in a Parato silk robe of exquisite 
cut. It was open to the waist to reveal a beautifully laundered ruff and embroidered undercoat set with 
glittering green gems. A purple belt held the waist, its edges studded with golden rivets. The 
sleeves poking through the slit armholes of the robe had been gathered into rivulet-ridges of dark green-
and-black fabric. 
The green-and-black said he wore the colors of and was loyal to the House of Paul Atreides. Paul 
wondered now if that loyalty went much below the laundered silk. 
The keening of the dwarf dwindled down to silence. 
Briefly, Paul explained the situation to the Naibs, watching their faces for a reaction that would betray the 
inner man to a trained awareness. There were too many of them to watch all at once, though, and the sit-
uation was clouded over with intense emotions, an excitement akin to that of battle. He could see that 
excitement kindling old patterns in the Naibs. Some of the dross from his Empire began to peel off them. 
They began calling for attention, protesting their loyalty. 
He silenced their sharp comments with a wave of his hand, said: "You will wait here and watch through 
the doorway while we go on with our questioning of the dwarf." 
As he turned to go into the other room, there was a stir off to the right. The heavy-shouldered form of 
Stilgar came thrusting through the press of Naibs. 
"They're being pursued, M'Lord," he said, stopping in front of Paul. "I must say that were I the one 
pursued, you'd not catch me . . . and there are men as wise in the desert with this group." 
"You sent men who'll think as they think?" 
Stilgar raised his eyebrows. 
"Sorry, Stil," Paul said. "Of course you did. What'll these fugitives do?" 
"You know the answer to that, Sire, as well as I." 
Paul nodded. This deadly crew would have friends off-planet, friends in the Guild, in the Bene Gesserit, 
perhaps even in the Landsraad. His enemies off-planet, Paul knew, would do everything they could--
short of exposing themselves-to dull the Emperor's power. Getting a pack of fugitives off Arrakis would 
be a thing they could attempt. 
"Give them two days and they'll be gone off Arrakis," Paul said. 
"Hadn't we better go back to questioning this human distrans?" Stilgar asked. He nodded toward the other 
room. 
Paul turned on a heel, led the way. Bijaz sat on a low divan against the opposite wall, feet crossed beneath 
him, a look of repose on his large features. In spite of the apparent relaxation, there was a charismatic 
alertness about him that reminded Paul of an ancient idol. The guards beside Bijaz stiffened to attention. 
One of them came forward diffidently with a distrans recorder. 
Stilgar took it, examined it, nodded to Paul. 



Bijaz met Paul's gaze, grinned. "Hai, hai," he said. "Have you learned a lot?" 
He doesn't realize we've missed most of his message, Paul thought. 
"We'll go through it again," Paul said. 
"And what'll be gained by that?" Bijaz asked. "The message is the same." 
"We want to check its veracity," Stilgar said. 
"And who's that big lout asking after truth?" Bijaz asked. 
Stilgar stiffened, put a hand to his knife. 
"Doesn't he know the Emperor should seek victory and not truth?" Bijaz asked, tipping his head slyly to 
the left. 
"Watch your tongue or I'll cut it out," Stilgar growled. 
Bijaz shot a look of questioning fright at Paul. "Would you permit that, Sire?" 
"What if he caught you when I wasn't around?" Paul asked, trying to lighten the mood. 
But Stilgar only shook his head sharply, said: "It's no time for jokes, M'Lord. Let's get on with it." 
Paul took a deep breath, said: "Jamis." 
At the key word which should have sent him back into a trance, Bijaz merely blinked, continued staring at 
Paul. 
"Jamis," Paul repeated. 
No response. 
"Why do you invoke the name of our departed comrade?" Stilgar asked. 
"It's the distrans key," Paul said. And again: "Jamis." 
Bijaz remained alert and staring. 
"Your distrans has been cleared," Stilgar said, glancing warily around at the guardsmen. "The message is 
erased."                                
"How was it done, Bijaz?" Paul asked, quelling a sense of frustrated rage. 
"I felt head sickness when the assassin made his move against you," Bijaz said. 
"An erasure signal in the distrans recorder," Paul said. "That means they were more than ready to slay 
me." He nodded to himself, turned and in a low voice told Stilgar what Otheym had said about Otmo the 
Panygerist. 
"A traitor?" Stilgar asked. "That one?" His brows came down in a heavy scowl. "I'll have him on a slow 
knife." 
"No." Paul shook his head. "We've lost the message Bijaz carried and . . ." 
"Then we'll get it from Otmo-the hard way if need be," Stilgar said. 
"Do you think they're not prepared for such a thing?" Paul asked. 
"Then how . . ." 
"There are other ways to smoke out our enemies," Paul said. "What time is it, Stil?" 
"Be dawn soon." He looked back to the faces of the Naibs crowded in the doorway. "Why, M'Lord?" 
"The stone-burner," Paul said. "Summon a Convocation of the Landsraad here, with the Naibs taking part. 
. . and a Guild Observer." 
"There'll be no evidence the burner contained atomics, Sire," Stilgar said. "The whole thing's turned to 
slag by now and how can we show a background radiation which differs from . . ." 
"It was a stone-burner," Paul said. "There's no other way to fire a stone-burner. Someone's playing a very 
dangerous game. There'll be 
traces of how it was brought here. It left a track as clear as a bird in mud." 
"Bird in mud, M'Lord?" 
"Never mind, Stil," Paul said. "The thing can be tracked. A Guild heighliner brought it here; that's the 
important thing to remember. The Guild will have to answer to the Landsraad. Not a trade agreement will 
be signed or honored until. . ." 
"The spice, M'Lord," Stilgar said. 
"Of course we'll stop all the shipments of the spice," Paul said. "Let's see how they like that. When they 
run out of spice, not a ship will run anywhere in our universe. And we ship no spice until the culprits are 
handed over to us." 



"Unless they've a substitute," Stilgar said. 
"Not likely," Paul said. 
Bijaz began to giggle. 
Paul turned toward the dwarf, noting how the creature had caught the attention of everyone in the room. 
"How they'll wish on the morrow they had no teeth," Bijaz sputtered between giggles. 
"What in the name of the worm does he mean by that?" Stilgar demanded. 
"Without teeth they'll be unable to gnash," Bijaz said, his voice reasonable. 
Even Stilgar chuckled. Paul stood silent, watchful. 
"Who do you mean by they?" Paul asked. 
"Why, Sire," Bijaz said, "the ones who planted that stone-burner on you. Could it be they wanted you to 
stopple the spice?" 
New Chapter: 
CONSPIRACY'S END 
(This dramatically changes the end of the Dune Messiah story.) 
My enemies can always dissemble. They can always dissemble. There are limits even to an Emperor's law. 
- MUAD'DIB AND HIS LAW, STILGAR'S COMMENTARY 
 Edric stared through the small, field-blocked communications hole into the adjoining cell. Ennui and a 
profound fatalism gripped him. The Reverend Mother paced restlessly back and forth in the confinement 
there, virtually ignoring a visitor. 
Irulan sat on the Revered Mother's bed, hands folded in her lap. Her blond hair had been tied in a severe 
knot at the neck and there was a look of bloodless austerity about her features. 
"I have done precisely as I was instructed," Irulan said. Could she flee to the children and take them? 
The Reverend Mother cast a warning look toward the door where the guards stood, looked around the cell 
at the places where listening devices probably had been planted. She sniffed. The smell of the place 
annoyed her. 
"It doesn't mater what they hear now," Irulan snapped. "If he wishes to continue ruling, he must come to 
me on my own terms." 
"Your terms?" the Reverend Mother inquired in a slyly insinuating tone. 
"His concubine, his link to the Fremen, is no more," Irulan said. 
"You're sure?" the Reverend Mother asked, not looking at Irulan. Something was wrong, and she could 
feel it with the limited oracular ability which spice addiction gave her. 
"Security communications never lie," Irulan said. "She is dead. There are two brats, but they have no 
status." 
"They have whatever status he gives them," the Reverend Mother said. 
As though she had not heard, Irulan said: "And he will be forced to free you. He is an astute politician, my 
husband. The days of the spice monopoly are numbered, and he knows it. He must give concessions, 
compromise. There is no way out for him." 
"Your husband," the Reverend Mother sneered. 
"He will be my husband completely now," Irulan said, voice smug. "That is one of the concessions we will 
require." 
"Will we now?" the Reverend Mother asked. She caught sight of Edric's face through the communications 
hole. "What say you, Guildsman?" 
"The days of the spice monopoly are numbered," Edric said, "but I don't believe it's coming out as we 
wished." 
"What do you see in the future?" the Reverend Mother demanded. "What's going wrong?" 
Edric shook his head. What did it matter? They could not change the thing now. Far too late for that. 
"You're supposed to be a Steersman, a living oracle," the Reverend Mother pressed. "What do you see?" 
Again, Edric shrugged. An unaccustomed sense of kindness held him silent. 
"You call yourself a living oracle," Irulan sneered, "yet you cannot know all the things I have done or will 
do." 
Edric bent to peer directly at her. "You should not be here, M'Lady," he said. "The guards will pass you 



out of here. Go while there is still time." 
"What nonsense is this?" the Reverend Mother demanded, sensing the unspoken communication in Edric's 
words. 
"This is a dangerous place," Edric said. "It is about to become even more so." 
"You prattle," the Reverend Mother said, but her voice lacked conviction. She moved fretfully back and 
forth in the cell, agitated by restless stirrings of her own prescience. 
"You have seen something," Irulan accused, getting up to stare back at Edric through the hole. 
The Reverend Mother pulled her away. "He has seen nothing but his own liver spots swimming on his 
eyes! Isn't that true, Steersman?" 
"Perhaps," Edric agreed, the ennui again dominant. 
"Well, what is it?" the Reverend Mother demanded. 
"What is it?" Edric asked. He shook his head. He missed the spice-saturated air of his tank. There was a 
hunger in his cells that no stomach could feed. 
"What have you seen?" the Reverend Mother barked. 
"He is dead," Edric said. 
"Dead?" Irulan asked. "Who is dead?" 
"The Atreides," Edric said. 
The Reverend Mother had come to a full stop facing the communications hole. She nodded to herself. "So 
that's it," she muttered. "So that's how it's to be." 
"It means he has defeated us, you know," Edric said. 
"Nonsense!" Irulan snapped. She glared at him, detesting the orange face, the spice-glazed blue of the tiny 
eyes. 
"Clever, clever, clever ..." the Reverend Mother muttered. 
"It can't be true," Irulan said. There were tears in her eyes. 
"Clever, clever . . ." the Reverend Mother said. 
"It is true," Edric said. "He is dead. He went into the desert to die. He has gone to Shai-Hulud, as they say 
in this forsaken place." 
". . . clever, clever . . ." the Reverend Mother said, shaking her head. 
"Not clever!" Irulan stormed. She turned her glare on the Reverend Mother. "If he has done this, it's 
foolish!" 
"Clever," the Reverend Mother argued. 
"It was the action of a child!" Irulan stormed. "You'll be sorry when I'm gone! It's a thing a child ..."                                     
,      . 
"And we are about to be sorry," Edric said. 
"Not the action of a child," the Reverend Mother said. 
"But why would he take his own life?" Irulan demanded. 
"Why not?" Edric asked. 
"Indeed, why not?" the Reverend Mother said. "He had but one life to spend. How else could he spend it 
to such advantage? It was clever. It was the supreme act of intelligence. We are undone by it. I am filled 
with envy." 
"M'Lady," Edric said, looking at Irulan, "do you have a religion?" 
"What are you talking about?" Irulan asked. She put a hand to her cheek, stared back at him defensively. 
"Listen," Edric said. 
In the sudden silence, Irulan grew aware of a faint roaring sound, a pulse of many noises. 
"What is that?" she asked. 
"A mob," the Reverend Mother said. "They've been told, eh?" She glanced at Edric. 
"Why should you ask if I have a religion?" Irulan insisted. 
"They blame you," Edric said. "They say you killed Chani and this killed Muad'Dib." 
"What. . . how . . ." Irulan rushed to the cell door, rattled it. But the guards were gone. 
"They're investigating the noise," Edric said. "It's too late, anyway." 
"Why do you ask if I have a religion?" Irulan shouted, rushing back from the door to stare through the 



communications hole. 
The Reverend Mother pulled her back, gestured toward the bed. "Sit down." 
"Religion helps at times," Edric said. "It's . . ." 
"Never mind," the Reverend Mother said, shaking her head. 
The roaring sound had grown louder. They could make out individual voices now. 
"I demand to be let out of here," Irulan said in a small child voice. 
"Once I asked him about religion and his god-orientation," Edric said, looking at the Reverend Mother. "It 
was an interesting conversation." 
"Oh," the Reverend Mother said. "What did you ask?" 
"Among other things, I asked if god talked to him." 
"And he said?" 
"He said all men talk to god. And I asked him if he was a god." 
"I'll warrant he had a devious answer for that one," the Reverend Mother said. She had to raise her voice 
above the increasing clamor. 
"He told me that some say so." 
The Reverend Mother nodded. 
"And I asked him," Edric said, "if he said so. And he said that very few gods in history ever lived among 
men. I taxed him with not answering my question, and he said: 'So I haven't... so I haven't.'" 
"I wish I'd known that," the Reverend Mother said. 
"Why won't they come and let me out of here?" Irulan demanded from her position seated on the bed. 
The Reverend Mother moved to the bed, sat down beside Irulan, took one of her hands. "Never mind, 
child. You are about to become a saint." 
They gave up talking then because the cell had become the inside of a terrifying drum, a battering ram 
pounding on the door. 
Presently, the door shattered, slammed back, and the mob poured through. The first of them died rather 
abruptly, but a mob is numberless. Eventually, they prevailed and tore the cell's occupants limb from limb. 
[FH handwritten note: Reverend Mother can't flee, too old. Perhaps she delays the mob for Irulan to escape?]  
BLIND PAUL IN THE DESERT 
(This was the original ending to Dune Messiah.) 
Abruptly, he sat up, looked around him in the green gloom of the stilltent. The fremkit pack lay at his feet. 
He felt contained by the tent and these few possessions. The fremkit held his attention. Such a small pile 
of human artifacts. They were, though, part of his ability to stay alive in this place. It was very curious. A 
great deal of death had gone into the experience which had created these few things . . . yet, they 
represented life. He considered abandoning some of the items in the kit. Which ones, he wondered, might 
prove most definitely fatal by their absence? The baradye pistol? He drew it from the pack, tossed it aside. 
Not the pistol. Why should he want to lay down a marker pattern in the sand, a visible call for help? 
His probing fingers encountered a scrap of spice paper. He brought it into the light, read it: an official 
proclamation on the necessities to be 
packed in a fremkit and the order of their insertion. An official proclamation! He realized he must've 
signed it. Yes, there it was: "By order of Muad'Dib." But he had no memory of the signing. 
"It shall be the solemn duty of the official in charge . . ." 
The plodding, self-important language of government enraged him. He crumpled the paper, hurled it 
aside. What had happened, he wondered, to the dutiful sounds, the clean meanings that screened out 
nonsense? Somewhere, in some lost where, they had been walled off, sealed up against chance 
rediscovery. His mind quested, Mentat fashion. Patterns of knowledge glistened there. Mermaid hair 
might wave thus, he thought, beckoning . . . beckoning the enchanted hunter into emerald caverns . . . 
With an abrupt start, he drew back from the ruh-chasm that invited him to plunge into catatonic 
forgetfulness. So, he thought, the Mentat computation said he should disappear within himself. Reasons? 
Sufficient. He had seen them in the instant of escape. His life had seemed then to stretch out as long as the 
existence of the universe. Prescience already had granted him an infinity of experiences. But the real flesh 
condensed, lay finite and reduced his emerald cavern to a stilltent beginning to drum with the pulse of a 



wind. Sand chattered like pecking birds against taut surfaces. 
Paul scrambled to the door, unsealed it, slipped out and scanned the desert, saw the obvious stormsign: tan 
gusts, no birds, the abrasive-dry smell of dust. He sealed his stillsuit and tried to peer through the brown 
haze concealing the distances. A vortex of winding dust lifted out of the haze far off in the bled. It told 
Paul what lay beneath. He pictured the storm, a giant worm of sand and dust-two hundred or more 
kilometers of rolling, hissing violence. It had come a long way without hindrance, building up speed and 
power. It could cross six hundred or more kilometers of desert in an hour. If he did no more than stand 
here, that storm would come to him, cut the flesh from his bones, etch his bones down to pale splinters. He 
would become one with the desert. The desert would fulfill him. 
It occurred to Paul then to wonder about life's insistent seeking after death. Wonder moved him. He 
decided that he could not let the planet simply take him. There could be no giving up to destiny for an 
Atreides, not even in the full awareness of the inevitable. 
There'd be no time to salvage the tent, Paul saw. He reached in, grabbed the fremkit, sealed its cover, 
carried it dangling from one hand as he scrambled over the rock ridge to the lee side. Survival required a 
niche sheltered from that storm, but there wasn't a break in the rocks on this side. Another storm had 
scoured the surface here into a smooth concavity down which he slid to the encroaching sand. Fremen had 
other resources, though. He chose the siff curve of a dune, ran toward it. As he reached the crest, the wind 
gusted. It tumbled him, rolled him, hissing and pouring sand over onto the slip-face. The storm pursued 
him as he fell. In the valley of the dunes, he burrowed into the sand, fighting for inches, his right hand 
hampered by the straps of the fremkit. A sandfall from the crest slid around him, trapping his feet. Dust 
had clogged his stillsuit filters. He spat out the mouthpiece, pulled the robe over his head as another 
sandfall buried him. 
In the abrupt dimming of the stormsound, Paul hunched his shoulders, made himself a small space into 
which to drag the fremkit. He found the compaction tool in it by feel, built himself a sandwalled nest. 
Presently, he had room enough to get out the snorkel. The air already was heavy with his exhalations. He 
drilled the snorkel at a downwind slant upward through the sand, feeling for the surface, for air. When he 
found it, the filters had to be blown free, and thereafter needed clearing on almost every alternate breath. 
It was a mother of a storm up there. He had been right in its path, dead center. There might be a hundred 
feet of sand through which to burrow free when it passed. He listened to the distant keening of wind 
coming through the snorkel. Would a worm come to the sound of his burrowing? he wondered. Was that 
how it would be? 
Paul sat back against the hard-packed wall of his nest, kept the 
snorkel mouthpiece between his teeth. Blow to clear it... inhale, exhale, inhale . . . blow to clear . . . 
The fremkit glowtabs were green jewels beside him, the only radiance in the darkness which confined 
him. Was this to be his tomb? Paul wondered. He found the thought vaguely humorous. It was a mouse 
nest for Muad'Dib, for Muad'Dib the jumping mouse. 
For a while, it amused him to compose epitaphs in his head. He died on Arrakis. He was tested here and 
found to be human . . . 
And he thought of how his followers would refer to him when he had gone beyond their reach. They'd 
insist on speaking of him in terms of seas, he knew. Despite the fact that his life was soaked in dust, water 
would follow him into the tomb. 
"He foundered," they'd say. 
Never again to see rain,  he thought. Or trees. 
"I'll never again see an orchard," he said. His voice sounded thinly resonant within the sand nest. 
Fremen would see rain, he knew. And many orchards finer than the ones at Tabr Sietch. 
The thought of Fremen with muddy feet struck him as a curious thing. 
Water.                                         
Moisture. 
He remembered the dew market where the water sellers had met in Arrakeen. They were disbanded now, 
destroyed by the changes which dripped from the hands of Muad'Dib. 
Muad'Dib, the foreigner whom they hated. 



Muad'Dib was a creature from another world. Caladan-where was Caladan? What was Caladan to a man 
of Arrakis? Muad'Dib carried a subtle, alien chemistry into the cycles of Arrakis. He disturbed the secret 
life of the desert. Sun and moons of Arrakis imposed their own rhythms onto the desert. But Paul Atreides 
had come. Arrakis had welcomed him as a savior, called him Mahdi and Muad'Dib ... and given him a 
secret name, Usul, the base of the pillar. None of this changed 
the fact that he was an interloper, product of other rhythms, poison to Arrakis;. 
Interloper. 
Weren't all men interlopers, though? he asked himself. They put on a mask of words, a persona, and they 
went out into the wild space, cluttered the universe with their stellar migrations.                         
Paul shook his head in the darkness. 
He had uncluttered the universe somewhat. Men would remember Muad'Dib's Jihad for that, at least. 
He grew aware that the snorkel was silent. Had the storm passed? He blew on the mouthpiece to clear it of 
dust. No keening of wind came down the tube. 
Let a worm come, he thought. I must at least try to die up there in the open, standing on my planet.  He 
took the compaction tool from the fremkit, began boring a slanting burrow upward. Sand rasped and fell 
around him while he worked. Sand scraped against the fremkit as he pulled it up behind him with a pack 
strap caught on one foot-a trick Otheym had taught him. 
But Otheym was dead now, crisped in the searing blast of the stone-burner. One of Otheym's tricks for 
survival lived on, though. Otheym had learned it from someone before him. And someone else before that 
had passed it along. Simple thing, but vital: don't lose your fremkit, don't let it slow your digging; carry 
the thing along by one of its straps hooked over a foot. 
Paul felt that his foot was really another man's foot far back in the history of Dune. He remembered a day 
in his beginnings on this planet, before the Fremen had found him and trained him. He had lost a fremkit, 
the key to survival. He and his mother could have died there in the desert without the tools represented by 
that kit. Her prana bindu training had saved them then-the training which went into the depths of the 
mind and to the smallest muscle. 
He realized abruptly that he had been ashamed of his mother for most of his life on Arrakis. She was a 
Bene Gesserit. She carried the 
hated blood of the Harkonnens who had killed his father. But before her there had been others-countless 
humans, each with a figurative foot hooked in the strap of a figurative fremkit. 
While his mind worried over such thoughts, he had burrowed very near the surface, Paul knew. Now, the 
cautious breaking out onto the surface. A Fremen was virtually helpless in this moment. Anything might 
await him out there, deadly enemies attracted by the sounds of digging. 
Cautiously, he probed upward to the slope of dune that he knew must be near. Instinct told him of that 
nearness.                     
Daylight came with a burst of tumbling sand. 
Paul waited, listening, probing with every sense.                 
No shadows crossed the hole-only grey sky darkening away toward sunset. There was a strong smell of 
spice, though, a touch of chill air onto his cheeks where the stillsuit hood left his skin exposed. A zephyr 
hissing of sand granules came to his ears-a background carrier wave of sound. He pressed an ear to the 
burrow wall-no distant roar of a worm, no thumping, no dislodging of sand from careless feet. 
Paul fitted his noseplugs into place, sealed his suit carefully, secured his fremkit and slid out of the burrow 
onto the windward slope of a dune. The sand was firm, compacted hard by the wind here. It felt crusty 
under his feet. The zephyr picked up fluttering bits of something from the crest above him. Brown flakes 
fell all around. Paul captured one, held it to the filters, inhaled the powerful, giddy aroma of fresh 
melange. He swept his gaze over the slope. The desert all around him was thick with spice-a fortune in 
melange, a real spice pocket up from the deeps. He threw the flake of spice into the air, climbed up the 
duneface through drifts of melange. 
Near the crest, he listened with ear against the sand. No wormsound came from the desert in spite of the 
noise he'd made burrowing to the surface: 
Perhaps there are no worms in this region,  he thought. 



Just below the crest, he lay flat, crept up Fremen fashion, peered all 
around. Abruptly, he froze and lay motionless as the sand geysered beneath a dune downwind. A hooded 
man climbed out onto a dune there. Others followed-more than twenty figures. They concentrated their 
attention briefly on the sky to the northeast, then began spreading out across the dune in a familiar pattern. 
They were going to call a worm, he saw. Occasionally, they paused, glanced to the northeast. 
Paul studied the horizon in that direction, saw the glistening sunset, underlighted pinpoints which had 
caught the troop's attention: 'thopters. Paul counted four of them spread out in a search pattern and headed 
toward the Fremen atop the dunes. The 'thopters drew near and the troop waited, heads down. 
A single 'thopter detached itself, climbed over the Fremen, banked above Paul. The thunder of its wings 
stirred the melange into a miniature storm. It curved around downwind, banked for a landing. 
Abruptly, the Fremen band whirled. Maula pistols were jerked from beneath their robes; the muzzles 
tracked the landing 'thopter. Its pilot apparently saw the menace. He spread his wings, jetted away in a 
steep climb. 
All four ships took up a stacked formation, circled once more over the troop, went dipping and gliding 
back to the northeast. 
They saw me, Paul thought, but they thought I was a member of this troop. He studied the Fremen. They were 
spreading out now in a familiar wide-armed deployment. No doubt who they were or what they were 
doing: these were wild Fremen, renegades who refused to fit into the ecological pattern which was 
transforming their planet. And now they were preparing to summon a worm for a ride into the deep desert. 
One member of the troop, an obvious leader, called out to his companions from a dunetop. A man 
detached himself from the band, sped across the dunes with a thumper. His feet kicked up tiny spurts of 
dust and sand. The whole desert passed into night while he ran, leaving the first moon with its sharply 
outlined handprint pattern dominating the sky. 
The thumper began to beat out its summons: "Lump-lump-lump-lump." It was a sound as much felt 
through the sand as heard. If a worm lay within range of that sound, it would come raging and hissing 
through the sand to be trapped as a steed for the Fremen troop. 
Could he join them? Paul wondered. A Fremen could abandon sietch, friends and family only for special 
reasons of honor. Another tribe was bound to consider those reasons and, finding them sufficient, accept 
the renegade . . . provided they had no urgent need for his water. The water burden took precedent over all 
else. 
But these were renegades who opposed the actions of Muad'Dib. These were men who'd gone back to the 
blood sacrifice and the old rites. They'd be sure to recognize him. What Fremen didn't know the features 
of Muad'Dib? Here were men who'd sworn on Fremen honor to fight the changes being wrought on 
Arrakis. They might slay Muad'Dib out of hand, offer his life as sacrifice in their rite. 
He heard the faint sand-hiss then, first warning that a worm answered the thumper summons. The clapper-
driven device still sounded from the dunes out there beneath the moonlight. There was no sign of the 
troop, though. They had blended themselves into the desert to wait. 
The worm came from the southwest past the island of rocks. It was a good-sized one riding partly out of 
the sand-about a hundred meters long. Its crystal teeth flashed in the moonlight as it curved toward the 
irritant thumper. Paul could see the rippling of its driving segments. 
A shape rose from the dunes as the worm passed. Maker hooks glistened as they drove into a segment of 
the worm. In the same instant, the creature swallowed the thumper, silenced it. The troop went up on its 
hooks then, turning the worm with a casual grace as they opened its segments. Goaders darted back along 
the high back as the worm rose farther from the sand. The beat of the goads drummed out in a frenetic 
rhythm. The worm picked up speed. 
Paul turned to watch them go. 
The worm was headed back on its own track. The robes of the riders strung out along its back whipped in 
the wind of its passage. Their 
voices wafted back to Paul, growing fainter as the rock outcropping hid them: "Hyah! Hyah! Hyah! Hyah! 
.. ." 
Paul waited against the duneface until the sounds faded away, blended with the natural sounds of the 



night. He had never before experienced such a profound sense of loneliness. The troop of wild Fremen had 
taken the last of human civilization away with them. Only the desert remained. 
He came curiously to the realization that he no longer cared where he was in the universe. He felt that he 
had lived a preassigned role and come to the end of it without an audience. There should be applause, he 
thought, but there's no audience. Well-remembered stars occupied their positions in the sky, but they no 
longer represented directions to him nor could he think of them as signposts. There was merely space all 
around him laid out against an enormous background of Time. The stars peered past him and through him 
like the empty eyes of his subject peoples. They were the sealed eyes of ignorance, always seeking to 
avoid their responsive status as human senses. They were the eyes from which nothing escaped. 
For a few minutes, he listened to and identified the night sounds around him. This desert teemed with life 
which had adapted to it. He had not adapted. His body was mostly water. That water was a poison which 
could sicken a worm. If a worm devoured too many men, it died. 
Presently, he pushed himself away from the dune, climbed up to the siff crest, struck out along the track of 
the worm. He knew why he had chosen this path and inwardly he laughed at himself for it. Life had 
passed here. Men had passed here. Outside this track lay a dreadful isolation where no passage was 
recorded. 
Sometime during the night, he came to the realization that Chani had been the moon of his premonition. 
She had been the one to fall from the sky with that terrifying sense of loss. He stopped, still unable to shed 
tears. There was only the ache of tears without their release. He drew a libation of water from his 
catchpockets, poured the water on the sand as an offering to Chani and the moon. 
The gesture helped and he went on along the worm track, not bothering to mask his passage in a stride of 
broken rhythm. At a point in the depressed early hours, he realized he had left the fremkit somewhere 
behind. It didn't matter. Paul-Muad'Dib was an Atreides, a man of honor and principle. He could not 
become the monster-of-possibility the vision of the future had revealed. That could not be permitted. 
Slowing as weariness crept over him, Paul followed the worm track into the wasteland. Prana bindu 
training kept his feet moving long after another would have fallen. Even when dawn came, he marched 
onward. All through the day, he marched. And into the next night. 
On the second day there was no marcher. 
Only the wind blowing sand across barren rocks of the basement complex. Rivulets of sand ran around the 
tiniest extrusions, twisting, changing . . . ever changing. 
SHORT STORIES 
INTRODUCTION 
Considering the immensity of the Dune universe, we often have trouble keeping each novel from getting 
too big. There are so many potential story lines and intriguing ideas to explore. This wealth of material 
leaves many side stories that can be told, hors d'oeuvres to accompany the exotic main course. 
When we published "A Whisper of Caladan Seas" in 1999, it was the first new piece of Dune fiction 
published since Frank Herbert's death thirteen years earlier. It appeared in Amazing Stories magazine, and 
the issue promptly sold out; even back issues are no longer available. This story takes place concurrent 
with the Harkonnen attack on the desert city of Arrakeen in Frank Herbert's original novel Dune. Af-
terward, we wrote the three Dune prequel novels, House Atreides, House Harkonnen, and House Corrino. 
By the time we turned to the Legends of Dune trilogy that chronicles the epic Butlerian Jihad, we were 
introducing Dune fans to history ten thousand years prior to the events in Dune itself .We felt this 
warranted an appetizer to ease readers into a whole new epoch that would span 115 years. 
"Hunting Harkonnens" is our short-story introduction to the world of the Butlerian Jihad. During one of 
our book-signing tours, we found ourselves waiting for several hours in the Los Angeles train station. 
There, while sitting on an uncomfortable wooden bench larger than a church pew, we brainstormed 
"Hunting Harkonnens." In this preliminary tale, which lays the foundation of the holy war between 
humans and thinking machines, we introduced readers to the ancestors of the Atreides and the 
Harkonnens, and to the evil machines with human minds that Frank Herbert mentioned in Dune. 



Passing a laptop computer back and forth, the two of us blocked out the story in detail, scene by scene. 
Then, like team managers picking baseball players during a draft, we each chose the scenes that most in-
terested us. Shortly after returning home from the tour, we wrote our parts of the story, swapped computer 
disks, and rewrote each other's work, sending the changes to each other by mail and fax until we were 
satisfied with the end result. 
Our second Jihad short story, "Whipping Mek," is a bridging work between the first and second novels in 
the trilogy, The Butlerian Jihad  and The Machine Crusade. The story is set at a vital point in the nearly 
quarter-century gap between the events in these two novels, and fleshes out a pair of key tragic figures 
from later parts of the story. 
An even longer time passes between the second and third novels in the series, decades in which 
remarkable changes take place in the long war against thinking machines. In our final bridging short story 
"The Faces of a Martyr," the surviving main characters have altered dramatically and we portray some of 
the driving events that set up the final battle between humans and their mortal enemies in The Battle of 
Corrin. 
A: WHISPER OF CALADAN SEAS 
Arrakis, in the year 10,191 of the Imperial calendar. Arrakis  . . . forever known as Dune. .. . 
The cave in the massive Shield Wall was dark and dry, sealed by an avalanche. The air tasted like rock 
dust. The surviving Atreides soldiers huddled in blackness to conserve energy, letting their glow-globe 
powerpacks recycle. 
Outside, the Harkonnen shelling hammered against the bolt-hole where they had fled for safety. Artillery? 
What a surprise to be attacked by such seemingly obsolete technology . . . and yet, it was effective. 
Damned effective. 
In pockets of silence that lasted only seconds, the young recruit Elto Vitt lay in pain listening to the 
wheezing of wounded, terrified men. The stale, oppressive air weighed heavily on him, increasing the 
broken-glass agony in his lungs. He tasted blood in his mouth, an unwelcome moisture in the absolute 
dryness. 
His uncle, Sergeant Hoh Vitt, had not honestly told him how severe his injuries were, emphasizing Elto's 
"youthful resilience and stamina." Elto suspected he must be dying, and he wasn't alone in that predica-
ment. These last soldiers were all dying, if not from their injuries, then from hunger or thirst. 
Thirst. 
A man's voice cut the darkness, a gunner named Deegan. "I wonder if Duke Leto got away. I hope he's 
safe." 
A reassuring grunt. "Thufir Hawat would slit his own throat before he'd let the Baron touch our Duke, or 
young Paul." It was the signalman Scovich, fiddling with the flexible hip cages that held two captive 
distrans bats, creatures whose nervous systems could carry message imprints. 
"Bloody Harkonnens!" Then Deegan's sigh became a sob. "I wish we were back home on Caladan." 
Supply sergeant Vitt was no more than a disembodied voice in the darkness, comfortingly close to his 
injured young nephew. "Do you hear a whisper of Caladan seas, Elto? Do you hear the waves, the tides?" 
The boy concentrated hard. Indeed, the relentless artillery shelling sounded like the booming of breakers 
against the glistening black rocks below the cliff-perch of Castle Caladan. 
"Maybe," he said. But he didn't, not really. The similarity was only slight, and his uncle, a Master 
Jongleur... a storyteller extraordinaire . . . wasn't up to his capabilities, though here he couldn't have asked 
for a more attentive audience. Instead the sergeant seemed stunned by events, and uncharacteristically 
quiet, not his usual gregarious self. 
Elto remembered running barefoot along the beaches on Caladan, the Atreides home planet far, far from 
this barren repository of dunes, sandworms, and precious spice. As a child, he had tiptoed in the foamy 
residue of waves, avoiding the tiny pincers of crabfish so numerous that he could net enough for a fine 
meal in only a few minutes. 
Those memories were much more vivid than what had just happened. . . . 
THE ALARMS HAD rung in the middle of the night, ironically during the first deep sleep Elto Vitt had 
managed in the Atreides barracks at Arrakeen. Only a month earlier, he and other recruits had been as-



signed to this desolate planet, saying their farewells to lush Caladan. Duke Leto Atreides had received the 
governorship of Arrakis, the only known source of the spice melange, as a boon from the Padishah Em-
peror Shaddam IV. 
To many of the loyal Atreides soldiers, it had seemed a great financial coup-they had known nothing of 
politics ... or of danger. Apparently Duke Leto had not been aware of the peril here either, because he'd 
brought along his concubine Lady Jessica and their fifteen-year-old son, Paul. 
When the warning bells shrieked, Elto snapped awake and rolled from his bunk bed. His uncle, Hoh Vitt, 
already in full sergeant's regalia, shouted for everyone to hurry, hurry! The Atreides house guard grabbed 
their uniforms, kits, and weapons. Elto recalled allowing himself a groan, annoyed at another apparent 
drill... and yet hoping it was only that. 
The burly, disfigured weapons master Gurney Halleck burst into the barracks, his voice booming 
commands. He was flushed with anger, and the beet-colored inkvine scar stood out like a lightning bolt on 
his face. "House shields are down! We're vulnerable!" Security teams had supposedly rooted out all the 
booby traps, spy eyes, and assassination devices left behind by the hated Harkonnen predecessors. Now 
the lumpish Halleck became a frenzy of barked orders. 
Explosions sounded outside, shaking the barracks and rattling armor-plaz windows. Enemy assault 
'thopters swooped in over the Shield Wall, probably coming from a Harkonnen base in the city of Carthag. 
"Prepare your weapons!" Halleck bellowed. The buzzing of lasguns played across the stone walls of 
Arrakeen, incinerating buildings. Orange eruptions shattered plaz windows, decapitated observation 
towers. "We must defend House Atreides." 
"For the Duke!" Uncle Hoh cried. 
Elto yanked on the sleeve of his black uniform, tugging the trim into place, adjusting the red Atreides 
hawk crest and red cap of the corps. Everyone else had already jammed feet into boots, slapped charge 
packs into lasgun rifles. Elto scrambled to catch up, his mind awhirl. His uncle had pulled strings to get 
him assigned here as part of the elite corps. The other men were lean and whipcord strong, the finest hand-
picked Atreides troops. He didn't belong with them. 
Young Elto had been excited to leave Caladan for Arrakis, so far away. He had never ridden on a Guild 
Heighliner before, had never been close to a mutated Navigator who could fold space with his mind. 
Before leaving his ocean home, Elto had spent only a few months watching the men train, eating with 
them, sleeping in the barracks, listening to their colorful, bawdy tales of great battles past and duties per-
formed in the service of the Atreides dukes. 
Elto had never felt in danger on Caladan, but after only a short time on Arrakis, all the men had grown 
grim and uneasy. There had been unsettling rumors and suspicious events. Earlier that night, as the troops 
had bunked down, they'd been agitated but unwilling to speak of it, either because of their commander's 
sharp orders or because the soldiers didn't know enough details. Or maybe they were just giving Elto, the 
untried and unproven new comrade, a cold shoulder. . . . 
Because of the circumstances of his recruitment, a few men of the elite corps hadn't taken to Elto. Instead, 
they'd openly grumbled about his amateur skills, wondering why Duke Leto had permitted such a novice 
to join them. A signalman and communications specialist named Forrie Scovich, pretending to be friendly, 
had filled the boy with false information as an ill-conceived joke. Uncle Hoh had put a stop to that, for 
with his Jongleur's talent for the quick, whispered story- 
always told without witnesses because of the ancient prohibition-he could have given any of the men 
terrible nightmares for weeks . .. and they all knew it. 
The men in the Atreides elite corps feared and respected their supply sergeant, but even the most 
accommodating of them gave his nephew no preferential treatment. Anyone could see that Elto Vitt was 
not one of them, not one of their rough-and-tumble, hard-fighting breed.. . . 
By the time the Atreides house guard rushed out of the barracks, they were naked to aerial attack because 
of the lack of house shields. The men knew the vulnerability couldn't possibly be from a mere equipment 
failure, not after what they'd been hearing, what they'd been feeling. How could Duke Leto Atreides, with 
all of his proven abilities, have permitted this to happen? 
Enraged, Gurney Halleck grumbled loudly, "Aye, we have a traitor in our midst." 



Illuminated in floodlights, Harkonnen troops in blue uniforms swarmed over the compound. More enemy 
transports disgorged assault teams. 
Elto held his lasgun rifle, trying to remember the drills and training sessions. Someday, if he survived, his 
uncle would compose a vivid story about this battle, conjuring up images of smoke, sounds, and fires, as 
well as Atreides valor and loyalty to the Duke. 
Atreides soldiers raced through the streets, dodging explosions, fighting hard to defend. Lasguns sliced 
vivid blue arcs across the night. The elite corps joined the fray, howling-but Elto could already see they 
were vastly outnumbered by this massive surprise assault. Without shields, Arrakeen had already been 
struck a mortal blow. 
ELTO BLINKED HIS eyes in the cave, saw light. A flicker of hope dissipated as he realized it was only a 
recharged glowglobe floating in the air over his head. Not daylight. 
Still trapped in their tomb of rock, the Atreides soldiers listened to the continued thuds of artillery. Dust 
and debris trickled from the shuddering ceiling. Elto tried to keep his spirits high, but knew House 
Atreides must have fallen by now. 
His uncle sat nearby, staring into space. A long red scratch jagged across one cheek. 
During brief inspection drills while settling in, Elto had met Gurney Halleck and the other important men 
in Duke Leto's security staff, especially the renowned Swordmaster Duncan Idaho and the old Mentat 
assassin Thufir Hawat. The black-haired Duke inspired such loyalty in his men, exuded such supreme 
confidence, that Elto had never imagined this mighty man could fall. 
One of the security experts had been trapped here with the rest of the detachment. Now Scovich 
confronted him, his voice gruff and challenging. "How did the house shields get shut off? It must have 
been a traitor, someone you overlooked." The distrans bats seemed agitated in their cages at Scovich's 
waist. 
"We spared no effort checking the palace," the man said, more tired than defensive. "There were dozens of 
traps, mechanical and human. When the hunter-seeker almost killed Master Paul, Thufir Hawat offered his 
resignation, but the Duke refused to accept it." 
"Well, you didn't find all the traps," Scovich groused, probing for an excuse to fight. "You were supposed 
to keep the Harkonnens out." 
Sergeant Hoh Vitt stepped between the two men before they could come to blows. "We can't afford to be 
at each other's throats. We need to work together to get out of this." 
But Elto saw on the faces of the men that they all knew otherwise: they would never escape this death 
trap. 
The unit's muscular battlefield engineer, Avram Fultz, paced about in the faint light, using a jury-rigged 
instrument to measure the thickness of rock and dirt around them. "Three meters of solid stone." He turned 
toward the fallen boulders that had covered the cave entrance. "Down to two and a half here, but it's 
dangerously unstable." 
"If we went out the front, we'd run headlong into Harkonnen shelling anyway," the gunner Deegan said. 
His voice trembled with tension, like a too-tight baliset string about to break. 
Uncle Hoh activated a second glowglobe, which floated in the air behind him as he went to a bend in the 
tunnel. "If I remember the arrangement of the tunnels, on the other side of this wall there's a supply cache. 
Food, medical supplies . . . water." 
Fultz ran his scanner over the thick stone. Elto, unable to move on his makeshift bed and fuzzed with 
painkillers, stared at the process, realizing how much it reminded him of Caladan fishermen using depth 
sounders in the reef fishing grounds. 
"You picked a good, secure spot for those supplies, Sergeant," Fultz said. "Four meters of solid rock. The 
cave-ins have cut us off." 
Deegan, his voice edged with hysteria, groaned. "That food and water might as well be in the Imperial 
Palace on Kaitain. This place . . . Arrakis . . . isn't right for us Atreides!" 
The gunner was right, Elto thought. Atreides soldiers were tough, but like fish out of water in this hostile 
environment. 
"I was never comfortable here," Deegan wailed. 



"So who asked you to be comfortable?" Fultz snapped, setting aside his apparatus. "You're a soldier, not a 
pampered prince." 
Deegan's raw emotions turned his words into a rant. "I wish the Duke had never accepted Shaddam's offer 
to come here. He must have known it was a trap! We can never live in a place like this!" He stood up, 
making exaggerated, scarecrowlike gestures. 
"We need water, the ocean," Elto said, overcoming pain to lift his voice. "Does anybody else remember 
rain?"  
"I do," Deegan said, his voice a pitiful whine. 
Elto thought of his first view of the sweeping wastelands of open desert beyond the Shield Wall. His 
initial impression had been nostalgic, already homesick. The undulating panorama of sand dunes had been 
so similar to the even patterns of waves on the sea . . . but without any drop of water. 
Issuing a strange cry, Deegan rushed to the nearest wall and clawed at the stone, kicking and trying to dig 
his way out with bare hands. He tore his nails and pounded with his fists, leaving bloody patterns on the 
unforgiving rock, until two of the other soldiers dragged him away and wrestled him to the ground. One 
man, a hand-to-hand combat specialist who had trained at the famous Swordmaster School on Ginaz, 
ripped open one of their remaining medpaks and dosed Deegan with a strong sedative. 
The pounding artillery continued. Won't they ever stop7. He felt an odd, pain-wracked sensation that he 
might be sealed in this hellhole for eternity, trapped in a blip of time from which there was no escape. 
Then he heard his uncle's voice. . . . 
Kneeling beside the claustrophobic gunner, Uncle Hoh leaned close, whispering, "Listen. Let me tell you 
a story." It was a private tale intended only for Deegan's ears, though the intensity in the Jongleur's voice 
seemed to shimmer in the thick air. Elto caught a few words about a sleeping princess, a hidden and 
magical city, a lost hero from the Butlerian Jihad who would slumber in oblivion until he rose again to 
save the Imperium. By the time Hoh Vitt completed his tale, Deegan had fallen into a stupor. 
Elto suspected what his uncle had done, that he had disregarded the ancient prohibition against using the 
forbidden powers of planet Jongleur, ancestral home of the Vitt family. In the low light their gazes met, 
and Uncle Hoh's eyes were bright and fearful. As he'd been conditioned to do since childhood, Elto tried 
not to think about it, for he too was a Vitt. 
Instead, he visualized the events that had occurred only hours before. . . . 
ON THE STREETS of Arrakeen, some of the Harkonnen soldiers had been fighting in an odd manner. The 
Atreides elite corps had shouldered lasguns to lay down suppressing fire. The buzzing weapons 
had filled the air with crackling power, contrasted with much more primal noises of screams and the 
percussive explosions of old-fashioned artillery fire. 
The battle-scarred weapons master ran at the vanguard, bellowing in a strong voice that was rich and 
accustomed to command. "Watch yourselves-and don't underestimate them." Halleck lowered his voice, 
growling; Elto wouldn't have heard the words if he hadn't been running close to the commander. "They're 
in formations like Sardaukar." 
Elto shuddered at the thought of the Emperor's crack terror troops, said to be invincible. Have the Harkonnens 
learned Sardaukar methods?  It was confusing. 
Sergeant Hoh Vitt grabbed his nephew's shoulder and turned him to join another running detachment. 
Everyone seemed more astonished by the unexpected and primitive mortar bombardment than by the 
strafing attacks of the assault 'thopters. 
"Why would they use artillery, Uncle?" Elto shouted. He still hadn't fired a single shot from his lasgun. 
"Those weapons haven't been used effectively for centuries." Though the young recruit might not be well 
practiced in battle maneuvers, he had at least read his military history. 
"Harkonnen devils," Hoh Vitt said. "Always scheming, always coming up with some trick. Damn them!" 
One entire wing of the Arrakeen palace glowed orange, consumed by inner flames. Elto hoped the 
Atreides family had gotten away . . . Duke Leto, Lady Jessica, young Paul. He could still see their faces, 
their proud but not unkind manners; he could still hear their voices. 
As the street battle continued, blue-uniformed Harkonnen invaders ran across an intersection, and 
Halleck's men roared in challenge. Impulsively, Elto fired his own weapon at the massed enemies, and the 



air shimmered with a crisscross web of blue-white lines. He fumbled, firing the lasgun again. 
Scovich snapped at him. "Point that damn thing away from me! You're supposed to hit Harkonnens!" 
Without a word, Uncle Hoh grasped Elto's rifle, placed the young man's hands in proper positions, 
reset the calibration, then slapped him on the back. Elto fired again, and hit a blue-uniformed invader. 
Agonized cries of injured men throbbed around him, mingled with frantic calls of medics and squad 
leaders. Above it all, the weapons master yelled orders and curses through twisted lips. Gurney Halleck 
already looked defeated, as if he had personally betrayed his Duke. He had escaped from a Harkonnen 
slave pit years before, had lived with smugglers on Salusa Secundus, and had sworn revenge on his 
enemies. Now, though, the troubadour warrior could not salvage the situation. 
Under attack, Halleck waved his hands to command the entire detachment. "Sergeant Vitt, take men into 
the Shield Wall tunnels and guard our supply storehouses. Secure defensive positions and lay down a 
suppressing fire to take out those artillery weapons." 
Never doubting that his orders would be obeyed, Halleck turned to the remainder of his elite corps, 
reassessing the strategic situation. Elto saw that the weapons master had picked his best fighters to remain 
with him. In his heart, Elto had known at that moment, as he did now thinking back on it, that if this were 
ever to be told as one of his uncle's vivid stories, the tale would be cast as a tragedy. 
In the heat of battle, Sergeant Hoh Vitt had shouted for them to trot double-time up the cliffside road. His 
detachment had taken their weapons and left the walls of Arrakeen. Glowlamps and portable illuminators 
showed firefly chains of other civilian evacuees trying to find safety in the mountainous barrier. 
Panting, refusing to slacken their pace, they had gained altitude, and Elto looked down on the burning 
garrison city. The Harkonnens wanted the desert planet back, and they wanted to eradicate House 
Atreides. The blood-feud between the two noble families dated all the way back to the Butlerian Jihad. 
Sergeant Vitt reached a camouflaged opening and entered his code to allow them access. Down below, the 
gunfire continued. An assault 'thopter swooped along the side of the mountain, sketching black 
streaks of slagged rock; Scovich, Fultz, and Deegan opened fire, but the 'thopter retreated-after marking 
their position. 
As the rest of the detachment raced inside the caves, Elto took a moment at the threshold to note the 
nearest artillery weapons. He saw five of the huge, old-style guns pounding indiscriminately at 
Arrakeen-the Harkonnens didn't care how much damage they caused. Then two of the mighty barrels 
rotated to face the Shield Wall. Flames belched out, followed by far-off thunder, and explosive shells 
rained down upon the cave openings. 
"Get inside!" Sergeant Vitt shouted. The others moved to obey, but Elto remained fixated. In a single 
stroke, a long line of fleeing civilians vanished from the cliffside paths, as if a cosmic artist with a giant 
paintbrush had decided to erase his work. The artillery guns continued to fire and fire, and soon centered 
on the position of the soldiers. 
The range of Elto's full-power lasgun was at least as long as the conventional shells. He aimed and fired, 
pulsing out an unbroken stream but expecting little in the way of results. However, the dissipating heat 
struck the old-fashioned explosives in the loaded artillery shells, and the ragged detonation ripped out the 
breech of the mammoth cannon. 
He turned around, grinning, trying to shout his triumph to his uncle-then a shell from the second massive 
gun struck squarely above the entrance to the cave. The explosion knocked Elto farther into the tunnel as 
tons of rock showered down, striking him. The avalanche sent shock waves through an entire section of 
the Shield Wall. The contingent was sealed inside. ... 
AFTER DAYS IN the tomblike cave, one of the glowglobes gave out and could not be recharged; the 
remaining two managed only a flickering light in the main room. Elto lay wounded, tended by the junior 
medic and his dwindling supplies of medicinals. Elto's pain had dulled 
from that of broken glass to a cold, cold blackness that seemed easier to endure . . . but how he longed for 
a sip of water! 
Uncle Hoh shared his concern, but was unable to do anything else. 
Squatting on the stone floor off to his left, two sullen soldiers had used their fingertips to trace a grid in 
the dust; with light and dark stones they played a makeshift game of Go, a carryover from ancient Terra. 



Everyone waited and waited-not for rescue, but for the serenity of death, for escape. 
The shelling outside had finally stopped. Elto knew with a sick certainty that the Atreides had lost. Gurney 
Halleck and his elite corps would be dead by now, the Duke and his family either killed or captured; none 
of the loyal Atreides soldiers dared to hope that Leto or Paul or Jessica had escaped. 
The signalman Scovich paced the perimeter, peering into darkened cracks and crumbling walls. Finally, 
after carefully imprinting a distress message into the voice patterns of his captive distrans bats, he released 
them. The small creatures circled the dusty enclosure, seeking a way out. Their high-pitched cries echoed 
from the porous stone as they searched for any tiny niche. After frantic flapping and swooping, at last the 
pair disappeared through a fissure in the ceiling. 
"We'll see if this works," Scovich said. His voice held little optimism. 
In a weak but valiant voice, Elto called his uncle nearer. Using most of his remaining strength, he propped 
himself on an elbow. "Tell me a story, about the good times we had on our fishing trips." 
Hoh Vitt's eyes brightened, but for only a second before fear set in. He spoke slowly. "On Caladan ... Yes, 
the old days." 
"Not so long ago, Uncle." 
"Oh, but it seems like it." 
"You're right," Elto said. He and Hoh Vitt had taken a coracle along the shore, past the lush pundi rice 
paddies and out into open water, beyond the seaweed colonies. They had spent days anchored in the 
foamy breakwaters of dark coral reefs, where they dove for shells, using small knives to pry free the 
flammable nodules called coral gems. In those magical waters they caught fan-fish-one of the great 
delicacies of the Imperium-and ate them raw. 
"Caladan . . ." the gunner Deegan said groggily, as he emerged from his stupor. "Remember how vast the 
ocean was? It seemed to cover the whole world." 
Hoh Vitt had always been so good at telling stories, supernaturally good. He could make the most 
outrageous things real for his listeners. Friends or family made a game of throwing an idea at Hoh, and he 
would make up a story using it. Blood mixed with melange ... a great Heighliner race across uncharted 
foldspace . . . the wrist-wrestling championship of the universe between two dwarf sisters who were the 
finalists ... a talking slig. 
"No, no more stories, Elto," the sergeant said in a fearful voice. "Rest now." 
"You're a Master Jongleur, aren't you? You always said so." 
"I don't talk about that much." Hoh Vitt turned away. 
His ancestral family had once been proud members of an ancient school of storytelling on the planet 
Jongleur. Men and women from that world used to be the primary troubadours of the Imperium; they 
traveled between royal houses, telling stories and singing songs to entertain the great families. But House 
Jongleur fell into disgrace when a number of the itinerant storytellers were proven to be double agents in 
inter-House feuds, and no one trusted them any longer. When the nobles dropped their services, House 
Jongleur forfeited its status in the Landsraad, losing its fortunes. Guild Heighliners stopped going to their 
planet; the buildings and infrastructure, once highly advanced, fell into disrepair. Largely due to the 
Jongleur's demise, many entertainment innovations were developed, including holo projections, film-
books, and shigawire recorders. 
"Now is the time, Uncle. Take me back to Caladan. I don't want to be here." 
"I can't do that, boy," he responded in a sad voice. "We're all stuck here." 
"Make me think I'm there, like only you can do. I don't want to die in this hellish place." 
With a piercing squeak, the two distrans bats returned. Confused and frustrated, they fluttered around the 
chamber while Scovioh tried to recapture them. Even they had been unable to escape. ... 
Though the trapped men had held out little hope, the failure of the bats still made them groan in dismay. 
Uncle Hoh looked at them, then down to Elto as his expression hardened into grim determination. 
"Quiet! All of you." He knelt beside his injured nephew. Hoh's eyes became glazed with tears... or 
something more. "The boy needs to hear what I have to say." 
ELTO LAY BACK, letting his eyes fall half-closed as he readied himself for the words that would paint 
memory pictures on the insides of his eyelids. Sergeant Vitt sat rigid, taking deep breaths to compose 



himself, to center his uncanny skill and stoke the fires of imagination. To tell the type of story these men 
needed, a Master Jongleur must calm himself; he moved his hands and fingers in the ancient way, going 
through the motions he'd been taught by generations of storytellers, ritualistic preparations to make the 
story good and pure. 
Fultz and Scovich shifted uneasily, and then moved closer, anxious to listen as well. Hoh Vitt looked at 
them with glazed eyes, barely seeing them, but his voice carried a gruff warning. "There is danger." 
"Danger?" Fultz laughed and raised his grimy hands to the dim ceiling and surrounding rock walls. "Tell 
us something we don't know." 
"Very well." Hoh was deeply saddened, wishing he hadn't pulled strings to get Elto assigned to the 
prestigious corps. The young man still thought of himself as an outsider, but ironically-by staying in the 
line of fire and destroying one of the artillery weapons-he had shown more courage than any of the 
proven soldiers. 
Now Hoh Vitt felt a tremendous sense of impending loss. This wonderful young man, filled not only with 
his own hopes and dreams but also with those of his parents and uncle, was going to die without ever 
achieving his bright promise. He looked around, at the faces of the other soldiers, and seeing how they 
looked at him with such anticipation and admiration, he felt a moment of pride. 
In the hinterlands of Jongleur, a hilly rural region where Hoh Vitt had grown up, dwelled a special type of 
storyteller. Even the natives suspected these "Master Jongleurs" of sorcery and dangerous ways. They 
could spin stories like deadly Spiderwebs, and in order to protect their secrets, they allowed themselves to 
be shunned, hiding behind a cloak of mystique. 
"Hurry, Uncle," Elto said, his voice quiet and thready. 
With intensity in his words, Sergeant Vitt leaned closer. "You remember how my stories always start, 
don't you?" He touched the young man's pulse. 
"You warn us not to believe too deeply, to always remember that it's only a story ... or it could be 
dangerous. We could lose our minds." 
"I'm saying that again to you, boy." He scanned the close-pressed faces around him. "And to everyone 
listening." 
Scovich made a scoffing noise, but the others remained silent and intent. Perhaps they thought his warning 
was only part of the storytelling process, part of an illusion a Master Jongleur needed to create. 
After a moment's hush, Hoh employed the enhanced memorization techniques of the Jongleurs, a method 
of transferring large amounts of information and retaining it for future generations. In this manner he 
brought to mind the planet Caladan, summoning it in every intricate detail. 
"I used to have a wingboat," he said with a gentle smile, and then he began to describe sailing on the seas 
of Caladan. He used his voice like a paintbrush, selecting words carefully, like pigments precisely mixed 
by an artist. He spoke to Elto, but his story spread hypnotically, wrapping around the circle of listeners 
like the wispy smoke of a fire. 
"You and your father went with me on week-long fishing trips. Oh, those days! Up at sunrise and casting 
nets until sunset, with the golden tone of the sun framing each day. I must say we enjoyed our time alone 
on the water even more than the fish we caught. The companionship, the adventures and hilarious 
mishaps." 
And hidden in his words were subliminal signals: Smell the salt water, the iodine of drying seaweed . . . Hear 
the whisper of waves, the splash of a distant fish too large to bring aboard whole.  
"At night, when we sat at anchor alone in the middle of the seaweed islands, we'd stay up late, the three of 
us, playing a fast game of tri-chess on a board made of flatpearls and abalone shells. The pieces 
themselves were carved from the translucent ivory tusks of South Caladan walruses. Do you remember?" 
"Yes, Uncle. I remember." 
All the men murmured their agreement; the Jongleur's haunting words were as real to them as to the young 
man who had actually experienced the memories. 
Listen to the hypnotic, throbbing songs of unseen murmons hiding in a fog bank that ripples across the calm waters. 
The shroud of pain grew fuzzy around Elto, and he could feel himself going to that other place and time, 
being carried away from this hellish place. The parched, dusty air at first smelled dank, then cool and 



moist. As he closed his eyes, he could sense the loving touch of Caladan breezes on his cheek. He smelled 
the mists of his native world, spring rain on his face, sea waves lapping at his feet as he stood on the rocky 
beach below the Atreides castle. 
"When you were young, you would splash in the water, laughing and swimming naked with your friends. 
Do you remember?" 
"I. . ." And Elto felt his voice merge with the others, becoming one with them. "We remember," the men 
mumbled reverently. All around them the air had grown close and stifling, most of the oxygen used up. 
Another one of the glowglobes died. But the men didn't know this. They were anesthetized from their 
pain. 
See the wingboat cruising like a razorfin under dazzling sunlight, then through a warm squall under cloudy skies.  
"I used to body surf in the waves," Elto said with a faint smile of wonder. 
Fultz coughed, then added his own reminiscences. "I spent a summer on a small farm overlooking the sea, 
where we harvested paradan melons. Have you ever had one fresh out of the water? Sweetest fruit in the 
universe." 
Even Deegan, still somewhat dazed, leaned forward. "I saw an elecran once, late at night and far away-
oh, they're rare, but they do exist. It's more than just a sailor's story. Looked like an electrical storm on the 
water, but alive. Luckily, the monster never came close." Though the gunner had been hysterical not long 
before, his words held such an awed solemnity that no one thought to disbelieve him. 
Swim through the water; feel its caress on your body. Imagine being totally wet, immersed in the sea. The waves 
surround you, holding and protecting you like a mother's arms.  ... 
The two distrans bats, still loose from the signalman's cages, had clung to the ceiling for hours, but now 
they swayed and dropped to the floor. All the air was disappearing in their tomb. 
Elto remembered the old days in Cala City, the stories his uncle used to tell to an entranced audience of 
his family. At several points in each of those tales, Uncle Hoh would force himself to break away. He had 
always taken great care to remind his listeners that it was only a story. 
This time, however, Hoh Vitt took no breaks. 
Realizing this, Elto felt a moment of fear, like a dreamer unable to awaken from a nightmare. But then he 
allowed himself to succumb. Though he could barely breathe, he forced himself to say, "I'm going into the 
water . . . I'm diving . . . I'm going deeper . . ." 
Then all the trapped soldiers could hear the waves, smell the water, and remember the whisper of Caladan 
seas. . . . The whisper became a roar. 
IN THE VELVET shadows of a crisp night on Dune, Fremen scavengers dropped over the ridge of the 
Shield Wall into the rubble. Stillsuits softened their silhouettes, allowing them to vanish like beetles into 
crevices. 
Below, most of the fires in Arrakeen had been put out, but the damage remained untended. The new 
Harkonnen rulers had returned to their traditional seat of government in Carthag; they would leave the 
scarred Atreides city as a blackened wound for a few months... as a reminder to the people. 
The feud between House Atreides and House Harkonnen meant nothing to the Fremen-the noble 
families were all unwelcome interlopers on their sacred desert planet, which the Fremen had claimed as 
their own thousands of years earlier, after the Wandering. For millennia these people had carried the 
wisdom of their ancestors, including an ancient Terran saying about each cloud having a silver lining. The 
Fremen would use the bloodshed of these royal houses to their own advantage: the deathstills back at the 
sietch would drink deeply from the casualties of war. 
Harkonnen patrols swept the area, but the soldiers cared little for the bands of furtive Fremen, pursuing 
and killing them only out of sport rather than in a focused program of genocide. The Harkonnens paid no 
heed to the Atreides trapped in the Shield Wall either, thinking none of them could have survived; so they 
left the bodies trapped in the rubble. 
From the Fremen perspective, the Harkonnens did not value their resources. 
Working together, using bare callused hands and metal digging tools, the scavengers began their 
excavation, opening a narrow tunnel between the rocks. Only a few dim glowglobes hovered close to the 
diggers, providing faint light. 



Through soundings and careful observations on the night of the attack, the Fremen knew where the 
victims would be. They had uncovered a dozen already, as well as a precious cache of supplies, but now 
they were after something much more valuable, the tomb of an entire detachment of Atreides soldiers. The 
desert men toiled for hours, sweating into the absorbent layers of their stillsuits, taking only a few sipped 
drops of recovered moisture. Many water rings would be earned for the moisture recovered from these 
corpses, making these Fremen scavengers wealthy. 
When they broke into the cave enclosure, though, they stepped into a clammy stone coffin filled with the 
redolence of death. Some of the Fremen cried out or muttered superstitious prayers to Shai-Hulud, but 
others probed forward, increasing the light from the glowglobes now that they were out of sight of the 
nighttime patrols. 
The Atreides soldiers all lay dead together, as if struck down in a strange suicide ceremony. One man sat 
in the center of their group, and when the Fremen leader moved him, his body fell to one side and a gush 
of water spewed out of his mouth. The Fremen tasted it. Salt water. 
The scavengers backed away, even more frightened now. 
Carefully, two young men inspected the bodies, finding that the uniforms of the Atreides were warm and 
wet, stinking of mildew and damp rot. Their dead eyes were open wide and staring, but with contentment 
instead of the expected horror, as if they had shared a religious experience. All of the dead Atreides 
soldiers had clammy skin . . . and something even more peculiar, revealed when the Fremen cut them 
open. 
The lungs of these dead men were entirely filled with water. 
The Fremen fled, leaving their spoils behind, and resealed the cave. Thereafter, it became a forbidden 
place of legend, drawing wonder from anyone hearing the story as it was passed on by Fremen from gen-
eration to generation. 
Somehow, sealed inside a lightless cave in the driest desert, all of the Atreides soldiers had drowned. . . . 
HUNTING HARKONNENS A Tale of the Butlerian Jihad 
The Harkonnen space yacht left the family-held industries on Hagal and crossed the interstellar gulf 
toward Salusa Secundus. The streamlined vessel flew silently, in contrast to the fusillade of angry shouts 
inside the cockpit. 
Stern, hard-line Ulf Harkonnen piloted the yacht, concentrating on the hazards of space and the constant 
threat of thinking machines, though he kept lecturing his twenty-one-year-old son, Piers. Ulf's wife, 
Katarina, too gentle a soul to be worthy of the Harkonnen name, asserted that the quarrel had gone on long 
enough. "Further criticism and shouting will serve no purpose, Ulf." 
Vehemently, the elder Harkonnen disagreed. 
Piers sat fuming, unrepentant; he was not cut out for the cutthroat practices his noble family expected, no 
matter how much his father 
tried to bully him into them. He knew Ulf would browbeat and humiliate him all the way home. The gruff 
older man refused to consider that his son's ideas for more humane methods might actually be more 
efficient than the inflexible, domineering ways. 
Clutching the ship controls with a death grip, Ulf growled at his son, "Thinking machines are efficient. 
Humans, especially riffraff like our slaves on Hagal, are meant to be used. I doubt you'll ever get that 
through your skull." He shook his large, squarish head. "Sometimes, Piers, I think I should clean up the 
gene pool by eliminating you." 
"Then why don't you?" Piers snapped, defiant. His father believed in forceful decisions, every question 
with a black-or-white answer, and that belittling his son would drive him to do better. 
"I can't, because your brother, Xavier, is too young to be the Harkonnen heir, so you're the only choice I 
have ... for the time being. I keep hoping you'll understand your responsibility to our family. You're a 
noble, meant to command, not to show the workers how soft you can be." 
Katarina pleaded, "Ulf, you may not agree with the changes Piers made on Hagal, but at least he thought it 
through and was trying a new process. Given time, it might have led to improved productivity." 
"And meanwhile the Harkonnen family goes bankrupt?" Ulf held a thick finger toward his son as if it were 
a weapon. "Piers, those people took terrible advantage of you, and you're lucky I arrived in time to stop 



the damage. When I provide you with detailed instructions on how our family holdings are to be run, I do 
not expect you to come up with a 'better' idea." 
"Is your mind so fossilized that you can't accept new ideas?" Piers asked. 
"Your instincts are faulty, and you have a very naive view of human nature." Ulf shook his head, growling 
in disappointment. "He takes after you, Katarina-that's his main problem." Like his mother, Piers had a 
narrow face, full lips, and a delicate expression . . . quite different 
from Ulf's shaggy gray hair framing a blunt-featured face. "You would have been a better poet than a 
Harkonnen." 
That was meant to be a grave insult, but Piers secretly agreed. The young man had always enjoyed reading 
histories of the Old Empire, days of decadence and ennui before the thinking machines had conquered 
many civilized solar systems. Piers would have fit into those times well as a writer, a storyteller. 
"I gave you an opportunity, son, hoping that I could depend on you. But I have my answer." The elder 
Harkonnen stood, clenching his large, callused fists. "This whole trip has been a waste." 
Katarina caressed her husband's broad back, trying to calm him. "Ulf, we're passing near the Caladan 
system. You talked about stopping there to investigate the possibility of new holdings ... maybe fishing 
operations?" 
Ulf hunched his shoulders. "All right, we'll divert to Caladan and take a look." He snapped his head up. 
"But in the meantime, I want this disgrace of a son sealed in the lifepod chamber. It's the closest thing to a 
brig onboard. He needs to learn his lesson, take his responsibilities seriously, or he will never be a true 
Harkonnen." 
AS HE SULKED inside his improvised cell, with its cream-colored walls and silver instrument panels, 
Piers stared out the small porthole. He hated arguments with his stubborn father. The rigid old ways of the 
Harkonnen family were not always best. Instead of imposing tough conditions and harsh punishments, 
why not try treating workers with respect? 
Workers. He remembered how his father had reacted to the word. "Next you'll want to call them 
employees. They are slaves!" Ulf had thundered as they stood in the overseer's office back on Hagal. 
"They have no rights." 
"But they deserve rights," Piers responded. "They're human beings, not machines." 
Ulf had barely contained his violence. "Perhaps I should beat you the way my father beat me, pounding 
contrition and responsibility into you. This isn't a game. You're leaving now, boy. Get on the ship." 
Like a scolded child, Piers had done as he was commanded. . . . 
He wished he could stand toe to toe with his father, just once. Every time he tried, though, Ulf made him 
feel that he had let the family down, as if he were a shirker who would waste their hard-won fortunes. 
His father had trusted him to manage the family holdings on Hagal, grooming him as the next head of the 
Harkonnen businesses. This assignment had been an important step for Piers, with complete authority over 
the sheet diamond operations. A chance, a test. The implicit understanding was that he would operate the 
mines as they had always been run. 
Harkonnens held the mining rights to all sheet diamonds on sparsely populated Hagal. The largest mine 
filled an entire canyon. Piers recalled how sunlight played off the glassy cliffs, dancing on the prismatic 
surfaces. He had never seen anything so beautiful. 
The cliff faces were diamond sheets with blue-green quartz marking the perimeters like irregular picture 
frames. Human-operated mining machines crawled along the cliffs like fat, silver insects: no artificial in-
telligence, and therefore considered safe. History had shown that even the most innocuous types of AI 
could ultimately turn against humans. Entire star systems were now under the control of diabolically smart 
machines, and in those dark sectors of the universe, human slaves followed the commands of mechanized 
masters. 
At optimal spots on the shimmering cliffs, the mining machines would lock onto the surface with suction 
devices and separate the diamond material with sound waves at natural points of fissure. Holding diamond 
sheets in their grasp, the dumb machines would make their way back down the cliff to loading areas. 
It was an efficient process, but sometimes the sonic cutting procedure shattered the diamond sheets. 
Though once Piers gave the slaves 



a stake in the profits, such mishaps occurred much less frequently, as if they took greater care when they 
received a vested interest. 
Overseeing the Hagal operation, Piers had come up with the idea of letting the captive gangs work without 
typical Harkonnen regulations and close oversight. While some slaves accepted the incentive program, a 
number of problems did surface. With reduced supervision, some slaves ran away; others were 
disorganized or lazy, just waiting for someone to tell them what to do. Initially, productivity dropped, but 
he was sure the output would eventually meet, and even exceed, previous levels. 
Before that could happen, though, his father had made an unannounced visit to Hagal. And Ulf Harkonnen 
wasn't interested in creative ideas or humanitarian improvements if profits were down. . . . 
His parents had been forced to leave their younger son, Xavier, on Salusa with a pleasant old-school 
couple. "I shudder to think how the boy will turn out if they raise him. Emil and Lucille Tantor don't know 
how to be strict." 
Eavesdropping, Piers knew why his manipulative father had left his little brother with the Tantors. Since 
the aging couple was childless, wily Ulf was working his way into their good graces. He hoped the 
Tantors might eventually leave their estate to their dear "godson" Xavier. 
Piers hated the way his father used people, whether they were slaves, other nobles, or members of his own 
family. It was disgusting. But now, trapped inside the cramped lifepod chamber, he could do nothing 
about it. 
PROGRAMMING MADE THE thinking machines relentless and determined, but only the cruelty of a human 
mind could generate enough ruthless hatred to feed a war of extermination for a thousand years. 
Though they were kept in reluctant thrall by the pervasive computer mind Omnius, the cymeks-hybrid 
machines with human minds-often bided their time by hunting between the stars. They would capture 
feral humans and bring them back to slavery on the Synchronized Worlds, or just kill them for sport. . . . 
The leader of the cymeks, a general who had taken the imposing name of Agamemnon, had once led the 
group of tyrants that conquered the decaying Old Empire. As implacable soldiers in the cause, the tyrants 
had reprogrammed the subservient robots and computers to give them a thirst for conquest. When his 
mortal human body grew old and weak, Agamemnon had undergone a surgical process that removed his 
brain and implanted it within a preservation canister that he could install into various mechanical bodies. 
Agamemnon and his fellow tyrants had intended to rule for centuries . . . but then the artificially 
aggressive computers stepped into power when they saw the chance, exploiting the tyrants' lack of dili-
gence. The Omnius network then ruled the remnants of the Old Empire, subjugating the cymek tyrants 
along with the rest of already-downtrodden humanity. 
For centuries, Agamemnon and his fellow conquerors had been forced to serve the computer evermind, 
with no chance of regaining their own rule. Their greatest source of amusement was in tracking down 
stray humans who had managed to maintain their independence from machine domination. Still, the 
cymek general found it a most unsatisfactory venting of his frustrations. 
His brain canister had been installed inside a fast scout vessel that patrolled areas known to be inhabited 
by League humans. Six cymeks accompanied the general as their ships skirted the edge of a small solar 
system. They found little of interest, only one human-compatible world composed of mostly water. 
Then Agamemnon's long-range sensors spotted another vessel. A human vessel. 
He increased resolution and pointed out the target to his companions. Triangulating with their combined 
detection abilities, Agamemnon discerned that the lone ship was a small space yacht, its sophisticated 
configuration and style implying that its passengers were important members of the League, rich 
merchants . . . perhaps even smug nobles, the most gratifying victims of all. 
"Just what we've been waiting for," said Agamemnon. 
The cymek ships adjusted course and accelerated. Connected through thoughtrodes, Agamemnon's brain 
flew his ship-body as if it were a large bird of prey, zeroing in on his helpless target. He also had a ter-
restrial walker stored aboard, a warrior form that could be used for planetary combat. 
The first cymek shots took the League vessel completely by surprise. The doomed human pilot barely had 
time to take evasive maneuvers. Kinetic projectiles scraped the hull, pounding one of the engines, but the 
ship's defensive armor protected it against severe damage. Cymek ships swept past, strafing again with 



explosive projectiles, and the human yacht reeled, intact but disoriented. 
"Careful, boys," Agamemnon said. "We don't want to destroy the prize." 
Out on the outskirts of League space, far from the Synchronized Worlds, the feral humans obviously 
hadn't expected to encounter enemy predators, and the captain of this vessel had been particularly inatten-
tive. Defeating him would be almost embarrassing. His cymek hunters would hope for a better challenge, 
a more entertaining pursuit.. . 
The human pilot got his damaged engine back on line and increased speed down into the isolated system, 
fleeing toward the water world. In his wake, the human launched a flurry of intensely bright explosive 
shells, which caused little physical damage, but sent pulses of confusing static through the machine 
sensors of the cymek ships. Agamemnon's cymek followers transmitted a series of imaginative curses. 
Surprisingly, the human victim responded in a gruff, defiant voice with equal venom and vigor. 
Agamemnon chuckled to himself and sent a thought-command. This would be more fun. His attack ship 
burst forward like a wild and energetic horse, part of his imaginary body. "Give chase!" The cymeks, 
enjoying the game, swooped after the hapless human vessel. 
The doomed pilot flew standard maneuvers to evade the pursuers. Agamemnon held back, trying to 
determine if the human was truly so inexperienced or just lulling the cymeks into an unwarranted sense of 
ease. 
They plummeted toward the peaceful blue world-Caladan, according to the onboard database. The world 
reminded him of the blue irises his human eyes once had. ... It had been so many centuries, the cymek 
general could recall few details of his original physical appearance. 
Agamemnon could have transmitted an ultimatum to the pilot, but humans and cymeks knew the stakes in 
their long-simmering war. The space yacht opened fire, a few pathetically weak blasts designed for 
shoving troublesome meteoroids out of the way rather than defending against overt military action. If this 
was a nobleman's ship, it should have much more serious offensive and defensive weapons. The cymeks 
laughed and closed in, perceiving no threat. 
As soon as they approached, though, the desperate human pilot launched another flurry of explosives, 
apparently the same as the gnat-bite bombs he had launched previously, but Agamemnon detected slight 
fluctuations. "Caution, I suspect-" 
Four proximity mines, each a space charge ten times as powerful as the first artillery, detonated with huge 
shock waves. Two of the cymek hunters suffered external damage; one was completely destroyed. 
Agamemnon lost his patience. "Back off! Engage ship defenses!" 
But the yacht pilot fired no more explosives. With one of the surviving cymeks moving only sluggishly, 
the human could easily have taken him out. Since he did not, the human prey must have no further 
weapons available. Or was it another trick? 
"Don't underestimate the vermin." 
Agamemnon had hoped to take the feral humans captive, delivering them to Omnius for experiments or 
analysis, since "wild" specimens were considered different from those raised for generations in captivity. 
But, angry at the pointless loss of one of his overeager companions, the general decided it was just too 
much trouble. 
"Vaporize that ship," he transmitted to his five remaining followers. Without waiting for the other cymeks 
to join him, Agamemnon opened fire. 
INSIDE THE LIFEPOD, Piers could only watch in horror and wait to die. 
The enemy cymeks pounded them again. In the cockpit, his father shouted curses, and his mother did her 
best at the weapons station. Their eyes betrayed no fear, only showed strong determination. Harkonnens 
did not die easily. 
Ulf had insisted on installing the best armor and defensive systems available, always suspicious, always 
ready to fight against any threat. But this lone yacht could not withstand a concerted attack from seven 
fully armed and aggressive cymek marauders. 
Sealed inside the dim compartment, Piers could do nothing to help. He watched the attacking machines 
through the porthole, sure his family could not hold out long. Even his father, who refused to bow to 
defeat, looked as if he had no tricks remaining to him. 



Sensing the imminent kill, the cymeks streaked closer. Piers heard repeated thumps reverberating in the 
vessel. Through the hatch porthole, Piers saw his mother and father gesturing desperately at one another. 
Another cymek blast finally breached the protective plates and damaged the yacht's engines as the vessel 
careened toward the not-close-enough planet with broad blue seas and white lacings of cloud. Sparks flew 
on the bridge, and the wounded ship began to tumble. 
Ulf Harkonnen shouted something at his wife, then lurched toward 
the lifepod, trying to keep his balance. Katarina called after him. Piers couldn't figure out what they were 
arguing about; the ship was doomed. 
Cymek weapons fire rocked the vessel with a dull concussion, sending Ulf skidding across the deck. Even 
the augmented hull armor could not withstand much more. The elder Harkonnen struggled to his feet at 
the lifepod hatch, and Piers suddenly realized that his father wanted to unlock the chamber and get both of 
them inside with their son. 
Piers read his mother's lips as she shouted, "No time!" 
The lifepod's instrument panel flashed and began running through test cycles. Piers hammered on the 
hatch, but they had sealed him inside. He couldn't get out to help them. 
While Ulf tried frantically to work the hatch controls, Katarina raced for the panel on the wall and slapped 
the activation switch. While Ulf turned to his wife in astonishment and dismay, Katarina mouthed a 
desperate farewell to her son. 
With a lurch, the lifepod shot into space, away from the doomed space yacht. 
Acceleration threw Piers to the deck, but he scrambled to his knees, to the observation port. Behind him, 
as the lifepod tumbled recklessly through space, the cymek marauders opened fire again and again, six 
angry thinking machines combining their destructive power. 
The Harkonnen ship erupted in a sequence of explosions into a dazzling fireball, which dissipated into the 
cluttered vacuum. . . snuffed out along with the lives of his parents. 
Like a cannonball, the lifepod tore into the atmosphere of Caladan, spraying red sparks of reentry as it 
zoomed toward the blue oceans on the sunlit side of the planet. 
Piers struggled with the crude emergency controls in an effort to maneuver, but the small ship didn't 
respond, as if it were a machine rebelling against its human master. At this rate of speed, he couldn't pos-
sibly survive. 
The young Harkonnen heir took an agonized breath and tapped pressure pads to alter the thruster pattern. 
He had little experience in 
piloting, though his father had insisted that he learn; previously, the skill had not been a priority for Piers, 
but now he had to figure out the systems without delay. 
Looking back, he saw he was being pursued by one of the cymek fighter ships. The spray of reentry sparks 
increased, like iron filings from a grinding stone. The pursuer's exploding projectiles rocked the 
atmosphere around him without making direct hits. 
Piers sped low over an isolated landmass toward a snowy mountain ridge, with the vicious cymek on his 
tail, still shooting. Sparkling glaciers girdled the jagged peaks. One of the enemy's kinetic projectiles hit a 
high ridge, shattering ice and rock. Piers closed his eyes and boldly-without a choice-flew through the 
debris, heard it pummeling the lifepod. And he barely survived. 
Just after he scraped over the ridge, he heard a tremendous explosion and saw the sky behind him light up 
in a flash of bright orange. The mechanical pursuer had gone out of control. Destroyed, just like his 
parents and their spacecraft. . . . 
But Piers knew there were other enemies, and probably not far away. 
AGAMEMNON AND HIS cymeks clustered around the space yacht's wreckage in unstable orbit, while 
mapping the trajectory of the single ejected lifepod. They marked where it crossed the atmosphere, how 
fast it descended, and where it would probably land. The general was in no hurry-after all, where could 
the lone survivor go on this primitive world? 
Without orders, though, the one cymek damaged by proximity mines shot after the lifepod, hungry for 
revenge. "General Agamemnon, I intend to make this kill on my own." Angrily, the cymek leader paused, 
then agreed. "Go, you get the first shot. But the rest of us won't wait for long." The cymek leader held the 



rest of them back until he could finish his analysis. 
Agamemnon played the distress signal the noble pilot had transmitted shortly before his destruction. The 
words were encoded, but not with a very sophisticated cipher; the cymek's onboard AI systems translated 
it easily. "This is Lord Ulf Harkonnen, en route from our holdings at Hagal. We are under attack by 
thinking machines. There is not much chance we will survive." 
Such amazing powers of prediction. Agamemnon assumed the survivor aboard the lifepod must also be a 
member of the noble family, if not the lord himself. 
A thousand years ago, when Agamemnon and his nineteen co-conspirators had overthrown the Old 
Empire, a group of outlying planets had banded together to form the League of Nobles. They had 
defended themselves against the tyrants, maintaining their defense against Omnius and his thinking 
machines. Computers did not hold grudges or gain vengeance ... but the cymeks had human minds and 
human emotions. 
If the survivor in the lifepod down on Caladan was a member of the defiant League of Nobles, the cymek 
general wanted to participate personally in his interrogation, torture, and ultimate execution. 
Within minutes, however, he received a last-second transmission just before the cymek pursuer crashed on 
the surface. 
"A foolish mission. Next time I want it done right," Agamemnon said. "Go; find him before he can hide in 
the wilderness. I give the hunt to the four of you-and a challenge. A reward to the cymek who finds and 
kills the prey first." 
The other cymek ships streaked away from the debris field, heading like hot bullets into the cloudy skies. 
The human escapee, unarmed in his barely maneuverable lifepod, certainly would not last long. 
ABRUPTLY THE LIFEPOD shuddered, and a warning siren sounded. Digital and crystal instruments 
sparked on the panel. Piers tried to interpret them, adjusting the clumsy controls of the careening vessel, 
then looked up through the porthole to see brown-and-white slopes 
ahead, bleak frozen hillsides with patches of snow, dark forests. In the last instant, he pulled up, just 
enough- 
The lifepod scraped tall, dark-needled trees and crashed into high tundra covered by only a thin blanket of 
snow. The impact bounced the pod back into the air, spinning it around for a second plunge into the 
patchy forest. 
In his energy harness, Piers rolled and shouted, trying to survive but expecting the worst. Cushioning 
bubblefoam squirted all around him just before the first impact, padding his body from the worst injuries. 
Then the pod crashed again, ripping up snow and frozen dirt. The pod finally came to rest, groaning and 
hissing. 
The bubblefoam dissolved, and Piers picked himself up and wiped the fizzing slime from his clothes and 
hands and hair. He was too shaken to feel pain and couldn't take the time to evaluate his injuries. 
He knew his parents were dead, their ship destroyed. He hoped his blurred vision was from blood in his 
eyes, not tears. He was a Harkonnen, after all. His father would have struck him across the cheek for 
showing cowardly emotion. Ulf had managed to damage the enemy in a fruitless attack, but there were 
still more cymeks up there. No doubt they would come hunting for him. 
Piers fought down panic, turned it into a hard, instant assessment of his situation. If he had any hope of 
surviving, circumstances forced him to respond with decisiveness, even ruthlessness-the Harkonnen 
way. And he wouldn't have much time. 
The lifepod contained a few survival supplies, but he couldn't stay here. The cymeks would zero in on the 
vessel and come to finish the job. Once he ran, he would have no chance to return. 
Piers grabbed a medical kit and all the ration packs he could carry, stuffing them into a flexible sack. He 
popped the lifepod's hatch and crawled out, smelling the smoke and hearing the crackle of a few gasping 
fires ignited by the heat of impact. He took a deep breath of cold, biting air; then, closing the hatch behind 
him, he staggered away from the smoking pod, crunching through slushy snow into the meager shelter of 
dark conifers. He wanted to get as far away as possible before pausing to consider his next step. 
In a situation like this, his father would have been concerned about the family holdings, the Hagal mines. 
With Piers and his parents gone, who would run the business and keep the Harkonnen family strong? 



Right now, though, the young man was more worried for his own survival. He had never fit in with family 
business philosophies anyway. 
Hearing a high-pitched roar, he gazed into the sky and saw four flaming white trails coming toward him 
like targeted munitions. Cymek landers. Hunters. The machines with human minds would track him down 
in the desolate wilderness. 
As the danger suddenly came closer to home, Piers saw he was leaving deep tracks in the snow. Blood 
dripped from a nasty cut on his left wrist; more scarlet splashed from another injury on his forehead. He 
might as well be leaving a roadmap for the enemy to follow. 
His father had said it in a stern, impatient voice, but the lesson was valuable nevertheless: Be aware of all 
facets of a situation. Just because something is quiet does not mean it isn't dangerous. Do not trust your safety at any 
moment. 
Under the trees, listening to the roar as cymeks converged over his pod's crash-down coordinates, Piers 
slathered wound sealant on his injuries to stop the bleeding. A moment's hurry can cause far more damage than a 
moment's delay to plan ahead. 
He abruptly changed direction, selecting a clear area where trees had sheltered the ground from the snow 
and rocks. He moved over the rocky surface in a deliberately chaotic course, hoping to throw off pursuit. 
He had no weapons, no knowledge of the terrain . .. and no intention of giving up. 
Piers climbed higher up the sloping ground, and the snow grew thicker where the trees became sparse. 
When he reached a clearing, he caught his breath and looked back to see that cymek landers had con-
verged at his lifepod. Still not far enough away, and still without any place to run. 
Watching in horrified fascination, Piers saw mobile, resilient walker-forms emerge from the landed ships: 
adaptable mechanical bodies to carry cymek brain canisters across a variety of environments. Like angry 
crabs, the cymeks crawled over the sealed wreckage, using cutter claws and white-hot flamers to tear open 
the hull. When they found no one inside, they literally ripped the lifepod apart. 
The walker-forms stalked around the pod, their optic threads gleaming with a variety of sensors. They 
scanned his footprints in the snow, moved to where their prey had paused to apply his medical pack. The 
cymek scanners could easily pick up his footprints in the dirt, thermal traces from his body heat, any 
number of clues. Unerringly, they set out across the bare ground toward where he had chosen to flee. 
Chiding himself for the momentary panic that had made him leave such an obvious trail, Piers broke into a 
full run uphill, always looking for a place to hide, a weapon to use. He tried to ignore his hammering heart 
and his difficulty breathing in this cold, rugged environment of Caladan. He crashed into another thicket 
of the dark pines, always climbing. The slope became steeper, but because of the dense conifers, he 
couldn't see exactly where he was going or how close he might be to the top of a ridge. 
He saw sticks, rocks, but nothing that would be an effective weapon against the mechanical monsters, no 
way to defend himself against the horrific machines. But Piers was, after all, a Harkonnen, and he would 
not give up. He would hurt them if he could. At the very least, he would offer them a fine chase. 
Far to his rear, Piers heard crashing sounds, cracking trees, and imagined the cymeks clearing a path for 
their armored bodies. Judging from the smoke, they must be setting the forest on fire as well. Good- that 
way they would ruin the subtleties of his trail. 
He kept running as the ground became rockier, with patches of ice spreading out on steep slopes. 
Precariously balanced snow clung to the mountain, ready to break loose at any moment. The trees at this 
elevation were bent and twisted, and he smelled a foul sulfurous taint in the air. At his feet he saw tiny 
bubbling puddles, suffused with yellow. 
He furrowed his brows, pondering what this could mean. A thermal area. He had read about such places in 
his studies, esoteric geological anomalies that his father had forced him to learn before sending him to the 
mining operations on Hagal. This would be a region of volcanic activity with hot springs, geysers, 
fumaroles ... a dangerous place, but one that offered opportunities against large opponents. 
Piers ran toward the strong smell and the thickening mist, hoping this would give him an advantage. 
Cymeks did not use eyes like humans did, and their sensors were delicate, sensitive to different parts of 
the spectrum. In some cases, it gave the machine pursuers an incredible advantage. Here, though, with the 
wild plumes of heat and the rocky, sterile ground, the cymeks could not use their scanners to pick up 



residual traces from his footprints. 
He raced through the misty, humid no-man's-land of rocks, snow patches, crusty bare earth, trying to 
throw off pursuit and seeking a place to hide, or defend. After hours of headlong flight, he collapsed on a 
warm boulder encrusted with orange lichen next to a hissing steam vent. More than anything else, he 
wanted to curl up under a rocky overhang next to one of the hot springs and remain hidden long enough to 
sleep for a few hours. 
But cymeks did not require sleep. All of their life-support needs were taken care of with restorative 
electrafluid that kept them alive in their preservation canisters. They would keep pursuing him without 
pause. 
Piers cracked open the food rations and gobbled two high-energy wafers, but he forced himself to set off 
again before he felt any resurgence of stamina. He had to press his advantage, not lose any ground. 
Using his hands and feet now, Piers climbed steeper rocks. His fingers became powdery with yellow 
sulfur. He chose the steepest terrain, 
hoping it would prove difficult for the cymek walker bodies, but it also slowed him down. 
The wind began to pick up, and Piers felt it against his face, alternating blasts of warm and cold. The mists 
cleared in patches, and suddenly the landscape was revealed around him. He looked back toward the last 
remnants of conifer forests, jutting rocks, and the bubbling mineral pools far beneath him. 
Then he saw one of the cymek walker-forms, alone, stalking him. The other three must have separated, 
circling in their hunt, as if it were some sort of game. The mechanical body glistened silver in the sudden 
wash of afternoon light. Searching. 
Piers knew he was exposed and unprotected on the rocky slope; he slammed his body tight against the 
rocks, hoping to remain unseen. But within seconds, the cymek had targeted its prey. The mechanical 
walker unleashed a fiery projectile, a splattering globule of flaming gel that missed Piers and struck the 
rock with clinging fire. 
He scrambled up the rock, finding a new surge of energy. Scuttling rapidly, the cymek negotiated the 
rough slope, no longer wasting time on the tedious job of tracking the human. 
Piers was trapped, with precipitous drop-offs and hot sulfurous pools on the left and right and a steep, 
smooth snowfield crusted with yellow contaminants above him. Once he got to the top of the ridge, 
perhaps he could throw rocks, somehow dislodge the cymek below him. He saw no other option. 
Clawing with his hands and struggling for footholds, Piers worked his way up the slick glacier field. His 
shoes punched through the crust, sinking into cold snow up to his knees. His fingers soon grew numb and 
red. The frigid air seared his lungs, but he scrambled faster, farther. His domineering father would have 
sneered at him for worrying about mere physical discomfort in a time of such urgency. The glacier seemed 
to go on forever, though he could see the top, a sheer razor edge on the crest. 
The machine hunters must have split up, and perhaps he had eluded 
the other three among the thermal plumes and crumbling rocks. Unable to find his tracks, they would be 
combing the ground . . . relentless, as machines always were. Only one of the cymeks had found him, 
apparently by accident. 
Even so, a single monstrous enemy was more than enough to kill him, and this one would be in radio 
contact with the others. Already they must be coming this way. But this one seemed eager to kill Piers all 
by itself. 
Below, the cymek reached the base of the ice field, scanned for a moment, and then scuttled up. Its long 
legs stabbed into the snow, climbing faster than any human could hope to run. 
The cymek paused, rocked back, then launched another gelfire projectile. Piers burrowed into the snow, 
and the hot explosive ripped a crater barely an arm's length away from him. The violent impact caused the 
steep and precarious snowfield to tremble and shift. Around him, the crust began to break apart like a 
peeling scab. Taking a chance, he kicked at one of the hard slabs of packed snow, hoping to send it 
tumbling down to strike his enemy, but the frozen surface jammed tight, squeaking and groaning, then 
falling silent. With a deep breath, he climbed upward again. 
As the cymek closed the gap, Piers noticed a rocky outcropping that protruded from the snow. He would 
scramble up there and make his stand. Maybe he could throw boulders at the machine, though he had no 



illusions about how effective that would be. 
Only a fool leaves himself without options, Ulf Harkonnen would have said. 
Piers grumbled at the memory. "At least I survived longer than you did, Father." 
Then, to his astonishment, at the crest of the glacier he saw a group of figures that looked . . . human! He 
counted dozens of people who stood at the top of the snowfield. They shouted incomprehensible curses at 
the cymek. 
The silhouetted strangers lifted large cylinders-weapons of some 
sort?-and began to beat on them. Loud booming sounds echoed across the mountains like thunderclaps, 
explosions. Drums. 
The strangers pounded on their noisemakers. They had no apparent rhythm at first, but then the pulses 
combined into a resonance, an echoing boom that set the whole snowfield trembling. 
Cracks widened atop the ice, and the glacier began to shift. The massive cymek walker struggled for 
purchase as the frozen ground began to slide. 
Seeing what was about to happen, Piers dove for the rock outcropping, sheltering himself in a pocket 
walled off by thick stone on each side. He held on just as the snow broke free with a hissing, tumbling 
roar. 
The avalanche struck the cymek like a white tidal wave, bowling over the walker-form, knocking and 
battering it against other rocks. As the enemy machine crashed down the slope, Piers closed his eyes and 
waited for the rumbling roar to reach its crescendo and then taper off. 
When he finally emerged, amazed to be alive, the air itself sparkled with ice crystals thrown into the sky. 
While the snowpack undoubtedly remained unstable, the strange people charged pell-mell down the bro-
ken snow and ice, yelling excitedly like hunters who had just bagged an impressive quarry. 
Still unable to believe what he was seeing, Piers stood atop the boulders. And then he spotted the 
twitching and battered cymek far down the slope, toppled onto its back. The avalanche had struck it with a 
destructive force equivalent to a heavy weapon. The cymek had been bashed, dented, and twisted, but still 
its mechanical limbs attempted to haul the walker-form upright. 
Although the primitive humans wore drab survival garb made of scavenged materials, they carried 
sophisticated tools, more than just spears or clubs. Four young natives-scouts?-hurried to the edge of 
the broken ice field and the trees and they kept watch, wary of other cymeks. 
The remaining humans fell like hyenas upon the crippled cymek, 
wielding cutters and grappling wrenches. Was the mechanical hunter calling for help from its three 
comrades? The natives quickly bashed the transmitter antennas on the walker body; then, with startling 
efficiency they dismantled the walker's struggling legs. The cymek weapon arm flickered in an attempt to 
launch another flaming projectile, but the Caladan primitives quickly disconnected the components. 
From the cymek's speakerpatch came a volley of angry threats and curses, but the humans paid no 
attention, showing no fear. They worked diligently to disconnect the hydraulics, fiber cables, 
neurelectronics, setting each piece aside like valuable scrap material. They left the cymek's brain canister 
exposed, the traitorous human mind disembodied once again, though this time not by its own volition. 
Numb, Piers looked at the oddly harmless-looking canister that held the cymek's mind. The natives did not 
destroy it immediately, but seemed to have other plans. They held it up like a trophy. 
Full of questions, Piers made his way down the shifting surface of broken snow. The natives looked up at 
him as he approached, showing curiosity without threat. They spoke a gibberish language that he could 
not comprehend. 
"Who are you?" Piers asked in standard Galach, hoping that someone here would understand him. 
One of the men, a gaunt old fellow with a short reddish beard and lighter skin than his companions, 
gestured toward Piers in happy victory. He stood in front of Piers, pounded himself on the chest. "Tiddoc." 
"Piers Harkonnen," he responded, then decided to simplify, "Piers." 
"Good, Piers. Thank you," he said in recognizable Galach, but with a thick accent. Seeing the young man's 
surprise, Tiddoc spoke slowly, as if fishing the right words out of his memory. "Our tongue has Galach 
roots from the Zensunni Wanderers, who fled the League long ago. For years I worked in cities of the 
noblemen, performing menial tasks. I picked up words here and there." 



Paralyzed and immobile, the captured enemy cymek continued to 
snarl insults through an integrated speakerpatch as the Caladan natives used two of the amputated walker 
legs as support rods, lashing the brain canister so that it dangled between the poles like some captured 
wild beast. Two of the strongest-looking natives put the metal rods over their shoulders and began to 
march back up the slope. The other natives gathered up the components they could carry and climbed the 
rough mountainside. 
"Come with us," Tiddoc said. 
Piers had no option but to follow them. 
AS PIERS FOLLOWED the rugged men uphill, one of his knees throbbed with each step, and his back 
stiffened until it burned. He had not yet had time to accept the deaths of his parents. He missed his mother, 
for her kind attentions, her intelligence. Katarina had saved his life, launching the lifepod before the 
cymeks could destroy the space yacht. 
In a way, Piers even missed his father. Despite Ulf's gruffness, he had only wanted the best for his sons, 
harshly focused on his responsibilities for Harkonnen holdings. Advancing the family fortunes was always 
paramount. Now it seemed that his little brother, Xavier, was all that remained of the Harkonnen 
bloodline. Piers had little hope that he would ever get away from Caladan . . . but at least he had survived 
this long. 
He limped up the steep slope, trying to keep pace with the agile natives. Inside its preservation canister, 
the evil cymek brain sloshed as the primitives carried it. Staticky shouts came from the canister's 
speakerpatch, first in standard Galach, then in other languages. Tiddoc and the natives seemed to find it 
amusing. 
The natives paid little attention to the disembodied brain, except to glare at it and bare their teeth. The red-
bearded old man was the most demonstrative. In addition to menacing facial expressions, he made 
threatening gestures with a cutting tool, swinging it close to the canister's sensors, which only served to 
agitate the captive brain more. Obviously they had encountered cymeks before and knew how to fight 
them. 
But Piers was concerned about the other three mechanical hunters. They would not give up the pursuit-
and once they found the avalanche site and the dismantled walker-form, the cymeks could track the 
natives here. Unless the captured one had not been able to signal for help before the avalanche had swept 
it away. Cymeks did not like to admit weakness. 
Piers looked around for any fortifications the people had made. Ahead, overhanging ice formed a giant 
roof that sheltered a settlement. The primitives had made their camp in a large area melted out by thermal 
vents in the ground. Women and children bustled among rock huts, performing chores, pausing to look at 
the approaching party. The people wore thick clothing, boots, and hats lined with fur from unknown local 
animals. Piers heard the yelping of animals, saw furry white creatures near the dwellings. 
Beyond the shelter of the overhang, steam roiled up through thick layers of ice and snow, accompanied by 
heat bubbles from mudpots and geysers. As Piers followed the tribe down narrow rock steps toward the 
settlement, he marveled at the stunning contrast of fire and ice, even as he cast constant worried glances 
over his shoulder to make sure he saw no sign of the other cymek hunters. Occasional droplets rained 
down from the frozen ceiling of the dome, slowly melting, but when Piers looked up at the blue ice 
overhead, he decided the glacier-and the settlement-had been here for a long time. . . . 
When abrupt darkness fell like a curtain drawn in front of the sun, the native Caladan women used jagged 
pieces of wood to build a large fire on a rocky area at the center of the settlement. Scouts went out on 
patrol to keep watch for enemy machines while the rest of the tribe settled down to celebrate. The men 
brought hunks of fresh meat from other hunts and speared them on long metal spits over the fire. 
They placed the captive cymek's brain canister off to one side, in the ice, and ignored it. 
Speaking to one another in their guttural tongue, the natives sat on furs around the fire and passed the food 
around, sharing with their visitor. Piers found the meat too gamey for his liking, but he finished a large 
hunk, not wanting to insult his hosts. He was famished, and supplemented his meal with part of a ration 
bar he had salvaged from the lifepod; he offered the rest of the packaged food to his rescuers, and they 
eagerly accepted. 



Still, the urgency gnawed at him. Even among so many other people, he did not feel safe, and he tried to 
convince the old leader that the danger had not gone away. "There are more cymeks, Tiddoc. I think 
they're hunting me." 
"We already killed one," he said. 
"But what about the others ? They are still out there-" 
"We will kill them, too. If they bother with you. Cymeks have little patience. Lose interest quickly. Are 
you so important to them? My people know that we are not." He patted Piers's wrist. "We have scouts. We 
have defenses." 
Following the meal, Tiddoc and his people sat around the story fire, telling ancient parables and 
adventures in their native tongue. During the sharing, the tribesmen passed around gourds of a potent 
beverage. Wrapped in a fur to ward off the chill air, Piers drank, and felt warm in his belly. At intervals, 
the old man translated for Piers, relating tales of the downtrodden Zensunni who had fled the machine 
takeovers, as well as slavery in the League of Nobles. 
A little tipsy, Piers defended the League and their continuing fight against the thinking machines, though 
he sympathized with the unpleasant plight of the Buddislamic slaves on Poritrin, Zanbar, and other League 
worlds. While Tiddoc struggled to translate, Piers told of epic battles against the evil Omnius and his 
aggressive robots and cymeks. 
And, with a thick voice, he told how his own ship had been destroyed, his parents killed. . . . 
Tiddoc gestured to the cymek brain canister. "Come. The feasting is done. Now we finish our machine 
war. The people have been looking forward to this." He shouted something in his own language, and two 
men lifted the canister by its improvised poles. The cymek grumbled from its speakerpatch, but it had run 
out of effective curses. 
Several women lit torches from the central fire and led the way up a path from the dripping glacier 
overhang. Full of good cheer, the natives marched away, carrying the impotent enemy brain. The cymek 
hurled threats in every language it could think of, but the primitives only laughed at it. 
"What are you doing?" the cymek demanded. Controlling its last functional thoughtrodes, the disembodied 
brain twisted in its container. "Stop! We will crush you all!" 
Piers followed them over a ridge and down a slope to where the air reeked of sulfur and the porous rock 
grew warm underfoot. Carrying the helpless cymek, the group paused at a steaming hole in the rock and 
stood chattering and laughing. They held the brain canister over the ominous opening. 
Piers bent closer to the hole, curious, but Tiddoc yanked him away. The red-bearded elder wore an eerie 
smile in the torchlight. 
A rumble sounded deep below, and with a preliminary spurt of hot spray, a geyser erupted, a scalding jet 
that parboiled the cymek's brain. The enemy's curses turned to shrieks, followed by babbling sounds and 
disjointed pain that trickled out of the damaged speaker-patch. 
When the geyser subsided, the delirious cymek cried and gibbered. Moments later the geyser erupted 
again, and the speakerpatch unleashed hideous howls that sent shudders down Piers's spine. 
Even though this monster had tried to kill him, had taken part in the murder of his parents, Piers could not 
tolerate hearing its misery anymore. When the boiling jet subsided again, he took a rock and smashed the 
speaker, disconnecting it. 
But the natives continued to hold the agonized brain over the geyser 
hole, and when the scalding spray gushed out a third time, the cymek screamed in silence, until it was 
boiled alive in its electrafluid. 
The natives then cracked the canister open on a rock and devoured the hot, cooked contents. 
THE ROCK HUT was warm and marginally comfortable, but Piers slept poorly, unable to put the horrific 
images out of his mind. When he finally dreamed, he saw himself strapped to poles while the natives held 
him over the geyser hole. He heard boiling water rushing toward him, and he awoke with a scream caught 
in his throat. 
Outside, he heard only the howl of an animal, then silence. 
Then mechanical sounds. 
He stumbled to the entrance of the hut and peered outside into the cold, sulfur-smelling air. Now the furry 



guard animals howled. The primitives shouted and stirred in their encampment. The scouts had been 
watching. 
In a slit of grayish, misty sky between the ground and the icy over-hang Piers saw four aircraft 
approaching with insect-machine noises, their engines glowing in the predawn sky. Cymeks! 
Tiddoc and the natives fled their stone huts, grabbing torches, weapons. Piers ran out, anxious to help. He 
had lost the other two cymek hunters in his flight the previous day, but the sophisticated thinking 
machines had combed the landscape with their scanners until they finally picked up his trail. . . which had 
led the monsters here. 
The cymek ships landed in the nearby rock field and opened hatches, each one disgorging an armed 
walker body. The crablike warrior machines marched downslope with alarming speed. Ahead, the 
primitives scattered, hooting, waving torches, taunting the enemy. 
One of the cymeks launched a rocket of gelfire, which exploded and collapsed part of the arched, glacier 
ceiling. Shards of ice tumbled down, smashing the evacuated stone huts. 
Tiddoc and the villagers scampered out of the way as if it were a game, gesturing for Piers to follow as 
they hurried along the path they had taken the night before, onto the geyser field. In daylight Piers saw 
that it was a broad, gently sloped area of boiling mudpots and hot springs. Fumaroles and geysers belched 
repeatedly, filling the air with foul steam and heat plumes. Shouting, cursing, the people split up, fol-
lowing instinctive routes across the crusty ground. The natives' supposed panic was a strangely organized 
action, like a cat and mouse game. Were they luring the enemy? They seemed to have a plan, a hunt of 
their own. 
Piers ran along with them, ducking as the four cymek walkers shot projectiles into the hissing thermal 
area. Their mechanical bodies plodded forward like heavy spiders on the uncertain ground. For so-
phisticated machines, their aim was terrible. The cymeks' optic threads and thermal sensors must be nearly 
blinded in the chaos of heat signatures. 
Tiddoc hurled a spear, which clanked on the head turret of the largest cymek walker. It was an ineffective 
weapon, designed to distract and provoke the cymek, rather than damage the walker body. The leader ran 
ahead, hooting, luring the cymek onward. 
Agitated, the largest machine-creature bellowed through a speaker-patch, "You cannot escape 
Agamemnon!" The other three cymeks scrambled along behind it. 
Piers shuddered. All free humans knew the famous general of Omnius's army, one of the brutal original 
tyrants. 
With a lucky shot, one of the enemy machines blasted a young man who danced too close to the weapon 
arm, and his twitching, burning body writhed on the ground. The Caladan natives, looking angry and 
vengeful, tightened their ranks and worked harder against the cymeks. They tossed homemade explosives 
that exploded with smoke and fire and a loud concussion, leaving scorch marks on the cymek bodies. The 
machines with human minds did not slow in their progress. 
Light-footed, the primitives raced across the volcanically active 
area. The cymeks, oblivious to the trap, charged after their prey, smashing salty encrustations, pursuing 
the natives into the reeking mists. They shot more blobs of gelfire, fired explosive projectiles. Another 
daring man died, his chest blasted into a smoking crater. 
Tiddoc and the natives kept hooting and shouting, defiant. Two of the smaller cymeks surged forward into 
a crater-pocked geyser field. The waving, taunting primitives stopped and turned, expectant. 
The thin shell of hardened ground cracked, split. The two mechanical walker-forms tried to skitter 
backward, but the surface gave way beneath them, breaking apart. Both cymeks plunged through the 
dangerous ground and tumbled screaming into roiling sulfur cauldrons. 
Piers joined Tiddoc and the other humans in their loud cheer, which was squelched when a third native, a 
long-haired young woman, was cut down by hot projectiles. 
Unexpectedly, a furious geyser blast rocketed out of the ground next to a third cymek attacker, scalding 
the brain canister. Its thoughtrodes damaged, the mechanical behemoth veered away and stumbled around 
in confusion. The cymek fell to its articulated knees, the electrafluid in its stained brain canister glowing 
blue as it focused its mental energy. 



Tiddoc tossed a small, homemade explosive onto the ground, like a crude grenade. The detonation caused 
no further damage to the armored walker, but the ground crust fractured. While the wounded mechanical 
enemy reeled, disoriented, the surface gave way. The third cymek joined the others in the molten mud. 
Agamemnon kept advancing toward the retreating humans, as if scorning his incompetent underlings. The 
lead cymek stalked unwavering toward old Tiddoc. The red-bearded man and his companions threw their 
spears and more crude explosives, but the mechanical general did not flinch. Behind them and on the sides 
lay superheated soil, while the immense cymek blocked their only avenue of escape. 
On impulse, Piers ran in front of the lead cymek, shouting to distract him. He snatched up a discarded 
spear and thumped it against one of the tall walker legs. "Agamemnon! You murdered my parents!" 
To his surprise, the cymek general swiveled his head turret, and thermal sensors locked onto the upstart 
human's form. "A feisty one!" the monster said with considerable amusement. "You are the vermin we 
have been chasing."                                                            
"I am a Harkonnen nobleman!" Piers swung the spear like a cudgel at the brain canister. He struck the 
thick armor plaz with a blow hard enough to rattle his bones-but he left only a tiny nick on the protective 
canister. 
The cymek bellowed a laugh. One of Agamemnon's clawed legs grabbed Piers, yanked away the spear. 
The young man felt the sharp claw tighten around his torso. He was dimly aware of Tiddoc howling- 
Then suddenly the crust gave way beneath the heavy cymek walker. Frothing mud gushed upward, and 
Agamemnon tumbled into a boiling geyser pit, still clutching his human victim. The claw loosened, just 
barely, and Piers scrambled on top of the body, trying to shield himself from the heat, to grab the rough 
rock of the pit's edge. Superheated steam blasted upward, eradicating all signs of Piers and the last ma-
chine invader. 
ALIVE AND ANGRY, Agamemnon reinstalled himself in an intact spaceship lander and departed from the 
watery world. With his heavily protected walker body, he had clamped onto the edges of the fuming pit, 
endured the steam blasts without falling into the molten mud. 
The verminous people rallied, hurled more explosives at him, and Agamemnon despised himself for being 
forced to retreat. With his hydraulics already damaged-and his foolish neo-cymeks all wiped out- his 
walker-form limped and scuttled back to the landed spacecraft, leaving the tribe behind. Systems onboard 
his ship reconfigured his 
brain canister to the controls; he discarded the ruined walker body, leaving it as scrap on the surface of 
cursed Caladan. 
The only survivor of his cymek squad, Agamemnon left the unremarkable world behind. He would return 
to Earth, and the computer evermind Omnius, and make his report. At this point, he was at liberty to create 
whatever explanation he chose. Omnius would never suspect him of lying: Such things simply did not 
occur to the all-pervasive computer. But the cymek general had a human brain. . . . 
As Agamemnon flew out into open space, he would have enough time to think of appropriate explanations 
and shift the blame. He would include a version of the events in his ever-growing memoirs recorded in the 
machine database. 
Fortunately, the all-powerful and all-seeing evermind simply wanted information and an accurate 
recounting of all events. Making excuses was a purely human weakness. 
ON THE LEAGUE capital world of Salusa Secundus, a young boy looked up at dark-skinned Emil Tantor, a 
wealthy and influential nobleman. They stood on the front lawn of the sprawling Tantor estate, with the 
tallest buildings of the city visible in the distance. It was early evening, with lights twinkling on in the 
palatial homes that dotted the hills. 
Ulf Harkonnen's distress signal had finally been intercepted, and Emil Tantor had brought the boy the 
terrible news about his parents and brother. More casualties in the long-standing war against the thinking 
machines. 
Young Xavier Harkonnen bowed his head, but refused to cry. The kindly nobleman touched his shoulder 
and spoke deep-throated, gentle words. "Will you have me, and Lucille, as your foster parents? I think it is 
what your father wanted when he left you in our care." 
Xavier looked into his brown eyes, nodded. 



"You'll grow into a fine young man," Tantor said, "one to make your 
brother and parents proud. We will do our best to raise you right, to teach you honor and responsibility. 
You will make the Harkonnen name shine in the annals of history." 
Xavier gazed beyond his foster father up to the faint stars glimmering through the dusk. He could identify 
some of those stars, and knew which systems were controlled by Omnius and which were League worlds,. 
"I will also learn how to fight the thinking machines," he said. Emil Tantor squeezed his shoulder. "I will 
defeat them one day." 
It is my purpose in life. 
ON A DARK night in the bright snowfield and dark pines, the Caladan primitives sat on furs around a 
roaring fire. Keeping their oral tradition alive, they repeated the ancient legends and stories of recent 
battles. The elder Tiddoc sat beside the foreigner accepted among them, a hero with bright eyes and waxy, 
horribly scarred skin. A man who had fought single-handedly against a cymek monster and fallen into a 
scalding hot opening . . . but had crawled out alive, clinging to the battered cymek walker-form. Piers 
gestured with one hand; the other-burned and twisted into uselessness-hung limp against his chest. He 
spoke passionately in the ancient Buddislamic tongue, halting as he struggled for words and then 
continuing when Tiddoc helped him. 
Caladan was his home now, and he would live the rest of his life with these people, in obscurity. No 
escape seemed possible from such a remote place, except through the stories he told. Piers kept his audi-
ence enthralled as he spoke of great battles against the thinking machines, while he also learned the Songs 
of the Long Trek, chronicles of the many generations of Zensunni Wanderings. 
As his father had realized, Piers Harkonnen had always wanted to be a storyteller. 
WHIPPING MEK A Tale of the Butlerian Jihad 
When the armored Jihad warship arrived, the population of 
Giedi Prime expected news of a great victory against the evil 
thinking machines. But with only a glance at the battle-scarred vessel, 
young Vergyl Tantor could tell that the defense of Peridot Colony had 
not gone at all as planned. 
On the crowded fringe of Giedi City Spaceport, Vergyl rushed forward, pressing against the soldiers stuck 
there like himself: wide-eyed green recruits or veterans too old to be sent into battle against Omnius's 
combat robots. His heart hammered like an industrial piston in his chest. 
He prayed that his adoptive brother, Xavier Harkonnen, was all right. 
The damaged battleship heaved itself into the docking circle like a 
dying sea beast beached on a reef. The big engines hissed and groaned as they cooled from the hot descent 
through the atmosphere. 
Vergyl stared at the blackened scars on the hull plates and tried to imagine the kinetic weapons and high-
energy projectiles that combat robots had hurled at the brave jihadi defenders. 
If only he had been out there himself, Vergyl could have helped in the fight. But Xavier-the commander 
of the battle group-always seemed to fight against his brother's eagerness with nearly as much per-
sistence as he fought the machine enemy. 
When the landing systems finished locking down, dozens of egress hatches opened on the lower hull. 
Middle-ranking commanders emerged, bellowing for assistance. All medically qualified personnel were 
called in from the city; others were shuttled from across the continents of Giedi Prime to help the 
wounded soldiers and rescued colonists. 
Triage and assessment stations were set up on the spaceport grounds. Official military personnel were 
tended first, since they had pledged their lives to fight in the great struggle ignited by Serena Butler. Their 
crimson-and-green uniforms were stained and badly patched; they'd obviously had no chance to repair 
them during the many weeks of transit from Peridot Colony. Mercenary soldiers received second-priority 
treatment, along with the refugees from the colony. 
Vergyl rushed in with the other ground-based soldiers to help, his large brown eyes flicking back and forth 
in search of answers. He needed to find someone who could tell him what had happened to Segundo 
Harkonnen. Worry scratched at Vergyl's mind while he worked. Perhaps everything was all right.. . but 



what if his big brother had been killed in a heroic rally? Or what if Xavier was injured, yet remained 
aboard the battered ship, refusing to accept help for himself until all of his personnel were tended to? 
Either scenario would have fit Xavier's personality. 
For hours, Vergyl refused to slow down, unable to fully grasp what these jihadi fighters had been through. 
Sweating and exhausted, he 
worked himself into a trancelike stupor, following orders, helping the wounded, burned, and despairing 
refugees. 
He heard muttered conversations that told of the onslaught that had wiped out the small colony. When the 
thinking machines had attempted to absorb the settlement into the Synchronized Worlds, the Army of the 
Jihad had sent its defenders there.                           , 
Peridot Colony had been but a skirmish, however, like so many others in the dozen years since Serena 
Butler had originally rallied all humans to fight in her cause, after the thinking machines had murdered her 
young son, Manion. Xavier's son. 
The ebb and flow of the Jihad had caused a great deal of damage to both sides, but neither fighting force 
had gained a clear upper hand. And though the thinking machines continued to build fresh combat robots, 
lost human lives could never be replaced. Serena gave passionate speeches to recruit new soldiers for her 
holy war. So many fighters had died that the Jihad no longer publicly revealed the cost. The struggle was 
everything. 
Following the Honru Massacre seven years earlier, Vergyl had insisted on joining the Jihad military force 
himself. He considered it his duty as a human being, even without his connection to Xavier and the 
martyred child, Manion. At their estate on Salusa Secundus, his parents had tried to make the young man 
wait, since he was barely seventeen, but Vergyl would hear none of it. 
Returning to Salusa after a difficult skirmish, Xavier had surprised their parents by offering a waiver that 
would allow underage Vergyl to begin training in the Army. The young man had leaped at the oppor-
tunity, not guessing that Xavier had his own plans. Overprotective, Segundo Harkonnen had seen to it that 
Vergyl received a safe, quiet assignment, stationed here on Giedi Prime where he could help with the 
rebuilding work-and where he would stay safe, far from any pitched battles against the robotic enemy. 
Now Vergyl had been in Giedi City for years, rising minimally in rank to second decero in the 
Construction Brigade . . . never seeing 
any action. Meanwhile, Xavier Harkonnen's battleships went to planet after planet, protecting free 
humanity and destroying the mechanized legions of the computer evermind Omnius. . . . 
Vergyl stopped counting all the bodies he'd moved. Perspiring in his dark green uniform, the young 
construction officer and a civilian man carried a makeshift stretcher, hauling a wounded mother who had 
been rescued from her devastated prefab home on Peridot Colony. Women and children from Giedi City 
hurried among the workers and wounded, offering water and food. 
Finally, in the warm afternoon, a ragged cheer penetrated Vergyl's dazed focus, just as he set the stretcher 
down in the midst of a triage unit. Looking up, he drew a quick breath. At the warship's main entrance 
ramp, a proud military commander stepped forward into the sunshine of Giedi Prime. 
Segundo Xavier Harkonnen wore a clean uniform with immaculate golden insignia. By careful design, he 
cut a dashing military figure, one that would inspire confidence and faith among his own troops as well as 
the civilians of Giedi City. Fear was the worst enemy the machines could bring against them. Xavier never 
offered any observer reason for uncertainty: Yes, brave humanity would eventually win this war. 
Grinning, Vergyl let out a sigh as all his doubts evaporated. Of course Xavier had survived. This great 
man had led the strike force that liberated Giedi Prime from the enslavement of cymeks and thinking 
machines. Xavier had commanded the human forces in the atomic purification of Earth, the first great 
battle of Serena Butler's Jihad. 
And the heroic officer would never stop until the thinking machines were defeated. 
But as Vergyl watched his brother walk down the ramp, he noticed that his footsteps had a heavy, weary 
quality, and his familiar face looked shell-shocked. Not even a hint of a smile there, no gleam in his gray 
eyes. Just flat stoniness. How had the man gotten so old? Vergyl idolized him, needed to speak with him 
alone as a brother, so that he could learn the real story. 



But in public, Segundo Harkonnen would never let anyone see his inner feelings. He was too good a 
leader for that. 
Vergyl pushed his way through the throng, shouting and waving with the others, and finally Xavier 
recognized him in the sea of faces. His expression lit with joy, then crashed, as if weighed down by the 
burden of war memories and realizations. Vergyl and his fellow relief workers hurried up the ramp to 
surround the brave officer, and escorted him into the safety of Giedi City. 
ALONG WITH HIS surviving sub-commanders, Xavier Harkonnen spent hours dispensing reports and 
debriefing League officials, but he insisted on breaking away from these painful duties to spend a few 
hours with his brother. 
He arrived at Vergyl's small home unrested, eyes bloodshot and haunted. When the two of them hugged, 
Xavier remained stiff for a moment before weakening and returning his dark-skinned brother's embrace. 
Despite the physical dissimilarities that marked their separate racial heritage, they knew that the bonds of 
love had nothing to do with bloodlines and everything to do with the loving family experiences they had 
shared in the household of Emil and Lucille Tantor. Taking him inside, Vergyl could sense the tremors 
Xavier was suppressing. He distracted Xavier by introducing him to his wife of two years, whom Xavier 
had never met. 
Sheel was a young, dark-haired beauty not accustomed to receiving guests of such importance. She had 
not even traveled to Salusa Secundus to meet Vergyl's parents or to see the Tantor family estate. But she 
treated Xavier as her husband's welcome brother, instead of as a celebrity. 
One of Aurelius Venport's merchant ships had arrived only a week before, carrying melange from Arrakis. 
Sheel had gone out this afternoon and spent a week's pay to get enough of the expensive spice to add to 
the fine, special dinner she prepared. 
As they ate, their conversation remained subdued and casual, avoiding any mention of war news. Weary to 
the bone, Xavier barely seemed to notice the flavors of the meal, even the exotic melange. Sheel seemed 
disappointed, until Vergyl explained in a whisper that his brother had lost much of his sense of taste and 
smell during a cymek gas attack, which had also cost him his lungs. Although Xavier now breathed 
through a set of replacement organs provided by a Tlulaxa flesh merchant, his ability to taste or smell 
remained dulled. 
Finally, as they drank spice-laced coffee, Vergyl could no longer withhold his questions. "Xavier, please 
tell me what happened at Peridot Colony. Was it a victory, or did the"-his voice caught-"did the 
machines defeat us?" 
Xavier lifted his head, and gazed far away. "Grand Patriarch Iblis Ginjo says that there are no defeats. 
Only victories and . . . moral victories. This one fell into the latter category." 
Sheel squeezed her husband's arm sharply, a wordless request that he withdraw the question. But Vergyl 
didn't interrupt, and Xavier continued, "Peridot Colony had been under attack for a week before our 
nearest battle group received the emergency distress call. Settlers were being obliterated. The thinking 
machines meant to crush the colony and establish a Synchronized World there, laying down their infra-
structure and installing a new copy of the Omnius evermind." 
Xavier sipped spice coffee while Vergyl put his elbows on the table, leaning close to listen with rapt 
attention. 
"The Army of the Jihad had little presence in this area aside from my warship and a handful of troops. We 
had no choice but to respond, not wishing to lose another planet. I had a full shipload of mercenaries 
anyway." 
"Any from Ginaz? Our best fighters?" 
"Some. We arrived faster than the thinking machines expected, struck them swiftly and mercilessly, using 
everything we had. My soldiers attacked like madmen, and many of them fell. But a lot more thinking 
machines were destroyed. Unfortunately, most of the colony 
towns had already been trampled by the time we got there, the inhabitants murdered. Even so, our Army 
of the Jihad drove in-and by a holy miracle we pushed back the enemy forces." He drew a deep, con-
vulsing breath, as if his replacement lungs were malfunctioning. 
"Instead of simply cutting their losses and flying away, as combat robots usually do, this time they were 



programmed to follow a scorched-earth policy. They devastated everything in their wake. Where they had 
gone, not a crop, structure, or human survivor was left behind." 
Sheel swallowed hard. "How terrible." 
"Terrible?"  Xavier mused, rolling the sound of the word on his tongue. "I cannot begin to describe what I 
saw. Not much was left of the colony we went to rescue. Over a quarter of my jihadis lost their lives, and 
half of the mercenaries." 
Shaking his head sadly, he continued. "We scraped together the pathetic remnants of settlers who had fled 
far enough from the primary machine forces. I do not know-nor do I want to know-the actual number 
of survivors we rescued. Peridot Colony did not fall to the machines, but that world is no longer of any use 
to humans, either." He heaved a deep breath. "It seems to be the way of this Jihad." 
"That is why we need to keep fighting." Vergyl lifted his chin. His bravery sounded tinny in his own ears. 
"Let me fight at your side against Omnius! Our army is in constant need of soldiers. It's time for me to get 
into the real battles in this war!" 
Now Xavier Harkonnen seemed to awaken. Dismay flashed across his face. "You don't want that, Vergyl. 
Not ever." 
VERGYL SECURED AN assignment working aboard the Jihad warship as it underwent repairs for the 
better part of two weeks. If he couldn't fly off and fight on alien battlefields, at least he could be here 
recharging weapons, replacing damaged Holtzman shield systems, and strengthening armor plating. 
While Vergyl diligently performed every task the team supervisors assigned to him, his eyes drank in 
details about how the ship's systems functioned. Someday, if Xavier ever relented and allowed him to par-
ticipate in the Holy Jihad, Vergyl wanted to command one of these vessels. He was an adult-twenty-
three years old-but his influential brother had the power to interfere with anything Vergyl tried to do ... 
and had already done so. 
That afternoon, as he checked off the progress of repairs on his display pad, Vergyl came upon one of the 
battleship's training chambers. The dull metal door stood half open, and he heard a clattering and clanging 
of metal, and the grunting sounds of someone straining with great effort. 
Rushing into the chamber, Vergyl stopped and stared in astonishment. A battle-scarred man-a 
mercenary, judging from his longhaired, disheveled appearance-threw himself in violent combat against 
a fighting robot. The machine had three sets of articulated arms, each one holding a deadly-looking 
weapon. Moving in a graceful blur, the mechanical unit struck blow after blow against the man, who 
defended himself perfectly each time. 
Vergyl's heart leaped. How had one of the enemy machines gotten on board Xavier's battleship? Had 
Omnius sent it as a spy or saboteur? Were there others spread out around the ship? The beleaguered 
mercenary landed a blow with his vibrating pulse sword, causing one of the mek's six arms to drop limply 
to its side. 
Letting out a war cry, knowing he had to help, Vergyl snatched the only weapon he could find-a training 
staff from a rack by the wall and charged forward recklessly. 
The mercenary reacted quickly upon hearing Vergyl's approach. He raised a hand. "Hold, Chirox!" 
The combat mek froze. The mercenary, panting, dropped his light ing stance. Vergyl skidded to a halt, 
looking in confusion from the enemy robot to the well-muscled fighter. 
"Don't alarm yourself," the mercenary said. "I was simply practieing." 
"With a machine?" 
The long-haired man smiled. A spiderweb of pale scars covered his cheeks, neck, bare shoulders, and 
chest. "Thinking machines are our enemies in this Jihad, young officer. If we must develop our skills 
against them, who better to fight?" 
Awkwardly, Vergyl set his hastily grabbed staff on the deck. His face flushed hot with embarassment. 
"That makes sense." 
"Chirox is just a surrogate enemy, a target to fight. He represents all thinking machines in my mind." 
"Like a whipping boy." 
"A whipping mek." The mercenary smiled. "We can set it to various fighting levels for training purposes." 
He stepped closer to the ominous-looking combat robot. "Stand down." 



The robot lowered its weapons-studded limbs, then retracted them into its core, even the impaired arm, 
and stood waiting for further commands. With a sneer, the man slammed the hilt of his pulse sword 
against the mek's chest, knocking the machine backward a step. The optic-sensor eyes flickered orange. 
The rest of the machine's face, with its crudely shaped mouth and nose, did not move. 
Confidently, the man tapped the metallic torso. "This limited robot-I dislike the term thinking machine-
is totally under our control. It has served the mercenaries of Ginaz for nearly three generations now." He 
deactivated his pulse sword, which was designed to scramble sophisticated gelcircuitry. "I am Zon Noret, 
one of the fighters assigned to this ship." 
Intrigued, Vergyl ventured closer. "Where did you find this machine?" 
"A century ago, a Ginaz salvage scout came upon a damaged thinking machine ship, from which he 
retrieved this broken combat robot. Since then, we've wiped its memories and reinstalled combat program-
ming. It allows us to test ourselves against machine capabilities." 
Noret patted the robot on one of its ribbed metal shoulders. "Many robots in the Synchronized Worlds 
have been destroyed because of 
what we learned from this unit. Chirox is an invaluable teacher. On the archipelago of Ginaz, students pit 
their skills against him. He has proved to be such a repository of information to utilize against our enemy 
that we mercenaries no longer think of him as a thinking machine, but as an ally." 
"A robot as an ally? Serena Butler wouldn't like to hear that," Vergyl said guardedly. 
Zon Noret tossed his thick hair behind his head like the mane of a comet. "Many things are done in this 
Jihad without Serena Butler knowing. I wouldn't be surprised to learn of other meks like this one under 
our control." He made a dismissive gesture. "But since we all have the same goal, the details become 
insignificant." 
To Vergyl, some of Noret's wounds looked only freshly healed. "Shouldn't you be recuperating from the 
battle, instead of fighting even more?" 
"A true mercenary never stops fighting." His eyes narrowed. "I see you're an officer yourself." 
Vergyl let out a frustrated sigh. "In the Construction Brigade. It's not what I wanted. I'd rather be fighting, 
but. . . it's a long story." 
Noret wiped sweat from his brow. "Your name?" 
"Second Decero Tantor." 
With no flicker of recognition at the name, Noret looked at the combat mek and then at the young officer. 
"Perhaps we can arrange a little taste of battle for you anyway." 
"You would let me . . . ?" Vergyl felt his pulse quicken. 
Zon Noret nodded. "If a man wants to fight, he should be allowed to do so." 
Vergyl lifted his chin. "I couldn't agree more." 
"I warn you, this may be a training mek, but it is lethal. I often disconnect its safety protocol during my 
rigorous practices. That is why Ginaz mercenaries are so good." 
"Still, there must be fail-safes, or it wouldn't be much good as an instructor." 
"Training that entails no risk is not realistic. It makes the student soft, knowing he is in no danger. Chirox 
is not like that, by design. He could kill you." 
Vergyl felt a rush of bravado, hoped he wasn't being foolish. "I can handle myself. I've gone through Jihad 
training of my own." But he wanted a chance to prove himself, and this combat robot might be as close to 
the fight as he ever got. Vergyl focused his hatred on Chirox, for all the horrors the fighting machines had 
inflicted upon humanity, and wanted to smash the mek into scrap metal. "Let me fight it, just as you were 
doing." 
The mercenary raised his eyebrows, as if amused and interested. "Your choice of weapons, young 
warrior?" 
Vergyl fumbled, looked at the clumsy training staff he had grabbed. "I didn't bring anything but this." 
Noret held his pulse sword up for the younger man to examine. "Do you know how to operate one of 
these?" 
"That looks like one we used in basic training, but a newer model." 
"Correct." Noret activated the weapon and handed it to the young man. 



Vergyl hefted the sword to check its balance. Shimmering arcs of disruptive energy ran along the surface 
of its blade. 
He took a deep breath and studied the combat mek, who stared back at him dispassionately, its eyelike 
optic threads glowing orange . . . waiting. The sensors shifted direction, watched Noret approach, and 
prepared for another opponent. 
When the mercenary activated the mek, only two of the six mechanical arms emerged from the torso. One 
metal hand clasped a dagger, while the other was empty. 
"It's going to fight me at a low difficulty setting," Vergyl complained. 
"Perhaps Chirox just wants to test you. In actual combat, your adversary will never provide a resume of 
his skills beforehand." 
Vergyl moved carefully toward the mek, then shifted to his left and circled, holding the pulse sword. He 
felt moisture on his palm, loosened his grip a bit. The mek kept turning to face him. Its dagger hand 
twitched, and Vergyl jabbed at the robot's weapon with the electronic sword, hitting it with a purple pulse 
that caused the robot to shudder. 
"Looks like a dumb machine to me." He had imagined combat like this. Vergyl darted toward his 
opponent and struck the torso with the pulse sword, leaving a purple discoloration on the metal body. He 
tapped a blue button on the weapon's handle until it reached the highest pulse setting. 
"Go for the head," Noret counseled. "Scramble the robot's circuits to slow him. If you strike Chirox just 
right, he will need a minute or two to reconfigure." 
Again Vergyl struck, but missed the head, sliding down to the armored shoulder. Multicolored sparks 
covered the mek's outer surface, and the dagger dropped from its mechanical grip to clatter on the floor of 
the training chamber. A wisp of smoke rose from the robot's hand. 
Excited, Vergyl moved in for the kill. He didn't care if anyone needed this fighting unit for training. He 
wanted to destroy it, to burn it into molten remains. He thought of Serena, of little Manion, of all the 
slaughtered humans . . . and of his own inability to fight for the Jihad. This scapegoat mek would have to 
do for now. 
But as he stepped forward, suddenly the flowmetal of the robot's free hand shifted, reshaping itself and 
extruding a short sword with barbs on the blade. The other hand stopped sparking, and a matching weapon 
also formed there. 
"Careful, young warrior. We wouldn't want the Army to lose your construction skills." 
Feeling a surge of anger at the remark, Vergyl snapped, "I'm not afraid of this machine." 
"Fear is not always unwise." 
"Even against a stupid opponent? Chirox doesn't even know I'm ridiculing him, does he?" 
"I am just a machine," the mek recited, its synthesized voice coming 
from a speaker patch. Vergyl was taken aback, thinking he had caught just a hint of sarcasm in the robot's 
voice. Like a theatrical mask, its face did not change its expression. 
"Chirox doesn't usually say much," Noret said, smiling. "Go ahead, pound him some more. But even I 
don't know all the surprises he might have in store." 
Vergyl moved back to reassess his opponent. He studied the robot's bright optic threads as they focused on 
the pulse weapon. 
Abruptly, Chirox lunged with the barbed short sword, exhibiting unexpected speed and agility. Vergyl 
tried to dodge the blow, but did not move quickly enough, and a shallow gash opened on one of his arms. 
He went into a floor roll to escape, then glanced at the wound as he leaped back to his feet. 
"Not a bad move," Noret said, his tone casual, as if he didn't care whether the robot killed Vergyl. Killing 
was both sport and profession to him. Maybe it took a harsh mindset to be a mercenary for Ginaz, but 
Vergyl-endowed with no such harshness-worried that he had gotten into this situation on impulse and 
might be facing a challenge more difficult than he was ready for. The combat mek kept advancing with 
jerking, unpredictable speeds, sometimes lunging with an astonishing fluidity of motion. 
Vergyl darted from side to side, striking repeated blows with the pulse sword. He executed proficient rolls 
and considered attempting a showy backflip, but didn't know if he could pull it off. Failure to properly 
execute a move could prove fatal. 



One of his pulse blows struck the panel box on Chirox's side, making it glow red. The robot paused. A 
thin, agile arm emerged from the robot's torso and adjusted something inside. 
"It can repair itself?" 
"Most combat meks can. You wanted a fair shot at a real machine opponent, didn't you? I warned you 
about this robot." 
Suddenly Chirox came at Vergyl harder and faster than before. Two more arms extruded from the body 
core. One held a long dagger with a 
jagged tip for snagging and ripping flesh. The other held a shimmering branding iron. 
Zon Noret said something in an anxious tone, but the words blurred. The entire universe that Vergyl had 
known up to this point faded, along with all unnecessary sensory perception. He focused only on survival. 
"I am a jihadi," Vergyl whispered. He resigned himself to fate and at the same time decided to inflict as 
much damage as he could. He recalled a pledge that even the Construction Brigade had to memorize: "If I 
die in battle against the machines, I will join those who have gone to Paradise before me, and those who 
follow." He felt a near-trancelike state consume him and remove all fear of death. 
He plunged into battle, flailing away, striking the pulse sword against the mek, discharging the weapon 
repeatedly. In the background, someone shouted words he couldn't make out. Then Vergyl heard a loud 
click, saw a flash of color, and bright yellow light immersed him. It felt like a blast from a polar wind and 
froze him in place. 
Immobilized, helpless, Vergyl shuddered, then toppled. He fell for what seemed like a great distance. His 
teeth chattered, and he shivered. He didn't seem to land anywhere. 
Finally he found himself looking up into the robot's gleaming optic sensors. Totally vulnerable. 
"I can kill you now." The machine pressed the jagged tip of the long dagger against Vergyl's neck. 
The combat mek could thrust the blade through his throat in a microsecond. Vergyl heard shouts, but 
could not squirm away. He stared up into the implacable optical sensors of the robot, the face of the hated 
machine enemy. The thinking machine was going to kill him- and this wasn't even a real battle. What a 
fool he had been. 
Somewhere in the distance, familiar voices-two of them?-called out to him. "Vergyl! Vergyl! Shut the 
damn thing off, Noret!" 
He tried to lift his head and look around, but could not move. Chirox continued to press the sharp point 
against his jugular vein. His muscles were paralyzed, as if frozen inside a block of ice. 
"Get me a disruptor gun!" He recognized the voice at last. Xavier. Somehow, incongruously, Vergyl 
worried more about his brother's disapproval than dying. 
But then the mek straightened and removed the dagger blade from his throat. 
He heard more voices, the thumping of boots, and the clattering of weaponry. Peripherally, Vergyl saw 
movement, and crimson-and-green jihadi uniforms. Xavier shouted commands to his men, but Chirox re-
tracted the jagged dagger, his other weapons, and all four arms into his torso. The fiercely glowing optic 
threads dulled to a soft glimmer. 
Zon Noret placed himself in front of the robot. "Don't shoot, Segundo. Chirox could have killed him, but 
didn't. He is programmed to take advantage of a weakness and deliver a mortal blow, yet he made a 
conscious decision against it." 
"I did not wish to kill him." The combat robot reset itself to a stationary position. "It was not necessary." 
Vergyl finally cleared his head enough to push himself into a stiff sitting position. "That mek actually 
showed . . . compassion?" He still felt dazed from the mysterious stun blast. "Imagine that, a machine with 
feelings." 
"It wasn't compassion at all," Xavier said, with a contentious scowl. He reached down to help his brother 
to his feet. 
"It was the strangest thing," Vergyl insisted. "Did you see the gentleness in his eyes?" 
Zon Noret, intent on his training mek, looked into the machine's panel box, studied instrument readings, 
and made adjustments. "Chirox simply assessed the situation and went into survival mode. But there must 
have been something buried in his original programming." 
"Machines don't care about survival," Xavier snapped. "You saw them at Peridot Colony. They hurl 



themselves into battle without concern for personal safety." He shook his head. "There's something wrong 
with your mek's programming, a glitch." 
Vergyl stared over at Chirox, caught the gaze of the glowing optic 
threads. In the depths of the lights, the young construction officer thought he detected a flicker of 
something animate, which intrigued and frightened him at the same time. 
"Humans can learn compassion, too," Chirox said, unexpectedly. 
"I'll run him through a complete overhaul," Noret said, but his voice was uncertain. 
Xavier stood in front of Vergyl, checking him for serious injuries. Then he spoke in a shaky voice as he 
led his brother out of the training chamber. "That was quite a scare you gave me." 
"I just wanted to fight a real enemy for once." 
Xavier looked deeply saddened. "Vergyl, I fear that you will have your chance, eventually. This Jihad will 
not be over anytime soon." 
THE FACES OF A MARTYR A Tale of the Butlerian Jihad 
I'm sorry," Rekur Van said to his fellow Tlulaxa researcher as he 
slipped the knife deftly through the victim's spine, then added an extra twist. "I need this ship more than 
you do." 
Blood seeped around the slender steel blade, then spilled in a final dying gush as Van yanked the knife 
back out. His comrade jittered and twitched as nerve endings attempted to fire. Van tumbled him out the 
hatch of the small vessel, discarding him onto the pavement of the spaceport. 
Explosions, shouts, and weapons fire rang through the streets of the main Tlulaxa city. The fatally 
wounded genetic scientist sprawled on the ground, still shuddering, his close-set eyes dimming as they 
blinked accusations at Rekur Van. Discarded, like so many other vital things ... 
He wiped the blood on his garments, but his hands remained sticky. He would have time to launder the 
clothes and clean his skin, once he escaped. Blood ... it was the currency of his trade, a genetic resource 
filled with useful DNA. He hated to waste so much of it. 
But now the League of Nobles wanted blood. His blood. 
Though he was one of the most brilliant Tlulaxa scientists and well connected with powerful religious 
leaders, Van had to flee his home-world to escape the lynch mobs. Outraged members of the League 
blockaded the planet and swept in to extract their justice. If they caught him, he could not begin to 
imagine the retribution they would inflict upon him. "Fanatics-all of you!" he shouted uselessly toward 
the city, then sealed the hatch. 
With no time to retrieve his priceless research documents and forced to leave his personal wealth behind, 
Van used his bloodstained hands to operate the stolen ship's controls. Without a plan, wanting only to get 
off the planet before the vengeful League soldiers could seize him, he launched his vessel into the sky. 
"Damn you, Iblis Ginjo!" he said to himself. It gave him very little consolation to know that the Grand 
Patriarch was already dead. 
Ginjo had always treated him as a lower form of life. Van and the Grand Patriarch had been business 
associates who depended on each other but shared no feelings of trust. In the end, the League had dis-
covered the horrific secret of the Tlulaxa organ farms: missing soldiers and Zensunni slaves were cut up to 
provide replacement parts for other wounded fighters. Now the tables had turned. All of the Tlulaxa were 
in turmoil, scrambling for their lives to escape the League's indignant vengeance. Flesh merchants had to 
go into hiding, and legitimate traders were run off of civilized worlds. Disgraced and ruined, Van was now 
a hunted man. 
But even without his laboratory records, his mind still carried vital knowledge to be shared with the 
highest bidder. And sealed in a pocket he took with him a small vial of special genetic material that would 
allow him to start over again. If he could only get away . . . 
Reaching orbit in his stolen ship, Van saw powerful javelin battleships manned by angry jihadis. 
Numerous Tlulaxa vessels-most of them flown by inexperienced and panicked pilots such as himself- 
streaked away in a pell-mell fashion, and the League warships targeted all Tlulaxa craft that came within 
range. 
"Why not just assume we're all guilty?" he snarled at the images, knowing no one could hear him. 



Van increased acceleration, not knowing how fast the unfamiliar ship could go. With the end of his sleeve, 
he wiped away a blot of drying blood on the control panel so he could read the instruments better. The 
League javelins took potshots at him, and an angry voice over the commline. 
"Tlulaxa craft! Stand down-surrender or be destroyed." 
"Why not use your weapons against the thinking machines?" Van retorted. "The Army of the Jihad is 
wasting time and resources here. Or have you forgotten the real enemies of humanity?" Surely any sup-
posed Tlulaxa crimes were minimal compared to decades of devastation by the computer evermind 
Omnius. 
Apparently, the javelin commander did not appreciate his sarcasm. Exploding projectiles streaked silently 
past him, and Van reacted with a sudden lurch of deceleration; the artillery detonated some distance from 
its intended target, but the shockwave still put his stolen ship into a spin. Flashing lights and alarm signals 
lit the control panels in the cockpit, but Van did not send out a distress signal. Noiselessly, he tumbled out 
of control, playing dead-and the League ships soon left him to hunt other hapless Tlulaxa escapees. They 
had plenty of victims to choose from. 
When the League battleships were finally gone, Van felt he was safe enough to engage stabilizers. After 
several exaggerated attempts, he compensated for the out-of-control rolling and got his ship back on 
course. With no destination in mind, intent only on escaping, he flew out of the system as far and as fast as 
he could go. He did not regret what he was leaving behind. 
For most of his life, Van had worked to develop vital new biological techniques, as had generations of his 
people before him. During the Jihad, the Tlulaxa had made themselves fabulously wealthy, and presum-
ably indispensable. Now, though, Serena's fanatics would raze the original organ farms, destroying the 
transplant tanks, and "mercifully" putting the donors out of their misery. Short-sighted fools! How the 
League would complain in coming years when eyeless or limbless veterans wailed about their injuries and 
had nowhere else to go. 
The myopic League idealists didn't consider practical matters, didn't plan well at all. As with so many 
things in Serena Butler's Jihad, they chased unrealistic dreams, were driven by foolish emotions. Van 
hated those people. 
He grasped the ship's control bar as if to strangle it, pretending it was Iblis Ginjo's thick neck. Despite a 
full resume of despicable acts, the Grand Patriarch had succeeded in keeping his own name clean while 
shifting blame onto an old, hard-bitten war hero, Xavier Harkonnen, and the whole Tlulaxa race. Ginjo's 
ever-scheming widow falsely portrayed her fallen husband as a martyr. 
The League could steal the "honor" of the Tlulaxa people. Mobs could take their wealth and force his 
people to live as outlaws. But the betrayers could never take away Rekur Van's special knowledge and 
skills. This scapegoat was still able to fight back. 
Finally, Van made up his mind where he should go, where he should take his secret and innovative 
cloning technology, as well as viable cells from Serena Butler herself. 
He headed out past the boundaries of League space to find the machine worlds, where he intended to 
present himself to the evermind Omnius. 
ON   SALUSA   SECUNDUS,  capital of the League of Nobles, a screaming, unruly crowd set fire to the 
figure of a man. 
Stony silent, Vorian Atreides stood in the shadows of an ornate arch, watching the crowd. His throat was 
clenched so tightly that he could not shout his dismay. Though he was a champion of the Jihad, this wild 
throng would not listen to him. 
The effigy was a poor likeness of Xavier Harkonnen, but the mob's hatred for him was unmistakable. The 
mannequin dangled from a makeshift gibbet above a pile of dry sticks. A young man tossed in a small 
igniter, and within seconds outstretched flames began to consume the effigy's symbolic Army of the Jihad 
uniform-like the one Xavier had been so proud to wear. 
Vorian's friend had devoted most of his life to the war against the thinking machines. Now an irrational 
throng had found a uniform and used it to mock him, stripping it of all medals and insignia, in much the 
same way Xavier had been stripped of his rightful place in history. Now they were burning him. 
As the fire caught, the figure danced and smoldered on the end of its tether. Raucous cheering rattled the 



windows of nearby buildings, celebrating the death of a traitor. The people considered this an act of 
vengeance. Vor considered it an abomination. 
After Vor learned how brave Xavier had exposed the Tlulaxa organ farms and brought down the 
treacherous Grand Patriarch Ginjo, he had rushed to Salusa. He'd never expected to witness such an 
appalling and well-orchestrated backlash against his friend. For days Vor had continued to speak out, 
trying to stop the hysterical anger from striking the wrong target. Despite his high rank, few came to his 
support. The smear campaign against Xavier had begun, and history was being rewritten even while it was 
still news. Vor felt like a man standing on the beach in a Caladan hurricane, holding up his hands to ward 
off a tidal wave. 
Even Xavier's own daughters bowed to pressure and changed their names from Harkonnen to their 
mother's surname of Butler. Their mother Octa, always quiet and shy, had withdrawn in misery to the City 
of Introspection, refusing to see outsiders. . . . 
Wearing street clothes to conceal his identity, Vor stood among the crowd, unnoticed. Like Xavier, he was 
proud of his service in the Army of the Jihad, but in the mounting emotional fervor this was no time to 
appear in uniform. 
Over the course of the long Jihad, Primero Vorian Atreides had engaged in many battles against the 
thinking machines. He had fought at Xavier's side and achieved tremendous, but costly, victories. Xavier 
was the bravest man Vor had ever known, and now billions of people despised him. 
Unable to tolerate the spectacle any longer, Vor turned away from the throng. Such mass ignorance and 
stupidity! The ill-informed and easily manipulated multitude would believe whatever they chose to. 
Vorian Atreides alone would remember the brave truth about the Harkonnen name. 
THE INDEPENDENT ROBOT stepped back to admire the new sign mounted on his laboratory wall. 
Understanding Human Nature Is the Most Difficult of All Mental Exercises. 
While considering the implications of the statement, Erasmus shifted the expression on his flowmetal face. 
For centuries his quest had been to decipher these biological creatures: They had so many flaws, but 
somehow, in a spark of genius, they had created thinking machines. The puzzle intrigued him. 
He had mounted various slogans around his laboratory to initiate trains of thought at unexpected times. 
Philosophy was far more than a game to him; it was a means by which he improved his machine mind. 
It Is Possible to Achieve Whatever You Envision, Whether You Are Man or Machine. 
To facilitate his better understanding of the biological enemy, Erasmus performed constant experiments. 
Strapped onto tables, confined within transparent tanks, or sealed within airtight cells, the robot's 
current round of subjects moaned and writhed. Some prayed to invisible gods. Others screamed and 
begged for mercy from their captor, which showed just how delusional they were. A number bled, 
urinated, and leaked all manner of fluids, discourteously messing his laboratory. Fortunately, he had 
subservient robots as well as human slaves to restore the facility to an antiseptic and orderly state. 
Flesh Is Just Soft Metal. 
The robot had dissected thousands of human brains and bodies, in addition to conducting psychological 
experiments. He tested people with sensory deprivation, causing extreme pain and unrelenting fear. He 
studied the behavior of individuals as well as crowd activities. Yet through it all, despite his meticulous 
attention to detail, Erasmus knew he continued to miss something important. He could not find a way to 
assess and collate all the data so that it fit within a comprehensible framework, a "grand unified theory" of 
human nature. The behavioral extremes were too far separated. 
Is It More Human to Be Good? Or Evil? 
That sign, next to the new one, had posed a conundrum for some time. Many of the humans he had studied 
in detail, such as Serena Butler and his own ward Gilbertus Albans, demonstrated an innate human 
goodness filled with compassion and caring for other creatures. But Erasmus had studied history and knew 
about traitors and sociopaths who caused incredible damage and suffering in order to gain advantages for 
themselves. 
No set of conclusions made sense. 
After thirty-six years of Serena Butler's Jihad, the machines were far from victory, despite computer 
projections that said they should have crushed the feral humans long ago. Fanaticism kept the League of 



Nobles strong, and they continued to fight when any reasoned consideration should have led them to 
surrender. Their inspirational leader had been martyred ... by her own choice. An inexplicable act. 
Now, he finally had a fresh opportunity, an unexpected new subject that might shed light on hitherto 
unexplored aspects of humanity. Perhaps when he arrived, the Tlulaxa captive would provide some an-
swers. After all, the foolish man had fallen into their laps... 
Rekur Van had brashly flown into Synchronized space controlled by the thinking machines, and 
transmitted his demand to see Omnius. The Tlulaxa's bold arrival was either part of a complicated trick ... 
or he genuinely believed he had a worthwhile bargaining chip. Erasmus was curious as to which it was. 
Omnius wanted to destroy the Tlulaxa ship outright; most humans trespassing in Synchronized space were 
either killed or captured, but Erasmus intervened, eager to hear what the well-known genetics researcher 
had to say. 
After surrounding the small vessel, robotic warships escorted it to Corrin, center of the Synchronized 
Worlds. Without delay, armored sentinel robots marched the captive directly into Erasmus's laboratory. 
Rekur Van's angular gray-skinned face was pinched into a scowl that flickered between haughtiness and 
fear. His dark, close-set eyes blinked rapidly. He wore a braid down to his shoulder and tried to look 
confident and nonplused, but failed completely. 
Facing him, the autonomous robot preened in his plush, regal robe, which he wore to make himself 
impressive in the eyes of his human slaves and test subjects. He fashioned a nonthreatening smile on his 
flowmetal face, then glowered, trying out another expression. "When you were captured, you demanded to 
see Omnius. It is strange for the great computer evermind to receive commands from such a diminutive 
human-a man both small in stature and in importance." 
Van lifted his chin and sniffed haughtily. "You underestimate me." Reaching into the folds of his stained 
and rumpled tunic, the Tlulaxa withdrew a small vial. "I have brought you something precious. These are 
samples of vital cells, the raw materials of my genetic research." 
"I have done a great deal of my own research," Erasmus said. "And I have many samples to draw from. 
Why should yours interest me?" 
"Because these are original cells from Serena Butler herself. And you have no technology or techniques to 
grow an accelerated clone of her, 
as I do. I can create a perfect duplicate of the leader of the Jihad against thinking machines-I'm sure you 
can think of a use for that." 
Erasmus was indeed impressed. "Serena Butler? You can re-create her?" 
"Down to her exact DNA, and I can accelerate her maturity to whatever point you wish. But I have planted 
certain . . . inhibitors . . . in these cells. Little locks that only I can open." He continued to hold the vial 
tantalizingly in the laboratory's light, where Erasmus could see it. "Just imagine how valuable such a pawn 
could be in your war against humans." 
"And why would you offer us such a treasure?" 
"Because I hate the League of Nobles. They turned against my people, are hunting us down at every turn. 
If the thinking machines grant me sanctuary, I will reward you with a brand-new Serena Butler, to do with 
as you wish." 
Possibilities flooded Erasmus's mental core. Serena had been his most fascinating human subject ever, but 
his experiments and tests on her had come to a grinding halt once he'd killed her unruly baby. After that, 
she was no longer cooperative. For decades, the robot had wished for a second opportunity with her-and 
now he could have it. 
He imagined the dialogues they might have, the exchanges of ideas, the answers to all his pressing 
questions. He studied another slogan on the wall. If I Can Think of the Ultimate Question, Will It Have an 
Answer? 
Fascinated, Eramus clasped Van's shoulder, causing the Tlulaxa to grimace in pain. "I agree to your 
terms." 
THE GRAND PATRIARCH'S widow sent him a formal invitation, and Vorian Atreides knew it was not an idle 
request. 
The message was delivered by a captain of the Jihad Police, which in itself carried an implied threat. But 



Vor chose not to be intimidated. He donned many of the medals, ribbons, and decorations he'd been 
awarded over the course of his long and illustrious career. Although he'd grown up among thinking 
machines as a trustee, Vor had later become a Hero of the Jihad. He didn't want Iblis Ginjo's pretentious 
wife to forget for one second who she was dealing with. 
Camie Boro-Ginjo had married Ginjo for the prestige his name offered, but it had been a loveless union 
between loveless people. Camie had every intention of turning her husband's spectacular death to her own 
political gain. Now, inside the same offices where the Grand Patriarch had formulated so many of his 
nefarious schemes, she sat beside the bald, olive-skinned Jipol commandant, Yorek Thurr. Vor steeled 
himself for whatever this dangerous pair might be planning. 
Smiling prettily, Camie directed Vor's attention to a model on a display platform, a small-scale rendition 
of a grandiose monument. "This will be our shrine to the Three Martyrs. Anyone who glimpses it cannot 
help but be filled with fervor for the Jihad." 
Vor eyed the arches, the huge braziers to carry eternal flames, and the three colossal figures inside, 
stylized representations of a man, woman, and child. "Three Martyrs?" 
"Serena Butler and her child, murdered by the thinking machines, and my husband Iblis Ginjo, slain by the 
treachery of humans." 
Vor could barely suppress his anger. He turned to leave. "I will have no part in this." 
"Primero, please hear us out." Camie raised her hands in a placating gesture. "We must address the 
extreme turmoil in the League, the horrible murder of Serena Butler by the thinking machines, and the 
tragic death of my husband due to the plot hatched by Xavier Harkonnen and his Tlulaxa cohorts." 
"There are no facts to prove Xavier's culpability," Vor said, his voice brittle. Camie had been primarily 
responsible for the blame-shifting and mudslinging. He was not afraid of her, or of her henchman. "Your 
assumptions are false, and you have stopped looking for the truth." 
"It has been proven to my satisfaction." 
Thurr rose to his feet. Though shorter in stature than Camie, he 
had the coiled strength of a cobra. "More to the point, Primero, it has been proven to the satisfaction of the 
League citizens. They need their heroes and martyrs." 
"Apparently they need their villains as well. And, if you cannot find the correct culprit, you create one-as 
you did with Xavier." 
Thurr meshed his fingers together. "We don't wish to engage in an acrimonious debate, Primero. You are a 
great military strategist, and we owe many of our victories to you." 
"And to Xavier," Vor said. 
The Jipol commandant continued without responding to the comment. "We three important leaders must 
work together to accomplish important goals. None of us can be mired down by bruised feelings and 
traditional grieving. We must keep the populace focused on winning our Holy Jihad and cannot afford 
arguments that divert us from the real enemy. You persist in raising questions about what happened be-
tween Xavier Harkonnen and the Grand Patriarch, but you do not realize the damage you're doing." 
"The truth is the truth." 
"The truth is relative, and must be taken in the context of our larger struggle. Even Serena and Xavier 
would agree that unpleasant sacrifices are warranted if they help to achieve the goals of the Jihad. You 
must stop this personal crusade, Primero. Stop casting doubts. You only harm our cause if you don't keep 
your feelings to yourself." 
Though Thurr's words were spoken calmly, Vor read the implied threat in them and suppressed a fleeting 
urge to strike the man; this Jipol commandant had no comprehension of honor or truth. No doubt, Thurr 
had the power to see that the Primero was quietly assassinated . . . and Vor knew he would do it if he 
considered it necessary. 
Still, the Jipol commandant had struck a solid blow, reminding him of his friends' intentional sacrifices. If 
Vor destroyed the public confidence in the Jihad Council and the League government as a whole, the 
political repercussions and social turmoil could be considerable. Scandals, resignations, and the general 
uproar would severely weaken the 
solidarity the human race needed in order to face the thinking machines. 



Omnius was the only enemy that mattered. 
Vor crossed his arms over his heavily medaled and ribboned chest. "For now, I will keep my opinions to 
myself," he said. "But I don't do it for you and your power plays. I'm doing it for Serena's Jihad, and for 
Xavier." 
"Just so long as you do it," Camie said. 
Vor turned to leave, but paused at the door. "I don't want to be anywhere around when you unveil your 
Three Martyrs farce, so I'm heading for the front lines." Shaking his head, he hurried away. "Battles I can 
understand." 
ON THE MAIN machine world of Corrin, years passed, and a female child grew rapidly into adulthood, her 
cloned life accelerated by Rekur Van. Erasmus regularly visited his laboratories full of moaning experi-
mental subjects, where his new Serena Butler was taking shape nicely. 
Among the tormented human subjects, the Tlulaxa researcher seemed quite at home. Van was himself an 
interesting person, with opinions and attitudes dramatically different from those Erasmus had observed in 
the original Serena or in Gilbertus Albans. Even so, the intense scientist had an unusual perspective: 
entirely self-centered, twisted by irrational hatred and spite toward the feral humans. In addition, he was 
intelligent and well trained. A good mental sparring partner for Erasmus . . . but the robot pinned his hopes 
on the return of Serena. 
During her prolonged development, Van used advanced machine instructional technology to fill her head 
with misinformation, false memories mixed with details of the real Serena's life. Some of the data took 
hold; some of it needed to be implanted again and again. 
When he had the opportunity, the robot engaged his new Serena in 
tentative conversation, anxious for the forthcoming days when he could debate with her, provoking her ire 
and her fascinating responses-just as it had once been. But though she looked like an adult, Rekur Van 
insisted that the clone's preparation was not complete. 
And after all this time, Erasmus was growing impatient.          
At first, he had assumed the discrepancies from the Serena he had known were inconsequential, the 
difference between a juvenile and the woman she would ultimately become. But as the clone approached 
the equivalent age at which he had known Serena, Erasmus became increasingly disturbed. This wasn't at 
all what he had expected. 
Sensing that he could no longer justify further delays, the Tlulaxa researcher rushed his final preparations. 
Dressed again in his regal robe, Erasmus arrived to observe as the Serena clone completed several days of 
immersion in an experimental cellular deceleration chamber, to slow the aging process. Her development 
had been stretched and pushed, and her weak biological body had endured incredible rigors. 
The Tlulaxa had been anxious to prove his claims, but Erasmus reconsidered now. Thinking machines 
could wait for centuries, if necessary. Perhaps, if he decided to make another clone, he would allow that 
one to grow normally, since this experimental acceleration might have introduced flaws. The independent 
robot had extremely high expectations for his renewed interactions with Serena Butler. He did not want 
anything to get in the way. 
As the gummy fluids drained and the female clone stood naked and dripping before him, Erasmus 
scrutinized her through several spectral regimes, using his full complement of optic threads. A long time 
ago, through his many surveillance systems, the robot had seen the original Serena naked many times; he 
had been present when she'd given birth to her frustrating infant, and he had personally performed the 
sterilization surgery on her so that the pregnancy problem could never occur again. 
Now Rekur Van came forward, leering unpleasantly, to give her a 
physical examination, but Erasmus lifted the little Tlulaxa out of the way. He did not want Van to interfere 
with what should have been a special moment. 
Still dripping from the tank, Serena didn't seem to care about her nudity, though the original would no 
doubt have been offended: just one of many personality variations that the robot noticed.          
"Do I please you now?" Serena asked, blinking her lavender eyes. She stood seductively, as if trying to 
lure a potential mate. "I want you to like me." 
An artificial scowl formed on Erasmus's flowmetal face, and his optic threads gleamed dangerously. 



Serena Butler had been haughty, independent, intelligent. Hating her captivity among the thinking ma-
chines, she had debated with Erasmus, searching for any chance to hurt him. She had never tried to please 
him. 
"What did you do to her?" Erasmus turned to the Tlulaxa. "Why did she say that?" 
Van smiled uncertainly. "Because of the acceleration, I had to guide her personality. I shaped it with 
standard female attitudes." 
"Standard female attitudes?" Erasmus wondered if this unpleasant, isolated Tlulaxa man understood 
human women even less than he did. "There was nothing 'standard' about Serena Butler." 
Van appeared increasingly uneasy, and he fell silent, deciding not to attempt further excuses. Erasmus 
remained more interested in the clone. This woman looked like Serena, in her soft, classically beautiful 
face and form, in her amber-brown hair, and in her unusual eyes. 
But she wasn't the same. Only close enough to tickle his own memories of her, of the times they had spent 
together. 
"Tell me your beliefs about politics, philosophy, and religion," the robot demanded. "Express your most 
impassioned feelings and opinions. Why do you think that even captive humans deserve to be treated with 
respect? Explain why you believe it is impossible for a thinking machine to achieve the equivalent of a 
human soul." 
"Why do you wish to discuss such subjects?" She sounded almost 
petulant. "Tell me how you would like me to answer, so that I can please you." 
As soon as the clone spoke, she shattered his fond remembrance of the real Serena. Though she looked 
exactly like Serena Butler, this simulacrum was very different in her internal makeup, the way she 
thought, the way she behaved. The cloned version had no social conscience, no spark, no glimmer of the 
personality that had become so familiar to him, and which had caused him so much interesting trouble. 
The real Serena's rebellious attitude had triggered an entire Jihad, while this poor substitute lacked any 
such potential. 
Erasmus noted the difference in the glint of her eyes, in the turn of her mouth, in the way she threw her 
wet hair over her shoulder. He missed the fascinating woman he had known. 
"Put your clothes on," Erasmus said. Looking on from one side, Rekur Van appeared alarmed, obviously 
sensing the robot's disappointment. 
She slipped into the garments he had provided, accentuating her feminine curves. "Do you find me 
pleasing now?" 
"No. Unfortunately, you are unacceptable." 
With a blur of his flowmetal arm, Erasmus struck a swift, precise blow. He didn't want her to suffer, yet he 
did not want to look at this flawed clone ever again. With all his robotic strength, he drove the sharp edge 
of his shaped metal hand into the base of her neck, and decapitated her as easily as he might cut a flower 
in his greenhouse gardens. She made no sound as her head tumbled away and her body fell, spraying 
blood on his clean laboratory floor. 
Such a disappointment. 
On his left Rekur Van made a choking sound, as if he had forgotten how to breathe. The Tlulaxa man 
stumbled backward, but sentinel robots stood all around the laboratory chambers. The numerous tortured 
experimental subjects moaned and chattered in their cages, tanks, and tables. 
Erasmus took a step toward the genetics researcher. Van held up his 
hands and his expression telegraphed what would occur next. As usual, he would try to worm his way out 
of any responsibility. "I did everything possible! Her DNA matches perfectly, and she is the same in every 
physical characteristic." 
"She is not the same. You did not know the real Serena Butler." "Yes! I met her. I took the tissue samples 
myself when she visited Bandalong!" 
Erasmus made his flowmetal face a bland expressionless mirror. "You did not know her." This Tlulaxa's 
ability to perfectly re-create Serena Butler had been overstated, at best. As in the robot's own attempts to 
imitate the paintings of Van Gogh to the finest detail, the copy never approached the original's perfection. 
"I have many more cells. This was just our first attempt, and we can try again. Next time, I'm sure we'll 



take care of the problems. That clone was different only because she never shared the real Serena's life 
experiences, never faced the same challenges. We can modify the virtual reality teaching loops, make her 
spend more time immersed in sensory deprivation." 
Erasmus shook his head. "She will never be what I want." "Killing me would be a mistake, Erasmus! You 
can still learn much." Staring at the Tlulaxa, the inquisitive robot noted how objectively unpleasant he 
was; apparently, all of his condemned breed were similar. Van had none of the noble attributes of 
character that could be found in so many people of other races. The little man might have some value after 
all, providing a new window on the dark side of human nature. 
He was reminded of one of his thought-provoking signs. Is It More Human to Be Good? Or Evil? 
The robot's flowmetal face formed into a broad smile. "Why are you looking at me that way?" Van asked, 
nervously.          
At a silent, transmitted signal from Erasmus, the sentinel robots came closer to surround the Tlulaxa man. 
Van had no place to run. "Yes, I can learn from you, Rekur Van." He turned, his plush robe 
swirling, and signaled for the sentinel robots to seize the man. "In fact, I already have several very 
interesting experiments in mind. . . ." The Tlulaxa screamed. 
FIXING HIS GAZE forward, Vorian Atreides sat stiffly on the bridge of the flagship. Over the past week, his 
assault force had been cruising across space. Soldiers and mercenaries continued their specialized drills. 
To the last man, they counted the days until reaching their next destination. 
As the fleet entered Synchronized space, Vor mentally tallied all the weapons and firepower, all the 
soldiers and Ginaz mercenaries he would bring to bear against the thinking machines in the next great 
battle. He had not heard of the target planet before, but nevertheless Vor intended to conquer it and 
destroy the machine scourge. 
Politics be damned. Out here is exactly where I belong. 
For years after the death and defamation of Xavier, Vor had thrown himself into the struggle against 
Omnius. He fought one accursed machine enemy after another, striking in the sacred name of humanity. 
Vor felt instilled with the holy determination of Serena, and of Xavier as well. Their strength allowed him 
to carry the Jihad forward. Always forward. He vowed anew to crush every thinking machine in his path. 
He would leave the next planet a blackened blister if there was no other way, despite the loss of 
unfortunate human slaves who served Omnius. By now, the Primero had learned to accept almost any cost 
in blood, just as long as it counted as a victory against the machines. 
His two dearest friends had become martyrs in their own fashion. They had known what they were doing 
and had been willing to make great sacrifices, not only of their lives, but of their memories as well, al-
lowing myths to replace truth, for the sake of the Jihad. 
In a private message, Serena Butler had begged Vor and Xavier to understand the personal sacrifice she 
was making. Later, Xavier made his own sacrifice in order to stop the Grand Patriarch's predatory organ 
farm scheme with the Tlulaxa, saving thousands of lives in the process. Xavier's decision to leave Iblis's 
name untarnished was unselfish and heroic: he knew full well how much harm would befall the Jihad if its 
Grand Patriarch was proven to be a fraud and a war profiteer. 
Both Xavier and Serena had paid terrible, ultimate costs with full knowledge of what they were doing. I 
cannot dispute the decisions of my friends, Vor thought, feeling a universe of sadness on his shoulders. 
And he realized that his own burden must be to let them do what they intended. He had to resist the 
impulse to change what Xavier and Serena had done, and to let the untruths stand in order to achieve a 
long-term result. In accepting their fates and accomplishing what they had hoped, Serena and Xavier had 
left Vor to carry on in their behalf, and to bear an unseen banner of honor for all three of them. 
Not an easy task, but that was my sacrifice. 
"We are approaching the target planet, Primero," called his navigator. 
On the flagship's screens, he saw the unremarkable planet-wispy clouds, blue oceans, brown and green 
land masses. And a bristling force of weirdly beautiful machine warships converging to form a defensive 
line. Even from a distance, the angular robotic battle vessels flickered with bursts of fire as they launched 
machine-guided projectiles in a hailstorm toward the League fleet. 
"Engage our Holtzman shields." Vor rose from his chair and smiled confidently to the officers on the 



bridge with him. "Summon the Ginaz mercenaries into ground teams, ready to shuttle down as soon as we 
break the orbital defenses." He spoke automatically, confidently. 
Decades ago, Serena had started this Jihad to avenge the murder of her baby. Xavier had fought beside 
Vor, crushing many machine foes. Now Vor, without his friends, intended to see this impossible war 
through to its end. It was the only way he could be sure the martyrs had made worthwhile sacrifices. 
"Forward!" Vor raised his voice as the first robotic shells impacted against the Holtzman shields. "We 
have enemies to destroy!"